Sort of singleton pattern , design question

Hi
i need to a class which has only one instance( can use a singleton pattern) but the problem is there have to be some variables to be initialised and this class will not know how to initialise them, how do i desin it
public class MyData
private String data;
private String data2;
private static MyData instance;
public MyData getInstance()
return instance;
public String doSomeThing(String parm3)
// but parm1 and parm2 are not initalised, they are common for all classes,
// how do i desing it
return parm1 + parm2 + parm3;
ashish

hi
I know it is not a good desing , but my problem is
that my SingleTon pattern is sort of worker class,
which will be accessed from many other classes, these
classes also dont know the values of parm1 and parm2
required by the worker class,
these values are setup by the startup java class
which reads them from a properties file, this worker
class has no knowledge of this properties file and
hence cannot retrieve it...
so what are my optionsHave the singleton get the values itself from system properties, or a file or database or java.util.Preferences or some other appwide configuration.
Or do what DrC suggested and have a factory do that and let the factory push the values to the singleton.
, i dont want to make these
variables static since there will be problem in my
applicationAnd what problem would that be?

Similar Messages

  • Is abap thread safe? Some question in Singleton pattern in ABAP

    Hi Grus,
    I have a very basic question but really make me headache...
    Recently I am learning the design pattern in ABAP and as you know in JAVA there is a key word "Synchronized" to keep thread safe. But in ABAP, I didn't find any key words like that. So does that mean ABAP is always a single thread language? And I found that there is a way looks like "CALL FUNCTION Remotefunction STARTING NEW TASK Taskname DESTINATION dest" to make multi-thread works. As you can see it use the destination, so does that mean actually the function module is always executed in a remote system, and in every system, it is always single thread?
    Could you help me on the question? Thanks a lot, grus
    And here comes up to my mind another question...It's a little bit mad but I think it may works....What if I set every attribute and method as static in the singleton class...Since as you can see it is already a singleton so every attribute in it should be only one piece. So then I don't even need to implement a get_instance( ) method to return the instance. Just call "class_name=>some_method( )" directly then singleton is achieved...What do you think?
    BR,
    Steve

    Steve,
    I've the same question, few days ago I tried to use the singleton in ABAP. In Java programming is possible to use the same reference in two sessions or programs, sharing attributes, methods and all data, but I could not do in ABAP.
    In my test I created a program with one global class using the singleton pattern, so I expected that when I run my program and see the reference returned after the get_instance method it should be equal to the same program run in another session, but the ABAP will create a new reference and instantiate again.
    So I deduced that the only way to share it between sessions in ABAP is using the ABAP Shared Memory Objects.
    I can be wrong, but I think that ABAP use a thread by user session (Each window) and we can't change it.
    Best regards.

  • Per Web Application singleton pattern

    Hello
    I have a application (ear) file that look something like this:
    App.ear
    -- Web_1.war
    ----- WEB-INF/lib/helper.jar
    -- Web_2.war
    ----- WEB-INF/lib/helper.jar
    -- Web_3.war
    ----- WEB-INF/lib/helper.jar
    inside helper.jar there is a singleton class., which get initialised differently depending on which Web_<X> it is loaded in. This currently works because each lib directory get loaded by each own classloader.
    I would really like to move the helper.jar up to the <ear file>/lib directory, but that means it is only loaded by the classloaders once anf thus the 3 singletons break as there is now only one.
    I would like to have some sort of "Per Web application" globally reachable "singleton".
    I have thought about using ServletContext, but it appears that there is no easy ways for helper classes to look it up, unless it is passed as a parameter.
    A second idea would be to use ThreadLocals, but that would rely on the Web container not reusing threads accross web applications. I am not sure if this is guranteed not to happen ...
    In any case, what is the best way to handle this ? is there any standard way or a design pattern to follow...

    I suppose another way of asking this question is this:
    is there a way to use the singleton pattern on a
    per-web-application basis without storing the
    singleton in the ServletContext? If I can find a way
    to do that, I can solve my initial problem.Some web application servers run each webapp in a separate JVM, or at least a separate classloader. If yours does either of those, then each webapp will have its own instance of the singleton. Try it.

  • Design question for database connection in multithreaded socket-server

    Dear community,
    I am programming a multithreaded socket server. The server creates a new thread for each connection.
    The threads and several objects witch are instanced by each thread have to access database-connectivity. Therefore I implemented factory class which administer database connection in a pool. At this point I have a design question.
    How should I access the connections from the threads? There are two options:
    a) Should I implement in my server class a new method like "getDatabaseConnection" which calls the factory class and returns a pooled connection to the database? In this case each object has to know the server-object and have to call this method in order to get a database connection. That could become very complex as I have to safe a instance of the server object in each object ...
    b) Should I develop a static method in my factory class so that each thread could get a database connection by calling the static method of the factory?
    Thank you very much for your answer!
    Kind regards,
    Dak
    Message was edited by:
    dakger

    So your suggestion is to use a static method from a
    central class. But those static-methods are not realy
    object oriented, are they?There's only one static method, and that's getInstance
    If I use singleton pattern, I only create one
    instance of the database pooling class in order to
    cionfigure it (driver, access data to database and so
    on). The threads use than a static method of this
    class to get database connection?They use a static method to get the pool instance, getConnection is not static.
    Kaj

  • Example for singleton pattern

    Describe a class in the JDK that uses the Singleton design pattern

    I am sorry............... could you please explain a
    class in JDK which follews singleton pattern?
    I was asked this question in an interview yesterday?See reply #2 for a fine example of a potential Singleton object.
    kind regards,
    Jos

  • Design questions on using JMX

    I have been reading about JMX and trying to understand it
    I have some specific design realted questions and wanted some opinions to validate my understanding
    Assume a simple j2ee application that exposes 2 webservices .
    I would like to find out how many times each service is called and the total number of success/faults/errors
    encountered for each service along with params like starttime etc
    From what I have understood , I will have to first create a Bean , say "StatsCollector"
    and then creae a StatsCollectorMBean interface.
    The StatsCollector will provide the methods to set/update the above values and those will also be exposed by the StatsCollectorMBean interface
    1) I have trouble understanding how to create and maintain the MBean Resource...
    Shouldnt there be always 1 instance of this resource ? ie shouldnt there be only one StatsCollector ?
    Most of the examples create a simple class "Hello implements HelloMBean" and that makes it a MBean
    but they create Hello hello = new Hello() and then register it with the MBean server
    What if we create multiple objects of Hello? Wouldnt that defeat the porpose of the MBean ?
    I think that we need to make sure that this resource is always created once only.
    Is that correct ?
    2) Is it the right practice to separate your MBean and your "managed" resource ?
    ie in the above case , should there be a Singleton StatsCollector POJO that stores the Appliction
    statistics and another StatsMBean that will be the MBean that will access the POJO ? This makes sure that your Resource does not have
    dependency management classes.
    3) How does the application update the values in the MBean ?
    In the above example , how do you update the success and failure counts in the MBean from the application ?
    Can I update the singleton StatsCollector directly or do I have to go through the MBean Server to update
    any value in the MBean ?
    If I update them directly , will they be "visible" thru the MBean server ?
    4) Assuming that the above app gets deployed in a appserver like WebSphere and in a Clustered environment ,
    how to ensure that statisitcs are collected for all the services on all servers cummulativly ?
    Is this something that the appserver should provide ? Do we register the MBean with the Appserver
    MBean server ?
    Any ideas/suggestions will be helpful !
    thanks
    Pat

    Hello pat,
    very interesting questions. You are covering the main JMX design questions there.
    You should have a look (if you not already did) to the JMX best practices : http://java.sun.com/javase/technologies/core/mntr-mgmt/javamanagement/best-practices.jsp
    This document summarize common JMX design patterns.
    Answers to your questions:
    1) The resources you want to manage/monitor are Web Services. The life cycle of these services is handled by the J2EE container itself. As you say, the tricky part is to link the WebService resource life cycle to the MBean resource
    The MBean leaves inside its own container, the MBeanServer.
    You should identify an initialization phase in which you create your MBeans and register them inside the MBeanServer once.
    In your case, you can go for a single collector that monitors the 2 Web Services or a collector per Web Service. It seems that you want to track each service independently. Having 2 MBeans should offer a more flexible solution.
    If you go for 1 MBean, you should name it "<your management domain>:type=StatsCollector". This name identify an MBean for which you have a single instance. Once the collector registered with this name, the MBeanServer will guarantee that no MBean with the same name can be registered.
    If you go for 2 MBeans, you should add the Web Service name to each MBean ObjectName. For example:
    MBean 1 : "<your management domain>:type=StatsCollector,name=MyWebService1"
    MBean 2 : "<your management domain>:type=StatsCollector,name=MyWebService2"
    Example of MBean creation and registration code :
    StatsCollector collector1 = new StatsCollector();
    ManagementFactory.getPlatformMBeanServer().registerMBean(collector1,
    new ObjectName("com.foo.bar:type=StatsCollector,name=WebService1");
    At this point you have an MBean registered inside the platform MBeanServer.
    2) A Standard MBean is formed of a java interface and a class. Generally the interface and the class are not separated. They could be but I don't see a strong reason in your case to have the POJO and interface not being the same object.
    3) You shouldn't expose the methods to set the values in your MBean interface. Only getters should be visible. It means that you will have to keep a direct reference to the collectors to update the statistics. During your initialization phase, you could use JNDI to register the collector instances. The WebServices will then use JNDI to retrieve the collectors.
    An example of a simplified StatsCollector class and StatsCollectorMBean interface
    public interface StatsCollectorMBean {
    public int getNumRequests();
    public class StatsCollector implements StatsCollectorMBean {
    private int numRequests.
    public int getNumRequests() {
    return average;
    public serviceCalled() {
    numRequests++;
    In the above example, serviceCalled is not part of the management interface and is called by the Web Service.
    4) Difficult question for which I can't provide you with a reply. JMX doesn't offer such cumulative service in a standard way. In some appserver (glassfish for instance), MBeans are cascaded inside the domain server. There is no cumulative representation offered, but you could implement your own by defining new MBeans linked to the StatsCollector ones.
    To conclude, Appservers are offering some "out of the box" management and monitoring features . For example glassfish relies on the AMX framework (that is JMX based) . AMX (https://glassfish.dev.java.net/javaee5/amx/) allows you to monitor and manage your services. A possible solution would be to rely on this infrastructure to build your own management and monitoring.
    Hope this help.
    Regards.
    Jean-Francois Denise

  • How we can limit the number of concurrent calls to a WCF service without use the Singleton pattern or without do the change in BizTalk Configuration file?

    How can we send only one message to a WCF service at a time? How we can limit the number of concurrent calls to a WCF service without use the Singleton pattern or without do the change in BizTalk Configuration file? Can we do it by Host throttling?

    Hi Pawan,
    You need to use WCF-Custom adapter and add the ServiceThrottlingBehavior service behavior to a WCF-Custom Locations.
    ServiceThrottlingBehavior.MaxConcurrentCalls - Gets or sets a value that specifies the maximum number of messages actively processing across a ServiceHost. The MaxConcurrentCalls property specifies the maximum number of messages actively
    processing across a ServiceHost object. Each channel can have one pending message that does not count against the value of MaxConcurrentCalls until WCF begins to process it.
    Follow MSDN-
    http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ee377035%28BTS.10%29.aspx
    http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/system.servicemodel.description.servicethrottlingbehavior.maxconcurrentcalls.aspx
    I hope this helps.
    Rachit
    If this answers your question please mark it accordingly. If this post is helpful, please vote as helpful by clicking the upward arrow mark next to my reply.

  • Design question: Scheduling a Variable-timeslot Resource

    I originally posted this in general java programming, because this seemed like a more high-level design descussion. But now I see some class design questions. Please excuse me if this thread does not belong here (this is my first time using the forum, save answering a couple questions).
    Forum,
    I am having trouble determining a data structure and applicable algorithm (actually, even more general than the data structure -- the general design to use) for holding a modifiable (but more heavily read/queried than updated), variable-timeslot schedule for a given resource. Here's the situation:
    Let's, for explanation purposes, say we're scheduling a school. The school has many resources. A resource is anything that can be reserved for a given event: classroom, gym, basketball, teacher, janitor, etc.
    Ok, so maybe the school deal isn't the best example. Let's assume, for the sake of explanation, that classes can be any amount of time in length: 50 minutes, 127 minutes, 4 hours, 3 seconds, etc.
    Now, the school has a base operation schedule, e.g. they're open from 8am to 5pm MTWRF and 10am to 2pm on saturday and sunday. Events in the school can only occur during these times, obviously.
    Then, each resource has its own base operation schedule, e.g. the gym is open from noon to 5pm MTWRF and noon to 2pm on sat. and sun. The default base operation schedule for any resource is the school which "owns" the resource.
    But then there are exceptions to the base operation schedule. The school (and therefore all its resources) are closed on holidays. The gym is closed on the third friday of every month for maintenance, or something like that. There are also exceptions to the available schedule due to reservations. I've implemented reservations as exceptions with a different status code to simplify things a little bit: because the basic idea is that an exception is either an addition to or removal from the scheduleable times of that resource. Each exception (reservation, closed for maintenance, etc) can be an (effectively) unrestricted amount of time.
    Ok, enough set up. Somehow I need to be able to "flatten" all this information into a schedule that I can display to the user, query against, and update.
    The issue is complicated more by recurring events, but I think I have that handled already and can make a recurring event be transparent from the application point of view. I just need to figure out how to represent this.
    This is my current idea, and I don't like it at all:
    A TimeSlot object, holding a beginning date and ending date. A data structure that holds list of TimeSlot objects in order by date. I'd probably also hold an index of some sort that maps some constant span of time to a general area in the data structure where times around there can be found, so I avoid O(n) time searching for a given time to find whether or not it is open.
    I don't like this idea, because it requires me to call getBeginningDate() and getEndDate() for every single time slot I search.
    Anyone have any ideas?

    If I am correct, your requirement is to display a schedule, showing the occupancy of a resource (open/closed/used/free and other kind of information) on a time line.
    I do not say that your design is incorrect. What I state below is strictly my views and should be treated that way.
    I would not go by time-slot, instead, I would go by resource, for instance the gym, the class rooms (identified accordingly), the swimming pool etc. are all resources. Therefore (for the requirements you have specified), I would create a class, lets say "Resource" to represent all the resources. I would recommend two attributes at this stage ("name" & "identifier").
    The primary attribute of interest in this case would be a date (starting at 00:00hrs and ending at 24:00hrs.), a span of 24hrs broken to the smallest unit of a minute (seconds really are not very practical here).
    I would next encapsulate the availability factor, which represents the concept of availability in a class, for instance "AvailabilityStatus". The recommended attributes would be "date" and "status".
    You have mentioned different status, for instance, available, booked, closed, under-maintainance etc. Each of these is a category. Let us say, numbered from 0 to n (where n<128).
    The "date" attribute could be a java.util.Date object, representing a date. The "status", is byte array of 1440 elements (one element for each minute of the day). Each element of the byte array is populated by the number designation of the status (i.e, 0,1,2...n etc.), where the numbers represent the status of the minute.
    The "Resource" class would carry an attribute of "resourceStatus", an ordered vector of "ResourceStatus" objects.
    The object (all the objects) could be populated manually at any time, or the entire process could be automated (that is a separate area).
    The problem of representation is over. You could add any number of resources as well as any number of status categories.
    This is a simple solution, I do not address the issues of querying this information and rendering the actual schedule, which I believe is straight forward enough.
    It is recognized that there are scope for optimizations/design rationalization here, however, this is a simple and effective enough solution.
    regards
    [email protected]

  • SOA real-time design question

    Hi All,
    We are currently working with SOA Suite 11.1.1.4. I have a SOA application requirement to receive real-time feed for six data tables from an external third party. The implementation consists of five one-way operations in the WSDL to populate the six database tables.
    I have a design question. The organization plans to use this data across various departments which requires to replicate or supply the data to other internal databases.
    In my understanding there are two options
    1) Within the SOA application fork the data hitting the web-service to different databases.
    My concern with this approach is what if organizations keep coming with such requests and I keep forking and supplying multiple internal databases with the same data. This feed has to be real-time, too much forking with impact the performance and create unwanted dependencies for this critical link for data supply.2) I could tell other internal projects to get the data from the populated main database.
    My concern here is that firstly the data is pushed into this database flat without any constraints and it is difficult to query to get specific data. This design has been purposely put in place to facilitate real-time performance.Also asking every internal projects to get data from main database will affect its performance.
    Please suggest which approach should I take (advantage/disadvantage. Apart from the above two solutions, is there any other recommended solution to mitigate the risks. This link between our organization and external party is somewhat like a lifeline for BAU, so certainly don't want to create more dependencies and overhead.
    Thanks

    I had tried implementing the JMS publisher/subscriber pattern before, unfortunately I experienced performance was not so good compared to the directly writing to the db adapter. I feel the organization SOA infrastructure is not setup correctly to cope with the number of messages coming through from external third party. Our current setup consists of three WebLogic Servers (Admin, SOA, BAM) all running on only 8GB physical RAM on one machine. Is there Oracle guideline for setting up infrastructure for a SOA application receiving roughly 600000 messages a day. I am using SOA 11.1.1.4. JMS publisher/subscriber pattern just does not cope and I see significant performance lag after few hours of running. The JMS server used was WebLogic JMS
    Thanks
    Edited by: user5108636 on Jun 13, 2011 4:19 PM
    Edited by: user5108636 on Jun 13, 2011 7:03 PM

  • Serializing a class that implements the Singleton pattern

    Hello,
    I am relatively new to Java and especially to serialization so the answer to this question might be obvious, but I could not make it work event though I have read the documentation and the article "Using XML Encoder" that was linked from the documentation.
    I have a class that implements the singleton pattern. It's definition is as follows:
    public class JCOption implements Serializable {
      private int x = 1;
      private static JCOption option = new JCOption();
      private JCOption() {}
      public static JCOption getOption() { return option; }
      public int getX() { return x; }
      public void setX(int x) { this.x = x; }
      public static void main(String args[]) throws IOException {
        JCOption opt = JCOption.getOption();
        opt.setX(10);
        XMLEncoder encoder = new XMLEncoder(new BufferedOutputStream(new FileOutputStream("Test.xml")));
        encoder.setPersistenceDelegate(opt.getClass(),  new JCOptionPersistenceDelegate());
        encoder.writeObject(opt);
        encoder.close();
    }Since this class does not fully comply to the JavaBeans conventions by not having a public no-argument constructor, I have create a class JCOptionPersistenceDelegate that extends the PersistenceDelegate. The implementation of the instantiate method is as follows:
      protected Expression instantiate(Object oldInstance, Encoder out) {
           Expression expression = new Expression(oldInstance, oldInstance.getClass(), "getOption", new Object[]{});
            return expression;
      }The problem is that the resulting XML file only contains the following lines:
        <java version="1.5.0_06" class="java.beans.XMLDecoder">
            <object class="JCOption" property="option"/>
        </java> so there is no trace of the property x.
    Thank you in advance for your answers.

    How about this:
    import java.beans.DefaultPersistenceDelegate;
    import java.beans.Encoder;
    import java.beans.Expression;
    import java.beans.Statement;
    import java.beans.XMLEncoder;
    import java.io.ByteArrayOutputStream;
    import java.io.IOException;
    public class JCOption {
        private int x = 1;
        private static JCOption option = new JCOption();
        private JCOption() {}
        public static JCOption getOption() { return option; }
        public int getX() { return x; }
        public void setX(int x) { this.x = x; }
        public static void main(String args[]) throws IOException {
          JCOption opt = JCOption.getOption();
          opt.setX(10);
          ByteArrayOutputStream os = new ByteArrayOutputStream();
          XMLEncoder encoder = new XMLEncoder( os );
          encoder.setPersistenceDelegate( opt.getClass(), new JCOptionPersistenceDelegate() );
          encoder.writeObject(opt);
          encoder.close();
          System.out.println( os.toString() );
    class JCOptionPersistenceDelegate extends DefaultPersistenceDelegate {
        protected Expression instantiate(Object oldInstance, Encoder out) {
            return new Expression(
                    oldInstance,
                    oldInstance.getClass(),
                    "getOption",
                    new Object[]{} );
        protected void initialize( Class<?> type, Object oldInstance, Object newInstance, Encoder out ) {
            super.initialize( type, oldInstance, newInstance, out );
            JCOption q = (JCOption)oldInstance;
            out.writeStatement( new Statement( oldInstance, "setX", new Object[] { q.getX() } ) );
    }   Output:
    <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
    <java version="1.5.0_06" class="java.beans.XMLDecoder">
    <object class="JCOption" property="option">
      <void property="x">
       <int>10</int>
      </void>
    </object>
    </java>

  • Candidates for use of Singleton Pattern

    Hi
    Can any guide me , where to use Single Design pattern in Java Based Applications
    Should i use Singleton Pattern in the following situations
    1)RMI Server
    2)Controller Classes ( MVC) invoked by Servlet
    3)Database cashing /handling classes
    Please suggest other suitable places also
    Thanks in Advance

    Hii
    Typical uses of a singleton pattern are in those cases where you have to have a single instance of a class.For example if u have an RMI based application and the client needs to perform a RMI lookup(for the URL etc)in that case for a particular user you wud like to have just a single instance for the lookup.
    In case of controller classes invoked by the servlet you would typically not want a Singleton as multiple instances of the servlet might require to use a controller object.As the request parameters would be different for each servlet instance,you would need a controller object for each of them.

  • WLPI Design Question

    I've got a bit of a design question for Process Integrator. Currently I'm building
    a prototype for an exception handling system using Process Integrator. The application
    has to be web based and I'm using the Front Controller design pattern that is
    described in the J2EE Blueprint docs.
    I've come across a bit of a design problem. Should I design the application so
    that all the user actions in a task are accessed via the api set or should I build
    this functionality into the template. For example, a user will action a task which
    requires the user to update some variables in the template. In the template definition
    should use a Send XML to Client action and then use the taskExecute method on
    the worklist, or should I do it all programatically?
    Also if I do use the Send XML to Client should I then mark the task done using
    the APIs or using the Studio. I have noticed that if I mark the task done wihtin
    the studio after sending the xml, the task becomes available for the next user,
    even if the variables haven't been updated yet.
    Sorry about the rambling nature of this post.
    Thanks in advance.
    Preyesh

    If you want to write code that's easier for you to write, you do whatever the hell you want.
    If you want to write good code, retain the ID.

  • Web design questions (Was: A number of questions..)

    Ok so!
    What fonts are known to go well together when making banners or headers? I have been messing around with a lot of fonts and im really just looking for some new ones!
    I know this question really depends on the banner itself but what is a recommended size of a font when making a header? lets say 860x250 ?
    Are there any real kind of "must nots" when designing banners?
    When Placing text onto A banner where is the usual place you would see it? I know it changes from site to site but from just looking around a lot of text seems to be in the left bottom corner, is this a norm of some sort?
    Are there any known font combinations which would go together well when making a full webpage? As in fonts for the sidebar, content area, footer etc, any combinations?
    Thank you very much!

    You are asking design questions, but most web designers, including those who frequent this forum, have  no design expertise.
    Your questions are good, but  incomplete. The right typeface and size depends on the impression you are trying to create. For instance, you wouldn't want to use the typeface "Comic" for a website selling financial services.
    Many corporations have lengthy documents detailing their identity for graphic design and advertising. Such documents define which typefaces may be used where, and how. Assuming that you don't have such a document to work with for the creation of this web banner, think about the business, organization (or whatever) the website is for. Should it convey conservative dependability? Edginess? Family friendliness? The typefaces you choose should take such qualities into consideration.
    There's no definite answer to any of the questions you have asked. But that's OK. You should research websites that create the kind of impression you want to make and study how they accomplish it.

  • Database Connection design question

    Hello, I have a design question. Awhile back I needed to create a database connection to SQL Server, so I created a class to do it
    import java.sql.*;
    import java.io.*;
    import java.net.MalformedURLException;
    import org.w3c.dom.Document;
    import org.w3c.dom.*;
    import javax.xml.parsers.DocumentBuilder;
    import javax.xml.parsers.DocumentBuilderFactory;
    import org.xml.sax.SAXException;
    import org.xml.sax.SAXParseException;
    public class SQLServerConnection
         private static Connection connection = null;
         public SQLServerConnection(String user, String password, String dbName) throws java.sql.SQLException
              getDBConnection(user, password, dbName);
         public SQLServerConnection(String configFileName) throws java.sql.SQLException
              getDBConnection(configFileName);
         private void getDBConnection(String user, String password, String dbName) throws java.sql.SQLException
             DriverManager.registerDriver(new com.microsoft.jdbc.sqlserver.SQLServerDriver());
             connection = DriverManager.getConnection(
                  "jdbc:microsoft:sqlserver:" + dbName, user, password);              
         private void getDBConnection(String configFileName) throws java.sql.SQLException
              String user;
              String password;
              String dbName;
              try
                   DocumentBuilderFactory factory = DocumentBuilderFactory.newInstance();
                   DocumentBuilder db = factory.newDocumentBuilder();
                   Document doc = db.parse(configFileName);
                   doc.getDocumentElement().normalize();
                   // get the configuration information
                   password = getConfigParameter("password", doc);
                   user = getConfigParameter("username", doc);
                   dbName = getConfigParameter("databasename", doc);
                   getDBConnection(user, password, dbName);
              catch (MalformedURLException murle)
                   System.out.println("Unable to connect to: " + configFileName + " -- " + murle);
                   System.exit(1);
              catch (FileNotFoundException fnfe)
                   System.out.println("Configuration file " + configFileName + " not found.");
                   System.exit(1);
              catch (IOException ioe)
                   System.out.println("IOException: " + ioe);
                   System.exit(1);
              catch (javax.xml.parsers.ParserConfigurationException pce)
                   System.out.println ("Parser Configuration Error: " + pce);
              catch (SAXException saxe)
                   System.out.println ("SAXException: " + saxe);
         private String getConfigParameter(String paramName, org.w3c.dom.Document doc)
              NodeList nl = doc.getElementsByTagName(paramName);
              if(nl != null)
                   Node n = null;
                   for (int i = 0; i < nl.getLength(); i++)
                        n = nl.item(i);          
                        if(n.hasChildNodes())
                             NodeList children = n.getChildNodes();
                             return ((Node)children.item(0)).getNodeValue();
              else
                   System.out.println ("nl is null");
              return "";          
         public void setCatalog(String catalogName) throws java.sql.SQLException
              connection.setCatalog(catalogName);
         public Connection getConnection()
              return connection;
         public void closeConnection()
              try
                   connection.close();
              catch(java.sql.SQLException sqle)
                   System.err.println ("SQL Server Connection failed to close: " + sqle);
    }Later on, I needed to do the same thing for MySQL, so I created a class for that, MySQLServerConnection which is exactly the same as above, except for:
    private void getDBConnection(String user, String password, String dbName) throws java.sql.SQLException
              try
                   Class.forName("com.mysql.jdbc.Driver").newInstance();
                   connection = DriverManager.getConnection(dbName, user, password);     
              catch(java.lang.ClassNotFoundException cnfe)
                   System.out.println (cnfe);
              catch(java.lang.InstantiationException ie)
                   System.out.println (ie);
              catch(java.lang.IllegalAccessException iae)
                   System.out.println (iae);
         }Later, on, I did the same thing with OracleServerConnection. My question is, I know this is probably not optimal code. For example, I didn't originally have a close connection method, so I had to go in and code one for all 3. I'm assuming that an interface would be a good idea so that if I have to code another database connection class I make sure and include all of the appropriate methods. I'm also assuming that it would have been smart to have a master class, maybe something like DatabaseConnection and extended these classes from that. Am I on the right track? Totally offbase?

    @nclow - I will work on trying the Factory Pattern for this over the weekend and post when I finish to see what you think.
    @abillconsl - just to make sure I understand, you're saying that I just try to connect and it will cycle through the different database connection possibilities and connect when it finds the right one? If it fails all 3, log an appropriate message. One question I have about this is, I thought I was being object oriented by separating the different types of db connections (Oracle, SQL Server, MySql) into different classes. Am I missing the point of OOP by what I was/am trying to accomplish? Going overboard? Also, does your way try and connect to all 3 even if I connected to one already?
    Thx, Grantarchy
    Edited by: grantarchy on May 9, 2008 9:50 PM

  • Singleton pattern, scheduled receive location and suspended orchestrations

    Hello,
    In our project we have several orchestrations that are triggered every minute with the Scheduler Adapter (business requirement is near real-time).
    Each of these orchestration must have only 1 instance running at the same time, so we have implemented the singleton pattern. We followed a design like this one: https://fehlberg.wordpress.com/2008/06/06/biztalk-singleton-orchestration-design/
    But we end up having suspended orchestrations with the error "The instance completed without consuming all of its messages. The instance and its unconsumed messages have been suspended."
    I know it's a risk with this pattern. I thought it would happen only when the instance would run in more than 1 min (because the scheduler adapter is sending a file every minute).
    But it happens even with some instances running in about 15sec, so there is something I don't understand, here is an example:
    Here we can see that the TransferRegion orchestration started at 10:26:00 (which is expected) and failed.
    When I open the orchestration debugger, the time is different, the orchestration is shown starting at 10:26:44 (44 sec later):
    And the orchestration ended at 10:27:00:453.
    The message not consumed that caused the error has been triggered at 10:27:00.
    So I understand that the message arrived just after the listen shape but before the orchestration ends, but I don't understand why the orchestration started 44 sec after is was supposed to ...
    Any idea? I'm kind of clueless for now ...

    So, are these 8 Orchestrations actually processing messages or are they doing some other work every minute or so?
    If they're not processing actual messages, maybe a Windows Service or job scheduled by the SQL Agent or Windows Scheduler would be more...appropriate.  We all love BizTalk, but some parts of the stack do some things better.
    If they are processing messages or doing some genuine BPI type work, calling services, transformations etc., then maybe a Singleton+Scheduled Task is not the best solution.
    I'm assuming the actual requirement is the process must run with no less than 1 minute between executions, but if an execution takes >1 min, don't overlap.  An internal 1 min timer would probably work very well, but you still have the problem of
    activating and deactivating the Orchestration.  You'd basically have to build some control infrastructure similar to the EDI Batching Service.
    Here's a completely different suggestion:
    SQL Table that maintains the state of each process, say Active or Complete.
    Poll every 15 seconds a Stored Procedure that tests the status and returns an activation message when that process shows Complete.  It would flip it to Active at the same time.
    Orchestration runs and the last shape sends a message to change the status to Complete.
    Rinse Repeat.  No long running Orchestrations, Singletons, Correlations, etc...
    Hi John,
    We have 8 independent orchestrations. Each of them is triggered by different scheduled receive location.
    The orchestrations then process messages (calling stored procedures, mapping and calling web services).
    You are right for the requirement. I tried to deactivate the receive location at the beginning of the process and restart it at the end, but I ran into some weird errors on the SSO DB and others like "Could not retrieve transport type data for Receive
    Location 'Trigger_xxxxx_SCHEDULE' from config store. The transaction associated with the current connection has completed but has not been disposed.  The transaction must be disposed before the connection can be used to execute SQL statements."
    Thanks for the new design suggestion, I will see the effort required and if the client approves it ;)

Maybe you are looking for