Camcorder format recomendations

I am looking for a new Camcorder. Sony and Canon are my top choices for Hard Drive HiDef cameras. I would really like one that records the video files in a format that can be directly used by FCE 4 rather than having to convert them or have to render the clips when I bring them into FCE 4.
Mostly, I have used tape based cameras that have to have FCE capture the data through FireWire as it plays it back, so they get stored as MOV files. However, my Pentax K-x records HiDef video as well, but it stores them as files in an AVI file wish requires a render before I can do anything with them. I really want to avoid that if possible.
Any recommendations?
Thanks.

If you're looking for a HD hard-drive camcorder, you'll have to purchase one that records in AVCHD. I'd recommend checking the websites of Sony and Canon to pick out an AVCHD camera that works for you and fits into your budget.

Similar Messages

  • Which camcorder format?

    I need to buy a camcorder but am confused by all the formats (MiniDV, HD etc) - with the software I have which type of camcorder will I be able to use EASILY.
    thanks

    Thanks for the info - and yes I am doing the homework as fast as p[ossible but ther e is a lot to sift through - very time consuming! Your help is appreciated!
    Are there restrictions on what will actually play/display HDV? i.e. does it have to have special presenting software?
    So even if I would like HDV miniDV the bottleneck is burning to DVD? - i.e. probably would need Adobe Premiere or Final Cut Pro?
    I need to video this event:
    http://internationaldayofpeace.org/participate/findanevent.html
    "An evening of Inspiration, Information and Celebration Expressions from local peace groups as well as entertainers, musicians and dancers.
    The Music Room
    Assembly House, Theatre Street
    Norwich, United Kingdom"
    which might be sent to any number of differing places afterwards to try to help promote peace
    thanks:D
    Message was edited by: Simon King

  • Sony HD Camcorder formats

    I am considering upgrading my current Sony Mini DV camcorder for a HD model - I believe for simplicity of editing it may be wise to stick with a DV tape model such as the DRH HC 9E (tape formats seem to be hard to find these days), in preference to a AVCHD format machine such as the HDR SR12.
    Or maybe it would make sense to wait until direct support for AVCHD format is available with editing software such as FCE.
    Any advice would be welcome.

    Many thanks for the advice - I would like to continue to use my G5 for editing as it's got the large hard drives for the job. I believe I would have to convert the AVCHD files due to the lack of an intel chip !
    it's given me plenty to think about ( tape v HD ) ...thanks

  • Canon VIXIA HF M31 camcorder format work with cs4?

    Has anyone actually imported footage from this camcorder to cs4?  The specs say the format is a HD MPEG AVC/H.264.
    CS4 shows different MPEG formats and an AVCHD format. I have never had any trouble capturing video from camcorders using a DVC tape.
    I have also had video sent to me in a AVI, MOV, or ASF format and none of them will import. Is cs4 very limited to the what formats it will really accept?

    AVCHD is one flavor of MPEG video.  If the camera has the AVCHD logo, it will probably work.

  • What are the best  asset formats to optimise DVD quality?

    Hi Guys
    Some of my clients have been complaining about the DVD quality they received from me, and I wondered to myself how can I improve in future.
    I just want to confirm if these are the best formats for each asset:
    1) Video - AVI format (as opposed to MPEG2)? The major irritation I find about AVI is that it eats up lots of disc space, and it takes a lot of time as far as transcoding in encore is concerned.
    2) Photos - TIFF format (as opposed to JPEG)? Same story as above regarding disc space.
    3) Audio - AIFF format (as opposed to MP3)? Same space problem as the first 2. Furthermore, my major annoyance with WAV files is that you have to know which version of WAV files are the best quality.
    Now, I do not what TVs most of my past and future clients own, i.e. a normal 4:3 TV like mine or the 16:9 plasma ones (although the trend these days seem to be LCD TVs). What is the best aspect ratio to use that will work on most TVs?
    Also, I use a Sony 30g HDD video camera to record events. I like it since these is no hassle about carrying tapes or DVDs around. But, the problem with the camera is that MPEG2 is the "highest quality" it can record events; my still camera can take jpeg's as the highest quality. And the photos on the DVD look - most of the time - OK in terms of quality. It's only in my last DVD that I built that I saw some of the photos having some sort of problem in the slideshow (something like a water effect on the blazers and shirts of some of the audience - definitely unwanted).
    To edit my assets, I use:
    1) Power director 6 (for my video). I know you are going to say I should use Premiere Pro. I'm still reading the manual for PPro2 and Ppro doesn't have SVRT like PD6 does.
    2) Photoshop elements or Fireworks (for my photos). Photoshop CS2 looks very complex for me at the moment - will learn later.
    3) Adobe Audition (for my audio).
    All I want is to have the highest quality possible. What's the best advice?
    Thanks for all your help guys.

    Since you raised the question of Hi8 versus DV tape formats, here are a few thoughts intended partly for you and partly for those who (unlike you) may be planning to get their first camcorder and are wondering about the different formats available.
    Hi8 is a second-generation analog format that was marketed starting about 1988 to permit better resolution than the original VHS and Video8 camcorder formats. It was superseded about 1995 by the digital video, or DV, format.
    Hi8 produced video of decent quality and was a good capture medium for material that was going to be distributed on VHS or SVHS tape. But the quality of DV is better, and DV has enormous advantages for editing and distribution. In particular, DV has absolutely no "generation loss" when transferring from tape to computer, from tape to tape, or from computer to tape, and it permits sophisticated editing using any one of many "nonlinear editing" applications that are available on PC's or Macs. Once you have edited your video using one of these applications, you may proceed to "author" your DVD's (i.e. add menus, etc.) and they will be of surprisingly high quality.
    In mentioning Hi8 you may actually have been thinking of the Digital8 format. This is a format developed by Sony as a bridge between the older Video8/Hi8 world and the DV world. It is logically identical to DV but it uses the same physical tape as Hi8. This tape is now customarily labelled "Hi8/Digital8" to emphasize this fact. Hi8/Digital8 tape is less expensive and reportedly more robust than DV tape.
    In principle Digital8 is just as good a format as DV. However, Digital8 has been targeted at a lower end of the market than DV, so even the best Digital8 camcorders may not have as good optics, as good sensors, or as many features as the better DV camcorders.
    A few years ago, many people would recommend Digital8 as a very practical format for someone just getting started in video, since it was available at lower price points than DV, was identical in quality as regards format and perhaps better in value as regards camcorders, i.e. Digital8 camcorders were less expensive than DV camcorders of the same quality. Above all, Digital8 was ideal for someone who had previously used Video8 or Hi8, since the early Digital 8 camcorders would play back analog tapes and so could bridge the transition to digital. In fact, by buying or borrowing a second Digital8 camcorder, you could play back your analog tapes from one camcorder and record them as digital tapes using the other camcorder, forever after enjoying the advantages of the digital format.
    At the present time, however, DV would be a much better choice than Digital8. Most (or all?) recent Digital8 camcorders have abandoned the ability to play back analog tapes. Only one or two manufacturers are making Digital8, and their offerings have dropped to a handful in recent years. This hardware will quite likely cease to be available in the near future, though the tapes will probably be marketed for years. When your present equipment wears out you would not want to be left with a library of family videos in an unsupported physical format.
    In the last few years the DV format itself has been superseded by various high-definition formats, especially by HDV, a format that records to the same physical tapes as DV, at the same bitrates as DV, but, thanks to much greater compression, with twice the horizontal and more than twice the vertical resolution of DV.
    Another format using even greater and more sophisticated compression, AVCHD, promises similar quality as HDV with even greater horizontal resolution, although the implementations of AVCHD available now are probably not as high in quality as the best HDV, and are certainly much harder to edit.
    Despite the emergence of high-definition formats, there are good reasons for some people to prefer standard-definition DV at this time. One reason is cost. A good HDV camcorder -- the Canon HV20 is probably the best consumer model right now -- is likely to cost $1,000 or a bit more, while good DV models cost a few hundred. A second reason is low-light capability. The imaging chips for high-definition have many more pixels than the chips for DV. If the lenses are the same size, then these pixels must be crowded into a sensor about the same size as that of a DV camera, meaning that each pixel must be smaller and therefore less responsive to low-light conditions. So a good DV camera may be much better in low light than even the best high-definition camcorder of the same size.
    Camcorders are now available that record direct to DVD (NOT advisable as John Smith said: the DVD medium is not robust for long-term storage and the necessary MPEG2 compression robs your source video of the quality it would have on tape and is much harder to edit).
    Camcorders are also available that record directly to hard disk. Depending on the implementation, and your handiness with computers, thes might be just right FOR SOME USES. In particular they permit much more rapid turnaround between shooting and editing, so they might be right for something that is needed quickly but where archiving is not important (for example, shots of a football team at practice). But (as you have undoubtedly discovered with your 30gig Sony) you must download the material from camera to hard drive when the camera fills up, and this is not as easy as putting in a new tape. Also, the file may not be stored on disk in the relatively uncompressed, and easily edited, DV format. Finally, no hard drive is as safe a storage medium as a tape. With a hard drive and especially with a DVD, you risk losing everything to a crash or scratch; with a tape, you risk at most losing a few frames to a dropout caused by imperfections in the media.
    Only you can balance all these factors knowing the type of things you will be shooting, how you will view or share your videos, and what you plan to do with them in the future. Note that DV can be edited together with HDV by many editing programs, though either the quality or the size on screen or both will be noticeably different. Also note that the high-definition formats are all in the widescreen 16:9 aspect ratio, like the newer TV's, while DV was originally 4:3 and may be available in 16:9 but with the additional width achieved by stretching the same number of pixels and possibly by using a smaller fraction of the imaging chip.
    I would recommend that you search for articles and forums about camcorders to learn what is available. There is a lot of information out there. As for me, I would certainly not recommend Hi8, or even Digital8, at this time. Choose DV if you have a pressing reason for it, such as cost or the need to get good images in low light; otherwise make yourself more future proof with HDV or AVCHD. They will produce high-quality DVD's when "downconverted" when capturing them into the computer or when exporting them from the nonlinear editor or authoring program (experiment to find which method is best). Unless you are using AVCHD, which is not a tape-based format, stick with tape (for now) if you are concerned with long-term storage.
    Best wishes!

  • How to import MPEG-1 camcorder video into iMac?

    I have a Sony digital camcorder purchased in 2002 which records to film. I would like to import the video from this camcorder into my iMac (purchased Jan. 2007) for playback on the computer and to burn the video to DVDs.
    When I hook up the camcorder to my computer via Firewire cable and turn it on to the VCR position for importation into the iMovie HD program, nothing happens. There is no communication between the camcorder and the iMovie HD program. None of the steps recommended by Apple that I have tried to establish communication between the camcorder and iMovie HD have worked. It appears that the camcorder format (MPEG-1) is incompatible with iMovie HD.
    I will appreciate any knowledgeable advice on how to successfully import this video into my iMac for the intended purposes.
    Bob

    Thanks for your responses.
    I’m embarrassed to admit that I miscued in attempting to import the camcorder video into my computer. I corrected my mistake and successfully imported the video, watching it on the iMovie monitor and seeing the video clips appear as the import proceeded.
    I added the clips to the movie and saved the project. I just got through playing back the whole movie. Yippee!
    I was surprised that this 12-minute recording produced a movie file size of 2.14 GB. Ouch! Is this normal? If so, I’m glad I opted for a 500 GB hard drive on this iMac!
    You may be wondering where I went wrong in my initial attempts to import this movie into my computer. John was right in saying “...it should be as simple as you thought.” Simple, that is, if you follow all of the necessary steps! Where I missed the boat was in not clicking the Create button after entering the various pieces of information into the Create Project window. I obviously overlooked the fact that Apple treats the importing of a simple camcorder video into a computer as a major movie-making event. The next time I go through this exercise I’ll don my Martin Scorsese hat to make sure it doesn’t happen again!
    The next step will be to burn this movie to a DVD. Wish me success as I research how to do this without any further miscues.
    Bob

  • Help with getting a better understanding on how APEX submits its pages

    Hi,
    I have implemented jquery with my app and have just applied the jquery UI plugins.
    I have the jquery UI dialog function working which gives the users some options. Now as an example, I have a cancel and a continue button. If the user clicks cancel it simply stops the page from submitting. Which works perfectly however, I cannot get the continue button to carry on with the request.
    I gather that I will need to determine what the href was of the link/button that was clicked before the dialog box appears.
    I know Apex uses a javascript function call doSumit() which simply submits the page but what does it use for other href like links to other pages?

    The problem is that you're taking a camcorder format that Premiere Elements is able to work with and converting it to a format that it can NOT work with.
    That Canon camcorder produces AVCHD video. You should shoot any video you want to edit in Premiere Elements only in MXP or FXP mode. Then, when you're ready to edit the video in Premiere Elements, you should set up a project for AVCHD 1920x1080 stereo. (Unless you're shooting in 5.1 audio. This cam shoots in a number of formats.)
    DO NOT CONVERT YOUR VIDEO BEFORE YOU PUT IT IN PREMIERE ELEMENTS.
    You can then use these specs to output high-quality video for YouTube.
    http://forums.adobe.com/thread/623549?tstart=0
    If you need some basic help with the program, be sure to check out my free 8-part Basic Training tutorial series at Premiere Elements support site Muvipix.com.
    http://forums.adobe.com/thread/537685?tstart=0

  • HT2455 how do I change the order of the songs on my playlist?

    I have 68 songs on my playlist.  Somehow the songs are all in alphabetical order, making my duplicates all play in a row.  How do I change the play order?

    Paul Brook wrote:
    … Perhaps it would help if the OP tells us what file types they are wanting to convert. …
    indeed, that should be step #1.-
    but …
    Problem with 'types' or 'formats' is: people do mix containers (or media wrappers) with codecs,
    You mentioned avi - that's no format, just a wrapper. could contain, e.g. a dv-encoded video = all easy; could contain some propitaire CanopusDV = absolutely NoGo on Mac; could contain h264/30fps - go; could contain h264/60fps - nogo.
    etc etc-
    therefore .........
    Apple likes it convenient. Or, say, simple.
    so, iMovie is meant BY CONCEPT for camcorders.
    ... and most/all camcorder 'formats' are supported; connect a camera, and some smart import/conversion routines are automatically triggered.
    the same mts 'orphanized' as a 'file' is impossible to be read by iMovie, but fully compatible, if from an intact AVCHD structure.
    …I bow to your superior technical knowledge
    … just bitter sweet experience
    not needed, if iM used as intended.
    needed, when abusing the app .....
    iMovie is no 'edits all moving images app'.-
    happy movie making!

  • Bridge CC trial on Mac Pro Mavericks

    How to make your Mac run like a PC!
    I have downloaded Bridge and Photoshop from the creative cloud trials.  I have NEVER had a program crash on my Mac.  Everytime I try to open bridge I get an error and it closes. Photoshop itself seems to work but I really haven't tried much there if bridge and camera RAW will not work then it is not worth the money.  I have seen a lot on the web about problems with Mavericks and various Adobe products. Is Adobe focusing more on PCs now?  Presumabley not everyone is having these problems or no one would buy the product.  Does anyone know if CS6 is any better or should I just give up and be happy with Aperture?  EXTREMELY Frustrated with this and will likely uninstall this weekend if it can't be fixed. 

    Premiere Elements works with specific camcorder formats, jt. It may not work with the type of codec produced by EyeTV.
    Although it's possible EyeTV uses a standard codec of some type.
    Which preset did you select when you started your Premiere Elements project? It's vital that you select the right project preset to match your source files. And, since this device may not produce standard camcorder files, you may need to try a number of project settings to find one that works.
    Though there are no guarantees, since this device isn't necessarily designed to produce standard, editable video.

  • How to import from Opra browser?

    My browser is Opra, how can I get my bookmarks transferred to Firefox?

    Hi(Bonjour)!
    It's important to select a sequence preset that match your camcorder format, like DV PAL. Use easy setup menu to select the right preset.
    Michel Boissonneault

  • PAL/NTSC footage: How does it all work?

    Hi
    I'm a complete newby to iMovie, so please excuse any stupid questions and please assume I know nothing!
    Here's my situation: I have imported a bunch of events into iMovie '09 from two DV camera's. One a tape camera and the other a miniDVD type camera. Both of these camera's are PAL.
    I have since moved to Canada (where I bought my MBP). I didn't change any settings in iMovie when I imported the events from the camera's using Firewire.
    I have edited a project in iMovie and eveything looks great. I can preview the project within iMovie and it looks great.
    I then want to make a a DVD using iDVD. This is where things go wrong. After burning the DVD the playback on my (NTSC?) DVD player in Canada produces a sort of stuttering effect. Audio is fine, colour is fine but the video just seems to stutter a little. I have not had a chance to try plying the DVD's on a PAL system to see if they work there, however I have played both PAL and NTSC DVDs on my system here in Canada, so I assume that this shouldn't be a problem. It must be somewhere in the process starting at importation and ending in the burning the disc in iDVD.
    I have a feeling this has something to do with my settings (PAL/NTSC/framerate) during import, my rendering settings and/or the settings in iDVD etc etc but I have no idea where to start to find the right settings and make the necessary adjustments.
    I don't even know if this is the problem.
    I did a search in the forums but found no posts directly related to my problems or filled with too much jargon for me to understand them.
    Please help!
    Thanks,
    Mike
    Message was edited by: Hakaman

    I believe that if you've shot in PAL (i.e. that's the camcorder format) you have to import as PAL, otherwise iMovie gets confused.
    You can make your DVDs NTSC in iDVD - it's under Project Info. As a test, you could make 2 DVDs of the same project - one PAL, the other NTSC, and see what differences in playback there are.
    There are often quality issues in swapping formats, because the frame rates have no relation to each other (25 vs 29.94).
    Otherwise, you might be able to switch frame rates in the camcorders

  • PE9 trial on Mac Pro - .mp4 is almost unworkable

    I've installed the trial version of PE9 on my Mac Pro (2x2.8GHz quad-core with 10 GB RAM).  It works well with MPEG-2 files from my DVD recorder (recorded TV broadcasts), but it bogs down seriously on .mp4 files exported from Elgato's EyeTV.  Even with 480i video (720x480) the preview shifts down to a reduced resolution, stutters and freezes regularly, and the playback controls take a long time (many seconds) to respond.  I haven't even dared to try 720p or 1080i.
    Is this a limitation of the trial version, or are there settings I can adjust to make this usable, or is MPEG-4 decoding simply too processor-intensive to make editing practical with my current hardware?

    Premiere Elements works with specific camcorder formats, jt. It may not work with the type of codec produced by EyeTV.
    Although it's possible EyeTV uses a standard codec of some type.
    Which preset did you select when you started your Premiere Elements project? It's vital that you select the right project preset to match your source files. And, since this device may not produce standard camcorder files, you may need to try a number of project settings to find one that works.
    Though there are no guarantees, since this device isn't necessarily designed to produce standard, editable video.

  • Export without video sequence coding

    I have edited clips from a camcorder format (panasonic full hd 1080x1920 50i/s progressive) wich is fully bluray compliant.
    I would like to export the sequence without reencoding since  a) it is a lengthy process and b) only provides quality reduction with respect to the native format. ( it stand to reason that effects have to rencoded).
    Can sombedoy explain to me how to proceed?
    Thank you
    Phalch

    Sorry, you can't. PRE does not 'smart render' - it always re-renders your entire project when Sharing. There are other video editors that do perform smart rendering (Sony Vegas and Magix Movie Edit Pro come to mind). The free GPL virtualdub can "Remove segments of a video clip and save the rest, without recompressing."
    Cheers,
    Neale
    Insanity is hereditary, you get it from your children

  • How to import from Kodak zi8

    I have a new Kodak zi8 video camera (flip variety). When I plug it into my computer to download, iphoto recognizes the camera, but imovie does not. Do I have to download into iphoto first, or am I missing something? I thought imovie would recognize the video camera. I am a novice in the movie department. Thanks for your help!

    Hi(Bonjour)!
    It's important to select a sequence preset that match your camcorder format, like DV PAL. Use easy setup menu to select the right preset.
    Michel Boissonneault

  • Analog to iMac for movie editing and DVD burning

    What is best combination of hardware/software that I should use to convert my Sony camcorder analogy video to my iMac that I can save, edit with iMovie and later create DVDs?

    Even though your comment is a "Reply" to the OP, you quote my previous comment, so in response:
    You do NOT need any program to convert it back to an editable format, if, like I, you edit in MPEG-2 (in my case I edit with MPEG Streamclip). 
    I already noted that the Apple MPEG-2 Component is required.
    Handbrake and Toast are not editing programs.  Handbrake will transcode (to, for example, the H.264 format that I use for AppleTV playback) and Toast will burn to DVDs (and Toast can transcode, but is my last choice of a transcoding option).
    When you say: "so much [is] lost in the .mpeg conversion" please elaborate.  Are you suggesting that MPEG-2 conversion from 1980s and 1990's analog camcorder formats will show less visual quality? 
    That has not been my experience.  I am quite pleased with my conversion and editing method.
    Perhaps your analog tapes suffer from "noise" and other analog artifacts that cause problems in the digital conversion.

Maybe you are looking for