Why has this Z depth expression not yet been made?

I recently had an issue where I needed to composite two objects from a 3d application together on separate layers..  But the objects interact in such a way where sometimes an object from layer A is in front, and sometimes the object from layer B is in front.....  But the layer order would give me a result where either A or B is in front the whole time depending which layer is on top in After effects.
(Yes I know in that example you could simply mask it, but in reality there were several objects all dealing with the issue named, and it would have been too complicated to do so.)
So in my search for the answer I found this tutorial...
http://www.digitaltutors.com/11/training.php?vid=22125&autoplay=1
This is a good answer if you're only dealing with two layers...  But it doesn't have an answer if you're dealing with any amount of layers more then two..... 
Soooo here's my question, why has nobody made a script, option, or button in After Effects yet that simply says "do you want to use the Z depth in your RPF/RLA file to determine where the objects should fit in the scene???"
I ask only because it seems like the most obvious thing to do.  If the 3-d application went through the trouble to create the option to have Z depth information, and even has file types that support having that information, then why wouldn't the compositing program have an option to use the information in the most obvious way?

I was just looking more into that!  And that seemed like an even better way to go.  But I noticed an interesting issue.  I'm rendering out of Maya 2012, and found that if I follow Autodesk's tutorial  it runs me into an issue...In that youtube tutorial where they explain render passes with the space ship, the instructor adds the various objects to different contribution maps, then the layer with the background he tells maya to make a "beauty pass"....Then in the attribute editor he edits the beauty pass node by clicking on the "hold attribute."  This masks out any area where the object is covered!! Great solution.... However this poses two problems for me...
1.That in the compositing program there exists about a one pixel area separating objects.... (This can be solved by duplicating the object, and adding a minmax effect to it, spreading the color out about one pixel, and setting that layer behind the original.  But that means you're going to double every layer once, and add an effect to it.  Not very efficient as far as render time goes...)....So if you have found a better way to solve this issue, I'm totally open to suggestions!
2.There's the issue that if I have a camera edit.....then I need to go back and re-render each image sequence... This could be ten different objects...  And since the parallax changes the shape and alpha, there's nothing that can be done about that.   But the real kicker is that if you used the contribution maps, you need to tell maya to batch render each contribution map individually one after the other, and name the image sequence correctly each time replacing your old image sequences....What a pain!!  It'd be so much easier if it were just like the render layers... Just check mark each one you want to re-render and click batch render, and then boom!  It re-renders each render layer correctly for you where the project is set, no need to re-name or anything... Far more organized.  So why don't I just do that instead of using contribution maps you ask?  Well that won't give me masked out renders becaus objects on separate render layers don't interact, so that "hold attribute" won't do me any good.
Since I'm new to this, I'm sure there's got to be an easier way to do this, or something that I've overlooked.  Let me know if you have any ideas, thanks!

Similar Messages

  • Feild assignment not yet been made

    Dear SD Gurus,
    Whenever i try to create an access sequence with standard table such as 004 and 005 and assign it to a access. I get following error in Yellow saying "<b>Feild assignment not yet been made</b>". I am trying to create a pricing for an item. Your help will be greatly appreciated. Thank you! in advance.
    Cheers
    Raji

    Hi,
    When you are trying to create new access sequence with standard condition tables you should follow the step wise procedure.
    1. Check the required condition tables available in T.Code V/04 ( Change)
    2. If required condition tables are not avaibale -ceate the table using T.code v/03(create)
    3. Go to access sequence ( v/07)
    4.give the naming for new access sequence
    5. add the table in access
    6. select the table entered in the access sequnce
    7. finally go to fields tab and check all the tables belongs to condition tables are available.
    then save it.
    regards,
    Naveen Duggineni

  • HT2589 when I try and log in my i-tunes account or my app store account on my i-phone it says "this apple I.D has not yet been used on the i-tunes store" it gives me 2 optins "cancel" or "review" I press review, enter my bank details but they decline..why

    Hi can anybody help or advise me? I've recently bought the i-phone 4s, I've set up my apple I.D and password but everytime I try and log in it says "this apple I.D has not yet been used on the i-tunes store" I click "review" follow the instructions and agree to the terms and condition's, enter my bank details but it declines every time? I've tried both my accounts and its declined both, this stops me from logging in so I can't download anything for free or buy anything, my sister had the option of skipping the bank details part when she created her apple I.D and just enters her's when buying something, why do I not have that option?? And why is it declining my bank details...please HELP!!!!!

    The details I'm entering are correct, I choose visa as my card type, enter my card number, enter my expiry date and my last 3 digts on the reverse of the card, enter my address and zip code plus my home telephone number, click continue and it says "the payment method you have selected has been declined, please enter another payment method". I've lost count how many times I've tried, I've typed my details in slowly making sure I put them in properlly and it still declines it, I've even tried makeing a new apple I.D and when I get to the bank details part it declines it again so I am forced to press cancel and all details are not saved so its just like I'm hitting a brick wall, its ******* me off!!! I can't even download any of the free app's because to do so you must log in but when I do it says "this apple I.D has not yet been used in the i-tunes store" review my details and can't get past the bank details part. So doesn't log me in, I'm honestly out of ideas

  • Why when i want to download a free app from app store it asks for my apple id and when i give my apple id it then says "this apple id has not yet been used in the itunes store". i dont even know what that means and it will this happen everytime?

    why when i want to download a free app from app store it asks for my apple id and when i give my apple id it then says "this apple id has not yet been used in the itunes store". i dont even know what that means and it will this happen everytime?

    If you are within 14 days of purchase you can still return the iPhone and get the phone that suits your needs, however, I think you will find that no matter which phone you get the content provider will want to know how you are going to pay for future purchases. For Android phones it is Google, and they will certainly want to know.
    To create an Apple account without a credit card see: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2534

  • Why when I go to my account by entering my Apple ID a dialog box  appears with inscription: "This Apple ID has not yet been used  with Itunes Store.Pleas review your account information."

    Why when I go to my account by entering my Apple ID a dialog box  appears with inscription: "This Apple ID has not yet been used  with Itunes Store.Please review your account information."?
    Почему когда я захожу в свой акккаунт в Itunes Store ? всплывает окно с надписью "This Apple ID has not yet been used with Itunes Store. Please review your account information"?

    I would be very grateful if you could help me as soon as all know ourselves))

  • HT5622 Why is there a message saying, "This Apple ID has not yet been used in the itunes store"

    Why is there a message saying that my apple id has not yet been used in the itunes store? i just registered

    Hi midanjm,
    This prompt is usually displayed when your Apple ID needs to be configured for purchases. We'll need to run through the additional steps to setup your country, and payment information. See Step 10 and above on this resource (For iPhone, iPad, or iPod touch):
    iTunes: How to set up an Apple ID within iTunes
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2731
    Tip: If you are trying to create an account using an existing Apple ID, like your iCloud email address, you will receive a prompt telling you that your email address is already an Apple ID. Simply tap Continue, and then tap Use Existing Account on the following screen.
    - Next, you'll be required to enter your billing information. To choose a different Credit Card type, tap one of the available options, and then tap Done. You will not be charged until you make a purchase.
    - Once you've filled out all of the fields for your billing information, tap Next.
    For additional information:
    Using an existing Apple ID with the iTunes Store and Mac App Store
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2589
    Thanks,
    Matt M.

  • When i am signing in on app store then it's showing: "this apple id has not yet been used in the iTunes store." why ?

    when i am signing in on app store then it's showing: "this apple id has not yet been used in the iTunes store." why ?

    Log into your account and verify that you have a valid payment metnod specified.

  • HT5622 why do I see the message "This apple ID has not yet been used in the itunes store"when I enter my password in app store or itunes??

    why do I see the message "This apple ID has not yet been used in the itunes store"when I enter my password in app store or itunes?

    Look at the options for payment methods.  Is there an option that says "None?"
    The short answer for this and for your next question is, "Read what the iPhone is telling you."

  • Why I cant use my apple id? error was this apple id has not yet been used in the iTunes store

    why I cant use my apple id? error was this apple id has not yet been used in the iTunes store

    Log into your account and verify that you have a valid payment method.

  • HT2204 why is it that i keep getting this message after signing in correctly-this apple id has not yet been used in the iTunes store

    Why cant i sign in to my itunes account,after setting up my apple id and password (which has been accepted ) all i get is a message saying -this apple id has not yet been used in the itunes store .
    How am i supposed to use it for the first time if it wont let me go any further,it just sends me back to create a apple id page!!!!!

    You haven't opened an account with that Apple ID in iTunes. Open iTunes and log in. A dialog will appear in which you need to enter your Apple ID and/or password. Below it you should see a link for creating a new account. Click on that link to get started.

  • I created an apple id and tried to authorize my computer but it says that this apple id has not yet been used with the itunes store, why?

    I created an apple id and tried to authorize my computer but it says that this apple id has not yet been used with the itunes store, why?

    FAQ apple id http://support.apple.com/kb/HT5622?viewlocale=en_US
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1311

  • Why my iphone 5 said'this Apple ID has not yet been used with the iTunes Store' when I signed in?

    why my iphone 5 said'this Apple ID has not yet been used with the iTunes Store' when I signed in?

    sameee hereee!! its driving me nuts

  • Why do I see "this Apple ID has not yet been used in iTunes Store when I try to download any apps?

    Why do I see message "this Apple ID has not yet been used in iTunes Store when I try to download some free apps? Please let me know how to resolve this

    Hey Maniopr,
    I would try out the information in the following article to sign in:
    Using an existing Apple ID with the iTunes Store, Mac App Store, and iBooks Store
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2589
    Welcome to Apple Support Communities!
    Cheers,
    Delgadoh

  • When i try to update OS it's showing this message why? This Apple ID has not yet been used with the App Store.

    when i try to update OS it's showing this message why? This Apple ID has not yet been used with the App Store.

    Hello Daijalove97,
    Thanks for using Apple Support Communities.
    For more information on this, take a look at:
    Using an existing Apple ID with the iTunes Store and Mac App Store
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2589
    To use your Apple ID at the iTunes Store
    Open the latest version of iTunes.
    Choose Store > Sign In from the Store menu.
    Enter your Apple ID and password, then click Sign In.
    Click Review when asked to review your information.
    Enter your billing information, a credit card will be required.
    Click Continue when you're done entering your credit card and billing information.
    Best of luck,
    Mario

  • This Apple ID has not yet been used with the App Store. i cant download anything from the store why is that??????

    i cant download anything from the store.whenever i try to log in they say my apple id has not yet been used with the app store........why is it like that???does anyone know how to fix this............can someoen pls help me with this

    The following may help: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2589

Maybe you are looking for

  • Report Custom Vertical Table Question

    Hello Guys, I am trying to display some data in a custom vertical table (for a report). The data that I have looks like this : Customer number          Name               Product          Age 123               John Customer          Checking     50 4

  • Problem with fingerprint setting

    Hey, i bought an iphone 5s yesterday. I set up the fingerprint yesterday and it worked fine. But after that i faced some problem with the system so i reset the wholephone and edit and deleted my original fingerprint. but after that, my phone cant ree

  • HT1414 The itunes is updated! Where is the Summary tab?

    I want to restore my iPhone, but I cannot find the Summary tab in iTunes.

  • What's the best way to clean dust out of headphone jack?

    Best way to clean iPhone headphone jack?

  • This may not be the best forum for you!

    This forum does not get a lot of traffic and I think many SDN members do not follow posts here. Although the title includes the word connectivity, most connectivity questions appear either in the [Portal Content Development|SAP Enterprise Portal : Ad