Best Source Video for iDVD 16:9

hi guys,
i'm creating a 16:9 dvd with idvd 08.
but what is the best source video material to import to idvd?
which resolution is the best? 768x576 / 720x576 or something different?
which Pixel-Aspect-Ratio - 1.000 / 1.066?
is dv-material the best source for that?
please, help
thanx
Message was edited by: lordpreston

A few useful links:
http://www.mmbforums.com/ipb/index.php?showtopic=18474&pid=109042&st=0&#entry109 042
http://www.ilounge.com/index.php/articles/comments/the-complete-guide-to-ipod-vi deo-conversion-mac/
http://dvinfo.net/conf/showthread.php?t=11480
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1134632&tstart=0
Message was edited by: SDMacuser

Similar Messages

Best settings to use when preparing HD source material for iDVD?

I realize iDVD is effectively abandonware, and that it was never really designed either to run on Lion nor to import high definition content...but nevertheless here I am (somewhat unavoidably) trying to do both and constantly getting the dreaded and mysterious "an error occured during movie encoding" result when I try to burn or export my project to a disc image.
If it matters, I am using a Mac Pro (1,1) with a 5770, running 10.7.5 with 8GB of RAM and oodles of free diskspace. All of my software is fully up to date, including iDVD 7.1.2 build 1158. Several utilities report nothing erroneous with my drives or their filesystems. I have made sure Perian is not installed. I have tried to create and export this DVD using both my primary user account and a clean dummy one I made for testing purposes.
After considerable trial and error experiments, each taking several hours to attempt, I've decided that I'm never going to easily figure out exacty which of my many various source files for this project (holiday videos for family) may be giving iDVD hiccups. Instead, I've decided to take another approach, making all of my content as easy to "spoon feed" to iDVD as possible. Hopefully then I can get this project done.
My question is what, ideally, does iDVD like to be fed?
For starters, I am in the process of transcoding and repackaging all of my content through MPEG Streamclip to be AIC video and uncompressed audio inside MOV containers. In each case I am scaling the video down to be 480 lines tall. Just guessing, but that seems like it would give iDVD the least possible work to "think" about and get confused. Does that sound about right to folks?
Should I be doing something drastic and old school like trying to create DV files? My content is all wide aspect, intended for a 16:9 iDVD project and that seems like it would get tricky (also, this would involve more quality loss than using AIC files).
I am totally open to suggestions here. Just please don't say "dude, use Toast" or something because while I have plenty of other tools that I know would work more easily and reliably, I really want to mimic the holiday discs from previous years that I've created using the same iDVD theme.

I haven't had to wrestle with this problem, but I've followed some of the discussions and here are several ideas and resources which seem reasonable. As background, have you read about better results from using iMovie6? Also, as you imply, DV Stream (.dv) was the native format for iDVD.
https://discussions.apple.com/message/16296991#16296991
http://blog.progravix.com/?p=456
http://support.apple.com/kb/PH5432
http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1611?viewlocale=en_US&locale=en_US
...and don't forget David Pogue's "Missing Manual" series for iMovie and iDVD are excellent resources.
John

Best export settings for iDVD?

Is there something better than "Share to Large"?
Last night I tried an export to QT as DV ("best quality", 1440x1080, interlaced 4:3) and this produced hideous results when encoded onto the DVD. Very jagged edges. Surprising, since the exported movie was gorgeous before encoding. Results like this may be what causes so many posts here about poor quality. Share to Large gave much, much better results.
I have a 3-disk project I've completed that I'm generally happy with. But I've been wondering if I could tweak up the quality a bit by exporting the iMovie project to something other than the "Share to Large" approach. That produces amazingly good results for the level of compression it achieves (about 20:1).
uh oh: I found another check box that told QT to de-interlace the source video. Not sure what effect this had.

I've finally completed my testing of various exports from iMovie 09 followed by a burn to DVD using iDVD at "Professional". DVD images were evaluated both when viewed on the Mac's DVD player and and finished DVDs were viewed on my Sony blu-ray player and Panasonic plasma TV (720p). I found no example where the disk viewed on the TV was any different than the disk image previewed on the Mac.
Bottom line - From now on I'll be using a QT export H264 at 1440x1080 when time allows, and 720x540 when I need it a little faster. Export to H264 takes much longer than exporting to AIC, but it's worth it in my testing.
In all my testing it was hard to find anything that looked better than the iMovie Share-to-Media Browser-Large option. My SD video footage looked pretty much the same no matter what I did; it was the photos that were more affected by export choice. DV and AIC were clearly inferior, giving pixelated titles, jagged, wiggly edges and so on.
Photos in the hi-rez H264 output, when viewed at double size on the Mac, were clearly sharper than the standard "large" output. I can't swear I can see the resolution difference on my TV (50", viewed from 12 feet), although I can tell the two resolutions are somewhat different when there is panning. I think the slightly sharper hi-res image actually wiggles a bit more.
I've set my blu-ray player sends a 720p image to the plasma (the most it can display). Is my progressive-vs-interlaced setup the reason why I'm getting a better result with H264 than AIC? I thought the latter was the "recommended" choice but it's very poor for my use. On the other hand, most other folks I might give a DVD to are still using old-school equipment. Should I be previewing results on an interlaced system?

What is the best iMovie codec for iDVD quality

Hello all,
I am importing analog video from an Alchemy pci card in MPEG4.
I've played around a bit but would like to know what you think is the best codec for my iMovie import that will then yield the best quality video end product from iDVD.
I am currrently using the dv codec.

yepp, that is the right choice, iM uses internal the dv-codec, same is with iDVD
any other codec has a much higher compression =>lower quality
does your pci card offer the export in dv too? would be much better in terms of pic quality, any mpeg flavor is meant as transport or playback format, not for editing/converting....

What is the best QT setting for iDVD?

Hi
I am making a Quicktime movie from a cut in Media 100. What is the best format to export for iDVD? I already tried exporting DV/DVC Pro - NTSC and it didn't look all that great (flickering and rippling on the DVD player.)
I am currently trying a straight best quality NTSC Video export. My cut is about 7:45.
thanks
JB
Dual 2 GHz PowerPC G5 Mac OS X (10.3.9)

Hi John:
Welcome to discussions!
I would use QuickTime Pro export settings, choose 'NTSC-DV' with a frame rate of 29.97. Choose 'No Compression' for audio and set the rate to 48.000 kHz.
Sue

Best Movie Format for iDVD

I have several DVDs of children's stories that I am making a backup copy protect the originals. I use iSkysoft DVD Ripper to make a movie & then load this into iDVD to burn.
I tried the Quicktime movie format & that worked fine in iDVD, but the quality was not great. I have the choice in iSkysoft of choosing several formats; QT, MPEGs 1,2 & 4, DV, ASF, & FLV MPEG-4.
I have been experimenting with the MPEGs, but iDVD will not accept them.
What is my best format choice for the best quality DVD from iDVD (I am using Professional Quality encoding)?

You need to convert the VOB files back to DV which iMovie is designed to handle. For that you need mpegStreamclip:
http://www.apple.com/downloads/macosx/video/mpegstreamclip.html
which is free, but you must also have the Apple mpeg2 plugin :
http://www.apple.com/quicktime/mpeg2/
which is a mere $20.
Another possibility is to use DVDxDV:
http://www.dvdxdv.com/NewFolderLookSite/Products/DVDxDV.overview.htm
which costs $25.
For the benefit of others who may read this thread:
Obviously the foregoing only applies to DVDs you have made yourself, or other home-made DVDs that have been given to you. It will NOT work on copy-protected commercial DVDs, which in any case would be illegal.

Best format for HD imovie export & 'archiving' source video for future

I’m sort of new to this but your help would be appreciated. I want to make sure I don’t mess up and delete any ‘precious’ moments.
I recently purchased a Canon HF100 Camcorder and have been recording various short movies and wanted to ‘plan’ for the future
1. I import the movies directly into imovie 08 without any issues (at the highest quality). I then drag the “MTS” files from my camcorder to a folder on my desktop (still compressed) and plan to save them for ‘future’ use (i.e., burn them to DVD or maybe move to an external hard drive) – I want to make sure I don’t lose any of the video ‘quality’
 Will I be able to easily ‘load’ these MTS files into imovie or other video software?
2. I currently do not have a HD DVD player or Blu Ray Player – but plan to get one in the near future. I want to make sure that when I export movies from imovie 08 I export the movie with the best HD quality.
 I’ve exported the movie using the best mac settings (.MOV) files, and they look ok on the computer, but the resolution was lower than the native resolution from the camcorder. I’ve also messed around with some of the various settings in the Quicktime, but none really looked that good with playback on the mac and there were a lot of different options I was not familiar with (maybe because I don’t have the Quicktimepro?) – anyway can anyone recommend some ‘univeral’ HD settings that I should use?
3. Once I save a movie to quicktime (or whatever the best recommended setting from #2 above), I’m assuming I can re-open or import it back into imovie and re-edit – correct?

HI there,
You need to preserve the file structure to a certain extent. Inside the Canon directory is a folder named "private" Inside that is one named "AVCHD". that's the one that needs to be saved, preserving directory structure within. It's best to save it as a disk image. Once opened, that disk image is seen as the camera by FCE or iMovie 08. Here's a thread about this on MacRumours (I'm gpeden):
http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=514751
I'm new to this too, but I have that much figured out so far:) Of course, one needs an intel Mac for this.
I'm preserving the raw files for the future in the disk images (and burning the 8 gig card's disk images to dual layer DVD - data only, for the ones I really want to backup), which assures me that any future upgrades to hardware or codecs will be able to possibly improve over what's available today.
Message was edited by: Snapt

What are the settings to for best quality video for playback on computer?

I'm not having any software or hardware issues. I have tried differnent combinations using AVI, MPEG and WMV and I'm still not satisfied with the quality.
I have used the same settings as my original video and it still is no where near the quality. Maybe this is as good as it gets, any help would be appreciated.
quick rundown
I'm using the recorder on my computer to record my screen and voice to create video tutorials for my students to watch on-line. This creates a 720x480 AVI file and has good quality.

What is the best preset to use for HD-lite?
The best is one that matches the Source Footage 100%. Unfortunately, with that variation on HD, I do not think that PrE, even PrE 10, will be able to come close. PrPro, however, does have the ability to do Custom Sequences (think a bunch of mini-Projects inside of a Project), and one can match odd Frame Sizes, FPS, etc.. I was hoping that PrE 10 would have Custom Presets, but it did not show up. This limits PrE to standard Frame Sizes, which is not what most video screen capture programs offer. Your footage does not match to any real HD-Lite Frame Sizes, so you will still have the same problem.
It does appear that your program, while different than the TechSmith Camtasia, does use the TSCC CODEC. This will give you a bit more info. Also, though you do not have Camtasia, or CamStudio, I think that the article, that I linked to above, might be of use.
Now, what options does your video capture program offer for output?
Good luck,
Hunt

Trying to output best quality video for later work on a PC?

I have a video file that was sent to me to work on, add effects to, then send back to a customer for him to incorporate into a larger video project.
I have finished my work, but am wondering what settings I should use in Compressor to maintain the best quality file that will be easily readable by PC editing software (such as Premiere)
Please, any suggestions?

The best solution is to ask to talk to the guy with the PC and ask him what he needs. Hopefully he has some clue as to what he is doing and will give you direct answer. If he doesn't know what he is doing the first question you need to ask is he working in HD or SD? Start there.
Basically you really need to talk to the other editor. If you don't then you are just wasting everyone's time.

What's the best replacement program for idvd to burn dvd's, what's the best replacement program for idvd to burn dvd's

What is the best dvd burning program to replace idvd? i'm trying to burn good quality DVD's from imovie.

There is no truly "best" replacement - I haven't found one that can do what iDVD can (customizable menus/themes).
You can still purchase the retail iLife 11 disk which includes iDVD from online resellers, ebay, and Amazon. I've seen it there for as little as $25; Apple no longer offers it - I'm assuming they ran out of stock. I purchased it because I use it extensively and wanted to make sure I can reinstall if necessary.
The closest alternative would be Roxio Toast ($$); excellent burning app (plus a slew of other things), I use it, but its' menu choices are not acceptable to me.

Settings for the best QT video for web use

I hope you didn't look here thinking I had them.
I don't but I want to know them.
I see great looking quicktime videos that perform automatically and perfectly all the time but I can't seem to make them.
Two of the best are Lynda.com and DigitalJuice.com.
Their videos play instantly, you can push the cursor to the end and the data is there. They just work great, but they are both unwilling to share what they do other than saying it's a combination of Sorenson and Quicktime.
Why is this such a closely guarded secret? I understand that it often takes weeks to uncover this combination on your own, but I've never seen this unwillingness to share in this community any stronger than in these two web sites.
Thay talk all around it but they just won't tell.
I'm hoping someone here might look at their sites and their movies and figure it out and then share it with the rest of us.
Thanks for any help you can provide.
Steve

[email protected] wrote:
> I work for a software company and we make intructional videos and product videos all the time and we are starting to use .flv's a lot more these days. I usually export them in AE and have them set to about 800kbps, preserve RGB and 15fps. But the file sizes are a little bigger then what I thought they would be, the videos are generally around 5 minutes, were green screened so there is some compositing work going on in the timeline and the file sizes are generally around 40mbs....I feel like I can get those down so any help you guys can give me would be amazing!
> Thanks
> - Jim
The 512K setting with a 2Pass encode (using On2's Flix Pro) gives me
files sizes about half of what your getting. I don't tweak anything more
than that because there really doesn't seem any need to.
(I am assuming that the size matters because you intend for web delivery
of the final product.)

Best Export Format for iDVD to cut down on multiplexing and processing

My processor is what it is and my Ram has been optimized. Is there some video/audio format/ bit rate that will require less time to convert and process?
I understand that MPEG2, mpeg4, H.264, avi, and all seem to take far too long. I prefer using FCPX and Wondershare to do my converting.
Also whenever I have a random burning error its almost always a “multiplexing error” so maybe if I make the “multiplexing” a little easier maybe I can prevent that headache.
Any thoughts about inve$ting in the fastest burners available? Isn’t the actual “burn” process the very last step that usually only takes about 2 minutes anyway?
Thank you in advance!

KidVid wrote:
My processor is what it is and my Ram has been optimized. Is there some video/audio format/ bit rate that will require less time to convert and process?
All depends on what format you need for what purpose. If you need a DVD it'll have to be MPEG-2 or for web use it'll have to be h.264. Other than that there are tons of codecs and containers available. All conversion takes time and to cut down on that time you will need a faster machine.
KidVid wrote:
Also whenever I have a random burning error its almost always a “multiplexing error” so maybe if I make the “multiplexing” a little easier maybe I can prevent that headache.
To avoid burn errors in iDVD create a disk image of your project, test that image file with DVD Player, and, if satisfied, burn with any dedicated disc burning app at no more than 4x to avoid errors.
KidVid wrote:
Any thoughts about inve$ting in the fastest burners available? Isn’t the actual “burn” process the very last step that usually only takes about 2 minutes anyway?
See the speed limit above.

What is the best output format for idvd

Am I better publishing to media browser and choosing "large," or is it better to export to Quicktime, and if so, what is the highest quality to choose for going to iDVD. This will be a presentation on a very large screen. Thanks.

The answer is: it depends. It depends on the resolution and format of the clips in your project, your aspect ratio (normal vs. widescreen), etc.
You want to try to keep the number of conversion steps at a minimum. I.e. using 640x480 source material in an iMovie '08 project, sharing as Large at 720x540 from iMovie '08 only to have it converted to 720x480 in iDVD isn't optimal as you end up with two resolution conversion steps.
Why don't you experiment with a short sample clip and a DVD-RW? Use a DVD player and a television to judge the results, not the software DVD player on your Mac.

Best export format for iDVD

I am compiling a movie in QT Pro from lots of various different iMovie projects. This will then be imported to iDVD. Is the best export setting from iMovie "large", or is there something better I should use?
(I have QT Pro) and have tried QT export with "compressor:none" and the files are great quality but unfeasible large).

I'll be honest .... I'm still shooting MiniDv tape on an old Sony 3 chip TRV900 and importing into iMovie as well as FCP via Firewire. I guess my age is starting to show. I have not yet taken the AVCHD plunge so the advice I can offer you is limited.
Anyway, so essentially you are shooting in AVCHD with the final objective of burning that to a Dvd. Is this correct? Per apple's help menu at least .... this format should work. I'm sure you've read it but I will post it here for reference purposes only.

How to best deliver video for bandwidth and copyright protection?

I'm thinking of producing some online technical video tutorials, and I am wondering how I should deliver them with the following in mind:
- I want to keep the download size as small as possible. I'm thinking of using captivate to create SWFs for each tutorial, so maybe this has nothing to do with Flex.
- I don't want anyone to be able to download the SWFs and distribute them, etc. (copyright protection).
My questions:
1) Should I simply use a VideoDisplay control, and stream the video?
2) Will users be able to right-click and save the SWF locally?
3) Will be videos be cached? That would be good to reduce data transfer on my side when users want to view multiple times, but does that mean a copy of the SWF is saved and thus accessible for misuse locally?
Any other hints on what to keep in mind when offering online video tutorials would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks!
Greg

I appreciate the suggestions, but I'm wondering about the default qualities of using video in Flex:
1) Should I simply use a VideoDisplay control, and stream the video?
2) Will users be able to right-click and save the SWF locally?
3) Will be videos be cached? That would be good to reduce data transfer on my side when users want to view multiple times, but does that mean a copy of the SWF is saved and thus accessible for misuse locally?

Best Source Video for iDVD 16:9

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for