What is the ideal RAID 5 logical drive configuration to use with editing 1080p on FCPX?

Hello,
I invested in one of the new Late 2013 Mac Pros (8-core 3GHz, dual Fire Pro D500 w/ 3GM VRAM each, 32GB RAM), along with a Promise Pegasus R6 Thunderbolt (ver 1) RAID because I wanted a fast and supremely smooth editing experience versus slow, laggy, drop frame performance I had been experienceing in my previous Mac (a mid-2010 27" iMac 2.8 GHz Quad-Core, 16GB RAM, Radeon 5750 with 1GB VRAM) that had media stored on a single 3TB firewire drive.
The RAID came pre-configured with 6 x 1TB Toshiba drives giving me a Logical Drive that has 5TB capacity, 128kb stripe size, 512byte sector size, with Read Ahead/Write Back cache policy. I've also enabled "Forced Read Ahead" using terminal.
THE PROBLEM:
Even with this super fast media storage that gives me about 600MB/sec data transfer rate, I'm still sometimes experiencing lag and stuttered playback from the timeline (In all fairness, the stuttering only happens for a few seconds then plays fine, but the lag can be frustrating when I'm trying to click through the timeline to check edits). The footage I work with is 1080p mov files from Canon DSLR that are transcoded to ProRes 422 and Proxy during import into FCPX. I never edit with camera-native formats, always with ProRes. I also always close all other applications, eventhough all the power boasted by the Mac Pro shouldn't have a problem with that. I've tested the video cards by playing multiple 1080p H.264 files at once and it played about 10 simultaneously without a hitch. I've also edited under a new user and still the issue remains. My conclusion is that the lag comes from the RAID. (I did a test project with having my library saved on the internal flash storage and editing improved dramatically with speed and responsiveness, which signals that my problem must lie with the RAID).
THE QUESTION:
Is there a preferred or recommended stripe size and sector size that would cure my problem? Is it because it's RAID 5 even though I'm using 6 disks and getting tremendous sustained data xfer rates?
OTHER RELATED INFO:
My FCPX import settings copies all files into the library and I have Optimized and Proxy checked. My projects are also saved in the same library so everything is contained in one place.
My projects are mostly 40 minute wedding videos 1080p at 23.98fps with lots of short video clips during montage segments, no more than 2 video tracks during the wedding the wedding ceremony.
I frequenly repair permissions on the internal boot drive. Sometimes trash FCPX preferences when performance gets ridiculous or other glitches happen, like audio refusing to play, or the timeline plays no video just audio.
Thank you! Any help or advice is appreciated!

Hi,
Making our tablespace in different directory does not improve the performance. See, Basic thing does if you are lauching your text file from different directory
say Drives C , D and F respectively does your hit any performance (your OS is installed on Drive C). I don't thinnk you will getany boost up performance. See Basicaltl what is happening is that, try to launch you textpad and try to open the files from any there then you file will open immediately, if you ask me the reason behind that, you application is already loaded in the Memory to give the Service (same as ORACLE Instance). That's the difference.
- Pavan Kumar N

Similar Messages

  • What is the newest version of iTunes i can use with OS 10.4.11?

    What is the newest version of iTunes i can use with OS 10.4.11?

    The maximum iTunes version is 8.2.1 for a G3, 9.2.1 for a G4 or G5 running Mac OS X 10.4.11, 10.6.3 for a Mac running 10.5.8, and 11 for computers running Mac OS X 10.6.8 or above. - https://discussions.apple.com/message/24186956
    iTunes 9.2.1 - http://support.apple.com/kb/DL1056

  • What are the ideal specs for professional graphic designer using CS5 illustrator, photoshop and indesign?g

    What are the ideal Mac Pro specs for a professional graphic designer using CS5 Premium- using mostly InDesign, Illustrator and PhotoShop?

    24GB RAM
    SSD for boot drive
    GHz, but not necessarily dual. Apple doesn't sell dual 3.33s.
    A single 3.33 6-core should do fine and "sweet spot" (when looking, there is "4-core" build to order..,. and like everything else on the Store, why in heavens they didn't be more accurate and clear and say "single socket" and then have "dual processor configurations" 0 I guess the writers don't understand or know workstations or jargon? I say that 'cause some have trouble even finding the 6-core 3.33 choice ($1200 over stock 2.8 4-core).
    W3680 though can be found on Buy.com for $620 (was $589 at earlier date) and people are known to then sell the stock cpu $300 making it even more attractive and save $600-900 that way rather easily. Or not.
    But yes, I would send you to MPG.com site as well and read through what is on there.

  • New video posted on IAC Driver configuration and use with Mainstage/Logic

    Shows how to configure IAC Driver for use with Mainstage and Logic.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wPhtRCwz8vs

    No problem, anytime...
    Yes, that should work. I haven't specifically tried that but don't see why it wouldn't work so give it a go. When I was testing this IAC driver method, I did confirm that the IAC object existed in the environment in Logic and it did, so you should be good to go.
    You're exactly right, both Logic and Mainstage should be active. You'll get a message saying another Rewire host is active when you open both, but just click ok and ignore it.
    Here are a couple of other vids as example of what you can do with the IAC driver just to keep your brain burning
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XgzBOJYSY64
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZL0ucV8dpo
    If I have time I'll try to test it as well, it's a good idea!
    Let me know how it goes or if you have any questions.
    J.

  • What is the brand of optical disk medium to use with mac MINI super drive?

    TDK brand of blank optical disk medium on my mac (super drive) is not reading the optical disk I put in there to burn to. The genius at the apple store put in a Memorex brand of optical disk medium and it worked. What is the consensus for buying blank medium that will work with the .mac MINI super drive it seems TDK doesn't work? What is the brand and type to go with?

    You need a regular optical digital cable, often called a Toslink, with a 3.5 mm miniplug adapter on the Mac mini end. The port is a combo port. When you insert the optical cable's miniplug into the port, because it is a tiny bit longer than a regular 3.5 mm miniplug, it activates the digital audio. Usually the port's output is analog by default.
    Dah•veed

  • What is the best DVD burner to buy for use with my Mac?

    I have a MacMini with a DVD player/CD burner. I would like to buy an external DVD burner for use with the MacMini and my Tiger OS. Could I get some thoughts on purchasing a good external burner and using the best burning program with it. Thanks

    Paul,
    LaCie d2 DVD±RW with LightScribe http://www.lacie.com/products/product.htm?pid=10113
    $179.99 includes full version Toast 7
    $129.99 includes Toast 6 Lite
    The $129.99 unit that comes with Toast 6 Lite can be found on the web for a lot less. Later, if you outgrow Toast 6 you can upgrade to Toast 8 (which is the latest version).
    External Multi-Format DVD RecorderDRX-830UL/T $129.00
    http://www.sonystyle.com/is-bin/%3Cwbr%20target=blank%3EINTERSHOP.enfinity/eCS/Store/en/-/USD/SY_DisplayProductInformation-Start ?ProductSKU=DRX830UL%2fT&Dept=computers&CategoryName=cpu_Sony_PCAccessories_CD%2 fDVDBurnDVDBurners
    My experience with Lacie and Sony burners has always been positve and Toast is good to have around, it's always complimented iDVD well (in addition to having a host of other useful features).
    Note:
    I'm not familiar with any of Toast 6 lite's features, but I do know you can burn DVD's with it. It adds another means of authoring a DVD outside of iDVD.

  • What's the best Gigabit Ethernet ADSL2  modem to use with the new Apple Extreme router?

    I Have upgraded to the new Apple Airport Extreme & need to update my old ADSL modem as it only has 10/100 ethernet. I don't want to spend a great deal as I will hopefully be upgrading to fibre later in the year. I find it strange that Apple have never sold them through the Apple Store.
    Thanks in advance.

    It would make no sense to recommend a modem that your Internet Service Provider (ISP) does not support, so your first task is to contact your ISP for a list of "approved" modems for use with their service.
    Once we have the list, it will be easy to eliminate the non-Gigabit models, since most, if not all, will be not be Gigabit rated.
    After all, the fastest speed that any ADSL provider might be able to deliver is maybe 30-40 Mbps.  Don't think that you will need 1,000 Mbps capability in a modem for that type of connection.
    Kind of like having a car that can go 1,000 miles per hour, but the streets are narrow, crooked, and won't allow much over 25 miles per hour.

  • What size should external back-up drive be for use with Time Machine?

    I am very new to Macs.
    My iMac has a 500GB hard disc - not much on it yet.
    I want to back the hard disc up daily and automatically to an external hard drive using Time Machine. So that I could restore everything if the iMac failed.
    1. Does the external hard drive that I buy need to be larger than the iMac's hard disc, e.g 1Tb? Or is 500Gb enough in my case?
    2. Should it be pre-formatted for Mac when I buy it? Or do I have to do this?
    3. Should it use firewire or USB?
    4. Presumably I need to leave the external drive plugged in all the time? Or will this stop the iMac from switching on and off?
    I really want the easiest solution possible as I am not very techie and I want the minimum amount of fiddling with it. So I am confused between whether to choose a Western Digital My Book Office edition or Studio edition, 500Gb or 1TB, firewire or USB, or maybe a Lacie?
    Would be grateful for advice.
    Thanks very much.

    Welcome to the Apple forums. If you have a 500G external disk, that will work fine for quite a while with hourly, daily and weekly backups, but sooner or later it will fill up, but then it begins to delete weekly backups. The same will happen with whichever size of external disk you buy: sooner or later. . . . Nonetheless, that disk will be fine for most purposes. I have 250G and use a 200G partition for my MacBook Pro and while that was fine, it tends to delete weekly backups so I have about 6 months of backups stored. (I also make other backups of all data).
    It may be preformatted, but that is unlikely. Use Disk Utility (in Applications>Utilities) and use MacOS Extended, which is selected in the Partition tab (you do this even if you only use a single partition).
    The system works with either Firewire or USB 2..
    You do not need to leave it in all the time. If it is connected, it will make the backups, if not, nothing will happen and it will indicate that the next backup will occur when the disk is attached. To disconnect, you would highlight the disk in a Finder panel and press the Eject icon (not while TM is running of course) then disconnect the cable.
    I am not able to suggest which disk is best, although my LaCie one has not missed a beat. Others may have a different idea. Try a Google search with the disk manufacturer's name and "problems" or somesuch. No disk is perfect of course.

  • How to find the type of webserver being configured for use with ColdFusion

    Hello,
    Where can I check to see the type of server that ColdFusion is configured to run currently? I have an existing installation of CF 9.0.1, which I will be removing and installing CF 9.0.2. During instalation of 9.0.2, I would need to specify the server to be used - ColdFusion server / Apache/ IIS etc. My question is, where should I see in the existing CF 9.0.1 to understand the server that is currently being used.
    Thanks!

    You could use the Web Server Configuration Tool. Assuming you are on Windows, the path to launch it is usually
    Start => Programs => Adobe => ColdFusion 9 => Web Server Configuratiol Tool
    In fact, you could use this tool to add or remove web servers.

  • What are the best low cost web cams to use with a Macbook Pro?

    I want to use both the Mac internal camera and a remote camera for teaching on Skype and I am therefore looking for the best solution for me - any help out there?

    For Skype use, see Skype Help starting at https://support.skype.com/en/faq/FA603/which-webcams-and-headsets-will-work-with -skype?q=webcam. In general, webcams from http://www.mac-compatible-web-cam.com that meets your budget limits will work.
    I suggest a USB (versus Firewire) cam.  Don't install any software that comes with it (all necessary software is included in Mac OS X 10.4.9 and later), and it should work with your Mac.
    When your Mac recognizes more than one connected camera, most camera-capable applications have settings that allow you to choose which camera to use. However, they do not all work the same way.  (In most apps, the selector choices do not show if you do not have more than one camera.)
    To switch Skype between your inbuilt and external webcams, select the camera you want in the "Camera" choices bar of Skype Audio/Video Preferences as shown in this image:
    These previous threads contain some general information on how to select between connected camera in some other camera apps:
       • http://discussions.apple.com/thread/6531512
       • http://discussions.apple.com/thread/5162798
    Message was edited by: EZ Jim
    Mac OSX 10.10.3

  • Doesn't play songs, "itunes is not configured for use with mac-formatted"??

    Hi, new ipod shuffle. Seems to charge fine, all indicator lights function as expected. Everything looks fine in itunes. But it doesn't play songs. I have the most recent versions of itunes and the ipod software. Re-set, updated, and restored, nothing works. Even restored using the restore utility. Re-started computer. Checked for volume control. Won't play songs. Tried different file types. Songs play fine from itunes library and from the device's library within itunes. Tried different headphones. Hooked it up to computer speakers. Turning volume all the way up on device and speakers, heard some very faint rhythmic static, so my guess is the jack socket (or whatever you call it) is just messed up, but it seems weird that it can transfer power and data to the device but doesn't work for sound...
    The only other issues that have come up is that the drive disappears in explorer once it syncs with itunes. Other people who've noticed this seem to have completely different problems so I don't think it's related.
    Also, I have MacDrive on my computer. And when it starts up with the ipod plugged in, MacDrive offers the message "Itunes is not configured for use with Mac-formatted ipods." It offers to automatically reconfigure itunes so it can read mac-formatted ipods. Since I've restored the device, I don't see why formatting should be an issue so I say "no."
    Should I try letting macdrive do its format thing? Should I try formatting the ipod disk on the My Computer menu? Or should I just email apple and tell them the jack's busted?
    Thanks for any thoughts!

    Well, I have had my iPod for about 3 years, it is a 4th generation non-video 40 GB. One day it just stopped working, and now it does not play any songs. when I turn it on it makes this odd whirring sounds that computers make when they try really hard to do something. I cannot charge it, and it is not recognized by iTunes. Also when I turn it on, I get the apple.com/ipod/support (or whatever it is) screen. Needless to say, my warranty is expired, and so I cannot do anything for it except get a new battery, or buy a new one. Is there any way to fix this problem, or anyone out there who is experiencing the same thing?
    I'm having the exact same problem with my wife's iPod. However it will play about 3 seconds of a song and go onto the next song.
    If there is anyone out there that can help please do!
      Windows XP  

  • What is the best RAID configuration for a MacPro as a Logic User?

    There ought to be a universal answer to this question: what is the best RAID configuration for Logic Mac Pro users? I will be more specific.
    I use Logic Studio, Reason, Ableton, and Motu Symphonic Instrument simultaneously.
    I want to fail safe my precious audio files and improve performance as the system reads/writes data from multiple files, from audio tracks to digital samples.
    I want to run video files simultaneously to do nifty audio soundtracking to video.
    Here is the configuration I have in mind.
    HD 1: OS and Logic Studio, Reason/Ableton samples etc. software (non-raid) (250 GB)
    HD 2/3: MIrrored RAID set for AUDIO FILES (500 Gb identical pair)
    HD 4: Video files / Bouncing (1 TB)
    Makes sense right? A disk for reading software. A pair of 500 GB disks for reading/writing audio files and sessions in mirrored array. A 1 TB disk for video and bouncing. The main question I have is, for audio files only, is striped or mirrored better? 64K blocks the best? And are there any more details. I assume to do this in Disk Utility.

    Well, both Mirrored and Striped have their pros and cons. If you use mirrored, it will offer no better performance than the spec'ed drive along with it's sata bus speed. The plus point is, if one drive goes down, you have the second as a backup as the complete contents of one drive are mirrored on the other.
    With striped you will get a performance boost because all files (for example a single project) will get written across both drives and hence split the load on the drives and the SATA busses. The drawback is that you'll have to make sure you have a good, regular backup schedule in place because when one of the drives goes to drive heaven, you're going to be stuffed without a full backup of both drives.
    Exactly what performance boost you'd get will depend on your project, number of files, size of files, fragmentation of files, track count etc. You may find it would be easier to use the 3 drives straight, with no raid and have:
    HD 1: OS and Apps. No samples at all.
    HD2: Audio Files for Logic projects
    HD3: Reason, Ableton, Logic etc instrument sample library
    HD4: Video and bouncing.
    Which is what I ended up doing although I use HD4 as an interchangeable backup for HD1 and 2.
    There is no universal answer to this as each must make their own choice based on their preferences and needs. Mirrored will give you full backup but on-site, in machine backup. Not much good if something untoward and drastic happens to the physical machine. I think a few people toy with striped RAID but fall on the side of using the drives straight, as in their projects they don't see a big enough gain over splitting the data across your 3 remaining drives without RAID. Studios that seriously consider raid often go out and get a dedicated raid that can offer more variations than raid 0 or raid 1 (Striped and Mirrored) and better throughput.
    I hope this helps a little and not just added to the dilemma.

  • Failed to create RAID logical drive WAE-7371-k9

    hi all  we have cisco wae-7371-k9 , we wanna recreate RAID device using cd recovery. we booting on cd, and when we done with option numbers 2,3,5 succes but when we came on option 7, we cannot recreate RAID, it failed, following the log: Installer Main Menu:     1. Configure Network     2. Manufacture flash (done)     3. Install flash cookie     4. Install flash image from network     5. Install flash image from cdrom     6. Install flash image from disk     7. Recreate RAID device (WAE-674/7341/7371 only)     8. Wipe out disks and install .bin image     9. Exit (Eject and reboot) Choice [0]: 7 Recreate RAID device option is selected   All disk data will be lost.   Are you sure you want to recreate RAID array? [n]: y Saving random seed... dd: opening `/state/random-seed': No such file or directory   No volume groups found Controllers found: 1  All data in logical drive 1 will be lost. Deleting: logical drive 1 ("")  Command completed successfully. Controllers found: 1  A selected physical drive is not available for use.  Command aborted. Failed to create RAID Logical drive. (1,2)     MODEL: OE7371    FLASH: found, directory validated   COOKIE: valid    IMAGE: 4.3.5.7 FLASHDEV: /dev/sda  what's wrong with wae ?if we run command show disk detail, all hard disk detected    NO-HOSTNAME# sh disk det  RAID Physical disk information:   disk00: Ready                      JTX1470L    286102 MB   disk01: Ready                      JTX1B24L    286102 MB   disk02: Ready                      JTX1B9SL    286102 MB   disk04: Ready                      JTWSEBWL    286102 MB   disk05: Ready                      JTX0VYRL    286102 MB  RAID Logical drive information:  Mounted file systems:  MOUNT POINT      TYPE       DEVICE                SIZE     INUSE      FREE USE%  Disk encryption feature is disabled.  can you help, what's the problem .?

    Budi,
    Please turn off the unit, make sure you reseat the disks and then try the CD-recovery in the following way:
    2,3, 5,8,7,8, remove the disk and 9
    Please log the session then we can see how it went
    Hope this helps!
    Jorge

  • What are the ideal settings for my TC with Shaw's Cisco DPC3825 router/modem

    My old 2nd Gen Time Capsule crapped out and now I am about to set up my new 2TB TC.  My provider is Shaw Communications and they have upgraded me to their Broadband 100 Mbps service.  This came with a new modem/router combo made by Cisco and is model DPC3825.  Before I start plugging things in I'd like to know what are the ideal settings such that I gain the most of the BB100 service.  Should I be setting the Cisco modem/router to Bridge mode or the TC?  Should I have Shaw disable anything?  Any insight is greatly appreciated.

    Unless you specifically need to have the TC perform as the main router for your network, life will be a lot easier if you configure the TC to operate in Bridge Mode.
    Whether the Cisco modem/router or gateway can possibly be configured to act as a simple bridge mode modem is one thing to consider.
    Whether Shaw would support you in the event of any connection difficulties with the modem/router configured this way is another.
    Since Shaw is your provider, it might make sense to talk with them about best practice as far as configuring the DPC3825.
    Once you have that information in hand, you will then have the answer on how best to configure the TC.....which will very likely be in Bridge Mode.

  • What is the Highest Capacity SATA Drive for a REV A G5

    What is the Highest Capacity SATA Drive for a REV A G5 (SP 1.8 with 8 RAM slots), it came with a 160, I know 250s work... will anything higher?
    I am looking at this if nothing else, it seems to be a nice 250,
    http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Seagate/ST3250823AS/
    but I am curious if I could go higher
    Thanks
    Patrick
    (Rep points given)

    Hitachi 400GB was trouble even on SeriTek controllers. Like the early 7K250, it was not a native SATA drive. Early SATA drives were often using Marvel or some other bridge on PATA drives. The T7K250 and 7K500, or Maxtor are fine. WD has some new drives, one model is optimized for RAID-only firmware.
    Whatever happened to just plug in and go, anyway?

Maybe you are looking for