Firewire or internal boot?

I have a question about which would be better to boot from, firewire, or the internal hard drive in my G4 Cube. I know that the max transfer rate for firewire is 400 something mbps, but the firewire enclosure i have is for a 2.5" ide drive, which at most ide drives run at is 133. I'm not sure, but I think the Cubes HDD runs at 66, it may be 100.. but yeah, you get the idea, which is better to boot from?

Hi -
...which is better to boot from?
The internal drive.
Although the internal bus is ATA/66, the net data transfer rate to and from the internal drive will be faster than that with a firewire drive.
FWIW, a firewire drive will have a faster data transfer rate than the optical drive, but the internal hard drive will be faster yet.

Similar Messages

  • Best Practice???  Change from internal boot disk to external disk

    I have a mini running 10.5.6 server and it currently boots off it's internal disk. I was hoping to get some feedback/input from others on a good process to convert the system from it's internal boot disk to an external boot disk (firewire).
    I wanted minimum downtime during the conversion and I of course, want a complete snapshot on the new boot disk. Lastly, I do not have a local keyboard and console on the system although I could connect one if it seemed to be much easier that way.
    In general, I am thinking of the following:
    1) Boot into the Leopard Server CD.
    2) Use diskutility to Restore from the internal boot disk to the new external boot disk.
    3) Choose the new boot disk as the startup disk.
    4) Reboot onto new disk.
    Is diskutility the best bet?? Meaning will it work this way if the drives are different sizes??
    Should I try to clone the disk from the internal boot disk (assuming I shutoff services first) using SuperDuper or Carbon Copy Cloner?? But I believe they do not copy over all logfiles, etc..
    Or does anyone have a quick overview of a methodology which they have done in the past or just are suggesting might be a better process than the ones I described??
    In Summary:
    1) From the CD, clone using diskutil and change boot disk
    2) From the running OS, clone using SuperDuper or CCC and than reboot onto new disk
    3) Something else??
    Thank you in advance.

    For cloning the machine you have the approach fine. Disk Utility is fine and booting from the CD is the best method. Simply use the restore method.
    But why on earth would you want to boot from an external Firewire drive? First, there is the issue of speed. You have a mini, let's assume it is a one generation back Intel. It has an internal SATA drive on a 1.5 Gbps connection. You want to move that to a 400 Mbps Firewire bus? Next, beyond the speed issues, you have a persistence issue. You are taking the boot volume and moving into to a transitory bus. One of Firewire's greatest strengths is easy connection/disconnection. Persistence is not a strong point.
    Next, if your plan is to move the boot volume to some form of a Firewire RAID, then you are even penalizing yourself more. The mini has one FireWire port. If you are using two devices and creating a mirror RAID, then you need to daisy chain. Talk about points of failure, asynchronous startup time, bus blocking, etc. Not wise.
    Plus, I can not count how many external firewire devices have burnt up in the effort to have small footprints. Lacie and the "let's put a drive in a metal case with no fan" approach = melted drive. Western Digital and Lacie with the "let's make a completely un-reusable external power brick that either breaks in a small breeze or falls out when the heavy guy walks by the server" approach.
    If you are looking at a Firewire RAID enclosure, then you are missing the objective of speed as you are limited by the 400 bus. It is nice to say that you have a four drive SATA 2 RAID case running a RAID 5, but you are defeating the purpose of why you bought the raid. The RAID 5 can provide an exponential increase in I/O performance. But that goes out the window because of the slow bus.
    If your argument is that "this is a server and my bottleneck is Ethernet," that too does not hold up. You are likely running on a gigabyte network.
    For system details check out http://developer.apple.com/documentation/HardwareDrivers/Conceptual/Macmini_0602 /Articles/architecture.html.
    Take this with a grain of salt. You caught me on a grumpy day as yesterday I dealt with a melted external firewire drive.
    My advice is buy real server class hardware. What is you objective? Drive redundancy? Capacity? A mini is a great dev server. Not a production server. This is your data. Presumably the data that makes your business function. Don't trust it to a single platter. And don't trust it to a consumer level, disposable system. I am not trying to malign the mini. It is a fine machine for its role. Its role however is not to be a production file server. Now as a web server, we are talking a different situation.
    Ok, I am rambling. Hope this helps in some way.

  • Internal boot drive not mounted -- Mac does not restart

    Hi everyone,
    I've got a problem with my  2013 MacBookPro 13" with OS X 10.10 Yosemite.
    It seems that somethings wrong with my internal boot drive. I wanted to start my Mac but the grey progress line stopped at about the half and didn't continue. I tried to boot in secured mode --> not possible. I loaded recovery mode and wanted to check and repair disk utilities but I cannot hit those buttons because my drive is not mounted and cannot be mounted. I also tried to connect my Mac via Firewire with another Mac in Target Disk Mode --> Drive could not be mounted. Finally I tried to mount my drive on a Windows and Linux computer --> not mounted :-(
    Is there another possibility to mount my drive or to access my data somehow? The thing is that I do not have a backup and that is why I need to access my data and store them somewhere prior being able to do a clean reinstall of my Mac.
    Thank you for your support.
    Markus

    Boot into the Recovery volume (boot with the Command + R keys held down), select Disk Utility and try to repair the disk and disk permissions. If you're able to reboot normally and see that works.
    If not reboot into the Recovery volume and reinstall the system.
    If you can't boot into the Recovery volume mamau08 may be right in that the drive has failed.

  • Lion Installer thinks that my internal boot hard drive "is used for time machine backups"

    I recently installed a new hard drive on my MBP. It's been running fine, but now I'm running into trouble when I tried to install Lion!
    The download worked just fine. But when I try to choose a disk to install Lion onto, my one and only hard drive (internal, boot disk) "is used for Time Machine backups" and is grayed out! I can't click it, I can't customize the installation or do anything except go backwards through the license agreement and such.
    No, I do not use my internal drive as a Time Machine. But somehow, even after I've disabled Time Machine, it keeps thinking I do! Time Machine is my menu bar is grayed out, but I can click "Browse other Time Machine disks" and for some reason my boot disk comes up! ("(My name)'s MacBook Pro on 'Untitled 1') I've never used this disk as a Time Machine!
    I have a feeling that this is somehow related to my using Super Duper to clone my old hard drive during the upgrade process.
    Is there a way to remove the Time Machine files from my boot disk or otherwise convince Lion to install? I've already repaired my disk permissions in Disk Utility. What else can I do?
    Thank you in advance. This is very frustrating!

    Alexander Chan1 wrote:
    No, I do not use my internal drive as a Time Machine. But somehow, even after I've disabled Time Machine, it keeps thinking I do!
    At some point, probably accidentally, your internal HD was selected as a destination for Time Machine.   Even if that was immediately changed, it had already created a Backups.backupdb folder at the top level of the drive.
    As long as that's there, OSX thinks you're trying to install OSX on your backup drive.  Just delete that folder.

  • How do I mount an external Firewire HD when booting into single user mode?

    Hi,
    How can I mount an external Firewire Harddisk from the Darwin Console, once I have booted into single user mode?
    I'm trying to make a backup of all my files and then re-install my iMac G5 since it doesn't start the GUI anymore and I haven't gotten any responses to my question here: http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1104762&tstart=0
    Thanks,
    Torsten

    ok, I executed the following commands:
    /sbin/fsck -fy
    /usr/libexec/registermach_bootstrapservers /etc/mach_init.d
    autodiskmount
    There were two messages:
    UniNEnet: Ethernet address 00:14:51:32:19:b8
    and
    Aug 29 20:55:29 launchd: server 2e3b in bootstrap 1103 uid 0: "/usr/sbin/lookupd"[16]: exited abnormally: Hangup
    I don't know whether this has anything to do with the commands I entered.
    And since I don't know what the volume name for the external Firewire HD is, I typed
    ls -l /Volumes
    but the only volume that is being listed there is my iMac's internal HD.
    What should I do next?
    Thx!

  • Install SL on 20GB Firewire ipod and boot Intel Mac?

    I have an old 20GB Firewire ipod gathering dust and I was wondering if I could install SL on it and use it for an emergency boot disk to boot a MacBook, perhaps with Disk Utility and another utility or two on it?

    Thanks, donv (The Ghost) this is wonderful news. I was hoping the answer would be yes it will work!
    One (or 2) further questions.
    I do use SuperDuper! Smart Updates to do my backups and I love it.
    ...you can clone the volume on your external drive to your internal--much easier and much less risky than reinstalling...
    So, after I've partitioned the new HD and installed and tested out SL from the external with my most used apps, I could move SL over to the MBP HD using SuperDuper!? But, I won't want to copy the volume containing SL over what's on the MBP, wouldn't it erase everything currently on the MBP.
    **There's probably a setting to do this sort of cloning, I just don't know where to find it...can you help with this, please?
    **Now I have my MBP backup on another LaCie that I partitioned in Apple Partition Map format (I believe that's the correct term) For installing the OS onto the external I've read that I must make a GUID partition. Can one HD be partitioned with both a GUID partition for SL install and Apple Partition map for the remaining partitions?
    Thanks again for your speedy reply and help.
    Mrs H

  • Internal Boot Camp to External

    So, seen several similar questions to this, but not quite in the same way. I swapped my internal hard drive for a new one, and the old one had Windows 7 installed on it, through Boot Camp. Is there any way to boot through that partition? I know there are ways to boot Windows off an external drive, but not sure how nicely they'll work with Apples drivers

    Thats not true, there are work-arounds, such as this:
    http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=1508618
    I was just seeing if anyone knew an easier way than a fresh install, though it doesnt seem there is

  • Firewire to internal hd crashes OS.

    The title says it pretty much. This is my second error I've had trying to move a folder from an external firewire drive to my second internal drive. Apple phone help proved less than helpful, anyone here have any ideas or sharing similar problems? I had to come to these forum to learn how to rewire my bluetooth that was installed wrong. Day 3 spent fixing my brand new computer.GRRRRRR.

    Perhaps the firmware used by the FW bridge needs updating?
    No idea really, all my FW drives are quite new, use Oxford bridge, good cables.
    My guess is there might be directory corruption. How large is the file and is it on a Mac HFS style partition?

  • Best way to upgrade internal boot drive

    Hi all, I have a G4 dual 1gig with the standard 76 gig internal drive and Lacie 250gig external for my I Tunes library, photos, and video editing.
    The internal drive is showing 33 out of 76 gig available. I know that ideally you should not have your boot drive filled more than 50%. My question is should I add another internal drive? Or get a bigger drive to use for the boot up?
    How do I tell my Mac to recognize or use another drive for boot up purposes?
    I'm relatively green at playing with start up preferences.
    Thanks,
    Ed

    Hi, Ed!
    You still have sufficient space on your startup drive to operate efficiently, unless you're working with two-hour video projects right on the startup drive, which can eat up over 30GB...
    You can easily add additional ATA hard drives of any size to an MDD Mac. You can have up to four total. Shop around online for a large ATA drive and you'll find some good deals, especially when coupled with a rebate. The mass merchants like CompUSA, Best Buy, Circuit City, Tiger Direct, Fry's (outpost.com), Newegg, etc. have sales that generally change weekly. You want an ATA drive for hooking up natively to your logic board bus. (A SATA drive requires the addition of a controller card.) For shopping purposes, don't let terms like ATA,PATA, IDE, EIDE, Ultra ATA-133, or Ultra ATA-100 confuse you - consider them all interchangeable terms for buying a new drive. Just don't mistakenly get a SATA or SCSI drive.
    I'd look for a 3.5" drive that runs at 7200 RPM and has an 8MB or 16MB buffer, as opposed to a 2MB buffer, which is slower. The four major brands are Seagate, Maxtor, Western Digital, and Hitachi, any of which should serve you well.
    When you get the drive, set it to Cable Select (for an MDD or later Mac) and connect it to the second bus on your logic board, attaching it to the end connector of the ribbon cable. You might first check to insure that your current drive is now set to Cable Select, which is the standard setting which it was to have originally been set when it shipped from Apple.
    After installation, reset PRAM and boot normally to your startup drive, launch Disk Utility, and initialize (fancy word for initial formatting) the drive using Mac OS Extended as the format. I'd recommend checking the box to install the OS 9 drivers even if you don't intend to use OS 9. You might also consider using the option to overwrite zeros to the drive when you first format it, which will map out any bad sectors which may be present and preclude their future use. This option takes a few hours, but is good insurance against potential data corruption.
    After formatting, the drive icon will appear on your desktop along with your startup drive (just like the external one does when mounted).
    If you load an OS on a second drive, you have a choice of drives to boot from. You can easily select or change the default startup volume by selecting it in the Startup pane of System Preferences. Alternately, you can boot to the Startup Manager by holding down the option key at startup, selecting and and booting to the non-default volume.
    You can clone your startup volume to another drive volume by using Disk Utility's Restore option, or better yet by using a third-party shareware utility like CarbonCopyCloner or SuperDuper!, which most folks seem to prefer.
    If you have questions, please feel free to post back and one of the Members will gladly help you further.
    Gary

  • Lacie firewire drive wont boot

    Hi there,
    Since i got the Lacie 200G firewire from Lacie back last November, I have been using Silver Keeper 1.14 for back up my powerbook. Starting new year, the Lacie drive is acting strangly again. it allows me to back up(I am using back up sets), but everytime when i boot from the Lacie back up drive, the system just froze at the gray Apple Logo. i noticed a twitch that shifted the grey apple logo downwards a little bit, and the spinning wheel didn't even showed up. i tried to zero format for the partition, zero format the whole HD, and nothing worked. Everytime i want to start back up, there will be an error message from Silverkeeper, "Failed to Register "Lacie Back up Support" for Privileges. I don't remember i encountered such error message before til recently.
    Oh, and when i try to repire permission on the back up partition, it seems that every files needs to be repire premission. The list of files is so long that i don't think it's a good idea to post it here...
    Is my drive broke again? Sigh.................
    Shan

    I believe you need to download and install a firmaware update from LaCie. My extrnal drive would not consistently appear after installing 10.4, so I went to the support section of the LaCie website and downloaded the latest firmware. It now works fine.

  • External Firewire iSight under Boot Camp

    Hi All,
    I've searched these forums and many others on the issue of getting an external firewire iSight working under Windows via Boot Camp. There seems to be a huge amount of conflicting information...
    Does anyone have the definitive response...?
    Can it be done...? Are there drivers available...? Can non apple drivers be used...? etc..etc..
    Advice appreciated.
    p.s. If there is no driver available, I'm amazed someone hasn't reverse engineered a driver for this yet... If I knew how, I would!!!

    Ted,
    Taken from Boot Camp setup guide PDF, Page 16.
    "You cannot use Boot Camp Assistant to partition and install Windows XP on an external drive."
    Link to setup guide: http://images.apple.com/macosx/bootcamp/pdf/BootCamp_Beta_SetupGuide.pdf
    Regards, James

  • Firewire or internal sata drive

    which is the better drive for recording audio using logic pro 8 on a mac pro intel 2.0 internal sata or firewire, thank you

    My experience says that internal SATA definitely is more stable than External firewire.
    Besides many other external devices (audio interface for example) also uses the firewire bus.
    Also you shouldn't find the cheapest option when buying a hard drive. Your drive is an essential device, and losing data is no fun.

  • Rebooted computer, now firewire drive's boot partition is gone...

    Here's the story.
    First, I run a Mac Mini (1.25Ghz with 1GB of RAM, booting from a 160GB firewire drive). Everything was running stellar until last night.
    Got home from work last night, noticed my computer wasn't seeing the internet, despite the fact that my home network was functioning. So, I decided to reboot. After hitting reboot once, Tiger tells me it cannot reboot because something had not quite (something loader, I think, I forget). I wait a second, and hit "reboot" again. This time, it goes to blue screen with spinning wheel (not the mouse spinning wheel), and the screen goes back.
    Computer powers down and comes back up. On startup, I get the grey screen with the "I can't find your OS" flashing icon.
    I reboot the computer again, get the same thing. Load in my Tiger disc, boot from the CD. From the startup screen, I go to Disk Utility, and it shows that Disk Utility sees my firewire drive (it tells me the enclosures connection hardware information, and my hard drive disk size), but it does not show my partition where all my data, especially my boot data, resides.
    Disk Utility will not let me repair or verify the hardware I see (since there's no partition it can see). I have DiskWarrior here at work, so I connected my hard drive to the computer here, started the firewire, and got the error "Disk Insertion - The disk you inserted was not readable by this computer. [Initialize] [Ignore] [Eject]".
    I hit ignore, and ran DiskWarrior, and it cannot see the partition either, so it can't help me rebuild my directory structure.
    So, what do I do now? I'm a Mac and PC guy, and an computer technician, so I know my way around, but I honestly get aggravated when just a simple reboot hoses my entire system. Kinda goofy, y'know? Anyway, any ideas would definitely be taken into account.
    -Will
    Mac Mini   Mac OS X (10.4.3)   Booting from firewire drive

    Welcome to Apple Discussions!
    Typically it is not a good idea to rely on an external drive for booting because you never know when cables or power to the external device might fail or the Firewire port might need resetting. Regardless, take a look at the hints at the beginning of my FAQ here:
    http://www.macmaps.com/firewirebug2.html
    And if none work you may need Prosoft Data Rescue to recover information off the drive if the data is not backed up. Note, any writing you do to that drive prior to attempted recovery will lessen your chances of recovery of information.
    Disclaimer: Reference to links I make to my Macmaps.com website are a for your information only type reference. I do not get any profit from this page, and it is open to the public.

  • I upgraded my internal Boot Drive, used Disk Utility to image and restore..

    ...Time Machine still recognizes my external drive as the backup disk, and I can still go back in time to bring something back using it.
    The problem is that, time machine thinks it needs to backup everything that is on my restored internal drive. So what I have now is this--
    Full Backup from original Leopard launch
    Incremental Backups
    Full Backup (in progress now) since imaging my old internal drive to a new one.
    My question: how can I turn what is happening now (a full backup of the present), into an incremental backup (where it should leave off, since it is an image of the same drive)?

    Unfortunately, nobody can tell you what you're likely to be able to restore. You can only try. See Recovering deleted files for some suggestions.
    The encrypted sparse bundles are the big problem. If all the individual "bands" of the sparse bundle are still intact, you should be able to recover them, although if the recovery software is unable to recover the directory structure, I imagine it may be difficult to piece them back together.
    However, if even a few bytes of a single band file have been overwritten, the entire sparse bundle is ruined. You'll never get it open again. A recovery service is not likely to be of any help in that case.
    BTW, you definitely need to be posting in the Snow Leopard forum, as there are some fairly significant differences between Snow Leopard and Mountain Lion. You risk getting answers that make assumptions on the system you are using, and that won't apply to you.

  • Internal boot error battery 601

    asking for bootable device. internal battery low charge battery 601

    Possible hardware issue on the HDD here. Any changes made in the BIOS? If not, I would check with tech support. 

Maybe you are looking for