Why does Apple prevent ipad from accessing Extreme hard drives?

I have a very simple requirement. I want to access my pictures from my NAS (Extreme with external HD). While OSX can do this, Apple has prevented iOS from doing this pedestrian feat. It is very frustrating and 'feels' like it was done to merely propogate Hard drive consumption by copying videos everywhere. If Apple has to hang on this approach for their upgrade strategy, it is extremely weak. The ipads/etc. don't have enough storage to even begin to support the video storage requirements and backing up to iCloud to have a latent solution is even more weak. Even if I could get a 1TB I wouldn't do it as I don't want to stream HD videos that could be placed locally.
So Apple. Why? And btw, if you don't have a good reason, just think about all those enterprises, etc. that want server file access.
Sincerely,
Very irritated Customer.

You are not addressing Apple here. This is a user-to-user technical support forum. If you wish to provide feedback to Apple go here:
http://www.apple.com/feedback

Similar Messages

What does Apple HW Test really test about hard drive?

My 2002 FP iMac was recently jolted. The internal hard drive is no longer recognized. Here is what I know:
When I boot with the Apple Hardware Test CD which came with the computer, it does not recognize anything wrong with the hard drive.
When I boot from an external hard drive, I get a dialog with buttons to Initialize, Ignore, or Eject the hard drive.
When I open Disk Utility (external HD boot), it can see the disk, but says it is unformatted.
I also downloaded a trial data recovery program and it could not find anything identifiable on the hard drive.
I don't really know what the Apple Hardware Test program tests with the hard drive, so I don't know how to interpret the information I have.
My questions:
Is there any hope for salvaging anything from the hard drive? (Probably not?)
Is the drive itself likely to be OK if I format and re-install my OS? (Is that what the HW Test is telling me?)
I have not tried to format the drive, because there are a few things I would really like to salvage. I have also not opened it up to examine anything on the inside because I would not know what to look for.
Suggestions for how to proceed will be welcome.

The data on the ill-fated hard drive may be recoverable; could be
there has been damage to the drive or the software on it that lets
the computer read files from the drive.
Some disk utilities such as Disk Warrior could see about trying to
fix the drive; although if physical damages exist, it can't fix that.
The booted OS X Installer's Disk Utility has options in the Installer
menu bar (drop down menu to select other things, when not just
reinstalling) and you could see if OS X's Disk Utility from the booted
Installer disc could give you a status report on the drive in Verify, &
also see what it says about 'Repair drive' when chosen to try a fix.
Sometimes, the OS X's Disk Utility can't fix something, and at that
point, other utilities (retail on DVD) may be able to. Then, the tossup
is, whether or not you want to pay for the utility to fix an old drive, or
put the money into a new one.
Data Recovery software is available as download, so if the old hard
disk drive were removed from the computer and a new drive put in,
later on the failed drive could be investigated through use of software
(such as those which can recover, then you pay to unlock results)
and that is another way to consider addressing the old drive contents.
Some would suggest, if you had Disk Warrior or some other disk utility
that could fix the old drive good enough to try and get data off it, maybe
even a full clone or just the files you need, then you would not need to
get the data recovery software. Of course, that software which runs to
see if you have recoverable files, can do that part for free.
The AHT may see the drive is present, while not recognizing a
failure in its firmware or in its directory, etc. Some kinds of disk
utilities can try to rebuild and replace a damaged directory or
other bits of software on the drive so it can be read again.
Usually, the test for the hard disk drive is Disk Utility on the
OS X Installer; and that gives you the boot version that sees
even a healthy drive as an unmounted and repairable volume
when it is correct and not beyond the limited ability of the utility.
Hopefully something practical comes from all these words...
Good luck & happy computing!

Why does installation cd not work for new hard drive for 2009 MacBook pro?

my hard drive died in my 2009 MacBook pro so I bought a 1tb ssd drive and had the store physically install the drive only. I arrived home and stuck in the original installation disc and pressed and held the c key after the chime. Nothing happened. after a minute or so the screen turned black and rebooted up again with the chime. It would continue to reboot whether I pressed the c key or not. when i pressed the d key it would say:
"Apple hardware test does not support this machine"
why why isn't this working like it is supposed to?
thsnks

Ryan,
Have you tried using the Startup Manager (holding down the option key) whilst booting? If everything works as it should, you should be given the option to choose the DVD to boot. Holding down the 'D' key should load the Apple Hardware Test.
Good luck,
Clinton
MacBook Pro (15” Late 2011), OS X 10.??, 16GB Crucial RAM, 960GB M500 Crucial SSD, 27” Apple Thunderbolt Display

Why can I not boot from my new hard drive?

After replacing my hard drive (40 Gb) with a larger (120 Gb) drive the computer will not boot. I can boot from the 10.4 system CD and have managed to install the system without problems, but after restarting the computer I only get to see a folder with a flashing question mark in it.
My computer is the first of the Titanium series (400 Mhz). The hard drive is a Seagate momentus 5400 rpm. Is there a compatibility issue here? Any input would be greatly appreciated!
PowerBook G4/400 Titanium Mac OS X (10.4)

Hi, StenErik. If I were you, I would forget about FireWire Target Disk Mode. I'd start the Powerbook from a retail OS X 10.4 installer DVD, open Disk Utility from the Utilities menu, select the hard drive, reformat it as "Mac OS Extended (Journaled)", check the box for installing OS 9 drivers, and then install Tiger. I can't explain why this should make the resulting installation any different from what you have installed now. But it seems to me there must be some detail you've failed to mention and we've failed to think of, and that detail, whatever it is, is much more significant than it seems: significant enough to prevent your Tibook from booting. Therefore, reverting to the most basic installation procedure possible, with as few external variables as possible, seems a useful thing to try. To minimize variables even further, disconnect all peripherals from the PB while reformatting and installing.
As Hardy has suggested, the size of your drive is not the issue. A 120GB drive should be fine.

Does apple needs to make a external hard drive?

me personally. i think if apple would make a external hard drive or make the ipad/iphone/ipod compatible with a third party hard drive i wouldnt have a need for a computer the apple system would be a all in one. Im going to get a ipad 2 but was interested to see if any one else was interested in this. thank you

I don't quite understand the original post. The iPad already has internal storage, using flash memory. What do you believe you need the hard drive for? As the other poster pointed out, the hard drive is not what you initialize the iPad with - you still need an actual computer. Some kind of external drive wouldn't help you.
Matt

Why can i only 'read' from some portable hard drives

I'm having trouble with some portable hard drives. I can only read them and not copy to. Why is this, and can i change this?

Keller is right - you probably have an NTFS drive - if it is yours, and you don't need to share it with folks with Windows machines, reformat it for HFS+. If you need to share it, and don't have files larger than 2gb, format it for FAT32. If you need to share it and need to move large files (larger than 2gb) then you'll have to figure something out with NTFS 3G or some other fix.

What is default(1).aspx and why is it preventing me from accessing hotmail account?

After I enter my username and password at hotmail.com sign in, I recieve a message saying 'default(1).aspx is missing and it tries to download. Then an error saying it cannot read file. Sometimes I can access mail but mostly not.

Hi,
If you add other accounts to the Messages app after activating the iMessages account then by default (if you don't name them in the Description box) that take the name of the Service they join up to the point you have a second AIM valid Name or a second Jabber valid Name.
In My List my accounts are Named in the Description Box
AIM is Aol Instant Messenger so the Add Screen Shows AOL. You will see in the right hand pane under Account Info it says it is AIM.
You will see in the list several others are also AIM Valid accounts.
If you don't Name them yourself then the account info is used (like the iMessages one) when you have two or more for that service.
Google and Facebook run Jabber servers.
They are unlikely to work with a Hotmail ID (which is MSN and not Native to the Messages app).
You seem to have Added an Account as Google and tried to use a Hotmail ID
As the Google Servers only allow IDs that end @Googlemail.com or @gmail.com it will not work and you will be "Off Line".
The ID is "accepted" when you type it in as it conforms to an email Address.
Japib has their Facebook account called chat.facebook.com which happens to be the server name and that it how it appears in the list on the left in their Pic. It will also be in the Window Menu like that.
See also an older iChat version when you could only login one account type of each
http://www.ralphjohns.co.uk/iChatPicsFolder/2%20iChat%20menus/slides/8_iChat_Men u_Window.html
There were only AIM and Jabber back then.
9:18 pm Tuesday; December 30, 2014
 iMac 2.5Ghz i5 2011 (Mavericks 10.9)
 G4/1GhzDual MDD (Leopard 10.5.8)
 MacBookPro 2Gb (Snow Leopard 10.6.8)
 Mac OS X (10.6.8),
 Couple of iPhones and an iPad

HT204057 Why does Time Machine no longer support external hard drives connected to an Airport Extreme base station?

I'm pretty sure that upto a few months ago I had a hard disk connected via USB to my Airport Extreme and I was able to backup all the computers on my home network. However, somehow over the last few months this had stopped happening. I am not able to select my network disks for time machine backup.
There is a very unhelpful sentence on Apple's website which simply says it does not allow backup to hard disks connected to Airport Extreme via USB. Does anyone know why this is? Is there a way around this? Can I connect a drive to my desktop computer and have other computers backup through the network to that?

This was never an approved configuration: OS X Mountain Lion: Disks you can use with Time Machine
Can I connect a drive to my desktop computer and have other computers backup through the network to that?
The above KB article indicates you can, though I have not personally tried it.

Why does my MacBook Pro not find USB hard drive after waking from sleep?

is this a known issue? i have to manually turn off/on the Mac's Airport to re-establish USB HD connection (or Time Machine won't find it either).

bender73 wrote:
is this a known issue? i have to manually turn off/on the Mac's Airport to re-establish USB HD connection (or Time Machine won't find it either).
I hate to have to tell you this, but backing-up that way is "iffy" and *+not supported by Apple.+* See [Using Time Machine with an Airport Extreme Air Disk|http://web.me.com/pondini/Time_Machine/Airport.html] (or use the link in *User Tips* at the top of this forum).
It sounds like you're using that disk for other things besides your backups; if so, and if you're going to continue backing-up that way, it really should be partitioned so Time Machine has it's own, exclusive space. See #Q1 in the same link.
Time Machine should find it's partition when OSX wakes up; if it doesn't, try a "full reset" of Time Machine, per #A4 in [Time Machine - Troubleshooting|http://web.me.com/pondini/Time_Machine/Troubleshooting.html] (or use the link in *User Tips* at the top of the +Time Machine+ forum).

Why does my mac dont recognize the external hard drive

i log the external HD, the lights on the Hd are going on (means electricity goes) but i cant see the thing inside the HD
thank you som much for the help

There's a program in your Application's Utility folder called Disk Utility. Run it and see if the program sees the drive. If so, attempt to mount it. (There's a mount option in the toolbar.) The drive might need to be repaired. (The repair button is at the bottom right of the program window.)
If Disk Utility doesn't see the drive try another cable...and it is possible that even though the lights come on showing the enclosure has electicity, that the drive or electronics in the enclosure are dead.

Why does opening Safari wake up my sleeping hard drives?

I have the newest of the new, best of the best i7 imac which came with Lion already on it.
I'll be editing in Final Cut Pro X(sigh) and I'll go to Safari to check my email or whatever but whenever I open Safari it wakes up my sleeping hard drives which in turn freeze Safari and Safari doesn't unfreeze until the hard drives are all the way awake?
WHAT THE???

I have it partitioned into 3 volumes - 1 is Time Machine, 1 is completely empty and 1 has a backup of the main drive (cloned using SuperDuper) that gets backed up only once a week.

How does one down load pictures from a PC hard drive to an itouch 4th gen.

How does one download pictures from a PC hard drive to a 4th generation itouch ?

By following the instructions here:
iPhone, iPad and iPod touch: Syncing photos via iTunes

How do i watch movies from an external hard drive on my macbook and iPad?

how can i watch movies on my macbook and ipad from an external hard drive?

Import it into an iTunes library and then sync the iPod with that library. If desired, create a new library on that drive by launching iTunes with the Shift(Windows) or Option(Mac OS X) key held down.
(81946)

Why does Apple iPad Camera Connection Kit no longer work with iOS8

Why does Apple iPad Camera Connection Kit no longer work with iOS8?

The kit is firmly inserted in thhe iPad's dock ? You could also try a reset and see if it's recognised after the iPad has restarted : press and hold both the sleep and home buttons for about 10 to 15 seconds (ignore the red slider), after which the Apple logo should appear - you won't lose any content, it's the iPad equivalent of a reboot.
I haven't had problems using the kit with SD cards from Canon cameras . What capacity is the card, and it's an SD or SDHC card - if it's an SDXC card that's formatted as ExFAT then it won't be recognised

Why does an email sent from an iPad or iPhone to ms outlook appear with attachments? Example signatures tend to be broken down into a series of unwanted attachments!

Why does an email sent from an iPad or iPhone to ms outlook appear with attachments? Example: signatures at the bottom of the mail tend to be broken down into a series of unwanted attachments!

It worked for me. I took a picture with the iPhone's camera. Then opened the Photos app and selected the picture, and emailed it from one of my IMAP accounts to my gmail (also IMAP) account. When it showed up in the gmail inbox (on my iPhone), I forwarded it to my yahoo mail account (choosing the "inlcude attachments" option). When that showed up on my iPhone's yahoo inbox, the picture was there just as it should be.
So I guess the next thing would be to try it with non-iPhone pictures to see if it is a problem with image size or something. I have some 6-megapixel images in iPhoto I can try (taken as RAW/DEC format pictures with my dSLR).
Just tried it sending a Photo from my computer's iPhoto library - picture is 728KB, 2272x1704 jpeg. I emailed it to my gmail account, and it showed up on the iPhone just fine. Then I forwarded that to my yahoo account and again, it showed up just fine on both the iPhone and reading my yahoo mail via the web page.
Don't know what to say - I don't mean this to be just another "works for me" post. I was hoping to see something maybe depending on the size and origin of the picture.
By the way, my 3GS shipped with 3.0.1 on it, and I've updated it via iTunes normally to 3.1.1 and currently 3.1.2. Sorry I don't have anything constructive to add.

Why does Apple prevent ipad from accessing Extreme hard drives?

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for