Which one of these two drives would you recommend and why

Hello,
I am planning on adding an external HD to be used with Time Machine.
I was looking at a WD My Book Studio LX 2 TB FireWire 800, then I saw another WD - 2 TB My Book Studio II.
While the first look very nice and sleek with its aluminum case, and judging by WD website, offers more features, the second one seem to be faster (7200 rpm vs 5400 rpm) and it also offers 5 years of warranty compared with only 3.
I am not a computer geek, therefore I am throwing the question here: which one should I buy and why? Do I really need that RAID technology?
Thanks in advance for your answers.
Regards,
Loerincz

IMHO, you want neither. I've heard enough bad things about WD drives on these forums that I wouldn't touch them with a ten-foot pole. Try [Other World Computing|http://www.macsales.com>. They've got quality stuff.
As for RAID, you probably don't need that. RAID is a way to make multiple separate drives act like one larger drive, but that's major overkill for most home backup needs.

Similar Messages

  • Which email service would you recommend and why? Google's or BC's?

    Which email service would you recommend and why? Google's or BC's?

    Easy Answer. Google. Hands down Google is better. BC has had issues in the past and while I think the issue is a little bit better I would choose Google. Do remember that Google Apps is $50 (USD) per year per user.
    I have used Google Apps since they were still offering 50 free users and has worked great ever since. If there have been downtimes I have not noticed or has been so slight that is hasn't effected me in anyway. This is not the case with BC.
    I am not trying to knock BC mail but it isn't the best.

  • MIDI CONTROLLERS WHICH ONE WOULD YOU CHOSE AND WHY?

    Between M-Audio 8v2 , M-Audio 02 , M-AUDIO 49E and M-Audio axiom 25. Which one of these would you choose and why?

    The Axiom 25.
    For the rotary encoders, pads and memory.
    I'd take this over the 49 because both of the keyboards will be pitiful and your better of getting a full size board with hammer action if its about the "piano" feel. These things are great to have at hand when fiddling with synths while setting up in logic.

  • Which would you keep, which would you sell, and why?

    This kind of question might not be totally appropriate for this forum, but here goes anyhow. If it's really off-topic, I suppose the mods can delete it, but I am really having a hard time with this decision.
    I am thinking of selling off a couple of laptops for a newer (refurbished) 15-inch AlBook. I am selling an iBook for sure. Also, one of the following will go to my wife, and one will get sold to help raise cash for the newer AlBook:
    1. TiBook, 15", 1GHz, 1GB RAM, 100GB hard drive, Superdrive, Airport
    2. AlBook 12", 867MHz, 1.12GB RAM, 60GB hard drive, Combo drive, Airport Extreme, Bluetooth
    Which one would you sell, which one would you keep, and why? I have my own ideas, but I am really on the fence as to a final decision. I need some other opinions from people who know TiBooks better than I do.
    Thanks. By the way, I'm really not this indecisive in real life. Now for my next question: Given the choice between pancakes and sausage or eggs and bacon for breakfast, which would you choose and why?

    IMHO no Powerbook as been as fine as a Titanium and as you have the 1GHz SD Ti I would defintely keep that. For the following reasons:
    Far more comfortable screen to use. (1280x854 versus XGA)
    DVI connection (instant connection to projectors/lcd monitors no need for adaptors like the Al 12)
    PCMCIA slot
    64Mb versus 32Mb Graphics Memory
    Style - it's slimer(2.5cm Ti versus 3cm Al) and I prefer the look.
    All ports convieniently on the back and under a cover to keep dust etc out.
    Shed load of replacement parts available on eBay (not had to use this yet though)
    and specfically because of what you list:
    100Gb HDD versus 60Gb
    Superdrive versus Combo
    Processor Speed
    You can soon add BT, 802.11g, card reader or USB 2 (or any future technology) to a Ti via the PCMCIA but even though the Al has AE and BT you can't add FW800 or whatever else crops up to the Al 12.
    The negatives of the Ti would be - battery is most likely to critically fail shortly and the slower memory speed on the Ti.
    I love my Ti, even though it's three years old now (still 2.5hrs charge!) new Al books are not at all tempting - tell me what else I could achieve witha new Al over the Ti?
    regards
    mrtotes
    P.S. Pancakes for breakfast - absolutely bonkers! I tried it once on my Honeymoon to Canada - it won't catch on. Eggs and bacon is the way ahead, but a Full English would be preferable...

  • I Mini with an i7 processor. I would like to use Boot Camp to install windows based CAD software on my MAC. Would it be better to use a plugin external hard drive to load my software on and if so what hard drive would you recommend?

    I Mini with an i7 processor. I would like to use Boot Camp to install windows based CAD software on my MAC. Would it be better to use a plugin external hard drive to load my software on and if so what hard drive would you recommend?

    Thank you for your quick response. I can then use a ZIP drive for data storage. I want to keep as much of my hard drive free of data as possible.

  • Photo/Video editing PC build; what would you change and why?

    I'm in the planning phase of my first photo/video editing PC build.  I've done quite a bit of research to this point, and I've finally come to a decision on all of the components (I think).  After seeing how helpful everyone is on this forum, I decided to post my plan and see what everyone thinks.
    Miscellaneous info:  I am an amateur photographer looking to expand my horizons and venture into the video realm.  I will be running Windows 7 64bit with Adobe CS5 Production Premium and Lightroom 3 on a singe solid state drive and everything else will be on a 3 drive RAID 0 config.  Eventually I plan on purchasing a RAID card and a few more drives for a RAID 3 (or 5) config, but that won't be for a while.
    Ok, here's my planned build...
    Component
    Description
    Processor
    Intel   Core i7 - 950 3.06GHz Quad-Core Processor
    Motherboard
    ASUS   P6X58D-E LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX Intel Motherboard
    Memory
    Corsair   Dominator 12GB (6 x 2GB) DDR3 1600 (PC3 12800) Triple Channel Memory
    System Drive
    Crucial   RealSSD C300 2.5" 128GB SATA III MLC Internal Solid State Drive
    Data Drive(s)
    3 - Western   Digital Caviar Black 1TB 7200 RPM 64MB Cache SATA 6.0Gb/s 3.5" Internal   Hard Drive (Configured in RAID 0 for now)
    Optical Drive
    Pioneer   BDR-205BKS Blu-ray Burner
    Video Card
    EVGA   GeForce GTX 470 (Fermi) SuperClocked 1280MB 320-bit GDDR5 PCI Express 2.0 x16   HDCP Ready SLI Support Video Card
    Power Supply
    Corsair   HX Series CMPSU-850HX 850W ATX12V 2.3 / EPS12V 2.91 80 PLUS SILVER Certified   Modular Active PFC Power Supply
    Case
    LIAN   LI PC-A71F Black Aluminum ATX Full Tower Computer Case
    Monitor
    NEC   MultiSync PA271W-BK-SV 27" Widescreen LCD Monitor with SpectraViewII   Color Calibration Solution
    So, what would you change and why?
    I'm looking forward to your responses!

    "I'll take your advice and go with Samsung F3s.  With the money I save  (by not getting the WD Caviar Blacks), I'll add a 4th drive and use the  RAID5 on the mobo until I can afford to upgrade to a proper RAID  controller."
    I might be a bit late, but wanted to let you know about motherboard software RAID configs (at least mine):
    I have an older system running an ASUS P5AD2-E Premium MB containing a Silicon Image 3114 RAID chip. I originally configured a RAID 10 array with four 74 G Raptors for speed and redundancy. Figured if I lost a disc, I could just rebuid the array. Come to find out, the Sil 3114 chip does not support rebuilding the RAID 10 array.
    I had lost a disc (disc was okay, just power to the disc was interupted) so was running on three. Fixed my power problem, went to rebuild the array and couldn't. So I figured what is the point of having a RAID 10 that I couldn't rebuild. Went to a RAID 0 with a backup disk.
    Never checked the documentation to see if software RAID 5 through the SIl 3114 was rebuildable.
    Mind you, I am not a computer guru nor all knowledgable about software/harware based RAID configs. But after talking to others who are the guru's, I found that I should stay away from the motherboard software RAID arrays and they mirror what Harm said about hardware RAID boards. But on a budget, the RAID 0 with a backup drive works for me.
    Just my 2 cents to help.
    Tony

  • Which of these 3 laptops would you recommend

    Hi,
    I got it down to the final 3 laptops that I like. Which one would you suggests. I'm looking for something that's fast, has lots a hard drive space, good monitor and a blue ray player would be nice.
    http://www.bestbuy.com/site/Sony+-+VAIO+Laptop+with+Intel%26%23174%3B+Core%26%23153%3B+i3+Processor+...
    http://www.bestbuy.com/site/Toshiba+-+Satellite+Laptop+with+Intel%26%23174%3B+Core%26%23153%3B+i3+Pr...
    http://www.bestbuy.com/site/Samsung+-+Laptop+with+Intel%26%23174%3B+Core%26%23153%3B+i3+Processor+-+...

    All 3 of these machines are solid! My personal opinion would be to get the Toshiba, love the battery life and they just make some great machines. I've never been huge on Vaio's, I feel you pay a little too much for the name. As far as the Samsung goes, I am in love with both Samsung models my store has in stock, only thing I'm unsure about is how they will do. We don't have a vast track record for Samsung and consumer laptops.
    All in all, these machines are all rock-solid but I'd have to lean towards the Toshiba as my personal opinion.

  • SQLSRV Driver vs PDO_SQLSRV. What would you suggest, and why?

    Hi all,
    My team and I are working on a mobile XMPP/Jabber instant messaging application, aimed at iOS, Android and Windows 8 phones. The back-end XMPP Server is
    OpenFire and this OpenFire Server works together with a SQL Server 2014 Database to store users, offline messages, etc. We also want to do some stuff to the database, which OpenFire does not
    do by itself. For this, I have opted to use PHP on the server and call it via jQuery Ajax on the front-end. Anyway, what I am wondering is, which of the two PHP Drivers for SQL Server I should use in this case. There seem to be two drivers provided by Microsoft:
    A) SQLSRV Driver (procedural)
    and
    B) PDO_SQLSRV (Object oriented).
    I am currently reading the documentation at Accessing SQL Server Databases from PHP to get some insight into these two options,
    but I am wondering if anyone has any preference for any driver, and why?
    Ideally, I would like a driver that is fault-tolerant in an environment where many quasi-simultaneous read/write operations are made to the database, as we are hoping for a high adoption rate for this application, meaning lots of users -> Lots of SQL
    Queries.
    Thanks for all help and suggestions,
    best regards,
    Chris
    Edit: Also, I am running PHP 5.5.15, however the download package at http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/confirmation.aspx?id=20098 only includes drivers for php 5.3 and 5.4. Will these also work for PHP 5.5.15 (running XAMPP)

    Hi, first I am not criticizing the Microsoft and liguagem.net is very good. depends on the sitau��o of its company. you must lead in consideration you will be that valley the penalty to migrar? you find that this taking care of the necessities of the company continues working with Asp.net! here in Brazil he would be for account of the money lack that great companies want to have its applications how much good, pretty and cheap... it could until saying makes in JSP 2,0 and good IDE and eclipse 3,0, I loved:) it would advise to think a little on the situation of migrar its applications! but it thinks... migration, has much the one that to plan! it studies and it thinks very!
    my opinion this
    success
    karla maria :)

  • I'm an architect looking forward to purchasing a new Mac. Which model do you recommend and why?

    I currently own a MacBook Pro 13 inch model (late-2011)
    Processor  2.8 GHz Intel Core i7
    Memory  8 GB 1333 MHz DDR3
    Graphics  Intel HD Graphics 3000 512 MB
    I'm an architecture student in my last semester, looking forward to buying a desktop Mac (for current and future use as a professional).
    Sadly, for us architects we are limited with some mayor Architecture Programs such as 3Ds Max & Revit (both of which I use frecuently and have to use in a PC )
    I have tried runing them in Parallels (in my MacBook Pro), but the result is slow and sluggish... so I plan on purchasing a new desktop computer as I believe these have more capacity to run this programs.
    I would like to avoid using Boot Camp (hate having to restart the computer frequently) so if a Mac with be it Parallels/VMWare Fusion/CrossOver can do the job EFFICENTLY I would be happy.
    So, which Mac model do you recommend for this case?
    I'm undecided and would like some advice from you guys.
    I'm not so limited on budget, but of course low cost would be appreciated.
    If you could give some specific specs as RAM, Processor model, etc. that would help me more.
    Im guessing the Power Mac is the best one...but just checking other opinions and answers.
    THANKS!

    Why not if you are going to run Windows pick up a PC with what you need?
    The new mac pro 2013 won't be out for couple months and figure more time for software, even Fusion etc to catch up.
    A VM is never going to be the same as running directly on the hardware natively.
    The new Mac Pro though should be able to handle what you throw at it but even support for Windows could take time.
    And looking at a new Mac operating system 10.9 Maverick. Windows 8.1 in same time frame.
    If you do use a VM, install Windows natively to begin with and then attach the VM to point to it. There are times you need or want to run or apply updates natively.
    The Mac has never had support for multiple high end graphic cards, no support for SLI and CrossFire-X, no 8-pin power connectors, if your software needs.
    Mac Pro 2013 product page - new design and up to 12-cores and FirePro (2) GPU if you want to burn a pile of $$s.
    http://www.apple.com/mac-pro/

  • Which of these solutions would you recommend?

    while trying to create a login system using JSP, I ran into several tutorials, and tried creating one by using java beans to keep track of the session.
    The bean stores the username by using setUserID(String userID), and also sets a certain variable to true if the user is logged in.
    To create different levels or types of users, and add more functionality to this login system, I believe I could add more properties to determine the level and other necessary information (with information taken from a database), and simply use a beanid.getProperty() to check for the information I need for example.
    I know that another way and the more common way to create a login system while securing other pages on the website, is to use session tracking and the session variable to set different values, etc... and keep track of the user.
    Now my question is, which one of these 2 solutions would you recommend? Which one do you believe to be more secure?
    Thanks.

    Arent both essentially the same? In the first, you set all properties in a single bean object and bind that object to the session. In the second, you bind each property individually to the session. So there is nothing to choose 'security' wise between the two options. Security, I believe, has nothing to do with how you track the user's session. Usage of SSL for example is a security technique.
    Having said that, if we confine your question to which is a better option for session management per se, I would favour the first (a single bean). I am not a great fan of a bloated session object though. You can always query necessary info from the db using this id rather than storing it in the session.
    Note you neednt set a variable to indicate that the user has logged in. The presence of the UserBean is sufficient to indicate the logged in status (assuming that you create such a bean only on successful login).
    Hope this is useful to you.
    ram.

  • Which of the two monitors do you recommend for Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 5:  EIZO CG 277 Coloredge o

    HI,
    Which of the two monitors do you recommend for Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 5:
    EIZO CG 277 Coloredge or NEC PA-272W.
    Thanks in advance for your reply.

    It depends on where you are. Things are very different in Europe (Italy?) compared to the US situation.
    The price difference between comparable NEC/Eizo models in Europe actually goes in Eizo's favor. The regular NEC PA272 in Europe cannot be hardware calibrated (it has a firmware lock) and the comparable offering would be either the NEC Spectraview 272 or the Spectraview Reference 272. These are more expensive than the Eizo CG277.
    Note that the European PA272 can be hardware calibrated with the US Spectraview II software - but that software cannot be bought in Europe and has to be imported from the US.
    All these displays are top reference quality. As for calibration software, which is a very important part in the equation, my vote goes to Eizo's ColorNavigator (I have a CG246). It is a superb piece of well thought-out software. The US Spectraview II - which I also happen to have - is a very, very close second, but the European Spectraview Profiler software that you get with the EU NEC units isn't all that impressive.
    Photoshop supports a 10 bit display pipeline, with either display, as long as you have a video card that also supports it. Lightroom doesn't support it.

  • Which one of these options are better for CDS updation?

    Hi,
    I was going through the data flow in the outbound direction in NW mobile.
    the data object instances in the CDS are updated by 3 means:
    1)  DOE triggered
    2) backend triggered
    3) backend pushes instance to DOE.
    which one of these is better.
    kindly explain the reason as well.

    Hi,
    Actually there are only two types of Synchronization types between Backend & DOE,
    1. DOE Triggered
    2. Backend Triggered
    DOE triggered adapters will pull the data from Backend to DOE where as Backend triggered adapters will push the data from Backend to DOE (there are two types in BE triggered, Key push & Instance push).
    Backend triggered sync type is always better since the changes have been pushed to the DOE then & there (this can be achieved by event,etc..). So that always DOE & Backend will be consistent & the receivers (devices) will also get the latest data in order to proceed with their day to day activities (i.e. business critical data).
    Regards,
    Ananth.

  • HT2589 I just bought an Imac. I have an ipad2 and an iphone 4s. My wife has an iphone 4s. Both of us have different apple ids. Would you recommend a new one or use an existing id?  Why?

    I just bought an Imac. I have an ipad2 and an iphone 4s. My wife has an iphone 4s. Both of us have different apple ids. Would you recommend a new one or use an existing id?  Why?

    It is best to stop making all new apple IDs, as software is permanently tied to them, and you can't converge them. Make differnt ones if you plan to get divorced though....

  • I need to buy a camcorder -- upgrading from a Flip. Which would you recommend as easiest to use with iMovie 11? Which for Final Cut Pro? Thanks!

    I need to buy a camcorder -- upgrading from a Flip. Which would you recommend as easiest to use with iMovie 11? Which for Final Cut Pro? Thanks!

    You can't run iMovie 11 on a PPC G5 running the old OS 10.3 Panther - which is what you say you have.
    iMovie 11 - cameras supported:
    http://help.apple.com/imovie/cameras/en/index.html?lang=en_US
    iMovie 9 - cameras supported:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3290?viewlocale=en_US
    iMovie 8 Camcorders supported:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1014
    Digital camera RAW formats supported by OS X Lion:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4757?viewlocale=en_US
    Digital camera RAW formats supported by OS X Snow Leopard:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3825?viewlocale=en_US

  • Which of of these two choices is the correct way to call a report ?

    Environment is 9iAS.
    Which of of these two choices is the correct way to call a report from the menu?
    Choice 1) CGNV$INVOKE_REPORT('W02226.adinfra.net:8888,reports9i', 'rv043knd.rdf', CACHE, '', 'HTML',NULL );
    Coice 2) qms$menu.set_current_action('LAUNCH_REPORT','rv043knd.rdf'); execute_trigger('QMS$MENU_ITEM');

    although the menu-preference MNUDRC has the value qms$menu.set_current_action('LAUNCH_REPORT','<MODULE>'); execute_trigger('QMS$MENU_ITEM');
    the generated code for calling the report in the menu is like the code under option 1).
    What else do we need to set (in the preferences or elsewhere) to use the Headstart Report Launch Form ???
    thanks! Bart

Maybe you are looking for

  • Uploading csv file into database using apex

    Dear all I am using apex 4 and oracle express 10g, i need to upload .csv file into the database for one of my appls, i have referred discussion forum for solutions, i found also, but some how its not working for me. below mentioned is error and the c

  • Live Office Connection not showing Go to Object Option

    Hi All, i m using Xcelsius Enterprise 4.5. I have created a dashboard in which I m having a live office connection. I had added the live office connection from a Webi Report, Binded the Prompt and created a live office connection to the server. The r

  • Power Mac connected to a TV

    Hello everyone, I am thinking of buying a Power Mac for home and until I can save up the extra money for a cinema display I was thinking of hooking up the mac to my LCD TV. It has a DVI connection and in theory can be used as a computer screen. Does

  • Zen vision m album artw

    Hi can anybody tell me how i get album cover pictures on my zen vision m please, Thanks

  • System copy with NW 7.01 Ehp1 MaxDB hang

    Hi I'm performing a system copy with a NW 7.01 Ehp1 MaxDB from a Dev to QA. The source system copy was run successfully but in the target system copy, the sapinst keep running and running for days at IMPORT ABAP step (Phase 18 of 27). I don't know wh