Which is better Struts or JSF?

I've been investigating the use of JSF for use in upcoming projects. Up until now I've been using struts as it's a very straight forward approach to implement.
Looking at JSF however it apperars that the process is somewhat slightly different such that you can't run certain JSP's related to a faces-config outside the faces context.
Anyone know of some article comparing Struts vs JSF?
Anthony

Loks like i found what I was after:
[url http://www.jsfcentral.com]JSF Central
Anthony

Similar Messages

Can Struts and JSF coexist?

I have a Struts based application and now I want to build an additional module on top of that using pure JSF. My question is, can Struts and JSF co-exist in the same application? If yes, what are the cons of that approach? What are the places I need to tweak in the configuration files so that they work together?
thanks,

Hi,
Yes they can coexist. Actually that's the approach recommended by Craig McClanahan. I have developed a full enterprise application (80% completed) which uses JSF in front and Struts in the back using Struts-Faces integration library (developed by Apache).
So far I haven't faced any major issues with this approach. However, I haven't try using Struts validator on JSF objects.
Read the article below on how to integrate JSF w/ Struts.
http://www.oracle.com/technology/pub/articles/masterj2ee/j2ee_wk8.html

Struts-faces & JSF commandLink bug in RI 1.1

Hello,
There was a bug with JSF, multiple forms and commandLink as discussed in thread: http://forum.java.sun.com/thread.jsp?thread=526788&forum=427.
This bug is now fixed for JSF h:form form type.
I personnally use Struts and JSF with the struts-faces JAR and this issue is still not fixed when you create a form using the s:form tag, in fact as long as there is a s:form on the page the commandLinks do not work the same way as first reported for pure JSF apps.
Will this be fixed anytime soon in the struts-faces library? I hope so because I do need it.
Thanks
Xav

hi,
i guess [email protected]
or
http://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/enter_bug.cgi?product=Struts
might be a better place for that.
regards.

Struts and JSF

I have an Action from Struts. This controls the data in the code behind bean.
After I call submit, how do I go Back to the Struts actions? the JSF navagation does not allow navigating to a servlet.

Hey Shay,
We have quite a large application based entirely on Struts. There is a keen interest in migrating to JSF, but in an incremental fashion. I did a fair amount of googling and almost everything i came up with , was purely theory oriented, are there any resources online , which clearly give examples/tutorials for doing a step by step migration to JSF from Struts. Couple of other questions that i dont seem to find an answer to with regards to the Integration of struts and JSF
1) I understand BC4J, struts and JSF can be integrated together, does the same hold for ADF ? there was a similar forum post back in 2005 , where they said this is yet to be done, do we have this integration with Jdev 10.1.3 ?
2) If i were to use only the jsf UI component tags as a first step in my struts application , what is the equivalent for the page definition file of JSF in struts, as in how would i achieve the binding ?

Any tutorials/demos available for using BPEL alongwith Struts or JSF

Hi All
Are there any sample tutorials/demos available for using BPEL alongwith Struts or JSF ?
Thanks
Badri

Not sure if this is of any help, it uses ADF which is basically a JSF page.
http://www.oracle.com/technology/products/jdev/viewlets/1013/bpelfromadf_viewlet_swf.html
there is also some tutorials you may be able to use in the following directory
SOA_HOME/bpel/sampels/Tutorials/102.InvokingProcesses
cheers
James

For a new web application project - Struts OR JSF ?

Hi ,
We are starting a new web application project and want to decide whetehr to us Struts or JSF ?
Currently, mots of the other development teams are using Struts .
We need to know pros and cons of each to decide one way or the other.
Any help is appreciated .
Thanks

Those are the articles and presentation about this topic:
http://homepage1.nifty.com/algafield/barcia.html
http://www.jroller.com/comments/dgeary/Weblog/top_ten_reasons_to_prefer
http://websphere.sys-con.com/read/46516.htm
http://www.pjug.org/JavaServerFaces.pdf
Sergey : http://jsfTutorials.net

Which is better to use: BEx query or Web Application as an iView in portal?

Hi gurus!
Are there any experienced opinions, which is better - publish a BEx query in portal or publish a BEx Web Application in portal? Is it easier to alter the layout attributes etc. if I create a BEx Web Application first before publishing?
What is the way of fixing for example filter item height if I publish BEx query in portal - is there a Web Application that it uses anyhow which I can fix? Or can I use in that case iView -properties in portal?
Thankful for advice
Sari

ok, means i can use jsp:useBean tag for all my
classes that are not actually bean. so it will be
instantiated at run time and provide efficiency .No. Jsp:useBean is used for java bean components.
>
but when should i use import statement in my jsp and
it happen at translation time so will it create any
type of burden for my code if i import multiple
classes.For non-java beans, you need to import the classes, period.
It's not a burden, it's a necessity.

Which is better for performance Azure SQL Database or SQL Server in Azure VM?

Hi,
We are building an ASP.NET app that will be running on Microsoft Cloud which I think is the new name for Windows Azure. We're expecting this app to have many simultaneous users and want to make sure that we provide excellent performance to end users.
Here are our main concerns/desires:
Performance is paramount. Fast response times are very very important
We want to have as little to do with platform maintenance as possible e.g. managing OS or SQL Server updates, etc.
We are trying to use "out-of-the-box" standard features.
With that said, which option would give us the best possible database performance: a SQL Server instance running in a VM on Azure or SQL Server Database as a fully managed service?
Thanks, Sam

hello,
SQL Database using shared resources on the Microsft data centre. Microsoft balance the resource usage of SQL Database so that no one application continuously dominates any resource.You can try the
Premium Preview
for Windows Azure SQL Database which offers better performance by guaranteeing a fixed amount of dedicated resources for a database.
If you using SQL Server instance running in a VM, you control the operating system and database configuration. And the
performance of the database depends on many factors such as the size of a virtual machine, and the configuration of the data disks.
Reference:
Choosing between SQL Server in Windows Azure VM & Windows Azure SQL Database
Regards,
Fanny Liu
If you have any feedback on our support, please click here.
Fanny Liu
TechNet Community Support

Which is better??????

which is better?Dam really confused which speaker to buy??
i currently have a creative m2600.but am not getting enough performance or that feel while watching movies like avatar,step up 3 etc......so am planning to buy a 5.1.......not planning but i have decided to buy a 5.1....so..
which is better? the 6160 or 6060 or 6100.
which of these will provide me relly great exprience while playing games and most importantly while whatching hd movies and while listening to music.......
and other than this what i have to ask is...what is this "db" in speakers. i mean while looking at a speaker specs we can see it..like 65db,85db,75db..etc........
and when i compared specs of the three speakers i mentioned above i saw that the 6160 has low "db"........why is that?

The specs is just a guide, you won't be able to tell the slight difference in db using just your ears. Besides, it is just a comparison between the level of a music to the level of background noise, it does not necessary mean which speaker sounds better. If possible, please make a trip to your local electronics store and try out the speakers system yourself.

Which is better, Photoshop or Corel?

Which is better, Photoshop or Corel? I am finding the best one to use for my website [link removed]. Let me know your opinion. Tks all.

Thank you! I am trying to find the best one for the site [Link removed].
I used to use Corel before, but now, I am trying to use Photoshop.
Tk you anyway
[Removed link]
Message was edited by: sinious

Which is better software for brochures and PDF forms ? Photoshop or InDesign ?

Which is better software for brochures and PDF forms ? Photoshop or InDesign ? and why ?

If you are going to be making a lot of brochures, with photos, you probably want both. Photoshop to edit the photos, and InDesign to assemble and layout images with text.

Which is better an android or apple

Which is better getting an android smart phone or an Apple I Phone?

As the poster Horses 547 said its a matter of personal preference. However I own and use both. Printing via air print is smooth and easy on an iphone. Printing on a android phone is iffy and tedious and you will have to find an app to print since there is no native app to do so. I purchased http://www.printhand.com which costs around $12 from the app store. but it is in my opinion the best printing app out there for android. I use it on my android tablet as well and its great. This company is the maker of the print app on iphones.
The iphone is a little harder to put your own ringtone on the device. However very easy from the Itunes you put on your computer and hook into.
Another thing an iphone does is if you use their cloud service or pay for a song it is available on all your ios devices. Iphone, ipad, or ipod or up to five computers registered through itunes on those computers.
Google play music also can sync with all your android devices.
Iphone don't have external Micro SD card slots, so the storage on the phone is all you have.
Iphones use imessage which does not count against your text allotment to another iphone or ipad user. it send regular text to non iphone users.
Another thing is Face Time but I found a better program called oovoo at http://www.oovoo.com or in the Google Play Store for free.
Iphones are paper thin but I have an android that has a larger view area and is also paper thin and light. Depending on the android phone it may have a removable battery, whereas iphones are sealed as are some new androids. I have found the sound for music better on my iphone, and videos are crystal clear. Again on some better androids the music and video is comparable .
There is really not many differences but it up to the user.
One last good thing is iphones are updated via Apple, no long waits for OS updates like is done with Android devices, and android devices on Verizon.

Which is better for doing animation? Flash 4, 5, MX, CS, or others?

Which is better for doing animation? Flash 4, 5, MX, CS, or
others?
I am used to using brush function more conveniently in Flash
4 than the other versions I ve tried. However, Flash 4 doesn't have
pen tool.
Free News Reader
http://put.hk
http://put.hk/reader/forums.macromedia.com/macromedia.flash.html

1Evan2Wing3 wrote:
> Which is better for doing animation? Flash 4, 5, MX, CS,
or others?
>
> I am used to using brush function more conveniently in
Flash 4 than the other versions I ve tried. However, Flash 4
doesn't have pen tool.
all pretty identical tho I would go with cs, just because I
like the GUI much
more than other versions...
Best Regards
Urami
"Never play Leap-Frog with a Unicorn."
<urami>
If you want to mail me - DO NOT LAUGH AT MY ADDRESS
</urami>

Which is better for bulk message scenario in sap xi RFC or Proxy

which is better for bulk message scenario in ( RFC or Proxy ) ?
Edited by: prabhatxi on Aug 6, 2010 4:44 PM

Proxy will alwaays be better option in this case, as it is adapter less framework, and communication happens directly with XI central integration engine. So it is always fast communication and gives good performance.
But still you should consider other factors, you may consider using RFC as well, as sometime we go for RFC/IDOC as this are the standard interfaces already available rather than creating structure...
May be you can share more info on what type/volume data are you planning to send via XI?
Hope this cleart your doubt..
Divyesh

Which is better - Add a dimension or create more members in an existing

Which is better - Add a dimension or create more members in an existing dimension?
We are trying to figure out which can give us better performance in terms of calculations and retrieving reports - to add another dimension (entity/country) or add about 500-800 more members in an existing location/division dimension?
Thank you!

If you have BSO cube i would recommend to add in the same dimension where as ASO you can add members in a new dimension. Adding a new dimension is like creating a new cube you have to change each and every single calc scripts,report scripts,FR reports,Webforms and your rule files .... all the dependencies has to be changed manually . I think 500 members in the exsting BSO dimension will not impact the calc or retrieval times that much .

Which is better Struts or JSF?

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for