Which is better  option SAP XI vs webservices to interact with Biztalk

HI everyone,
We have biztalk as integration tool. I would like to know is it feasible to implement Biztalk with SAP XI to communicate with our SAP ECC server. I heard it will be over weight to use both Biztalk and SAP XI coz each will have its own message box and leads to more process time. So we are planning to use Biztalk with SAP webservices. So please let me know which is better as cost wise and work wise biztalk with SAP XI or Biztalk with SAP Web services.
SAP Guys please take some time to provide some useful information. it will be much appreciated.
cheers
ram

SAP XI and BizTalk both offer a tight integration of Web Services into the engine and development tools. Using the SAP XI SOAP Adapter enables the consumption and publication of Web Services based on the SOAP 1.1 protocol according to the WS-Basic Profile 1.0.
The BizTalk SOAP Adapter also offers Web Services support based on SOAP 1.1
support and Basic Profile 1.0 capabilities.
Anyway XI and Biztalk can interoperate, you should evaluate the scenario you are going to implement.
Based on transactionality, trhroughtput, communication etc, the following scenarios are in focus:
Synchronous and non-transactional communication
Synchronous and transactional communication
Asynchronous and non-transactional communication
Asynchronous and transactional communication
This leads to eight scenarios overall, as both hubs may act as the initiating starting point of the communication. The choice of communication types for a certain integration process depends on business needs, technical needs and performance considerations.
if it may be useful rewards point are appreciated

Similar Messages

  • Advantage of using SAP XI over webservices to interact with Biztalk

    HI everyone,
    We have biztalk as integration tool. I would like to know is it feasible to implement Biztalk with SAP XI to communicate with our SAP ECC server. I heard it will be over weight to use both Biztalk and SAP XI coz each will have its own message box and leads to more process time. So we are planning to use Biztalk with SAP webservices. So please let me know which is better as cost wise and work wise biztalk with SAP XI or Biztalk with SAP Web services.
    SAP Guys please take some time to provide some useful information. it will be much appreciated.
    cheers
    ram

    Ram,
    This is a contentious issue.
    In principle a middleware to middleware integration is against the basic ideas of EAI. We need to integrate applications and not middlewares, but in reality this is in most cases an inevitable situation.
    This blog discusses a similar middleware- middleware integartion ( XI and WebMethods) . Use the tips and tricks in this blogs to understand the issue you need to address , etc,
    /people/abhy.thomas/blog/2007/04/19/sap-xi--webmethods-integration-150-challenges-and-migration-strategies
    Regards
    Bhavesh

  • Which is better mac book pro or Mac book pro with retina display?

    which is better mac book pro or Mac book pro with retina display?

    MacBook Pro
    https://discussions.apple.com/community/notebooks/macbook_pro
    https://discussions.apple.com/community/mac_os?view=discussions 
    http://www.apple.com/support/macbookpro
    If or when upgraded to the max, the Retina is a good value.
    But talk to other users on the notebook forum.

  • Which is better approach to manage sharepoint online - PowerShell Script with CSOM or Console Application with CSOM?

    Which is better approach to manage sharepoint online - PowerShell Script with CSOM or Console Application with CSOM?
    change in sharepoint scripts not require compilation but anything else?

    Yes, PowerShell is great, since you can quick change your code without compilation.
    SP admin can write ps scripts without specific tools like Visual Studio.
    With powershell you can use cmdlets,
    which could remove a lot of code, for example restarting a service.
    [custom.development]

  • WHICH IS BETTER OPTION IN THE U.S. MARKET SAP CRM or SAP SD

    HI I WISH TO DO A COURSE IN SAP I HAVE TO DECIDE BETWEEN 2 OPTIONS SHOULD I DO SAP SD or SAP CRM WHICH ONE IS A BETTER OPTION AS I AM AN M.B.A. IN MARKETING WITH NO I.T. OR TECH KNOWLEDGE AT ALL. SO WHAT CAN YOU RECCOMEND PLEASE REPLY IT WOULD BE APPRECIATED
    THANKS

    Hello Monty,
    I m located in Mumbai, India.
    Surely I would have helped in India.
    As  far as NY or NJ is concerned I don't know much.
    Here in India we have SIEMENS or GENOVATE which provide SAP Cerification.
    Search for some authorized training acadamey of SAP there, search on net........
    Definitely U will succeed.
    Reward me points, if this helps.
    Anubhav
    [email protected]

  • Which is better option to trigger data to XI

    Hi Experts,
    Happy new Year to all of you.
    here I have one query, How we decide at the ERP side, whether we have to use IDOC, RFC and Proxy to trigger the Datafor the XI Interface. I know for the XI Performabce wise proxy is better option.
    Please give more inputs of yours on this.
    Many Thanks.

    >
    > here I have one query, How we decide at the ERP side, whether we have to use IDOC, RFC and Proxy to trigger the Datafor the XI Interface. I know for the XI Performabce wise proxy is better option.
    >
    Suppose if you develope scenario between IDoc->PI> in this case you need to import IDoc from SAP System in to PI,when you triegegr IDoc in ERP/ECC the day will reacches PI System.
    If you develop RFC>PI-> IN THIS CASE THE PROCEDURE ALSO SAME,like import RFC in to PI,trigger RFC in ERP system...
    When you go for Prosy,you need to specify the logic in ABAP Proxy class which program,and interface going to use.
    we can say Proxy performce better,but it depends on volume of Data.
    Regards,
    Raj

  • Which is better API Frame work or WebServices

    Dear All,
    We are planning to make a design for Open architecture to communicate four of our products which are previously designed independently. So we need to establish an interaction between one product with the other project up on their requirements. Which is the better option we can proceed from API Design or Making each of the product as web service or any other thing.
    Please reply to me ASAP.
    Thanks&Regards
    Mahesh Yamsani

    To be fair if you download an applet all the class files are stored in your .jpi_cache, and depending on how that game requests its graphics sometimes they are stored there to, so really if you have to download an applet game twice, blame the programmer (I've probably got that dead wrong :B ).
    But, what's wrong with Jars. They offer so much more.
    No offence meant by this Malohkan but if you can't organize your downloaded files the internet must really be a landmine for you :)
    Personally I'd be happy if I never seen another applet again, it seems java is tied to this legacy, and to the average computer user it seems that is all java is capable of.
    Admitidly there are some very funky applets out here using lots of way over my head funky pixel tricks, but they would look so much better running full screen and offline.

  • Which is better, many PXI cards or fewer PXI cards with more SCXI cards?

    I have a pretty basic question.  Which is "better", using multiple PXI cards for analog inputs or a single PXI card and multiple SCXI cards?  For example, if I have say 100 channels to sample (all at the same rate), I could use 2 6225s at 80 ch each.  Or I could use 1 6220 and 4 SCXI 1100s (32 ch each).  What are the pros and cons with either approach?  Keep in mind sample rate probably isn't an issue (less than 1 kHz) but it is the same for all channels.
    Thanks.

    The pros/cons will depend on your application now and in the future.  I recommend contacting your local NI sales representative.  Synchronizing across a PXI system is easy to do via the backplane.  There are PXI/SCXI combo chassis available, you could use PXI multifunction DAQ cards and then SCC for signal conditioning for thermocouples for additional functionality later.  There are many possibilities that may be best discussed with your sales representative.
    Regards,
    h_baker
    National Instruments
    Applications Engineer
    Digital Multimeter Resources

  • I have a G5 which I intend to keep.  Now that I have updated my iphone 4s to iOS 7.0.  I cannot add music to my iphone or upload photos to iphoto.  I have the last itunes 10.6.3. which was supported by apple.  itunes will not interact with my iphone on an

    I have a G5 which I intend to keep.
    Now that I have updated my iphone 4s to iOS 7.0.
    I cannot add music to my iphone or upload photos to iphoto.
    I have the last itunes 10.6.3. which was supported by apple.
    itunes will not interact with my iphone on any level.
    Apple made all the equipment I use.
    Bentley and Ferrari etc do not stop making parts for their cars?
    The least Apple could is.
    A. Update itunes to run on a G5
    Regarding iOS 7.0 you have totally lost the plot.
    We buy apple why?
    Quality.
    Intuitive interface.
    Stable software.
    Design.
    All that Steve Jobs consider sacrosanct.
    Quality is about ongoing support longevity of product.
    Its not about trying to sell to every person on the planet, others are way ahead of you.
    So try respective the customers you have, it wont be long before theirs a better operating system and your lead in hardware is marginal. 
    Regards
    Glyn Evans
    My post on facebook this morning.
    If you have an iPhone or iPad do not update to ISO 7 unless you want an operating system that looks like windows 8. The graphics looks like it was designed by a artistically challenged mongoose and the operating system is not intuitive something apple users expect. Overly complicated ugly and generally change for the sake of apples paranoia since the death of Steve Jobs.

    You need to update iTunes to 11.1 on your PC

  • Which is better for User Managed Hot backup - running in cron or oracle scheduler

    We are taking hot backup in our environment by using sql script of just begin backup, host copy and end backup
    Can we use this script to be put in cron for weekly two times or to use oracle scheduler .
    Which is better option and why?

    The answer to your question depens on your condition. Do you have more experienced Unix admin or DBA?
    From my point of view cron is better becuase all you need is SQL*Plus utility and shell script:
    export ORACLE_SID=...
    sqlplus <username>/<password> as sysdba <<EOF
    ALTER TABLESPACE .. BEGIN BACKUP;
    host copy ..
    ALTER TABLESPACE .. END BACKUP;
    EXIT
    EOF

  • Which is better? Resize datafile or add datafile in same diskgroup.

    Hi All,
    Can you explain which is better option between adding a datafile or resizing one in a diskgroup with 20 disks?
    Regards,
    Avi

    hello buddy,
    Since you know that a small file datafile has a limitation of 32gb then if your tablespace is out of this space then the solution is add more dfiles, also, in my point of view less datafiles in a hughe database is better for evite ckpt contention. The answer is dependo always for your situation!!!
    I hope it helps
    best regards,
    Rodrigo Mufalani
    www.mufalani.com.br

  • Which middleware to use SAP Netweaver XI  or Oracle Fusion

    Hello All,
    I have to integrate several modules like CRM, Siebel, Telephony  Supply Change Management, etc.  --- ERP Integration
    Which is better middleware SAP XI or Oracle Fusion.
    Any suggestions,  links/pdfs
    Regards

    Hi Rick,
    starting with point no.2:
    When we are talking about XI and true EAI system the interfacing is done with the application instance and not with the Database instance....so...there is no importance for XI whether your application "seats" on Oracle,DB2,SQL or commodore-64 as long as the application has an API and protocol that XI can speak with,
    That is : SOAP over HTTP, File system over FS\FTP,RFC\IDocs for SAP based system and so on...
    To make it more clear for you - With SAP XI we <b><u>Don't</u></b> do database synchronization! we send Orders,Invoices, or any business document\information between two or more systems.
    XI job is to do 2 things:
    1.change between protocols of the two systems for example Mail to IDoc
    2.change between messages structures (same example) Mail invoice to inbound INVOICE IDoc to the R3 SAP system.
    I'm sure sieble has some APIs that can work with XI swiftly.
    If you want to synchronize master data between you systems ..this issue has to be addressed more carefully taking into account the size of the messages send,the occurrence and a few more issues.
    Regarding point No.1 well from my knowledge - the equivalent  to Oracel fusion is more the NetWaver 2004s then the mySAP ERP which will be more equivalent to Oracle application.
    <b><i>If this post was helpfull please reward</i></b>
    <i>If you need more information please contact me at:
    [email protected]</i>
    Nimrod Gisis

  • Which is better or 'standard' option for a Delta DTP request

    Hi folks,
                I am creating a delta DTP for loading HR Payroll data. While creating the DTP I see two options
    a) Only Get Delta once
    b) Get all new data request by request
    which is a better option if I have a lot of records to upload for every delta upload.
    Points waiting to be given to you...
    Thanks
    Sunil

    U should go with Get all new data request by request
    i. With Only Get Delta Once, define if the source requests should be transferred only once.
    Setting this flag ensures that the content of the InfoProvider is an exact representation of the source data.
    A scenario of this type may be required if you always want an InfoProvider to contain the most recent data for a query, but technical reasons prevent the DataSource on which it is based from delivering a delta (new, changed or deleted data records). For this type of DataSource, the current data set for the required selection can only be transferred using a full update.
    In this case, a DataStore object cannot normally be used to determine the missing delta information (overwrite and create delta). If this is not logically possible because, for example, data is deleted in the source without delivering reverse records, you can set this flag and perform a snapshot scenario. Only the most recent request for this DataSource is retained in the InfoProvider. Earlier requests for the DataSource are deleted from the (target) InfoProvider before a new one is requested (this is done by a process in a process chain, for example). They are not transferred again by the DTP delta process. When the system determines the delta when a new DTP request is generated, these earlier (source) requests are considered to have been retrieved
    ii. Define if you want to Get All New Data in Source Request by Request.
    Since a DTP bundles all transfer-relevant requests from the source, it sometimes generates large requests. If you do not want to use a single DTP request to transfer the dataset from the source because the dataset is too large, you can set the Get All New Data in Source Request by Request flag. This specifies that you want the DTP to read only one request from the source at a time. Once processing is completed, the DTP request checks for further new requests in the source. If it finds any, it automatically creates an additional DTP request.
    u201COnly get Delta Onceu201D
    /people/community.user/blog/2007/06/21/sap-netweaver-70-bi-data-transfer-process-with-147only-get-delta-once148
    u201CGet Data by Requestu201D
    /people/community.user/blog/2007/06/21/sap-netweaver-70-bi-data-transfer-process-with-147get-data-by-request148

  • Can anybody help me SAP MDM or SAP XI is better option for an ABAPer

    Hi All,
        I have 5 years of exp in SAP ABAP.I want to learn new techonology.I am planning for SAP MDM or SAP XI.
    Can anybody guide me which one is better for me like for a ABAPer which one is a better option and why.

    hi,
    if you have the chance of working with MDM,better to go MDM
    other wise XI for ABAPer

  • SP2013 - What better to use for custom webservice creation, which will be save filled in Infopath form to sharepoint library

    Client use SharePoint 2013. I have to develop a custom webservice for this SharePoint. Webservice will receive some information as request, will fill in a InfoPath form (on based existing infopath template from library) with this information and save result
    to SharePoint library.
    Could advice how it right  organize? What is better to use for custom webservice in SharePoint 2013 (REST api or something else), how better fill in and save infopath form to library? 
    thanks

    Hi,
    In SharePoint 2013, you can still reference the way what it used to be in SharePoint 2010 or previous version.
    The two demos would also work in SharePoint 2013:
    http://blogs.msdn.com/b/jannemattila/archive/2007/01/21/infopath-and-web-service-data-connection.aspx
    http://wmostafaw.wordpress.com/2012/08/07/calling-web-service-from-infopath-2010-with-parameters/
    If the customer just want an interactive form for easy input, there are also other options in SharePoint 2013 like:
    Customization on the default form pages of a list using JavaScript Client Object Model;
    Create a SharePoint App which will enable you implement more complex requirements with Client Object Model and REST API, you can even upload it to the App store to share it with
    other people.
    Thanks
    Patrick Liang
    Forum Support
    Please remember to mark the replies as answers if they
    help and unmark them if they provide no help. If you have feedback for TechNet
    Subscriber Support, contact [email protected]
    Patrick Liang
    TechNet Community Support

Maybe you are looking for