DHCP Reservation problems caused by ARP proxy?

Question

We have been having recurring problems at three of our new school sites with printer IP addresses. We have created the address reservations in our DHCP servers (Windows Server 2012) but several times per week, the address shows up as a "BAD ADDRESS" in the DHCP leases and the printer never does get a good lease until we recreate the reservation and power cycle the printer. This is happening across several different printer models.
Because this is only happening at our new sites, I've been investigating possible reasons. The configurations are mostly identical at our new sites and old; we have 3750X's at the old sites and 3850's (and one school with 4500X's) at the new sites. We have the correct IP helpers on every VLAN - one for each of our DHCP servers and one for each ISE node. ISE doesn't respond to the DHCP requests, it only listens for them to profile the endpoints. I've also begun enforcing ISE at one of the sites to see if it was just related to IP conflicts - no luck so far.
Today I was fixing a printer reservation and came across something interesting. At one of the new schools, the MDF ARP table reported that 10.24.12.20 was assigned to a workstation (it is supposed to be assigned to a printer).  When I ran a check on the port in the IDF associated with that IP address to find the IP that was associated with the device, the device had an IP of 10.24.12.26. This caused me to start looking for ARP problems.
I went looking for a difference in the configs on the 3850's and the 4500X's compared to the 3750X's at the older sites. Here's what I found when I did a "sh run all":
4500X:
ip arp poll queue 1000
ip arp poll rate 1000
no ip arp proxy disable
ip arp gleaning tftp
ip arp gleaning udp
ip arp incomplete retry 20
ip arp incomplete entries 5000
ip arp incomplete enable
ip arp inspection log-buffer entries 32
ip arp inspection log-buffer logs 5 interval 1
ip sticky-arp
no ip gratuitous-arps
The 3750X only has the following ARP commands:
ip sticky-arpno ip gratuitous-arps
ip arp inspection log-buffer entries 32ip arp inspection log-buffer logs 5 interval 1
I was looking in particular at the "no ip arp proxy disable" on the 4500 and 3850's. I'm wondering if the newer switches are working as ARP proxies and causing problems with the printers. It doesn't seem that the 3750X's or older are doing this, or even have the commands. I am headed down the wrong path here? What are the repercussions of disabling the arp proxy on the newer switches to test it?
Thanks

Answer 1

Hi,
if you have proxy arp then you should see multiple IP mapped to same MAC( the one from the device with proxy arp enabled), is this the case ?
Regards
Alain
Don't forget to rate helpful posts.