Aspect ratio issue when movie burnt to DVD

I've filmed some holiday footed on my iPhone 4 and created an iMovie, exported it to iDVD and burnt a PAL 16:9 DVD. However the aspect ratio is too wide on my TV and I'm missing a lot of the picture and text which is off screen, especially in the menus and end titles. I've played about with the TV's aspect with no result. Where am I going wrong? The only thing I've noticed is that my iMovie project is in 30fps NTSC. The PAL option is greyed out in iMovie project prefs so I've set it to PAL in iDVD (which then re-rendered then movie)
Any help appreciated.

PS I do have a new Panasonic Viera 42" widescreen plasma, so it's not an old 4:3 TV or anything!

Similar Messages

Aspect ratio issue when watching 16'9 idvd created DVDs on regular players

I am having problems with the aspect ratio of any DVDs that I burn in iDVD as 16'9 - The original video is 16'9 and edited as such in FCP, then exported with current settings selected and then in iDVD I select a widescreen project - preview of the project is fine and when the DVD is done it plays with the correct aspect ratio if I watch on the computer's internal DVD player - but my issue is when I watch on any regular DVD player (on a widescreen tv of course) all the video looks tall and skinny, including the menu. The only way I found to get the video to look like it's natural proportion is to switch the settings to 4'3 on the DVD player, then it creates almost a "super-widescreen" look where there are bars at the top and bottom of the screen. On the otherhand, when i used to shoot in 4'3 and create DVDs as 4'3 projects, I NEVER had this problem when watching on a regular DVD player on widescreen TV! It would take up the whole screen and look normal (I know it must stretch it to fit, but it wasn't noticable). I thought creating a 16'9 video I should be able to watch on a widescreen TV and it should take up the whole screen and look normal. Please help!

No, that is not the way it should work. This may help:
iDVD: DV widescreen 16:9 workflow from Final Cut Pro
http://support.apple.com/kb/TS2179?viewlocale=en_US
Final Cut Express: DV widescreen 16:9 workflow for iDVD at http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1611
and
Preparing your Final Cut Express or Final Cut Pro movie to work with iDVD at http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?path=iDVD/7.0/en/6652.html

Aspect Ratio issue when replacing a clip in Premiere CS6 with an After Effects CS6 Composition

Please assist! When I attempt to right click on a clip in my Premiere timeline and replace it with an After Effects composition, I can do so, but problems ensue.
After Effects will start up, but the composition will be in 4:3, even though the Premiere project and clip that I'm altering were both 16:9.
I was able to change the aspect ratio to 16:9 in After Effects and then edit what I wanted, but an hour later when I had finsihed, saved, and gone back to Premiere, it had smushed the replaced clip into 4:3 within Premiere.
So to reitterate:
When I replace a clip in Premiere with an AE comp, AE opens in 4:3.
I can change the AE comp to 16:9, but when I save and go back to Premiere, it has smushed the AE comp down to 4:3.
What can I do to stop this?

If you right click on the clip in the Project panel, then select Modify / Interpret Footage you will see a Pixel Aspect Ratio.
What does it say?
If it says 0.9091 then change it to 1.2121
If it says something else, come back and let me know. I will then have a different answer for you.
Also, what is the frame size of the video.

Can you help me solve my aspect ratio issue?

Hey guys,
I'm posting this in hopes that someone can help me solve an aspect ratio issue with a project that I have to finish by tomorrow.
I'm trying to avoid having to re-edit the entire thing.
I shot the project with my Nikon D7000 DSLR. in 720p 30p (29.97)
I am running Adobe Premiere Pro CS5 (the trial version). I have the full version of Adobe Premiere Pro CS3.
The reason I was working with the trial is that CS3 can't handle the H.264 MOVs that the D7000 records.
You can work with a timeline, but if you try to export anything, it never works. I always have to convert my footage to ProRes MOVs with MPEG Streamclip before I can work with them is CS3. That takes a lot of time and a lot of hard drive space. After much research, I found out that CS5 is the way to go for DSLR footage. I just need to save up my pennies for the upgrade.
So I thought I'd edit this short (1 minute) project with the trial to see how CS5 works with the D7000 footage.
Upon installing the trial program, I found that the project presets were limited. I knew this ahead of time because it's clearly stated on the Adobe's website.
But I wasn't aware how limited they are.
Since "DSLR 1280x720p 30p" is not an option with the trial, I was going to use HDV 720p 30p. But that was not an option either!
So basically, my only option for 16x9 30p was "DV NTSC Widescreen". It's my understanding that this is 864x480 (in square pixel aspect ratio) or 720x480 (in widescreen pixel aspect ratio) I needed the output file to be 864x486. I downsized the footage to 69% in the "Video Effects: Motion" setting so it looked correct in the project. I didn't think about those extra 6 pixels until I outputed the file and saw thin black lines on the top and bottom. My guess is that Premiere is adding black pixels because my project is technically 720x480 (1.2121)
Any thoughts on how I can get a clean 864x486 export? I'd rather not re-edit the whole thing...which I would have to do in CS3 after I spent a few hours converting the original files in MPEG Streamclip. I don't know if there is a way to export something out of CS5 and then open a new project in CS3 to make this work.
Thanks in adavance!
- Jordan

On export, just crop a few pixels off of each side; that'll let the image scale correctly to the output frame size without black bars.
I'm not running the trial, but you should still be able to create a custom sequence preset using the Desktop editing mode. Just switch over to the General tab when you create a new sequence, and choose "Desktop" from the editing modes. Set the rest of the parameters as you need them.
Even easier: once you've imported your footage, just drag a clip to the New Item icon at the bottom of the project panel; a sequence will be created matching your footage parameters. You can edit at full-resolution, and then export to your desired frame size when complete--you'll probably still need to crop a few pixels (in the Export Settings window) to eliminate the black bars.

Aspect Ratio issues getting 16:9 to look right, what is the best workflow?

Hi all,
I am having trouble getting my 16:9 footage to look right when I export, especially when playing on DVD. I shot the footage with a Sony HDR-HC1 which apparently shoots in 16:9 anamorphic. Originally when I imported the footage it appeared it the FCP viewer and canvas in 4:3 letterboxed form, the image did not look squeezed or stretched but appeared with black stripes on top and bottom.
I have tried several experiments with exporting this footage to dvd with the following results:
Using Compressor with 4:3 setting in export:
DVD Studio Pro track settings to 16:9 looks extra squashed vertically
DVDSP track settings to 4:3 image looks in proper aspect ratio but displays with black stripes on all 4 sides.
Using Compressor with 16:9 settings in export gives the same results.
In conclusion, if it appears in 4:3 letterbox in FCP viewer and canvas there is no way to get it to export and display in DVD with proper 16:9 aspect ratio.
I have also done some experimenting with re-capturing some of the footage from the tape.
For one sequence I recaptured the footage and it displayed in 4:3 without the letterboxed effect (filling the whole screen) but appeared squeezed, I am guessing that this is because of the anamorphic nature in which my camera captures the footage. No pixels were missing. In the FCP viewer and canvas it looked squeezed and did not display in the correct aspect ratio, however when it was exported via Compressor in 4:3 and then in DVDSP Track Settings put to 16:9 Letterboxed, it is displayed perfectly (letterboxed vertically, the image filling the width of the screen without the extra stripes on the sides).
So I thought that I had my solution here, although that did involve re-digitizing and batch capturing all 18 tapes used in the project, so its not exactly a quick fix.
This is where it gets a bit confusing. In order to understand where I had originally gone wrong in my workflow I did some more experiments, this time with the settings on the camera (which I use for a deck in batch capturing). I found the function on the camera where you can set the "TV Type" to either 16:9 or 4:3. I switched the TV Type to 4:3 and when batching it went back to the original letterboxed look (in the batch preview screen that you see while capturing), however when put into the viewer and canvas it was too letterboxed and looked squashed vertically. So then I switched back to TV Type 16:9, now it looks 4:3 squeezed in the batch preview screen (no letterboxing, no missing pixels), however when it goes into the viewer and canvas it becomes letterboxed like the original footage that I had described earlier.
So now even though I have switched the camera back to its original settings it will not display in that 4:3 squeezed look in FCP viewer and canvas.
So after all that my main questions are, in 16:9 can I view it in the FCP viewer and canvas in its correct (anamorphically converted) aspect ratio and still export it without the black bars on all sides?
(The FCP canvas seems to only display in 4:3)
If not, what setting do I need to capture in FCP in the 4:3 squeezed look I have described earlier?
(This is the only setting that I have found that displays properly when anamorphically stretched via DVDSP)
I know that this is a long essay so thanks for making it this far. I have spent weeks experimenting trying to find the best solution so please help me if you know how! I will be very appreciative.
Thanks
Liam

Hi there,
I am not sure if it is necessarily a bug, but its a matter of understanding all of the settings needed. I had the same problems for a while but after a fair bit of trial and error have found some workable settings.
It probably has more to do with the export settings rather than what viewer options have selected (I don't think that viewer settings affect your export).
What program are you using to export?
I am using compressor to export with aspect ration set to automatic 16:9. Then use DVDSP with the track set to 16:9 letterbox, it seems to export to DVD with the correct aspect ratio that way.
I am having trouble with the image strobing, looks like some kind of interlacing problem, but at least I have got it in the right aspect ratio.
Its typical video, solve one problem and it just creates another.
I am yet to find the absolute best workflow.
In response to Andy above, the original letterboxed footage probably did have something to do with the downconverting settings on the camera, as when I import without downconverting it does not letterbox. In the HDR-HC1 there is an option in the menu called "TV Type" with options of 4:3 or 16:9. I was reviewing my footage on a 4:3 television so I most likely had it set to 4:3 which created the letterboxing in the viewer when I then imported the footage.
Importing the footage in HDV solves the issue of aspect ratio, but creates a new problem with the image strobing.
I hope this was some kind of help to you.
Liam

Aspect Ratio Problems when Copying IMovie Clips

I am a relatively new user of Imovie. I copied a series of clips from a second movie and pasted them onto the end of my first movie. I shot the video for both movies with a video camera set up for 16:9. Normally my movies display at a standard aspect ratio on my computer but are stretched to the proper 16:9 ratio when I play the movie or DVD on my TV. When I copied these movie clips from the second movie, they pasted as letterboxed clips onto the first movie. When I play the movie and corresponding DVD on my HDTV, I still have the letterboxed top and bottom bars on the clips that I pasted from the second movie into the first movie.
I am looking for any suggestions on how to fix my movie to get a consistent aspect ratio throughout the movie and get rid of the letterboxing.
Thanks for the help.
Tom

Thank you for your answer.
Is there any way fix this or do I need to go all the way back and re-import the video from tape?
Also, when you mention pillarboxing, that means to me the black borders on the right and left side. I am getting letterboxing on the top and bottom of the picture.
Thanks,
Tom

Aspect Ratio Issues in CS4 -- no real 16:9 / 4:3? Need Help.

Hi,
i´m a little bit confused.
When we work in PAL Land -> 1024x576 is 16:9 Pixel Ratio 1:1 and 768x576 is 4:3 Pixel Ratio 1:1. In CS3 we have 720x576 with 16:9 Pixel Ratio 1:1,422 so 1,422x720=1024 so correct 16:9 and with 4:3 Pixel Ratio 1:1,067 so 1,067x720=768 so correct 4:3.
Now there is CS4:
Pixelratio changed for 16:9 it is 1,4587 and for 4:3 it is 1,0940. OK Maybe now we go with 702x576. BUT: The Resolution for DVD PAL Export is still fixed 720x576. NO 702x576 is possible!. So what the Hell is going on here? If i Export any Video in 16:9 PAL DVD i get 720x576 with 1,4587 so the result is a Video which is to wide with black borders (left&right side).
Any Ideas appreciate .
-nick

a) PAL in digital format, for example on Digital Beta, is aspect ratio 4:3, and 720x576. The sync lines from in the captured Digibeta have to be cropped.
b) PAL digital format aspect ratio 16.9 (widesrceen), for example when capturing from DigiBeta cassette, is also 720x576 but anamorph.
c) PAL 4:3 transcoded to square pixel format for computer use, for example as VP6 flash, or H.264 format is 768x576, aspect ration 4:3.
e) 720x576 Pixel-AR 12:11 normal, 16:11 anamorph, transcoded to square pixel, e.g. VP6 flash, H.264 etc. is 1024x576 real (not anamorph)
d) 704x576 Pixel-AR 12:11 normal, 16:11 anamorph is the analogue TV-Signal without overscan. If you receive a video like that you have to re-render it to 720x576 anamorph, or using a workstation which can interprete this footage. As far as I know, Premiere has no problem interpreting this footage, however, for example EncoreDVD will refuse to interprete it, but also other authoring application accept 704 video and the DVD plays the corrcet aspect ratio, but when demultiplexed it is still 704.

Shot in 4:3 aspect ratio, but when i capture it turns to widescreen format

I shot my footage in standard 4:3 aspect ratio, and when i import it the clip looks fine, but when i drag it to the timeline it goes into widescreen format, and i can't figure out why it is doing this. If i select the clip from my browser window and play it in my viewer window it plays fine in the 4:3 aspect ratio, but when i drag it to the timeline it goes to wide screen and it stays that way. Please help

Sounds like your sequence settings are off. If you hit command>0 (zero) you should be able to change them. One way to know they are off for sure is if when you drag your clip to the timeline you get the red line above it meaning it needs rendering. You should never have to render if your sequence settings are right.
In sequence settings make sure all your settings match the format of you clip. Frame Size, Pixel Aspect Ratio, Editing Timebase, and compressor. That should do it.
You could also just use the Easy Setup to change the whole project to match DV.

I have a project in FCP that is a 2:1 aspect ratio. When I send to compressor to author a DVD I lose the aspect ratio and the image fills the 16x9 frame. How do I preserve the original ratio thru compressor?

Aspect ratio lost in compressor

Hi Tom, thanks so much for answering. I totally get the need to letterbox but my issue is, how do I get the best quality in letterbox format?
Should I export it thru QT Conversion or just Export to Quicktime Movie? I exported as a self contained movie to keep the quality but when I send it thru the MPEG-2 compressor for DVD it fills the 16x9 frame without letterbox.
How would I modify the MPEG-2 preset to give me the letterbox in the MPEG-2?
I've been playing around but haven't hit the jackpot yet.
If there's any info you have, it would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks so much
James

Aspect ratio problems when exporting from FCP and creating DVDs

Hi there
Can anyone help? I'm using FCP to edit material shot using a Sony z1 in SD 16:9 mode. My media displayed correctly in FCP with the 'anamorphic' option ticked in the browser.
I then exported my short films as QuickTime movies and created a DVD in iDVD using those video assets.
When I then viewed the films on a widescreen tv, the films did not display at the correct aspect ratio. They were horizontally elongated, as though they had been stretched twice over, so that objects, people and text appeared fatter than they should.
Can anyone let me know whether there are any settings I could change in either FCP or iDVD to stop this happening?
Many thanks!
Jacqui

this thread may help
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=7422463

Aspect ratio issues in iDVD with mov files exported from FCE

Please help. I believe this is an iDVD bug. I have found some relevant discussion of it on online forums - but have not found a solution that works for me. I am looking for a workaround.
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1356500&tstart=31
PROBLEM STATEMENT:
My 4:3 movies, exported from FCE in QT-with-conversion formats (any 4:3 format) - appear in iDVD with gray side-pillars (as expected for 4:3) AND with a black line (letter-boxing) at top and bottom - as would be for 16:9. It appears the aspect ratio is also distorted i.e. 16:9. (The iDVD project is set to 4:3.)
1- A 4:3 mov file exported from FCE using Quicktime Movie format (no conversion) does not have the problem, but I cannot de-interlace the video using this export mode.
2) A 4:3 mov file exported using QT-with-conversion mode (any 4:3 format) DOES have the problem. I need to use this mode in order to get de-interlace.
(Exception: 640x480 VGA mode does not have the black lines, and it displays correctly in dvd player on my computer screen - but on the TV screen, it crops content from the top and bottom of the movie, so this is not an option.)
3) In Finder, if you click on mov file exported QT-only (no conversion), it opens in the FCE viewer. If you click on mov file exported in any other 4:3 mode, it opens in Quicktime viewer (i.e. there is absolutely something different in the header/ID of these files.)
4) All mov files, regardless of export mode, show correctly in Quicktime viewer - no black line, no distortion. The problem does not occur outside of iDvd.
5) I tried passing the QT-with-conversion mov files through an Inverse-Anamorphicizer (per suggestion on forum - this apparently fixed the problem for some people) but the resulting output mov (i.e. the inverted product) still had the same problem.
I am, so far, left with this trade-off: Give up the de-interlacing, or live with the letter-boxing/ distortion. Neither is acceptable.
I am looking for a workaround:
1) A way to export de-interlaced 4:3 mov from FCE that shows in correct ratio in iDVD
2) A way to "convert" / re-head mov file after exported so that it displays corrrectly (inverse-anamorphicize) so that iDVD reads it correctly
3) Can the mov be de-interlaced after the fact (so I could use QT export without conversion)?
4) Something besides iDVD to put this together - that doesn't have this problem? (I like and want to use the iDVD menu/theme.)
5) Other?????
I also notice that all the QT-with-conversion mov files are 1/3 to 1/2 the size of the QT-only mov file, which is valuable and preferable to me. (I don't see any quality difference in the display...)

In the Preview window > top frame > middle button
do you have correct for pixel aspect ratio checked or not?
!http://i533.photobucket.com/albums/ee340/gogiangigo/Picture1-4.png!

Aspect ratio on DivX movies

I'm having a few issues with the correct aspect ratio not being reproduced in Quicktime when watchting a DivX. When viewing in VLC Player everything is correct. For example I have a movie with a size of 852x368 but in Quicktime it's 720x368. The funny thing is when I view the information for the film in both VLC and QT it does actually say it's 720x368.
It's not a biggy because I'll happily watch it in VLC but I'm a little confused as to why it's happening.

But why does it show correctly in VLC but not QT?
Both sets of dimensions are "correct" (whether or not the aspect is correct is something else). QT keeps track of three sets of dimensions (4 with certain types of content) --
1) the "Format" line -- e.g., an NTSC SD DV encoded file 720x480 (640x480)
where 720x480 is the encoded rectangular matrix dimensions and 640x480 is the square pixel dimensions.
2) the "Normal Size" -- e.g., the same file as above would be 640x480 representing the dimensions as displayed/output for the current device which is a square pixel monitor.
3) the "Current Size" -- e.g., the same file as above would read whatever size I am currently scaling the display window to be. Command-0 would be 320x240, Command-1 would be 640x480, Command-2 would be 1280x960, Command-F would be whatever size would fit in the monitor display, etc.
However, if I should re-compress the file in QuickTime to a different compression format that doesn't differentiate between rectangular and square pixels using a "scaled size" either in the original aspect ratio or one that changes the aspect ratio, then the new file would have all three values reset to the scaled dimensions in effect when the file was re-compressed. This means that you can both distort and correct distortion (e.g., fix a file that has "lost" its aspect flag) and that the term "correct" can be both arbitrary and relative when discussing clip dimensions.
Confused enough yet?

Aspect ratio issue not letterbox related

i am running all video thru my receiver. my appletv outputs to my plasma TV w/black bars on either side of the picture. it appears it is output at 4:3 and not 16:9. i don't have this issue w/any of the other video inputs (dvd, cable tv). i don't see this as a tv or receiver issue/ can anyone offer any suggestions on fixing this? is there an output ratio adjust in apple tv?

The content you are watching sounds like it is not widescreen but 4:3 format.
When this is sent to the TV from the Apple TV via the HDMI cable it is shown on the TV in the aspect ratio that it was made. What you maybe able to do is make the TV stretch the signal to fill the full screen as it is doing when you use the VGA connections The issue here is that some TV's do not allow the TV signal to be stretched when fed via the HDMI port. It is not an issue with the Apple TV, it is outputting the signal correctly. See if you can adjust the TV to stretch the content to full screen.

Aspect Ratio Issues in Premier Pro CS 5.5

I'm trying to produce a DVD for my daughter's school and my wife bought me a copy of CS 5.5 to help (thanks lovely wife!).
I made a number of rookie mistakes when originally trying to produce the final video, but I think I have managed to correct most of them. Sadly, the final product still does not play correctly on a DVD player.
Here are the attributes of the original source footage (from Windows):
And here are the settings from PP for a similar file (same settings, just a file from a little later in the filming process)
And finally, here are the settings for the sequence that I created by right-clicking on the footage in PP and creating a new sequence from the file:
The problem is this... The footage plays correctly in PP when previewed. It plays fine when exported as media and played on my PC, but when played through a media player (as a digital file) the aspect ratio is off and the file seems constrained horizontally, which pushes the top and bottom of the footage off screen (not sure I'm describing this well).
Also, when I use Encore to produce a DVD as a test, the same issue occurs. So I can only assume that the problem is the render from PP.
Can anyone help? Do you need more info to help? I'm getting frustrated... time for a beer while I wait for replies.
Thanks in advance

Once I realised that I'd made some mistakes with the processing, I started doing some tests with a sample piece of footage. This has allowed me a much shorter render time when testing the settings.
Here's what I did:
I took the piece of footage and imported it into a blank Premier Pro project (with no sequences). Then I created a new squence from the file (by right-clicking and selecting "create new sequence from file). Then I dickered with the footage, inserted some picture in picture and changed the speed of some of the footage (all things I intend to do with the final production). Then I sent that to a brand new Encore project created by sending the sequence via dynamic link.
Once I was in Encore, I made sure the project made sense (set the end action etc...) then I set it to build a .ISO file. I then burned that to disc (a standard 4.7Gb DVD-R) and I also sent the ISO to my DViCO TViX media player. Whether I play the disc on my Sony Blu-Ray player or the ISO on my media player, the aspect ratio is wrong. But if I play the same ISO or disc on my PC - it works fine!
I've yet to try it on another player, but I think there's something fundamentally wrong with my process, or the way I'm doing this.
Here's a piece of footage from a camera that had EXACTLY the same setting as the original footage (I used this piece of footage because it's straight from the camera - most of the files from the main camera are too big to share):
https://www.dropbox.com/s/mocizf4d3vdx0y4/00037.MTS
(If that didn't work, I can try again...)

Aspect Ratio Problems Importing mov files

I am creating an imovie project that combines slideshow and video. The slideshows were produced in iPhoto06 as 16:9 and exported via iDVD into .mov format. They are 16:9 and play fine as widescreens in Quicktime. However, when imported into iMovieHD6, they are compacted into a squished 4:3. The iMovie project is set as widescreen (I've tried both widescreen NTSC and 720p) but this makes no difference when importing the widescreen clips. The 4:3 videos can appear with boxes on ether side, but I want the widescreen slideshows to be widescreen.

@MRogovin - I wish I knew more about this exact issue so I could give you a solid answer. All I know is that I encountered a very similar issue recently.
For reasons I won't explain, I was exporting a slideshow from iMovie '08. It would play just fine in 16:9. But every time I tried to import into iMovie HD 6, it would get squashed and there would be black pillarboxes on the left and right sides.
Research revealed that the exported video "lost its 16:9 flag." I was hoping there would be a way to simply tick a box and restore the flag. And people suggested that MPEG Streamclip would do the trick. But every time I tried to restore the flag, it would go through another round of compression, and degrade the **** out of the video (despite my experimentation with 20 different settings) -- maybe there is a way to ONLY restore the flag.
So, in the end, I had to export out of iMovie 08 without any compression. Only then did the importation process maintain the 16:9 aspect ratio. Of course, the un-compressed video slideshow was huge (8.5GB for 20 pictures).
Since you're using iPhoto, you probably can't do as I did, since iPhoto slideshows cannot be exported un-compressed. Hopefully someone can chime in and explain how to maintain/restore a 16:9 anamorphic flag.

Aspect ratio issue when movie burnt to DVD

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for