What is the best frame rate to shoot/edit with for export to DVD?

Hello, I am going to shoot some instructional martial arts videos that need to be exported to DVD. I haven't exported to DVD since 2005. I am curious what the best frame rate is to shoot with and edit in Premiere to export to DVD. I've read conflicting information online. Some forums say that you can edit in whatever frame rate you want as long as the output is SD, 30i, which seems outdated to me.
I'm shooting on the GH2, so my options are 1080 24p (which has terrible strobiness compared to other cameras at 24p), 1080 60i, 720 60p, and apparently there is an HBR firmware update that allows 1080 30p. I want the motion to be as unstroby as possible, without being too soft. My friend's camera can shoot 1080 60p and I'm considering buying the G6, which also shoots 1080 60p. But I've read online that 60p to DVD looks choppy.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thank you very much.
Jeremy

Thank you Jim. I do have one more question with regards to your advice:
I am putting the new firmware on my GH2 today, so I will be able to capture 1080/30p as opposed to only 1080/60i to edit in the 30p timeline. Is there a reason you would prefer 60i over true 30p at the same res? I've had problems with interlacing in the past never quite going away and getting funky when doing slow motion and other effects.

Similar Messages

  • What is the best frame rate to use for movies watched only on computer scre

    Hello all,
    I'm UK based, and so use the PAL system of 25 fps. This works well enough if I want to make a DVD, but I'm now starting to work on projects that will only ever be seen on You Tube or Mobile Me - that sort of environment.
    A portion of my work features stills, and I prefer to use Photo to Movie for pan, scan, and zoom and rotate - it's much more versatile than Ken Burns in iMovie.
    However, I can't seem to get perfectly smooth pans when viewing on a screen. Depending on whether I use 25 fps or 30 fps, the pan is slightly 'trembly'. I've tried all the codecs, different frame rates etc, but I can't seem to remove this problem. A pan created in iMovie is perfectly smooth. Does anyone know why I can't replicate this in Photo to Movie?
    I'm starting to suspect it isn't really a frame rate issue, but something else - but there my knowledge runs out.
    Can anyone offer advice on this?
    Thanks in advance.

    For Video projects, use the same frame rate as your source material. If your camcorder shoots PAL use PAL. For photos it should not matter.
    I get a whole lot more control over Ken Burns in iMovie. I always thought that iPhoto was just kind of random with no control.
    I guess I'll have to go back and look at it. In iMovie 09 and before, iMovie did not handle vertically oriented photos very well for Ken Burns. This is fixed in iMovie 11.
    Message was edited by: AppleMan1958

  • What is the Best settings in Compressor 3.5.3  for burning a DVD when the sequence is 1080 60i -- shot on P-2 -- DVCPO HD 1280x1080 29.97

    I tried a few changes in Inspector... Video Format such as - Field Dominance to Bottom First... and Quality to Automatic Bit Rate & Motion Estimation at Best. I think GOP and Extras are set on default ( IBBP, Closed 15 -IBBPBBPBBPBBPBP) & ("Add DVD Studio Pro metadata" checked). When the DVD is played back on 40" HDTV from consumer Blu-ray player... it looks awful. Images seem to have double or shadow images (field shifting or something) and the color and detail on distant images have a block type look. I seem to be a master at making High Definition look like multi-dubbed VHS.
    Compressor, Mac OS X (10.6.8)

    What is the duration of your original video file?
    If going from FCP, I highly recommend exporting a ProRes 422 file first, then encoding that.

  • What is the max frame rate in depthFrame

    In v1.8, I remembered the frame rate can be up to 30fps in depthFrme. what is the max frame rate in depthFrame in the v2.0? And how can i set it? thx!

    Depth (and IR, body, face and HDface) frame rates are 30fps.
    Color is 30fps unless low light mode is detected then it automatically switches to 15fps.
    If you're using the multistream source it will stream at the lowest framerate from the chosen framesources.
    When you're using separate sources they all stream at their own fps rate.
    Frame rates can not be set by the user.
    Brekel

  • What is the best scrubbing rate for youtube?

    what is the best scrubbing rate for youtube?

    Ummm... can you elaborate? why do you think a 1-pass would be better? Before i go through another 5 - 6 hours of compression, I would like to understand a little bit better... 2 0r 3 word answers aren't going to help me at all. Sorry.
    Lisa <
    You have about three thousand pages of manuals, why do you think we can shrink that information down? Compression is really difficult to understand and to control. There are dozens of Web sites you can explore or you could look at amazon.com and buy yourself some training systems. If you are going to be doing a lot of compression and encoding, you will learn it the same way everyone else does, slowly. It's often easier and faster and therefore cheaper to pay a service to do your encoding. Spend a few hours reading the Compressor forum.
    Consider that you don't need to waste mjuch time rendering entire projects. Just assemble a short collection of problem scenes and use different settings till you get something you like. To confuse things even further, encoding results are totally subjective and a terrible compromise. You give up image quality to save time encoding or to gain program length. Youinvest tons of set up and encoding time to gain control the image quality. And you must process the audio separately to get the best use of your delivery media's capacity.
    bogiesan

  • Is the best frame rate 31fps?

    In years past, 31fps was considered the best frame rate, as far as getting the best performance on both Mac and Windows.  Has that changed with hardware acceleration?  Does the frame rate still mater in getting consistent performance?

    I'd say anything beyond 36 - max 40 fps is too much and unneeded. Plus, a higher framerate would be too demanding on CPU resources as flash player needs to redraw the screen as much times as the framerate count. This is the main reason for flash player causing a slow down in system response. Take for instance moviemaking - it has a framerate of 25 fps and this is enough for even the most dynamic scenes. A framerate between 24 and 30 for flash is considered to be smooth enough and at the same time not too much demanding on system resources
    Emil Georgiev - Flash & Web Design

  • What is the best way to back up photos and videos to a dvd from iPhoto, not in iPhoto format but just in jpeg format to access on either windows or mac

    what is the best way to back up photos and videos to a dvd from iPhoto, not in iPhoto format but just in jpeg format to access on either windows or mac

    When you export the videos out of iPhoto be sure to select Kind = Original.  Otherwise you'll just get an image file of the first frame of the video.
    OT

  • What is the best USB 3.0 (small) ext HDD for recording my music on

    Hello everybody!
    i start with saying...........
    A Happy Newyear!!!!!
    I wish you all the very best and love.
    Now for my question.
    I would like to know what is the best portable usb 3.0 external HDD for recording my music on.
    Because since today i am a very happy new owner of the new Retina Macbook Pro 2.3 GHz, with 8 GB of Ram and 256 GB of Flash.
    .... and yes it has the Samsung Retina Display
    Since 8 years i use Logic Pro and because the flash is only 256 Gb i want to record on a external drive
    and not on the internal storage (and especially now with usb 3.0).
    But i would like to know what is the best portible external HDD for this function.
    500 GB is enough for me because i have 2x a 2 TB for my Mac Pro and Macbook pro where i make back ups from all my music (2 back ups just to be safe).
    Some Examples i saw:
    - WD My passport USB 3.0 - 500 GB harde schijf
    - G-Technology 500GB G-DRIVE Slim USB 3.0-harde schijf
    - LaCie 500GB Rugged Triple USB 3.0 externe harde schijf
    - Freecom Mobile drive mg 500 GB harde schijf
    - Western Digital My Passport Essential SE USB 3.0 500 GB harde schijf
    I would really like some good advise in this.
    Hope you guys can help me out with this.
    Greetings,
    Glenn Cornelisse
    Gaya Productions Studio
    The Hague, Netherlands

    I cannot speak specifically about any of those Ext HDs because i don't own any of them..
    But...
    Make sure the external drive is 7200rpm.... and not 5400rpm or a 'green' drive with something called "varipower' or a similar name...

  • What is the best USB powered portable 1TB hard drive for a macbook pro that allows Time machine to work, windows (thru Parallels software) and mac storage and is available in Australia?

    What is the best USB powered portable 1TB hard drive for a macbook pro that allows Time machine to work, windows (thru Parallels software) and mac storage and is available in Australia?

    I agree with teh OWC sggestion above, but why must it be USB powered? I find that far more unreliable, and the low power devices slow.
    I'd frankly get a good external enclosure and buy a bare drive.  But the OWC stuff is quite good - vastly better than some of the majors (WD being aprime example of stuff that's boderline quality and often not compatible)
    Grant

  • What is the BEST way to get my macbook with lion on it, to communicate with my Canon 40D camera?

    What is the BEST way to get my macbook with lion on it, to communicate with my Canon 40D camera? It says the utility disk is a PowerPC app and that is no longer supported. What do I do now? I can't upload photos from my camera.

    Also, I had the same problem happen when I tried to install an older version of Corel Painter. Are Macbook Pro users just NOT supposed to be able to use their laptops for the purposes they are best designed for?
    -Frustrated new Mac user

  • What is the best wireless camera that will work with my mac

    What is the best wireless camera that will work with my mac?

    Any reliable brand that claims Mac compatibility.
    Different wireless cams (wi-fi versus BlueTooth) may work better for different purposes, so ask your retailer for one that best does what you want to do with it.  For some examples of all kinds and types, click the link at the end of this sentence to see results of this search for your posted question.
    Message was edited by: EZ Jim
    Mac OSX 10.10.1

  • What is the best edge to edge glass screen protector for iPhone 6

    What is the best edge to edge glass screen protector for iPhone 6

    none of the ones at the link below are glass - they are all film - if you are looking for glass i know of several options
    Zeos - www.zeosdirect.com
    Crown - www.bodyguardz.com
    Moshi - www.moshi.com
    i think Zagg may have one www.zagg.com
    and im sure there are others
    search Amazon for iPhone 6 tempered glass screen protectors

  • What is the best free word processing or office program for OS X Mountain Lion

    What is the best free word processing or office program for OS X Mountain Lion?

    "Best" is quite subjective. As William points out, TextEdit may be the "best" in someones eyes as it isn't cludged up with crap you don't need.
    What are your requirements?
    Basic text editing?
    Do you need:
    Table of Contents
    Index
    Footnote/endnote management
    Different headers/footers
    Page Layout
    What are you going to use it for?
    Technical Reports
    Screenplay
    Leaflets and newsletters
    Coding

  • What is the best spec to run multiple programs with photographs?  Includes:  Lightroom, PhotoMechanic, and Internet DAM system?

    What is the best spec to run multiple programs with numerous photographs?  Includes:  Lightroom, PhotoMechanic, and Internet DAM system?
    For a Macbook Pro.  What's the least amount I need to process, upload, download images using these 3 programs?
    Thank you.
    pt

    That's a nice system Kevin, and it will work very nicely with Photoshop.  I do take it that you have 16Gb RAM in Total?
    250Gb SSD is a good size, but you can still run short, and that will affect Windows performance.  When you get your system, instal WinDirStat which gives you a graphic display of everything on your drive, like below. Clicking on any of the large areas will tell you what and where they are, so you can think about moving cache folders etc. to one of the HDDs.
    Leave the Pagefile.sys on the boot drive.  Think about disabling Hyphenate as it takes a ton of space, and too often crashes on wake up.
    My Documents
    Desktop
    Downloads
    Look at Bridge cache
    iTunes backup
    Other stuff like that.
    Think about another 500Gb drive just for Photoshop Scratch.  Drives are cheap as chips nowadays
    Do yourself a favour, and invest $100 in Shadow Protect (or similar if there is such a thing) SP saves incremental backups every 15 minutes (you can set the interval, but it has no impact on performance with a system like yours).  If you have a problem you can mount the back up at any of those 15 minute points, and open files from it.  You can also make a bootable DVD image of your C drive, and be back up and running five minutes after disaster strikes.
    Optimize Performance in Photoshop
    Photoshop CC and CC 2014 GPU FAQ
    For more ideas, swing by the Premiere Pro Hardware forum.  Those guys are serious good at this stuff, and you'll find links tips and ideas.
    Happy computing, and have fun with your Creative Cloud® apps.

  • What is the best way to maintain your Battery Life for Iphone 5 ?

    What is the best way to maintain your Battery Life for Iphone 5 ?

    hi,
    so what would you suggest to do here then. let it get to 50% then run the battery down and at say 5-%ish re-charge it fully.
    is there anything i could switch off on my phone to save battery power. ive taken off he location services apart from ym locate my iphone, stopped the fetch new data and set it to manaul . this is also the same for the icloud as well.more or less everything has been set to manual or set to off ??

Maybe you are looking for