White Macbook (Early 2009) Why mini-DVI to S-video adapter no longer works?

I am a lifelong Mac user and by now think I pretty well know the ins and outs of Macs and most Mac-related issues... but this one has stumped me.
The new white Macbook was upgraded to include many of the components of its big brother unibody Aluminum Macbooks (including 1066 MHz frontside bus and the NVIDIA 9400M) just over a week ago. I was lucky enough to be in the market for a new laptop about this time and snatched one up a few days ago (retiring my awesome 12" Aluminum PowerBook G4 which is still kicking).
One of the main reasons I upgraded was to be able to use Silverlight 2.0 (d--- Microsoft) as I can't watch streaming lectures from school without it. A nice bonus would be the ability to stream Netflix videos to my TV through my laptop which I've wanted to do for a while. Anyone who has bought one of these new Macbooks and uses their laptop with their TV as much as I do has probably read one of these two links:
http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3413
http://store.apple.com/us/product/M9319G/A?mco=MzE2OTkzMA
Note the asterisk at the Apple store: "* This adapter is not compatible with the 2.0GHz Intel Core 2 Duo white MacBook introduced in January 2009."
Can someone tell me why this is? I've been using the s-video out of my Apple laptops for the past 6 years... why change it now? Is this a temporary problem or permanent change?
I have been fervently searching for a work-around but no blogs, forums, or boards have given me any answers. One tech blogger at http://createdigitalmotion.com/2009/01/22/white-macbook-snubs-adapter-i-want-my- tv-out/ speculates that Apple is cracking down on DRM video being watched on TV's... but that makes no sense, any new TV can use the DVI output still supported by this computer.
Dear Apple: PLEASE give me my TV back!!! I want to watch Netflix and use that cool Front Row feature you put in your system!
Message was edited by: zioneyes

Ziatron wrote:
Apple does not regularly read these forms. The best way to communicate with Apple is with the below link.
http://www.apple.com/feedback/macbook.html
Thank you for your helpful and detailed response, Ziatron. I am aware Apple is unlikely to peruse my forum post, I was just crying out in anguish at the gods that be, so to speak.
Everything you wrote is consistent with what I have read in other places, thanks for consolidating it here. I am not as proficient in display technologies as I am in other areas so let me see If I am understanding you correctly. Apple has licensed HDCP technology and is employing it across its desktop and laptop lineups. The new white MacBook was the last of the MacBook lineup to be upgraded to include this new technology and as it still retains the older Mini-DVI out rather than the new Mini-Displayport Apple had to "flip the switch" and turn off the MacBook's ability to put out video through the old adapter. I notice that there is no Mini-Displayport to video adapter available in their store. Am I good so far?
So I am left to assume that they turned off the capability of outputing to s-video because that output cannot be managed by the new HDCP technology, correct? If so, I suppose I understand but am still frustrated as it seems they are prevent the growth of a few weeds (illegal content) by burning the whole lawn (preventing many such as me from using the output I love). Thanks for your help again.

Similar Messages

  • Mini-DVI to S-Video Adapter doesn't work

    Hi, I am using the Mini-DVI to S-Video adapter from apple to connect my macbook to the TV. But the only thing I get is a grey flickering picture on my TV. When I click on the monitor-button I can see that my macbook detects only a monitor (but not a TV) in addition to the macbook-LCD-display. I tried all different resolutions, but needless to say it doesn't work.
    Can the adapter be broken, or is there a problem with the macbook?
    Macbook white 2 GHz Intel Core Duo 1GB RAM   Mac OS X (10.4.8)  

    my macbook detects only a monitor (but not a TV) in addition to the macbook-LCD-display
    If you connect the Mini-DVI to S-Video adapter, the monitor button on the menubar should show resolutions for Color LCD in one section and NTSC/PAL in the other.
    A grey flickering picture is indicative of picking the wrong standard-PAL vs. NTSC.

  • HOW TO REPLACE HARD DRIVE WHITE MACBOOK EARLY 2009

    I have a White MacBook Early 2009, I need suggestions. My Macbook is still running fine, but would like to know which Hard Drive I should purchase as replacement. Thinking of going 500GB if possible, I already downloaded the instructions. Just trying to get my ducks in order for when that time comes, hopefully not for a few more years.

    For a new hard drive try Newegg.com  
    Regular SATA drives http://www.newegg.com/Store/SubCategory.aspx?SubCategory=380&name=Laptop-Hard-Dr ives&Order=PRICE  Use the list at the left for larger and faster drives.
    SSD drives
    http://www.newegg.com/Internal-SSD/SubCategory/ID-636?Order=PRICE  Use the list at the left for larger and faster drives.
    Or OWC for regular hard drives and SSDs  http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/hard-drives/2.5-Notebook/
    Here are instructions on replacing the hard drive in a MacBook with a removable battery. http://creativemac.digitalmedianet.com/articles/viewarticle.jsp?id=45088
    To transfer your current hard drive I like the applications Carbon Copy Cloner or SuperDuper. They make a bootable copy of everything on your hard drive. http://www.bombich.com/index.html or http://www.shirt-pocket.com/SuperDuper/SuperDuperDescription.html 
      You'll need a cheap SATA external hard drive case. Put the new drive in the case then format and partition the new drive and clone your old drive to the new one. Check that it's set up right by booting up from the external drive. Then replace your old hard drive with the new one and put your old one in the external case.
    Here's a cheap SATA external hard drive case on Amazon http://www.amazon.com/Vantec-NexStar-2-5-Inch-External-Enclosure/dp/B002JQNXZC/r ef=pd_cp_pc_0
      If you don’t have the tools to open up the MacBook OWC has a set for $5
    http://eshop.macsales.com/item/OWC/TOOLKITMHD/

  • Mini-DVI to S-video adapter and no colour on TV screen

    I just purchased a mini-DVI to S-video adapter for my MacBook. I want to connect it to my TV through my DVD/Video player.
    I do get a nice picture on the TV and I can manage it in the screen settings panel, BUT the TV-screen doesn't show any colour, just black and white. Why?
    I've tried several settings in the Preferences panel, but no luck. What to do?

    The cable is brand new and I've checked it with a mulitmeter. It's OK.
    I've also heard that this is a fairly common problem with S-video and I got a tip to try the composite video instead. It worked beautifully, so now I've got nice and crisp video in full colour on my TV!

  • Mini dvi to s-video adapter

    when i connect my macbook to my sanyo hdtv via the mini dvi to s-video adapter the image on the computer screen apears on the tv, but with orange stripes down it.

    At what resolution? Have you tried different ones?

  • Dynex mini-DVI to S-video adapter

    I bought a Dynex mini-DVI to S-video adapter with my Macbook and I just tried to use it to plug into my projector via S-video. The resolution of my screen dropped to 800x600 but otherwise nothing happened. I even followed the Max OS X help information and turned on the computer with the adapter and cable plugged in and it still didn't display on the projector. I went to the display settings in system preferences and asked it to detect displays but I don't think it changed anything either. It seems the Dynex website is rather sparse on documentation and support. Any ideas? It'd be greatly appreciated!

    I've tried pretty much everything with the same mini-DVI adapter made by Dynex.. if anyone can help it would be much appreciated!

  • I am attempting to plug my mac into my tv. I am using the mini dvi to s video adapter. When I plug it in, the display goes all wonky and becomes stretched and enlarged.

    When I attempt to connect my mac to the monitor using a mini dvi to s video adapter the display becomes enlarged and stretched. I cannot seem to fix this using the system preferences or the quick keys that allow you to zoom in on the display. Any suggestions?

    I am using MAC OSx 10.5.8 (9L31a) as my operation system.  The TV says "No signal.  Check connected device's power, cable connection and source selection."  Seems to me that that goes in hand with what the Samsung tech said about the Mac needing to be forces to use the external display.  But how do I do that?

  • Mini dvi to Component Video adapter !

    Help !
    Where Can I Find "mini dvi to Component Video adapter" ?
    Help !

    "there is no such thing in apple store"
    I MAID,
    Begging your pardon, but I just tried the above linked Search Results, and what you seek is apparently on the list, as the search was performed exactly as you specified. You can read the description of the various items for sale and tell us what is different about the one that you need. That way we can perform a new search for you, or, in the alternative, you can search for yourself. If the Apple Store doesn't have what you want, search CompUSA.

  • When I unplug Mini-dvi to S-video adapter mouse often disappears

    When I unplug my mini-dvi to s-video/rca adapter, the mouse cursor often disappears. This results in me having to restart the computer. Does anyone know how to fix this problem?

    At what resolution? Have you tried different ones?

  • Apple Mini DVI to S-Video Adapter

    i was planning to buy a new Apple Mini DVI to S_Video Adapter
    can some one tell me if I need an extra audio cable for sound or if s video can do this
    thanks for your help

    Yes, it's only video. However, I have a cable that combines two audio cables and the s-video physically together. The audio cables are terminated with RCA jacks, so a short stereo RCA-to-headphone Y-adapter on one end connects to the headphone jack on the MacBook, and the appropriate audio and s-video jacks on my TV at the other.

  • Can I install a Hybrid HDD SSD drive in my Macbook early 2009?

    I was thinking of installing this new drive into my 13-inch White MacBook early 2009 edition.  I have read community pages stating it should be fine so long as i do not go over 9.5 mm height and is a 2.5 inch SATA.
    http://www.amazon.com/Seagate-Momentus-Solid-Hybrid-ST95005620AS/dp/B003NSBF32/r ef=reg_hu-rd_add_1_dp
    But I would rather be safe than out all the cash.
    Please let me know if this is a good decision.  (Note I am not high on cash at the moment and am using some winnings from a hackathon to purchase the item.)

    I installed one in an early 2008 MacBook 4,1 and it worked perfectly.....I would expect the same results for the early 2009.....

  • Mini DVI to S-video display problem

    I connect my macbook to a plasma TV using mini DVI to S-video adapter so I can give keynote presentations. All of a sudden, having not changed any settings, the plasma display went to black & white while my macbook's display remains in color. I have checked with two different s-video cables and with another TV, as well as trying to change the color display in my system preferences, but after several hours have given up. Anyone else have this problem or have any thoughts on how to alleviate it? Thanks
    Hungus

    A wire may have broken inside the mini DVI to S-video adapter. S-video uses one wire for the brightness, and one for the color information. If the color wire breaks you will get a black and white picture. Until Apple replaces the adapter, you could use the composite video output, but the picture will not be as sharp.

  • Mini DVI to S-Video B&W only!!

    I bought a Mini DVI to S-Video adapter and a S-video to RCA cable to hook my MacBook up to my TV, but when I plug it in I can only see it in Black and White. I checked System Prefs>Displays and tried out several different profiles, to no avail. FWIW the audio seems to be fine.
    What am I doing wrong? Thanks in advance for your assistance.

    In my experience when you try to connect an s-video source to a TV you need the TV to be able to accept s-video signals or it does come out black and white.
    One of my televisions has front inputs which consist of one s-video plus the standard three phonos. If i dont tell the tv its an s-video cable the image is black and white.I had the same kinda thing with an older tv when using a scart convertor which had s-video input. I had to use the correct scart socket which was the one that supported s-video and then tell the tv it was s-video by switching to AV2/S instead of just AV2.

  • Mini-DVI to S-Video resolution

    I've plugged my Mini-DVI to S-Video adapter into the MacBook, but there is only limited selection of resolutions available in the NTSC/PAL preference pane. My Mac mini S-Video adapter has options for 16:9 output, but the MacBook only lists the following (none are 16:9 resolutions):
    640 x 480
    720 x 480
    720 x 576
    800 x 600
    1024 x 768
    Any ideas how I can get the MacBook to output 16:9 widescreen via the S-Video adapter?
    Thanks very much, Rich

    Thanks namke, had no idea that rectangular pixels were employed to achieve widescreen on a TV - you learn something new everyday!
    I wondered what other MacBook users get when they plug in the mini dvi to s-video adpater because 16:9 resolution is an option when a DVI adapter is plugged into my Mac mini (e.g. 1024 x 576), but not my MacBook.

  • Mini DVI to S-video and composite giving complete distorted output!!

    I tried to hook up my 20" Sony Trinitron either through S-video or composite to the powerbook without any success. I got completely distorted picutre. I have tried all the video resolution setting that is available on the Displays reference window with the same result. Does anybody out there run into this problem at all.

    I have a 12" PowerBook 1.5ghz and had the same problem with garbled video today. When I plugged in the Mini-DVI > Composite/S-Video adapter the PowerBook would consistently think it was attached to an ordinary VGA monitor, and could not sync with the television. This caused a B&W, warped, split in half picture.
    I took the adapter back to the Apple store, plugged it into one of their demo units, and saw it behaved the same way. They gave me a replacement and everything has been fine since.
    QS2002, 1.4ghz, 1gb, GeForce 4 Ti4600, SATA; 12" PB 1.5ghz, 512mb   Mac OS X (10.4.4)  

Maybe you are looking for

  • AcroExch.App with Adobe Reader

    If a computer only has Adobe Reader installed, can an application running on that computer interact with a pdf document via OLE?  In particular, can an application on that computer use AcroExch.App and AcroExch.AVDoc objects? Example code: #import "a

  • Possible problem with Zen Micro, quick questi

    The top button on my Micro, the Play/Pause touch button, is quite a bit brighter than the other 5 buttons and the glowing ring around the edge of the player. They're fairly dim in comparison. The play button is pretty bright. Is this normal? Also, th

  • Generic standard table type

    Anybody please resolve my doubt types tb_std_type type table of sflight. -->this i understand as not a generic table type.'NON-UNIQUE" and DEFAULT KEYS are implicity defined . data it_std type tb_std.-->Since i could declare an internal table of tb_s

  • Unable for some reason create a Software Instrument

    In the Environment I suddenly can't create a software instrument when I go down to New / Channel Strip. The option is greyed out. Instead I have to go to Arrange and choose New Track. Then choose software instrument from the drop-down menu. That crea

  • Unable to edit, add or change passwords in iphoto web gallery

    Iphoto and Web Gallery were working great but recently, I am unable to add, change, or delete passwords to my web galleries. When I go Settings and into Edit Names and Passwords, I can add or change a password but when I click OK, it will not allow e