Widescreen frame size question-720x404?

When I bring 16:9 widescreen material into Compressor and I use the 16:9 presets, the settings within the program tell me I'm going to get a 720x480 result with an anamorphic pixel aspect ratio.
However, when I open the .m2v result in Quicktime and get movie info, the file appears to be 720x404.
I've been told that Quicktime is just showing me an optically correct frame size, and therefore is just narrowing the height from 480 to 404. I'm not quite sure that I believe this yet, however, because it's actually telling me that that 720x404 is the "Normal Size" of the movie.
I don't want to be losing vertical resolution if I can actually use the full 720x480 frame. Does anyone know what's happening here?
G5 Dual 2.5   Mac OS X (10.4.9)  
G5 Dual 2.5   Mac OS X (10.4.9)  

Hi:
If you did follow the correct encoding workflow (and I think you did!) everything will be fine. The problem is with QT and MPEG2 playback component:
http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=302075
Hope that helps !
  Alberto

Similar Messages

  • Adjusting frame size question

    Could someone help me with something?
    I’m downloading video from a Canon Vixia HF 10 into Final Cut Express for editing. Then I'm exporting that video/movie into iDVD. When I pop it into a drop zone on the main theme page in iDVD the movie doesn’t fill out the entire space available in that drop zone. It has black space above the movie just like a movie does when played in wide screen mode on your tv. Are there settings in fce where I can adjust the movie so it won’t play in wide screen mode, and thus completely fill up in the drop zone, or is this some that needs to be addressed in iDVD?
    Thank you ever so much,
    Scott

    You could select a piece of your video, double-click it so it opens in the Viewer, click the Motion tab in the Viewer, and adjust the scale slider. You could then export that clip and use it as your drop zone. I say to use only a piece, because
    a) the longer the clip in your drop zone, the less space on the disc you'll have for your movie.
    b) putting your whole finished movie into the drop zone looks bad.

  • Question: PE4 -- missing presets, project settings frame size disabled

    Hi -- I'm running PE4 and with YouTube's new widescreen abilities, I want to make some widescreen (16:9) videos, rather than the ol' 4:3 ratio.
    However, in the intitial set up when I'm creating a new video, when I attempt to change settings, I discover that all the presets are missing. Using windows explorer, I discover that they are all no longer available. Where did they go?
    And by the same token, I can't seem to edit my settings, either. From the edit menu, then preset settings, then general... The frame sizes are disabled and no amount of fiddling with the other settings will enable them.
    Am I missing something obvious?
    I also feel that the simplest way of fixing the problem would be for someone running PE4 to create a wide screen video in 16:9 and e-mail me the working files. I should be able to clone that over and over for videos. Just an idea.
    Please help!

    You can only change your PROJECT presets when you start a project. You can't change them mid-project.
    As for output presets under the Share tab, if you're not finding those, then something is wrong with your installation and you probably need to either uninstall and reinstall (you won't lose any work if you do) or at least do a repair install -- do an installation without removing the program from your system.

  • Compressor mucking up frame sizes?  Totally confused.  Help!

    Here's the situation.
    I have some 720x486 (NTSC-CCIR) 16:9 23.976 video (nice, yummy, uncompressed 10-bit) in Final Cut.
    I want to compress this for DVD.
    But no matter what settings I use, Compressor mucks it up.
    If I use the Apple-provided MPEG-2 5.0Mbps 2-pass 16:9 setting, I get a 720x404 file.
    If I uncheck 16:9 in the compressor settings, I get a 640x480 file.
    Changing the output format to NTSC makes no difference.
    I have tried just about every combination of settings available, and cannot get compressor to stop changing the frame size -- and btw, the "frame size" feature is always grayed out.
    Any clues as to how I should proceed?
    G4 1.44DP    

    Actually, I did a fair bit of searching, just didn't hit on the right keywords. Such is search.
    Thanks for the info. The tip in the thread you mentioned about MPEG StreamClip was a good one, it confirms that the output is actually 720x480.
    For QT Player and Final Cut to not properly describe the native format of the files is outrageously stupid. And Final Cut still cant bring in the .m2v file and use it without mucking it to 720x404. Sigh.
    Okay, the basic question is answered. Now for a subtle one, oh wizards.
    My source video is CCIR-601, 720x486. MPEG-2 for DVDs is 720x480, oh so slightly different.
    If I use the Apple preset, it converts the 720x486 to 720x480. The question is, is it clipping the top and bottom 3 lines, or is it scrunching (which will cause a slight vertical resolution loss)?
    Changing the preset to crop the top and bottom 3 lines also gives 720x480, which I assume means there's no scrunching (at the cost of a very slight distortion, which nobody will notice). So this is what I'm leaning towards doing, but I'd like to be sure.

  • Can PE4's "Scale to Frame Size" scaling of stills be adjusted?

    I have authored a movie with over 50 stills at the end. Some of those stills have a caption that I added by enlarging the canvas with white background in Photoshop Elements and typing in people's names. Some of the captions have 1 line, some 2 lines, and some 3 lines. All the stills are about the same size, but no matter how many lines a caption has, the bottom half of the last line is cut off from view. I tried extending the bottom of the caption area, but that made the photo smaller and the white blank area just didn't look right. Next I tried cropping off the caption area and typing the caption on the bottom part of the photo itself--but the last line still gets cut off.
    If I uncheck "Scale to Frame Size", the photo is huge. How can I overide PE4's default scaling so that the photos with bottom captions are small enough for the captions to fit within the Safe Title Margin instead of being cut off? The stills are digital photos 3264 pixels wide with heights varying for 2448 to 2992 pixels. My preset is widescreen 16:9.
    Thanks for your help.

    Sorry I couldn't respond sooner, the site kept saying try again later--then
    after reading over your helpful article several times, I kept digging and
    experimenting and was able to produce exactly what I wanted! So, at least
    you didn't have to read the earlier reply I had composed with several more
    questions.
    Since I shot the video clips in widescreen mode, I batch re-sized all the
    non-captioned photos to 720 X 480. That sure shortened the loading time of
    Premiere! For the ones with captions, I decided the extra text at the bottom
    of the photos would make the photos smaller on screen than I wanted. I used
    PSE to type text on the photo itself, saved the layers, then re-sized it by
    resampling to 432 (480 height X 90%). I found out how to change the ruler in
    Premiere Elements from inches to pixels. I adjusted the text layer so that
    the bottom line would not below the Safe Title Margin of 384 (480 X
    80%)--but when put on the timeline, there was still plenty of room before
    the text was cut off, so I re-positioned the text to about 395. Of course I
    had to select all the stills on the timeline and uncheck the option to scale
    to frame size. Now that I understand how scaling works, I can get any size
    photo to fit just right!
    I had struggled with how to get captions to display for a couple of years,
    so I appreciate so much your pointing me in the right direction with your
    response and helpful article!

  • Advice on sequence settings - frame size for VHS video in FCP

    Hello,
    I was hoping that I could get some advice on editing and output for video captured from VHS Tapes to ensure the best quality possible.
    My current workflow to digitize the VHS tapes is:
    VHS signal from JVC S7600u with TBC into ADVC 300 (no de-interlace or other filters set) into a Mac Pro via firewire.  Capture preset in FCP is DV NTSC 48khz.
    Once in FCP - the captured VHS video frame size is 720 X 480, Vid rate is 29.97, pixel aspect is NTSC-CCIR 601 and field dominance is lower (even)
    My questions are:
    If my final destination is for You Tube sharing , are these the best sequence/ frame size settings or should I convert the sequence frame size to 640 X 480, or should I leave at 720 X 480 while working in FCP and then output to Compressor and select the H264 you tube sharing video setting and change the frame size to 640 X 480? 
    Should I de- interlace for internet/youtube destination?
    Should I de-interlace for DVD/TV destination?
    If I want to burn the finished project to DVD and watch the video on a progressive montitor/ TV screen, what would be the best settings/frame size for that?
    If any of you out there have experience with editing vcr/analog video in FCP and have a good workflow to ensure best quality, I would really appreciate  any advice/suggestions.
    Thanks in advance.

    Digitize to 720X480 frame size in FCP. In compressor, your YouTube preset will automatically deinterlace and a square pixel aspect ratio.No deinterlacing for DVD.
    Russ

  • AV output and non-standard frame sizes

    I usually work in non-standard frame size for my FCP projects because my final output will be in a 2:35:1 ratio. I use a Blackmagic Ultrastudio Mini Monitor as an HDMI output to a client monitor. Up until a few months ago the AV output of FCPX would allow the Mini Monitor to accept a frame size of 1920x818 and letterbox the output to 16x9 on this consumer grade LCD. One day, this just stopped working... I've reached out to Blackmagic and they have no solution or reason why this happened, and are not willing to offer support since what I was achieving wasn't an "officially supported" feature. Now, the AV output will distort the image vertically to fill a 16x9 frame. At this point I am stuck having to use either a matte layer or a widescreen effect on individual clips to output correctly to my monitor which increases edit time having to re-render any edits underneath the matte and having to re-order the letterbox effect after apply color correction etc. It was also very easy to adjust the frame offset with this wide angle project size.
    Is anyone editing in 2:35:1 (or other cinema standard) projects and getting successful conversion on output? What are you using?
    Cheers,
    Matt

    Thanks Tom, you clarified it .......  or at least something clicked in my brain.
    I was trying to set "Custom" when I created the new project.
    I didn't know, or had forgotten, that in the "error" window I could select "Custom".
    All is now well and FCP X 10.1.1 is pretty clever after all!
    There is one weird thing I'd like to mention.
    When I clicked on "Custom" the 960 x 600  frame dimensions appeared but the  frame rate was listed as 23.98p as shown in the screenshot below.
    So what's wrong with that?
    Well the clip is 30p  and I naturally thought I was going to end up with a project with an incorrect frame rate.
    Now here's the funny thing  .........  when I selected the project and viewed it in the Inspector it was the correct 30p
    So why was I given that worrying piece of misinformation.

  • Frame size discrepancies in project settings?

    Hi Guys
    I have some new information and some observations on my problems with getting full screen output.
    I looked through all the project settings and I noticed that the ones I was trying to use…
    HD 1080i (60i) and HDV 1080i 30 say that the output is at a16 to 9 ratio and have a frame size of 1440 by 1080i.
    This is the frame size or ratio, I kept trying to import.
    I finally realized that this isn't a frame size that is proportional to the image ratio that it lists.
    16 by 9 would really be proportional to 1440 by 810.
    The 1440 by 1080 video that I import using either of these,does not export full screen even if it’s exported the same size it comes in, i.e.1440 in and 1440 out.
    So I looked through the project setting for a selection where the stated ratio and the frame size matched.
    I found HDV 720p 30.
    16 by 9 at a 1280 by 720 frame size.
    This would be an easy size for my to work in.
    So I made a video at that size then loaded it into PE8 and it exported fine.
    Full screen no border.  In fact it comes out full screen no matter what size I export it.
    When I exported the same video at 1600 by 900 it exported full screen and looked fine.
    Then I went back and loaded the same 1280 by 720 video inthe HDV 1080i 30 settings.
    It also came out full screen with no border.
    So the problem is that as far as I can see the selection screen is wrong about the frame size for both the HD 1080i and the HDV 1080isettings.
    You really have to load in something at 1600 by 900 or proportional to that.
    And as far a I can find there is no setting that supports any thing other the wide screen except for the Standard 48kHz settings.
    It looks like unless you want to go to a wide screen format 720 by 480 is the only option.
    Now I’ll have to decide whether I want to do future projects wide screen or live with the restrictions on frame size.
    I hate to change horses in the middle of the stream so I may just stick with the smaller size for the Lucy videos but other projects I will do wide screen.
    Thanks again for all the help.
    Mike

    This question is from some other forum member. Don't know why they're linked to my e-mail address.
    Fran (luvsfotos)
    > Date: Tue, 7 Jun 2011 22:22:36 -0600
    From: [email protected]
    To: [email protected]
    Subject: Re: Frame size discrepancies in project settings?
    Hi Guys
    Ok, I think I get it at last.
    So when I create a 1440 by 1080 file, to use in the 1080i format, it should change the PAR from 1 to 1.333 when I create it, but since I can't control that I get an image that is too small, even though the pixel size is the same.  The aspect ration should still end up 16 by 9.
    So since Poser creates everything with a PAR of 1, my only option if I want a wide screen video is to actually pick a 16 by 9 ratio when I output it and ignore the listed frame size. 
    I still don't quite get why the image is both shorter and narrower, it seems like it should only be narrower but I'll live with it.
    And there is no way to make PE8 output a full height image in the wide screen format that 3 by 4 except to drag it larger in the preview window.
    And there is no advantage in doing that since I'm still using a 16 by 9 window and getting the file size that goes with it.
    So if I want to work in a 3 by 4 format then the Standard 48kHz format it the only option.
    Well at least I know what to do next time.
    That should save a lot of time.
    I may just give up and go to 16 by 9 and quit fighting it.
    Thanks again.
    Mike
    >

  • FCP- DVDSP sequence settings. frame size

    Question of sequence settings. when making a DVD, will the sequence setting, Frame size make a difference?
    We are just starting to edit a documentary, which uses alot of still photos and graphics. The rest of the video is shot on DV. I have tried laying still photos on the DV sequence, but it looks like still photos look really compressed and blurry. Not so good quality wise. If I set it to CCIR 601-NTSC, the photos look super good. We are NOT outputting any digi-beta uncompressed, but only to DVD.
    I am editing sequence in NTSC DV, but thinking of just before getting outputting with compressor, I am thinking of changing to uncompressed sequence CCIR 601-NTSC, and then compress it to MPEG2. (doing this later so that i can do alot of edits RealTime and worry about picture quality later) of course the picture size does get smaller... I don't really know the effect of this on a teleframed television.
    Will that make a difference? Seems that if I go through DVcompression AND MPEG2 compression, both, is more compression than MPEG2 compression itself. Is there a site that talks about it?
    Thanks in advance.
    Lost

    I only have "a bit" of experience working with stills in a DV sequence. But one thought concerns how you are integrating the stills and the video. I assume you are going to pretty much intermix the stills and the video and audio (interviews or whatever) that may go with video and stills.
    The DVD format, of course, supports stills as a slide show directly, but this will not accomplish the intermix very effectively.
    As far as size-quality, you may want to import the stills are larger than DV image size and then pan across them, etc.
    At the end of the day, to achieve a seamless edit job, you are probably going to need to have all the stills sitting on a regular DV timeline for export / encoding to MPEG2.
    I honestly do not put much stock in the differences between viewer and canvas. I always use an external NTSC monitor to judge the final appearance. I started with a cheap TV and recently upgrade to a nice JVC production monitor. This is the real measure of the final video, in my experience.

  • UITableView with custom frame size within a UINavigationController... how?

    I've seen similar questions asked all over the web, but so far not a single "real" answer has cropped up, so hopefully you folks will know the way to do this.
    I have a main view that with a UIView subview, inside of which I am programmatically adding a UINavigationController and UITableView that is encapsulated in a +regular UIViewController+, to allow it to be pushed/popped onto the navigation controller. I'm essentially just trying to get a table+navcontroller combination that only takes up about half the screen height.
    The problem isn't that it doesn't work, because I have no problem getting the table and navigation controller working together as expected. The problem is that no matter what I do or try, I cannot get the table view to be smaller (in height), than full-size, meaning that when contained in this ~200px navcontroller-in-subview, there are a large number of rows the user cannot select because attempting to scroll to them immediately "bounces" back. You can see that the rows are there when you "pull" the scroll down, but can never get it to stay.
    As it appears, the table view is too large in height. I've gone as far as setting the table to a height of 10, to no avail. Autoresize masks have no effect.
    Please note that I'm NOT using an instance of UITableViewController, but rather the plain vanilla UIViewController, because creating an instance of the former automatically creates the underlying UITableView, which was always sized to large, as well. I had some advice that I should attempt creating the table and view controller independently, add the former to the latter and then push the view controller onto the navigation controller. Again, this does work, but the size is all out of whack.
    Finally, in quick psuedo-code, this is essentially what I'm doing:
    (this is found in MainViewController::viewDidLoad)
    CGRect frame = subviewContainer.frame;
    frame.size.height = 10;
    frame.origin.x = 0;
    frame.origin.y = 0;
    UITableView* table = [[UITableView alloc] initWithFrame:frame];
    table.autoresizesMask = UIViewAutoresizingNone;
    UIViewController* tVC = [[UIViewController alloc] init];
    tVC.view = table;
    UINavigationController* navC = [[UINavigationController alloc] initWithRootViewController:tVC];
    [subviewContainer addSubview:navC.view];
    Thanks for any tips you might have: this is quite the frustrating problem!

    I have an app that is absolutely kicking my butt. I have a UITabBarController that contains a UINavigationController that contains a custom UIViewController. When the user rotates the iPhone, I want to hide the navigation bar, hide the tab bar and swap out a UIImageView in the custom view controller and I want the image to be full-screen. I've figured out how to get rid of the navigation and tab bars, but making the UIImageView full-screen is what's killing me. When the image shows up, it is the size it would be if the tab bar was visible. In the didRotateFromInterfaceOrientation method, I hide the tab bar by doing:
    tabBar.hidden = YES;
    I've tried resizing the UIImageView by doing:
    img.frame = CGRectMake(0.0, 0.0, 320.0, 480.0);
    but that just screws up the image even more. I tried resizing the tabBarController's view, and I've tried resizing the current view, but alas to no avail.
    Can anyone help me not be stupid?
    Thanks!

  • How do you know what frame size to make your movie?

    Hello everyone,
    I know this is probably an easy question, but I just need someone to sum it up for me
    If I'm going to compress my movie (Shot in 4:3, 720x480) and I want to put it on someone else website... which I don't know there frame size... like youtube, can I just submit any size and their website will fit it for me?
    Does that make sense?
    Like I know youtube says you can submit a file size of up to 1 gb, but what frame size should it be? Or do I just make the best looking movie I can from compressor and then just submit?
    Thanks...

    Most sites such as YouTube will resize it for you, yes. For specific YouTube encoding, this may be of assistance:
    http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/you_tube_reduxgary.html

  • 16:9 Frame Size Setting

    I'm working on a film installation with 2 x 4:3 sized Video Streams that will stream alongside each other in a 16:9 format presentation (leaving a thin black border top and bottom)
    I want to finally export a HD Sequence (1920 x 1080, 29.97fps, Apple ProRes 422 Compressor, Square Pixel Aspect Ratio) onto HD for projection
    but the Sequence Settings box only gives the following options:
    960 x 720 (16.9) --- but 960 divided by 720 = 1.3333 !
    1280 x 1080 (16.9) --- but 1280 divided by 1080 = 1.185 !
    1440 x 1080 (16.9) --- but 1440 divided by 1080 = 1.333 !
    I have 2 questions:
    1. Why do the given options listed above not equal 16:9 when i divide the length by the height ? (very confusing) even though 1280 X 1080 looks correct in the canvas
    2. What Frame Size and Pixel Aspect Ratio Should I be working in to get the final desired HD 16.9 export without compromising the quality by blowing my 720 x 480 size frames up to fit into the 16.9 canvas ?
    thanks so much for your advise !

    The problem you're likely seeing is due to the fact that you're trying to change the sequence settings of an HDV sequence or something like that. Instead of doing that, go into the browser and hit CMDOPTN to create a new sequence from sequence presets.
    From the preset list choose prores 1080i.
    Andy

  • Frame size and compressor

    I had captured a mini DV movie in another program as an .avi file. When I import this file as is into FCE, its properties show in the browser as:
    frame size 720 x 480
    compressor DV/DVCPRO - NTSC
    data rate 3.6 MB/sec
    I then used MPEG Streamclip to export this .avi file into a QuickTime file in 3 different ways. The methods, and resultant properties as they show in FCE, are as follows:
    Test 1:
    Compressor = Apple DV/DVCPRO - NTSC
    Frame size = 720 x 480
    Data rate = 3.6 MB/sec
    Test 2:
    Compressor = Apple Intermediate Codec
    Frame size = 720 x 480
    Data rate = 2.5 MB/sec
    Test 3:
    Compressor = Apple Intermediate Codec
    Frame size = 640 x 480
    Data rate = 2.3 MB/sec
    Observations and questions:
    In the FCE canvas, Test 1 and Test 2 look pretty much identical. Test 3 looks very slightly horizontally stretched compared to the other tests. Or, as everything's relative, Test 1 and Test 2 look very slightly horizontally compressed compared to Test 3. By the way, I placed markers in each test clip at the exact same frame to get a good comparison. Then I jumped marker to marker while looking at the canvas.
    QUESTION 1: Is FCE in fact handling these clips differently due to the different frame sizes?
    When I play the clips in QuickTime Player (not pro), Test 1 and Test 2, which both have frame size 720 x 480, are horizontally stretched. Test 3, frame size 640 x 480, is normal. The differences between the stretched and the normal are much more pronounced than they appear in the FCE canvas. When I open the ORIGINAL .avi captured clip (720 x 480) in QT Player, it is normal, not stretched like Test 1 and Test 2 which have the same 720 x 480 size.
    QUESTION 2: I know this isn't the QT forum, but is this normal behavior in QT Player?
    When I open iDVD version 7.0.3 from iLife '09, the only one of the three test clips that appears in the media browser is Test 3.
    QUESTION 3: Does anyone know why? I posted this in the iDVD forum; nobody replied.
    I then put the three test clips on the timeline in FCE and exported the sequence as a QuickTime movie. When I play it in QT Player, it is (gulp) stretched; ALL of it, not just the Test 1 and Test 2 portions. The finished .mov file DOES appear in the iDVD media browser; when I preview it there, it is STRETCHED.
    QUESTION 4: When I export .avi to QT files in MPEG Streamclip, what compressor should I choose for use in FCE?
    QUESTION 5: When I export .avi to QT files in MPEG Streamclip, what frame size should I choose for use in FCE?
    QUESTION 6: Why are FCE and QT Player handling the differences in frame size in different ways? FCE shows a very slight difference when viewed in the canvas, whereas QT Player shows a drastic stretching when playing the clips.
    Thanks for your help.

    jla930 wrote:
    QUESTION 1: Is FCE in fact handling these clips differently due to the different frame sizes?
    Apple Intermediate Codec is reserved to transcode HD content (from HDV or AVCHD). Don't use it for Stand def DV-NTSC nor PAL.
    QUESTION 2: I know this isn't the QT forum, but is this normal behavior in QT Player?
    There is a setting in quicktime player pro under movie properties (command-J) to select the correct aperture option. That's enable the correct aspect ratio when movie is opened with quicktime.
    QUESTION 3: Does anyone know why? I posted this in the iDVD forum; nobody replied.
    That's because all cool members are here.
    I then put the three test clips on the timeline in FCE and exported the sequence as a QuickTime movie. When I play it in QT Player, it is (gulp) stretched; ALL of it, not just the Test 1 and Test 2 portions. The finished .mov file DOES appear in the iDVD media browser; when I preview it there, it is STRETCHED.
    See question #2
    QUESTION 4: When I export .avi to QT files in MPEG Streamclip, what compressor should I choose for use in FCE?
    DVCPRO50-NTSC for standard definition and Apple Intermediate Codec (1080i60 or 50 or 720p) for HD.
    QUESTION 5: When I export .avi to QT files in MPEG Streamclip, what frame size should I choose for use in FCE?
    720X480 for SD, 1920X1080 or 1280X720 for HD
    QUESTION 6: Why are FCE and QT Player handling the differences in frame size in different ways? FCE shows a very slight difference when viewed in the canvas, whereas QT Player shows a drastic stretching when playing the clips.
    See question #2
    Michel Boissonneault

  • Mpeg1 custom frame size

    Hello,
    I do a lot of videos or video presentations for sales type people to use within powerpoint files. I usually supply clients with WMV files using flip4mac, which works well.
    Occasionally I see mpeg1 muxed movies that are more than the default 320x240 frame sizes. My question is 2 part - 1. Is there a quicktime/compressor way to do this? 2. Any thoughts on whether mpeg1 is a superior way to supply movies for things like inserting into powerpoint presentations?
    Thanks
    Pete

    That's pretty much the frame size of a MPEG-1 file, 320x240. There's a MPEG-1 file called Super Video (CD) that uses MPEG-2 compression for the MPEG-1 file. I think the frame size is 480x360. The video quality is still garbage. The reason you still see MPEG-1 files is that the format is still popular in India and Indonesia.
    Use h.264 for your presentation. If you use MPEG-1 you'll hate the quality.
    Open that MPEG-1 you have in Quicktime and see what the inspector window tells you what the format is.

  • Creating custom frame size for ProRes?

    This would be an addendum to my previous question about frame sizes.
    Say I have a bunch of odd-sized png files ... and want to convert them to a ProRes HQ clip ... but they have this odd size (which we need to keep). 1428 x 1050. Can I make an odd frame size ProRes HQ 8 bit clip? And if so, any tips on how to do it right?
    Ben

    This Forum is to discuss issues of the forums.  Best to post in Forum of application you are using.  Here is link to list.  http://forums.adobe.com/index.jspa

Maybe you are looking for