Query of query with left outer join
Hi,
I cannot use joins in query of query, I try the old method using the ( + ) but no luck "Query Of Queries syntax error. Encountered ( + )."
Here is an example of my query code:
select p.part_id, s.supplier_name, s.second_name
from part p, supplier s
where p.supplier_id = s.supplier_id ( + )
and p.second_id = s.second_id ( + );
PART SUPPLIER_NAME SECOND_NAME
P1 Supplier#1 A
P2 Supplier#2
P3
P4
How can I do the same in query of query syntax?
Thanks!
I found a solution:
http://www.bealearts.co.uk/blog/2007/06/20/how-to-do-an-outer-join-in-query-of-queries/
I am not sure about my second condition. i create the join query for the empty columns.
select part.part_id, supplier.supplier_name, supplier.second_name
from part, supplier
where part.supplier_id = supplier.supplier_id
and supplier.second_id is null
union
select part.part_id, supplier.supplier_name, supplier.second_name
from part, supplier
where part.supplier_id = supplier.supplier_id
and part.second_id = supplier.second_id
union
select part.part_id, joinQuery.supplier_name, joinQuery.second_name
from part, joinQuery
where part.supplier_id not in (#ValueList(supplier.supplier_id)#)
Can anyone check and let me know if this is correct?
My final result have one less row from parts table.
Thanks
Similar Messages
-
Update Statement with left outer join
hi,
i have to update a column in table "a" from table "b" and both of them joined with left outer join
How can I do this
Thanks in AdvancePlease consider the following when you post a question. This would help us help you better
1. New features keep coming in every oracle version so please provide Your Oracle DB Version to get the best possible answer.
You can use the following query and do a copy past of the output.
select * from v$version 2. This forum has a very good Search Feature. Please use that before posting your question. Because for most of the questions
that are asked the answer is already there.
3. We dont know your DB structure or How your Data is. So you need to let us know. The best way would be to give some sample data like this.
I have the following table called sales
with sales
as
select 1 sales_id, 1 prod_id, 1001 inv_num, 120 qty from dual
union all
select 2 sales_id, 1 prod_id, 1002 inv_num, 25 qty from dual
select *
from sales 4. Rather than telling what you want in words its more easier when you give your expected output.
For example in the above sales table, I want to know the total quantity and number of invoice for each product.
The output should look like this
Prod_id sum_qty count_inv
1 145 2 5. When ever you get an error message post the entire error message. With the Error Number, The message and the Line number.
6. Next thing is a very important thing to remember. Please post only well formatted code. Unformatted code is very hard to read.
Your code format gets lost when you post it in the Oracle Forum. So in order to preserve it you need to
use the {noformat}{noformat} tags.
The usage of the tag is like this.
<place your code here>\
7. If you are posting a *Performance Related Question*. Please read
{thread:id=501834} and {thread:id=863295}.
Following those guide will be very helpful.
8. Please keep in mind that this is a public forum. Here No question is URGENT.
So use of words like *URGENT* or *ASAP* (As Soon As Possible) are considered to be rude. -
Not using Index when SDO_RELATE in Spatial Query is used in LEFT OUTER JOIN
I want to know for every City (Point geometry) in which Municipality (Polygon geometry) it is.
Some cities will not be covered by any municipality (as there is no data for it), so its municipality name should be blank in the result
We have 4942 cities (point geometries)
and 500 municipalities (polygon geometry)
SELECT T1.NAME as City, T2.NAME as Municipality
FROM CITY T1
LEFT OUTER JOIN MUNICIPALITY T2 ON SDO_RELATE(T1.GEOM, T2.GEOM, 'MASK=ANYINTERACT') = 'TRUE'The explain plan for this query is:
SELECT STATEMENT
FILTER
Filter Predicates
MDSYS.SDO_RTREE_RELATE(T1.GEOM, T2.GEOM, 'mask=ANYINTERACT querytype=window ') = 'TRUE'
MERGE JOIN
TABLE ACCESS CITY FULL 11
BUFFER SORT 100605
TABLE ACCESS MUNICIPALITY FULL 20So the cost is in the BUFFER (whatever that is), it takes +2000 seconds to run this, it is not using the spatial index.
And we are not getting all rows, but only the ones interacting with a municipality, e.g. 2436 rows.
But I want all rows, including the ones not interacting with any Municipality.
When we want only those cities that actually are in a municipality, I use a different query and it will use the index.
SELECT T1.NAME as City, T2.NAME as Municipality
FROM CITY T1, MUNICIPALITY T2
WHERE SDO_RELATE(T1.GEOM, T2.GEOM, 'MASK=ANYINTERACT') = 'TRUE'I get (only) 2436 rows (as expected) in 5 seconds (it is fast) and the explain plan shows it is using the spatial index.
But in this case, I am not getting any cities not inside any municipality (of course)
SELECT STATEMENT
NESTED LOOPS
TABLE ACCESS MUNICIPALITY FULL 22
TABLE ACCESS CITY BY INDEX ROWID 22
DOMAIN INDEX CITY_SDX 0
Access Predicates
MDSYS.SDO_RTREE_RELATE(T1.GEOM, T2.GEOM, 'mask=ANYINTERACT querytype=window ') = 'TRUE'I always thought a LEFT OUTER JOIN would return all rows from the Table, whatever happens in the next,
but it seems the query has been rewritten so that it is now using a Filter Predicate in the end, which filters those geometries having no interaction.
As an example I also do thing alphanumerically, I do get 4942 rows, including the ones which have no Municipality name.
In this case the names must match, so its only for testing if the LEFT OUTER JOIN returns stuff correctly, which it does in this case.
SELECT T1.NAME as City, T2.NAME as Municipality
FROM CITY T1
LEFT OUTER JOIN MUNICIPALITY T2 ON T1.NAME = T2.NAMEIs this an Oracle Spatial bug, e.g. not return 4942 rows, but only 2436 rows on the first query?
Note all tests performed on Oracle 11g R2 (11.2.0.1.0)Patrick,
Even so, your geoms in the relate were the wrong way around.
Also, I don't recall you saying (or showing) that you wanted the municipality geometry returned. Still,
no matter, easy to do.
Here are some additional suggestions. I don't have your data so I have had to use some of my own.
set serveroutput on timing on autotrace on
SELECT T1.SPECIES as City,
(SELECT T2.ADMIN_NAME FROM AUSTRALIAN_STATES T2 WHERE SDO_ANYINTERACT(T2.GEOM, SDO_GEOM.SDO_BUFFER(T1.GEOM,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M')) = 'TRUE') as Municipality,
(SELECT T2.GEOM FROM AUSTRALIAN_STATES T2 WHERE SDO_ANYINTERACT(T2.GEOM, SDO_GEOM.SDO_BUFFER(T1.GEOM,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M')) = 'TRUE') as geom
FROM GUTDATA T1;
762 rows selected
Elapsed: 00:00:21.656
Plan hash value: 2160035213
| Id | Operation | Name | Rows | Bytes | Cost (%CPU)| Time |
| 0 | SELECT STATEMENT | | 762 | 49530 | 5 (0)| 00:00:01 |
| 1 | TABLE ACCESS BY INDEX ROWID| AUSTRALIAN_STATES | 1 | 115 | 0 (0)| 00:00:01 |
|* 2 | DOMAIN INDEX | AUSTRALIAN_STATES_GEOM_SPX | | | 0 (0)| 00:00:01 |
| 3 | TABLE ACCESS BY INDEX ROWID| AUSTRALIAN_STATES | 1 | 115 | 0 (0)| 00:00:01 |
|* 4 | DOMAIN INDEX | AUSTRALIAN_STATES_GEOM_SPX | | | 0 (0)| 00:00:01 |
| 5 | TABLE ACCESS FULL | GUTDATA | 762 | 49530 | 5 (0)| 00:00:01 |
Predicate Information (identified by operation id):
2 - access("MDSYS"."SDO_ANYINTERACT"("T2"."GEOM","SDO_GEOM"."SDO_BUFFER"(:B1,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M'))='TRUE')
4 - access("MDSYS"."SDO_ANYINTERACT"("T2"."GEOM","SDO_GEOM"."SDO_BUFFER"(:B1,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M'))='TRUE')
Statistics
7 user calls
24576 physical read total bytes
0 physical write total bytes
0 spare statistic 3
0 commit cleanout failures: cannot pin
0 TBS Extension: bytes extended
0 total number of times SMON posted
0 SMON posted for undo segment recovery
0 SMON posted for dropping temp segment
0 segment prealloc tasksThe above can look messy as you add more (SELECT ...) attributes, but is is fast (though can't use in Materialized Views).
/* The set of all cities not in municipalities */
SELECT T1.SPECIES as City,
cast(null as varchar2(42)) as municipality,
cast(null as sdo_geometry) as geom
FROM GUTDATA T1
WHERE NOT EXISTS (SELECT 1
FROM AUSTRALIAN_STATES T2
WHERE SDO_ANYINTERACT(T2.GEOM, SDO_GEOM.SDO_BUFFER(T1.GEOM,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M')) = 'TRUE')
UNION ALL
/* The set of all cities in municipalities */
SELECT T1.SPECIES as City,
T2.ADMIN_NAME as Municipality,
T2.GEOM as geom
FROM GUTDATA T1
INNER JOIN
AUSTRALIAN_STATES T2 ON (SDO_ANYINTERACT(T2.GEOM, SDO_GEOM.SDO_BUFFER(T1.GEOM,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M')) = 'TRUE');
762 rows selected
Elapsed: 00:00:59.953
Plan hash value: 2854682795
| Id | Operation | Name | Rows | Bytes | Cost (%CPU)| Time |
| 0 | SELECT STATEMENT | | 99 | 13450 | 38 (87)| 00:00:01 |
| 1 | UNION-ALL | | | | | |
|* 2 | FILTER | | | | | |
| 3 | TABLE ACCESS FULL| GUTDATA | 762 | 49530 | 5 (0)| 00:00:01 |
|* 4 | DOMAIN INDEX | AUSTRALIAN_STATES_GEOM_SPX | | | 0 (0)| 00:00:01 |
| 5 | NESTED LOOPS | | 61 | 10980 | 33 (0)| 00:00:01 |
| 6 | TABLE ACCESS FULL| AUSTRALIAN_STATES | 8 | 920 | 3 (0)| 00:00:01 |
|* 7 | TABLE ACCESS FULL| GUTDATA | 8 | 520 | 4 (0)| 00:00:01 |
Predicate Information (identified by operation id):
2 - filter( NOT EXISTS (SELECT 0 FROM "AUSTRALIAN_STATES" "T2" WHERE "MDSYS"."SDO_ANYINTERACT"("T2"."GEOM","SDO_GEOM"."SDO_BUFFER"(:B1,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M'))='TRUE'))
4 - access("MDSYS"."SDO_ANYINTERACT"("T2"."GEOM","SDO_GEOM"."SDO_BUFFER"(:B1,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M'))='TRUE')
7 - filter("MDSYS"."SDO_ANYINTERACT"("T2"."GEOM","SDO_GEOM"."SDO_BUFFER"("T1"."GEOM",10000,0.5,'UNIT=M'))='TRUE')
Statistics
7 user calls
131072 physical read total bytes
0 physical write total bytes
0 spare statistic 3
0 commit cleanout failures: cannot pin
0 TBS Extension: bytes extended
0 total number of times SMON posted
0 SMON posted for undo segment recovery
0 SMON posted for dropping temp segment
0 segment prealloc tasksMuch slower but Materialized View friendly.
This one is a bit more "natural" but still slower than the first.
set serveroutput on timing on autotrace on
/* The set of all cities in municipalities */
WITH municipal_cities As (
SELECT T1.ID as City,
T2.ADMIN_NAME as Municipality,
T2.GEOM as geom
FROM GUTDATA T1
INNER JOIN
AUSTRALIAN_STATES T2 ON (SDO_ANYINTERACT(T2.GEOM, SDO_GEOM.SDO_BUFFER(T1.GEOM,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M')) = 'TRUE')
SELECT T1.ID as City,
T2.Municipality as Municipality,
T2.GEOM as geom
FROM GUTDATA T1
LEFT OUTER JOIN
municipal_cities T2
ON (T2.CITY = T1.ID);
762 rows selected
Elapsed: 00:00:50.228
Plan hash value: 745978991
| Id | Operation | Name | Rows | Bytes | Cost (%CPU)| Time |
| 0 | SELECT STATEMENT | | 762 | 44196 | 36 (3)| 00:00:01 |
|* 1 | HASH JOIN RIGHT OUTER| | 762 | 44196 | 36 (3)| 00:00:01 |
| 2 | VIEW | | 61 | 3294 | 33 (0)| 00:00:01 |
| 3 | NESTED LOOPS | | 61 | 10980 | 33 (0)| 00:00:01 |
| 4 | TABLE ACCESS FULL | AUSTRALIAN_STATES | 8 | 920 | 3 (0)| 00:00:01 |
|* 5 | TABLE ACCESS FULL | GUTDATA | 8 | 520 | 4 (0)| 00:00:01 |
| 6 | INDEX FAST FULL SCAN| GUTDATA_ID_PK | 762 | 3048 | 2 (0)| 00:00:01 |
Predicate Information (identified by operation id):
1 - access("T2"."CITY"(+)="T1"."ID")
5 - filter("MDSYS"."SDO_ANYINTERACT"("T2"."GEOM","SDO_GEOM"."SDO_BUFFER"("T1"."GEOM",10000,0.5,'UNIT=M'))='TRUE')
Statistics
7 user calls
49152 physical read total bytes
0 physical write total bytes
0 spare statistic 3
0 commit cleanout failures: cannot pin
0 TBS Extension: bytes extended
0 total number of times SMON posted
0 SMON posted for undo segment recovery
0 SMON posted for dropping temp segment
0 segment prealloc tasksFinally, the Pièce de résistance: trick the LEFT OUTER JOIN operator...
set serveroutput on timing on autotrace on
SELECT T1.SPECIES as City,
T2.ADMIN_NAME as Municipality,
T2.GEOM as geom
FROM GUTDATA T1
LEFT OUTER JOIN
AUSTRALIAN_STATES T2
ON (t2.admin_name = to_char(t1.ID) OR
SDO_ANYINTERACT(T2.GEOM, SDO_GEOM.SDO_BUFFER(T1.GEOM,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M')) = 'TRUE');
762 rows selected
Elapsed: 00:00:50.273
Plan hash value: 158854308
| Id | Operation | Name | Rows | Bytes | Cost (%CPU)| Time |
| 0 | SELECT STATEMENT | | 762 | 92964 | 2294 (1)| 00:00:28 |
| 1 | NESTED LOOPS OUTER | | 762 | 92964 | 2294 (1)| 00:00:28 |
| 2 | TABLE ACCESS FULL | GUTDATA | 762 | 49530 | 5 (0)| 00:00:01 |
| 3 | VIEW | | 1 | 57 | 3 (0)| 00:00:01 |
|* 4 | TABLE ACCESS FULL| AUSTRALIAN_STATES | 1 | 115 | 3 (0)| 00:00:01 |
Predicate Information (identified by operation id):
4 - filter("T2"."ADMIN_NAME"=TO_CHAR("T1"."ID") OR
"MDSYS"."SDO_ANYINTERACT"("T2"."GEOM","SDO_GEOM"."SDO_BUFFER"("T1"."GEOM",10000,0.5,'UNIT=M'))='TRUE')
Statistics
7 user calls
0 physical read total bytes
0 physical write total bytes
0 spare statistic 3
0 commit cleanout failures: cannot pin
0 TBS Extension: bytes extended
0 total number of times SMON posted
0 SMON posted for undo segment recovery
0 SMON posted for dropping temp segment
0 segment prealloc tasksTry these combinations to see what works for you.
Interestingly, for me, the following returns absolutely nothing.
SELECT T1.SPECIES as City,
T2.ADMIN_NAME as Municipality
FROM GUTDATA T1
LEFT OUTER JOIN
AUSTRALIAN_STATES T2
ON (SDO_ANYINTERACT(T2.GEOM, SDO_GEOM.SDO_BUFFER(T1.GEOM,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M')) = 'TRUE')
MINUS
SELECT T1.SPECIES as City,
T2.ADMIN_NAME as Municipality
FROM GUTDATA T1
LEFT OUTER JOIN
AUSTRALIAN_STATES T2
ON (t2.admin_name = to_char(t1.ID) OR
SDO_ANYINTERACT(T2.GEOM, SDO_GEOM.SDO_BUFFER(T1.GEOM,10000,0.5,'UNIT=M')) = 'TRUE');(I leave it to you to see if you can see why as the LEFT OUTER JOIN seems to be working correctly for me but I am not going to dedicate time to detailed checking of results.)
Note all tests performed on Oracle 11g R2 (11.2.0.1.0)
If you get the answer you want: mark the post as answered to assign points.
regards
Simon -
I'm kind of new to using left outer joins, so I don't know if I'm doing it quite right. Right now there's only one table that may or may not have a corresponding record, so I'm only using left outer join on it. I get the error ORA-00904: "A"."SGBSTDN_PIDM": invalid identifier right now when I try to run my query. This gives me the impression that I need to use left outer join on all the tables in my FROM clause. Any suggestions on what I need to do?
/*Get those students not awarded ACG1 yet with an entry in shrlgpa*/
SELECT spriden_id id, spriden_last_name||', '||spriden_first_name name, sgbstdn_styp_code student_type,
sorhsch_graduation_date hsch_grad_date,shrlgpa_hours_earned hours_earned,rorenrl_finaid_adj_hr hours_enrolled,
0 AS disbursement_to_date, 0 AS offer_amt, 0 AS current_disbursement,
rnvand0_unmet_need unmet_need, 'N' AS awarded
FROM RCRESAR,RCRAPP1,SORHSCH,RORHSDT,SGBSTDN A,SORLCUR, shrlgpa, rorstat, ROBINST, spriden
,rnvand0
LEFT OUTER JOIN rorenrl ON (A.sgbstdn_pidm = rorenrl_pidm)
WHERE (RCRESAR_PELL_ELGBL = 'Y')
AND SORHSCH_GRADUATION_DATE>'01-JAN-2006'
AND RCRAPP1_CITZ_IND IN ('1','2')
AND RCRAPP1_CURR_REC_IND='Y'
/*Possible change once rigorous curr. decided AND (RORHSDT_AP_IB_COURSES = 'Y' OR RORHSDT_REQ_COURSES='Y')*/
AND RORHSDT_REQ_COURSES='Y'
AND sgbstdn_stst_code = 'AS'
AND SGBSTDN_STYP_CODE IN ('F','H','T')
AND (SORLCUR_DEGC_CODE LIKE 'B%' OR SORLCUR_DEGC_CODE LIKE 'A%'
OR SORLCUR_DEGC_CODE = 'UND')
AND sorlcur_seqno = (SELECT MAX(sorlcur_seqno)
FROM sorlcur
WHERE sorlcur_pidm = A.sgbstdn_pidm
AND sorlcur_term_code = &enrollment_term)
AND SORLCUR_CACT_CODE='ACTIVE'
AND rorenrl_term_code = &enrollment_term
AND shrlgpa_hours_earned BETWEEN 0 AND 29
AND shrlgpa_gpa_type_ind = 'O'
AND rorstat_pckg_comp_date IS NOT NULL
AND A.SGBSTDN_TERM_CODE_EFF = (SELECT MAX(B.SGBSTDN_TERM_CODE_EFF)
FROM SGBSTDN B
WHERE B.SGBSTDN_PIDM = A.SGBSTDN_PIDM
AND sgbstdn_term_code_eff <= &enrollment_term
AND NOT EXISTS (SELECT 'X'
FROM RPRAWRD
WHERE RCRESAR_PIDM = RPRAWRD_PIDM
AND RCRESAR_AIDY_CODE = RPRAWRD_AIDY_CODE
AND RPRAWRD_FUND_CODE = 'ACG1')
AND rorstat_pidm = rcresar_pidm
AND spriden_pidm = rcresar_pidm
AND RCRAPP1_PIDM = RCRESAR_PIDM
AND shrlgpa_pidm = rcresar_pidm
AND SORHSCH_PIDM = RCRESAR_PIDM
AND RORHSDT_PIDM = RCRESAR_PIDM
AND SGBSTDN_PIDM = RCRESAR_PIDM
AND SORLCUR_PIDM = RCRESAR_PIDM
AND rnvand0_pidm = rorstat_pidm
AND RCRESAR_INFC_CODE = RCRAPP1_INFC_CODE
AND RCRESAR_SEQ_NO = RCRAPP1_SEQ_NO
AND RCRAPP1_AIDY_CODE = RCRESAR_AIDY_CODE
AND ROBINST_AIDY_CODE = RCRESAR_AIDY_CODE
AND RCRESAR_AIDY_CODE = '&AIDY_CODE'
AND rorstat_aidy_code = rcresar_aidy_code
AND rnvand0_aidy_code = rcresar_aidy_code
AND spriden_change_ind IS NULL
ORDER BY nameFrank Kulash wrote:
Hi
blackhole82 wrote:
Yeah I realized that I was probably mixing styles after it wouldn't work. What you suggested does execute, so I assume it's right even though I'm not getting any rows at the moment. Don't assume it's correct: verify it
I suggest re-writing the query using all ANSI syntax.
Start with just two tables. Make sure that join is working.
When you have something that works perfectly with just those tables, then add one more table.
So if I wanted to left outer join onto shrlgpa too I would just need to add that underneath the join for rorenrl before the , and SORLCUR?In your existing query, it looks like shrlgpa is only connected to rcresar, using an inner join. Do you want to change that?At any rate, the order of tables using the old doesn't matter. Using ANSI notation, however, a join condition can only reference tables that have already been named in the same group of ANSI-joined tables.
So you would probably would have to re-arrange the FROM clause.
Sorry, I don't understand exactly what you want to do, so I can't tell you exactly how to do it.
Make you best guess, and try it.
If it doesn't produce the results you want, and you can't figure out how to fix it, then post the query, some sample data, and the desired results. If you post just the revised query, and a description of the problem, I'll try to answer, but without the sample data and desired results I can't guarantee that I can.Well I'm getting rows and the data seems to go with the query I had before using the outer join except for the records that have no record on shrlgpa. It appears that by having the clauses
AND shrlgpa_hours_earned BETWEEN 0 AND 29
AND shrlgpa_gpa_type_ind = 'O'that those I'm trying to pull in with the left outer join are being eliminated. Is it possible to still limit the hours earned while pulling in those who do not have a record on shrlgpa? Before I was just using a UNION to accomplish this, but I thought that I might be able to fine tune the query to eliminate the need for another UNION. -
Hi,
I Have this database structure:
Artist(IDA,Name,Year_b)
Work(IDW,Title,IDA,IDL)
City(IDL,IName,Nation)
I Want to do a query that retrieve for one Artist all Works availables on database and,if present,the City where each work was realized.
This SQL code is correct?
SELECT Name,Title,IName
FROM Artist a,
Work w LEFT OUTER JOIN City c ON w.IDL=c.IDL
WHERE w.IDA=a.IDA and a.IDA='2';
If it's not correct, what type of correction need it?
Thanks for Help
AndreaIf you asked... The original query works, but it is not "right".
You should use either the old Oracle style of joins, like in the VM's query, or, better, the ANSI join style, recommended by Oracle (not a mix of them, like in your query):
SELECT a.name,
w.title,
c.iname
FROM artist a
JOIN work w
ON w.ida = a.ida
LEFT OUTER JOIN city c
ON w.idl = c.idl
WHERE a.ida = '2' -
Can we join 3 tables with left outer join
hi friends.
Can any one tell how to join 3 tables using <b>left outer join</b>...i tried by taking some fields of <b>ekko,ekpo,eket</b>, but this not working ... plz give a sample code with some fields.Hi Uday
<b>Inner joins using 3 tables </b>
<i><b>Try this :-</b></i>
SELECT stpo~stlnr stpo~idnrk mast~matnr mara~mtart stpo~menge
INTO CORRESPONDING FIELDS OF TABLE zmat1 FROM mast
JOIN stpo ON stpo~stlnr = mast~stlnr
JOIN mara ON mara~matnr = mast~matnr
WHERE stpo~stlty = 'M' "AND stpo~idnrk IN s_matnr
AND mast~werks = 1000.
<b><i>Here s_matnr is a select-options on the selection-screen. </i></b>
<i><b>Or this. </b></i>
<b>Code: </b>
Select single Vbrk~Bukrs Vbrk~Kunrg Vbrk~Vbeln
Vbrk~Fkdat Vbrk~Bstnk_Vf Vbrk~Zterm
Tvzbt~Vtext
Vbak~Vbeln Vbak~Bstdk
Likp~Vbeln Likp~lfdat Likp~Lfuhr
into w_vbrk
from vbrk
inner join Tvzbt on Tvzbt~Zterm = Vbrk~Zterm and
Tvzbt~Spras = sy-langu
Inner join Vbfa as SalesLnk
on SalesLnk~vbeln = pu_vbeln and
SalesLnk~vbtyp_v = c_order
inner join Vbak on Vbak~Vbeln = SalesLnk~Vbelv
Inner join Vbfa as DeliveryLnk
on DeliveryLnk~vbeln = pu_vbeln and
DeliveryLnk~vbtyp_v = c_Delivery
inner join Likp on Likp~Vbeln = DeliveryLnk~Vbelv
where vbrk~vbeln = pu_Vbeln.
<i><b>This code locates sales, delivery and payment terms info from a billing document number.</b></i>
<i><b>or</b></i>
<b>
Here, this one also works fine :</b>
select zfpcd~cadivi zfpcd~proforma zfpcd~factura zfpcd~aniofactura
zfpcd~montousd zfpcd~montoap zfpcd~ebeln zfpcd~inco1
zfpcd~lifnr lfa1~name1 zcdvs~status zfpcd~conint
into it_lista
from zfpcd inner join zcdvs
on zfpcd~ebeln = zcdvs~ebeln
and zfpcd~proforma = zcdvs~proforma
and zfpcd~lifnr = zcdvs~lifnr
inner join lfa1
on zfpcd~lifnr = lfa1~lifnr
where zcdvs~status = '04'.
Reward if helpfull
Regards
Pavan -
Hi Experts,
I am facing a problem with left outer join query. Am using one standard table and ztable for this join. My problem is values are not extracted from the Ztable.
Query:
SELECT b~lifnr b~belnr b~gjahr b~xblnr b~shkzg b~blart b~zfbdt b~budat b~wrbtr
b~wskto b~zlspr s~EXTRACT_STATUS s~maturity_date FROM bsik AS b
LEFT OUTER JOIN zprm_rvne_sapdoc AS s
ON s~belnr EQ b~belnr
AND s~gjahr EQ b~gjahr
INTO CORRESPONDING FIELDS OF TABLE it_join
WHERE b~zlsch = p_zlsch
AND b~xblnr IN so_invno
ORDER BY b~lifnr b~xblnr.
I have all entries of BSIK table in Ztable with extract status as Y but this query is not fetching extract status and maturity date of ztable so it is blank in the internal table.
Need solution.
Regards
Sridevi SHi,
see the sample wiki for writing the Left outer join
http://wiki.sdn.sap.com/wiki/display/Snippets/EmployeeInfotype0000to9999ChangeHistory
Specifying Two or More Database Tables as a Left Outer Join
The left outer join, on the other hand, reads lines from the left-hand database table or join even if there is no corresponding line in the right-hand table.
SELECT...
FROM <tab> LEFT [OUTER] JOIN <dbtab> [AS <alias>] ON <cond>
<options>
<tab> and <dbtab> are subject to the same rules and conditions as in an inner join. The OUTER addition is optional. The tables are linked in the same way as the inner join with the one exception that all lines selected from <tab> are included in the final selection. If <dbtab> does not contain any lines that meet the condition <cond>, the system includes a single line in the selection whose columns from <dbtab> are filled with null values.
In the left outer join, more restrictions apply to the condition <cond> than in the inner join. In addition to the above restrictions:
EQ or = is the only permitted relational operator.
There must be at least one comparison between columns from <tab> and <dbtab>.
The WHERE clause may not contain any comparisons with columns from <dbtab>. All comparisons using columns from <dbtab> must appear in the condition <cond>.
If we have two tables named stud1,stud2 with the following data
Stud1: id Name stud2: id Name
1 xxx 1 aaa
2 yyy 2 bbb
3 zzz 4 ccc
4 www 6 ddd
When we use Left Outer Join we get the output as:
1 aaa
2 bbb
3 <Null>
4 ccc
When we use Right Outer Join we get the output as:
1 aaa
2 bbb
4 ccc
<Null> ddd
When we use Full Outer Join we get the output as:
1 aaa
2 bbb
3 <Null>
4 ccc
<Null> ddd
Prabhudas -
Query with multiple outer joins
I had a doubt with whether the following kind of query is valid with multiple outer-joins. The format of the query is something like this:-
select A.col1, B.col2
from table1 A, table2 B, table3 C where
A.col3=B.col4(+) and B.col5=C.col6(+)
This would mean the follwoing with regard to outer-joins in the query.
1) fetch records with col3 in table A matching or not matching col4 in table B
2) fetch records with col5 in table B matching or not matching col6 in table C
So, this query is valid?
I hope, my question is clear.
Please, help in solving the doubt.
regardsThis is valid and it works fine
-
BI 7.0 Infoset - Infocube - Left outer join - query
Hi Expert,
A infoset contain Infocube and ODS, linked with left outer join, common fields are PO,PO item. PO account assignment ODS have three keyfields: PO Doc.,Item,account Assignment .
PO Infocube <b>PO Account Assignment ODS</b>
PO PO item Amt<b>PO Doc. Item AccAssignment Cost object</b>
1000 10 230 <b>1000 10 1 CC1</b>
1001 10 250 <b>1002 10 1 CC1</b>
1002 10 150 <b>1002 10 2 CC2</b>
in BEx result are like this:
1000 10 230 1 CC1
1001 10 250 # #
1002 10 150 1 CC1
1002 10 150 2 CC2 ( amount only duplicated)
The issue was that amount gets duplicated. It only occurs if PO has more than one account assignment.
In report, we want show like this
1000 10 230 1 CC1
1001 10 250 # #
1002 10 150 1 CC1
1002 10 # 2 CC2
Any suggestion or input to overcome this issue?
Thanks,
Saran
Message was edited by:
Saravanan KHi,
did you solve your problem? because I have the same issue right now: the left outer join doesn't seem to do its job.
Let me know if you have found a solution, it would be appreciated.
have a nice day,
Dominic -
Using Left Outer Join along with reference
I have three tables.
Table 1 : BOOK_DETAILS
Fields: BOOK_ID, BOOK_NAME
Table 2: BOOK_ISSUE_RECORD
Fields: BOOK_ID, USER_NAME
Table 3: BOOK_AUTHOR
Fields: BOOK_ID, AUTHOR_NAME
I have to link Table 1 and Table 2 with Left outer Join because even if the book is not issues to anyone, its name should come.
Again I have to display the Book Author name for each Book.
I am able to create a query with the Left outer join between Table 1 and Table 2. However I am not able to give a reference to the Table 3.
Can any one please help me with this.
Regards
Hawkerselect d.book_name,
a.book_author,
i.user_name
from book_details d
join
book_author a
on (d.book_id = a.book_id)
left join
book_issue_recors i
on (d.book_id = i.book_id)
/SY. -
Left outer join using anyOfAllowingNone
Hi,
I'm trying to join two tables (tableA and tableB) with left outer join using anyOfAllowingNone (One to many relationship) and try to fetch the tableB data with some constraint on it.
But the sql generated out of the expression builder is not a proper left join, it actually forms a inner join, which brings only table A data which satisfies all the condition. Actually I want all of tableA data and for every record from tableA I want the data from TableB which matches the key from tableA to tableB and some condition applied on tableB data.
I guess I'm doing some thing wrong, I went through the document and sample but still its not getting me the right data.
Below is my expression builder:
exp = builder.get("tableA_K").equal(some value);
exp = exp.and(builder.get("effectiveIn").toChar("MM/dd/yyyy").lessThanEqual(date));
exp = exp.and(builder.get("effectiveOut").toChar("MM/dd/yyyy").greaterThanEqual(date));
exp1 = builder.anyOfAllowingNone("tableBCollectionAttribute").get("effectiveIn").toChar("MM/dd/yyyy").lessThanEqual(date);
exp1 = exp1.and(builder.anyOfAllowingNone("tableBCollectionAttribute").get("effectiveOut").toChar("MM/dd/yyyy").greaterThanEqual(date));
return exp.and(exp1);
Below is the sample query generated:
select distinct tableA.all data
where (((((tableA.key = 2219785)
and (to_char(tableA.EFFECTIVE_IN_S, 'MM/dd/yyyy') <= '03/27/2008'))
and (to_char(tableA.EFFECTIVE_OUT_S, 'MM/dd/yyyy') >= '03/27/2008'))
and ((to_char(tableB.EFFECTIVE_IN_S, 'MM/dd/yyyy') <= '03/27/2008')
and (to_char(tableB.EFFECTIVE_OUT_S, 'MM/dd/yyyy') >= '03/27/2008')))
and (tableB.key (+) = tableA.tableB_Key))
Any help is appreciated. Thanks
Sai.hi Mansi,
this is how i populate
SELECT VGBEL LFIMG POSNR VBELN FROM LIPS INTO TABLE IT_delv FOR ALL ENTRIES IN IT_VBAP WHERE VGBEL = IT_VBAP-VBELN.
LOOP AT IT_delv INTO WA_delv.
WA_FINAL-VBELN_1 = WA_DELV-VBELN_1.
WA_FINAL-LFDAT = WA_DELV-LFDAT.
WA_FINAL-LFIMG = WA_DELV-LFIMG.
WA_FINAL-POSNR2 = WA_DELV-POSNR2..
APPEND WA_FINAL TO IT_FINAL.
CLEAR: WA_FINAL , WA_delv.
ENDLOOP.
LOOP AT IT_FINAL INTO WA_FINAL.
READ TABLE IT_vbap INTO WA_vbap WITH KEY VGBEL = WA_FINAL-VBELN.
WA_FINAL-VBELN = WA_VBAP-VBELN.
WA_FINAL-MATNR = WA_VBAP-MATNR.
WA_FINAL-KWMENG = WA_VBAP-KWMENG.
WA_FINAL-NETWR = WA_VBAP-NETWR.
MODIFY IT_FINAL FROM WA_FINAL.
ENDLOOP.
My question is , it_vbap has 5 five records A,B,C,D,E.
in it_delv ,there are 20 record corrresponding to A,B,D of IT_VBAP.
in final table i wont get info of recors B,E. I want those info also in final table ..how can i do that... -
Hi,
I am trying to create a materialized view and trying replace + left outer join with 'left outer join' clause. I am getting
ERROR at line 68:
ORA-00904: "RF"."DATA_TYPE_ID": invalid identifier
Here is the sql I am using. Any help is appreciated.
CREATE MATERIALIZED VIEW HHC_CUSTOM.HHC_RESULT_FIELD_DIMENSION0925 (DATA_ELEMENT_ID,FIELD,PROFILE,PROFILE_ID,PARENT_FIELD,PARENT_PROFILE,PARENT_PROFILE_ID,DATA_TYPE,DECODE_TYPE,CFG_GROUP,CFG_SET,ACTIVITY_COUNT)
TABLESPACE CUSTOM_01
PCTUSED 0
PCTFREE 10
INITRANS 2
MAXTRANS 255
STORAGE (
INITIAL 80K
NEXT 1M
MINEXTENTS 1
MAXEXTENTS UNLIMITED
PCTINCREASE 0
BUFFER_POOL DEFAULT
FLASH_CACHE DEFAULT
CELL_FLASH_CACHE DEFAULT
NOCACHE
ENABLE ROW MOVEMENT
NOLOGGING
NOCOMPRESS
NOPARALLEL
BUILD IMMEDIATE
REFRESH COMPLETE on DEMand
WITH PRIMARY KEY
AS
/* Formatted on 9/25/2012 11:53:36 AM (QP5 v5.215.12089.38647) */
SELECT /*+ ALL_ROWS FULL(rf) FULL(dt) FULL(dc) FULL(rd) FULL(mc) FULL(ad) FULL(ag) USE_HASH(rf,dt,dc,rd,mc,ad,ag) INDEX(prf,KP_RESULT_FIELD) INDEX(prd,KP_RESULT_PROFILE) INDEX(pmc,KP_RESULT_MULTI_FIELD_PROFILE) INDEX(pad,KP_ASSESS_PROFILE) INDEX(pag,KP_ASSESS_MULTI_FIELD_PROFILE) USE_NL(prf,prd,pmc,pad,pag) ORDERED(rf,dt,dc,rd,mc,ad,ag,prf,prd,pmc,pad,pag) */
rf.data_element_id AS data_element_id,
rf.name AS field,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.data_element_id, 1, 3),
'RD/', rd.name,
'AG/', ag.name,
'AD/', ad.name,
'MC/', mc.name)
AS profile,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.data_element_id, 1, 3),
'RD/', rd.profile_id,
'AG/', ag.profile_id,
'AD/', ad.profile_id,
'MC/', mc.profile_id)
AS profile_id,
prf.name AS parent_field,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.parent_profile_field_id, 1, 3),
NULL, NULL,
'RD/', prd.name,
'AD/', pad.name,
'AG/', pag.NAME, --shouldn't happen
'MC/', pmc.name --shouldn't happen
AS parent_profile,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.parent_profile_field_id, 1, 3),
NULL, NULL,
'RD/', prd.profile_id,
'AD/', pad.profile_id,
'AG/', pag.profile_id, --shouldn't happen
'MC/', pmc.profile_id --shouldn't happen
AS parent_profile_id,
dt.name AS data_type,
NVL (dc.name,
DECODE (UPPER (dt.name), 'ORGANISM', 'Organism', 'Not Coded'))
AS decode_type,
NVL (cfg.cfg_group, 'UNDEFINED') AS cfg_group,
NVL (cfg.cfg_set, 'UNDEFINED') AS cfg_set,
DECODE (rslt.data_element_id, NULL, 0, rslt.activity_count)
AS activity_count
FROM ud_master.result_field rf,ud_master.result_field prf
join ud_master.data_type dt on (rf.data_type_id=dt.data_type_id)
left outer join ud_master.decode_type dc on (rf.decode_source_id = dc.decode_source_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_profile rd on (rf.profile_id = rd.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_multi_field_profile mc on (rf.profile_id = mc.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.assess_profile ad on (rf.profile_id = ad.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.assess_multi_field_profile ag on (rf.profile_id = ag.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_field rf on (prf.parent_profile_field_id = rf.data_element_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_profile prd on (prf.profile_id = prd.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_multi_field_profile pmc on (prf.profile_id = pmc.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.assess_profile pad on (prf.profile_id = pad.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.assess_multi_field_profile pag on (rf.profile_id = pag.profile_id)
left outer join (SELECT * FROM hhc_custom.dw_cfg_v WHERE cfg_type_id = 1) cfg on (rf.data_element_id = cfg.cfg_value)
left outer join (SELECT data_element_id, COUNT (*) AS activity_count FROM ud_master.result GROUP BY data_element_id) rslt on (rf.data_element_id = rslt.data_element_id);
Regards,
KoteshHi Monica,
I need to have 2 aliases for ud_master.result_field table
So I f I change it like this
CREATE MATERIALIZED VIEW HHC_CUSTOM.HHC_RESULT_FIELD_DIMENSION0925 (DATA_ELEMENT_ID,FIELD,PROFILE,PROFILE_ID,PARENT_FIELD,PARENT_PROFILE,PARENT_PROFILE_ID,DATA_TYPE,DECODE_TYPE,CFG_GROUP,CFG_SET,ACTIVITY_COUNT)
TABLESPACE CUSTOM_01
PCTUSED 0
PCTFREE 10
INITRANS 2
MAXTRANS 255
STORAGE (
INITIAL 80K
NEXT 1M
MINEXTENTS 1
MAXEXTENTS UNLIMITED
PCTINCREASE 0
BUFFER_POOL DEFAULT
FLASH_CACHE DEFAULT
CELL_FLASH_CACHE DEFAULT
NOCACHE
ENABLE ROW MOVEMENT
NOLOGGING
NOCOMPRESS
NOPARALLEL
BUILD IMMEDIATE
REFRESH COMPLETE on DEMand
WITH PRIMARY KEY
AS
/* Formatted on 9/25/2012 11:53:36 AM (QP5 v5.215.12089.38647) */
SELECT /*+ ALL_ROWS FULL(rf) FULL(dt) FULL(dc) FULL(rd) FULL(mc) FULL(ad) FULL(ag) USE_HASH(rf,dt,dc,rd,mc,ad,ag) INDEX(prf,KP_RESULT_FIELD) INDEX(prd,KP_RESULT_PROFILE) INDEX(pmc,KP_RESULT_MULTI_FIELD_PROFILE) INDEX(pad,KP_ASSESS_PROFILE) INDEX(pag,KP_ASSESS_MULTI_FIELD_PROFILE) USE_NL(prf,prd,pmc,pad,pag) ORDERED(rf,dt,dc,rd,mc,ad,ag,prf,prd,pmc,pad,pag) */
rf.data_element_id AS data_element_id,
rf.name AS field,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.data_element_id, 1, 3),
'RD/', rd.name,
'AG/', ag.name,
'AD/', ad.name,
'MC/', mc.name)
AS profile,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.data_element_id, 1, 3),
'RD/', rd.profile_id,
'AG/', ag.profile_id,
'AD/', ad.profile_id,
'MC/', mc.profile_id)
AS profile_id,
prf.name AS parent_field,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.parent_profile_field_id, 1, 3),
NULL, NULL,
'RD/', prd.name,
'AD/', pad.name,
'AG/', pag.NAME, --shouldn't happen
'MC/', pmc.name --shouldn't happen
AS parent_profile,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.parent_profile_field_id, 1, 3),
NULL, NULL,
'RD/', prd.profile_id,
'AD/', pad.profile_id,
'AG/', pag.profile_id, --shouldn't happen
'MC/', pmc.profile_id --shouldn't happen
AS parent_profile_id,
dt.name AS data_type,
NVL (dc.name,
DECODE (UPPER (dt.name), 'ORGANISM', 'Organism', 'Not Coded'))
AS decode_type,
NVL (cfg.cfg_group, 'UNDEFINED') AS cfg_group,
NVL (cfg.cfg_set, 'UNDEFINED') AS cfg_set,
DECODE (rslt.data_element_id, NULL, 0, rslt.activity_count)
AS activity_count
FROM ud_master.result_field rf,ud_master.result_field prf
join ud_master.data_type dt on (prf.data_type_id=dt.data_type_id)
left outer join ud_master.decode_type dc on (prf.decode_source_id = dc.decode_source_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_profile rd on (prf.profile_id = rd.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_multi_field_profile mc on (prf.profile_id = mc.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.assess_profile ad on (prf.profile_id = ad.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.assess_multi_field_profile ag on (prf.profile_id = ag.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_field rf on (prf.parent_profile_field_id = rf.data_element_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_profile prd on (prf.profile_id = prd.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.result_multi_field_profile pmc on (prf.profile_id = pmc.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.assess_profile pad on (prf.profile_id = pad.profile_id)
left outer join ud_master.assess_multi_field_profile pag on (rf.profile_id = pag.profile_id)
left outer join (SELECT * FROM hhc_custom.dw_cfg_v WHERE cfg_type_id = 1) cfg on (rf.data_element_id = cfg.cfg_value)
left outer join (SELECT data_element_id, COUNT (*) AS activity_count FROM ud_master.result GROUP BY data_element_id) rslt on (rf.data_element_id = rslt.data_element_id);
I am getting the following error
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.parent_profile_field_id, 1, 3),
ERROR at line 51:
ORA-00918: column ambiguously defined
Following is the original query I tried to modify
CREATE MATERIALIZED VIEW HHC_CUSTOM.HHC_RESULT_FIELD_DIMENSION (DATA_ELEMENT_ID,FIELD,PROFILE,PROFILE_ID,PARENT_FIELD,PARENT_PROFILE,PARENT_PROFILE_ID,DATA_TYPE,DECODE_TYPE,CFG_GROUP,CFG_SET,ACTIVITY_COUNT)
TABLESPACE CUSTOM_01
PCTUSED 0
PCTFREE 10
INITRANS 2
MAXTRANS 255
STORAGE (
INITIAL 80K
NEXT 1M
MINEXTENTS 1
MAXEXTENTS UNLIMITED
PCTINCREASE 0
BUFFER_POOL DEFAULT
FLASH_CACHE DEFAULT
CELL_FLASH_CACHE DEFAULT
NOCACHE
ENABLE ROW MOVEMENT
NOLOGGING
NOCOMPRESS
NOPARALLEL
BUILD IMMEDIATE
REFRESH COMPLETE ON DEMAND
WITH PRIMARY KEY
AS
/* Formatted on 9/26/2012 1:59:27 PM (QP5 v5.215.12089.38647) */
SELECT /*+ ALL_ROWS FULL(rf) FULL(dt) FULL(dc) FULL(rd) FULL(mc) FULL(ad) FULL(ag) USE_HASH(rf,dt,dc,rd,mc,ad,ag) INDEX(prf,KP_RESULT_FIELD) INDEX(prd,KP_RESULT_PROFILE) INDEX(pmc,KP_RESULT_MULTI_FIELD_PROFILE) INDEX(pad,KP_ASSESS_PROFILE) INDEX(pag,KP_ASSESS_MULTI_FIELD_PROFILE) USE_NL(prf,prd,pmc,pad,pag) ORDERED(rf,dt,dc,rd,mc,ad,ag,prf,prd,pmc,pad,pag) */
rf.data_element_id AS data_element_id,
rf.name AS field,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.data_element_id, 1, 3),
'RD/', rd.name,
'AG/', ag.name,
'AD/', ad.name,
'MC/', mc.name)
AS profile,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.data_element_id, 1, 3),
'RD/', rd.profile_id,
'AG/', ag.profile_id,
'AD/', ad.profile_id,
'MC/', mc.profile_id)
AS profile_id,
prf.name AS parent_field,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.parent_profile_field_id, 1, 3),
NULL, NULL,
'RD/', prd.name,
'AD/', pad.name,
'AG/', pag.NAME, --shouldn't happen
'MC/', pmc.name --shouldn't happen
AS parent_profile,
DECODE (SUBSTR (rf.parent_profile_field_id, 1, 3),
NULL, NULL,
'RD/', prd.profile_id,
'AD/', pad.profile_id,
'AG/', pag.profile_id, --shouldn't happen
'MC/', pmc.profile_id --shouldn't happen
AS parent_profile_id,
dt.name AS data_type,
NVL (dc.name,
DECODE (UPPER (dt.name), 'ORGANISM', 'Organism', 'Not Coded'))
AS decode_type,
NVL (cfg.cfg_group, 'UNDEFINED') AS cfg_group,
NVL (cfg.cfg_set, 'UNDEFINED') AS cfg_set,
DECODE (rslt.data_element_id, NULL, 0, rslt.activity_count)
AS activity_count
FROM ud_master.result_field rf,
ud_master.data_type dt,
ud_master.decode_type dc,
ud_master.result_profile rd,
ud_master.result_multi_field_profile mc,
ud_master.assess_profile ad,
ud_master.assess_multi_field_profile ag,
ud_master.result_field prf,
ud_master.result_profile prd,
ud_master.result_multi_field_profile pmc,
ud_master.assess_profile pad,
ud_master.assess_multi_field_profile pag,
(SELECT *
FROM hhc_custom.dw_cfg_v
WHERE cfg_type_id = 1) cfg,
( SELECT data_element_id, COUNT (*) AS activity_count
FROM ud_master.result
GROUP BY data_element_id) rslt
WHERE rf.data_type_id = dt.data_type_id
AND rf.decode_source_id = dc.decode_source_id(+)
AND rf.profile_id = rd.profile_id(+)
AND rf.profile_id = mc.profile_id(+)
AND rf.profile_id = ad.profile_id(+)
AND rf.profile_id = ag.profile_id(+)
AND rf.parent_profile_field_id = prf.data_element_id(+)
AND prf.profile_id = prd.profile_id(+)
AND prf.profile_id = pmc.profile_id(+)
AND prf.profile_id = pad.profile_id(+)
AND prf.profile_id = pag.profile_id(+)
AND rf.data_element_id = cfg.cfg_value(+)
AND rf.data_element_id = rslt.data_element_id(+);
Can you tell me how can I rewrite it with 'LEFT OUTER JOIN' syntax?
Regards,
Kotesh -
Using Command to fix null / left outer join issue
Hi
I was told awhile ago that it's possible to fix crystal's issue with left outer join and null records being eliminated.
I think i remember most of how this goes, but i can't seem to duplicate it.
1) You can't have any select expert -- record
2) You create the report normally and then make a new report using the SQL Query
- Can't remember if its the whole report or upto the tables that have hisotry (null results)
3) You move parts from WHERE to FROM
Hopefully someone can help correct the steps i'm doing wrong or add what i'm missing from this.
Below is the Query from my comlpeted report, but when i run it with the last LEFT OUTER JOIN added it removes all the products with no sales during that year.
Any help would be greatly appreciated even if it's to say this can't be done.
SELECT
"prod_warehouse"."pw_whs_id",
"prod_warehouse"."pw_prodline_id",
"prod_warehouse"."pw_prod_id",
"prod_warehouse"."pw_bin_location1",
"prod_warehouse"."pw_min_onhand_qty",
"prod_warehouse"."pw_max_onhand_qty",
"prod_warehouse"."pw_onhand_qty",
"product_lookup"."prlkp_lang1_1_desc",
"prod_customer"."prcu_cust_part_num",
"contract_details"."cond_level1_amt",
"sales_history"."sah_year"
FROM (((("sisl_data05"."dbo"."products" "products"
LEFT OUTER JOIN "sisl_data05"."dbo"."prod_warehouse" "prod_warehouse"
ON ("products"."pr_prod_id"="prod_warehouse"."pw_prod_id")
AND ("products"."pr_prodline_id"="prod_warehouse"."pw_prodline_id"))
LEFT OUTER JOIN "sisl_data05"."dbo"."product_lookup" "product_lookup"
ON ("products"."pr_prod_id"="product_lookup"."prlkp_prod_id")
AND ("products"."pr_prodline_id"="product_lookup"."prlkp_prodline_id"))
LEFT OUTER JOIN "sisl_data05"."dbo"."prod_customer" "prod_customer"
ON ("products"."pr_prod_id"="prod_customer"."prcu_prod_id")
AND ("products"."pr_prodline_id"="prod_customer"."prcu_prodline_id"))
LEFT OUTER JOIN "sisl_data05"."dbo"."contract_details" "contract_details"
ON "prod_warehouse"."pw_prod_id"="contract_details"."cond_prod_id")
LEFT OUTER JOIN "sisl_data05"."dbo"."sales_history" "sales_history"
ON (("prod_warehouse"."pw_whs_id"="sales_history"."sah_sortkey1")
AND ("prod_warehouse"."pw_prod_id"="sales_history"."sah_sortkey2"))
AND ("prod_warehouse"."pw_prodline_id"="sales_history"."sah_sortkey3")
WHERE
"prod_warehouse"."pw_whs_id"='20123'
AND ("prod_warehouse"."pw_onhand_qty"<>0
OR "prod_warehouse"."pw_bin_location1"<>' '
OR "prod_warehouse"."pw_max_onhand_qty">0)
AND "sales_history"."sah_year"=2014
ORDER BY "prod_warehouse"."pw_bin_location1", "prod_warehouse"."pw_prod_id"Try this:
SELECT
prod_warehouse.pw_whs_id,
prod_warehouse.pw_prodline_id,
prod_warehouse.pw_prod_id,
prod_warehouse.pw_bin_location1,
prod_warehouse.pw_min_onhand_qty,
prod_warehouse.pw_max_onhand_qty,
prod_warehouse.pw_onhand_qty,
product_lookup.prlkp_lang1_1_desc,
prod_customer.prcu_cust_part_num,
contract_details.cond_level1_amt,
sales_history.sah_year
FROM sisl_data05.dbo.products products
LEFT OUTER JOIN sisl_data05.dbo.prod_warehouse prod_warehouse
ON products.pr_prod_id=prod_warehouse.pw_prod_id
AND products.pr_prodline_id=prod_warehouse.pw_prodline_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN sisl_data05.dbo.product_lookup product_lookup
ON products.pr_prod_id=product_lookup.prlkp_prod_id)
AND products.pr_prodline_id=product_lookup.prlkp_prodline_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN sisl_data05.dbo.prod_customer prod_customer
ON products.pr_prod_id=prod_customer.prcu_prod_id
AND products.pr_prodline_id=prod_customer.prcu_prodline_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN sisl_data05.dbo.contract_details contract_details
ON prod_warehouse.pw_prod_id=contract_details.cond_prod_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN sisl_data05.dbo.sales_history sales_history
ON prod_warehouse.pw_whs_id=sales_history.sah_sortkey1
AND prod_warehouse.pw_prod_id=sales_history.sah_sortkey2
AND prod_warehouse.pw_prodline_id=sales_history.sah_sortkey3
AND sales_history.sah_year = 2014
WHERE prod_warehouse.pw_whs_id='20123'
AND (prod_warehouse.pw_onhand_qty<>0
OR prod_warehouse.pw_bin_location1<>' '
OR prod_warehouse.pw_max_onhand_qty>0)
Take a look at what I've done with the last line of the last join. The issue is that when you left join to a table and you use that table in the Where clause, you've basically turned your you left outer join into an inner join because the record has to be there in order to get the value in the filter. By moving the filter into the join, you'll still get the rest of the data when there is no corresponding record.
NOTE: Crystal adds all sorts of "extra" stuff like quotes and parentheses that you don't need and which I have removed to make the query easier to read.
-Dell -
Restriction to Left Outer Joins in PS Query
Hello I am trying to do Left Outer JOin in PS QUERY. I need to do dept tbl, job code tbl and locatable as left outer joins with JOB Table. Looks like in PS QUERY there is a error message saying as below. Can someone has any workaround to achieve this in PS QUERY. I know I can create a View and use that in PS QUERY but BUsiness Users are dependent on IT, so that doesn't work. Also, adding JOB table multiple times works but I am looking for better solution if anyone had come accorss working through PS QUERY Outer JOins.
Windows Internet Explorer
Left outer joins must be joined to the last record in the query. (139,290)
OK
Thanks,
SC.Hi Mike,
According to your description, you want to improve the performance for your DAX query in SQL Server Analysis Service Tabular model, right? Here is a white paper describes strategies and specific techniques for getting the best performance from your tabular
models, including processing and partitioning strategies, DAX query tuning, and server tuning for specific workloads.
http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dn393915.aspx
Since this is a complex DAX query, from a support perspective this is really beyond what we can do here in the forums. If you cannot determine your answer here or on your own, consider opening a support case with Microsoft. Visit this link to see the various
support options that are available to better meet your needs:
http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?id=fh;en-us;offerprophone
Regards,
Charlie Liao
TechNet Community Support -
Issue on left outer join query in 10G
Dear Mr./Mrs./Ms. Oracle expertise,
The following query structure can function properly in Oracle 9i, but not work in Oracle 10G.
Please kindly advise what happened in Oracle 10G?
Is it a bug in 10G? If yes, any patch for it?
select a.col1,
a.col2,
a.col5,
b.col3,
b.col4
from t1 a
inner join t2 c on c.col1 = a.col1
left join (select col3
col4
from t3) b
on b.col1 = a.col1
and a.col2 = 'Y' <---------- seems 10G cannot allow this condition
where a.col5 = 123;
Purpose of above SQL
====================
Only those records from t1 table with a.col2 = 'Y' will
do the left outer join to "b" table and get the columns b.col3 and b.col4
Result set in Oracle 9i
=======================
col1 col2 col5 col3 col4
AAA N 111
BBB N 222
CCC Y 333 XYZ OOO
DDD Y 444 QPR 111
Result set in Oracle 10G
========================
col1 col2 col5 col3 col4
AAA N 111
BBB N 222
CCC Y 333
DDD Y 444
Rgds,
Ken ChanDear Schneider,
Sorry that there was a typo in my query.
Below is the revised query.
select a.col1,
a.col2,
a.col5,
b.col3,
b.col4
from t1 a
inner join t2 c on c.col1 = a.col1
left join (select col1,
col3,
col4
from t3) b
on b.col1 = a.col1
and a.col2 = 'Y' <---------- seems 10G cannot allow this condition
where a.col5 = 123;
Thanks.
Rgds,
ken Chan
Maybe you are looking for
-
Locking mechanism provided by the Web AS Java
Hi All, I have a requirement to lock an object for a specific action with using locks provided and managed by the Web AS Java (i have to use TableLocking API). I have read about the locking mechanism in "SAP NetWeaver Developer Studio Documentation h
-
Server does not support remote front panels
hello I'm about to command the front of my labview program remotely. I followed all the steps that I found on the NI website. when I do the test on my Intenet Explorer browser it gives me the following mesage: "Server does not support remote front pa
-
Error running J2EE App on Web AS 6.40
Hi all experts, I'm triying to implement JSPWiki on Web As 6.40 SP17, I've followed the instructions this blog /people/pankaj.kumar32/blog/2005/09/10/wiki-wiki-world-and-portals This is what a did: 1.- Downlowded the latest version of JSPWiki from ht
-
Can I make two differents selection screen in my program?
Hi experts!! I don't know how to male this, the problem is that I need to make two differents selection screen in my program because I have two differents kinds of button, BUTTON1 BUTTON2 BUTTON3 When I press button1 I received. BUTT
-
HH5 arrived this morning ready for wed set up. Installed it and wired and wireles working ok. The query I have is do I connect vision+ box same as HH4 with the ethernet cable to HH5? and do I need to do anything else after cab visit on wednesday? Th