High Availability Options Without Enterprise Edition

I think I've found the answer to this already but I just wanted to confirm that I'm getting this right. In SQL Server 2012, is there no way to implement a high-availability solution which doesn't require shared storage or use of a deprecated feature without
having Enterprise Edition?
At the moment we have databases hosted on a primary server running Windows Server 2012 Standard and SQL Server 2012 Standard.  We have a second, identical server, and the databases are mirrored between the two servers using Database Mirroring. 
This works perfectly and meets all of our requirements.  The only possible problem is that we're looking at storing documents using FILESTREAM, which isn't available in Mirrored databases.
From what I've read, Database Mirroring is deprecated in SQL Server 2012.  High Availability Groups, which sound great, are only available in the Enterprise Edition.  This feels like a real kick in the teeth from Microsoft.  We're stuck
with either using a deprecated feature (Mirroring), which is only postponing the problem until the end of 2012's life cycle, or laying out significant amounts of money (in the tens of thousands of pounds GBP) to upgrade to Enterprise Edition, which we just
don't have the budget for.
Why couldn't Microsoft continue to offer a high availability option for businesses without deep pockets?  Do I have any options I'm not thinking of?  Shared storage is not an option (too costly, single point of failure, geographically separated
datacentres).

Thanks for all the feedback.
I was forgetting that even data stored as FILESTREAM would need to be backed up using SQL backups, so I guess that's an issue either way, thank for reminding me, Sebastian.
Geoff, I agree that replication isn't a viable HA solution.  FCI has lots going for it, but from what I can make out (and I am just reading up on this now so I could be wrong) requires either shared storage or a third-party tool to move the data from
the Primary server's local storage to the local storage of the Secondaries.  It all seems overly complicated when Mirroring does exactly what I need it to do, merrily writing transactions to the mirrors at the same time as the primary databases. 
Additionally, whilst you might be right about making the case for Enterprise Edition, it's difficult to make a clear case to non-technical people when we already have a working HA solution and document management.  Trying to explain the nuanced advantages
of SQL Server full-text indexing (at present we use a third-party indexing product which stores the index discretely) and simplified querying when the documents are in the same database as their associated data as justification for spending tens of thousands
of pounds is a challenge!
David, that's useful to know, about the disadvantages of using FILESTREAM and how just storing the documents in a VARBINARY(MAX) column might actually give better performance, thank you.

Similar Messages

  • SAP NetWeaver 7.30 High-Availability installation without MSCS

    Hi all,
    Do we have any option to install SAP NetWeaver 7.30 High-Availability System on the third-party cluster solution, except for MS Cluster Service?
    I tried to install the first cluster node without MSCS configuration, however, sapinst.exe checks whether we already set up MSCS on this node, then installer aborted.
    I'd like to know the way to disable this checks. (Or, way to mimic the installer as if MSCS cluster configuration was done.)
    If unavailable, I have to install MSCS first, and SAP NetWeaver, then also have to uninstall MSCS instead of out cluster software;
    It seems to me no sense.
    Best regards,

    Hi Peter,
    Thanks for your quick response.
    It is disappointed for me that HA Installation is tightly combined with MSCS.
    Do we have a way to migrate from other installation scenario to High-Availability?
    For example, once we install ASCS instance as distributed system, then migrate
    it for High-Availability usage, leveraged by profile updates and so on?
    I'm not sure how High-Availability installation is different from other installation
    scenario except for installation path and hostname to be used for connection.
    Best regards,

  • Identify db-functionality only available in Oracle Enterprise Edition

    Hi
    I have an application with lots of PL/SQL logic. The development database for this application is Oracle Enterprise Edition and now we are going to install the application in an Oracle Standard Edition database at customer site.
    To be prepared I want to verify if I use (and remove) any db-functinality only available in Enterprise Edition.
    Is it possible to start an Oracle Enterprise Edition database in “Standard Edition mode”? Or is there any other way to scan the code?
    /Jonas

    For 11g refer
    http://docs.oracle.com/cd/B28359_01/license.111/b28287/editions.htm#BABDJGGI
    For 10g refer
    http://docs.oracle.com/cd/B14117_01/license.101/b13552/editions.htm
    After installing the EE software, IMO there is no way to start it in SE mode. As Data dictionary metadata stuff is different for EE and SE.
    You need to install SE and do exp/imp
    Converting An Enterprise Edition Database To Standard Edition [ID 139642.1]

  • Detail on High Availability options for Web Apps

    Hi,
    I do really struggle to locate actual information on Azure Availability offerings / capabilities...as an Infrastructure Architect it has bugged me for years now with Azure offerings!
    Something that simply states the availability within any local DC and options for true HA over 2 or more DC's.
    We are moving away from using Web Roles to Web Apps for solutions for our clients. I understand the principles of fault domains, etc. with Web Role requirements for min. of 2 to (mostly) avoid MS update disruption within a single DataCenter, but cannot locate
    similar info. with regard to Web Apps.
    Really appreciate if someone could point me to some appropriate detail as I've failed....
    (Also, cannot find anything on DocumentDB....)
    Many Thanks,
    Lee

    Hi,
    High Availability of a running service always comes with a cost, and priorities will be app-specific. If it's the web tier, then you may indeed want to consider hosting in multiple geo's. If it's a backend processing tier, sometimes it's "ok" to
    let a service go offline, as long as requests are queued up. If it's the storage system (preventing queueing of messages), perhaps an alternate queue in a different data center could be available for redundancy purposes.
    I would request you to check this article:
    https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/azure/dn251004.aspx
    Hope this information helps.
    Regards,
    Azam khan

  • ESP - MQ High Availability options

    Hi there,
    My organisation (DHS Australia) have recently upgraded our Websphere Message Broker environment from v7 to v8.
    As part of this upgrade, in our Production environment we are now running 4 queue managers, the idea behind this is that it helps to provide a higher level of availability (i.e. basically if one queue manager goes down, the others can pick up it’s load).
    The ESP MQ adapter currently only allows for connection to the one queue manager, so in our ESP-MQ implementation we are exploring possibilities of how we can possibly get the output from ESP shared across the 4 queue managers. We are looking at a number of options within MQ/Broker itself (eg. clustered queue definitions, clustered queue manager etc), and currently doing some testing to see how/if this works with the supplied ESP MQ adapters.
    However, my question for the ESP community/tech-team is whether there has been any thought to implementing something similar to how SAP PI can connect to MQ in a High Availability sense? For example, see this blog post:
    http://scn.sap.com/people/anandan.krishnamoorthy/blog/2010/06/08/high-availability-in-jms-adapter
    Has there been any thought given to whether the ESP MQ adapter can be enhanced or configured to use a MQ Client Channel Definition Table, as an alternative connection configuration method?
    Cheers,
    Jason.

    Jason - this isn't something that is currently on the ESP roadmap, but perhaps it should be. I'll be interested to see if others in the community have other perspectives on this, or experience doing something similar.

  • "Persistent (high performance) lookups" in Enterprise Edition

    Hello everybody,
    the Enterprise Edition of SQL Server 2014 has a SSIS feature "Persistent (high performance) lookups".
    https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc645993.aspx#SSIS_AT
    Does anybody know what this actually means? Is this the Full/Partial cache mode of normal data flow lookups? Hopefully not. Because making this an "enterprise" feature makes SSIS with Business Intelligence/Standard editions pretty useless.

    This has good explanation of persistent lookups
    http://community.altiusconsulting.com.ourwindowsnetwork.com/blogs/altiustechblog/archive/2008/09/16/sql-server-2008-part-2-ssis-persistent-lookups.aspx
    Please Mark This As Answer if it solved your issue
    Please Vote This As Helpful if it helps to solve your issue
    Visakh
    My Wiki User Page
    My MSDN Page
    My Personal Blog
    My Facebook Page

  • WebCat high availability options?

    Calling out to experienced BI architects...
    What is the best practice/recommended approach to high availability of the web catalog?
    Background:
    We just realized that there is a flaw in the design of our clustered, load balanced BI architecture, which consists of the following:
    ServerA= OBI Server1 + WebCatalog on local shared Drive
    ServerB= OBI Server2
    ServerC= JavaHost1/OBI Presentation Server1 pointing to WebCat on ServerA
    Server D= JavaHost2/OBI Presentation Server2 pointing to WebCat on ServerA
    the flaw is obvious: if ServerA goes down, we have redundance with ServerB for the OBI Server, but we've lost the web catalog. having the Webcat on a shared local drive on ServerA is a single point of failure.
    We are considering creating a small 2 node cluster and having the webcat on a clustered drive resource.
    Are there any alternative approaches that others have implemented successfully?
    Is there an Oracle option that allows 2 separate web catalogs which are kept in sync through replication?
    Thanks in advance for sharing any ideas on this.

    Thanks Deepak... do you know anything about replication using sawrepaj utility? Seems a bit difficult to setup, maintain and automate. Lot's of manually setup in config files. Anyone had good/bad experiences using sawrepaj?
    (Deepak: tried to give you some "helpful" points, but for some reason, I'm not able to award any points...)

  • MapView Available to 9i Enterprise Edition Users?

    MapViewer sounds cool. I'm running 9i EE, is the MapViewer package available to me? If so how?
    Thanks!

    MapViewer is available as part of an Oracle9iAS Rel. 2 license.
    It includes the java environment/web listener stuff.
    I believe all the pieces are downloadable from OTN (OC4J and MapViewer).

  • What is the difference between 9i standard edition and enterprise edition

    hi,
    who can tell me what is the difference between ora 9i standard edition and enterprise edition?? relevant http links are also appreciated. thank you!
    regards,
    iron teung.

    If your 'professor' really said that then I think you need to find a new college!I agree. 11g is a superset of 9i. In fact,you can tell 11g to run in 9i compatibility mode.
    >
    I firmly believe that you would do well starting with
    9i and then going through the new features with each
    release to 11g.Since 9i is officially about to start it's second year in 'Extended Support' (which, due to the surcharge in support fee, will likely see a drop-off in adoption) I would encourage anyone studying Oracle database to start with 10g.
    But the idea of starting at 9i is not bad.
    >
    'Client' is the software required to
    access/interact/maintain an Oracle database remotely
    from a client machine. Different features become
    available as you progress from Personal to Standard
    to Enterprise editions. They are cost related to
    whichever license you buy in a production environment.One point of confusion is that Personal Edition really is targeted for the Developer and therefore includes all capabilities, features and options of Enterprise Edition turned on and included in the license. (Except RAC and OEM packs) When I draw a picture, I put Personal Edition at the top as most capable.

  • ENTERPRISE EDITION 데이터베이스를 STANDARD EDITION으로 변경하는 법

    제품 : ORACLE SERVER
    작성날짜 : 2004-08-31
    ENTERPRISE EDITION 데이터베이스를 STANDARD EDITION으로 변경하는 법
    ====================================================
    PURPOSE
    이 문서는 Enterprise Edition 데이터베이스를 Standard Edition 데이터베이스로
    변경하는 방법에 대하여 설명한다.
    Introduction:
    Oracle 서버는 Standard Edition과 Enterprise Edition 사이에 다양한 차이점이
    존재한다. 두 Edition간의 차이점에 대하여는 메타링크에서 <Note:1011449.7>와
    <Note:112591.1>를 참조한다.
    다양한 Option들을 사용하는 경우 이 두 Version간의 차이점 때문에, Enterprise
    Edition에서 Standard Edition으로 변경하는 것이 간단하지 않다. 사실 이러한
    문제는 Enterprise Edition이 Standard Edition에서는 사용할 수 없는 많은
    Data Dictionary object들을 포함하고 있기 때문이다. 단순히 Standard Edition
    소프트웨어를 설치하더라도 쓸모없거나 데이터베이스를 관리하면서 문제를 만들
    소지가 있는 Data Dictionary object 가 남아 있을 뿐이다.
    Standard Edition에서 Enterprise Edition으로 변경할 때는 단순히 적합한
    소프트위어를 설치하고, 새 Oralce 특색을 위한 Oracle Data Dictionary 를
    업그레이드 하기 CATALOG.SQL과 CATPROC.SQL (또는 EE Version 소프트웨어의
    Advanced Replication 같은 Option 사용을 위한 Data Dictionary 스크립트)를
    실행하면 된다.
    Actions:
    Enterprise Edition에서 Standard Edition으로 돌아가는 가장 적합한 방법은
    Export/Import 를 이용하는 것이다. SYS 스키마의 Object들은 추출되지 않기
    때문에 이것만이 Enterprise Edition에만 있는 Data Dictionary object들을
    제거하는 방법이다.
    Standard Edition 데이터베이스로 Import 후에는 MDSYS 계정과 같은 Enterprise
    Edition 기능들과 연관이 있는 스키마들을 삭제하는 것만 필요하다.
    NOTE: CAT* 스크립트들을 실행하는 것만으로도 EE 에서 SE 로 변경할 수는
    있지만, data dictionary에서 더 이상 사용할 수 없는 Object들을 볼 수 있다.
    이러한 invalid object들을 제거 하는것을 원하지 않는다면, EE 소프트웨어를
    설치하고 데이터베이스를 생성 후 data를 import 해야만 한다.
    RELATED DOCUMENTS
    Oracle8i Getting To Know manual
    Oracle8i Utilities manual
    <Note:139642.1> Converting from Enterprise Edition to Standard Edition
    <Note:1011449.7> Differences between Oracle7 Workgroup Server and Oracle7
    Enterprise Server
    <Note:112591.1> Differences Between Standard Edition and Enterprise
    Edition in 8i
    <Note:117048.1> How to Upgrade from Standard to Enterprise Edition

  • Installing SAP ERP on DB2 with high availability

    Hey Gurus,
    currently we're installing SAP ERP 6 EHP 6 based on DB2 for unix and windows, this is done using the high availability option on AIX 7.1 and IBM's power HA.
    We have the following architecture:
              Node A:
                        1-A host for ASCS, ERS and CI.
                        2-A host for the DB instance.
    The same with node B replacing CI with DI.
    Please advise on how to proceed with installation.
    Also I need a bit of clarification regarding how to share (or export) the file systems between the hosts of the same node so that the CI can and DB can be connected, since as far as I know the DB installation will ask for the profile directory through the installation, while the CI will ask to see the db file systems as well as the db instance.
    Thanks in advance

    Hi Ahmed,
    For your query
    Also I need a bit of clarification regarding how to share (or export) the file systems between the hosts of the same node so that the CI can and DB can be connected, since as far as I know the DB installation will ask for the profile directory through the installation, while the CI will ask to see the db file systems as well as the db instance.
    Please refer installation guide sections related to file system planning.
    Here you can see the file system directory structure as well as information on which filesystems to be shared.
    Attached are some screenshot for reference
    Hope this helps.
    Regards,
    Deepak Kori

  • Cisco Prime LMS High Availability

    Hi,
    I am trying to setup prime LMS 4.2 with a pair of soft appliance. As I understand that HA is possible with the use of veritas/vmware for windows/solaris; I was wondering what are the possible high availability options available with a pair of prime LMS appliances? Can it form active/secondary with data synchronization/data redundancy of the LMS on top of the traditional backup/restore of the lms?
    Any input is appreciated.
    Thanks

    As iceman said, in VMWare it is not needed to have a pair of host machines to configure HA. Pairs are managed using third party HA services like veritas.
    In VMWare's HA concept all Host machines are pooled into one cluster and in case of host failure the entire cluster is moved to another host. vMotion can also help to move the entire vm to another host.
    This is when the host fails where vm resides. In case of failure of vm itself, the HA can be set for various actions lilke Automatic restart when hardware or OS failure is detected. OR it can restart another backup host in other cluster when failure is detected.
    You need to check availble HA option on VMWare and you can consider HA options via third party applications like veritas as well.
    -Thanks
    Vinod
    **Support Contributors. Rate them. **

  • Identity management 11g in High Availability Mode.

    Hi All,
    Can any one please give me some pointers on how to configure Identity management 11g in High Availability Mode. If possible please provide some document links for reference.
    Currectly I am looking into below Oracle Ducument.
    http://download.oracle.com/docs/cd/E15523_01/core.1111/e12035/directorytier_im.htm#BACIEEBD
    This document completely configuring the High Avaialability case when we have Oracle Data Base in RAC mode. Please correct me if i am wrong.
    But I just wanted to know how can we configure the high availability mode without Oracle DataBase in RAC mode.
    Do we need to configure the DataBase in high Availability Mode also?
    Thanks in Advance.
    Siva Pokuri.

    Below resources should be of some help to you:
    http://www.oracle.com/technology/products/ias/hi_av/F5v9LBR.pdf
    http://www.oracle.com/technology/products/ias/hi_av/904_Distributed_IM.pdf
    http://www.oracle.com/technology/products/ias/hi_av/904_rack_mounted_im.pdf
    http://www.oracle.com/technology/products/ias/hi_av/904_cfc_im.pdf
    http://www.oracle.com/technology/products/ias/hi_av/OracleASInfraHAArchs.pdf

  • Oracle Identity Federation - High Availability

    Hello,
    We are trying to figure out the high availability options supported by the Oracle Identity Federation. While reading the documentation we find it a bit confusing. We read the OIF Administrator Guide here: http://download.oracle.com/docs/cd/E10773_01/doc/oim.1014/b25355/advtopics.htm#CHDBCDFG
    In Section "9.4 High Availability" it said that "Oracle Identity Federation supports the Cold Failover Cluster (CFC) or active-passive high availability configuration,". In the Application Server 10g guide also said the same and explicitly said that the active-active configuration is not supported for the OIF.
    Then in Section "9.5 Setting Up a Load Balancer with Oracle Identity Federation" it explains how to set up a load balancer for the OIF. When it explains this it says that we can have several instances of OIF in different machines, configured with a load balancer. All these instances share the same transient database where the sessions are stored.
    Which is the difference between this load-balancer-based configuration and an active-active high availability configuration? If one node of the load-balancer configuration goes down, the sessions administered by him are lost? That is the difference?
    Thanks!
    Leonardo

    Hi
    I am not very sure about High Availability configuration but for Load balancer as mentioned in the document, You have to have both the instances sharing transient database where sessions will be stored.
    If both the OIF instances are not sharing transient database and you have LB sharing load, It will not work as sessions will be store in memory. So sessions from one OIF instance will not be known and available to the other instance of OIF.
    Thanks
    Kiran Thakkar

  • SAPConsole - Telnet server in high-availibility

    Hi there,
    I was asked by a customer to deploy all components of the SAPConsole and the Telnet server without SPOF. I doubt that the SAPConsole and any Telnet server is natively cluster aware nor can they be installed in a high availability scenario without additional software and development. My idea is to deploy two consoles with two telnet server clients. Additionally using a MSCS and some lines of code in a batch file, it should be possible to make both Apps cluster aware.
    Has anybody out there ever designed a scenario like this?
    Any hint or help is much appreciated.
    Regards,
    Bodo

    Hi Barbara.
    I'm sorry to use this old thread, but did you managed to get high availability on your SAPConsole?
    Thanks,
    Pierre

Maybe you are looking for

  • Error when changing unit of Issue in material master

    Hi, When i am  trying to change Unit of issue in Qualitymanagement view of  a material using MM02 transaction, we  got error message - "The unit of issue cannot be changed because the material is used in a BOM-------Mesage no. M3214" Can anyone sugge

  • HP OFFICEJET WITH MAC

    I have a Mac desktop - OS X Version 10.8.3 and have had problems with printing since Oct 2012 when I purchased my mac, I have HP Officejet6500A and it only prints about 50% of the time, can anyone assist me.

  • ?my apple account used an email from a previous job that i can't access now

    My apple account was my ex work email I no longer have access to I thought i had changed it but when I try and update apps my user name still comes up with the old one and won;t let me chane it help please ?

  • Keyboard mismatch between Mac and Windows

    Hi I am currently running VMware (latest release) with two virtual machines: Windows XP and Scientific Linux 4.5 Do you know where can I find a correct Portuguese keyboard map of my Mac Book Pro (Mac OS X 10.5.6) for those virtual machines ? Thanks a

  • Why can't I use final cut pro 7 with Mavericks?

    Why can't I use final cut pro 7 with Mavericks? Is any one else having problems? All my media is reputedly "offline" even though I can see all the files. Using the reconnect to media function doesn't do a thing. All of my previous projects are the sa