Why keep old iPhoto Library?

This does not make any sense to me at all. Apple creates a new and improved Photo's app that is supposed to replace iPhoto and Aperture. Yet after the conversion it still requires that we keep the iPhoto and Aperture Libraries on our hard drives. What if we need the space and don't want everything duplicated? What happens when the decide to come out with a newer and more improved Photo's app?

1. Your data isn't being duplicated; the media only counts once towards the amount of space used despite appearing in both libraries. Click here for more information.
2. The same as what's happening now. You don't need to keep the iPhoto library, but may want to until any glitches have been worked out.
(125943)

Similar Messages

  • Why does old iPhoto library show that it's been updated?

    I 'backed up' my iPhoto library a few months ago by dragging it to and creating a copy on an external drive.  I never used that extra, copied library.  I continued using the one in my home Pictures folder on my hard drive.
    I am moving stuff around for extra hard drive space when I recognize my iPhoto library on my external drive (just as I left it, I'd just forgotten about it).  So for kicks, I clicked on GET INFO for that file so that I could compare it to my current iPhoto library.
    Both were 'created' on the same day in 2009.  The old one was a little smaller than the active one.  Fine.
    Interestingly, my backup copy said that it was Modified:  Yesterday 5:30pm. 
                        my current library said that it was Modified:   Today 10:10pm.
    QUESTION:  Why was my unused, backup copy of iPhoto Library modified yesterday when I haven't accessed that file, clicked on the icon, or even remembered that it was there (until today)?
    I appreciate any insight you may have.  While not a burning issue, my interest is piqued.  THANKS!

    Have you rebooted since the deletions.  That will empty a number of caches and may restore the freed up space. Also open the iPhoto Library package with the Finder as shown in this screenshot
    locate the iPod Photo Cache folder and delete its contents.  Make no other changes to the contents of the iPHoto LIbrary Package.
    OT

  • Why does the old iphoto library still remain after the upgrade? Takes up HUGE space on my laptop

    Why does the old iphoto library still remain after the upgrade? Takes up HUGE space on my laptop

    Why does the old iphoto library still remain after the upgrade? Takes up HUGE space on my laptop
    Actually, it only looks like it takes up additional space. The file size shown is misleading.  When you migrate an iPhoto library to Photos, both libraries will show the media files using hard links. The actual file content of the image files and videos is shared by hard links:
    See this linked document:   Photos saves disk space by sharing images with your iPhoto or Aperture libraries - Apple Support
    You will gain no free storage at all by deleting either the iPhoto Library or the Photos library.  So keep both libraries until you are very sure, that Photos is working well  on your Mac and your iPhoto library has been migrated correctly. Also, check, if you like the workflow in Photos. It is very different from iPhoto and some iPhoto features are not supported.
    There will be no easy way back to iPhoto, if you delete your iPhoto library or the iPhoto application. Apple does not sell it any more.

  • HT204476 is there anyway to get rid of the old iPhoto Library? It defeats the purpose of having a new software if I have to keep the remnants of the older one.

    is there anyway to get rid of the old iPhoto Library? It defeats the purpose of having a new software if I have to keep the remnants of the older one.

    dubthedankest wrote:
    Where are the masters actually stored upon conversion from Aperture to Photos? Photos?
    The master files are stored on your drive, but they are not actually stored "in" any folder. Folders are really just special files that store various bits of information about the files associated with that folder, including links to where they actually are stored. That's why you can "move" a file from one folder to another very quickly: all that you really are doing is moving the link & other info from one folder to the other folder, while the file itself stays where it was.
    Because of this, it is possible for more than one folder to link to the same file -- in the Finder it looks just like there are two copies of the file, one in each folder, but there really is just the one copy. From the description in the Photos saves disk space by sharing images with your iPhoto or Aperture libraries doc, it looks like that's what happens when you import your iPhoto library into Photos -- both the old iPhoto Library "file" (which actually is a set of folders & subfolders of files) & the Photos Library (also consisting of folders & files) contain links to the master files, but like the Apple doc says, there really is just one set of master files being stored.
    This is very similar to the way Time Machine backups look like they have multiple copies of the same unique file, one in each time-stamped backup folder, but there really is only one copy on the Time Machine drive. My guess is Apple is using hard links for this, which means the actual master files will not be deleted from the file system as long as at least one link remains to each of them.
    So you should be safe in deleting the old iPhotos Library once you are absolutely sure you don't need it, but to be sure, if it was me I would make a backup just in case, or better yet just leave it alone.

  • Why does my iPhoto Library.photolibrary in my MacAir running OS X Yosemite keep expanding?

    Why does my iPhoto Library.photolibrary in my MacAir running OS X Yosemite keep expanding?

    I will find a way to empty the system trash
    Does the System Trash refuse to empty?
    Usually simply clicking the Trash icon in the Dock will show you a window with the content of the Trash and a button labelled "Empty".
    Or ctrl-click the Trash icon in the Dock and select "Empty Trash".

  • How do I import an old iphoto library from an external hard disk while keeping my editing and organization in tact?

    I am running iPhoto '08 on a MacBook Pro 2.2 GHz Intel C2D (MacBook Pro 3,1). I backed up my hard drive contents onto an external hard drive, then formatted my computer and installed Mountain Lion. I then re-installed iPhoto '08 and ran all the updates. Now, I would like to import my old library from the external disk onto my computer without losing my editing and organization; however, when I select "import to library" from iPhoto, the old iPhoto library is not a selectable option.
    I know how to "show package contents" and import directly from the Original and Modified folders, but I don't want to lose my organization. Can I simply drag the content of those folders into my new Original and Modified folders? Will iPhoto read that correctly?
    I tried to open the old library from the external disk, thinking to export them all to a folder and import from there, but that just opened my new library and none of the old photos were imported or available.
    I'm running out of ideas and would appreciate any help you guys can give. Thanks!!

    You don't import it.
    Just drag the iphoto Library from the external to the Pictures Folder.
    Then open it:
    Hold down the option (or alt) key key and launch iPhoto. From the resulting menu select 'Choose Library'
    Never import one Library to another. Every version and thumbnail is imported like a distinct photo, you lose all your Albums, Keywords etc., the link between Original and Previews is destroyed, the non-destructive editing feature is ruined and so on. In summary: it's mess.

  • How can I import my old iPhoto library into my new version of iPhoto?

    Just purchased new iMac and am trying to import my old iPhoto library, but keep getting Unreadable Files message. I have the library file and see that it shows up as an iPhoto Library under the Kind column.

    Now that you're tried to open the correct library once see if you can perfor the following:  apply the two fixes below in order as needed: 
    Fix #1
    Launch iPhoto with the Command+Option keys held down and rebuild the library.
    Since only one option can be run at a time start with Option #3, followed by #4 and then #1 as needed.
    Fix #2
    Using iPhoto Library Manager  to Rebuild Your iPhoto Library
    1 - download iPhoto Library Manager and launch.
    2 - click on the Add Library button, navigate to your Home/Pictures folder and select your iPhoto Library folder.
    3 - Now that the library is listed in the left hand pane of iPLM, click on your library and go to the File ➙ Rebuild Library menu option.
    4 - In the next  window name the new library and select the location you want it to be placed.
    5 - Click on the Create button.
    Note: This creates a new library based on the LIbraryData.xml file in the library and will recover Events, Albums, keywords, titles and comments.  However, books, calendars, cards and slideshows will be lost. The original library will be left untouched for further attempts at fixing the problem or in case the rebuilt library is not satisfactory.

  • I can't copy my old iPhoto library from a external HD to my new mac?

    Hi. I just bought a new mac and want to have all my old iphoto pictures from my old mac into my new iPhoto library. I've tried to copy the old iPhoto library into a external HD(works fine), but the problem is that I can't copy it out from the external HD an in to my new mac again. It just say that it doesn't work because it doesnt have enough storage.
    I don't get why it would say that, because the old iPhoto library is 89.55 GB and I haven't used any memory at all on my new macbook pro, and my old macbook pro has memory enough to have the iPhoto library on it (the mac is 5 years old and has almost a full memory), so why can't my new macs memory manage the iPhoto library when my old mac can? It doesn't make sense at all.
    I've googled it, and it says everywhere that it should work by simply copy to external HD and move over the library from there and into the pictures folder, but this definitely doesn't work for me.
    I hope that some please can help me with this, I don't know what do to.

    Do you know how much space the cheapest macbook pro with reatina has?
    http://www.apple.com/mac/compare/notebooks.html
    A basic MBP may only have
    128GB solid-state drive

  • HT5037 Difficulty moving old iPhoto library from 2008 (not sure which version of iPhoto it is) to new macbook pro running OSX Mavericks.

    I tried downloading AND RUNNING the upgrader and I'm stuck in an infinite loop.  After running the upgrader from the utilities folder, it looks like things are working.  Then a window pops up asking me to launch iphoto to complete the upgrade.  After launching iphoto, iphoto goes back to the original error message that I need to download the upgrader.
    I've tried uninstalling and reinstalling the upgrader multiple times to no avail.  I've also tried dragging my iphoto library from the external hard drive it is housed on to many different areas before trying to launch the upgrader, none of them worked.  The external hard drive format is Mac OS Extended (Journaled). I also tried dragging the iphoto library folder in the pictures file onto my new Macbook right next to my new iphoto library folder.  This allowed me to open up iphoto (Yay!) but of course, none of the photos from my old iphoto library were in their, even when the old library was selected.
    I've read what seems like hundreds of posts on this same issue, but can't seem to find a solution that works for me.  I want to simply transfer my iphoto library from an external hard drive (my old macbook just crashed, so this is the only option) to my new macbook, keeping the albums, slideshows, and organization intact.
    I would appreciate any help or feedback.  Thank you in advance for reading this!

    Option 1
    Back Up and try rebuild the library: hold down the command and option (or alt) keys while launching iPhoto. Use the resulting dialogue to rebuild. Choose to Repair Database. If that doesn't help, then try again, this time using Rebuild Database.
    If that fails:
    Option 2
    Download iPhoto Library Manager and use its rebuild function. (In early versions of Library Manager it's the File -> Rebuild command. In later versions it's under the Library menu.)
    This will create an entirely new library. It will then copy (or try to) your photos and all the associated metadata and versions to this new Library, and arrange it as close as it can to what you had in the damaged Library. It does this based on information it finds in the iPhoto sharing mechanism - but that means that things not shared won't be there, so no slideshows, books or calendars, for instance - but it should get all your events, albums and keywords, faces and places back.
    Because this process creates an entirely new library and leaves your old one untouched, it is non-destructive, and if you're not happy with the results you can simply return to your old one.  
    Regards
    TD

  • Upgrading iphoto 9 and unable to access old iphoto library

    this week I did the maverick OS 10.9 upgrade without really reading about it, trusting that Apple knows what they are offering us. This upgrade prompted a suite  of annoying events. Apart from having to purchase new programs as the old ones would not work anymore (Illustrator, Adobe), I also had to purchase all my dictionaries (I work in three languages so that means at least 3 of them plus the bilingual ones = $$).
    Apart from that, the most annoying of all is the iphoto upgrade. I could no longer open my old iphoto program, so I did an software upgrade, and I went to the app store and upgraded it there (now installed is iphoto 9.5.1). I think it went for free (not sure) but in any cases, when I opened it, it prompted me to choose a library; I chose my iphoto library file - but despite the little button glowing in blue, nothing would happen or open. I then accepted to create a new library. it created a iphoto library_2 file. I have tried opening the program differently (pressing option and command while opening) but could not really get anywhere to the folder and open my old iphoto library file. How do I access my old library?? I have a 15,000 pictures in there!!!!
    I have a backup that is not too old, I have no idea why both on my back up and on my main computer both files are dated aug 2013 - even if my latest back up was last week (dec 2013). But that is question no 2...
    thanks for your help!

    I have exactly the same problem And in my case no back-up
    Have looked at some older support forums and this is not an isolated problem
    If i search my machine I can't find the iphoto library anywhere.
    If I "Create a new Library" and want to turn on icould to get the few photo's i have saved there then it tells me that my apple  ID is use by another Library????
    I cant find that Library.
    Although I have had a mac for 2 years I do not know the in's and outs.
    Have a tried a few suggestions from other forums but no luck
    Any help appreciated!
    RB

  • HT5037 import old iPhoto library in iPhoto '11

    I would like to import an old iPhoto library (iPhoto '08 version 7.1.5 (378) ) from my old iMac G5 into my macbook which is running iPhoto '11 version 9.4.3 (720.91.
    When I am chosing the import function, I can see a blurred file "iPhoto lirbary" but it is impossible to open it.
    Can someone help me and/or indicate me the right procedure.
    Thank you !

    Yes you are wrong - if you drag any file into a folder where that file already exists you will delete and replace the old file and have only the new file left - this is true for the iPhoto libary package
    Your best solution is to either upgrade to Aperture or use the paid version of iPhoto Library Manager - http://www.fatcatsoftware.com/iplm/ -  to merge libraries
    You can export the photos form your old library and import those photos into the new library but this does not keep your originals, only your edited versions which become originals in the new library
    LN

  • Why is my iPhoto Library duplicating photos

    why is my iPhoto library duplicating photo's, sometimes 3 times ?

    Your iPhoto library is not duplicating anything. Give virtually no information the only guess is that you imported an old iPhoto library into a new one.  NEVER import one photo library into another one. If you did and still have the old library you can easily recover. Drag the library you messed up to the desktop and drag the old library to the pictures folder and launch iPhoto
    LN

  • Why is my iPhoto library greyed out in the Screensaver folder selection dialog on one iMac but not my other?

    Why is my iPhoto library greyed out in the Screensaver folder selection dialog on one iMac but not my other?

    I have an update to my issue above, with a Semi-solution found. I brought my Macbook Air back to the Genus bar today and they were able to identify (using “Activity Monitor”) that when the particular iPhoto library was being launched through iPhoto both Photostream and iPhoto's CPU% usage was excessively high (between 100% - 200% each). She discovered that if we turn off Photostream in iCloud settings iPhoto then behaved fast and snappy and CPU% came back down to a healthier level. When we turned Photostream back on the problem continued. After an hour of trying to trouble shoot why Photostream was causing the issue they recommended I keep Photostream turned off until a future software update/fix comes out. The particular Genus I worked with was not familiar with this issue. I’m very happy to at least be able to use iPhoto again, but if anyone has ideas or theories on how the Photostream conflict can be fixed please share. Thanks.

  • Recently purchased a new imac and thought my old iPhoto library transferred over. It wasn't. And I can't get iPhoto to open on my old mac ("can't open your current version of iPhoto using this version of iPhoto. You have made changes to your photo lib ...

    I purchased a new imac (4G, OS X 10.6.8) in Feb 2011 and thought my old iPhoto library transferred over. It wasn't. And I can't get iPhoto to open on my old mac. It says, "can't open your current version of iPhoto using this version of iPhoto. You have made changes to your photo library using a newer version of iPhoto. Please quit and use the latest version of iPhoto". I don't think my old mac will support the newer version of iPhoto so I feel like I'm stuck (this is why I got a new mac -- cheaper than upgrading all my software, etc). Help! I really need to get to my old photos, and no, they are not backed up anywhere. Thanks.

    You have two options:
    Run the Library on a machine that has the same version as the machine that was stolen.
    or
    Recover the files from this library and start over from scratch.
    To recover the files:
    Go to your Pictures Folder (or whereever you have the back up) and find the iPhoto Library there. Right (or Control-) Click on the icon and select 'Show Package Contents'. A finder window will open with the Library exposed.
    Your originals are in the Masters folder.
    Note this will only recover your photos as imported from you camera.
    Regards
    TD

  • Moving my old iPhoto library to my new macbook

    I recently purchased a new Macbook and did not use Migration Assistant to set it up. I want my iPhoto library moved to my Macbook intact. My old computer is an iMac G4 running OS X 10.4.11. That computer has iPhoto 2.0.1. I dragged my iPhoto Library on to an iPod in disk mode and dragged it from that device onto my new Macbook which is running Snow Leopard and iPhoto '09. I started iPhoto on the Macbook and pointed it to the old iPhoto Library. It started up fine, updated the Library and went through its Faces recognition routine. Super, except that my old machine tells me that my Library holds 4818 images and iPhoto on my new machine counts just 3415 images.
    Can someone help me understand the discrepancy and how to rectify? Thank you.

    Hello Old Toad:
    Thanks for your second response to my photo dilemma--I've been unusually busy the past ten days and haven't been able to try your suggestion. Part of the "busy" was exasperation at Apple over the download of the iPhone upgrade 4.0; I didn't understand all the ramifications of the upgrade and thus lost all the remaining photos on my iPhone except those taken with the iPhone camera. Luckily for me, that numbered over 1100 so all was not lost. I told a friend who has both iPhone and Mac desktop of my inability to download photos from iPhone to laptop, and he said he has been doing it for over two years! I asked him to show me how he does it. We then tried it with my iPhone but were stopped by a message on his desktop saying it could not download photos from my iPhone because I didn't have iTunes 9.2 installed. At home I opened iTunes on my MacBook and found that I did have 9.2 installed. I plugged my iPhone into my computer and to my utter amazement in less than 30 seconds iPhoto opened up and asked if I wanted to download x number of items. That had never happened before, and I don't know why it happened now. Two possibilities come to mind: that iTunes 9.2 was downloaded recently as part of an upgrade bundle and I hadn't tried the photo download SINCE the upgrade--in other words, all I needed was iTunes 9.2? Or, that in the iPhone 4.0 upgrade a mechanism was installed to accomplish the task, but neither explains my friend's success at the same task. If anyone else is as puzzled by this as I am, I'd like to hear about it. Also, why was such a seemingly simple question/task so difficult to find a solution to?
    Sincerely,
    Medren

Maybe you are looking for