Why does De-interlacing looks better with MPEG StreamClip?

For our client we need to render 1080i for TV and 1080p for WEB. After creating graphics in AE we add final touch and audio in PR.
If we make it progressive in PR (CC2014.1) the zoom in the packshot does not look good.
However if we make the 1080i ProRes progressive in MPEG Streamclip the zoom does look great.
How is it possible a freeware swiss army-knife makes a better progressive export than commercial software?
Or is there something we do wrong?
Herewith links to the ProRes material:
1 1080i rendered from AE: http://gvs.ftpaccess.cc/_q8w_U9SXYWR6tR
2 1080p rendered from AE: http://gvs.ftpaccess.cc/_WSw7A_kh-W66sR
3 1080p rendered with PR: http://gvs.ftpaccess.cc/_dAxuZAvbVWP6AR
4 1080p rendered with MPEG StreamClip: http://gvs.ftpaccess.cc/_nQwqP-HqMWz6FR
Please do not use this material elsewhere except for testing purposes.
Thank you in advance!
Ivery Barel
Gooi & Vecht Studio - Netherlands
OSX 10.9.5. Mavericks

ok
just to illustrate the problem a little better, here's the actual difference
this is what I have in Lightroom after editing:
and here's what I get after exporting

Similar Messages

Why does my 24fps look bad on my TV?

I just got the Panasonic AG-HMC150. I have shot some footage at both 1080p24 and 720p24. I transcode the files to Pro Res in FCP and they look pretty good, I realize the panning isn't as smooth as 60i. I drag one of the files into the FCP timeline and let it automatically "optimize my settings" for the sequence. I have verified that it is 23.98fps and field dominance is none. I have tried selecting "share" and going straight to AVCHD from FCP, and also taking the original MTS file, and Apple Pro Res and dropping into Toast and trying that way. The footage just looks choppy, jiddery and unsmooth. I have seen enough movies in my life to know that when they pan, or have cars drive by, that movies 24fps looks a million times better. My Sony HDTV even accepts and displays 24fps, and when I press info on the TV remote when watching one of these AVCHD discs it in fact says 1080 (or 720) 24p. It just looks bad. Even taking the HDMI output from the camera and hooking up to the TV and playing from the camera looks lousy.
What am I doing wrong? I know a ton of post work goes into Hollywood movies, but why does their 24fps look nice and smooth and mine looks horrible? Do I need to render with pulldown in FCP or something. I can't figure it out. Any advice, suggestions?

I transcode through FCP to apple pro res, the files shows up as 1920x1080 24fps. Field dominance is none. I edit the video and then export as quicktime movie using current settings. The Pro Res file says 23.98 when played in quicktime so I know that's good. I simply then drop the file into Toast (10.0.4) and burn blu-ray disc, selecting DVD as the media. I noticed too I need to change the field dominance under the encoding tab in Toast to progressive, as automatic doesn't work. It only burns the top half of the image. Regardless, when I make these discs and play them on PS3, my TV's info says 1080/24p. Maybe my eyes aren't use to seeing 24fps. Does it sound like I am doing anything wrong in my workflow/encoding process.
Again, good tip on the shutter speed Jerry.

Why does Illustrator CS4 save pdfs with clipping paths and make rasters of gradient areas

I am on a IMAC and upgraded to 10.6.8 Jan 2014. I am using CS4 Illustrator to create with. When i save my work as a pdf then reopen the pdf in Ill to make changes, the whole page has:
A.) Multiple clipping paths around it
B.) Most text has now become outlined. Not editable anymore.
C.) Gradient areas have multiple clipping paths of the single gradient area
D.) The gradient areas now become rasterized.
This is very frustrating as now all of my marketing files, some 300+, are worthless. I don't know where to look anymore to find the problem.
Please help.
Thank you very much

John,
I have the presets as you have shown. I had been editing the supplied items as you suggested. Then figured i should ask the questions of those who are better than I.
But still a bit confused as to why the new save places clipping paths around the document.
Thank you John and Monika for your help.
why does Illustrator CS4 save pdfs with clipping paths and make rasters of gradient areas
created by John Mensinger in Illustrator - View the full discussion
I do a save as "pdf" in the format pull down tab. I save to a folder on the hard drive. Where is the "Illustrator editability" check box? I presumed it is in Acrobat some where
but i seem to be lost.
It is in Illustrator's Save Adobe PDF dialog, which pops up before the saved file is written.
https://forums.adobe.com/servlet/JiveServlet/downloadImage/2-6439399-644928/450-397/Untitl ed-1.jpg
Sorry i didn't mention this, but this seems to have occurred when using images and text from provided pdfs.
That's a critical fact. If you didn't do the original save, the above is moot, and it's too late to exercise any control over the save process. Someone else failed to save for editability. The only thing you can do is clean up/repair the content, (release clipping masks, rebuild rasterized elements, expand objects, etc.), and save correctly as AI. Then, if necessary, re-save as PDF with the correct settings.
Please note that the Adobe Forums do not accept email attachments. If you want to embed a screen image in your message please visit the thread in the forum to embed the image at https://forums.adobe.com/message/6439399#6439399
Replies to this message go to everyone subscribed to this thread, not directly to the person who posted the message. To post a reply, either reply to this email or visit the message page:
To unsubscribe from this thread, please visit the message page at . In the Actions box on the right, click the Stop Email Notifications link.
Start a new discussion in Illustrator by email or at Adobe Community
For more information about maintaining your forum email notifications please go to http://forums.adobe.com/thread/416458?tstart=0.

Team Blog: Why does my page look different in BrowserLab?

Duane O'Brien, engineer on the BrowserLab team has a new blog post on the BrowserLab Team blog that you might find interesting. It covers when/why you might see rendering differences between the BrowserLab browsers and your local browsers. Good info.
http://blogs.adobe.com/browserlab/2011/07/11/why-does-my-page-look-different-in-browserlab /
Bruce
Bruce Bowman
BrowserLab product manager
BrowserLab Team Blog: http://blogs.adobe.com/browserlab
Twitter: @brucebowman, @adobebrowserlab

As Wyodor indicated IE is not the most advance, up-to-date browser out there.
See Roddy’s tips for making iWeb pages more compatible with IE.
OT

Why does tcodes of cit start with J

i have two questions
1. why does tcodes of CIN starts with J like J1id, J1is is there any specific reason?
2. secondly by mistake on our plant we had made a excise invoice in which we had a placesspayable of rs 17 lakhs which was actually not payable . accounts has rectified the entry by passing a JV. but how can excise in SAP can rectify this mistake.
while making Utilisation J2iun we getting this rs 17 lacs which is not payable. how can we rectify this problem thru SAP CIN.
how can we make a reversal entry of the cess part only. can we do it thru j2is or j2ih and how?
if anyone has a better answer pls suggest.
Edited by: ca sanjeev mehndiratta on Oct 10, 2010 5:28 PM
Edited by: ca sanjeev mehndiratta on Oct 11, 2010 6:07 PM

no result

Why does my MacBook come up with window saying "setting Up Mac" when I turn it on and enter my password and stays there and does not go any further

Why does my MacBook come up with window saying "setting Up Mac" when I turn it on and enter my password and stays there and does not go any further

You may want to put this question on the MacBook community forum to get a better response.
https://discussions.apple.com/community/notebooks/macbook

Why does my imessage not work with only 1 phone number

Why does my imessage not work with only 1 phone number? It keeps going to imessage and then back to text message

Both you and the recipient have to have active data connections, and both devices have to have iOS 5 or higher to be able to use iMessage. Also, they both have to have iMessage activated. If that is already the case, there is a possiblility that iMessage is down. It has gone up and down several times in the past week. Check this page for status, and if necessary you can report a problem with a link in the lower right corner. http://www.apple.com/support/icloud/systemstatus/

Why does flash player not work with facebook?

Why does flash player not work with fcebook? Whenever I wish to view a video, I get the message that i need to upgrade my flash player. Then no matter how often I download and install flash player I still get the message that I need to upgrade my flash player. When I go check which version I have, I always get the message that I have the most current one. I run Mozilla Firefox with Windows. I don't know anything else.
Message was edited by: khettich

This means you don't have the latest version installed. Update to 11.9.900.117, and Firefox will allow it: Flash Player Plug-in (All other browsers)

Why does Java Application not working with Macromedia Flash 5 or MX?

Why does Java Application not working with Macromedia Flash 5 or MX?

Who says they don't?
Although I don't know much about those I'd think they should be able to talk to Java Aps using Sockets or request Servlets ...
Spieler

Why does the videos looks so slow

why does the videos looks so slow only in the internet

Many reasons, like what format they are, for instance Flash Videos will be slower.
Any links to the slow ones?
Which exact Mac do you have?

Why does my iphone come up with a different email when updating apps?

why does my iphone come up with a different email when updating apps?
Everytime I go to update my apps some other persons email or AppleID comes up and I have to cancel. its annoying enough to have to update all the time but now I have about100 update notifications (don't judge, you probably have a ton of apps too..haha) that are sitting idol, what's up how do I fix?
thx
Jackie
p.s. not updating to iOS6 yet

I'm sorry Allan, I should have clarified, your answer is improbable (well the first part atleast).
The apps I have had since the first week of purchase of my iphone back in 2011, I have not added any apps until 2 months before the last software update. This starting happening when the new software was implemented but I have not updated to iOS6 yet. Unless this person was able to hack into my account & transfer them to their account, I do not see how that is possible.
Prior to seeing this other AppleID, I have a popup to prompt me for my AppleID each time I download content. Each time I would see mine and enter my password.

Why does my ipad air work with my netgear routerWGT624

why does my ipad air work with my netgear routerWGT 624

Why wouldn't it work with that router?
Or are you really asking why doesn't it work with that router? If that's your question try rebooting the router by powering it off for thirty seconds then turning it back on.
If this doesn't help please explain in more detail what happens when your iPad attempt to connect to your Wi-Fi network.

Why does my IPad not sync with my IPhone for Ibooks bookmarks?

Why does my IPad not sync with my IPhone for IBooks bookmarks? Both Pad and Phone have sync turned on.

I must apologize as I misread your post. I though that you were talking about Safari bookmarks but you post does clearly state iBooks bookmarks.
You may want to just try restarting both devices and see if that helps. One other thing that you could try is quit iBooks on both devices and then launch it again and see if the bookmarks are synced when you relaunch.

Why does a specific site open with Firefox 3.6 running under Windows 7 Ulimate but not under Windows 7 professional?

Why does a specific site open with Firefox 3.6 running under Windows 7 Ulimate but not under Windows 7 professional?
== URL of affected sites ==
http://www.bmw.co.uk

Why does a specific site open with Firefox 3.6 running under Windows 7 Ulimate but not under Windows 7 professional?
== URL of affected sites ==
http://www.bmw.co.uk

I m coming from linux platform ... now need my g to work with vim ... how to install g which supports C 0x ... why does not it has repository with apple ... its so easy rather than going to UI ...

i m coming from linux platform ... now need my g to work with vim ... how to install g which supports C 0x ... why does not it has repository with apple ... its so easy rather than going to UI ...

tom i have been using ubuntu for c++ project
i use lambda and atomic (c++0x) but now as I am working on MAC not able to use them
installed xcode(4.3) and changed compiler settings to LLVM3.1 but still both features are not available
to compile wanted to have g++ which supports c++0x features ...
new to MAC (2-3 days) so was in rush to solution
let me know if you have some suggestion ...
else will try with eclipse cdt ....

Why does De-interlacing looks better with MPEG StreamClip?

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for