Why new final cut X is so restrictive connected clips? I do not see benefit.

I am coming from final cut 7 and I have no idea why new final cut X is so restrictive in having primary storyline and connected clips. I loved how in FC7 all clips were independent in timeline and gave you freedom to move and organize your clips however you wanted.
Now I have to take extra steps or jump through hoops to move clips around becaused they are connected to primary storyline. Like I have to create secondary storylines. Really??
I do not see any benefit to connected clips except that it automatically follows primary storyline when you move primary clip around - which most of time I do not want it to do.  We should be able to turn this off because I do not see any benefit to connected clips with primary storyline.
FCX is dictating how we organize clips on timeline which is way more restrictive than FC7. This is just wrong.
Also bring back enable tracks. Why in the world did they remove tracks. Tracks work and is easier to visualize and organize clips in timeline. Like if I wanted to disable audio or video for a track it was just one click in FC7.  Now there are extra steps in FCX  They should enable this for people who are use to tracks.
They should really talk scold to whoever mad scientist who wanted to make FCX more restrictive than FC7 and impose their workflow on everyone else.
I like magnetic timeline where you can move clips around and other clips will automatically move to make room for it. This save time.
So can we disable connected clips and let us enable tracks just like better FC7?

The first Quantel NLE, back in the 80ies, was mimicing the Moviola - showing vertical stripes of 'film'.
So, you could ask "Why have they changed to horizontal?"
On editing film, you wrote with some white wax pen an X onto it, to indicate a dissolve....
So, you could ask "Why have they changed that to drag'n drop grey boxes?"
On recording they hold a clapper into the cam, to 'sign' the time-code.
So, you could ask "Why have they changed that to meta-tags, hidden invisible in the file?"
Aside doing compos ('Brady Bunch', '24'), there are no 'tracks' in no movie.
In any movie, there's always just a single storyline...
If you like to apply 'variations', get customed to FCPX' Auditions.
If you like to adjust cut-aways, get customed to the various trim/ripple/nudge options of FCPX.
If you like to pre-select clips, get customed to the Events-concept and its endless options (you can even abuse to create 'bins'!) to tag clips.
If you like to 'pre-comp', get customed to FCPX' compounds and their own timelines.
It is a different, a new way of editing. That simple.
As others told you: nobody forces you to adopt it.
There's AP, there's DaVinci Resolve .... and many others.
And you even can Position a clip...
Russ H wrote:
@Tom and David: OP has posted identical  comment in Creative Cow/The Debate.
excellent obeservation...
Such a debate comes two years too late here, I assume...

Similar Messages

  • Why is final cut pro x 10.0.8 hanging in video preview?

    why is final cut pro x 10.0.8 hanging in video preview?

    There's all kinds of problems with FCP and the new iMacs.
    Mostly it's running out of memory, there are several threads about it. I hope there will be an update soon!

  • Spinning ball all the time? new final cut?

    Hi there,
    After spend 300 dollars in the brand new final cut X, i notice that i also have a free spinning colourfull beachball?! yes in the previous version i never add so many hang ups and so time waiting for some operations, i have, as u can say the best comfiguration tha a imac can have until a year ago, 16 g of ram and a i7 processor, well the best on a imac.
    Now and after a expatation i notice that its far for the desire result and i need help to try to resulve this bugs or not.
    Hope to have any news, from someone and especially an update to fix from Apple

    I'm running it on a 15" MacBook Pro and I get constant beach balls, they seem to get more frequent the longer I have the app open, and ultimately I have to force close and restart my computer because the whole system bogs down.  Very aggravating. I have a Core 2 Duo and only 4 GB RAM, so I understand it would run slow, but after about an hour of editing, sometimes less, it becomes unusable.

  • Ok, I thought I could do a project in my new Final Cut Pro X. I got everything downloaded on Final Cut and I made my Project. The problem is is has taken so long to render that I don't have time. How do I download the video from Final Cut to Imovie?

    ok, I thought I could do a project in my new Final Cut Pro X. I got everything downloaded on Final Cut and I made my Project. The problem is is has taken so long to render that I don't have time. How do I download the video from Final Cut to Imovie?

    Your media is stored in Final Cut Events folder > "name of event"  > original media. The Final Cut Events folder is in your movies folder or at the root level of an external drive if you are using one to store your media. Simply open iMovie and under file menu select import movies. Navigate to the original media folder and import your clips to Imovie event library.

  • I just updated to new final cut pro x 10.1.1 and i am also on mavericks so but on my editing timeline i was trying to color grade using magic bullet looks but i am having problem with it. when it comes back to tcp x it's black.

    I just updated to the new final cut pro x 10.1.1 and i am also on mavericks so but on my editing timeline i was trying to color grade using magic bullet looks but i am having problem with it. When i send a sample to MBL and color grade it , it comes back to final cut pro x all black even after render. By the way on the MBL i am using the GPU rendering, I used before like 4months ago and it was fine. And i don't like to use the CPU because it very slow.

    What is the frame rate of the project? At what frame rate was the media recorded? What frame size?
    What are the audio settings?
    What are the specs of the machine, in particular how much RAM, how is the hard drive connected, etc.?
    If possible, post screenshots of the inspector for the project.
    It could be related to the audio frequency?

  • I have a copy of Final Cut Express 2. Can I get a current upgrade instead of repurchasing the new Final Cut Pro?

    I have a old copy of Final Cut Express 2 that I never installed. Can I get a current upgrade instead of repurchasing the new Final Cut Pro?
    The Apple Store does not show does not contain purchase information of the old unused Final Cut Express. What can I do to register Final Cut Express 2 will not operate in the current OS systems on my iMac. It only is compatible with the G3 or G5.

    If you have a record/documentation of your FCS full version purchase, you can contact Apple here:
    https://ssl.apple.com/support/proapps/serialnumbers/
    to obtain your serial number.
    MtD
    Message was edited by: Meg The Dog to fix typo

  • If I download New Final Cut Pro X ... Will I Still be able to use my Final Cut Pro 7.0.3?

    If the answer is yes how do I separate them?  Can they both be in my applications folder?  I just want to try the new program.
    I have one more  question ... Will the New Final Cut Pro X be able to use some of my old footage NTSC DVPro 720x480?
    Thank You
    roger

    The answer is yes to all your questions.
    Final Cut Studio gets moved to its own subfolder inside Applications.

  • I have a 13 inch macbook 4g 2.26ghz intel core 2 duo. will it run the new final cut software?

    i have a 13 inch macbook 4g 2.26ghz intel core 2 duo. will it run the new final cut software?

    Matey - you should be ok
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4728.

  • Why does final cut x not recognize the sharp PN- K321 monitor ( European version ) as output video monitor and premiere it? Working with two cinema display and PN- K321 and I can not preview the output video at 4K for DisplayPort, whereas with premie

    Why does final cut x not recognize the sharp PN- K321 monitor ( European version ) as output video monitor, and premiere yes?
    Working with two cinema display and PN- K321 and I can not preview the output video at 4K by DisplayPort, whereas with premiere and after effects I have no problems

    Look, you can build an HD DVD with an SD movie, just as you can build an SD DVD with an HD movie. This is not a bug, it is most likely user error. Apple will not be addressing it.
    Just start over, and ensure you are building an SD DVD by bringing up the inspector for the disc (click on the background in the Graphical tab).
    Make sure SD DVD is selected:
    (If you do the same thing on your ill fated project, you'll see that HD DVD is selected)
    Build your DVD and you'll be fine.
    Patrick
    P.S. You will need to google HD DVD and Blu-Ray if you want to understand the difference between the formats. The reason that DVDSP included HD DVD was that its format was similar to SD DVD's. Blu-Ray is something else entirely.

  • Will the new final cut pro x work with my Final cut pro version 6.0.6 data

    will the new final cut pro x work with my Final cut pro version 6.0.6 data

    Thanks Tom.
    So I will need  upgrade to FCP 7 first, then convert to an XML file in 6.0.6, then convert to another file that FCP X can read? I have a lot of half done projects that need finishing. Is this process very complex and time consuming?
    Maybe I should be approaching this from a different angle. The reason I am asking is that I now need to upgrade to a new Mac book pro and have been told that I cant run final cut pro 6.0.6 on the new models using maverick. Is this true?
    Roger

  • Opening an old FCp project in new Final cut?

    I was working on a previous version and recently got the new Final Cut X but now my project won't open? Any ideas?

    Unfortunately, this is just not supported in FCX, and Apple has stated they have no plans to add it in. There are some third party developers working on solutions, but no products or timelines have been announced yet.
    The best thing to do is to finish your project in FCP and use FCX for new projects.
    Eventually, converters may become available to port your old projects to FCX.

  • NEED HELP Deciding. new final cut and a powerpc4

    I have a power mac G4 and I want to know will the new final cut package work on it? My pc has a radeon 9000 pro, dual 1.25 processors,, memory 1.25.
    i just want to know if final cut and the other programs will work on it. I do not do HD and when i do i will buy another but for Sd is this ok to run and buy the new fc.
    thanks everyone who can help

    I'd think you will be able to run FCS 2. Your computer is above all of the minimum specs, only wild card here is your graphics card. It has enough VRAM ... just not listed in the compatible cards. Bet it works OK though. Look at the Motion and Color minimums. FCP will work without a hitch in any event, and so should compressor, LiveType, and DVD SP. You could upgrade it if you find it lacking but I'd give it a go with the card you have to see if you're OK first.
    http://www.apple.com/finalcutstudio/specs.html
    Jerry

  • We've just downloaded Maverick and the new final cut 10.1.  On two separate computers it has crashed and we have lost our entire project that we were editing.  Not sure if it is a final cut problem or maverick.  Any suggestions on how to get the timeline

    We just installed maverick and the new final cut.  On 2 separate computers we have had it crash while using final cut and have lost the project.  Now we are reading that our time machine is not working with maverick.  Any suggestions on how to get timeline back from the new final cut?  Thought it was suppose to save automatically.

    We just installed maverick and the new final cut.  On 2 separate computers we have had it crash while using final cut and have lost the project.  Now we are reading that our time machine is not working with maverick.  Any suggestions on how to get timeline back from the new final cut?  Thought it was suppose to save automatically.

  • New Imac/New Final Cut Ex/New JVC Hard Disc Camcorder no bueno!!!!

    New Imac/New Final Cut Ex/New JVC Hard Disc Camcorder
    Please help me. I have been editing on a tiny little pc, and finally made the switch. Now, I can't access any of my videos, can't edit or even open the files. If all the files are moi or mod, what does final cut express need to open the files? How do I go about converting them? Such a big powerful machine, such limited accessibility!
    Thanks!

    FCE4 on an Intel Mac can only edit DV, HDV and AVCHD video.
    All other formats will not work.
    You will have to download an app like Streamclip to convert your non-standard files to DV.
    http://www.squared5.com/

  • Can Premiere Pro CS 5.5 Export An XML To The New Final Cut Pro X?

    Can Premiere Pro CS 5.5 Export an XML to the new final Cut Pro X?

    No, it won't. Premiere Pro can only export an XML for FCP7 or earlier. Make a feature request if you like: http://www.adobe.com/go/wish

Maybe you are looking for

  • How do I find my CC Files Directory?

    Hello! Very new to the Creative Cloud. Trying to figure out the most basic thing--where can I find the Creative Cloud Files Directory? I want to be able to automatically backup my Photoshop and Indesign files, just in case my computer crashes. This s

  • Problem with Extract Filter

    I have Problem with Extract Filter which was working OK until recently. Now, when I choose the filter the screen does not come up as the extract screen as it should and no other action can be taken except to press escape which returns me to normal. w

  • Why cannot any longer do "slow motion" gesture with 2 fingers of videos in iPhoto 9.2

    why cannot any longer do "slow motion" gesture with 2 fingers of videos in iPhoto 9.2 under lion ??? anyone knows why ? bug or feature...

  • Strange Window at start-up after installing Final Cut Studio 2

    After installing Final Cut Studio 2, everytime I start up I get a window with the Final Cut icon in it And the following text: Alert Title Alert: something happened At the bottom are two buttons: Cancel and OK

  • Compatibility, print

    Hello, I'm using Oracle 8i client on Windows NT (Release 3 (8.1.7), Part No. A85305-01) I would like to print to a file with parser.getDocumentElement()->print() It doesn't work, printing to a stream parser.getDocumentElement()->print(xmlBuff,1024,0,