Which 15" MacBook Pro will be best for my planned use?

I am heading back to school and am required to get a MacBook Pro for class (I am a Design, Art & Technology - AKA Multimedia - major).  The suggested specs from the school are as follows:
15-inch MacBook Pro
2.7GHz Quad-core Intel Core i7, NVIDIA GeForce GT 650M with 1GB GDDR5 memory
8GB 1600MHz DDR3 SDRAM - 2x4GB
750GB Serial ATA Drive @ 7200 rpm
I am in the process of researching if this is the best computer for my needs.  I am upgrading from my current laptop - a 2.53 GHz 15" MacBook Pro from '09 with 4GB of RAM and 7200 RPM 750 GB HDD (upgraded from a 5200 RPM 250 GB HDD) running 10.6.8 - which has been holding up great for four years.  At this point though I need a second computer that has a quadcore processor.
My normal/expected usage:
I will likely be working on projects in web design, some light game design, app design, interactive installation, etc. for class.  I anticipate working on video editing software and Photoshop as well.  I regularly use Ableton Live with an external audio interface, MIDI devices and third party plugins for music production (20 to 40+ track mixing & mastering) and may start to use it for live or interactive projects.  I run an external monitor as a second screen when at home and do a good amount of multitasking work with the second display where quickness switching between applications is key.
I stopped by the local Apple store today and had a conversation with one of the sales reps exploring the possibilities of deviating from my school's suggested bundle above.  We talked about the benefits of SSD's on performance but the drawbacks on storage size to $$ ratio (I need at least 500GB of storage space, preferably 700GB).  The rep suggested multiple times that the Retina display model would be best for me because it is a more durable computer and makes more sense than dropping the 2.7 GHz processor to a 2.6 GHz on the above recommendation and using the money to upgrade the hard drive to an SSD (since it would be a similar computer but without the hi-res screen).  But the Retina models were in stock, while the custom non-retina model I was considering building online was not, so I do not know if the rep was just doing his job as a salesperson and trying to move what the store had in stock...
What I am hoping to get opinions on is: Given my planned usage, will the school's suggestion be sufficient/will my downgrade of proccessing power to fund an SSD be insufficient/does it make sense to really stretch my budget and get the Retina 15" 2.7 GHz with 8GB RAM and 512/768 GB SSD?  Even with the educational pricing and my usage, I don't know if the upgrade to the Retina 15" is justified - but I am not very experienced in comparing computers.  Any thoughts or suggestions?  Thanks!

I say DITTO to what Clinton just told you, AND what woodmeister said.
As to use of the External HD  use same for all large media files, PDF , pics, movies etc.
Keep your internal SSD for programs and primary (use it every day) working files of small size.
Yes, I would replace the SSD as upgrade and RAM myself.
Ram takes 30 seconds to do, anyone can do that nearly with eyes closed.  EASY
SSD, youd need to use carbon copy cloner or likewise, clone your internal HD to the SSD, check with a boot to make sure all ok........then install the SSD, very easy, like Clinton said, .....done it many times.
You asked:
Are you able to reference info on them without moving the data to the internal SSD?
Yes, you can alter, open close etc files off the external HD same as you can the internal SSD, however access speed will be slower, but plenty fast enough for anything you want to do, watch movies off same, work on/ alter/ create files on internal and then backup to external
You need an external HD at any rate for Time Machine backup, and backup in general. NEVER trust any internal HD, or a single copy of anything.
In fact you should always have at least 2 backups for data, in which case a 2nd external HD is highly recommended.

Similar Messages

  • I'm a recently graduated film student and my macbook pro needs an upgrade... Will be using FCPX, Adobe CS6 etc. Which 15' macbook pro will be best suited for me? I'm most concerned about the processor speeds (what do they really mean in english?)

    I need a new 15" MBP for film editing. The processor speed numbers are confusing.

    The Tech Specs for the MBPr are here:http://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs-retina/ and you can see both 15" models come with the i7 processor, one at 2.0 and the other at 2.3 GHz.  The processors are identical except for the clock speed, which directly indicates how many calculations a second they can perform.  If you are doing things like editing or rendering or ray tracing, heavy duty computational things, the faster the processor, the less time it takes to do the task.
    But the 2.3 GHz machine has even more, twice the memory and twice the storage capacity.  With film work that will get to be important since you can load more directly into memory where it is readily accessible to the processor, and twice the storage so you do not have to move material to an external drive so soon.  Both of which will contribute to faster workload turn around for you.
    For your needs, the faster machine with twice the memory and twice the SSD storage will be the thing you need.  And, keep in mind that the MBP cannot be upgraded after purchase like in the past.  So get all you will need now at the time of purchase.

  • My macbook pro will not charge when I am using it.

    My macbook pro will not charge when I am using it. My battery will say "charged" then "not charging" and it goes back and fourth. It says "Power Source: Power Adapter". But when I use my pro it will loose the power source then reconnect a second later to it. This problem is getting annoying because I have to stop using my macbook pro to charge it.

    Reset SMC.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3964
    Choose the method for:
    "Resetting SMC on portables with a battery you should not remove on your own".
    If this does not help, contact Apple.
    Best.

  • Which MacBook Pro is the best for me

    Hello, I was looking to purchase a MacBook Pro but the thing is I don't know which one to get. It is between the
    13-inch: 2.4GHz
    with Retina display
    Specifications
    2.4GHz dual-core Intel Core i5
    Turbo Boost up to 2.9GHz
    8GB 1600MHz memory
    256GB PCIe-based flash storage1
    Intel Iris Graphics
    Built-in battery (9 hours)2
    Or
    15-inch: 2.0GHz
    with Retina display
    Specifications
    2.0GHz quad-core Intel Core i7
    Turbo Boost up to 3.2GHz
    8GB 1600MHz memory
    256GB PCIe-based flash storage1
    Intel Iris Pro Graphics
    Built-in battery (8 hours)2
    The 2,600 is out of the question.
    Which one should I get if I am
    -Surfing the Internet
    -Watching Netflix
    -Doing School Work
    -Editing and uploading videos
    -Playing 1 or 2 Games.
    Thanks if you can help me.
    Tom L.

    Go for the 15-inch MacBook Pro with Retina display. It has got a quad-core CPU and a better GPU, which will improve your video editing and games experience, even if the Intel Iris Pro GPU is not the best GPU for those tasks

  • Using MacBook Pro as a monitor for video camera using HDMI

    I want to connect my Canon 70D to HDMI port on MacBook Pro so that I can use the MacBook Pro as a monitor while shooting video with the camera? AppleCare unable to provide a solution.  Is there a way to do this....and/or an app for that?

    Welcome to Apple Support Communities
    You cannot use a MacBook Pro as an external display. To do this, you need that Target Display mode is included in the firmware, and this is only available on iMacs.
    However, you can still use your MacBook Pro as an external display for another Mac by using ScreenRecycler

  • Which traditional daq example will be best for thermocouple temp measurements?

    Hi,
    i have a PCI 4351 card connected to a TBX 68T connector block which is used to measure the temp using thermocouples. it uses an analogue input from the thermocouples, but the card is only compatible with traditional daq programming.
    i have looked at the example finder, and under the folder 'Hardware and software' click the sub folders 'traditional daq', then click 'analogue input' and finally click the 'general' sub folder and you will see a list of example vi's, if you have the traditional daq installed. but i do not know which will be of great benefit to my work. please help.
    does anyone know of a good example that i can use and relate to my work and devices? it would be of great help as i am new to daq.
    thanks!
    Notay

    Hi Notay!
    Sorry about that, thos sub Vi's are part of the analog in library of daq. Most likely you will only need the traditional daq driver and the correct configuration of your hardware. Im attaching the VI's, keep me updated of your results and if you need something else let me know.
    Best of luck!
    Oswald Branford
    Attachments:
    (Sub) 4350 Parse Settings.vi ‏16 KB
    (Sub) 4350 Remove offset and get CJC voltage.vi ‏24 KB

  • Macbook Pro will not shut down AND other issues...

    Macbook Pro will not shut down. Not using the POWER button, not using control/alt/command/esc, not using force quit, and obviously not by selecting Sleep or Shut down from the Apple menu.
    Force quit will not even pop up when selected.
    Top row keys do not work either, have gone into settings and switched them to F keys and back again, no luck.
    iPhoto will not import photos and will not shut down, gives me a message stating it is importing photos (nothing is connected to computer though). Baffling.
    HELP! Computer is only a month old
    Thank you everyone xx

    Please make a Genius Appointment and take it in for service.

  • My MacBook pro will not turn on after connecting to an external display

    I connected my MacBook pro to a projector for a presentation using a VGA adapter. It worked for a couple of minutes, then my computer shut off and I can not turn it back on. It has never given any trouble before then. Now when I try to turn it on, the white led comes on briefly, then it makes a tone and nothing happens, the screen stays dark, any idea what is wrong????

    Probably  option, command, P, and R to reset the pram. Article at link.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1379

  • My MacBook Pro will not start up - it was just on last night - what do I do?

    My MacBook Pro will not start up. I used it last night and it was fine.  What should I do?

    Try a SMC reset.
    http://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201295
    Do you get anywhere in the startup sequence?
    Ciao.

  • Which new MacBook Pro is best for a graphic design student?

    Hi there, I was just wondering if anyone could give me some advice on which new MacBook Pro to get. I'm a graphic design student who would like to be able to use Photoshop, InDesign, and Illustrator at the same time, while also web browsing (I tend to have a million windows open). I won't be using the computer for any video work or heavy gaming.
    Here's what I do know: I'd like the retina display, and I need the 8GB of memory (do I need more?). Other than that, I'm not too sure about what specifications I need. I'm not super knowledgeable about all of this, so apologies if these are very elementary questions. Any help would be much, much appreciated. Here are my main questions:
    1. Would you recommend getting the quad core i7, or is i5 fine? For i5, do I need to pay attention to the difference between 2.4GHz and 2.6GHz?
    2. What exactly is PCle-based flash storage, and would you recommend 256GB or 512GB?
    3. What's the difference between Intel Iris Pro and Intel Iris?
    Thanks so much!

    1) Depending on which software you'll be using most of the times a quad core has more benefits (since it's more future proof). Not all software supports multiple cores (and thus rendering the extra cores of the quad "useless" if it's not supported).
    2) PCI-e is what we use in desktops to attach for example a graphic card. Previous hard drives used a cable to connect it with the motherboard (in the old days we used IDE, now recent hardware uses SATA3). Basically because it's directly connected to your motherboard (there's more to it but to keep it simple) this will allow it to read and write faster from and to it. (Double the speeds of your regular SSD)
    3) I reckon (haven't checked into it) that the base core speeds are clocked higher on the Iris Pro and probably has more dedicated ram to it.
    What a graphical student wants would be most likely a quad core CPU with a dedicated graphics card. The extra is storage is nice if you reckon you'd need it. (I mostly work on cloud but keep my current projects on my drive because then I'd have faster access to it).

  • The MacBook Pro will not allow me to cut-and-paste to and from or to click-and-drag to the external drive. I can copy-and-paste, but then I must send the original to the trash, which doubles the time and effort. Is there any way to cut-and-paste?

    I have recently switched from a PC to a MacBook Pro.
    I have a large number of documents and photographs on a multiterrabite external drive, backed up on a second multiterrabite external drive.
    Both external drives are formatted for MacIntosh. This has been verified by agents at an Apple store and also at Best Buy in two different cities.
    This is the problem:
    The MacBook Pro will not allow me to cut-and-paste to and from or to click-and-drag to the external drive. I can copy-and-paste, but then I must send the original to the trash, which doubles the time and effort. Is there any way to cut-and-paste?
    Also, the MacBook Pro will not allow me to rename multiple documents or photographs. I can click-and-rename a single one, but this is impossibly time consuming. I can batch-rename in iPhoto, but when I transfer the photographs to the external drive, the rename does not transfer.
    I’m reduced to using my wife’s Toshiba to cut-and-past, rename, and transfer documents. It works perfectly. Is there any way to do this on the MacBook Pro?
    Thanks!
    Roderick Guerry
    [email protected]

    Roderick Guerry wrote:
    The MacBook Pro will not allow me to cut-and-paste to and from or to click-and-drag to the external drive. I can copy-and-paste, but then I must send the original to the trash, which doubles the time and effort. Is there any way to cut-and-paste?
    No, this is a philosophical difference between Apple and Microsoft. Apple believes that it's dangerous to cut a file in case the user never pastes it; in that case the file is lost. Microsoft seems to not have this problem (if I remember Windows correctly) because they don't delete the originating file if it's cut but never pasted.
    Even though Macs have a lot of keyboard shortcuts, philosophically Macs have traditionally been mouse-first. This applies to file copy operations. In your case, what a Mac user would do is open the source window, open the destination window (on your second drive), and then Command-drag the selected files from the source to destination window. This is because a normal drag would leave the originals behind, while adding the Command modifier key tells OS X that this is a Move, not a Copy, so don't leave the originals behind.
    (In addition there are different rules for drag-copying within the same volume or between different volumes. If you drag between two folders on the same volume, the files are moved. If you drag between different volumes, the files are copied unless you hold down Command to delete the copies on the source volume.)
    Roderick Guerry wrote:
    Also, the MacBook Pro will not allow me to rename multiple documents or photographs. I can click-and-rename a single one, but this is impossibly time consuming. I can batch-rename in iPhoto, but when I transfer the photographs to the external drive, the rename does not transfer.
    Two problems in this case. First, batch file renaming is not built into OS X unless you build something with Automator. However, there are many utilities that can do batch file renaming which you can find at macupdate.com or on the App Store. Since I work with media I often batch rename using one of the media managers I have lying around like Media Pro or Adobe Bridge (comes with Photoshop).
    iPhoto is a database front end designed to shield the file system from the consumer and let them concentrate on creativity and sharing. As such it is often a poor choice for managing files directly. When you "transferred the photographs" chances are you moved the originals, not the ones iPhoto edited which are stored in a hidden folder.
    Roderick Guerry wrote:
    I’m reduced to using my wife’s Toshiba to cut-and-past, rename, and transfer documents. It works perfectly. Is there any way to do this on the MacBook Pro?
    There will not be a way to do it exactly like Windows. As described above, there are ways to do it "the Mac way." If it is possible to remove judgment on which way is "better" you might find the Mac way to be acceptable, but of course sometimes we simply prefer what we're used to.

  • Which MacBook Pro suits me best?

    Hello,
    I am wundering which MacBook Pro suits me best? I am going to study computer science in Colone soon.
    So the MacBook will mainly be for university, but I also want to use it for:
    - Photoshop
    - Xcode
    - Surfing the internet
    - Virtual machine with Windows, Windows Server, and Linux
    So after all I hast two questions:
    1) Is 8 GB of RAM enough or shall I upgrade to 16 GB?
    2) Should I buy the Core i5 2.6 GHz of the Core i7 2.8 GHz model?
    That you for your help
    Se7enUltimatePro

    If you want to save some money don't bother with the Moshi or Belkin.  You're paying for the name like buying Monster cables, which are overpriced too.  Get the following adapter from monoprice.com.
    Mini DisplayPort | Thunderbolt® to HDMI® Adapter w/ Audio Support

  • Which Macbook Pro do you recommend for CS6?

    I need to purchase a new laptop because I recently got a copy of CS6 Design & Web Premium. My old Macbook won't run it so I was wondering which MacBook Pro model is best to run the program. I mainly use Illustrator and Photoshop to make fashion illustrations and technical sketches. All the feedback is appriciated. I need to buy a new laptop ASAP!

    I would recromend the macbook pro retina for adobe CS6, this computer should sufice for years to come. If however you have insufficient funds, another choice would be the above (Macbook Pro 15'). Like he said you should get 8GB Ram, so Go to crucial.com and you could get the same ram with lifetime warranty for 60 $ instead of apples 100 $

  • I bought my macbook pro at a best buy, am I still eligible for the $100 on free apps?

    I am a student and I bought my macbook pro at a best buy, am I still eligible for the $100 on free apps? If so, how would i get access to it?

    http://www.apple.com/promo/

  • The software i use to play video cause for multi display in which my Macbook pro has only a single display. Is theres a way to get a multi display added to to my computer

    The software i use to play dj music videos cause for multi disply in which my Macbook pro has a single display funtion. Is the ant way to get multi monitor display added to my computer

    If the monitor can be detected your Displays preferences should show it in its Arrangement panel.  You may have to play around with your Display panel to get the desired resolution.  And also may have to click detect displays and gather windows to see both sets of preferences on your main screen.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Cannot Connect to the Internet ?

    So I am a new iPad user very new 3 weeks It started this morning when I downloaded updates to some of my apps - I then sync'd it with my itunes on my windows vista pc...then i noticed that the iPad screen looked really heavily pixelated in some of th

  • CM755A HP Officejet Pro 8500A Not Connecting

    Bought my Officejet Pro 8500a in July, 2011.  Hooked it up via USB directly to my PC and it worked great for almost two years.  This past winter I started getting messages saying it was not connected.  I would power it off and back-on, remove and re-

  • Hi, my firefox wont load websites but other browsers like internet explorer , chrome can . This problem occurs when i use my company's router ?

    my company have two internet connection ; 1 is dsl connection , firefox working fine on it ; 2 is my company's own cisco 2911 cisco router with internet connection , firefox wont loading pages except just the homepage of google.com and that's it , an

  • Distorted video-format in presentation

    Hi! I'm making a presentation which consists of both photos and videos. The videos are cut in Premiere Elements and exported in DV-PAL format (16:9). When the videos are played in Elements or other media players they look allright, but when they are

  • RE: Workspace methods

    David, You can contact Forte Technical Support to get information on the undocumented and **unsupported** repository hooks available in Forte Releases 2 and 3. Chances are good that Forte will completely overhaul this interface in Release 4, so any c