Comparing quality of analog video conversion...Canopus vs. new camcorder

Greetings:
I have stacks of 8mm and Hi8 tapes to convert and edit in iMovie/iDVD, as well as pre-recorded VHS and some old LP's for good measure. The Canopus will do the job for me, but it's kind of pricey, so here's my questions...
•If I looked at video converted by Canopus side by side with video converted by a brand new Canon ZR700, could I tell the diference? I'm afraid that if I ever watch this stuff on a big screen TV that going the cheap route and using a camcorder for the conversion will compromise the quality.
•If I did go with a stand alone converter, does Canopus offer the best quality conversion and/or video 'enhancement'?
•Will both the Canopus and the camcorder convert pre-recorded VHS tapes, or do they handle copy protected tapes differently?
•How about audio only...I know the Canopus will do this, but how about a camcorder?
Thanks in advance for your help with this.

The Canopus uses itself DV codec, which is excellent.
Given your footage in VHS, you should realize that it will not look as good as originally shot DV.
Can't advise you on tryong to input copyprotected material.
best wishes
David
Remember to mark an response helpful or solved.
It protects the integrity of the board.

Similar Messages

  • I was advised to purchase dazzle video creator to move analog videos from an old sony camcorder to a mac.  I have purchased the dazzle and the specs seem to be for windows only.  Has anyone used this product on mac?

    I was advised to purchase dazzle video creator to move analog videos from an old sony camcorder to a mac.  I have purchased the dazzle and the specs seem to be for windows only.  Has anyone used this product on mac?

    I am not certain, but I believe there is a version of Dazzle for the Mac. However, it is not the route I would chose.
    You really need a proper analogue to digital converter, like the ADVC110, to connect to your camera via the usual RCA cables, and to your Mac via firewire.

  • Importing Analog Video via Canopus ADVC300

    When you Import video if there is a glitch in the video tape playback the imovie import stops. So if you have a an older video tape and it drops out the import stops. Is there anyway to for the import to stay running without the input affecting it?
    The Canopus 300 is a analog video to firewire converter. It does a great job otherwise.
    Thanks,
    Andrew

    Hi
    in iMovie HD 6 - I set it to not import as individual clips.
    • there are non in analog import
    • turning it off makes iMovie less sencitive to drop outs
    Cheque Your Canopus ADVC-300 manual. Think I set it so that it's not so
    sencitive to drop-outs. But may be I'm wrong in this.
    Yours Bengt W

  • Does premiere elements support analog video

    I have DVD's of analog videos burned from a 8mm Camcorder recorded in UDF format. Does Premiere Elements support analog video for editing?

    theodorepost
    Thanks for what sounds like good news.
    I see no need for you to convert those VTS_01_1.VOB files into anything else.
    Here is my suggested plan...
    a. Download and install the free 30 day tryout of Premiere Elements 12 from Adobe
    b. Put your DVD disc in the DVD burner tray. Open Premiere Elements 12 to the Expert workspace.
    Click on File Menu/New/Export and set the project preset for NTSC DV Standard or Widescreen (depending on whether
    your files are for standard 4:3 or widescreen 16:9)...do not forget the check mark next to "Force Selected Project Setting on
    This Project".
    c. Then back in the Expert workspace, use Add Media/"DVD Camera or Computer Drive"/Video Importer. In the Video Importer,
    put a check mark next to your VTS_01_1.VOB, a check mark next to Add to Timeline, and designate at Save In location. Then click
    Get Media to put the file in Project Assets and on the Timeline.
    d. Then we can gauge the situation.
    Again, if possible, do not purchase the program until you have work through the tryout in order determine if Premiere Elements 12 work for your video editing/export goals and is compatible with your computer environment.
    We will be watching for further developments.
    ATR
    Add On...If any problems (I do not expect any) with Add Media/DVD Camera or Computer Drive), we might consider Add Media/Files and Folders/ and navigate to the VTS_01_1.VOB.

  • Trouble using Canopus to convert analog videos to digital for iMovie

    I am trying to convert my old Sony HandyCam Video 8 analog videos so that I can edit them on iMovie and burn them on a disc. I have connected it as described in the directions but although my computer recognizes the device, I just get the blue import screen and no picture or sound. I have pressed play on the camera and video is running there but does not appear on the screen. Any idea what I am doing wrong? It is connected with the 6pin firewire that came with it to the computer and the DV out plug... and on the other side it is connected with the two plugs I use with the camera...Video IN and Audio IN... and Video OUT and Audio OUT on the camera. The camera is in the player mode with power on. And my computer is a new MacBook Pro with iMovie 08.
    Really need help. Thanks

    K.C.S.
    I am having the same problem ADVC-55 to MacBook Pro and iMovie 8. I was able to convert two full VHS tapes but when I started the third, no go. Red status light and nothing I have tried will get it to green. I tried myVCR and iMovie 7, also no go.
    Geoff

  • Converting old analog video with maximum resoultion for archieving and eventual use in iMovie

    There seems to be a lot of information on converting old (amatuer) analog video media to a digital format, and which one is best to preserve the maximum amount of data.  I have already imported old VHS, analog 8, hi8, and dv into iMovie interations from iMovie 6 and forward.  The later versions seem to convert the older files to their own format, I suspect, with a loss of data.  I want to reimport the old media to create masters in the best digital format for eventual editing by iMovie 11, or whatever iMovie comes after that. 
    I have the following formats:  VHS, super VHS, 8MM, Hi8, DV, and a memory card (from a camera which is not directly compatible with iMovie 11)
    I have the following equimpent:
    SONY dual deck VHS DVD.  This allows me to convert VHS directly to DVD.  I can later decode using Handbreak, and import etc. but it seems I would be losing quality.
    SONY Digital 8 handicam.  This will play analog tape and output a digital file.  I do not know the quality of the output.
    Canon VIXIA HFS100, HD camcorder.  This uses memory cards.  It is NOT compatible with iMovie 11, which I should have checked before I bought it.  I have played around with the memory card and have been able to import video but, I do not know the quality, and I've forgotten how I did it.
    MacBook Pro, about 4 years old, with a 2Ghz Intel core duo processor and 2GHz Ram.  This is obviously not state of the art.  I am willing to upgrade within the Mac family but I don't what to upgrade to for my purposes
    Canopus ADVC 110. This as DV out via a firewire port, and a DV in/out.  It also has svideo in, and composit in.
    I have the following software:
    iMovie 6, iMovie 9, and iMovie 11.  I am fairly comfortable with each version.
    Final Cut Express, circa 2006.  I would have to learn this.
    Handbreak.  I use this to rip the DVDs I made with SONY deck.  It outputs all kinds of video codecs but is obviously working with compressed imput files.  I don't know if I could get it to accept input directly from one of the cameras or the Canopus.
    Audacity.  I'm using this to combine audio tracks from various sources to add commentary to silent videos, which i would like to add as a voice over track to my iMovies
    Toast.  I think this can convert files of one video format to another in the process of copying.
    Thanks for any advice on any part of this question.
    Steve B

    Yes
    I found a program but am experiencing lots of trouble with it. I was hoping that others could give me a better suggestion.
    I've actually downloaded and installed ffmpeg but the problem I'm experiencing now is that the videos do not convert. The program starts to work and then three seconds later I get the dialog box that says everything has been converted but the file created is 0KB and of course will not open.
    Any ideas about what could be going wrong? I've attempted to convert the files to different formats and try converting different files as well. I still have the problem.

  • Converting analog to digital:  Canopus, etc. vs. Camcorder

    I have a bunch of old analog tapes and, unfortunately, a digital camcorder that doesn't take analog input. So I need to acquire some new hardware to convert the tapes (I have the old analog camcorder for playback). Is there any reason I should get something like a Canopus, or other converter box, rather than simply buying a used camera off Ebay (understanding the risks of buying used), and then reselling it when done? Looks like there are more used camcorders than used Canopus units. Or, the Canon Elura 100 is available around $300. Guessing that I could use that for a week, in the house only, and sell it on Ebay and lose less than the cost of a Canopus unit. Of course, I guess a Canopus could be resold as well.
    Any ideas on the best option here? Part of the equation, of course, is the quality of conversion.

    the step of creating a digital tape from the analog tape, with a digital camera, adds an extra step.
    Some camcorders feature also analog-to-DV passthrough so you don't have to store the material on a tape if you don't want to.
    But it also creates the digital tape to save as an archive, right?
    Yes. This is why I 1st transferred my old VHS tapes to digital tape, eventhough my camcorder supports* a-to-dv passthrough. I fianlly wanted to backup those precious tapes.
    *This works with iMovie 1-4 only... iMovie 5-6 broke the a-to-dv passthrough feature of my Sony TRV320E. This is why I still have also iMovie 4 installed.
    BTW, I haven't seen any good tests whether dedicated converters offer any better quality than the a-to-dv chips inside camcorders.

  • Captured analog video, where does the actual captured file go?

    I am backing up old analog video 8 tapes to digital, using a Canopus ADVC-55 converter. The process is going just fine as far as I can tell, but I am sure I will have more questions as I get into this further. I am using FCP 6.04.
    As an initial test, I completed a Capture Now (non-controllable device selected) of a short 30 min. analog tape, using an older video 8 Sony Handicam, running through the Canopus interfacing with FCP. Primarily I want to run through all these old tapes (about 15 of them…) and back them up onto a dedicated Iomega external firewire drive, to retrieve for later use.
    Question du jour… Where the heck is the actual data file on the hard drive? Isn’t the file I see in the bin, from a result of the capture, just an alias pointing to the actual captured data file? The FCP document is only 24 KB, but I know the data file is much larger. I have searched the drive high and low but cannot locate it… Can anyone answer this? Also, I’ve read in discussions here about doing transfer to DV (I have a Canon digital camcorder I could use) rather than the hard drive… but if this is for backup purposes only, should that matter? And wouldn’t I lose a step of quality that way?

    I understand Kevan. For the time being, all I wanted to do was get these old 8 mm tapes backed up to digital format because I am afraid the tapes will degrade. They are about 12 years old. I also have some VHS cassettes that are much older that I plan to back up also.
    Eventually I would like to build some family movies and will use these files, but if you think I should be capturing into DV (I can use my Canon DV camcorder I guess) I will do that instead.
    Also, I will go ahead and define the folder so I can find the files more easily in the future.
    I sure appreciate that you are taking the time to answer these questions, thanks again.

  • Trouble capturing analog video using Quicktime 7 in Yosemite

    I am attempting to use Quicktime 7 Pro under Yosemite to convert old 8 mm or Hi8 analog videotapes to digital .mov files. The tapes are being played through a Sony TRV350 camcorder, which digitizes the analog video, and outputs digital video via the iLink (Firewire) output, which then goes to the Thunderbolt input on my MacBook Pro using an adapter. I start the camcorder and then start QT7 Pro.
    This DOES WORK - for a short while. After taking in 32MB of data or a minute (of a 90 minute video), QT7 stops capturing data with a message:
    "Recording stopped because the format of the source media changed. Media of different formats cannot be recorded to the same file"
    What does this mean and how do I get around it?
    PS: There are not many ways to convert these old tapes. Under Yosemite iMovie will no longer accept video from a Hi8 camcorder. There is some discussion of older iMovie HD but this does not work properly under Yosemite at all.
    Need to digitize these old family tapes - any help will be appreciated

    One tiny wrinkle is that "Save" from Vidi gives an error message but "Save as" works fine. I suspect Vidi may also stop working with the next OS X release.
    Since you did not indicate the specific nature of the error message, I don't know if this is a "fixable" problem or not. The difference between the "Save/Record" and "Save As.../Record As..." options is that the former automatically stored the captured files in a designated location using a default filename. You may wish to check or reset the preference settings here to see they are causing your issue.
    Yes, the conversion of a 90 min tape does give a 21 GB file but I don't care - these family videos are irreplaceable and storage is cheap.
    This sounds about right—i.e, the normal average DV-25/DVCPRO-25 total data rate is on the order of 28.5 Mbps (or about 13 GB/hour) with DV-50/DVCPRO-50 about 57 Mbps and DV-100/HDV about 114 Mbps.
    One more question. Now that I have a DV file, what can I use to convert to a more compressed format that preserves quality? QT7 to save as H.264 is best? Or something else? Toast?
    This normally depends on your goals and personal workflow preferences.
    For instance, if you are editing content (i.e., trimming; merging; adding titles, fades, transitions, effects, etc.), I would normally use the export/share options that are available from within the editing app itself. On the other hand, for simple trims and export/share of files, I would normally use QT X or QT 7 Pro depending on the specific project needs and/or level of manual control desired. For totally edit-free conversions, I would normally use the encoder options now built into Yosemite (or Mavericks) operating system at the Finder level or the free HandBrake app. (The former basically employs a non-anamorphic approach with high/low quality or target device controlled quality options while the latter has a better graphic user interface for anamorphic strategies with more manual control for truly customized exports as needed.)
    EXAMPLE 1: The family normal has Thanksgiving at my brother-in-laws home in PA so my son hosts a second "pseudo-Thanksgiving" dinner on January 1st for the relatives here in NJ. This year I wore a GoPro and within minutes of returning home created the following "trailer" of the gathering (with a total absence of any real planning or forethought) using iMovie to shared the file directly to Mail for posting to others. In this case, I used the video editor to both edit and share a "quickie" video with the rest of our relatives from the East to West Coast. I.e., it seemed the most efficient workflow for the mini-project... SAMPLE VIDEO
    EXAMPLE 2: On the other hand, several yeas ago I was asked to post a "quickie" tutorial showing how to layer audio and video content. As this was a relatively simple project, I used QT 7 Pro for this project. Here is the resulting SAMPLE FILE created while making the tutorial.
    EXAMPLE 3: In cases where the quality of the source file varies drastically—one video being an 80 year old cinema classic and the next a just released blockbuster loaded with special effects—and/or the source files are not "natively" compatible with QT, I prefer HandBrake for its ability to "tweak" settings over a wide range to create "universal" playback files for all mobile devices, local network streaming, and sharing via internet... SAMPLE 1959 TRAILER
    EXAMPLE 4: Lastly, when I simply want to just transcode one or more QT compatible files (for any number of reasons) at the Finder level without having to open a dedicated converter utility, I simply select/highlight the files in the Finder and pass them to the Yosemite/Mavericks operating system for conversion... POCKET RECORDER SAMPLE FILE
    As you can see, you have a myriad of options to choose from depending on your personal preferences, needs, goals, etc. As to H.24/X.264/MPEG-4 AVC, yes I would recommend sticking with any encoder that adheres to the JVT standard since it has become a default Mac system standard and, with different settings, is extremely scaleable with regard to use—i.e., it can handle anything from cellular streaming to Blu-ray or multi-K Hi-Def resolutions. However, for all-purpose use, I stick to High Profile (current mobile, TV, High-Speed Internet compatible) or Main Profile (older mobile device, original TV, lower-speed platform compatible) anamorphic encodes at level 3.1 which nicely covers data rates from less then 100 Kbps up to 14 Mbps or anything most users will ever need.

  • Changing color and contrast before capturing analog video?

    Is it possible to change color (colorcast / saturation and contrast etcetera) before capturing analog video in Final Cut (software)? I have some old dv tapes I would like to upscale to hd and are considering to upscale via the super vhs outlet / connector on the camera through an I/O box (maybe Matrox).
    Do you loose much quality when compared to capturing from DV (digital capture)? I would like to make "a first generation" good capture.....

    You would need a capture card and a deck with built in controls, or an external TBC that works with compatible decks. Not every deck allows for this external control.
    S-VHS or component out would be lesser quality than straight DV capture via firewire. Via firewire it is lossless...straight digital capture. analog capture is a loss of quality. Capture as DV and then upscale with After Effects or Compressor...or get a DV deck with SDI out and capture with...oh, the Mini doesn't do SDI. You'd need the MXO2 LE for best quality capture. With your options, the best bet would be capture as DV and then use Compressor. Or spring for the Matrox MXO2 LE.
    Sorry, good quality costs...
    Shane

  • Capture analog video audio for MacBook

    Is there an inexpensive way to get analog video and audio in/out using my MacBook? I'll be using Final Cut Pro 5.1 Studio to edit. Most of my media will be from my BetaCam SX camera. I will be exporting to DVD, Beta and who knows what for broadcast and internet. Thanks for the help. Gary
    MacBook    
    MacBook    

    The cheapest viable choice you have is to go DV-rez for your project. All you'll need is a Firewire breakout box such as a Canopus, Pyro AV, or other similar box - they usually cost around the $200 mark.

  • Is there a way to shorten iMovie video conversion ?

    I am starting with a "m2ts" video file.
    I purchased a video conversion program from the Mac App Store.   It is called “AnyVideo converter HD".  It is well reviewed.
    So, I dropped in my "m2ts" file.  I set the conversion to "Computer MOV 720p HD".  "AnyVideo converter HD" converted a 1 minute video in about 15 seconds to a "mov".   The converted file had excellent picture quality and sound, it played perfectly using QuickTime.
    When I dropped this 60 second clip into iMovie 06 (set for 720p) it's conversion process took 35 minutes ?!?!   The result was flawless!  However, a two-hour video conversion would not be complete until about the time Capt. Kirk joins Starfleet.
    How can I speed this up ?

    baltwo - thank you for the expert advice. 
    I did as you instructed and the situation is better but I don't believe it's solved. 
    I still get 3 versions of Photoshop when I right click on a PSD.  I also get Dashcode and Textwrangler - which are the oddest associations.  All together I get 25 apps responding to "Open With" on a PSD.  And this is an improvement.
    Do you think I would get even better results if I ran the same command again?
    Thanks again.
    JL

  • What should I expect in quality? Make video better? optimize?

    Hello
    I'm using iChat 3.1 for the first time. I have tried using both a AIM account and .mac account. The software works fine for me. My question is
    1) what should I expect in terms of video quality? Is there something out there I can compare it to? I must say it is not the resolution I was expecting. I guess mine looks good as a 3" x 3" screen but strtching it to 12 x 12 is pretty bad. Is this what it's supposed to look like? is there a way to optimize it? I read somewhere that the bad video was a function of AIM? and if you go through this "other way" it will be better. (can't find that info I read!)
    2)Alternatively, could I theoretically network my computer and my mom's, and then have a better video session using another video access. (don't know which one or how)
    3) I have also tried using my wireless access and the video is much worse and the audio is delayed, so I switched back to ethernet. Am I doing something wrong?
    At this point I would only be videoing with this one other computer.
    thanks for any help
    iMac G5   Mac OS X (10.4.7)   using iSIght on one and DV-camera on other

    Hello Gina,
    Welcome to apple discussions. The video quality on ichatav depends on many factors:
    1. Bandwidth limitations of your ISP
    2. CPU speed (the faster the better)
    3. The size of the actual chat window (the bigger, the lower the quality) Full screen ichatav can be marginal at best.
    4. Lighting
    5. Unusually fast motion or panning will effect your video quality
    6. Camera quality ... Generally Mini DV cameras capture great quality. In fact they often get significantly better picture quality than most web cams. Firewire cameras are generally far better than most usb devices.
    7. iChat video pref. settings will effect video quality (try setting video preferences to "None").
    8. The connection doctor is a useful tool w/in ichatav. However having it constantly open during a video chat can actually slow the application down a bit and hence may also effect video quality. Check it quickly and then close it after you see all is working as expected. Do not leave it constantly open during a video chat or while attempting to start a video chat.
    9. Having several applications open while video chatting can also effect the quality of your video chat/s.
    10. Hosting a 3 way video conference will run significantly slower and at lower frame rate than video chatting with just one other party at a time.
    And according to Ian Bickerstaff, the following also effects quality:
    LIGHTS:
    In system preferences ( from the Blue Apple top left of your screen there )
    System preferences > Personal > Desktop&Screensaver > Desktop > Solid Colours.
    Select the pure white option ( Its invisible - Just click to the right of the last colour option )
    That increases the light thrown onto your face. It also prevents any odd discolouration that can come with using darker back grounds.
    Use a local Spot light to light just you in a larger room. Very atmospheric
    Use the video preview before you start a video chat to make sure that your image is "up to scratch" Play around with the amount of light and where it is positioned.
    SOUND:
    Is the volume set correctly? Setting it at 75% seems to be the best option.
    CAMERA:
    If you wear glasses try to get the camera in a position where by the screen does not block out your eyes.
    Look at the camera - It sort of implies "making eye contact" - Instead of looking at the screen. Placing the video " window " as near as you can to the camera helps ( thanks Sillydog )
    If its a family chat - Place the camera so that all people can be seen and move the microphone ( if you have one ) so all people can be heard.
    ACTION: Not just yet....
    Are you sitting comfortably? Is it going to be a long chat? Do you have a drink to hand? Do you know what you want to say?
    If there is a phone in the room - Do you want to turn it off to avoid interruption?
    SDMacuser

  • Import Analog Video

    Hi,
    I would like to import analog video into my Mac so that I can edit and extract video. I have many analog video tapes and I would like to import into my Mac. I can output video to my analog video camera or to a VCR but can't input. There is a unit, Elgato's EyeTV, for viewing TV that imports but I don't plan on watching TV on my Mac. I hear you can burn to DVD with a VHS-DVD deck and Extract from the DVD using software (Hand-Brake).
    I saw a cheap unit that works with Windows which interfaces through, I believe, USB 2 port but it didn't seem to be Mac suported.
    Looking for suggestions I have open slots on my G4 Mac for PCI cards.
    Richard
    1.25 GHz Dual G4 Desk Top   Mac OS X (10.4.9)  
    1.25 GHz Dual G4 Desk Top   Mac OS X (10.4.9)  

    There is a unit, Elgato's EyeTV,...
    It is possible to use the Elgato EyeTV devices (and EyeTV software) to capture analog video. The Elgato devices record mpg-2 video on your hard drive and you can then use something like DVDxDV or MPEG-Streamclip to convert the mpg-2 content to DV video for use in iMovie,
    Since you will be starting with VHS tapes, you shouldn't loose any additional quality in the process.
    F Shippey

  • Getting analog video over DVI

    I have a Samsung monitor connected to my 17" Macbook Pro using the Mini-Display to DVI adapter and a DVI cable. However, I believe I'm somehow getting analog video converted to a digital signal. I believe this because:
    1.) The picture is noticeably not as sharp. It looks like analog video.
    2.) If I reboot in Windows (via BootCamp) I get a much sharper picture - looks like digital video
    3.) When the OS X first boots up I get static on the monitor, like you get on an analog TV when you can't get the station.
    Anyone have any ideas about how to tell OS X to output digital video? Do I need to install a driver for the monitor?
    Thanks.

    Hi igril,
    both apps, iM and iDVD, expect signals via firewire; both apps using this standard, because a) it is more reliable then usb and b) the specs of fw allow a "generic" set of protocols to remotely control devices (a usb connected camcorder needs "drivers").
    b) 30 frames per second in realtime into 768x576 pixles plus color info plus audio with a sampling rate of 44.1Khz... just simple A/D .. ehm, well...
    in the PC market you find some cheapo usb "sticks", claiming to digitize.. but with a much smaller res...
    Apple decided in meaning of simplicity, convenience and quality, not to go this route...
    inexpansive? ebay some used miniDV with analogue-in or an old Formac box...

Maybe you are looking for