What would be the advantage of using Arch Hurd?

Would all the current packages work or would there be some incompatibilities? What are the main benefits? Just curious
Last edited by trusktr (2010-08-11 06:41:37)

xenobrain wrote:
I'm not sure if this is the right place to ask, but I've been wondering for some time now.  Why HURD?  Wouldn't it be easier for people wanting a microkernel to work on Minix 3?  Bu all accounts it's very high quality, very well documented code, and already stable to boot.  And licensing hasn't been an issue for the last ten years or so.
Microkernels are a neat idea, but I just don't see need for continued work on HURD.  Can someone enlighten me as to what I'm missing?
You must understand Hurd predates Linux. It was the kernel that was under development for the GNU system, when Linus showed up with his Linux kernel. Minix predates Linux, but it wasn't an option since its license was restrictive (although, I seem to remember universities could have it for free).
Today it is less clear why the project moves on. Stallman has this to say about it, which quite frankly leaves more questions than answers. So the debate (if there is a debate) rages between the potential benefits of a microkernel entirely supported by the GNU operating system and the accusation that Stallman and the folks at the GNU foundation never really came to terms with the Linux the kernel (it was adopted then because they had an operating system they wanted in the wild, but no kernel). The fact most people call it Linux and not GNU/Linux is yet another point of contention. So Hurd exists in the hopes one day the GNU operating system can exist on its own.
Personally, and despite my own acidic opinion that the Hurd project is a stain in the reputation of the GNU foundation (many microkernels have come and gone in these 20 years, some of which successfully adopted, and hurd is still nowhere to be seen), I think it is an important project. Breaking the barrier to the microkernel may be technologically relevant. I'm not imagining it being a ubiquitous solution for domestic computers, but instead as a possible solution for, for instance, mission critical systems.
Last edited by marfig (2010-08-13 04:07:44)

Similar Messages

  • I'm currently running NMS4.15p7 and it is quite stable. What would be the advantages to go for iMS 5.1?

     

    You'd want to review the IMS Release Notes and documentation for a complete picture of what's different in IMS. There are a number of things that jump out though.
    Aside from NMS nearing the end of its life-cycle, IMS is more stable. It's built on a foundation of both Netscape Messaging Server and SIMS.
    It includes server-side rules that can be selected by a user to apply to their mailbox or by the administrator to apply server-wide, using the very flexible SIEVE language.
    You can also easily integrate other software such as a virus scanner by using the conversion channel. You can filter MIME-Types, scan message bodies, and so on.
    In 5.2, you'll be able to use the Webmail Multiplexor similar to the POP and IMAP MMP in 4x. Domain hosting, user provisioning, security and message store management are far better in IMS.
    IMS is also the go-to product if you're looking for a Unified Messaging solution or expecting to scale-up your current deployment.
    There are dozens of other benifits to IMS, but there are too many to list. The best way to decide if it suits you is to read through the Admin Guide and possibly the Provisioning Guide and then install it in a test environment yourself to really feel it out.
    The learning curve for IMS is a bit steeper as it is a more complex product and there are more components to interact with and configure. You will have to thoroughly read the documentation available and do a trial installation and deployment before using in the real-world. But once you get over that bump, it's a very powerful server.

  • What would be the best way to install Arch, if I have Broadcom wifi?

    I can boot into an Arch USB disk, but I can't connect to the Internet, since my laptop doesn't have ethernet and the wifi card is Broadcom, which requires the `broadcom-wl` package. What would be the easiest way of proceeding with this install? On IRC, I was advised to either: (1) boot into another distro, connect to the Internet there, then chroot into the Arch USB image, and download the additional packages from there, or (2) download the `broadcom-wl` package from the AUR, and a build environment, transfer these files to the USB system, and then compile and install the module there. Both of these solutions seems rather complicated to me. With (1), I was having difficulty mounting the arch .img as a drive using Ubuntu, since Ubuntu's `mount` command needs a filetype, and didn't seem to like any of the filetypes I tried. With (2), I have a feeling this would be fairly complicated--I'm not sure which binaries I can install for my system, or how to install packages that I downloaded offline.

    I was having difficulty mounting the arch .img as a drive using Ubuntu, since Ubuntu's `mount` command needs a filetype
    Not sure what you mean?
    I too had issues with my internet, eventually I installed arch from Ubuntu. I used bootstrap image and it worked as advertized in the wiki.
    EDIT: If you using Ubuntu then don't forget to create '/run/shm' otherwise pacstrap will fail.
    Last edited by fantab (2014-10-29 04:17:46)

  • What are the advantages of using firefox mobile

    I do not understand the advantage of using Firefox mobile over just clicking "internet" on my Android. Firefox mobile seems sluggish and slow. I would support it if I knew there was some sort of advantage. What might that be?

    Here is a list of some of the features you might like to try in mobile Firefox like add-ons, Firefox Sync, and more:
    http://www.mozilla.org/en-US/mobile/features/
    I'm sorry that it's sluggish on your Android device! We are working on making it faster in future versions.

  • What is the advantage of using Wrapper Classes ?

    Hi friends,
    I am happy to join Java/J2EE tech. My project is scaled over the network. MVC-II struts, EJB based architecture, we are using.
    We are asked to use Wrapper Classes in in Java programs and not the primitive data types. I could not understand the reason.
    Pls tell me what is the advantage of using Wrapper Classes over the primitive data types ?
    means Integer instead of int, etc....

    Hi friends,
    I am happy to join Java/J2EE tech. My project is
    scaled over the network. MVC-II struts, EJB based
    architecture, we are using.
    We are asked to use Wrapper Classes in in Java
    programs and not the primitive data types. I could
    not understand the reason.
    Pls tell me what is the advantage of using Wrapper
    Classes over the primitive data types ?
    means Integer instead of int, etc....I am not sure why use Integer over int; but Wrapper classes are used to remove coupling between classes and create one hand doesn't know what the other hand does effect.
    for example:
    when you have a SFTP java package but doesn't do everything that your application needs to do in one step and you need to do sftp stuff at many places in your application, it would be wise not to use SFTP java package directly from all the classes that need to do sftp stuff. Because if you were to change the SFTP package later due to say some bug fix or newer version or ... you would have to go and modify all the classes that had sftp stuff to update.
    Instead you could write a custom sftp wrapper that handles all the sftp stuff for your application needs and that wrapper deals with the SFTP java package. So all the classes don't need to know which SFTP java package is being used only the custom-wrapper needs to know.

  • What are the advantage of using a passive monitoring technique ?

    What are the advantage of using a passive monitoring technique

    Hi Plawansai,
    I saw your question that is still unanswered.
    I believe an advantage of using a passive monitoring technique is that it won't interfer with live traffic, as it does not inject traffic into the network or modify the traffic that is already on the network.
    One drawback anyway, is that post-processing time can take a large amount of time with passive monitoring!
    A combination of the two monitoring methods seems to be the route to go.
    V.

  • What is the advantages of using Flexconnect groups

    what is the advantages of using Flexconnect groups in WLC?
    Reg,
    Ezra.

    Pls refer this document for more detail about these features
    http://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/solutions/Enterprise/Mobility/emob73dg/emob73/ch7_HREA.html#wp1091114
    FlexConnect is one mode an AP can operate, typically deployed in Branch setup where you do not have a controller at branch site. Those AP can register to a controller at your HQ or main site. So traffic will terminate at your branch switch instead of tunnel back to HQ-WLC.
    If you want roaming within your branch FlexConnect AP then you have to put those AP into a FlexConnect Group. Then only key information shared among those AP to facilitate fast roaming.
    Pls do not forget to rate our responses if you find them useful.
    HTH
    Rasika

  • What are Parameters? How are they differenet from Variables? Why can't we use variables for passing data from one sequnece to another? What is the advantage of using Parameters instead of Variables?

    Hi All,
    I am new to TestStand. Still in the process of learning it.
    What are Parameters? How are they differenet from Variables? Why can't we use variables for passing data from one sequnece to another? What is the advantage of using Parameters instead of Variables?
    Thanks in advance,
    LaVIEWan
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    Hi,
    Using the Parameters is the correct method to pass data into and out of a sub sequence. You assign your data to be passed into or out of a Sequence when you are in the Edit Sequence Call dialog and in the Sequence Parameter list.
    Regards
    Ray Farmer

  • Does Adobe Reader for iOS have the ability to open inbedded links to additional PDF docs?  If not, then what would be the best way to use these already created PDF's?

    Does Adobe Reader for iOS have the ability to open inbedded links created with Acrobat Standard to additional PDF docs?  If not, then what would be the best way to use these already created PDF's on an I Pad?

    driddy61,
    As of June 2014, none of the Adobe Reader mobile products support the hyperlink action for opening a separate PDF document.
    Adobe Reader for iOS
    Adobe Reader for Android
    Adobe Reader Touch for Windows 8
    In addition, the Reader mobile products do not open multiple windows/documents simultaneously, which would make the navigation between PDF documents nearly impossible. (Once a hyperlink takes you to a different PDF document, you have no way to go back to the original PDF document.)
    The only Adobe Reader product that fulfills your department's requirements is Adobe Reader XI (mostly for Windows/Mac desktop/laptop computers).  Acrobat Pro and Standard are paid products.
    Because you are in search of a less expensive device for your department, you could get a Windows tablet instead of a Windows desktop/laptop computer. Microsoft Surface Pro (that you've mentioned in your previous reply) is just one example.  You can also find other less expensive Windows tablets.
    Tablets
    However, please keep in mind that there are two different types of Windows tablets running two different operating systems.
    (a) A Windows tablet with an Intel-based processor running Windows 8.1 Pro
    Example: Surface Pro 3
    You can install and run traditional desktop apps (e.g. Adobe Reader XI) and new Windows Store apps ("Modern" or "Metro-style" apps).
    (b) A Windows tablet with an ARM-based processor running Windows RT 8.1
    Example: Surface 2
    You can only install and run Windows Store apps (e.g. Adobe Reader Touch) but not traditional desktop apps like Adobe Reader XI.
    In general, type (b) tablets are more affordable than type (a) tablets.  However, if you want to run Adobe Reader XI, you do need to check the technical specification of each tablet and make sure the following conditions are met.
    Processor: Intel
    Operating system:  Windows 8/8.1 or Windows 8/8.1 Pro, not RT
    Hope this helps you choose the right device for your department.  Please let us know if you have any questions about system requirements or supported features in the Adobe Reader products.

  • What are the advantage of using Oracle Database when compare to SQL SERVER

    Hi all
    Please tell anyone about
    what are the advantage of using Oracle Database when compare to SQL SERVER
    Thanks in advance
    Balamurugan S

    user12842738 wrote:
    Hi,
    There are various differences between the two.
    1. SQL Server is only Windows, but Oracle runs on almost all Platforms.
    2. You can have multiple databases in SQL Server, but Oracle provides you only one database per instance.Given that the very term 'database' has s different meaning in the two products, this "difference" is absolutely meaningless.
    3. SQL Server provides T-SQL for writing programs, whereas Oracle provides PL/SQLWhich means what? Both products have a procedural programming language. They named them differently, and the languages are not interchangeable. Means nothing in comparing the features/strengths/weaknesses/suitability to purpose.
    4. Backup types in both are the same. (Except Oracle provides an additional backup called Logical Backup.)You make that sound like "Logical Backup" is something more than it is. It is nothing more than an export of the data and metadata. Many experts don't even consider it a backup. I'm sure SQL Server provides the same functionality though they probably call it by some other name.
    5. Both provide High Availability.Well, I guess they both have a suite of features they refer to as "High Availability". But what does that really mean? The devil is in the details. Remember, the two products don't even agree on what constitutes a "database".
    6. Both come in various distributions.???
    >
    If you are going for an Implementation, you can try SQL Server Express Edition and Oracle XE which are free to use.
    Then you can choose whichever is comfortable for your needs.
    Thanks.

  • What is workflow ? What are the advantages of using workflow? What are the

    what is workflow ? What are the advantages of using workflow? What are the steps for building a workflow ?

    Hi Leela,
    Your question is very straight question.
    Better u can follow these links.
    http://www.esnips.com/doc/90b7763b-f9d9-4861-a273-04674b9fe3f2/Workflow
    http://www.esnips.com/doc/991843e0-8686-4949-94b9-f45d90081b22/workflow
    And i'll give some theory answer for ur questions
    i.e.,SAP Business Workflow can be used to define business processes that are not yet mapped in the R/3 System. These may be simple release or approval procedures, or more complex business processes such as creating a material master and the associated coordination of the departments involved. SAP Business Workflow is particularly suitable for situations in which work processes have to be run through repeatedly, or situations in which the business process requires the involvement of a large number of agents in a specific sequence.
    You can also use SAP Business Workflow to respond to errors and exceptions in other, existing business processes. You can start a workflow when predefined events occur, for example an event can be triggered if particular errors are found during an automatic check.
    SAP provides several workflows that map predefined business processes. These workflows do not require much implementation. For an overview of these SAP workflows, refer to Workflow Scenarios in Applications.
    Integration
    SAP Business Workflow uses the existing transactions and functions of the R/3 System and does not change the functions. You can combine the existing functions of the R/3 System to form new business processes with SAP Business Workflow. The workflow system takes over control of the business processes. If you are already using SAP Organizational Management, you can use the organizational structure created there to have the relevant agents carry out the individual activities. It is possible to have an activity carried out by a position. This ensures that the respective occupiers of the position can carry out the individual activities during execution of the workflow. This means that personnel changes in your organization are taken into account immediately in the execution of a workflow.
    Features
    SAP Business Workflow provides a number of tools for defining and analyzing workflows as well as for monitoring operation.
    The Workflow Builder is for displaying and making changes to workflows. You can make small extensions directly to the original workflows supplied by SAP, such as carrying out your own agent assignments or changing deadline monitoring.
    There are several Workflow Wizards to support you in the definition of workflows, with which you can create specific parts of a workflow. The Workflow Wizard Explorer gives you an overview of the existing Workflow Wizards.
    In order to make the functions of the R/3 Systems available to a workflow, you use business objects, which you can define and analyze in the Business Object Builder. These business objects are made available to the workflow in reusable tasks. The Business Wizard Explorer gives you an overview of all existing tasks.
    The end user receives information about the activities they are to carry out in their Business Workplace. This provides them with a central overview of all the activities that they are authorized to carry out. They can commence the activities from here.
    Several tools are available to the workflow system administrator, with which they can control and analyze the current workflows. The workflow system administrator is notified of problems automatically by the system.
    Workflow tutorials with step-by-step and with screenshots are available at http://www.****************/Tutorials/Workflow/Workflow.htm
    This has a step by step procedure :
    http://fuller.mit.edu/workflow/debugging.pdf
    www.erpgenie.com/sap/workflow/debugging.htm
    http://www.erpgenie.com/workflow/debugging.htm?2b5de440
    Rewards if it is useful.

  • What are the advantages of using an internal table with workarea

    Hi,
    can anyone tell me
    What are the advantages of using an internal table with workarea
    over an internal table with header line?
    thnks in adv
    regards
    nagi

    HI,
    Internal tables are a standard data type object which exists only during the runtime of the program. They are used to perform table calculations on subsets of database tables and for re-organising the contents of database tables according to users need.
    http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw04/helpdata/en/fc/eb35de358411d1829f0000e829fbfe/content.htm
    <b>Difference between Work Area and Header Line</b>
    While adding or retrieving records to / from internal table we have to keep the record temporarily.
    The area where this record is kept is called as work area for the internal table. The area must have the same structure as that of internal table. An internal table consists of a body and an optional header line.
    Header line is a implicit work area for the internal table. It depends on how the internal table is declared that the itab will have the header line or not.
    e.g.
    data: begin of itab occurs 10,
    ab type c,
    cd type i,
    end of itab. " this table will have the header line.
    data: wa_itab like itab. " explicit work area for itab
    data: itab1 like itab occurs 10. " table is without header line.
    The header line is a field string with the same structure as a row of the body, but it can only hold a single row.
    It is a buffer used to hold each record before it is added or each record as it is retrieved from the internal table. It is the default work area for the internal table
    1) The difference between
    whih header line and with out heater line of internal table.
    ex:-
    a) Data : itab like mara occurs 0 with header line.
    b) Data: itab like mara occurs 0.
    -While adding or retrieving records to / from internal table we have to keep the record temporarily.
    -The area where this record is kept is called as work area for the internal table.
    -The area must have the same structure as that of internal table. An internal table consists of a body and an optional header line.
    -Header line is a implicit work area for the internal table. It depends on how the internal table is declared that the itab will have the header line or not.
    a) Data : itab like mara occurs 0 with header line.
    table is with header line
    b) Data: itab like mara occurs 0.
    table is without header line
    2)work area / field string and internal table
    which one is prefarable for good performance any why ?
    -The header line is a field string with the same structure as a row of the body, but it can only hold a single row , whereas internal table can have more than one record.
    In short u can define a workarea of an internal table which means that area must have the same structure as that of internal table and can have one record only.
    Example code:
    data: begin of itab occurs 10,
    ab type c,
    cd type i,
    end of itab. " this table will have the header line.
    data: wa_itab like itab. " explicit work area for itab
    data: itab1 like itab occurs 10. " table is without header line.
    Regards,
    Padmam.

  • What are the advantages of using CACHE and NOCACHE Hint

    What are the advantages of using CACHE and NOCACHE Hint & difference of them.I saw one of oracle.sql script have CACHE & oracle rac script include NOCACHE .Why is that

    924250 wrote:
    In a SOA product include db scripts,when we install the product we want to execute the db script to create sequence both oracle RAC & Oracle db
    Oracle DB
    CREATE SEQUENCE REG_LOG_SEQUENCE START WITH 1 INCREMENT BY 1 NOCACHE
    Oracle RAC DB
    CREATE SEQUENCE REG_LOG_SEQUENCE START WITH 1 INCREMENT BY 1 CACHE 20 ORDERas sb mentioned, this has nothing to do with oracle hints.
    you'll want to search the documentation about sequences.

  • What are the advantages of using LabVIEW projects in TestStand, as apposed to just a path to a vi

    What are the advantages of using LabVIEW projects in TestStand, as apposed to just a path to a vi ?
    I am modifying an existing workspace for a new product, and it seems like more work to add the vi's into a LabVIEW project
    does it gain anything in the long run

    Hi Rusty,
    I wanted to quickly clarify on the integration between TestStand and LabVIEW Projects.
    As Jeff mentioned, some of the big benefits of using LabVIEW Projects is to organize code and to namespace them.
    For instance if you had a project called "Power Supply" that housed all your power supply code and had a VI in that called "Initialize", and another project called "Temperature Chamber" that also had a VI called "Initialize", both these VIs are namespaced by the project, so there is no longer confusion about which "Initialize" VI is being used.
    Now from a TestStand point of view, in prior version of TestStand, we lost some of this benefit because TestStand did not know about TestStand projects and called VIs simply as un-namespaced VIs. However, in TestStand 2010 (released last year, free eval available at ni.com/teststand), we added the ability to (optionally) call VIs within the context of their projects. This means that:
    VIs are now namespaced by their project, even when called from TestStand
    VIs can use project specific constructs like NI-DAQmx tasks and conditional compilation settings
    Note: When creating deployments, the VIs maintain their projects and namespacing, so this benefit holds true for deployments as well.
    Additionally, someone had mentioned looking into using lvlibs to namespace your VIs for deployment. Two comments:
    With TestStand 2010, this is no longer neccessary since the project itself namespaces the VIs
    You might also want to look into LabVIEW Packed Project Libraries, which combined several VIs into a single file. Think of it as a DLL specific to LabVIEW that is as easy to call as normal LabVIEW VIs. TestStand 2010 can call VIs that are exposed by PPLs. In addition, the deployment utility can automatically pack your VIs into PPLs for deployment.
    Hope this is helpful!
    Jervin Justin
    NI TestStand Product Manager

  • What is the advantages of using oracle10g database?

    Hi,
    I didn't feel many advantages when using oracle10g.
    So what is the advantages of using oracle10g database?
    For common using,not for advance.It is not big different.
    Thanks in advance!

    For normal users versions before 10g is sufficent.But for large applications means distributed applications(grid) 10g is good one

Maybe you are looking for

  • Print in report generation

    Dear all, I am using Report Generation Toolkit to create a report of my project. I am using "Word" type Report and want the VI to print it after creating the report. However i dont want it to open the MS Word and just want it to print it right away.

  • Error Converting Currency --  Load from SAP ECC / R/3  to BW / BI

    Hi, I have a custom extractor pulling data from ECC. However, I am getting the following error. 'Error Converting Currency from USD4 to  on 8/27/2008' RSA3 works fine. PSA load fails and the above message can be seen in the application log in ECC. An

  • Update with two subquerries (in set and where)

    Hi there, this statement doesn't work: update GFDXT_CLIENTES set CLT_NUMERO_CLIENTE_GEICO = (select COD_CORRECTO from LOOKUP, GFDXT_CLIENTES where GFDXT_CLIENTES.CLT_NUMERO_CLIENTE_GEICO = COD_ERRONEO) where GFDXT_CLIENTES.CLT_NUMERO_CLIENTE_GEICO =

  • SAP SCM Console error

    Hi SAP Friends, Iam using a SAP SCM IDES version 5.0. while posting transactions in SCM system the system dose not responce after 2 hours of starting the management Console. When i had a look at the management console the first instance status was en

  • How do i see whats been backed up to icloud

    how do i see whats been backed up to icloud