How to set up 6th Generation AirPort Extreme to cable modem as a wireless router and then connect my 3rd Generation Time Capsule to AirPort Extreme as a wireless extender?

What is the best way to set up my 6th Generation AirPort Extreme (A1521) to my cable modem as a wireless router and then connect my 3rd Generation Time Capsule (A1355) to my AirPort Extreme as a wireless extender? I live in a small 1 story house and I currently have the Airport Extreme connected to my cable modem in the living room and the Time Capsule plugged into the wall in my bedroom. I am able to wirelessly connect to the internet using the AirPort Extreme as my router and I can also do wireless back ups to my Time Capsule. My problem is that my connection seems to be really slow! My 1TB Time Capsule back up is only half way complete and it has been 3 days! My computer has been backing up all day and night for almost 72 hours and its still not even 75% complete. I have backed up to this Time Capsule in the past and it never took this long. I am thinking that when I set up my AirPort Extreme and Time Capsule using AirPort Utility I must have set it up incorrectly or something.
How do I set up my Airport Extreme and Time Capsule for the fastest possible internet speed and back up speed?
Thank you,

AirPort Utility 5.6 works with AirPort Extreme 802.11g base stations.
It works with N version airports.
It will also show details of the AC model but cannot be used for the setup.. mostly.
I purposely got the new 6th Gen Airport Extreme so my internet connection would be a lot faster!
Your network will be much faster when you have AC client directly connected to the AE. Older client will go no faster.. but what is worse.. extend wireless is mixing new and old wireless standards.. guess what one wins.. OLD.. So when you extend wireless.. you have no improvement whatsoever. This whole post is about extending wireless.. so you cannot extend to older equipment and do any better.. maybe slightly better signal although from your comments that isn't happening either.
I would rather not have to use an ethernet at all with the TC and I don't know EOP adapters are!
If you do not use ethernet then you are going to be forced to accept slow speed.
EOP (ethernet over power). Also called homeplug in the US.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HomePlug
Provides a method of networking over power cabling that already exists in your house.
So what your saying is for the fastest internet speed and back up speed possible I should keep my Airport Extreme plugged into my Modem and keep my TC set up as a wireless extender? Then when I want to do back ups I should plug an ethernet cable from my TC to my MacBook Pro?
To spell this out.
A wireless link to an extended device will go very slowly.. if it is not direct.
So lets say you have a laptop sitting in the lounge.. Your connection goes.. Laptop- - - - - AE- - - - -TC.
That means two wireless links.. wireless has this nasty half duplex and single channel nature.. it can send or receive (Tx or Rx) but not at the same time.
Ethernet by contrast does both at once. It is full duplex.
Wireless can talk to one client at a time.. so if there are multiple items using wireless lets say 4 devices.. then your computer gets a 25% time slice. Since wireless cannot handle multiple simultaneous connections.
Ethernet by contrast can connect multiple computers to multiple destinations at the same time.. all transmitting and receiving at full speed.
When you put all this together.. there are a couple of rules for fast connection.
1. Use ethernet at all times. Where you cannot use ethernet use anything but wireless.. eg EOP (homeplug) at least to try and get rid of wireless.
2. Where you must use wireless use it sparingly and make sure it is never more than one hop.. ie never have an extend wireless (repeater is more usual term). Repeater will cause instant slowdown of 50% and maybe up to 75% just because it is so inefficient.
3. Fastest wireless is 5ghz but it has very short range.. you need to be up close and personal to get it working.
Apple routers however unless you do manual setup I suggest are set to connect to best signal strength not best speed. It will therefore use 2.4ghz at 25% less speed than 5ghz because it is 1db better signal.. this madness means you need to setup manually for the best setup.

Similar Messages

  • HT2497 do I connect my airport express to my modem via the WAN port and then connect to my imac via ethernet cable?

    Do I connect my airport express to my modem via the WAN port and then connect from airport express to my imac with ethernet cable? Is that how you "hard wire" the connection? Because when I do that, I still can't get online. Thanks.

    What is the make & model of your modem?
    You pretty much stated the correct wiring. There should be an Ethernet cable connected between the modem and the WAN (circle of dots) port on the AirPort Express base station.
    Anytime you change networking hardware it is always a good idea to perform a complete power recycle of that hardware. Check out the following AirPort User Tip for details. Please post back your results.

  • How do I configure my AirPort Extreme as a wireless access point?  My cable modem goes to a router, and one of those ports goes to my AirPortExtreme.

    I am about to hook up my airport extreme.  My cable modem goes into a router, and one of those ports will supply my airport extreme.  I was told by the Apple Store that I would need to configure my airport extreme as a wirreless access point.  How do I do this?

    With sbcgobal I got a Gateway 2wire modem. What I would like to know is how do I set up my APE as remote?
    Unfortunately, you won't be able to do this as few non-AirPort routers will work with AirPorts in a Wireless Distribution System (WDS).

  • How to set up the iPhone 5 so that I can receive iMessage (incoming messages) and send text messages (outgoing) every time?

    How do I set up the iPhone 5 so that I can receive iMessage (incoming messages) and send text messages (outgoing) every time? I have limited internet quota but unlimited sms!

    Thanks!!
    The reason I don't want to set it off is because I want to let others send me iMessage - most people prefer that according to their plan.
    How do I bring this request to the hands of the people doing the ios updates? Maybe they could work on this for the future...

  • How do I connect a 1 T time capsule to a new airport extreme so I can use it with time machine?

    How do I connect a 1 T time capsule to a new airport extreme so I can use it with time machine?

    Bridge the TC.. plug it into the AEBS with ethernet.

  • Adding Time Capsule to Airport Extreme/Epresses

    I'm not sure if this is the right place and I'm posting this question in other Discussion groups as well. If this isn't the right place, please let me know where I should post this.
    I just purchased a Time Capsule. I've got an old (cone shaped) Airport Extreme and two Airport Expressses (to extend the range of my wireless network).
    I've also got a DSL modem which is connected to an old SMC Wireless router. Right now the Airport Extreme is connected (in bridge mode) to the SMC Wireless router and the Expresses are "connected" to the Extreme. There's also a printer connected to the Express.
    Everything works (more or less) fine as things are (there are some issues with two laptops trying to use the Extreme/Express network "knocking each other off, but that's not what I'm concerned with now).
    I'm wondering whether I should replace the Airport Extreme portion of things with the Time Capsule, or if I should just connect the Time Capsule to the SCM Wireless router (it has four or five ethernet out ports) and set it up to work with the Extreme/Express network some how.
    Has anyone ever tried that kind of thing or have any input?
    Thanks!

    Thanks for the input! I wouldn't mind doing away with the SMC part of things, but there are some "legacy" reasons why I keep it (plus it does have a more ethernet ports than either the Extreme or TC).
    As for this:
    "Also, a possible reason of why there is an issue with the two laptops connecting to the network, is that maybe they are trying to be assigned the same IP address, and so therefore are cutting each other off when they connect to the network."
    I'd worried about that, but . . . I've got an old Pismo that can talk to the Extreme at the same time as my MacBook and an Apple TV and two iPhones and a wireless webcam that all talk to the Extreme while the MacBook does. It's only the MacBook and MacBook Pro that have problems with each other. I've check the MAC address (or whatever) of them and seen they're different. For what it's worth, the MacBook started life as a clone of the MacBook Pro.

  • I would like to set up a media server on time capsule using airport express and an ipad as a remote for dance studio

    I am wanting to set up a network for my business and was hoping if someone could tell me how to do this and if it will indeed work. Or if you have any better ideas.
    I want to transfer all music to Airport Time Capsule. I want to plug in the aiport express to my sound system. I want to access music through the ipad off the timecapsule to play it without downlaoding it on the ipad.
    We currently use Icloud, but there is too much music and too many devices accessing for it to work effectively. I am running a dance studio so we need more music than what could ever be stored on an ipad/ipod.
    As an extention to this, can we use multiple Airport expresses plugged into mutiple sound systems to simultaneously access different music from the same time capsule?
    Any ideas would be so great!

    The answer is not if you use iTunes.
    The TC is NOT an iTunes server.. it is not a media device at all. It is a backup location for Time Machine.
    You need a computer in the network which stores the iTunes library and you can then play it via the ipad.
    A mini with a large USB drive plugged in will work fine.. it doesn't need to be new.. a couple of years old mini will work just as well.
    As an extention to this, can we use multiple Airport expresses plugged into mutiple sound systems to simultaneously access different music from the same time capsule?
    I am not sure.. there will be network limitations to this.
    Look up how to use itunes in a network.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht4620
    You would do better perhaps posting the question in iTunes section.. if as I guess you are actually using iTunes.

  • Time Capsule or Airport Extreme

    I have a 1st generation Time Capsule that I use as the main wireless access point in my house.  All devices connect to it:  laptops, iPads, iPods, iPhones, televisions, playstations, etc.  I also have gigabit switch plugged into the Time Capsule, and I run some of the wired devices from it.  Among the wired devices is a docking station that I use for home office work--so I have an ethernet cable running from the switch to the docking station in the office.  Wireless range of the TC does not quite get to the upper floor of my house as well as I would like, so I need to extend my network.  I was going to get an Airport Extreme for this.  However, I was wondering a couple things:
    1.  Is the Extreme overkill for what I am trying to do?  Will I even realize very much of the potential of the Extreme, given that the TC is a 1st Gen?  In other words, is the performance of the Extreme dependent in any way on the TC?
    2.  Would it make any sense to use the Airport Extreme as the main wireless router and use the TC to extend the network.  Would this cause any issues with the backups?
    Thank you!

    cannonfish9212 wrote:
    I have a 1st generation Time Capsule
    That is very old and well worth considering replacement.
    1.  Is the Extreme overkill for what I am trying to do?  Will I even realize very much of the potential of the Extreme, given that the TC is a 1st Gen?  In other words, is the performance of the Extreme dependent in any way on the TC?
    When you say extend do you mean by wireless or ethernet? Extending by wireless will certainly drag the speed down to the speed of the TC.. so that is highly undesirable. If you do the connection by ethernet then it is fine.
    You get the full potential of the wireless on the AE assuming you have modern products to use it. Mostly of course it will be no faster as 2.4ghz is still just as limited as ever.
    2.  Would it make any sense to use the Airport Extreme as the main wireless router and use the TC to extend the network.  Would this cause any issues with the backups?
    Same thing applies.. backups over a wireless bridge will be very poor. That would be a setup to be avoided.
    As long as you run ethernet then it doesn't matter which goes where.
    You might consider buying a Gen4 TC second hand or from the refurbished shop if you do want to use wireless extend.. then you will still have a TC as the main wireless router.. with far superior wireless to the Gen1.. but not AC .. for which you probably have no use yet anyway. And can use the old Gen1 as a wireless extender to that.

  • Airtune Over Ethernet  with Time Capsule or Airport Extreme

    Can the previous generation Time Capsule or Airport Extreme bridge an ethernet client to an Airtunes network?
    Current Setup: I have an aluminum iMac wired to my Time Capsule; currently, I use the aluminum as a music server by connecting to several Airport Express clients over the the iMac's built-in Airport for Airtunes support.
    Problem: I have 3-802.11g clients dragging my wifi network. I would like to dedicate the iMac's internal network to the g-clients so I don't have to use compatibility mode for my n-network. However, I will lose Airtunes speaker support when I use internet sharing over the built-in Airport. Airtunes does not appear to support the Time Capsule ethernet client.
    Nodes:
    -AE 802.11g (Airtunes only)
    -AE 802.11n (Airtunes and USB printer)
    -1st gen Time Capsule (Internet gateway, "creating network" 802.11 g/n,
    -iMac 8,1 (Music server via internal wifi, wired TC client)
    -Macbook 4,1 (wifi client)
    -iPhone
    -Canon MP620 (USB to iMac, wifi to Macbook)

    Further to Bob's comments..
    A Gen1 TC will be using marvel wireless chip and your 2008 and 2010 Macbook will use atheros and/or broadcom cards.. Just open your system profiler and look for info on the airport. We find the mixture of wireless chipsets especially older draft N and later N products can give very varied results.
    The very fact you are linking at 270 and not 300mbps shows some reduction from theoretical max speed.. and really to get over 100mbps with any wireless you need perfect setup.. matched wireless chips etc.
    Do a test uploading and downloading a file to the TC to see if the LAN speed is better than internet speed.
    In reality I think you are doing especially well.. we see loads of people complaining about slow internet here who are getting less than 10% of the speed they get direct when routed through the TC. And on most occasions the limit in speed is not really going to affect what you do, as the real links to the internet are not that fast.

  • Trying to set up time capsule with airport exteme. Apple advises to use manuel setup and click on Advanced.  Then enter mobileme ID. I did this but Time Machine doesn't display anything on the capsule window.

    Can't set up my time capsule on Airport Extreme (updated).  Apple instructions are to use manual set up.  Click on Advanced tab.  Click on Mobileme and enter Mobileme ID and password.  I did this.  But Time Machine window is blank.  Tryed to click on update window after entering Mobileme ID but Airport does not respond (turn of then on)

    mickair wrote:
    I have been experiencing some networking problems
    Welcome to Apple's discussion groups.
    I have the latest Time Capsule ("TC"), an old Airport Extreme Base Station ("AEBS") bought in 2007 and 2 Airport Expresses, one bought in 3 months ago ("AE-Alpha") and the other bought back in 2007 ("AE-Beta"). All of them have been updated with the latest firmware.
    Based on those dates, the AirPort Extreme is probably flat (as opposed to dome-shaped), making it 802.11n-capable. The Newer AirPort Express is probably an 802.11n-capable model A1264, while the older one is probably a model A1084 or A1088.
    I use {the TC's} DHCP function ... to avoid unauthorized use.
    This a discussion for another thread, but that's not what DHCP is for.
    The wireless setting for it is to participate as WDS Main, but after reading various posts, it seems WDS is a bad idea
    With that older AirPort Express you're stuck with WDS unless you decide to replace it with a newer model.
    The AEBS is currently setup as being a WDS Relay at the moment
    Why a relay? That's only needed if there's another base station "beyond" it that is configured to depend on it.
    Since the AEBS is connected to the TC via Ethernet, you should probably configure it as a "roaming network":
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2273124
    {The AE-Alpha} connects fine as WDS remote at the moment
    I don't have any experience with mixed WDS and non-WDS networks, but since it's 802.11n-capable, you may be able to configure it to "extend" the network of the TC rather than as WDS. Look for a setting on the TC to "Allow this network to be extended".
    Physical location:
    AEBS in one end, TC and AE-Alpha in the middle while AE-Beta on the other end.
    A device such as "AE-Beta" that's supposed to extend a network shouldn't be "at the end" but should be half way between the central base station and the clients that need an extended network.

  • I have a Cisco/Linksys WRT-54G wireless router and 2 Airport Extremes (the small ones that plug directly into the wall). Is it possible to extend the network from the router using these two AEs? I have a DVD player and Ext HD plugged into the router too..

    I have a Cisco/Linksys WRT-54G wireless router and 2 Airport Extremes (the small ones that plug directly into the wall). Is it possible to extend the network from the router using these two AEs? I have a DVD player and Ext HD plugged into the router too. Any ideas? I'm guessing the only way is to do what I've seen in these community pages which states that it can be done but it will drop the bandwidth by 50%. Thoughts?? Thanks!

    The Cisco/Linksys WRT-54G was one of the very few routers said to be compatible with Apple's implementation of WDS (Wireless Distribution System) settings.
    The info that I have on file indicates that only the WRT-54G versions 4 and under were compatible, so that would be one bridge to cross.
    Even if you find that your Cisco/Linksys might be the right version, Apple never published instructions on how to configure the Express devices with other manufactures, so users were left to their own devices to try to figure out how to get things working. Apple's instructions to connect to other Apple devices are in the link below:
    WDS network
    If you were hoping to use 2 Express devices in this type of configuration...even if it works...the bandwidth penalties will be extremely severe.
    The first Express drops the bandwidth (and speed) on the entire network in half and the second halves everything again. So, the result, in effect would be a "g" wireless network running at 25% speed. Few users would consider installing this type of network.
    At this point, it becomes one of those things where the fact that you might be able to do something does not mean that there would be much value in doing so. But, it is your decision to decide if you want to try to proceed.

  • Time Capsule v Airport Extreme

    I'm currently using a fairly old Belkin wireless router and a LaCie NAS. I think both of them are heading towards end-of-life, as I now have to reboot the router daily and recently had to poke the NAS in the eye as well.
    I've decided I may as well stop messing about and shell out a little extra to buy a decent Apple product as a replacement, but I'm trying to decide between an Airport Extreme, whilst trying to get a little longer out of my LaCie drive, or going one step further and buying a Time Capsule. Obviously with the latter I can use the LaCie via USB to extend the capacity until such time as it finally keels over.
    As I see it, the TC would normally be a no-brainer, but I have a few concerns which might encourage me to wait for the next version of the TC.
    First of all, is there any Airport Extreme functionality that's missing on the TC? Also I've read it runs very hot - is this a general observation or only in some circumstances, as I don't really want to keep powering it up and down every day? And how hot is "very hot" - too hot to touch, toasty warm etc.?
    To further complicate the picture, I'm thinking of changing ISP which will entail moving my network hub out of the study, as the broadband will be coming into a different part of the building. Can I use an Airport Express (2005 model, I think) to extend the network and hook up the printers in the study with either the Extreme or TC?
    Incidentally, I won't be wanting to run Time Machine across the network, as I have a dedicated USB drive hooked up on this Mac for that purpose.
    Thanks in advance for any advice and/or comments.

    To further complicate the picture, I'm thinking of changing ISP which will entail moving my network hub out of the study, as the broadband will be coming into a different part of the building. Can I use an Airport Express (2005 model, I think) to extend the network and hook up the printers in the study with either the Extreme or TC? yes

  • HT1178 How do I set-up my Time Capsule to work with my existing Wireless Router?

    The existing  wireless router is my connection to the Internet and I would like to keep it that way. I really want the TC to fuction as an external Hard Drive/Server, Backup Disc! The TC is where all my Music and Photos are located together with my Backups!
    I have tried different configurations and I get it to work for a wile, but after a few minutes it will disappear from my Air Port Utility, a rescan will not bring it back, but if I unplug and then plug it back in it will reappear. However if the TC shows in Air Port Utility or not the TC still shows up on my Desktop.
    What Settings should I use in Air Port Utility, Should the Ethernet Cable be plugged into Ethernet or LAN Port?
    My Current Settings are:
    Ethernet Cable: Connected to the ETHERNET PORT
    AirPor Tab:
    Wireless Mode: OFF
    Connect Using: ETHERNET
    Internet Tab: Internet Connection
    Connect Using: ETHERNET
    Connection Sharing: OFF (BRIDGE MODE)
    TCP/IP:
    Configure IPv4: USING DHCP

    I am Running OS 10.5.8 on a PowerBook G4.
    Below you will see the Log (IP Address, AirPort ID, Eternet ID, Subnet Mask, Router Address, DNS Server Info has been removed).
    I had the TC was originally set-up connected to a DLS Modem, all worked fine Backups over TM all was ok, but then the Modem died. (I upgraded to a Wireless Router). I did have it set up, but I nolonger know the settings, I wanted to do a backup with TM, which had not been done for a long time (6 months)
    I tried to backup, but either it was not working or was taking sooooo long, that I decided to do the Backup over Ethernet (still took the hole day for 8.5 GB). I had read that I nedded to chang my setting to be able to Backup with Ethernet. Did not Save the previous settings hence my problem!
    Log:
    Nov 21 08:23:26
    Severity:5
    Initialized (firmware 7.6.1).
    Nov 21 08:23:31
    Severity:3
    No Address for NTP server time.apple.com.
    Nov 21 08:23:31
    Severity:5
    Internet configuration leased [IPv4] -- host <0> gateway <> dns <> wins <> lease <1814400> domain <Speedport_W723_V_Typ
    Nov 21 08:23:33
    Severity:5
    Internet configuration leased [IPv4] -- host <> gateway <> dns <> wins <> lease <1814400> domain <Speedport_W723_V_Typ
    Nov 21 08:23:46
    Severity:3
    No Address for NTP server time.apple.com.
    Nov 21 08:24:01
    Severity:5
    Clock synchronized to network time server time.apple.com (adjusted +7 seconds).
    Nov 21 08:28:05
    Severity:5
    Connection accepted from [%bridge0]:49362.
    Nov 21 08:28:06
    Severity:5
    Connection accepted from [%bridge0]:49363.
    Nov 21 08:28:06
    Severity:5
    Connection accepted from [%bridge0]:49364.
    Nov 21 09:24:53
    Severity:5
    Initialized (firmware 7.6.1).
    Nov 21 09:24:57
    Severity:3
    No Address for NTP server time.apple.com.
    Nov 21 09:24:59
    Severity:5
    Internet configuration leased [IPv4] -- host <> gateway <> dns <> wins <> lease <1814400> domain <Speedport_W723_V_Typ
    Nov 21 09:25:00
    Severity:5
    Internet configuration leased [IPv4] -- host <> gateway <> dns <> wins <> lease <1814400> domain <Speedport_W723_V_Typ
    Nov 21 09:25:02
    Severity:5
    Connection accepted from [%bridge0]:49884.
    Nov 21 09:25:03
    Severity:5
    Connection accepted from [%bridge0]:49885.
    Nov 21 09:25:03
    Severity:5
    Connection accepted from [%bridge0]:49886.
    Nov 21 09:25:12
    Severity:3
    No Address for NTP server time.apple.com.
    Nov 21 09:25:28
    Severity:5
    Clock synchronized to network time server time.apple.com (adjusted +7 seconds).

  • How do I connect to Time Capsule from a Windows 8.1 machine which is on a Windows domain. I have been able to connect from a Windows 7 machine on a Windows domain to a Time Capsule. Airport utility is not displaying the Time Capsule Win8.1 machine

    How do I connect to Time Capsule from a Windows 8.1 machine which is on a Windows domain. I have been able to connect from a Windows 7 machine on a Windows domain to a Time Capsule. Airport utility is not displaying the Time Capsule Win8.1 machine.
    I have checked that the firmware has been updated to 7.6.4 . Similalrly the Win8.1 machine has been loaded with the update specified in another discussion.

    Firstly how are you connecting to the TC.. wireless or ethernet?
    Please open a command window and ping it.. ping by name and by IP address.
    If ping succeeds at least by IP it should work.
    In windows explorer type
    \\10.0.1.1 (or whatever the TC ip is.. that is the default).
    Having the airport utility for windows loaded can help the process. As it loads bonjour for windows.
    7.6.4 firmware on the TC is useless. It works better on 7.6.1
    If the ping does not succeed by either name or IP address yet you have internet through the TC, then your network is setup wrongly. You are have firewalls blocking local IP. Take down all the firewalls.

  • HT201514 i can't see the time capsule from airport utilities. i did follow "From the Apple menu, choose System Preferences. Choose View Time Machine. Set Time Machine to On if it is off. .....but i couldn't find the time capsule from airport utility.....

    i did follow "From the Apple menu, choose System Preferences. Choose View > Time Machine. Set Time Machine to On if it is off "
    . .....but i couldn't find the time capsule from airport utility..... why?

    Are you using a new 802.11ac Time Capsule - the "tall" one - and are you still using Mac OS X 10.6.8?
    You need OS X 10.7.5 "Lion" or later, or an iOS device, to configure an 802.11ac Time Capsule:
    http://manuals.info.apple.com/MANUALS/1000/MA1645/en_US/airport_time_capsule_802 11ac_setup.pdf
    See page 12.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Thunderbolt iMac - mini-dvi to HDMI - Image not sharp on TV

    I am trying to use my TV as a second monitor for my newish iMac.  I used to do the same thing with my macbook (2006) with a mini-dvi to HDMI adapter.  The signal then was crisp and typical of 1080p.  I recently tried two different mini-displayport to

  • Use Time Machine HD as regular external HD?

    Is it possible to convert the backups.backupdb folder on an external HD I've been using for Time Machine into a regular folder? Or to otherwise move around and delete files within the backups.backupdb folder on the Time Machine HD? My old Macbook Pro

  • [SOLVED] KDE Plasma 5 | Lock Screen Issues

    Everytime my computer locks - whether it be manually or automaticly, I get this lock menu with 3 options. The first option has my username and my avatar, which prompts me for my password. Everytime I type in the correct password, the screen turns bla

  • Installing iphoto 6 on my PC

    I want to be able to share my pictures with my wife and mother in law only they both have pcs. Is it possible to download iphoto on their computers. I burned a dvd of my whole iphoto library and the wifes pc can not read it. Any suggestions? She has

  • IPhoto 08 not recognizing smart playlists

    Been trying to make a slideshow and play from my Christmas playlist (Smart Album of Christmas Genre music) and iPhoto 08 either can't find the music or just doesn't play it. If I pick an individual song it seems to work. And hypothetically, if I did