What happens if you try Target Disk Mode?

Has anyone tried booting up the new MB's (those without a FW port) while holding down "T" to see what happens? Does the FW logo appear?

Without Firewire I can't use any of my HD cameras to load footage into FCP or onto the MB's hard drive. USB is on the cameras but only supported under Windows. Everything I shoot is true HD (not HDV or AVCHD) and because Apple has decided to drop teh FW port on the MB I'll be forced to buy a MBP just because it has a FW port and I'll have to get a FW400 to FW800 adapter for an additional $8 to $30 which ends up essentially being a Firewire Tax of $708 to $730 just to get my tapeless workflow, flowing.
My FireStore drives are useless without a FW port as are many (most in fact) of my external HDs. I can't use the MB in TDM to load footage onto, copy off of or even dump footage directly from a P2 card reader or even one of my cameras. Without firewire I simply can't work.
Apple touted FW as the next big thing, FW3200 is on it's way, sony has iLink, many Pro cameras can only work with Macs via FW so without a FW port a MB is literally useless to me. I'm just upset that if I wanted to upgrade today, or had to, or had to bring more edit stations on the road or on location I'd be forced to pay an additional $700+ just to make each one as compatible as the previous model. As well as forced to carrying around a heavier and larger laptop with essentially the same graphics capabilities as the MB (since the MBP can't use both graphics systems at once which is an Apple limitation not Nvidias). You can't really edit HD over USB either due to the different technologies between FW and USB.
USB to FW adapters don't work in this workflow and while an express card with FW ports would, the MB is lacking that as well. Apple has chosen to alienate some customers while forcing others to pay this Firewire Port Tax.
Having owned Macs and Apple products since my Apple ][, and owning stock since it was $14 a share when Steve dropped the "i" from his iCEO status I'm, for the first time, truly disappointed and a little angry at Apple.
For my company it is that bad. The next portable upgrades we do we will have to factor in $700+ times the number of laptops we want or need. For every two MBPs we'd buy we could almost get an extra MB with the firewire tax. I'm not paying $700 for a port that's been standard for a while now, especially since Apple invented Firewire.

Similar Messages

  • What happens when you're using nav mode on Ovi Map...

    ... or does nav mode shut down incoming calls?

    you can still here voice aut cannot see route!
    hope this helps

  • What happens when you try to spend $600+ in Store

    On Saturday the 19th I tried to upgrade my phone to the buy one get one deal currently going on now. I have 2 smartphones on my account, one HTC Droid something another and an Apple Iphone 4S 8G. The Iphone is on the edge up program (6 months old) the droid is real old and has an upgrade available. We have no contract at this point. 
    I asked about getting the buy one get one and was told the edge up was not upgrade-able, so i offered to pay the phone (Iphone) off completely. NOPE the computer would not update the owed amount for at least a couple of days. So i guess ill spend my money ($600+) elsewhere, and I did, I got a computer to take all the pics off the iphone (8g is a joke do not buy one) so we can use it. Straight Talk is looking so much better every day.
    Keep it Classy Verizon.
    Another Happy Customer
    Rsuppa

    Some Solutions for Resetting Forgotten Security Questions: Apple Support Communities

  • Why MBP heats when working in target disk mode?

    I connect my MBP to iMac using target disk mode through Thunderbolt interface, close the lid and work on iMac booted from MBP's disk. My understanding is that in this mode MBP should consume very little energy because CPU and GPU are mostly inactive. But I can feel that MBP actually heats up considerably. It not critically hot, but still hotter than I would expect. Can someone explain why this happens?

    For FireWire Target Disk Mode, if there are two drives connected to the same IDE bus, I believe only the one that is set as Master is accessible from the "other" computer.  So it's possible that your optical drive is Master and hard drive is Slave, in your config.
    Copying the files to the external drive, while the iMac G4 is still bootable, was a good move.
    Once the data is safe, you might try the following (assuming you are able to continue starting up that iMac).  Download a cloning utility, such as Carbon Copy Cloner
    http://www.bombich.com/
    Clone the internal drive volume to a FireWire external drive volume.  Set System Preferences Startup Disk pane to start up from the clone on the FireWire drive, and try to start up from the clone.  While started up from the FireWire drive, you can run Disk Utility on the internal drive.  Maybe you can do a Repair Disk successfully.
    You can also use Disk Utility to completely erase the internal drive.  Be sure to select the internal DRIVE (not the volume indented under the drive) in the sidebar, then go to the Erase tab.  Doing an erase in this way will re-partition and reformat the hard drive.  That may get rid of your data corruption problem.
    Then, clone the clone back to the internal drive, and try to start up from it.  If there was an underlying hardware problem on the hard drive, this will not fix it.  But if it was just data corruption at the volume level, that iMac G4 may still have some life left.

  • What happens when you cant login or anything on itunes?

    It wont let me login to anything redeem cards open anything!

    What happens when you try to login? Error messages?

  • Using Target disk mode from hard drive which is starting to fail, when I move files, I get a preparing to copy message but nothing happens. Any ideas?

    Hello, i have a MacBook Pro. The hard drive is failing to such an extent that I can't currently use the computer, only things like utility mode etc. I have connected it unto my iMac and using a Firewire in target disk mode, I am attempting to move files across using that mode. The HD of the Macbook Pro appears in the IMac devices menu and I copy and paste the appropriate folders/files but as I do this I get a progress bar which says "preparing to copy" but then nothing appears to happen. Any ideas on what to do? Is there a password or other issue here that I am over-looking. Perhaps the hard drive of my macbook pro is so corrupted that I can't move files over. Any help would be great?

    Try moving smaller groups of files. I' guessing that you don't have a backup huh?

  • How do you install Tiger using target disk mode?

    Hi guys,
    I have an old Powerbook G4 that seems to have a dead DVD drive, so i am now trying to install Tiger using target disk mode from my Macbook Pro.
    I successfully mounted the G4 using target disk mode and the Tiger install DVD but when I double click the install icon, I get an error message saying: "Mac OS X 10.4 cannot be installed on this machine"
    Okay, fine but i want to install the OS on the G4. How do I go about selecting the G4 for installation?
    Thanks in advance for your help.

    Hi Nichola,
    Have you tried a search on the support site with the error messages you are receiving? (Maybe your computer doesn't meet the minimum requirements to run Tiger.)
    To re-initialize your disk, go into disk utilities, select 'Erase' and follow the instructions. This will erase and format your disk. Hopefully this helps, but I'm not sure if it will solve your kernel panic problem - maybe that's a different issue all together??
    Hopefully, you've already backed up your important data, but you should try to use target disk mode to do that if you are still unable to boot up the G4 using Tiger. Good luck - hope this is helpful.

  • What is the set-up when transfer files through target disk mode

    I'm a bit confused on how to set up the macs to do a file transer in target disk mode.  I am transferring files from an imac to a macbook pro.  I have the cable 6pin to 9pin.  Now what I can't remember (apple.com instructions is what confused me) is on which computer do I hold down the  'T' on start up?  Is it the computer I am transferring the files to? ( in this case the macbook pro).  I use to do this fairly often, but not recently, and I have forgotten.  Any help would be greatly appreciated. 

    Transferring files between two computers using FireWire - Apple

  • Can you install tiger on a power mac g4 with out a DVD drive if so how, I do have have a 2011 iMac can I use that in target disk mode with a FireWire cable any help would be appreciated

    Can you install tiger on a power mac g4 with out a DVD drive if so how, I do have have a 2011 iMac can I use that in target disk mode with a FireWire cable any help would be appreciated

    Hello,
    You need to put the Tiger Install Disc in the 2011 iMac, boot the 2011 uMac into Target mode...
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1661
    Boot the G4 holding the Option or alt key, hopefully the Install Disc in the 2011 iMac will show as a boot choice.
    We just want to use the 2011 iMac as a big expensive FW Optical drive, it cannot be installed osing the 2011 iMac itself.

  • Using Target Disk mode to reinstall OS-X

    I have a PPC G5 Dual 2.0gHz which failed the other day. All the fans were running full and a red LED showing on the logic board (it's just a warning I think). Since then the machine cannot be started up. It will begin the startup process normally but will hang on the Apple logo screen (no spinning gear wheel).
    The same thing happens when attempting to start up from the install disks and also when started in safe mode or with Option pressed down at startup.
    The logical assumption (given the original failure) is a hardware problem but I'm not entirely certain that's the case and cannot get it to a technician right now. I can run Apple Hardware Test and it passes that. I can also mount the G5's drive in Target Disk mode using a PowerBook G4 as a host so the drive itself appears to be okay. All the data is there and can be transferred.
    Is it possible that this is software not a hardware issue? The normal startup chime is there, the relay clicks at startup and it does begin to access the drive and all the normal noises can be heard. Just stops loading at the Apple logo screen. I'm wondering if some OS files were corrupted in the original crash (which happened overnight so I don't know what caused it) and if there is some way to eliminate the OS as the problem before going to a technician.
    As I can mount the drive in target mode, is it possible to use my PB as a host and reinstall the G5 OS-X that way? They're different machines so I don't know if that would work or the PB would reject the installation. Alternatively, if it could be just corrupted OS system files would it make sense to try to 'guess' the most likely to have been corrupted and manually replace them, again using the PB as a target host?
    I'm really stuck without this machine but just can't get it to a workshop for at least a couple of weeks so I'll try anything!

    Boy, I love these forums, and I love Macs (most of the time). I was so convinced this was hardware but it seems (fingers crossed) to be fixed. Yay!
    You guys were both right in a way. Roam's solution would clearly have been the easiest but because I had tried it before without success I didn't expect it to work. And, trying it again with the G5 install disk, it didn't. Same problem as before. But Graham's reminder of using the original multi-machine Tiger disks in target mode made me wonder. So before trying Target Disk mode I tried just restarting the machine using the Tiger DVD instead of the G5 disks -- and it booted into the installation dialogue!
    I figured I'd need to reinstall 10.4 (and, if it worked, go through the whole update drag to get back to 10.4.10). Before I did that though, on a whim, I tried quitting the installer and selecting the normal G5 system as the startup disk. Restarted and voila -- there it was, all back to normal, everything sweet and no data lost!
    I didn't even need to repair the disk. Disk verify shows no problems. Even repairing permissions was just a couple of minor changes. I'm amazed. And delighted.
    I might be jumping the gun and there might still be a hardware problem that will repeat the original failure and I'll find all the fans going full blast and nothing working again tomorrow but, if Murphy is having time off, for the moment I'm back in business.
    I would love to figure out what caused the problem in the first place. I suspect a big power surge overnight did it but I have no idea exactly what it did to cause these symptoms.
    My grateful thanks guys.

  • Boot up from target disk mode doesn't work. (Why?)

    I have a 2010 Macbook Pro, and a 2013 iMac. I connected the Macbook pro with the firewire cable to the iMac, and enabled target disk mode on the laptop. (It is successful because I see the hard drive appear on the iMac desktop.
    I restart the iMac and hold 'option' to show the hard drive list, and sure enough the Mac Book Pro hard drive appears. I select it, and this lovely icon greets me.
    From this point, I have no idea what to do.
    Would you happen to know why it doesn't work and/or how to fix it?

    I am able to do that... this is not the problem.
    I have seen people boot up from the hard drive using target disk mode. When I try to do it, it doesn't work. Does this feature still exist?

  • Pismo with Tiger won't go into target disk mode

    I recently upgraded my Pismo to Tiger and can't seem to boot into firewire target disk mode. The computer restarts and gives me a terminal screen that reads: "can't OPEN DISK" and then goes on to say "Welcome to Open Firmware. To continue booting, type "mac-boot"..."
    I tried zapping the pram, but that did nothing. Does anybody have any suggestions?

    MacUser,
    When booted in 10.4.8, select Target Disk Mode in the System Preferences > Startup Disk and see what happens.
    If no success, try resetting Open Firmware (from Apple docs):
    Boot into Open Firmware by holding down the 'Command-Option-O-F' keys from a cold start while the chime is being played. You will see a command-line screen...enter these commands:
    1. At the Open Firmware prompt, type: reset-nvram
    2. Press Return.
    3. At the Open Firmware prompt, type: reset-all
    4. Press Return.
    Example:
    0 > reset-nvram
    Press Return
    0 > reset-all
    Press Return
    The reset-all command should cause the computer to restart. If this occurs, you have successfully reset the Open Firmware settings.

  • Macbook in target disk mode locks up when trying to transfer files to another computer. Suggestions?

    A week ago I installed snow leopard on my girlfriend's macbook without backing anything up. Dumb idea I know. The installation failed multiple times. I ran her computer in target disc mode to try to save what files I could. Now when I try to transfer files it will freeze up at different times. Sometimes I can transfer a huge amount of data like 4GB's and the other times it locks up trying to transfer 4kB's. I'm at my wits end trying to figure this out. I can see the files but can not transfer them.
    Any suggestions or past similar past experiences?

    Hi Anand,
    Have you noticed when you plug the drive in whether its making any sounds? You can put your ear up to the drive on the Macbook. Its located on the right hand front sided of the top case.
    Also, check to see if the target disk mode icon is moving after a few minutes. If the firewire icon has stopped moving it usually indicates that theres something seriously wrong (probably mechanical) with the drive.
    Id definitely give Disk Warrior a try. Especially if you have a situation where you can hear the drive running or spin up but it doesn't make any sound after that. Hope this helps.

  • Power Mac G4 stuck in Target Disk Mode

    The other night I put my Gigbit Ethernet into Target Disk Mode so I could migrate my files to a newer machine (a mirrored drive door G4 with dual 1.42mhz processors). After the migration was complete (which took 9 hours), I tried ejecting the target disk but got a perpetual spinning beach ball and had to force everything off. Unfortunately, either because my newer machine came with a faulty Tiger installation, or my migration messed the installation up - the finder kept crashing and things such as "Get Info" wasn't working- I had to endeavor to get a working version of Tiger on the newer machine. I wanted to clone my older drive to my newer drive.
    Futzing around for over an hour to try to gain access to my old Power Mac's hard Disc, which was still, according to the bouncing Icon on the screen, in target disk mode, I could not access the drive at all from the newer machine. When I tried, such as by double clicking on its desktop icon, by right clicking on the same Icon, or if I went into the system preferences to change the startup disk with the gigabit ethernet attached, I got the perpetual spinning beach ball. Also, I could not access the drive from the disk utility app that is on the Tiger install DVD. Luckily, I had a pretty fresh bootable backup of the gigabit ethernet on a firewire drive that I cloned to my newer computer. I just have a handful of files that I want to transfer from the gigabit ethernet if I had my drothers.
    Am I screwed here? Is there a way to force my Gigabit Ethernet out of Target Disk Mode without hooking it up to another computer? If it's possible to get the Gigabit Ethernet to boot again successfully, I can transfer my file over my network. Any help would be appreciated.
    Cheers

    I am confused...it sounds to me like what you wish to do is to make an exact copy of the hard disk in your Gigabit Ethernet and apply that copy to the drive in your MDD, correct?
    From what I understand, you are saying you cannot access your GE's hard disk using target disk mode? Or am I mistaken? Also, can you not boot up normally on the GE's hard disk? Is there something wrong with it?
    The easiest way to clone a disk is to just make a disk image of the hard disk you wish to keep, and then apply that disk image to the destination disk. Disk utility can perform all this very easily, and pretty quickly. Of course, if you are having trouble booting in target disk mode, this can be a problem...
    I'm still kind of confused on what exactly is the problem, and what you are trying to accomplish. Could you please explain a little more and answer the questions above? Much appreciated.

  • How-To: Install Bundled Apps to another MacBook Pro using Target Disk Mode

    Recently, I replaced the dead hard drive on my wife's computer. All the data was previously backed-up so all I needed to do was reinstall the original OS. Oops! Those disks disappeared over two years ago...perfect, right? No poblem, I already had the boxed install DVD for Snow Leopard and installed the core OS. But what about those bundled applications? Aha! That is the marketing coup Apple doesn't really talk much about. You see, you get the entire suite of Apple branded apps with the original install disks but not with a boxed OS install disk. It's just something that you have to find out for yourself...the hard way.
    My requirement: restore all the iPhoto data to the reimaged machine running Snow Leopard. But that data has no application that can read it. Solution - Reinstall iPhoto from another source.
    So I developed this workaround I hope the rest of you find amusingly simple, wildly helpful
    Here's how I restored iPhoto on my wife's computer:
    1)  Get two Laptops side by side. In our case we both have macbook pro 2008 computers (Wife's and Mine)
    2)  Power both down and direct connect a firewire 400 cable (or 800 if you have it) between the two
    3)  Start the Wife's laptop in Target Disk Mode: Press "T" immediately after engagin the power button, hold it down until you see the "fanned" firewire symbol floating across a grey screen - it's quite large, about the size of your hand making a "stop" gesture
    4)  No start the Mine laptop by pressing the "option" key (two keys to the left of the space bar)
    5)  You will presented with a pair of hard disks to boot from, choose the Wife's laptop hard drive
    5a) you'll notice now that the Mine laptop is booting the OS system files of the Wife's laptop (Her desktop, her preferences, etc...)
    6)  On the Mine laptop, insert the original Mac OS Install Disk (#1) that came with the Mine laptop (usually any OEM install disk will work, though)
    7)  Double-click on the DVD icon on the desktop when it mounts and look for a shortcut that reads, "Install Bundled Applications Only"...launch it
    8)  Now choose install bundled applications but make sure to press the "Customize" button in order to specifically choose which OEM software you want. In our case, just iPhoto
    9)  Follow the installer prompts all the through to completion and exit (you will be prompted to insert disk #2 along the way).
    10)  Remove the install disks, power down
    11)  Power down the Wife's laptop too
    12)  Disconnect the Firewire cables from both laptops
    13)  Power up the Wife's laptop normally
    14)  Launch the FInder and drill down to Applications. Look for iPhoto and launch it
    15)  iPhoto will either pickup the "iPhoto Library" that was previously restored after reimaging with Snow Leopard or you may be prompted to manually associate a library with iPhoto.
    16)  Once complete, you'll se all the restored pictures and data from when before the original hard drive crashed. Wife will be pleased and you'll look like a Genius
    This is a really handy trick for troubleshooting a lot of install and restore related issues.
    Hopefully you'll find other uses for it too.
    Good Luck,
    TheHighSierras

    I think the problem is that you can't install an older OS X version onto a system running a newer OS X version. So I would try the following:
         1. have an external disk or create another partition on an internal drive to use for the Mountain Lion install (you might have to shrink an existing partition to make room for another)
         2. Create an external bootable USB thumb drive with the Mountain Lion OS on it (do a search on the web for this - for example see http://www.macworld.com/article/1167857/how_to_make_a_bootable_mountain_lion_ins tall_drive.html
         3. Reboot Yosemite and then boot from the USB thumb drive by holding down the option key
         4. run the mountain lion installer and install on the new disk/partition you created in step 1 - it will also create another recovery partition from this same part of the disk
    Now your Mac system will have both a Mountain Lion install as well as the Yosemite install. You won't be able to use Migration Assistant to move things from Yosemite to Mountain Lion because it will see that you're "going backwards" and won't allow you to.
    Have a good backup of everything before starting in case there are problems.
    Good luck...

Maybe you are looking for