Which Mac should we buy?

Hi,
We are in the market for a new Mac and don't live near an Apple store. Trying to decide between a new Mac Mini or iMac.
Here is the main use,
Short videos in High Definition. We record using a Sony HDR-FX7 in 1080i and edit down to about 1 minute to 1 minute 20 seconds. This short video is then sent to iDVD and burned, as well we then transcode to mp4 and flash for web.
We have been using iMovie 6 HD on a dual G4 and while it wasn't the fastest in the world, because the videos are relatively small, it works, mostly. I say mostly because the system crashes often, iMovie 6 crashes often etc.
Time for a new system! iMovie 9 isn't really what we are after so we have decided to go for FCE 4. Now we just have to decide on the new hardware.
The new Mac Mini is intriguing, but is it really powerful enough to handle FCE4? I would think it is because apparently we can run FCE 4 on our G4... Should we look at an iMac? We already have two very nice monitors and external firewire drives. Would the entry level iMac be a better solution?
Anyone out there have any experiences they would like to share with either the mini or iMac and FCE4?
Cheers!
Chris

Hello, and welcome to the Apple Discussion forums!
Regarding the Mac mini vs. iMac if you intend to use FCE, there's hardly any question in my mind ... go with an iMac!
• The integrated video processor in the Mac mini is not ideal for FCE.
• If you configure a Mac mini as closely as possible to a basic iMac (4GB RAM, 2.6GHz processor, 500GB hard drive, keyboard & mouse), they are +within $52 of each other+ ... and you +still need a display!+
• The iMac has features no mini can match in any configuration - 3.06GHz i3 processor, discrete ATI Radeo 4670 video processor, LED display
• The iMac is more powerful and will yield better performance over a longer life than a mini will.
Or you might consider a refurbed 21" Core i3 iMac ... which you can purchase for +even less+ than an upgraded Mac mini! I have a number of refurbed Macs and they are all flawless.

Similar Messages

  • Which Mac Should I buy??

    Hi there,
    I am currently debating which mac to buy :/   I currently have a macbook pro retina 2013 and I love itttttt
    This are the mac
    1- MacPro Refourbished 2012 for 2145.00
    2- iMac (new) 27" i7, Fusion Drive and 2GB Nvidia 680MX
    The reason why I am not sure which one to get is because I am afraid that in a future I wont be able to upgrade the iMac but at the same time the MacPro 2012 is pretty old, it doesnt even has USB 3.0.
    If I get the MacPro I will end up spending more money because I gonna need a display which cost 1000
    So guys what do you think?????
    Oh also the other reason I am thinking on getting the MacPro is because with the MBPR if I use bootcamp OMG  it really get HOTTTTT and I know that at least the mac pro has better cooling compare to the iMac...
    Any Adviseee plssss

    if you need it now... imac otherwise sit on fence for now.

  • I want to buy a mac and i am confused between macbook air 13 inch and i mac. which one should i buy

    actually i am new to mac so i am confused between macbook air 13 inch and i mac. which one should i buy? i will be installing windows 2 on it..

    An MBA is a portable while an iMac is a desktop and is not portable. You could install Windows on either provided each had sufficient memory installed and a large enough hard drive. The iMac is better equipped for this from the outset, but the MBA can be adequately configured if you are willing to spend the money to do so.

  • I have a macbook 2006 its hard drive was not working anymore so i install a new 500GB hard drive but now i just need the software. Which one should i buy?

    I have a macbook 2006 its hard drive was not working anymore so i install a new 500GB hard drive but now i just need the software. Which one should i buy?

    Snow Leopard 10.6 Technical Requirements - http://support.apple.com/kb/SP575
    You can buy Snow Leopard at:
    Snow Leopard disc source - http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC573Z/A/mac-os-x-106-snow-leopard
    You could contact Apple Support and see if they have the original discs for that machine but it would be 10.4.11 and there's no reason not to go to at least Snow Leopard, especially since the 10.6 discs would probably cost the same as a replacement set of 10.4.11

  • I am a photographer looking to purchase a new iMac.  Which one should I buy and what should I include in the package?, I am a photographer looking to purchase a new iMac.  Which one should I buy and what should I include in the package?

    I am a photographer looking to purchase a new iMac.  Which one should I buy and what should I include in the package?, I am a photographer looking to purchase a new iMac.  Which one should I buy and what should I include in the package?

    In general most macs you buy are the same. If you will be doing quite a lot of editing of photos and videos, then the big things to look for are:
    Processor - 2.8ish GHz Intel i7 4-core - is about the best I have head of thus far.
    RAM - fairly easy to upgrade yourself, but 16GB is typically more than you will need for the next 5 years at least.
    iLife is reasonably good software for editing media, but as a photographer, you may have your own prefered software
    The good thing about Apple is that they don't sell ****** computers in general. They offer little in the way of customization of hardware which is both their strength and weakness.

  • I'm 51 years old and recently retired. I have a new IPad Air. Which MacBook should I buy to go with it?  I don't understand flash storage.  It feels like I would have a bunch of flash drives to keep up with.  Help an old lady out!!!

    I'm 51 years old and recently retired. I have a new IPad Air. Which MacBook should I buy to go with it?  I don't understand flash storage.  It feels like I would have a bunch of flash drives to keep up with.  Help an old lady out!!!

    Depends on how you want to use it. Flash storage on the newer macbook and macbook air are built in. A macbook air is the most light weight and a very good machine. It will do all you want it to do unless you are running some very intensive programs. If you go to the apple store on line you can compare  the different macbook pro" and macbook Air's.

  • Which PC should I buy?

    Hello~
    I want to buy a desktop PC or an All-in-one PC recently, but I don't know which one should I buy?
    I have a monitor and keyboard+mouse, maybe Nightblade B85 or Z97 is suitable for me, but is it have wireless network? 
    According to that, I consider maybe All-in-one PC is more convenient, but I love to play World Warcraft and Diablo III, is it can support to play these games? 

    Quote
    maybe Nightblade B85 or Z97 is suitable for me, but is it have wireless network? 
    both has WiFi:
    http://www.msi.com/product/desktop/Nightblade-B85.html#hero-overview
    http://www.msi.com/product/desktop/Nightblade-Z97.html#hero-overview
    Z97 is the better option if the extra $$ is not issue for you.
    Else:
    You can get an MSI's Gaming AIO depend of your taste:
    http://www.msi.com/product/aio#?category=Gaming%20Series
    It has superior display, outstanding 3D performance, excellent Yamaha Speakers,
    high quality military certified components and many more
     

  • Which cable should I buy in order to plug my Iphone 3GS to a projector?

    Which cable should I buy in order to plug my Iphone 3GS to a projector?

    This is the apple supported vga/projector cord. Not sure about off brand or 3rd party cords tho... Hope this helps. Good Luck!
    http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC552ZM/B

  • I want to buy an ipad for someone that lives in Brazil. Which carrier should i buy so that it will work with the carriers in Brazil?

    I want to buy an ipad for someone that lives in Brazil. Which carrier should i buy so that it will work with the carriers in Brazil?

    Look, any officially unlocked GSM iPhone will work in India. You purchase from Dubai, no FaceTime, and Dubai is part of the UAE. You purchase anywhere but India, and you will have NO warranty or support. Frankly, doesn't make any sense to me why you want to do this...and don't bother telling me you save hundreds of dollars...still doesn't make any sense. Do a forum search here. We get posts daily, from users in India, who didn't purchase their iPhones in India...guess what? They all have problems. You want to join that bunch? It's your money, have at it.

  • HELP WHICH PHONE SHOULD I BUY

    I'M TORN BETWEEN THE IPHONE4 OR SAMSUNG GALAXY S3? HELP WHICH ONE SHOULD I BUY AND WHY.....THANKS GUYS

    I would think that experience level and comfortableness with phones have more to do with which phone to choose than an arbitrary age. 

  • Which product should I buy? I want to create vintage/retro posters for band and Bar

    which product should I buy? I want to create vintage/retro posters for band and Bar

    Good day!
    Instead of buying right away you may want to avail yourself of the free 30 day trial first to see which program fits your needs.
    Photoshop and Photoshop Elements may be worth a try.
    If you intend to create more graphic/typographic designs Illustrator may be worth looking into, too.
    Someone else may have more/other recommendations, though.
    Regards,
    Pfaffenbichler

  • Which Mac Pro to buy for Studio 3

    Guys, I'm in the process of upgrading my trusted Power Mac G5 Quad to a Mac Pro.
    I will also upgrade to FCS 3.
    My question is, which Mac Pro to buy? Quad 2.93 OR Octo 2.26?
    Will FCS 3 along with Snow Leopard utilise ALL the Octo's processors? Or am I better off saving the money and sticking with a Quad?

    If your income depends on this work, then buy the biggest, baddest, most RAM-filled Mac Pro you can.
    At least get the octo 2.66. Put 12GB RAM in it, if you can, but put a minimum of 6GB in there. The concept is that as a professional editor, editing for clients, you must be as time efficient as you can afford to be.
    Compressor will use that RAM to compress your stuff a lot faster. Also, Motion can make use of as much RAM as you throw in there. Final Cut Pro itself, not yet.

  • Which RAM should i buy for my HP PAVILION G6 2230TX with Windows 8 Pro(64-bit)

    Spoiler (Highlight to read)
    Hi! Everyone. How are you all? 
    Spoiler (Highlight to read)
    Spoiler (Highlight to read)
    Spoiler (Highlight to read)
    The RAM of my PC is expendable upto 8 GB and contains 2 slots, 1 slot is filled with 2 GB RAM and i want to fill the other empty slot 6 GB of RAM, so that all the slots are filled and i get best performance but i don't know which RAM should i buy. Any help?
    Spoiler (Highlight to read)
    Regards
    Spoiler (Highlight to read)
    Aniket Chauhan
    Hi! Everyone. How are you all?  The RAM of my PC is expendable upto 8 GB and contains 2 slots, 1 slot is filled with 2 GB RAM and i want to fill the other empty slot 6 GB of RAM, so that all the slots are filled and i get best performance but i don't know which RAM should i buy. Any help? Regards Aniket Chauhan

    Hi,
    Please use the following information for the similar machine:
        http://www.crucial.com/uk/upgrade/HP-memory/Pavilion+G6/Pavilion+g6-2230us-upgrades.html
    You can buy from them or use the info to buy elsewhere.
    Regards.
    BH
    **Click the KUDOS thumb up on the left to say 'Thanks'**
    Make it easier for other people to find solutions by marking a Reply 'Accept as Solution' if it solves your problem.

  • Which Mac should I choose? I have a 13 inch and will up upgrading to a 15 inch but which Mac should I choose?  Thanks!

    I have a Macbook 13 inch I got in Feb 09. Its starting to show its age. I know my next will be at least a 15 inch. Which Mac should I choose? I prefer laptops. Thanks!

    You should also ask this in the MacBook Pro forum. This is the forum for the 13” white and black plastic MacBooks that were discontinued in 2010. You should also post this question there to increase your chances of getting an answer.
    https://discussions.apple.com/community/notebooks/macbook_pro

  • If we buy a game for iPad and now it's available for Mac, should we buy again?

    If we buy a game for iPad and now it's available for Mac, should we buy again? I've bought fractal for iPad and now it's available for Mac, if I want to play on my mac should i buy the same game again?

    If you want to play it on the Mac, you need to buy it again. iOS and Mac OS X versions of applications are separate products.
    (63592)

Maybe you are looking for

  • Grab application doesn't work

    I select the Grab app from the utilities folder and it appears in my dock, but it doesn't work. How can I get it to work? Thanks!

  • Planning, Budgeting, Forecasting, Reporting & Analysis Add-on for SBO?

    Any proven solutions out there for planning, budgeting, forecasting, reporting & analysis for SAP Business One? Something that is applicable to a service-based industry. Something like http://centage.com/products-planningmaestro-product-overview.htm.

  • WAG200G not load configuration page

    Hi. I have a WIRELESS-G ADSL Home Gateway WAG200G.  When i try to access in the configuration page my router, the page isn't load correctly. I can connect with my username and password, but only half page is load.  If i access in the configuration pa

  • ITEM SUPPLY/DEMAND QUERY

    HI All, Working in EBS Version : 11.5.10.2 I need some help to achieve the below result Item Code Item Description Current on hand Available Qty (Last Value) item A item123 140 -382 when i look at form it shows temp table, please advice me which tabl

  • Xcode freaks out when I switch C++ project to 10.3.9 SDK

    I have a very simple program in a .cpp file in a command-line project that can build for 10.5, but I wanted to make this project build for the oldest version of OS X that's reasonable. So I went into the Project configuration and simply chose the Bas