Why are moves in FCPX so awful?

I can't believe how silly making moves on graphics and whatnot in FCPX is. What happend to handles and being able to ease in/out the way you want instead having some default end-eases that make your moves look ridiculous.
Everytime I make a move and it isn't a straight horiz or vert. direction I get some goofball "S"curve sort of tracking with the element I'm moving. The move that prompted me to write this really took the cake. I wanted a chart to slide into the frame alongside a talking head. I wanted it to sit there for some seconds and then zoom in to a particular line on that chart while still leaving the subject visible. So I put a keyframe with the chart off-frame, a keyframe when it reached the end of its right-left slide, I advanced the timelineindicator up a few frames, added a keyframe there so it held position and then I went to the point where I wanted the zoom to end and enlarged/positioned the chart as I wanted it to end. But what I got was the chart sliding in and stopping as I designed it, but after the pause it BACKED UP several pixels in the OPPOSITE direction it was supposed to and THEN went in the direction I keyed for. And just before it reached its endpoint it stopped and slightly enlarged as though it were moving towards the viewer. Insane!
Am I missing something or is there no better control over these moves? Because this is prettty unacceptable. And the infuriatingly named "Ken Burns" move I find untenable (and not because of the appelation)

Well gentlemen. Here's one for the "How on earth did they figure THAT out?" file.
Since I hit my dead end here I went searching for other answers to this vexing problem. I ran across one in another forum that sounded so implausible that I wasn't going to even test it. But FCP was open and my event active I figured I might as well.
The person who supplied said remedy described it thusly: go to the first offending keyframe and tap the forward arrow key a few times to get just beyond that point (I went 3 frames). Go to the viewer window and select a new keyframe for that point. WIthout doing anything else DEselect that new keyframe. Repeat this at the very same point a few times (again, three for me). After that, advance to the next offending keyframe and then tap the backwards arrow key to retreat several frames from it (again, I did three). Once there, repeat the on/off precedure with the add keyframe button.
I went back to before that motion clip and hit the space bar. The video played and the motion graphic performed perfectly! No s-curve. I find this totally bizarre but who am I to argue with results? Any idea why this would have worked?

Similar Messages

  • HT204370 Why are movies excluded from iCloud?  They are the most expensive purchase from iTunes and just as valuable and important to be able to access anywhere from any device?

    They are the most expensive purchase from iTunes and just as valuable and important to be able to access anywhere from any device?  I find it so frustrating that first I had to purchase iWorks for my Mac, then I had to purchase it all over again for my IOS device so I could use iCloud, then I purchase thousands of dollars of movies and am not able to store them in the cloud, yet we have only purchased the rights to the songs no differently than we have the movies.  Why would they exclude movies from icloud?

    They are not part of icloud in all countries, becuase the movie industry in those copuntries does not allow Apple to offer this.

  • Why are movies on the AppleTV 3 are in 1080p and in iTunes in only 720p

    Hello,
    on the AppleTV 3 some Movies are in FullHD and in iTunes only in 720p?
    Here are Screenshots from my iTunes:
    On AppleTV 3 the Movies are in FullHD
    Why is this?

    mac_pro wrote:
    Where you are wrong is that drm in movies and drm in general isn't all about copyright. 
    I never said it was. I said the copyrights holders are the ones demanding the DRM.
    mac_pro wrote:
    https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/01/apple-shows-us-drms-true-colors
    Quote-unquote "uses of DRM have little to nothing to do with the risk of "piracy" and plenty to do control and limiting how customers can use their products".
    You will get no argument from about over this quote. I dislike DRM and think it should go away, however I do disagree with EFF's assumptions in that article.
    The fact that Apple was able to convince the record lables (who very, very publically still blame "piracy" for thier falling profits) to finally drop their DRM demands from the music sold on the iTunes Store says more to me about Apple's historical stance on DRM than anything you have to say since you hide behind a "contractual obligation." I'm not saying you are making anything up, but unless you can provide any corroborating evidence for what you say I'm going to have to call shennanigans and go with what I have heard from the mouths of the movie studios about their desire to completely control what we can do with their "products" and how they want us to pay for it over and over. Never have I heard any movie studio executive state publically they want their products digitally avaiable, DRM-free and playable on any mobile device. No, they all want them locked down with DRM.
    So I believe my statement that it is the rights holders, i.e. the movie studios, that are preventing all movies in the iTunes Store from being avaialble in iTunes in the Cloud is still valid.
    We're probably going to have to just agree to disagree on this.

  • Why Are Movies Disappearing?

    I was so excited when I updated my Apple TV on Wednesday night. I looked through all the movies available, and was thrilled to see one of my favorite movies of all time was available for rent in HD, Blazing Saddles! I called a couple of friends and scheduled a Blazing Saddles party for Saturday! I didn't rent it then, because I wanted to show off the whole process to my friends on Saturday.
    When I checked again on Friday night, the movie was no where to be found in the rental selections. So I had to call off the party. Way to go Apple. Way to make a great first impression. I was all stoked to see it in HD on my Apple TV. Now I am just let down.
    Any reason why Blazing Saddles was pulled? Will it be available again sometime?

    I tried renting Blazing Saddles immediately after I had updated my AppleTV the night of it's release, and got an error that the movie was no longer available. So, you most likely would have never been able to rent it anyways.
    As for people wondering about Blazing Saddles being in HD, it was one of the first titles released for HD-DVD and Blu-ray. It is mostly only TV shows and low-budget indie flicks that were filmed on magnetic tape. The "major" studios all use film. A master HD transfer is done from film and then stored digitally. The transfer used for HD-DVD/Blu-ray and for Take2 are then created from the new digital master. If you ever purchase a Blu-ray player be sure to buy or rent "Grand Prix" to see just how beautiful an old movie can look with a new HD transfer. Also notable: Blade Runner, Forbidden Planet, and Casablanca.

  • Why are movies in MobileMe not playing as they used to?

    I have for years posted movies (from my Canon camera) on MobileMe (or prior "dot Mac") and had them play back without issue.  Now I posted short movies via iPhoto as before and when I try to view them a still picture appears then goes blank while a part of the audio is played and (sometimes) a message appears saying that I might find additional software I need to view this movie at QuickTime Components page.  No details given as to just what is missing/needed.  What is going on here and how do I overcome this problem?

    Doctor Drive wrote:
    Stebalien wrote:Try disabling USB power saving.
    Shouldn't this feature be enabled by the user? I did not enable it.
    If it's really enabled, how should I turn it off?
    I assumed that you were using laptop-mode-tools. laptop-mode-tools autosuspends usb devices when the laptop is on battery power. Usually this would only suspend inactive devices but I have been experiencing a kernel bug that causes devices to be incorrectly suspended (exhibiting the same symptoms that you described).
    Try adding usbcore.autosuspend=-1 to the kernel command line.
    https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Common_k … n.27t_work

  • HT1657 Why are movie rentals not allowed to move to other devices

    I am a new iPad and apple tv user.  So let me get this straight.  I rent a movie from my pc, I can move it to my iPad or apple tv.  But if I rent it from my apple tv or my iPad I can not move or share it thru iCloud with any of my other devices.  Is this all true and is there a work around for it?
    Frank71hd

    iTunes Store: Viewing and downloading HD content on iPad - http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4095 > Movie Rentals on iPad >     *Movies rented on iPad cannot be transferred to other devices and can only be viewed on iPad.
    iTunes Store Movie Rental FAQ - http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1657

  • Why are Box and BoxLayout so awful?

    Box and BoxLayout would actually be useful if they weren't so poorly designed and implemented.
    1. Until JSE 1.4, Box was a subclass of Container instead of JComponent, which meant you couldn't put a border around it.
    2. Why does the constructor for BoxLayout need the container its managing as a parameter? The other layout classes don't.
    3. And the big problem with BoxLayout (and Box) is thay they often screw up the layout of their components, limiting their usefullness.
    It's as though Box and BoxLayout were an afterthought, and low priority on the list of things to fix.

    I've used it extensively since 1.3 without problems...

  • Why are all my movies and tv shows now on my ipad with the icloud icon?  How can i get rid of them?

    Why are all my movies and tv shows from my library now on my ipad with the icloud icon?  I have turned off all icloud related services. I have never used it.  On top of that, my ipad now gets stuck on step 5 of the sync - waiting for changes to be applied and never finishes.
    Help

    Hi, go in Settings, under Videos turn off "Show all videos"  this will remove the purchased videos to be displayed in the Video app.  The same can be done with the music.
    As for Step 5, connect you iPad and on the summary Tab, uncheck
    "Sync only checked songs and videos".  Then wait, it takes a while but this made it work for me after many restore attempts.
    good luck

  • HT201359 Why the ISTORE of Malta is not up to date with the latest movies and series like the UK & USA and why old movies are being uploaded .

    Why the ISTORE of Malta is not up to date with the latest movies and series like the UK & USA and why old movies are being uploaded .
    I believe the apple should be universal in all the products and a small island like Malts should have the same products for sale on ISTORE like of the UK and USA.

    The iTunes and App stores are inherently different in different countries.  Local laws on copyright and other limits on the distribution of intellectual property make it impossible for Apple to simply put everything in every store.  Sometimes, the owner of the intellectual property does not allow it to be distributed everywhere.  Keep in mind that Apple does not own the music, books, movies and such that they allow for sale in their store front, so they do not necessarily have any say in what may, or may not appear in what store.

  • Why are some of my movies not syncing while others are? All of my movies are in m4v form, and some of them sync but some of them don't.

    Why are some of my movies not syncing while others are? All of my movies are in m4v form, and some of them sync but some of them don't. Also, when i try to play my movies on my mac AND ipod, some of my movies just randomly freeze and wont let me continue watching. I dont understand why its doing this.

    iTunes: May be unable to transfer videos to iPhone, iPad, or iPod - http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1497

  • Why are my movies not showing on my Mac Book, which is the computer that I used to purchase the movie, but showing on my IMAC at home...I am currently deployed.

    why are my movies not showing on my Mac Book, which is the computer that I used to purchase the movie, but showing on my IMAC at home...I am currently deployed so this ***** a bit. Also how do I keep this incedent from happending in the future?

    No, this is not the case. I know where i purchased the movie and I also know movies cant be added to the cloud such as music, TV shows can.  The instance happened during the dowload. I think that depending which computer is up and running and the bandwith allocated on either network, which ever computer that finishes first is the one that gets the movie. Just a thought. So next time I will ensure my IMAC is not running. I think that fixes it.
    Thanks

  • Why are my movies not downloading? there is always coming error 9006 or it pretends that its loading but nothing is going...

    Why are my movies not downloading? there is always coming error 9006 or it pretends that its loading but nothing is going...

    wjdavis wrote:
    I can't remember exactly what I did. I do know that when I started it up, I couldn't find the Setup Assistant on the hard drive,
    No, once a user has been created, you can't run Setup Assistant  (without erasing and reinstalling).
    What do you recommend for fixing this?
    Here's what's happened: 
    When you first start up a Mac and create the first user account, OSX assigns it UID (User ID) #501.  The next one gets #502, etc.  Those UIDs (not the user name) are what control permission to files.
    You can see those numbers via System Prefs > Users & Groups;  click the padlock and enter your Admin password, then select an account and right-click it, and select Advanced Options.  Do not change anything on that window.
    So . . . assume your old iMac had a user 501 with the data you want; it's identified that way on the backups.
    When the Apple Store started up your new Mac, and created their account, it became #501.
    When you used Migration Assistant to transfer the 501 account from the iMac's backups, OSX copied everything there "as is" except it had to change the 501 to 502. 
    The new 502 account has all the right permissions to things now in it's home folder, but the backups belong to user 501.
    Have you added much to the Mac since you did the migration?  Have you done any new backups?  If not, while it's a bit of a hassle, one fix would be to create yet another user account temporarily.  Make it an Admin account.  Log on to it and delete all the other accounts.  Then migrate the accounts from your backups; this time there won't be a conflict, so OSX won't have to change the UUID(s).
    But if you have done new backups, this won't work, since Migration Assistant automatically uses the most recent backup.  There's a way around that, but it's a bit (or more) tedious.
    Clear as mud? 

  • Why are the songs in my iphone playlists grey and I can't move them.

    Why are the songs in my iPhone playlists grayed out.  I am unable to move and organize them.  I just downloaded some audio books from Audible and I cannot moved them to a playlist on my iPhone either.  What step am I missing?

    margielm2 wrote:
    So, if I haven't made any albums, I can't move pictures in the main window of the Organizer?
    Yes, you can't. The default order in the main window is based on date, ascending or descending when you are in the standard 'thumbnail view'. If you are in 'folder' view, with your folders shown in the left panel, you are shown the pictures in alphabetical order of the file names.
    I haven't created albums yet.
    I have so many pictures. I wanted to put all the pictures for each album next to each other so I can find them easily.
    It's not difficult to create albums and 'drag' pictures in it. When an album is selected, you can move your pictures around in any order in the main window panel.
    Albums are one way of grouping and ordering pictures. You should try to use keywords to organize and retrieve your pictures.

  • Why are the movie and television icons missing from my Apple TV menu?

    Why are the movie and television icons missing from my Apple TV menu?

    likely because it does not have a working connection to the internet
    check the settings and maybe reenter the wifi pasword

  • Why are rentable movies not Dolby Digital?

    Can somebody tell me why most movies rentable via AppleTV do not have surround sound?  I'm not talking about the technical capability of an AppleTV, I know it can handle it as occasionally some movies and TV shows have it.  But most do not.  I personally will not rent any movies without it as quality sound is a huge part of a good movie. Does anybody know the reason for this?

    I'm pretty sure that every movie that gets released in a movie theater is going to be in surround sound. If not DD, than one of the other formats.  It's not exactly high tech to produce a movie with surround anymore (although the quality of the effects may not always be great)  I think the question is why Apple is not carrying the surround encoding over.
    I definitely have seen issues where movies on ATV are lableled as having DD but don't output as such.  That is a long running problem and I have fixes for that. 

Maybe you are looking for

  • IPhone 4 not connecting to any computer, Mac OS or Windows, or iTunes after ios 7 update

    Hello Apple community,   I desparately need help connecting my iphone 4 to iTunes so I can restore my previous iPhone4 backup that is on my windows laptop computer.  It used to connect perfectly to my windows 7 laptop with iTunes, but after ios 7 (an

  • Using Wireless in Windows 7 on Macbook White

    Hi, I recently purchased a Macbook white and have both Mac OS 10.6.2 and Window 7 installed using Bootcamp. However after setting up everything in the Windows 7, including drivers from the Mac OS installation disc; the network adapter (Broadcom 43xx)

  • My inported videos only has sound and no picture!!!!

    Hi I installed CS5 and when I import video files (avi) it only gives me the sound and no picture. Is this a codec issue and how do I set up my codec's in Affter Effects??? Cheers

  • User Details iView - show an image as property

    Hi, I would like to add an image to the user details iView showing the gender of the person (e.g. male = blue icon, female = red icon). So the shown image must be depending on the users gender. Do you know if this is possible? Is it only a "simple" L

  • Using DW CS6 and PS CS6 "file info" causes crash+freeze

    Each time I try to use "File Info" in Photoshop or Dreamweaver CS6, a freeze, or crash is the result, and must force quit. Can't seem to find any specifics using keyword search of similar problem. The only thing I've done different lately is I've had