W540 is being shipped - having second thoughts after reading such negative user reviews.

Hello I just purchased a high end W540. ($3,500 including tax)
I purchased the machine Monday afternoon based on my trusted colleagues advice to go with Lenovo.  I didn't do nearly as much market research as I normally would because my current machine, Dell Precision is starting to act up after 5.5 years of excellent use, and I need a replacement sooner than later.   Even though, we went over the specifications with my colleague in detail before finalizing the purchase I don’t believe my colleague is aware of all the negativity surrounding the latest W540 model.
Although I think I will be fine with the W540 because most of the negativity is focused on the keyboard and trackpad I still would like to have some re-assurance the W540 was a decent choice for my needs.  It is possible that I may cancel the order (probably with penalty) based on the feedback I receive from this post but my preference is not to.
How I use my workstation:
I work with 1GB datasets and run SQL queries, do a lot of development in MS Access including heavy data massaging using VBA.
For me the most important thing is speed when I am working / developing with MS Access.  I also care very much about my Outlook, Web Browsing and YouTube experience. 
Ideally, because of the power of the new machine I will also setup Virtual Machines so I can test my applications in various environments.
90% of the time I use my laptop docked and connected to an external monitor, mouse and keyboard.
5% of the time I am using my machine for presentations connected to a projector so I like that there is a VGA output on the W540.  When I do presentations I typically use an external keyboard but I always use an external mouse.
The final 5% of the time I am using the machine as a laptop without an external keyboard but I always use an external mouse.
The Replacement Warranty is extremely important to me because if my machine is down I need it back up within 24 hours which is what the Lenovo salesman promised me. 
Things that Concern me about the W540
Heat around the track pad where the palm sits to the point that you have to remove your palm.
Keyboard design is cumbersome and track pad is unusable.
People have said that the Screen is flimsy.  I am assuming that could cause potential damage.
No LED for HD activity.  I am curious with a SSD does that even matter?
There is tremendous negativity on the internet about the W540. Other colleagues may question why I would buy this model with all the negative feedback.
Things that I like about W540
I was able to customize it with the CPU, RAM, SSD that I wanted and it’s a powerful machine.
4 DIMM slots.  However is it capped at 32GB or will I be able to put 64 GB in 3 years?
I am under the impression that Lenovo has the best customer service and that they will honor their 24 hour replacement policy.
It’s light and thin.  I have to admit my Dell Precision is a brick but since I use the laptop docked 90% of the time it’s not a major consideration.
The laptop looks stylish.
My W540 Specs:
Intel Core i7-4900MQ Processor (8MB Cache, up to 3.80GHz)
Windows 7 Professional 64
Windows 7 Professional 64 English
15.6" FHD (1920 x 1080) LED Backlit Anti-Glare Display, Mobile Broadband Ready
W540 NVIDIA Quadro K1100M 2G
16GB PC3-12800 DDR3L (4 DIMM)
ThinkPad New Precision Backlit Keyboard with Number Pad US English
ThinkPad TrackPad with Fingerprint Reader
720p HD Camera
512GB Solid State Drive SATA3
DVD Recordable
9 Cell Li-Ion Cylindrical Battery 99.9Wh
Country Pack AG with Line cord & 170W AC adapter
Intel Dual Band Wireless 7260AC with Bluetooth 4.0
Integrated Mobile Broadband upgradable
Publication - US English
1 Year Depot or Carry-in
4YR Depot/CCI + Accidental Damage Protection
ThinkPad Ultra Dock - 170 W US / Canada / Mexico
Thank you for your comments.

Hello.
Speaking now as a long time W-series fan and owner, and writing this on my W520, I don't think you'll be disappointed with the W540. Based on your chosen specs and the tasks it is destined for, I have no doubt in my mind that it will perform admirably.
I tried out a W540 with the 3k screen when it came out, which was ridiculously fast compared to my W520, but the only reason I got myself a T440p instead of it was the full-size keyboard since I use my W- machine about 50/50 docked / laptop. Today it is mostly docked though as the T440p has taken over as my main travelmate when I need the power it possesses. Otherwise I got a T440s too for lighter work.
My T440p has pretty much the same hardware beneath the "hood", besides the obvious larger specs of the W- series, and it is an absolute delight to work on, and it's by far the most powerful 14" machine I've ever used.
Regarding upgradability in the future, I can only speculate regarding the 16GB DDR3 RAM module compatibility, but I really don't think that they'll become a widespread solution as the new Broadwell Intels have been confirmed with DDR4 support. In any case, they will undoubtetly be a very expensive upgrade.
Regarding the reviews, they are many and vary hugely between users, I can only say that even though the negative ones tend to be much louder, there are plenty of good reviews on it too, and when it comes to the negative reviews, they mostly tend to focus on the changes on keyboard layout, the new ClickPad and the "lack" of vintage ThinkPad features, none of which I think are crucial when it boils down to the actual performance of the machine. I've also seen highly negative reviews on the 3k display and the scaling problems some programs have with such a high resolution display, but that is hardly Lenovo's, or any other computer manufacturers fault. Besides, since you ordered the FHD display, you won't have those problems.
I can't really comment on the Lenovo support in Canada, but here in Iceland, our Lenovo partner goes way beyond the call of duty to keep their customers satisfied. In all my years as a ThinkPad user, starting with IBM, which our partner here also manages, I've never had a single issue with them. The official online support is also the best I've experienced as well as these forums here, but this peer2peer network is unrivaled in terms of collected knowledge to almost any possible situation and scenario.
In any case, you'll probably have a completely different experience with it than anyone else, as it's a highly customizable machine, and personal preferences and experiences will always vary greatly. But I would most certainly do the same as your colleague and advise it for anyone looking for a powerful workstation.
Best wishes and best of luck with your machine if you go through with it!
Atli Jarl.
ThinkPad W540 (20BG) - i7-4800MQ/24GB // ThinkPad T440s (20AQ) - i7-4600U/12GB
ThinkPad T440p (20AW) - i7-4800MQ/16GB // ThinkPad Helix (3698-6EU) - i5-3337U/4GB
ThinkPad W520 (4282-W4Q) - i7-2720QM/32GB // ThinkPad T400 (2767-W1C) - P9500/8GB
ThinkPad T61 (7665-CTO) - T7700/4GB // ThinkPad T60p (8741-C2G) - T7400/4GB

Similar Messages

  • Just bought a macbook...having second thoughts...

    Today i bought a white macbook, the $1299 one. Anyway, I haven't opened it yet, and after reading through these forums I am having some second thoughts. I have never used a mac, and my decision came down to the macbook and a toshiba M105-S084 with a duo core processor, 2 GB RAM and a 120 GB HD for 999...a great deal, but I still decided on the MAC because I heard such great things about reliability. Now I am afraid I am going open the box and have a really really slow computer that shuts down, catches fire, and moos. I am seriously considering returning it and just getting the Toshiba...at least I am used to PC problems: freezing, spyware, pop-ups, etc. Also, is the macbook worth keeping if I can't afford to upgrade the RAM? Will this laptop be obsolete in 6 months? 60 GB of HD doesn't really seem like much considering my ipod is 40 GB.
    I'd appreciate any insight...
    -uneasy potential convert

    My personal opinion is your not going to be completely happy with the MacBook in it's current configuration. One, you really need to add more RAM to it--(suggest adding 1G for starters)--or you may run into slow performance. Two, that 60G hard drive is going to fill up fast--especially if you add a lot of music and podcasts to it. I ordered the 100GB HD for mine and it's nearly filled, and I don't even have all my music loaded on it.
    -Bmer
    Mac Owners Support Group
    Join Us @ MacOSG.com
    ITMS: MacOSG Podcast
     An Apple User Group 

  • Trying to install Windows 7, downloaded it and disk is being shipped having trouble installing the windows from download, please help!

    I have bought the download and backup disk online to put windows on my computer, but it keeps saying please put disk in and wait a few seconds for your computer to open it. There has to be away to put this on my computer from a download....

    Yes I have LION,  I do not have a DVD burner but I was told i can do this via Flash Drive. I have it formatted correctly but it still will not open it. I guess i am just going to have to return this Windows b/c i cant figure it out. I am downloading it one more time and then saving it to my flash drive. This time I am downloading the 64 bit ISO. Think that may help?

  • System not installed yet, having second thoughts

    Hi,
    The system is awesome, there are some times when the app malfunctions but they've fixed this issue. We love our system but the pricing is $49.98 for the system and cameras. This is unless you've added the set up fee onto the monthly for the first few months?
    I'm in the UK watching my house and knowing it's safe and accessible makes me happy. I would definitely install this system!!!

    Yeah, I've enjoyed the system so far. I've only had to call into support a couple of times and it wasn't a horrible experience. $69 does seem a little steep, but maybe you did work in the setup. I have not been unhappy with the system at all. I would definitely figure out the deal with the pricing. 

  • Scheduling same program inbackground after reading values.

    Hi,
    I have a sel screen, where user is entering the file path,on click of a button , i am reading this file.
    I have a check after at sel-screen, that if sy-batch NE 'X', then some code(do in foreground).
    else (background) it will go to start-of-selection event, where i am manipulating with the file.
    But if after reading the file, user executes this program in background, the file data is getting refreshed.
    Please help.
    OR - i would like to put in simple words.
    Is it possible to execute a program in background from F9 and in foreground using a pushbutton on screen. (after reading values and manipulating them on at-selection screen event)
    Regards
    Manu
    Edited by: Manu on Sep 25, 2010 6:23 PM

    If you save the data in a Database table, then in the background the program can do a SELECT to recover data.
    or
    Why you don't create a second program for backgroup, then ...
    1st Program for Read, process and store data (foreground)
    2nd Program to process data (to be exec in background)
    In the 1st program you can use a checkbox for launch the second program (in background) :
      - Using the command SUBMIT you can pass values from the first program to the second program
        or
      - Creating a JOB for call the second program (functions JOB_OPEN, JOB_SUBMIT and JOB_CLOSE)
    Regards.
    JMV

  • Having some Issues After Installing Windows Vista

    I just recently installed Windows Vista Ultimate 32 Bit SP1 on my Intel iMac running OS 10.6. I thought everything was good until I noticed 2 things. 1. I did not have a Boot Camp icon in the system try, nor could I find it listed in control panels. 2. When I tried connecting to the internet via Internet Explorer while in Windows, it told me that I did not have a internet or network connection. When I'm on the Mac OS X side my internet connection is fine. I tried reinstalling the drivers, but my only options were install CD/DVD or to connect my computer to another computer. I tried installing them manually but I noticed a yellow exclamation point on my iSight and Broadcom drivers. I can't update them because I can't connect to the internet. Can anyone help? Any assistance is greatly appreciated. I'm not a PC expert. Thanks!

    Hi Adeedo,
    Even I have the same kind of problem. After reading an update features list, I turned off and on the "Network Time Zone" button, its the same issue and its almost an hour its still saying that "Waiting for Network Time. After reboot the msg didn't appear but after turn off and turn on, same issue.
    Seems like the update broken this issue while fixing the part of not showing the city and country when the "Network Time Zone" option is turned on.
    I have got the 1.3.5 features info from the following link.
    http://www.everythingpre.com/forum/palm-webos/offi​cial-webos-1-3-5-update-discussion-25209.html
    ( Date & Time
    When the user has Network time zone enabled, a city and country are no longer displayed.
    I got this phone recently two week ago, and it was on WebOs 1.2.1 till i upgraded to 1.3.5 a week ago. 
    I am also having some other issues like Alarm. I have set two alarms one at 6.30 am and another at 6.45 am. It used to work fine, like getting buzzed for two alarms one after the other till before I update to 1.3.5. Today morning i observed that i got the buzz for first alarm, but i was waiting for the second one and it didn't come at all. I dismissed the first one. The phone was in charging using AC power.
    (Sprint Navigation
    A user can launch Sprint Navigation from an address in an open contact entry in Contacts
    Either this statement is wrong or the update is not working as it supposed to if this statement is correct. When i click the address from the open contact entry it takes me to Googles Page but not to Sprint Navigation launcher. Either i am doing wrong. Some one can help me how to launch Sprint navigation from the contact entry.

  • Failure to down load CC Acrobat DC Pro for a second time after a system recovery

    Failure to down load CC Acrobat DC Pro for a second time after having to perform a system recovery.
    The previous 'DC Pro' is not showing as not being an installed program.
    When trying to perform the update again an error shows in the Creative Cloud window 'the download appears corrupt please try again in a few minutes(26).
    Trying again both in a few minutes and after a restart the same error message shows again.
    What next?

    check the dl'd file size vs expected file size to see if you're getting a completed download.
    also, you can try a different browser and/or different wired connection and/or a download manager.

  • I am having sporadic issues after new hard drive install and recovery using Time Machine. The same sluggish response, start up screen pixelating...If I reinstall Lion will it wipe out other applications? My HD was formatted and partitioned correctly, I ha

    I am having sporadic issues after new hard drive install and recovery using Time Machine. The same sluggish response, start up screen pixelating...If I reinstall Lion will it wipe out other applications? My HD was formatted and partitioned correctly, I have a late 2009 iMac.

    Use the trackpad to scroll, thats what it was designed for. The scroll bars automatically disappear when not being used and will appear if you scroll up or down using the trackpad.
    This is a user-to-user forum and most people will post on here if they have problems. You very rarely get people posting to say there update went smooth. The fact is the vast majority of Mountain Lion users will not be experiencing any major problems with the OS, or maybe with apps which are not compatible, but thats hardly Apple's fault if developers don't update their apps.

  • Cannot activate my computer with my Adobe ID after having activated my ebook reader

    I cannot activate my computer with my Adobe ID after having activated my ebook reader with the same ID. I get the error message: "You cannot authorize this computer with an Adobe ID that was previously used to authorize another compuer or moblie device". Shouldn't it be possible to use the same ID on more than just one device? I would like to read the same book on my ebook reader and on my computer.

    Unfortunately, you de-authorized your computer but NOT your items.
    Once a book is accessed on one ID, it cannot be used on another ID.
    I am afraid you may be stuck ... if you are lucky the vendors will give you a second chance.
    ~~~
    This is a vicious trap that Adobe lays for unsuspecting customers.
    When you register 'without ID', ADE creates an anonymous/implicit ID with limited powers (eg can't be used to share with other devices).
    Whenever you first load a DRM book, that copy of the book is associated with whatever ID the computer is registered to at the time.
    Any book you load while this anonymous ID is active gets associated with that ID, and can't be read on any other device.
    When you properly register your computer with a real ID, that old anonymous ID is lost.
    Now you don't have any devices that can read the book.
    I think that even if you de-authorize again and revert to anynomous authorization, it will be a different anonymous ID, but worth a try.
    Not helpful for you if reverting to anonymous doesn't help, but general comment that might help other readers .....
    The only way I know round this is to use a DRM stripper such as epubee BEFORE you deauthorize the device.
    I do NOT advocate using such code to get around the valid limitations placed on a DRM book.
    However, where the problem arises only because of the ineptness of Adobe's ADEPT DRM infrastructure and its implementation,
    such a measure is totally justifiable.

  • CP and BP is not being created in E-Recruitment after PFAL

    Dear Experts,
    I need your valuable insight into the below issue:
    We are implementing SAP E-Recruitment in our company and we have a stand alone system for e-rec, i.e. I2-B scenario. Release 604. 
    We defined the process model, filter groups as described in note and many threads here. We are able to transfer (distribute) objects O, S, C, Q and QK using PFAL. When I am trying to distribute object P (IT0000, 0001, 0002, 0006, 0009, 0105 and 1001), object P is getting created with PA infotypes but system does not create the CP, BP and NA objects in E-Rec. My understanding after reading the documentation and some threads on SCN is that system should create these objects (CP, BP and NA) on distributing Object P from ECC.
    Do we need to Run the HRALXSYNC program in E-Recruitment to create these objects? We thought of running this program as well but the Employee Check box in the selection screen of the program is disabled. Even after implementing BADI  HRALX_HRALXSYNC_BADI it remains disabled.
    Any sort of help would be greatly appreciated...
    Kind Regards
    Syed Aijaz

    Dear Salil,
    Thank you for the quick response.
    I had considered maintaing the number ranges for CP in E-Recruitment, but had two concerns/doubts about it:
    1. We have already generated CP in ECC for all Persons and the numbers are taken from an internal range Subgroup ($$$$) and CPs have their own IDs starting with 5XXXXXXX. Now if I maintain a number range in E-Rec, different from this, would that be an issue? I understand that we need to have the same CP ID in both the systems (ECC and E-Rec). Kindly clarify.
    2. We have not maintained any number ranges for other objects (O, S, C, Q, & QK) in E-Rec system. But system has created these objects in E-Recruitment on running PFAL.
    Currently we are doing all these settngs in Sandbox system only.
    Kindly advise....
    Thanks
    Edited by: meetaijaz on Feb 1, 2012 9:38 AM

  • Help Please.  I am setting up my macbook pro for a second user but office didn't transfer over.  Is there a way to have additional users on the same comp have office available without having to re-install it for each user?

    Help Please.  I am setting up my macbook pro for a second user but office didn't transfer over.  Is there a way to have additional users on the same comp have office available without having to re-install it for each user?

    mpr130 wrote:
    Help Please.  I am setting up my macbook pro for a second user but office didn't transfer over. Is there a way to have additional users on the same comp have office available without having to re-install it for each user?
    How did you attemp to transfer Office?
    OS X Lion: Set up a guest account

  • Hi, we are using mac mini's for our developement purpose. connecting the same through using Real VNC. Mac mini's are late 2009 and 2010. Now we have upgraded them to 10.8.5. after upgrading having display issues after launching the simulators

    hi, we are using mac mini's for our developement purpose. connecting the same through using Real VNC. Mac mini's are late 2009 and 2010. Now we have upgraded them to 10.8.5. after upgrading having display issues after launching the simulators, we are unable to view the icons we need to move the simulator (into different places) to view the icons.
    Also we are having Mac book pro's (Late 2009 & 2010) after upgrading them to 10.8.5. Unable to launch the mac, getting only white screen with apple icon.
    Let me know is there any specific Hardware (Graphic Cards) we need to use for the same.
    Please provide me the early solutions.
    Regards,
    Suresh.

    Hi, try this first...
    Bootup holding CMD+r, or the Option/alt key to boot from the Restore partition & use Disk Utility from there to Repair the Disk, then Repair Permissions.

  • Having Problems opening After Effects CC

    Having Problems opening After Effects CC - wont open and I get an error message 0cx00000005

    You'll get better answers to product questions from the appropriate product forums.
    http://forums.adobe.com/community/aftereffects_general_discussion
    Nancy O.

  • Second day after updating to iOS 6 on my iPhone 4, my contacts have duplicated.  Probably not all but many, and my contacts already numbered in the thousands.  Please tell me there is an easy fix to this problem!! I already had to go through contact-by-co

    Second day after updating to iOS 6 on my iPhone 4, my contacts have duplicated.  Probably not all but many, and my contacts already numbered in the thousands.
    Please tell me there is an easy fix to this problem!! I already had to go through contact-by-contact when I bought this phone and added contacts from my Blackberry and MS Outlook on the phone.  Many duplicated at that time and Apple said the only fix was to go through each one and decide to keep or delete.  I really don't want to do that again!

    I had this problem while I had iOS 5.1.1 installed for many months. Fortunately I only have about 150 contacts and only about half of them duplicated. I found that my problem was the way thing were set up in Outlook. I removed all of the duplicates and corrected everything in Outlook contacts (ignoring the address book) and have not had the problem since, Hope this helps.

  • Why aren't any iPhone 5's being shipped to Iowa Apple Store?

    For the last two weeks I have been checking the Online Apple Store at 10:00pm daily for a Black 16G or 32G Verizon iPhone 5. The store made it sound like you just have to order the phone at 10:00pm and pick it up the next day. I even called one night before closing and asked if they would have any to sell (knowing that they probably couldn't say) but the guy said that he was pretty sure they had some so make sure you check at 10:00! I had my hopes up and have every night for the past two weeks and its getting kinda old! When I check availability, all of the other stores have gotten shipments of iPhone 5's at least once if not twice per week yet the Apple store in Iowa hasen't had any since the iPhone 5 got released. Anyone know why that is? I know the store might not be as big as the Mall of America but there are plenty of people waiting here so its a little frustrating when other stores are getting shippments of these phones twice a week and we haven't even gotten one yet.

    I have been checking with my carrier and other stores such as Best Buy and they are still fulfilling pre-orders. I should have just ordered it through Apple or Verizon and had it shipped to me but after talking with an employee from my local Apple store, he made it sound like I could just order the phone during 10pm-4am and pick it up the next day so I wouldn't have to wait 3-4 weeks for it to be shipped to me. Thanks for the suggestions. I will probably just order it and wait the month to get it even though it will probably become available for in-store pickup the day I decide to order it for delivery..

Maybe you are looking for

  • LINKS NO LONGER WORK

    After re-installing my system software, I find that email links in various apps, i.e. Firefox, Acrobat, no longer open a new email (in Entourage). Is there something I need to do? I am trying Repair Permissions for now... Thanks, Warren88

  • What is the correct adapter to connect my Macbook pro with mini-dvi to my TV with Scart

    I have a MacBook Pro with mini-DVI and I want to connect it to my TV which has only a scart thing. Can I use the mini-DVI to Video-Adapter and then a Video to Scart-Adapter? Thanks for your help!

  • Is there a ballooning size issue in iBook Author?

    Now that I near completion of my layout, my IBA file reads 706 MB. My page count is 240 pages, 70,000 words. There are 90 images of different sizes. And the 5 videos total around 200 MB on their own, about 12 minutes of interviews. My feeling is that

  • External USB Drive Issues. PC can see it but My MAC cannot.

    I have this External USB HD. I used to have it plugged into my MAC, it worked fine the entire time I had it plugged in. I took it off to save some files from my PC, everything saved fine. I tried to plug it back into my MAC and I get nothing. I tried

  • Newbie Needs Help

    I am running iPlanet Fasttrack 4.1 under Win2K and it starts fine, seems to work to view a=static web pages etc. But, when I tried to set an alias or virtual directory up under additional document directories, it won't run my web app. Is it possible