Why can't PS be more like LR ?

I somehow had the impression that one could use PS CS5/6 in much the same way as Lightroom, in respect of 'continuous editing'.
In LR, if I close and restart, my situation is exactly as if I had stayed continuously open. I can backtrack, do whatever I could have done if I had not closed down (and even rebooted). The basic situation in LR is that one is always looking at the same photo with all the editing steps applied, but all the steps undo-able.
I thought that if I saved in PS as a PSD file, it would be the same, but of course, it is not.
Is there a mode for operating and saving files in PS in similare or same way as LR ?
If not, why on earth not ? LR is on version 4.3, so, although PS is a more mature product, there has been plenty of time for this desirable operation to be integrated.
I have been doing some work with PS which I really would like to have been able to go back on, but I now have the choice of staying with what I have got or going back to the original LR export and starting again. I also thought that using smart objects would do the trick, but first it limits what one can do and second only the layers seem to be saved and not the history.
Mind you, as I am not a PS or LR geek, I am probably missing something which is staring me in the face....

Hmm, thanks for the links, C.P. I would have been more surprised if I had been the first to think this would be desirable.
We can all have our view as to desirability, but the option to click a box or two in preferences would seem to satisfy both worlds? As to massive waste of resources... I dont think storing history would require much at all. Masks are stored as just a value of 0 or 1 for each pixel in the mask and thus not 24/48 bits per pixel like layers and transient images. But brush strokes are another problem, they would need 8 bits per pixel, still not a lot in modern storage availability.
(I have 24GB memory, 12-core i7 and about 3 TB of disk space -- so I have a different view of memory and such, so I would tick the boxes in preferences.)
With smart objects, or with 16bit/px images, some things are greyed-out as not available. Surely, an intermediate ground could be found, so that if one has the history storage facility turned on some features would not be available?
There are a lot of features in PS that I do not want to use and cannot imagine the use people put them to, but I don't feel they should be removed just because I dont like them.
What I DO find is that I might spend a long time working on something and I decide that the latest things I did are not to my liking. If I have not stepped out of PS, I am ok, but otherwise, I have lost it, and it is back to the beginning. I do not belong to the linear, organized, part of mankind, hence my question and preference.
I find JJM's contribution helpful, so obviously a good idea, and one I may well adopt.

Similar Messages

  • Why can´t i have more than one initiator task on my bpm process

    Hi All.
    I am working with BPM 11g and would like to know:
    Why can´t i have more than one initiator task on my bpm process
    In this case, i will have two separeted process where each has its initiator task?
    Regards,
    Diovani

    Hi Diovani
    Two different processes can have different task initiators...task initiator means creation of a process instance which can happen only once

  • Why can't I get more than 80min. of AAC on a CD

    My iTUNES library 2237 songs, 6.4 days, 9.62GB...Playlists of 1.3 hrs. or longer, (74.0 MB) when burned with blank TDK/CD-R 52X 80min. 700MB can't be burned on 1 CD I am told by iTUNES two CD's will be needed...Reduced down to less than 1.3 hrs. it's all burned on 1 CD when I look at the burned CD surface it looks like only about 1/10th. has been used...All the music is AAC from imported CD's and converted files from Audacity 1.2.4b it all plays in iTUNES and every burned CD plays fine.....Why can't I get more than 80min. of AAC music on 1 CD...THANKS in advance
    17" G5   Mac OS X (10.4.4)  
    17" G5   Mac OS X (10.4.4)  

    Yes Chris that is the right...should I change it to MP3 CD?...I get it now 80min. is all the Audio that will fit if it were data more would fit.... THANKS
    17" G5   Mac OS X (10.4.4)  
    17" G5   Mac OS X (10.4.4)  
    17" G5   Mac OS X (10.4.4)  

  • Why can't you download apps(like Flixster) to the Apple TV

    Why can't you download apps(like Flixster) to the Apple TV

    Apple tend to provide regular updates with access to more content, they have added PBS and Yahoo in the last few days.
    Nobody here will have any information about future updates since the community is only made up of users like you or I. Anything else is mere speculation and speculation is not permitted here under the Terms of Use for these communities.
    Any responses you may receive may well be removed and would be wholly unreliable in any case.
    If you believe that Apple's product may be enhanced in anyway you can leave feedback here.

  • Why can't TextEdit open more than 5 links at a time in Yosemite?

    Why can't TextEdit open more than 5 links at a time in Yosemite? In the previous OS, I could highlight many links at a time, right click and then select "Open URL" to open the links in Safari. Now, if I select more than five links at a time (and sometimes with five links) it will only open the first five and TextEdit pops up with the alert, "The 'Open URL' service could not be used."
    I'm running 10.10.1 on a MacBook Pro (13-inch, Mid 2009), 2.53 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, 4 GB 1067 MHz DDR3, 500 GB HD.
    TextEdit is Version 1.10 (319).

    Send Apple feedback. They won't answer, but at least will know there is a problem. If enough people send feedback, it may get the problem solved sooner.
    Feedback

  • Why can't I iMessage more than 9 people at a time?

    Why can't I iMessage more than 9 people at a time?

    Group settings for iMessage is restricted to 10, I believe. Check the User Guide here http://manuals.info.apple.com/en_US/iphone_user_guide.pdf

  • Iphone6 why can't I save more than one contact?

    iphone 6 why can't i save more than one contact?

    Hi Diovani
    Two different processes can have different task initiators...task initiator means creation of a process instance which can happen only once

  • Why can't I minimize more than 2 notepads in FF? I used to be able to minimize as many notepads as I wanted. FF must have done an update & now I can't do that anymore. Is there a setting I can change that will enable me to do that?

    # Question
    Why can't I minimize more than 2 notepads in FF? I used to be able to minimize as many notepads as I wanted. When I do research on a topic I keep many notepads open until I am finished. FF must have done an update & now I can't do that anymore. Is there a setting I can change that will enable me to do that again?
    Also at that time, the length of sentence I am typing changed.
    It doesn't seem to have any limit to how far it can extend to the right.
    Please help. I am not very techy & don't understand Computerese.
    Please explain in everyday English.
    Thanks in advance,
    posy

    Hi Prabhuti,
    Thank you so much for all your suggestions & helpful links to get help. I am not very computer literate. I have taken many classes over the years I've had a computer but I am still only a beginner.
    I want to tell you that I found a solution to my problem. I finally realized that maybe FF was not the problem but Wind. 7 on my new comp. I went on the 7 Forums & found another person who had the same problem & the answer was simple all I had to do was to right click on the Notepad icon & it would bring up a new Notepad & I could open & minimize as many as I want. I had moved the Notepad icon to my taskbar from the Start menu when I got my new computer.
    I have one more question for you. The notepad 2 program was mentioned there along with several others. I think it was about that prog. that someone said that it could open many notepads & when you closed the comp. the notepads would not disappear. Do you know if it was that program? Also is it possible to use that program the same way as I used the original Notepad? There are so many technical options on that program that I didn't understand. All I want to do is open the Notepad & copy & paste my notes in it & minimize them. Not losing them if I shut down the comp. would be real benefit to me. I believe that is the same prog. you recommended to me. Since you seem to understand tech things I thought maybe you could tell me if that is possible?
    Thank you so much for all your help.
    posy

  • I got a $15 iTunes card and my receipt says I only spent $10.25. Why can't I buy more song?

    I got a $15 iTunes card and my receipt says I only spent $10.25. Why can't I buy more songs?

    No idea.
    What happens when you try?
    Do you have enough to cover the taxes?

  • Why can't I download more than 50mb in iPhone ??

    Why can't I download more than 50mb in iPhone ??

    Deggie is correct. The carriers originally wanted it so people wouldnt be downloading large files on their networks and causing congestion. Also look at is from a carrier perspective for protecting costumers. People could also complain if they went over their data plan that they should have received a warning about downloading large files. Rather than argue about updating/downloading apps, they have the warning now.
    I am hoping down the road that carriers converse with Apple to lift those, we will see what happens. Rodgers has more influence on lifting that limit that normal costumers would.

  • Why can't I have more than one iTunes linked t my iPod

    I have Macs for years, all sorts, I currently actively use, iMac g417,iMac g5 20, iMac intel 24. G4 Mac Mini,Intel Mac Mini, G5 tower, G4 Tower, powerbook g4 and mac book. Yes I know but I work from home with Mac all day...
    I have thousands of songs, all legal, I'm old and have huge CD collection.. I have them spread around the Macs.
    I want to add different playlist from different iTunes to my iPod, just want to drag and drop. Don't care about iTunes store, my CD, my Macs, My iTunes, My Ipod, Not pirating any thing here, WHY CAN I NOT SIMLY DO THIS. I'm forced to go with another player that does not have these retrictions

    Hi Dean, I have no problems using my iPod simultaneously with my notebook and desktop (iBook G4 & iMac G5). All you need to do is un-check the "sync" iPod with iTunes box, or check manually manage music... whatever it is. As long as you are manually managing everything, it should not give you any problems. You can drag and drop to your heart's content! A few notes: MP3 CD's... are amazing, because you don't actually have to import them to your computer, you can just drag and drop the tunes onto your iPod. It might be to your advantage to back up your music libraries on MP3 CD's, the initial process is slightly tedious, but well worth it because you can always create CD's in the future if necessary and free up GB of your hard drive (I'm sure you already thought of this though, you sound pretty savvy.) The ONLY problem I do encounter is sometimes the iTunes on my G5 will just close on me. The trick is to only MANAGE the music from the initial iTunes regardless of where you ADD music from... if that makes sense. Alright, good luck and if you have any questions or anything needs clarifying, just drop me a line (or reply or whatever) Good Luck!
    P.S. I am using the newest iPod Video 80GB, I don't know if that will make a difference or not, but both my sisters have different Nano's and they work the same way that mine does.

  • Satellite L855 - Why can't updates be more specific?

    Bios update for L855
    The only detail I can find is:
    *This Bios Update adds increased functionality to your system.*
    A more detailed explanation of this 'functionality' would be useful in deciding whether to update the bios, or should one update as matter of course and assume it wouldn't be offered if not useful?
    Reading other posts suggest it's something to do with Bluetooth, which although installed, I have never used.

    You are right but as far as I know only on Toshiba US page you can find detailed BIOS update with all necessary information.
    Anyway if there is no problem with your notebook BIOS update is not necessary. In worst case fan activity can be changed and you can be faced with more cooling fan activity that can be very annoying.
    Some people have reported about such issues in the past. So if there is no reason and you are happy with your notebook dont change anything.

  • Why can I not add more bookmarks anymore - Firefox v25.0.1

    I have many bookmarks but suddenly I can't add any more to favourites.
    Nothing happens at all when I click "bookmark this page" in the "bookmarks" drop down box
    Running Firefox v25.0.1
    Any ideas on a cure please ?

    Problems with bookmarks and history not working properly can be caused by a corrupted places.sqlite database file.
    You can check for problems with the places.sqlite database file in the Firefox profile folder.
    *http://kb.mozillazine.org/Bookmarks_history_and_toolbar_buttons_not_working_-_Firefox
    *https://support.mozilla.org/kb/Bookmarks+not+saved#w_fix-the-bookmarks-file

  • Why can't I send more than one picture at a time to anyone? THey do not go through!!!

    I am wondering why since the new update the photos I take and try to send out cannot be sent unless they are sent one by one. I like to take several pics and put in a message and send together bt they do not send. They come back message send failure. WHY?

    Michele Stapleton wrote:
    I think using Numbers is too complicated because what I want essentially is a text document I can alter.  I take the information they put into my form and repurpose it in a way I find more useful while performing the job. So, I want to be able to take their typed information and move it around. And add some more of my own.
    You may perfectly "their typed information and move it around" in Numbers which behave as the AppleWorks Draw environment.
    Here is the second page in the document which I posted before.
    As you may see, the standard Word Processor features are at work:
    Spell Checker
    Selection…
    I exported my AppleWorks documents in Numbers ones.
    And of course, with the Numbers document open, you may copy pieces of it and paste them in Pages's pages.
    Yvan KOENIG (VALLAURIS, France) jeudi 16 juin 2011 16:44:30
    iMac 21”5, i7, 2.8 GHz, 4 Gbytes, 1 Tbytes, mac OS X 10.6.7
    Please : Search for questions similar to your own before submitting them to the community
    To be the AW6 successor, iWork MUST integrate a TRUE DB, not a list organizer !

  • Why can't I type more than one space in a split-view in DW

    Say, I am an a split view in a Dreamweaver CS5 and I'm typing in the right view (whatever it's called), but for some reason I can't type more than a single space there. Can I disable that?

    Thank you, Curtis. One thing that needs to be added to your post is that one has to restart DW for this setting to take effect. (Well, that may be a bug.) But it still doesn't fix the issue (read below.)
    As for the other two comments, I hate when people try to pigeonhole something without even trying to understand someone's situation. Did I say that I would be using it for a layout?
    Here's why I need it. Say, I'm working on typing a paragraph of text. My preference is to have DW in a split-view, with the HTML being displayed on the left and the "result" view on the right. That view on the right allows me to type in text directly into the page w/o worrying about HTML semantics -- very handy feature, except one little detail. Say, I have the following snippet of text, "This is some sample text" and I want to edit out the word "some" with the phrase "very important". So I highlight the word "some" and begin typing. Everything goes well when I finish typing "very", but as soon as I put a space to begin typing the word "important", something in DW makes the resulting phrase to look like this: "This is very importantsample text" Notice that the space after "important" was removed. You see, I'm not used to adding spaces after each of my edits (and that is how 99% of word processors work in the world) so my documents started to miss spaces and it took me awhile to figure out why. I was truly hoping that Curtis' suggestion would fix the issue, but even though I can add more than a single space, DW still removes spaces for me automatically, like I just explained above.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Verizon Mms support for Google voice

    Google voice now supports mms, albeit not in the most graceful fashion.  I ported my number to Google voice as I was a user previously when I was a Sprint customer.  Sprint had native Google voice integration and it is great!  I was simply fed up wit

  • Can't Capture Clip SD Card Reader

    I shot interviews with a JVC GY-HM100U at 1280 x 720, 30P HQ. I am trying to transfer the clips to FCP 7 on a MacBook Pro (to an external drive )from a SanDisk 32 GB GB 30 MB/s SDHC Class 10 Card. I'm using a GGI Gear card reader. I'm clicking and dr

  • Scroll bar in table control without wizard

    Dear All, I have made a module pool program for gate pass. In which i have taken a TABLE CONTROL WITHOUT WIZARD. Now my problem is , the table control does not have the SCROLL BAR  functionality. It is not showing the scroll bar also. So can any one

  • Purchasing new iMac 27

    does iPhoto come with this??

  • 12545 error -- brconnect and cluster

    When i try to configure some action on db13, sometimes gives me 12545 error. The cause of it, may be the cluster on the machine. THere is some tips to do? thanks