Which harddrive is best??

Which one should I get?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136279
or
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822145160
I like the cheaper one obviously, but I've heard of WD giving errors and panic attacks with the sensor in my MacBook and sensor in the drive to cause issues with each other. Anyone have any suggestions on which one, or what other ones??
Thanks,
Lorne

We can't really tell you which drive is "best." You can find benchmarks and reviews at Bare Feats and Storage Review where you can do your own research and decision-making.

Similar Messages

  • Which is the best Analog to Digital Converter

    Hey everyone,
    Im new to this movie making digital world.  I have been using imovie for a while and looking to upgrade to FCP.  Before I spend the money, just a few questions hoping someone would know the answers.
    1:  Can I use idvd to burn my movies with FCP?
    2:  Im need an analog to digital converter, but not sure which one to get.  I have VHS, Hi8, mini DV, etc...     Which converter is best with mac, specifically with FCP? 
    3: Does FCP work well with an external harddrive?
    Thanks...

    1. Yes
    2. Canopus and DataVideo are popular but some camcorders have a built in A-D converter. Note that Mini-DV works without needing a converter. Just plug in your camera with FireWire.
    3. Yes

  • Which OS, Version, Best Setup on like-new 2008 MBP for non-HD archival DV?

    MacBook Pro 15"
    (Early 2008)
    2.4 GHz Core 2 Duo
    4GB RAM
    720GB 7200rpm Hard Drive (original 360GB 5400rpm drive also available)
    OS 10.6.8
    (6GB RAM possible but additional $100+ for 4GB module needed now for software upgrades)
        I first and last used Final Cut Pro 2-3 in film school on a Titanium PowerBook (500MHz!) during the OS9/X transition.  Next, was an Aluminum PowerBook (1.67Ghz) but because of life changes, I did little editing other than occasionally in iMovie.  Then as an early adopter of iPhone/Pad, I rarely used my AlPB other than for back up, writing, and occasional simple editing.
        Now I'm finally entering the early MacIntel age with a pristine "early 2008" MacBook Pro bought for $250 from an elderly original-owner couple who used it only at home for email and iPhoto.  Though at the end of its supported life, it's practically new with a known history of light graphics usage (no video or gaming rendering ever) delivered in the original box with original battery (only 46 cycles!), discs, manual, like-new charger, and no sign of wear.  The original internal wrapper was even saved and put back on the device!  Furthermore, because the wife was a photo enthusiast, the Apple Store swapped out her internal hard drive for a Western Digital 720GB 7200rpm drive and the husband just gave me the original 360GB drive!
        I want to do several things with this "new" device.  I've done a lot of research but the world has changed since FCP 3 and the G4 processor and I'm overwhelmed with all the possibilities.  I need guidance and have always appreciated the wisdom and generosity of the gurus here. I thank you all in advance!
    iCloud integration: I'd like it since I'm an iPhone/Pad user.  I could upgrade to Mountain Lion but Mavericks, under the best of conditions, is doable on my device and may give me improved CPU and battery performance.  I realize this is best left for the OSX forums.  HOWEVER...
    Final Cut Pro: I want to also return to editing in FCP an unfinished documentary using primarily archival film and video converted to non-HD DV.  This may greatly impact how I set up my drives and the decision as to which OS is best.  So, this should probably be my initial decision.
    Hard Drive:  First and foremost, I should probably swap the drives and place the 7200rpm drive into an enclosure (Firewire or is that stone-age?) for FCP media, correct?
    OS:  With Mavericks, I must use FCPX which is beyond my current non-HD needs and will most likely strain my system resources.  However, the new simplified interface is appealing and I've read some users are running it on "early 2008" MBPs.  If an earlier OS is better suited, then which one?  And also...
    FCP Version:  Which is most stable given my model?  And which is best for non-HD needs?  What about FCExpress?  I want to explore more possibilities than what's available in iMovie and would appreciate the simpler interface found in FCE and FCPX, especially since I haven't used any Final Cut since FCP 3 but will gladly embrace what's best.  I want to relearn the program and hope to continue using it for other projects.
    Partitioned drive:  Finally, what about partitioning my drive, one for daily life running Mavericks or other OS, the other solely dedicated to an optimized OS/FCP for non-HD editing?  Even at 360 GB it should be doable if I keep it lean and the bulk of storage externally (I ran FCP 3 adequately on a partitioned 40GB drive back in the day).  How much space should I dedicate to an FCP partition?
        Finances are tight and I'll need to upgrade Office, other apps (I know there's Rosetta in Snow Leopard but must weigh that with iCloud integration; decsions, decisions!) and probably locate an older copy of FCP on EBay or elsewhere which could be expensive.  I must wait a bit before swapping in a 4GB RAM module and possibly upgrading to an SSD.  Meanwhile, I'd like to experience this like-new MacBook Pro now, both as it was during its heyday and with what's still possible today.  It seems doable and I appreciate any and all suggestions.
    Thank you all and have a great day!
    Evalyn
    PS: I realize my FCP3 files are probably useless and plan to reimport everything into a new project.  And sorry for the lack of paragraph spacing.  Can't get it formatted right on the iPad!

    CyberFinch wrote:
    FCP Version:  Which is most stable given my model?  And which is best for non-HD needs?  What about FCExpress?  I want to explore more possibilities than what's available in iMovie and would appreciate the simpler interface found in FCE and FCPX, especially since I haven't used any Final Cut since FCP 3 but will gladly embrace what's best.  I want to relearn the program and hope to continue using it for other projects.
    Just to note that there is much more commonality between FCP3 and FCP7 and/or FCE than with the early version and FCP X. IMO, learning FCP X is worth the effort, but it will require some effort since it is so different than traditional NLE's. You could "get by" with FCE for many types of projects and you should be able to find a copy on eBay or Amazon  for a few hundred dollars. However, you will not be able to open a FCP project of any version with it.  Also, I don;t think I would agree that  its UI is simple; it's essentially the same as FCP.
    As for partitioning, some people advise against editing from drives that have been partitioned. I use a partition on one machine and I've not had any problems, so I think it is an option.
    As you can see from the replies you've received so far, you have  reasonable choices. Good luck.
    Russ

  • I have a external Hard drive of 1TB. I want to transfer HD movies to it from my MAC but it can only take 4 gb at a time, now i have to format it which is the best format in this situation NTFS or exFAT, as i use windows part ion as well??

    I have a external Hard drive of 1TB. I want to transfer HD movies to it from my MAC but it can only take 4 gb at a time, now i have to format it which is the best format in this situation NTFS or exFAT, as i use windows part ion as well?? plzz help
    Merry Christmas

    Repartition and format the drive for a Mac:
    Drive Preparation
    1. Open Disk Utility in your Utilities folder.
    2. After DU loads select your hard drive (this is the entry with the mfgr.'s ID and size) from the left side list. Click on the Partition tab in the DU main window.
    3. Under the Volume Scheme heading set the number of partitions from the drop down menu to one. Click on the Options button, set the partition scheme to GUID then click on the OK button. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Partition button and wait until the process has completed.
    4. Select the volume you just created (this is the sub-entry under the drive entry) from the left side list. Click on the Erase tab in the DU main window.
    5. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Security button, check the button for Zero Data and click on OK to return to the Erase window.
    6. Click on the Erase button. The format process can take up to several hours depending upon the drive size.

  • Which is the best software to convert dvd to IPad 2d

    Which is the best software to convert dvd to IPad 2d

    unfortunately discussing the breaking of the encryption that comes with commercial dvd's is prohibited in these forums. however a quick google search will get you to quite a few software providers....
    on a personal note, i don't agree with the fact that we can't "legally" transfer dvd's because breaking the encryption is considered illegal, even though the "fair use act" has said that copying dvd's for personal use or for backup purposed is considered legal. it's just the software to do that isn't. i'm not one who would rip a dvd then make multiple copies to make a financial gain. i just want to be able to convert my "old" media into a format that meets my current needs.
    good luck my friend on your search. i really wish i could help you more

  • Which is the best app to create cartoon images on that i can move around to other apps and animate to create cartoons

    which is the best app to create cartoon images on that I can move around to other apps and animate.  I want to create the image only, no background or anything

    Hi Susan,
    Kindly check out Flash pro CC
    For more details: Explore Adobe desktop apps | Adobe Creative Cloud
    Thanks,
    Atul Saini

  • How do I upload to Facebook in High Resolution using my iPhone. Do I need an app? Which ones are best for the job? (I know how to do it on a PC :) )

    How do I upload photos to Facebook in High Resolution using my iPhone. Do I need an app? Which ones are best for the job? (I know how to do it on a PC )

    100pat wrote:
    Thanks, I can do it fine from my Windows desktop PC, I just want to know how to do it from an iPhone4
    Like I said before ask facebook or look at their support site to see if that is even a feature.

  • Which Is The Best Free Video Converter Software?

    Which is the best FREE software for encrypting dvd's for Ipod and which is the best FREE software for converting encrypted dvd videos to my Ipod, or is there out a FREE software that can do both thing?
      Windows XP Pro  

    Try this software:
    Firefox or IE7.
    Go to these forums.
    Search these forums.
    This question is asked 1000 times a month. So try a search , honest it works. (Google has a few thousand answers as well).
    Note DVD's are already encrypted, so you will be looking to decrypt them, then convert to MP4 for iPod..

  • Which is the Best way to upload BP for 3+ million records??

    Hello Gurus,
                       we have 3+million records of data to be uploaded in to CRM coming from Informatica. which is the best way to upload the data in to CRM, which takes less time consumption and easy. Please help me.
    Thanks,
    Naresh.

    do with bapi BAPI_BUPA_FS_CREATE_FROM_DATA2

  • Avast, clamXAV and MacScan - which is the best of these OSX AV scanners?

    Avast, clamXAV and MacScan - which is the best of these OSX anti-virus scanners?
    Does anyone have experience of all three?

    Ermmm. I think you'll not find anyone here that's got experience of one, let alone all three.
    My thoughts on anti-virus for the Mac, is that it can be more hassle than it is worth, given the nature of OSX. Don't get me wrong, it's not like I think the OS is invulnerable, but other than the one lone mock video codec trojan that was out a few years ago, there really isn't much of a need for anti-virus.
    Yet.
    The best web security right now for general browsing is Firefox with NoScript and AdBlock Plus and have it set to delete the cache and cookies after each session.
    Beyond that, the commonest things vexing Mac OS right now, are 'social engineered' trojans or virii, that the user installs themselves.
    If you stick to legitimate download sites, (c-net, versiontracker) you will be fine.
    Deb.

  • I want to relocate my iTunes library on a NAS drive and stream to apple tv2 and DLNA tbs around the house is this possible and if so which is the best NAS drive to buy???

    I want to relocate my iTunes library on a NAS drive and stream to apple tv2 and DLNA tbs around the house is this possible and if so which is the best NAS drive to buy???

    ged2001 wrote:
    I want to relocate my iTunes library on a NAS drive and stream to apple tv2 and DLNA TV's around the house is this possible and if so which is the best NAS drive to buy???
    i don't have any experience with DLNA TV's but i recently moved my iTunes library to a NAS. streaming content to airport express remote speakers and TV2 works great. however, i have all my gear hardwired to my time capsule (except the airport express) so i'm not sure how well streaming e.g. HD movies to TV over wifi works.
    i have a Synology DiskStation 411j and am very happy with it.

  • Which browser is best for macbook pro?

    Which browser is best for macbook pro.
    I have used Safari for a couple of years but have been told recently that I would be better switching to Chrome

    The best browser for you depends on your specific needs; as you can install multiple browsers without them interfering with each other, download Firefox, Chrome, and any others you'd like to try out, and pick the one which works best for you.
    (82388)

  • I am considering buying a new MAC laptop to run LOGIC for composition and band live/recording, but which one is best as I do not want to spend too much money? Does it have a line in and how do you monitor sound? Will I need adaptors and a interface?

    Can anybody help?
    I am considering buying a new MAC laptop to run LOGIC for composition and band live/recording, but which one is best as I do not want to spend too much money?
    Does it have a line in and how do you monitor sound?
    Will I need adaptors and an interface?
    Also, I am guessing as Logic only runs on MAC surely then they would not the best spec to recommend to run it?
    I see all the upgrades as additional memory or a faster process?
    Is a retina screen necessary, and why flash based storage against a 1TB hard drive, and a i5 instead of an i7
    The main reason for this purchase is to play live and use backing tracks and record found sounds and make creative songs.
    I hope you can provide some valuable feedback, as I am a longtime MAC user and see upgrades and changes happen regularly but the most important thing is the songs not the equipment.
    I have £500 already and willing to add another 500 to 700 pounds, then software extra.

    Can anybody help?
    I am considering buying a new MAC laptop to run LOGIC for composition and band live/recording, but which one is best as I do not want to spend too much money?
    Does it have a line in and how do you monitor sound?
    Will I need adaptors and an interface?
    Also, I am guessing as Logic only runs on MAC surely then they would not the best spec to recommend to run it?
    I see all the upgrades as additional memory or a faster process?
    Is a retina screen necessary, and why flash based storage against a 1TB hard drive, and a i5 instead of an i7
    The main reason for this purchase is to play live and use backing tracks and record found sounds and make creative songs.
    I hope you can provide some valuable feedback, as I am a longtime MAC user and see upgrades and changes happen regularly but the most important thing is the songs not the equipment.
    I have £500 already and willing to add another 500 to 700 pounds, then software extra.

  • I want to play AVCHD videos in ipad from my JVC camcorder.which is the best tool for converting the avchd videos to formats that ipad can play?

    I have a JVC HD camcorder that creates videos in AVCHD format that ipad cannot play. Which is the best tool to convert these avchd videos to the format ipad can play?

    Airplay is a wireless streaming protocol. It allows content to be pushed from the iPad through the Apple TV onto your connected HDTV.
    If she wants to see the iPad displayed on the big screen and/or play games that involves mirroring. As long as it's an iPad 2 (or later) then you will be fine. More info on both has been referened below
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4437?viewlocale=en_US&locale=en_US
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht5209

  • In my scenario from r3 to CRM,IDOC for r3,which adapter is best for CRM

    from r3 to CRM which adapter is best for CRM for customer data

    Hi ,
    Some more info that might help you make a decision:
    CRM Middleware & XI
    Will SAP CRM Middleware be replaced by XI
    Regards
    Vijaya

Maybe you are looking for

  • Error on the r12 about workflow

    what error on this foe workflow noticfiction? System: Error Local Event ERROR : oracle.apps.fnd.system.exception / 4206714 thanks

  • My notes app keeps freezing when I try to delete a note

    My notes app keeps freezing every time i try to delete a note. Here is what I get: Process:         Notes [4034] Path:            /Applications/Notes.app/Contents/MacOS/Notes Identifier:      com.apple.Notes Version:         1.1 (99) Build Info:     

  • Chart options in BI

    Dear all, We have data in the report which runs monthwise for a year. Our requirement is if i have values for the months e.g APR,MAY,JUN etc., then I should get a chart as bar chart for APR,MAY and run chart for JUN - i.e., always the current month o

  • Running an ISo file on mac

    Please I'm in great need of help. I am a medical student and there a program that we are using for our anatomy class. but the file is saved as in ISO format. I'm pretty new to macs and i've been on countless forums trying to find out how to run the p

  • Error occur when installing iPlanet App server 6.0 SP2

    Dear All, I have problems in installing the iPlanet App server 6.0 SP2 in Solaris. I choose typical installation and select default settings. - install iplanet server - typical install - install ALL components However, the following errors occur duri