When I am finished editing an image in Lightroom, what files or versions should I have in my database of images?

When I am finished editing an image in Lightroom, what files should I have in my Library?  I start with a RAW file or a tiff scan from film. I label that "A" as the archived file. I make a virtual copy to work on in the Develop module. When I am done, I save a file as a Print file with dimensions of the print.  Since Lightroom is non-destructive, do I need to save any other versions?  For instance, in Photoshop since the crop is destructive,
I edit an uncropped version and do the crop when I am working on the Print version.  What should I have for the most flexibility over time in Lightroom? 
I use Lightroom CC on a IMAC desktop.  My photos are on a separate hard drive and are also backed up offline.  Im running OSX10.9.4.

You don't need to make a virtual copy before you edit the photo (this is optional, but most people don't bother as its extra work with little or no benefit). EXCEPTION: If you are doing multiple crops of the image, you would need virtual copies in that case, created after all other editing is completed.
You can't "save" from Lightroom, you can "export". (It's a terminology thing) You would need to export a photo at the desired dimensions for printing, but there's no need to retain this exported photo, you can consider it temporary and delete it once the print has been made, knowing that you can always re-create it exactly from Lightroom if you need it.
So to answer the question in your title, all you need to retain on your hard disk is your original image (and in the EXCEPTION case where you have multiple crops of the image, you would retain the multiple virtual copies in Lightroom).

Similar Messages

  • My Images won't open in Photoshop CS5 when I click on Edit in Lightroom - even though this option has been selected?  To edit in Photoshop I have to export image from Lightroom then import into Photoshop.  I have other programmes such as NIK and if I wish

    My Images won't open in Photoshop CS5 when I click on Edit in Lightroom - even though this option has been selected?  To edit in Photoshop I have to export image from Lightroom then import into Photoshop.  I have other programmes such as NIK and if I wish to edit in these everything works fine.

    Same here. I've never had trouble with this function before.
    It opens the Photoshop application with all the menus/windows, but it never opens the actual image I chose to work on.
    I'm on a Mac, using OS X Yosemite, 10.10.1  Lightroom is version 5.7  Photoshop is CS5, version 12.0.4
    FWIW, I also can't automate>Photomerge ... . Makes me think Photoshop, not Lightroom, is all wacky. I tried dumping PS preferences

  • When I go to edit a picture from Lightroom to Photoshop it does not open in Photoshop, it use to work before the latest update, but I deleted the last version of CC and now it isn't editing photos!  HELP please required.

    When I go to edit a picture from Lightroom to Photoshop it does not open in Photoshop, it use to work before the latest update, but I deleted the last version of Photoshop CC and now it isn't editing photos!
    Lightroom opens up Photoshop but the image doesn't appear!  Any help gratefully needed!

    Ok I sorted it, by uninstalling and re-installing Photoshop

  • Anyone has print out the iPhoto album book by apple after finish editing? May I check is the quality good? I have compiled my photo album book , choosen hard cover option , 100 pages , estimated cost is US150. Not sure worth to print out or not?

    Anyone has print out the iPhoto album book by apple after finish editing? May I check is the quality good? I have compiled my photo album book , choosen hard cover option , 100 pages , estimated cost is US150. Not sure worth to print out or not?

    All I can say is the books I've created as gifts to my children for their children were received with absolute joy and appreciation (each book chronicled in pictures  the first year of each grandchild's life). Granted the sentimental factor had a lot to do with the recipient's enjoyment of the book but they were spetacular. The book with its glossy dust cover is a very impressinve way to present your photos. 
    As Larry has pointed out so many have posted here that they were very satisfried with their book and Apple is very good about correcting problems. 
    To make sure there are no errors in the book before you order preview the book as described in this Apple document: iPhoto '11: Preview a book, card, or calendar before you order or print it. If the PDF file shows no errors, either in text typos (my biggest problem) or in missing photos, etc., the printed book will be error free.
    OT

  • Lightroom export file size: why so small? How can I maximize image quality?

    My image file sizes are much smaller after editing and exporting through Lightroom. Is it impossible to maintain original file size to preserve image quality? Will this smaller file size have negative impact on prints? Any help is appreciated!

    Per Berntsen wrote:
    My view on this is somewhat different ...
    Jpgs should never be edited, except as a last resort. And it defeats the purpose of working with raw files if you export a jpg, and then edit it.
    Agreed. Unfortunately there are many cameras that only output JPEG format files. The camera file (or any other original JPEG file) is your "raw" unedited file inside LR. If you need to send the file to someone else for further editing who doesn't have LR then Exporting with 100% Quality setting might make sense. I say "might" because it's still possible to get very good results using lower Quality setting JPEGs if you only re-save the file one (1) time after further editing. I agree that 16 bit, ProPhoto RGB, TIFF Export files are best for "critical" work and when using 'Edit in Photoshop' from LR.
    I suggest taking a look at the JPEG compression image tests on Jeffrey Friedl's Blog. It's a wealth of information! LR's Quality settings range from 0% to 100% or 100 Quality levels. In reality there are only 13 Quality levels, which are the same as in PS.
    JPEG QUALITY SETTINGS
    Photoshop
    Description
    Lightroom
    0
    Low
    0-7%
    1
    Low
    8-15%
    2
    Low
    16-23%
    3
    Low
    24-30%
    4
    Low
    31-38%
    5
    Med
    39-46%
    6
    Med
    47-53%
    7
    Med
    54-61%
    8
    High
    62-69%
    9
    High
    70-76%
    10
    Max
    77-84%
    11
    Max
    85-92%
    12
    Max
    93-100%
    I use LR JPEG Quality settings of 77-84% for outside printing and LR 62-69% for web posting. I've yet to see any compression artifacts using these settings and I am a pixel-peeper!
    Per Berntsen wrote:
    If someone gives me a jpg to edit, I always save it as a tiff and convert to 16-bit, to minimize furhter deterioration. I realize that this will not be true 16-bit - no information is added to the image - but my impression is that it will withstand heavy editing better, and not end up with a comb-like histogram.
    Why not simply Import the JPEG file into LR and do all your editing non-destructively? There's no need to convert the JPEG file to TIFF unless you need to use LR 'Edit in PS.' Lightroom uses a16 bit/color, ProPhoto RGB, Linear Gamma workspace for all images even when editing sRGB JPEG files.

  • When I am finished editing and I click on library from develop, LIghtroom will no longer save my sharpening edit. How do I fix this?

    When I am done editing a photo and want to export it, I click on library from
    develop, and Lightroom will no longer save the setting I used in detail for sharpening.This
    has never been a problem before; How do I fix this?

    Are you setting the sharpening at 100% zoom (1:1)? Only when zoomed in is the sharpening applied to the Develop display. Also, LR may not be redrawing the Library preview image file. To force the creation of a new preview, select loupe view (E) and zoom to 1:1 and then out to fit.

  • Colour shift when using 4.2 Edit In to adjust a NEF file in CS6

    If I choose Edit In and CS6 the resulting image in CS6 shows a marked colour green/yellow colour shift.
    The LR4 external editor is configured to edit using ProPhoto RGB with 16 bit TIFF.
    However, if I use the Export option with the same settings and then open the image in Photoshop it is fine.
    Equally, if I first convert the NEF image to a DNG and then use Edit In with the same settings it also appears fine in Photoshop. This would appear to rule out any issues with monitor profiles (monitor profiled with i1).
    Therefore this appears to be an issue with NEF files (Nikon D3) using the Edit In facility.
    Also for some obscure reason it also does not always give the option to Edit a Copy with Lightroom Adjustments and just goes straight to Photoshop (even though it has been adjusted in Lightroom!).

    manicfoto wrote:
    Richard,  perhaps I have not made the issue clear.   If I import an image into Lightroom and choose Edit In Photoshop it should go straight to Photoshop as no changes have been made in Lightroom.  However, if I make any adjustments in the Develop module and choose to make further changes in Photoshop I should have the option to Edit a Copy with Lightroom Adjustments etc.  This dialog is not offered consistently.
    If I make a change in Photoshop it should (and does) correctly save it as a new TIFF file.  Again if I make any adjustments in Develop module and then choose to make further changes in Photoshop to the TIFF file it should still offer the dialog box with the copy options.  Again this is not happening consistently.
    Richard correctly explained how 'Edit In' works with raw files, at least that's the way it does on my Windows 7 64 bit system.
    When selecting 'Edit in' with a raw file the 'What to Edit' popup with options for 'Edit a Copy with LR adjustments,' 'Edit a Copy,' and 'Edit Original' will not appear. Instead a TIFF file is created in system memory with LR adustments applied, which then opens in PS. Until you hit 'Save' in PS the TIFF file resides only in system memory. Once you hit 'Save' or Save As' (with the same folder location) the TIFF file will appear inside LR with both the LR and PS adjustments applied.
    manicfoto wrote:
    trshaner, I have done some further testing of the DNG files, and they do, in fact, also exhibit the same colour shift behaviour, although the amount of the shift seems to depend on the original image - some images show a more marked shift than others which was not obvious to me at first.
    This is consistent with LR output rendering engine problem if both the NEF and DNG copy for a specific image take on the same color shift. Since the effect is very subtle on a single conversion I can see where you might have confused the DNG as looking OK.
    manicfoto wrote:
    I then performed another test with a TIFF file and although the change was smaller the colour definitely shifts, with the amount of shift being determined by the contents of the original image, so I have to conclude that I have the output rendering issue mentioned earlier in the thread.
    Incidentally, the colour shift issue is also found if I use the option to Open as a Smart Object in Photoshop.
    I have re-installed Lightroom 4.2 but the problem is still the same.
    To really confirm that this is being caused by the LR output rendering engine you will need do an additional 'Edit a Copy with LR Adjustments'  to the TIFF file. This will create a 2nd TIFF file, which you can then select and then 'Edit a Copy with LR Adjustments.' I would do this at least three times to insure you can see the "cumulative' effect from the LR output rendering engine conversion. You will want to compare the last TIFF file (4th) with the original (1st) TIFF file.
    Please try this and post the histograms for the original TIFF and last Tiff with three cumulative 'Edit a Copy with LR Adjustments,' or confirm that's what you have already done in the above posted histograms.

  • When trying to use "Edit a copy with Lightroom Adjustements" from Lightroom, Photoshop opens but no photo is displayed.

    I can see from searching online that this is a regular question but I have not yet seen a solution.
    I am running Lightroom 5.4 and Photoshop CC 14.2.1, both kept updated via the monthly subscription, on a 2013 MacMini running OSX 10.9.3
    Starting with jpg's:
    If I try  "Edit a copy with Lightroom Adjustements" - Photoshop opens but no photo displayed in PS
    If "Edit a Copy" or "Edit Original" then Photoshop displayes the file OK
    If I am using Canon Raw files (.CR2) from my Canon 70D, then AS EXPECTED Lightroom starts Photoshop with the intervening dialog box about opening a copy or original but again just a blank screen and no photo displayed.
    Has anybody found a solution yet?
    Thanks in advance

    Hi Victoria,
    I dont have 3.6. but I installed lightroom 4 and the function worked fine. But i didnt like the version 4, as it consumes a lot of resources.
    I can open raw files without any problem.
    And this function had been working before and suddenly this stopped working. I didnt do any setttings changes even.
    Really appreciate your help on this.

  • How can I attribute my edits before aperture to the raw files as versions?

    Hi,
    I am in the middle of importing all my files (approx 100,000) into aperture. I have previously made edits of my best images and in some cases have several edits for one 'master' file. How can I attribute or link the edits to the master files? I have followed a simple nomenclature, where the camera raw file was say bfes1001.tif, I would name the files bfes1001e1.psd or bfes10001e1-small.jpg, bfes1001e1-epson7600.psd. So my question is really two parts, first is there a way to link my old edits to the master raw files, and secondly is there a way to import photoshop files without flattening them? I can't image throwing away all that time making masks etc. If there is no way to import a layered photoshop file then is there a way to make an association to the files if I leave them outside of Aperture (althought that seems to defeat a big part of Aperture)?
    Thanks,
    Eric

    This is not a method suited to automation, but what you can do is:
    1) Import original RAW into Aperture.
    2) Edit in external editor - it creates a new version based on PSD or TIFF (you choose in options).
    3) Kill external editor, replace created TIFF file with your new "master" tiff (or PSD). To do this just open the Aperture Library package using "Show Package Contents" in finder, do the same for the Project package held within the library, and finding the new TIFF version of your file. You could either replace the TIFF file before you return to Aperture form the editor or replace all the TIFF files with Aperture closed. The name must be identical. If you have a TIFF or PSD not in RGB mode Aperture will not like you much and probably crash whenever you go to view the picture.
    That seems the most space-efficient way to me and keeps Aperture understanding that your edited TIFFS are versions of a particular master.

  • Why does Lightroom say "file can not be found" but I can see the image?

    I have uploaded pics from my Fujifilm XPro1 but some of them can not be moved, exported or developed(?)  The image is there but I can't do anything to it.

    Thanks very much. I found the missing images in another folder on my desktop although when I originally uploaded from the camera card they did not automatically upload to Lightroom as usual.   I found another folder with icons came up as Lightroom and Lightroom2 with those images. When I opened it it automatically imported to Lightroom but now the Lr app only opens with that last download and my entire library of 2500+ images is empty!! and all of these new ones have "!” on the thumbnail.  Now what have I done, if it was me?

  • Resolution Change When I am Using "Edit a copy with lightroom adjustment"

    Hi Guys,
    I am using the latest version of lightroom and I have been trying to fix the error that lightroom made.
    1. I open most of my photos (resolution 300dpi) on lightroom to do some adjustment
    2. I am using "Edit with photoshop CS3" to continuemy editing
    okay this the problem!
    I just realized that every time, I open the photos on photoshop the resolution change became 240.
    I am really not sure which part of lightroom that I need to change :( because I just want to keep the original resolution when I bring it to photoshop.
    Thanks

    Bear in mind that there is no meaningful resolution number in an image file coming from a camera. The only truly "correct" resolution would be the number of pixels per inch on the sensor array, but that would be several thousand ppi, and your image size in inches or cm would appear to be very small -- i.e., the size of the sensor. Any other number put in there by the camera, by ACR, or by LR is merely a placeholder. Both LR and ACR set this to 240 ppi by default, which gives a typical camera image dimensions bearing some reasonable relationship to a potential print size.

  • This is my first time using FCPX and I just completed editing a music video. What are the last things I have to do to get the best quality out of my video before I try to upload it to youtube?

    I want my music video to look as crisp as possible. I was wondering if there were an tricks or tips that needs to be done before i upload it to youtube. This will be my first time uploading anything to youtube so im not sure. also what does rendering mean? and compressing? thanks

    Best quality = "master file" export. You can export said file and store it where ever you like.
    But quality "out" depends on what you put "in." You can never "improve" on the quality during the edit process. If you had low quality H.264 files to begin with, that's the best it's gonna get. If you had HQ ProRes422 or even 4444... (which is "above" 2k HD quality) those are great. And the output will be rich. But most likely, you will have to compress that file to exhibit it. (I'll get to that later.)
    Now, when you share to YouTube, you will be limited on quality. They have a prescribed bit-rate and compression. (Even though they do offer 1080p.)
    Now, you will NOT be able to share a "master" file to YouTube. Much too big.
    Luckily, in the share options, FCPX has an option for "YouTube." It does all the compression for you. BTW: This is awesome. It finds your account and does the "posting" for you. It's simple.
    Rendering = calculations made on various effects. A non linear editor has to build files for some effects... dissolves, moves, filters, etc, etc. The software does "math" and crunches numbers--to make your image animate across the screen, example. This is called "rendering." Depending on your preferences, this is done for you.
    Now when you output or "share," rendering is done for you automatically. If you choose to see how an effect will look "smoothed out," you can choose to render a file on the fly.
    Compression means just that. Video files are, by nature, huge... billions of O's and 1's. To make them flow thru various pipelines (the electronic infrastruture) most files are compressed--or made smaller. Basically, some of the duplicate O's and 1's are taken out. (It's much more complicated than that, I'm givng a laypersson's definition.) The more you compress, the less quality you get. The picture begins to look "jig-jagged" or pixelated. There is less detail in the picture.
    When you go to "share" to YouTube, FCPX will do this compression for you, up to (or should I say, "down to") YouTube's specs.

  • I got this when I clicked RSS Feed of this list: This XML file does not appear to have any style information associated with it. The document tree is shown below.

    Question:  My MacBook Pro is completely F*cked up I am aging like I used to when I used Windows ie.  I need GENus to contact me and help me with so many problems.

    yea I got the same error for playing files on filestube and its just not that, ever since 2 days ago when I updated firefox everything have just started to ..uck up all the time, high cpu memory load without any addons and it wont terminate for another 20secs after I close it... I think I'll just reinstall with an older version, everything worked just fine then

  • When I press Command 1 it doesn't do what I thought it should-jusp to my first tab. Help?

    I use Safari in full screen on Lion. I press Command 2, it opens my 2nd tab, Command 3 opens my 3rd. When I press Command 1, it jumps to my desktop. I cant find anything in System Preferences to change this. I want Command 1 to open my first tab. Can this be done? Am I doing something wrong?

    Try disabling the pop-up blocker or adding the site to your safe list -> https://support.mozilla.com/en-US/kb/Pop-up%20blocker

  • I have version 3.6.23 on a desktip PC. When I "check for updates", I get a message that there are no updates available. What version should I have and how do I get it?

    I tried to use a shmetsy.com tool for Etsy. I couldn't use it because of my version of Firefox - 3.6.23
    I went to "About Mozilla Firefox" to check for updates and got the message "There are no updates available"

    I don't know what versions of Firefox work with Shmetsy. Do they have a system requirements page? It's not in the very short FAQ...
    You have the latest in the 3.6 line.
    If you want Firefox 7, go to http://www.mozilla.org/firefox to get the installer.
    Normally, major upgrades go without a hitch, but just in case, I recommend backing up your Firefox settings to cover yourself in the rare case that something goes wrong. See [https://support.mozilla.com/en-US/kb/Backing+up+your+information Backing up your information]. (You can copy your entire Firefox profile folder somewhere outside of the Mozilla folder.)

Maybe you are looking for