What am I losing when I see individual color clipping in Camera Raw?

I hope this is the right place to leave this question as it's probably more about color than a technical question about PS. I have enough knowledge of color theory to be dangerous, as they say.
I am adjusting some landscape images taken in RAW mode with a Nikon D200.
In Camera Raw, as I draw the black slider to the right, I see clipping of blue channel before the image looks adjusted properly for contrast. With the option key down, large blocks of yellow appear before black appears, and I assume that also means the blues are being clipped. The only place I see that clipping is areas of green foliage.
Deep blue skies are not showing clipping and neither are other obvious blues in the images.
When I adjust Camera Raw's black slider to the point where I get full shadow clipping (black shows up with the Option key down), back off slightly, and then look at the image's channels in PS, I see the blue channel is all blocked up.
I understand (or think I understand) that the weak channel carries detail...yet I really can't see any difference in foliage detail whether the blue channel is clipped or not.
I am not clear about what I am doing, and I am also not clear whether this is a result of the rendering of certain greens by my camera. I know from experience that manipulations of yellows in later processing seems to affect foliage colors more than manipulation of greens. Saturation of foliage is affected far more by selecting "yellows" in the saturation adj layer dropdown box than by selecting greens.

Thanks, everyone.
Opening the image in ProPhoto colorspace completely eliminates the blue clipping. When I compare two instances of an image in PS after assigning ProPhoto in ACR for one and Adobe RGB in ACR for the other, I see much more detail in the blue channel of the image in PS.
Yes, then this is a good lesson on gamut clipping and colorspace.
I tried the workaround but it's much easier to just work in a larger colorspace.

Similar Messages

  • What does it mean when I see the file with the question mark on my screen?

    What does it mean when I see a file with a question mark on the screen?

    Means no bootable system can be found or required system files are missing or damaged. Reinstall OS X.
    Reinstall OS X without erasing the drive
    1. Repair the Hard Drive and Permissions
    Boot from your Snow Leopard Installer disc. After the installer loads select your language and click on the Continue button. When the menu bar appears select Disk Utility from the Utilities menu. After DU loads select your hard drive entry (mfgr.'s ID and drive size) from the the left side list.  In the DU status area you will see an entry for the S.M.A.R.T. status of the hard drive.  If it does not say "Verified" then the hard drive is failing or failed. (SMART status is not reported on external Firewire or USB drives.) If the drive is "Verified" then select your OS X volume from the list on the left (sub-entry below the drive entry,) click on the First Aid tab, then click on the Repair Disk button. If DU reports any errors that have been fixed, then re-run Repair Disk until no errors are reported. If no errors are reported click on the Repair Permissions button. Wait until the operation completes, then quit DU and return to the installer.
    If DU reports errors it cannot fix, then you will need Disk Warrior and/or Tech Tool Pro to repair the drive. If you don't have either of them or if neither of them can fix the drive, then you will need to reformat the drive and reinstall OS X.
    2. Reinstall Snow Leopard
    If the drive is OK then quit DU and return to the installer.  Proceed with reinstalling OS X.  Note that the Snow Leopard installer will not erase your drive or disturb your files.  After installing a fresh copy of OS X the installer will move your Home folder, third-party applications, support items, and network preferences into the newly installed system.
    Download and install Mac OS X 10.6.8 Update Combo v1.1.

  • What do i do when i see script writing appear on my i phone when i switch it on?

    what do i do when i see script writing appear on my i phone when i switch it on?

    Contact your carrier. Voice Mail is a carrier function, and setup and management differs from carrier to carrier.

  • When will Adobe issue an update to Camera Raw to include the Olympus E-M 5 MARK II camera?

    When will Adobe issue an update to Camera Raw for CS6 and Lightroom 5 to include the Olympus E-M 5 MARK II camera, does anyone know?

    What I wonder is when folks will start researching their favorite software BEFORE buying a new camera model?
    I have never seen a cart pulling a horse!!
    We know the our software, we know the new camera will be 'ahead' of updates. its the time between that we all seem to just accept. We should not.
    We can go round in circles pointing fingers as to who is to 'blame', thats not the point. The point is, no matter how far you go back, since the advent of digital this has been a problem. Posting on all web sites as far back as I remember contain "when will there be RAW support for xyz?". There are even some on this site back in 2006 asking the same question.
    The interdependent link between camera makers & software vendors is not working properly. They need each other yet don't support each other. Do you think Adobe thought up DNG just as a exercise? From memory it was an attempt to standardize, with an open code, a raw format that was universal. I blame Canikon for not wholeheartedly supporting it. Then the Oly, Panny alliance come along with MFT, an ideal opportunity, but proprietary issues prevail as if they got some sort of advantage from it. They don't IMO.
    Sorry for the rant, got carried away! Its just so frustrating.

  • Adobe Bridge CC crashes when opening file with Photoshop CC or Camera RAW!

    Adobe Bridge CC crashes when opening file with Photoshop CC or Camera RAW!
    - Tried to Reset the preference with CTRL + Click.
    - It's just new clean install didn't do anything with it yet.
    - Windows 8.
    Any help?

    Just that one project, or any project?  Can you create new projects?

  • No matter what i try i cannot get Photoshop or Bridge to open Camera Raw Filters, how do i fix this?

    no matter what i try i cannot get Photoshop or Bridge to open Camera Raw Filters, how do i fix this?
    I have windows 8 and ive tried everything i can to open it but it refuses to let me.

    Let's get some information first.
    What is your version of Adobe Camera Raw, Bridge, and Photoshop?
    What files are you trying to open in ACR? If Raw, for what camera model?

  • When will Nikon D5500 be added to Camera Raw or Lightroom

    When will Nikon D5500 be added to Camera Raw or Lightroom

    The camera raw updater is only for updating the plug-ins that Photoshop uses.  If you want to work with your D5500 in Lightroom you need to download and install the DNG Converter 8.8, and create DNGs from your NEFs, one folder at a time, and then those DNGs will open in the older LR version.
    For LR to open the D5500 NEFs, directly, it would need to be LR 5.8 or LR 6.0 and we don’t have either of those, and I expect we’re not going to get LR 5.8, because that would delay LR 6.  My thinking is that ACR 8.8 and the DNGC 8.8 were stop-gap updates to give people a path forward for new cameras while everyone waits for LR 6 and ACR 9.

  • What should I do when I see this error message: iPhone cannot be synced required disk cannot be found?

    What should I do when I try to sync my iPhone 4s with a MacBook and get the error message: "iPhone cannot be synced...required disk cannot be found?"

    Close "iPhoto" if it is open. Open the "Pictures" folder and right-click on "iPhoto Library." Select "Show Package Contents." Right-click the "iPod Photo Cache" folder, select "Move to Trash" and sync your iPhone. The error message should no longer appear.
    if that doesn't work,
    uninstall itunes and download the lastest version

  • I can't see my control panels in Camera Raw

    Ever since I purchased CC, I can not use Camera Raw. The control panels are black and I can't read what each of the sliders is adjusting. See the attached screen shot.
    I contacted support previously and they said it was because I was also running MacKeeper. So, I uninstalled MacKeeper, deleted the trash, rebooted, and I still have the same problem. When I go to Camera Raw Preferences, I get the same thing. Black control panels and I can't see what I'm adjusting. Does anyone have a suggestion?
    I am running an iMac with Intel Core i5, System 10.9.3

    About AirPlay Mirroring in OS X
    About AirPlay and Airplay Mirroring
    AirPlay Mirroring requires a second-generation Apple TV or later, and is supported on the following Mac models: iMac (Mid 2011 or newer), Mac mini (Mid 2011 or newer), MacBook Air (Mid 2011 or newer), and MacBook Pro (Early 2011 or newer). For non-qualifying Macs you can try using Air Parrot.
    Several Apple Articles Regarding AirPlay
    Apple TV (2nd and 3rd gen)- How to use AirPlay Mirroring
    How to set up and configure AirPort Express for AirPlay and iTunes
    iTunes- Troubleshooting AirPlay and AirPlay Mirroring
    iTunes- Using AirPlay
    Apple TV (2nd and 3rd gen)- Understanding AirPlay settings
    About AirPlay Mirroring in OS X Mountain Lion
    iTunes 10- About playing music with AirPlay
    Troubleshooting AirPlay and AirPlay Mirroring
    Using AirPlay
    Thanks to the $15 Beamer, AirPlay streaming is still possible on Macs  that do not support Airplay and mirroring.
    Other solutions are the Air Parrot, StreamToMe, and AirServer.

  • Why can't I see the recovery slider in camera raw of elements?

    I have the most recent version of elements, version 11. The camera raw plug-in is up to date, some 7.4 something. On the online help list and tutorials I have seen, there is a recovery slider. Yet, when I tried to practice with raw files in camera raw, the recovery slider was not there. I tried looking around the window, clicking menus, but can't find it. So where is it?

    PSE 11 has a new 2012 raw engine but you can switch between the old and the new. In the camera raw dialog click on the camera icon. Then change Process to 2010. Then go back to the basic tab.

  • What to do now when I see a white page?

    Hi All,
    My iBook has kernel panic if I enable the Airport card. To repair cost me about 850 USD because a simple connection problem and that started when the computer was 15 months buying. Now I have new problem. When I start I got a white screen written Illegal instruction at....etc...Welcome to Open Firmware.
    To start the computer with "C" and the original disk is in it not help.
    The HD disk was checked before by the Disk utility.
    Where I can find list of commands for this page?
    What can I do now?
    How can I make installation without the Airport driver.
    I am quite sad about the situation of this computer.
    Thanks for you help and for your patience to help solve this problem.
    Best regards,
    doki

    OK. Forgive me for not quite understanding. I have worked as an electronic technician myself, so I understand what you are saying now. It is bad practice to fix electronic problems by applying pressure with shims and spacers. It may make something work for a while, but it can and probably will cause problems in the long run. It is always better to do a proper repair. I just wanted to be sure you were aware of all the possibilities.
    It is unclear just what the proper repair would be here. You could replace both the logic board and the airport module, but if the problem lies in the connection between the two, due to poor design perhaps, then the problem will just never really be fixed.
    If you don't want airport at all, then one option would be to just remove the airport card and leave it out. But since you indicate that you are visually handicapped, this is likely not an option for you.
    Now I am wondering if the simplest thing to do would be to just get rid of the AirPort Utility? Go to Finder>Applications>Utilities>Airport Utility. Drag the AirPort Utility to the trash, but don't empty the trash just yet. The utility should not be able to open if it is in the trash, so the airport module should not be able to turn on. See if this helps.
    Also, check that AirPort is not a login item. Go to System Preferences>Accounts>Login Items. If Airport is on the list, remove it by highlighting it and clicking on the "-" sign.
    I am no software expert, but it seems to me that this should work. Try it and see. If it does and all seems well, you can eventually empty the trash. But it would be best to run for a while and be sure that there aren't going to be any problems first. Not emptying the trash gives you the option to restore the Airport Utility if you have to. And maybe a software expert can give an opinion here.
    Good luck!

  • What can you do when you see a white screen of death when you turn your computer on

    My MacBook Pro had the color wheel rotating when I clicked on a link. It stopped and displayed a white screen. There was no way to force quit or do anything else, so I pressed the power button and turned it off. Since then, I have removed the battery and the cord, replaced them, and turned it back on. It does come on, but it displays the same white screen and nothing else. What is the problem?

    Sounds like your hard drive died and the NVRAM got flushed.
    You'll have to take it in and/or replace the drive and install your EFI firmware from cd to be able to install OS X back onto the machine.
    Install/upgrade RAM or storage drive in Mac's
    Restoring firmware on Intel Mac's
    How to erase and install Snow Leopard 10.6
    For Snow Leopard Speed Freaks

  • HT1551 what does it mean when I see a black screen with the Apple logo but it wont do anything but that.  I have re booted 4 times  same outcome.  Help!

    I just hooked up my Apple TV.  I see a black screen with Apple logo.  Nothing else happens.  Remote functions as I see the white light respond.  Have rebooted 4 times but same thing occurs.  What should I try.
    Thanks.

    If your problem persists get yourself a micro USB cable (sold separately), you can restore your Apple TV from iTunes:
    Remove ALL cables from Apple TV. (if you don't you will not see Apple TV in the iTunes Source list)
    Connect the micro USB cable to the Apple TV and to your computer.
    Open iTunes.
    Select your Apple TV in the Source list, and then click Restore.

  • What can I do when I see "The backup disk image cannot be mounted"

    I ran the time machine. Then, "preparing backup" showed up for a long time. After that, a window pop out: "Time machine error, The disk image cannot be mounted" What is disk image? What can I do (I can't back up anything)
    P.S. I use time capsule for backup. there were no problem on connection

    I suggest reposting in the TimeCapsule forum here:
    http://discussions.apple.com/forum.jspa?forumID=1253
    This may not be a TimeMachine problem at all but something else.

  • What is this mean when I see a gray screen with a symbol circle with single cross?

    Why the gray screen appear on my screen? I have tried instructions and none is working. I think I loss it and I went ahead to reformat by using my CD and its not coming through and please help!

    amboarman29 wrote:
    Why the gray screen appear on my screen? I have tried instructions and none is working. I think I loss it and I went ahead to reformat by using my CD and its not coming through and please help!
    Care to share?  Any from KB Article: 
    http://support.apple.com/kb/TS2570 Mac OS X: Gray screen appears during startup?
    Care to share which OS you are using?

Maybe you are looking for

  • Find and edit specific line in text file?

    Hello I want to read a text file that could look in some different ways since the user choose file from a list. I then want to igonre all the lines that begin with a special character, for example %. I then want to find all the lines "words" that beg

  • How to minimize without crashing?

    Howdy Adobe! Is there a way I can minimize the program window without having the program crash? Or is that just too much to ask? I believe you call it Adobe Digital Editions, version 4.0.3. Build 110333... ish? It totally sucks! Let me tell ya! I had

  • Reestablishing iPhoto Library after Hard-drive crash

    After replacing the HD on this 1 yr old machine, restoring photos from iDisk and an external back-up drive I was able only to view my photos as thumbnails. Clicking on these or otherwise trying to access the "original" image resulted in the lovely gr

  • No such element exception when applet window closed

    My applet can throw a NoSuchElementException as it closes during sudden death. The Java Console reports: Exception in thread "AWT-EventQueue-2" java.util.NoSuchElementException      at java.util.LinkedList.getFirst(Unknown Source)      at java.awt.Se

  • Moving presets from lr3 to lr4

    I upgraded from lr3 to lr4.4. 3rd party develop presets [datacolor spydercheckr] are showing up in lr3, not lr4. how do I move and redirect these presets from 3 to 4?