Best DVD camcorder ?

Please advice me about the best DVD Camcorder to :
1) it Gives a very good quality in Resolution and Colors,
2) it has a good way to record and store the data on an economic level...
3) Mac - Pc
4) Other advantages...
Many Thanks

None of them do which was the point. They record in MPEG-2 which does not even have individual frames.
Read up on how MPEG-2 compression works but suffice it to say it makes one keyframe (all the data) then a bunch of differential frames holding only what has changed from the keyframe, then a keyframe after say 30 frames.
You don't have frame by frame editing as there are no frames other than one every 30 frames, say one per second.
MPEG-2 is a "delivery" format, e.g. a DVD to view, not an editing format. DV or other high quality source is compressed (data is lost) to make the DVD which is supposed to be the final form. Not the starting point.
All these DVD cam wonks (vendors) are doing a disservice to anyone who will not be happy with everything that is shot to the DVD as being acceptable as the end product.
You may know that most raw video is horribly boring, long, dull, and badly shot and there might be 10 minutes of keeper stuff per hour shot. So the DVD people have these little 30 minute DVDs and the audience suffers with the 25 minutes of dreck that exists with the 5 worthwile minutes.
New AVCHD may offer frame by frame HD MPEG-4 but right now even though Sony and others sell these cameras there is no software to edit the video. Not much value there quite yet.

Similar Messages

  • Help on purchasing a dvd camcorder to work with imovie

    hello out there...was wondering which camcorder that has a dvd burner works best with imovie and osx...i want a sony, but i thought the small dvd's did not work on osx. presently, i have a digital8 and use a firewire connection to ingest video for editing with imovie. thanks for any help...

    ... boxes that holds DVD and hard drive recorders:
    These files are intended for "one time" captures.
    The file format is not intended for editing.
    I totally agree with your recommendation: try to avoid DVD and harddisk camcorders at this point if you plan to edit on a Mac. Not only is software support seriously lacking, those Mini-DVDs don't even work with slot-loading drives that are common on Mac's.
    But... there is nothing wrong with the MPEG-2 compression used on DVDs. Just look at HDV: It uses the same MPEG-2 compression to fit the the HD video into the space of a SD MiniDV tape. iMovie converts HDV video streams during capture into a format that is easier for editing - that's why the files on your harddisk are 4 times as big as the data on the tape. The quality of video captured by most consumer camcorders is more limited by the optics and the video sensor (in particular indoors, with less than perfect lighting), than the recording format and media. And yes, you can edit MPEG-2 just fine, it is just more challenging to get it working right.
    I used to tell all my friends to stay away from DVD camcorders, too, but then broke down and very reluctantly bought a DVD camcorder recently. It's mainly used for recording music lessons, with instant and repeated replay. It took me some tinkering to work out a good workflow for editing with iMove. I did some side-by-side comparisons with a similarly priced MiniDV camcorder (Canon DC50 vs. Sony TRV-33). Overall, the video clips were almost identical from either camcorder, with the DVD camcorder producing slightly better video in some situations. But as I said in the beginning, that is probably mostly a result of the better video sensor and the optical image stabilization in this particular model.
    So how does my workflow go:
    - Use DVD-RWs, formatted in Video-VR mode, and prefinalized. This allows
    you to pop out the DVD from the camcorder at any time and immediately
    use it in your DVD player or computer without another time-consuming
    finalization step.
    - Find a Windows PC to copy the video files from the DVD to my Mac.
    Mac OSX cannot read the filesystem used by Video-VR discs without
    additional software like Roxio's Toast (which I don't have). Besides, all
    my Macs are slot loading.
    - Convert the clip with the Quicktime MPEG-2 plugin and MPEG Streamclip
    to DV format.
    - Finally, import the clips into iMovie.
    Workable yes, but neither convenient nor esay. Stick with MiniDV.

  • What is the best miniDV camcorder to buy to export miniDV tapes to Macbook pro?

    Hey there,
    I have miniDV tapes with home videos that I want to export to iMovie or FCP 5.0 so I can turn the footage into digital video clips to burn to DVD's.  They were shot on a Sony handicam that no longer works.  I bought a Panasonic PV-gs15 in order to do the job but it doesn't export video, only pictures from SD card. Now I just want to get the best camcorder or device (within financial reason) for the job.  Can anyone tell me the best way/Camcorder to get this video off these miniDV tapes and onto my computer please?

    Hi
    May be You find something of interest in my notes regarding this (and iMovie - but it is General)
    NO CAMERA or A/D-box
    Cable
    • Are You sure that You are using the FireWire Cable - USB-Cable will not work for miniDV tape Cameras
    FireWire - Sure not using the accompany USB-Cable but bought a 4-pin to 6-pin (or 9-pin) FW one ?
    • Test another FW-Cable very often the problem maker.
    Camera
    • Test Your Camera on another Mac so that DV-in still works OK
    • Toggle in iMovie pref. Play-back via Camera (on <-> off some times)
    • Some Cameras has a Menu where You must select DV-out to get it to work
    • Camera connected to "charger" (mains adaptor) - not just on battery
    • Camera set in Playback mode - NOT Recording mode
    Does Your Camera work on another Mac ?
    Sorry to say it is to easy to turn the 6-pin end of the FW-cable 180 deg wrong.
    This is lethal to the A/D-chip in the Camera = needs an expensive repair.
    (Hard to find out - else than import/export to another Mac ceased to work
    everything else is OK e.g. recording and playback to TV)
    A/D-box
    • Is the dip-switches set right ?
    • Set to same standard as recorded/editing e.g. NTSC 29.97fps or PAL 25fps
    • Try resetting it
    Connections
    • Daisy Chaining most often doesn’t work (some unique cases - it’s the only way that work (some Canon Cameras ?))
    Try to avoid connecting Camera <--> external HD <--> Mac but import directly to the Mac then move
    the Movie project to dedicated external hard disk.
    • FireWire-port - Can be re-setted by - Turn off Mac and disconnecting Mac from Mains/Power for 20-30 minutes
    External device’s (hard disk’s)
    • Should be FireWire as USB/USB2 performs badly and so does Airport or Net-work connected ones too.
    • MUST BE - Mac OS Extended formatted - UNIX/DOS/FAT32/Mac OS Exchange - DO NOT WORK for video due to 4Gb barrier.
    Mac
    • Free space on internal (start-up) hard disk ? Please specify the amount of free space.
    (Other hard disks don't count)
    I go for a minimum of 25Gb free space for 4x3 SD Video - and my guess is 5 times more for 16x9 HD ones
    after material is imported and edited. No Camera or A/D-box
    • GarageBands fix - Close iMovie, Open GarageBand, Play some notes, Close GB and iMove can now be OK
    • Does Your Mac have a FireWire Port
    • White MacBooks - don't
    • MacBook-Air - don't
    if not then a few Mac’s has a PCM-CIA slot and there are FW-Cards that makes a FW-port this way
    else - NO SOLUTION
    Only option as I get it is either
    • Use another Mac to Capture material (to an external USB2 - Mac OS Extended formatted hard disk - or -
    • Change to another Camera that can be used with Your Mac (no there are no miniDV tape Cameras that can)
    • If Your Mac-Book has a PCM-CIA Card place - then there are FW-port-Cards and then
    You can import via this - but I've not seen this on more modern Macs. My PowerBook G4
    has one and this FW-Card-port works greatly.
    SoftWare
    • Delete iMovie pref. file may help sometimes. I rather start a new account, log into this and have a re-try.
    • Any strange Plug-ins into QuickTime as Perian etc ? Remove and try again.
    • FileVault is off ? (hopefully)
    • Screen Saver - OFF
    • Energy Saver - OFF
    Using WHAT versions ? .
    • Mac OS - X.5.4 ?
    • QuickTime version ? (This is the heart in both iMovie and FinalCut)
    • iMovie’08 (7.1.?), 09 or 11 ?
    • iMovie HD 6 (6.0.4/3) ?
    Other ways to import Your miniDV tape
    • Use another Camera. There where tape play-back stations from SONY
    but they costed about 2-4 times a normal miniDV Camera.
    • If Your Camera works on another Mac. Make an iMovie movie project here and move it
    over to Your Mac via an external hard disk.
    (HAS TO BE   Mac OS Extended   formatted - USB/DOS/FAT32/Mac OS Exchange WILL NOT DO)
    (Should be a FireWire one - USB/USB2 performs badly)
    from LKN 1935.
    Hi Bengt W, I tried it all, but nothing worked. Your answer has been helpful insofar as all the different trials led to the conclusion that there was something wrong with my iMovie software. I therefore threw everything away and reinstalled iMovie from the HD. After that the exportation of DV videos (there has not been any problem with HDV videos) to my Sony camcorders worked properly as it did before. Thank you. LKN 1935
    from Karsten.
    in addition to Bengt's excellent '9 yards of advice' ..
    camera set to 'Play' , not rec/computer/etc.?
    camera not on battery, but power-line?
    did your Mac 'recognize' this camera before...?
    a technical check.
    connect camera, on, playback, fw-connected...
    click on the Blue Apple, upper left of your screen ..
    choose 'About . . / More . .
    under Firewire.. what do you read . . ?
    More
    • FileVault - Secure that it’s turned off
    • Network storage - DOESN’T WORK
    • Where did You store/capture/import Your project ?
    External USB hard disk = Bad Choice / FireWire = Good
    If so it has to be Mac OS Extended formatted
    ----> UNIX/DOS/FAT32/Mac OS Exchange is NOT Working for VIDEO !
    mbolander
    Thanks for all your suggestions. What I learned is that I had a software problem. I had something called "Nikon Transfer" on my Mac that was recognizing my Canon camcorder as a still camera and was preventing iMovie from working properly. After un-installing Nikon Transfer and doing a reboot, everything worked great.
    I never liked the Nikon Transfer software anyway--I guess I'll get a cheap card reader and use that to transfer photos in the future.
    No Camera or bad import
    • USB hard disk
    • Network storage
    • File Vault is on
    jiggaman15dg wrote
    if you have adobe cs3 or 4 and have the adobe bridge on close that
    or no firewire will work
    see if that helps
    DJ1249 wrote
    The problem was the external backup hard drive that is connected, you need to disconnect the external drive before the mac can see the video camera.
    MaryBoog wrote
    Maybe your problems is solved in the meantime, but for all others this might help as I had the same problem, also have the Sony HDR-HC7, but the 7e (Europe, PAL). I found this link today and it works perfectly
    //support.sony-europe.com/tutorials/dime/videotransfer/vtransfer.aspx site=odw_en_GB&sec=DVH&m=HDR-HC7E
    What I exactly did.- put camera in play mode - open guide - choose connection guide - choose comp./printer (where to transfer movie to) - select connection.- i-link (on my camera) but equal to firewire - OK - choose HDV - choose NO for conversion of i.link.
    Settings are shown then (VCR HDV/DV.- HDV and i.link-conv..- OFF), press OK, OK, END.
    Switch camera off. Connect firewire cable to camera & Mac. Switch camera on, in play/edit mode.
    Open i-movie, choose import from camera. On screen below the camera connection is shown.- DV (HDV). Now you can import, automatically or manually.
    This worked perfectly for me. Took me 2 days to find out. Could not find any clear thread explaining what I had to do on the camera and the manual was not clear either.
    Yours Bengt W

  • Best DVD format for burning Using iDVD '09?

    I have created some movies using iMovie with recordings from my digital camcorder. What is the best DVD format to use when burning them to disc using iDVD? I am new to this. Thanks

    I mean, DVD-R, DVD+R, DVD-RW, DVD+RW, etc. Thanks
    I have found DVD+R to be more reliable than DVD-R. The only disadvantage to DVD+R is that DVD players manufacture before 2003 may not play them.
    I would recommend Taiyo Yuden DVD+Rs. (I get excellent results using iMovie 06 with iDVD 11.)
    http://www.supermediastore.com/product/search?search=TaiyoYuden+%23Category%3A%27DVD%2BRMedia%27
    What is the reason for using something less than the maximum burn speed? Thanks.
    I burn at 4X.
    Burning too slow is often just as bad as burning too fast. Rule of thumb is to burn at 1/2 the max speed of the media's max.
    "But believe it or not, there are still people who insist on waiting 55-60 minutes to burn a CD or DVD at 1x speed, because they are convinced anything faster will yield a bad or "lower" quality burn. However, burning too slow is often just as bad as burning too fast. Because of this unreasonable impulse to go too slow, some discs and drives now block out the lower range too"
    http://www.digitalfaq.com/media/advancedconcepts.htm

  • Firewire and mini-dvd camcorder

    If I purchase a mini-dvd camcorder that does have firewire, can I play [and capture] the movie from the camcorder into quicktime pro?

    No.
    Your file is MPEG-2 and QuickTime Pro can't extract audio (during any conversion) from muxed formats.
    QuickTime Pro (Mac only version) can record from many cameras and can convert to MPEG-4 (good), H.264 (better) and device native (best).
    Firewire is required to move the data from the camera to the machine.
    You could import and convert using a DV tape camera with Firewire using QuickTime Pro but I don't think a DVD camcorder has any "pass through" features. If it does then the source may be able to be captured (bypassing recording to MPEG-2).

  • Best DVD to iPod Converter

    I just got a New iPod video and I was looking for some advice for the best DVD to iPod Converter. The two programs that I have been looking at are
    1.) Super DVD to iPod Converter and
    2.) PQ DVD to iPod Video Converter
    Both of them run around $30 and boast that they are the fastest. Anyone have any input?

    Well, I'll disagree. I've used quite a few and to me, PQ DVD is by far the best. It records all DVD's, not just ones that aren't encrypted. All of them are slow, pretty much 1:1 when doing a movie. Meaning, if your video is a hour long, it's going to take an hour to do it. I just start it before I go to bed. I don't really know why support is needed- it is an extremely simple program to use. Personally, the how long have they been around thing doesn't mean a hill of beans to me. It works, it's simple, and affordable.

  • DVD camcorder to Mac ?

    Hoping someone can help. DVD camcorder, want to put film onto mac to edit. No USB or firewire connection only AV. Records onto 8cm discs not compatible with imac G5, any ideas?? The camera is a samsung DC172W. Thanks

    I would recommend that you get an inexpensive USB DVD reader/burner that sits flat with a sliding tray. You definitely do not want to put a miniDVD into a vertical iMac drive (unless you have a high tolerance for rattles.)
    Once you have it, you need to find a way to convert the contents of your DVD to an editable format. First check your manual to see if you need to finalize the DVD.
    Then take your 8cm DVD to your new USB burner and drag the contents into your Mac using the finder.
    Most, but not all, DVD camcorders record onto MPEG2, which is not editable in iMovie. So first you have to convert it to an editable format.
    There are several tools that will do this conversion. MPEG Streamclip combined with the MPEG2 Playback Component for Quicktime will do it. Visual Hub will do it. Many other options as well.
    Convert your MPEG2 to DV or h.264 or AIC. Then it can be edited in iMovie, Final Cut Pro, or Final Cut Express.
    If your camcorder does not use MPEG2, post back with what codec it is using and we can suggest other workarounds.

  • Mini-DV Camcorder V. DVD Camcorder?!

    I want to buy a camcorder but I'm not sure if it should be a Mini-DV Camcorder or a DVD Camcorder. What would be most compatible with iLife 04 and my computer in general, (statistics below).
    I have two in mind: Sony Mini-DV DCRHC24E and the Sony DVD105.

    iMovie likes to take take video from the device via iLink (Sony speak) or Firewire (Apple speak). The DCR-DVD105 doesn't have iLink/Firewire so to use that you'd have to insert the DVD in to the iMac and then import to iMovie (you may have to perform some conversion too depending on the format Sony are using). 
    Should you move up to a new iMac with a slot-loading disk drive the camcorder would become useless as you can't put an 8cm disk in the new iMacs.
    Of course the disadvantages of the DCR-HC24E MiniDV version is that tapes of course need re-winding etc. Note that the MiniDV version doesn't have DV in which means you can't archive projects back to tape. I'd advise looking for a model with DVin and DVOut.
    You might wish to post in the iMovie forum too as the users there may have further experience.
    regards
    mrtotes

  • Capturing DVD video shot with a DVD Camcorder

    I have a Panasonic DVD camcorder. It records on mini DVD's.
    With FCE, how do I capture what I've shot. The camera has a USB output but not a fire wire.
    Can I go directly from my digital camcorder to the capture tool? Or can I use the internal DVD player in my MacBook?
    MacBook   Mac OS X (10.4.9)  

    this is the usual reply in the iMovie section of this board, when it comes to converting DVDs into 'dv' (=for editing in iM/FCE):
    DVDs are in a socalled delivery format (mpeg2), which isn't meant and made for any processing as editing... or, as honorable forum member QuicktimeKirk stated: I use the analogy of the old Polaroid "instant" cameras. Push the button, wait for the print to develop and show it off. ..
    for using the iLife apps (= and FCE...) , you have to convert'em first, in recommended order, choose one of the following tools/workarounds:
    * DVDxDV (free trial, 25$, Pro: 90$)
    * Apple mpeg2 plugin (19$) + Streamclip (free)
    * VisualHub (23.32$)
    * Cinematize >60$
    * Mpeg2Works >25$ + Apple plug-in
    * Toast 6/7/8 allows converting to dv/insert dvd, hit apple-k
    * connect a miniDV Camcorder with analogue input to a DVD-player and transfer disk to tape/use as converter
    none of these apps override copyprotection mechanisms as on commercial dvds...
    http://danslagle.com/mac/iMovie/tips_tricks/6010.shtml
    http://danslagle.com/mac/iMovie/tips_tricks/6018.shtml
    be nice to copy rights

  • Transferring a movie from a dvd camcorder

    I have purchased an analog converter called ADVC110 to try and burn a copy of my home movies which were recorded on my Sony DVD camcorder but the process seems to take forever and is using up all the memory on my i-mac, surely this cannot be right ? I am trying to do this via i-movie HD, each recording on my dvd camcorder is taking about 1 hr 12 mins and there are about 70 of them , can anyone help to make this quicker and easier ?

    The ADVC 110 is an analogue to digital converter. The way it works is for your camcorder to play the DVD in real time just like you were watching it. The camcorder outputs an AV signal that the ADVC converts to DV on the fly.
    Therefore it is hardly surprising that a DVD containing about 1hr 12mins of real time recording takes exactly that time to download to the computer by this method. The DV format produced by the ADVC is the same as that used by tape digital camcorders - either digital 8 or minidv. This takes a lot of memory - about 17 gig per hr.
    Another way would be to copy the DVD contents direct to your hard drive from a DVD player. The size of these DVD movies will be a lot less than if in DV format but they cannot be utilised directly by imovie. They can, however be played by various other means. These can be converted by your computer to DV using various third party programs. The process is not easy and probably takes as long as your real time conversion using the ADVC. You will still be stuck with the large file size.
    Do you need to edit all of your movies using the full features of imovie or do you just want to cut/crop? If so there are alternatives to imovie. Look on Versiontracker
    Maybe it would be better to cut/crop your DVD (mpeg 2) footage before imovie conversion.

  • DVD Camcorder, anyone sucessfully able to import into to IDVD, I

    purchased the Panasonic VDR D220 and while an excellent camera in everything a camera should do it would not let me drag and drop to IDVD. Panasonic tech told me I needed "video arranger" but she had no idea where it was or even if it was a download. The camera did not have a firewire port, just USB.

    Welcome to iMovie Discussions! ..but perhaps what you really need is iDVD Discussions..
    iDVD is meant for turning movies, which have been created in iMovie in .DV or .mov (QuickTime) format, into the MPEG-2 format which is used for burning DVDs.
    Your DVD camcorder has already recorded your movie(s) in MPEG-2 format, so iDVD wouldn't know what to do with those: iDVD is a program which converts other formats into MPEG-2.
    You don't say what you want to do with your movies: iDVD isn't an editor ..it isn't for re-arranging scenes into a different order, and adding sound effects and fades, etc. That's what iMovie does.
    But because iMovie can't accept (..or the current iMovie HD 6 can't accept, anyway..) anything which is already in MPEG-2 format, what you'll have to do is (..fairly simply..)
    (1) Connect your camcorder to your iMac with a USB cable, and drag (copy) the video files from the camcorder into your Mac. (..If your iMac has a horizontal tray-loading DVD drive, you could try dropping the little camcorder disc into the DVD tray, and copying from that, but NEVER try that with a slot-loading DVD drive - and I wouldn't try it with a vertical-loading DVD drive - or the teeny disc will get lost and trapped inside your Mac, and it'll have to be taken apart to get the disc out!..)
    (2) Use the doanloadable MPEG Streamclip software to convert the MPEG footage of your video(s) into .DV, which iMovie can edit.
    (3) After editing, send your edited movie to iDVD for burning onto a normal-sized DVD, adding menus, etc, as you wish.

  • What is the best DVD-ripping software for mac?

    what is the best DVD-ripping software for mac?

    Handbrake to copy to avi or mp4(I use it for watching my DVD's on the go, so my battery lasts for a longer time)
    I think MP4 is better quallity.
    To copy a DVD: simply use Toast (maybe withe popcorn, but I don't use it).
    But, be legal! This is a forum, and anyone can see your posts!

  • BEST DVD TO IPOD SOFTWARE

    Does anyone have an opinion on the best DVD to Ipod software to purchase? I've tried the trial versions of PQDVD, Xilisoft, and Cucusoft and have found problems and numerous differences with those. If there are any others out there please let me know that may be better/easier/higher quality, etc.. Also, I am trying to convert home movies that are on DVD-R's, it seems as though PQDVD can sometimes convert them, but they freeze up or don't show up at all on the others. A regular DVD was no problem on any of them. Thanks!

    theres this doftware but this can be troublesome for soem and not for others. but remember this is a 3rd party software that is not suported by apple. any and all quesitons should be directed on their website not here.all links below
    To use Videora iPod Convertor to convert movies for use on your iPod, consult these helpful links:
    To get started: http://www.videora.com/en-us/Converter/iPod/
    If you have questions: http://www.videora.com/en-us/Converter/guides.html
    If you have more questions, post them here: http://www.pspvideo9.com/forums/index.php?c=8
    Note that Videora iPod Convertor is a 3rd party program. If you need help with it, post your question there.
    GFF

  • Canon DC-10 DVD Camcorder and iMovie (VR/Video DVD) *complicated*

    Hi Guys,
    I have a complicate issue and I have no idea how to do it.
    The Problem: I like to cut and edit my short movies which I have recorded with the Canon DC-10 DVD Camcorder.
    Because the Camcorder only writes small sized DVDs I have to copy it onto a standalone HDD/DVD recorder which is connected to my TV and than from its HDD back to a standard sized DVD. I can record this DVD in VR and Video mode but my MacBook Pro can only read the DVD which was recorded in Video mode. Therefore I cannot copy the movie files to my HDD. I think ripping might be a possibility but I don't know. Does anybody have an idea how to get my movie clips into iMovie HD?
    Which movie file format does iMovie HD use?
    By the way connecting the Camcorder to the Mac directly is currently not supported by Canon and Apple. I have to use the small DVD to normal size DVD way (because of the slot in drive in the MacBook Pro).
    Thanks.

    as Michael told you: iM does not support these DVDcorders...
    your workflow is absolutely correct: to avoid damage to the slot-in, first create a standard-shaped/sized dvd-r; it has to be finalized and in "video mode"....
    then, your options to import DVD content are:
    * DVDxDV (free trial, 25$, Pro: 90$)
    * Apple mpeg2 plugin (20$) + Streamclip (free)
    * Cinematize >60$
    * Mpeg2Works >25$ + Apple plug-in
    * Toast6/7 allows converting to dv/insert dvd, hit apple-k
    * connect a miniDV Camcorder with analogue input to a DVD-player and disk to tape/use as converter
    ... and as Micheal told you: DVD are end-of-the-road, a delivery format, not meant for further processing as editing, all these conversion could mean a loss of pic quality (and are very inconvenient, for sure)... if you are seriously interested in movie-making AND want to use the iApps, you should consider to buy a miniDV....

  • Best dvd-r recording material

    I am having a problem searching for the best dvd-r material to use. I keep getting problems with canon dvd-r recording captures.
    Can someone guide me in the recommened brands of DVD-R material?
    I understand most people rely on Taiyo Yuden as the least problematic. Is this so?
    Dave

    Double posted: http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1133801&tstart=0

Maybe you are looking for