InDesign's auto-handling of parallel texts in parallel columns

Everyone I have asked this question of says -- "I am not exactly sure what you are trying to do ..."   So PLEASE READ CAREFULLY.
I was told that Indesign could handle this easily.  Adobe's East Indian support had no idea what I was talking about.  Their U.S. office failed to respond.
When you develop a book length project (400 pages or so) of 4 parallel texts, there is NO REASON whatsover why you would want EVEN pages to wrap over to ODD pages.  You typically have 2 columns holding 2 *different* texts on the left (even) page, and you also have 2 totally different columns holding another 2 totally *different* texts on the (odd) right pages.  So in facing page mode, you see 4 different texts ALL in parallel with each other.
The consequences of this seems SO hard for most people to understand.  It means the 2 columns of texts on the LEFT (even) page will ALWAYS stay on the left page, no matter which page of the book you turn to, and the 2 columns of texts on the right page will ALWAYS stay on the right pages.
There is NO WRAPPING from even pages onto odd pages, and vice versa.  What is in column 1 of the even page ALWAYS stays in column 1 of every even page in the book.  When you turn the pages of the book, everything aligns perfectly -- the left 2 texts are in parallel with the right 2 texts.
I can't see why people have so much problem understanding this SIMPLE book layout, of 4 parallel texts spread across 2 facing pages -- which is VERY common in scholarly texts. Nevertheless, they do.  So if you don't see what I am asking for, please re-read the above until you do.  Now, I was told that Indesign can do this easily, but Adobe staff have failed to respond.  So let me ask you Indesign experts in this forum the crucial question --
If you set up a 4 page layout, where the 2 columns in the left (even) page of page 2 wraps down to the left (even) page of page 4 (no, not page 3) -- and the 2 columns in the right (odd) page of say page 3 wraps down to page 5 (no, not page 4) -- can you get the program to make this layout persist over 400 pages without the user having to laboriously link, page by page, every even page to the next even page, and every odd page to the next odd page?
More specifically, if I have 4 columns spread across 2 facing pages, and I tell Indesign that page 2 columns wrap to page 4 columns (no, not to page 3 columns), and I link page 3 columns to page 5 columns (no, not page 4 columns)  -- CAN INDESIGN realize this is a pattern that repeats throughout the entire book, and do it automatically for me???  My people are simply NOT going to understand how to link odd to odd pages and even to even.
i.e. I need to set up a 4 page layout, which gives the even-to-even linking, and the odd-to-odd linking, and after that the PROGRAM ITSELF needs to be smart enough to realize that this is the layout that you want for 4 parallel columns .... and it replicates it on all pages, until you tell it otherwise.
So the question is -- can Indesign do this or not??  It is a simple YES / NO answer.  Either Indesign can recongize the layout for 4 pages (i.e. two facing pages replicated to the next 2 facing pages) and keep this layout going for the length of the book -- or it cannot.  It is either one or the other.
If I have to laboriously link EVERY odd page frame in the book to every odd page, over 400 pages, and I have to link every even page frame in the book to every subsequent even page -- then we have a serious mental gap with the developers of the program.  Anyone who has worked with multiple parallel texts knows that this is the NORM for multiple parallel book texts.  The problem I am having is finding a program whose developers comprehend this.
Please realize, I have gone through about 30 programs, and YES, I am frustrated.  If Indesign can do this easily without me having to mindlessly create 400 repetitive page-frame to page-frame links that should be obvious to the program (and its developers) then please say: "YES it can do this for you."
Thank you for your knowledgeable help -- without getting upset that I have struggled over the past 2 months to make people realize this simple need.

Hey Joel, nice post, thank you.  If you look for scratchyboy or "scrathcyboy" on the web, you will see I am a hardware and M$ software guru.  There is almost nothing about windows I can't fix or tear to pieces.  But why windows would destruct on installing SP2 -- I have never figured that out yet !!
"It sounds like the the CS4 functionality and AFP will work well for you; do you have a second computer to use as a testbed?"
I have a network of 10 computers, each dedicated to special functions.  I thought of Win7 on one, but decided not to, because of no efficiency advantage (see the best XP-W7 comparison -- http://www.experts-exchange.com/OS/Microsoft_Operating_Systems/Windows/Windows_7/Q_2525764 2.html).
"In your shoes, I might try to do it more cheaply"
THANK YOU for sugesting this, it was on my mind since this morning.  Between monitor and software, we are pusing $2000 here, and since my ORG is non-profit, I probably won't recover that outlay.  So let me ask you -- and EVERYONE ELSE too -- something that has been bugging me ....
Why can't a Word Processor do this??  I know this is an InDesign forum, but you guys are the sharpest I have met, so let me lay it out for you .. and hold your breath !!  The first parallel column book I ever produced was written in WORDSTAR for DOS ( ... Gasp !!! ....)  and with Wordstar's DOT commands, hell, I could do anything I wanted ... font kerning, multi-column layout, even odd pages wrapping to odd pages, and even to even.
This, as it turns out is the achilles heel of all modern word processors.  The developers (yes they are to blame for lack of experience) NEVER conceived of parallel columns, and since they did not understand parallel texts, they never realized this obvious -- "hey if you have 2 different parallel texts on the even pages and 2 other ones on the odd pages -- then suddenly the page wrap model changes -- it then becomes illogical to wrap even to odd pages.
So I have tried just about every word processor but PageMaker (never liked it, maybe you guys can help here??) -- the only two WPs that attempt to grasp parallel columns are Lotus WordPro, and Corel Wordperfect (which I found unstable and unusable for long texts of more than 15 pages or so).
If you look at my layout above, it is really quite basic -- 2 parallel "discussions" on the left page, aligned with 2 parallel texts on the right page.  There is nothing here a word processor should not be able to handle ... except for their ONE achilles heel -- they all seem to insist on forcing every even page to wrap to the next odd page number ... blindly NEVER considering a 4-parallel-column layout spread across facing pages, as ALL books display.
So how about PageMaker 7?  Can it do this?  I have bought and acquired so much Adobe software (I was an early beta tester for Photoshop) that I have never used ... I sure would like to make some use of it, even if years old.  All I need is a WP that can do 4 columns split 2 on the left, 2 to right.  It is really that simple, and all the WP has to do is realize if the left page texts differ from the right, you do NOT wrap even to odd, only even to even.
So HOW ABOUT IT GUYS???  If you can't figure this out, hell, there is no group of people I know who can figure it out.  So LAY ON McDUFF ....

Similar Messages

  • Parallel text box in selection screen

    Hi all,
    Can anyone please tell me that how can i create parallel text boxes in selection screen?
    Exa : Company code    <Input box>                        Date       <Input box>
             Pers No.              <Input box>                    Cust No. <Input box>
    Regards.

    hi,
    Use COMMENT and POSITION statements in selcection-screen to achieve the same.

  • Auto-tabbing between input text fields in AS3

    Hello-
    I am having some trouble figuring out how to work auto-tabbing between input text fields when a user inputs a character. I have a series of text boxes with maxChar set to 1, and when the user inputs a character, I would like it to auto-tab to the next one. I'm putting together a crossword-style banner ad so the auto-tabbing will help tremendously.  All the input text fields are instanced on the stage as input1, input2, etc; not called in from a custom class.  Also, I've been working with AS3 for about 2 weeks lol!
    thanks!

    Awesome, thank you, that works nicely! Now I need to figure out how to capture individual keyCodes for each input and then come up with a conditional to check for right or wrong answers. I have a "check your answers" button all set up. I think I am almost there, possibly a syntax hiccup for me. Any advice on how to do that would be appreciated.

  • After Updating Adobe Indesign CC ,While I'm selecting text in a paragraph, the text disappears and this problem repeated several times before update everything was ok

    After Updating Adobe Indesign CC ,While I'm selecting text in a paragraph, the text disappears and this problem repeated several times before update everything was ok

    First, see Replace Your Preferences and do it for the original account.
    If that fails to solve the problem, rename the two Adobe folders that contain the prefs in the user profile for that account and copy the folders from the new account where it works. You want to be sure you copy the folders, rather than merge the contents, so you must rename the old folders first.

  • Having several problems with Adobe Premiere Elements 13.  Right now my worst is that when I add text to a clip, it goes out of "auto color" while the text is up.  Help?

    I'm having a number of problems with Elements 13.  One is that, while in "play" mode, the sound will just stop happening.  I have to click "pause" then "go" again and the sound comes back.  It also stops playing on it's own, I have to hit "play" repeatedly.  Just got the software, have been using it extensively for a week or two, and this just started happening.dor
    Now today, when I add text to a clip, it drops out of "auto color" while the text is visible in the clip, then back into auto color when the text is gone.  Any suggestiosn?

    nikovichb
    If we are looking at the same thing, you have called attention to one strange Premiere Elements 13 AutoColor/Titler interaction. This can be reproduced in the Expert or
    the Quick workspace. I will demo this in the Quick workspace since that is where you have been working.
    1. Import a still into the Quick workspace/Filmstrip.
    2. With the still selected, go to Adjust Tab/Adjustments Palette/Color Panel expanded and just click on the Auto Color Tab. Close the Adjust Tab route.
    3. Go to Text Menu/New Text/Default Text to open the project's Titler. When you do that you see the following and not the still over which the text title is to go.
    And when you close the Titler, you then see the "Add Text" text title in the still.
    The only solution that I can think of at this time is to create the text title and then apply the Auto Color to the still.
    It is interesting that this only happens with the Auto Color in the Color Panel selected. If you do not click on
    Color Panel and use the More options for Color adjustments, this behavior does not take place.
    Deletion of Adobe Premiere Elements Prefs file does not correct this situation.
    As for
    I'm having a number of problems with Elements 13.  One is that, while in "play" mode, the sound will just stop happening.  I have to click "pause" then "go" again and the sound comes back.  It also stops playing on it's own, I have to hit "play" repeatedly.  Just got the software, have been using it extensively for a week or two, and this just started happening.dor
    I think that here we need to explore project settings (project presets), properties of source media, and Timeline rendered and unrendered content prior to export.
    Please review the above
    a. verify if the Auto Color Text Title glitch that I saw is what you described in your situation
    b. give the details of your project so that we can explore cause and effect for Timeline content playback irregularities as seen in the Edit area monitor.
    Thanks.
    ATR

  • Numbers-Auto Generating a numbered list in a column of cells

    Having trouble creating an auto-generating numbered list in a single column. In text inspector I choose bullets>numbers>start at 1. The first cell is filled in with a "1", but when I hit return or down arrow the 1 disappears. If I go back and type a "1" again, two "1's" appear in the same cell. I'm trying to make a table with 250 rows. Not sure what I'm missing, as I'm new to iWork.

    Numbers can fill a column or row of cells with a pattern. Type the first two numbers in the first two cells, select both cells, then click on the small circle at the lower right of the second cells & drag down to fill however many cells you want. You can see in this picture that it works for other patterns, not just consecutive numbers. I've also used it to fill across month names or dates.

  • Text wrap effects text in different columns differently

    In InDesign CS4, if you have a 2-column text box and a graphic with a text wrap that spans from one column into another, the text wrap will offset the text in the two columns by different amounts if the graphic is aligned with the top of the text box. That shouldn't happen; the very same text wrap on the very same graphic should offset the text in the two columns by the same amount. But it doesn't. The baselines will not line up from column to column.
    Clearly you can get around this if you snap to a baseline grid. But what if you don't want to use baseline grid? Is there a way to get the text wrap to offset the text in both columns equally?
    I have attached a screen capture to demonstrate the problem. In this case, the baselines align, but the text wrap is clearly affecting the text in the left column and not affecting the text in the right column, even though they are aligned on the same baseline! Any suggestions?

    You're right, it shouldn't happen, but it's a long-standing bug (or feature).  One workaround is to use a baseline grid. Another is to adjust the wrap offset so that it matches the baseline in the opposite column. Another way is to not design so a wrapped object blocks the full width of one column but not it's neighbor. It doesn't matter where you have the wrapped object -- if it completely blockst the top of one column and leaves a any space at the top in an adjacent column where text will fit, you'll get the potential for unbalanced baselines.
    The reason it happens is that in a column where text can reach the top, the baseline for the first line is controlled byt he first baseline settings in the text frame options. If the text can't reach the top of the column the positioning is controlled by the depth of the object and any additional offset for the wrap.

  • I need to create a flyer which contains as example 33 lines of text in a column. All textlines have

    I need to create a flyer which contains as example 33 lines of text in a column. All textlines have to be underlined in a color. I tried this with „Absatzlinie darunter“ (might be „Paragraph line underneath“.
    The short-cut is „Command / Alt / J“, but nowhere I can see any information how to duplicate the underlines.
    By the way: I am a InDesign-Beginner; I used to work with QXP before for many years. Who can give me a hint – if possible in German? Thanks a lot!
    Dieter

    Guten Morgen!
    Zunächst herzlichen Dank für die Reaktion und die Tips. – Ich will da nicht
    nerven, aber ich bin erst seit kurzer Zeit mit InDesign zugange und stelle
    immer wieder fest, dass, je tiefer ich einsteigen will, immer mehr Fragen
    auftauchen. Es gibt auch so viele Begriffe, die sich von QuarkXPress
    unterscheiden, das ist ja furchtbar.
    Können wir vielleicht mal kurz direkt Kontakt über E-Mail aufnehmen? Auch
    mit dem Forum habe ich noch Probleme zurecht zu kommen. Ich würde gerne
    einen Screenshot senden, der mein "Problem" besser erkennen lässt.
    Schöne Grüsse
    Dieter Ullrich
    Von:  Willi Adelberger <[email protected]>
    Antworten an:  <[email protected]>
    Datum:  Mittwoch, 15. Januar 2014 20:34
    An:  Dieter Ullrich <[email protected]>
    Betreff:  I need to create a flyer which contains as example 33
    lines of text in a column. All textlines have
    Re: I need to create a flyer which contains as example 33 lines of text in
    a column. All textlines have
    created by Willi Adelberger
    <http://forums.adobe.com/people/Willi+Adelberger>  in InDesign - View the
    full discussion <http://forums.adobe.com/message/6016307#6016307>
    Wenn Du jede Zeile unterstreichen musst, dann sind Absatzlinien (Paragraph
    Rules) nicht dazu geeignet. Es gibt zwei Absatzlinien, eine unterhalb, eine
    oberhalb.Für das Unterstreichen aller Zeilen kann man nur die Auszeichnung
    „Unterstreichen” verwenden, das findest Du im Absatzformat unter
    „Grundlegende Zeichenformate” die Option „Unterstreichen”. Besser wäre es
    jedoch in der Absatzformatdefinition im Bereich ”´„Unterstreichungsoptionen”
    die EInstellungen vorzunehmen, weil dort feinere Einstellungen möglich sind
    und sogar zweifärbige Unterstriche möglich sind. Leider hat die
    Unterstreichungsfunktion gegenüber den Absatzlinien den Nachteil, dass
    Unterstreichungen nur unterhalb des Texts und unterhalb von Leerzeichen und
    Tabulatoren funktionieren, Absatzlinien können hingegen auch außerhalb de
    Rahmens angelegt werden und eine feste Länge bei allen Zeilen haben.
    Please note that the Adobe Forums do not accept email attachments. If you
    want to embed a screen image in your message please visit the thread in the
    forum to embed the image at http://forums.adobe.com/message/6016307#6016307
    Replies to this message go to everyone subscribed to this thread, not
    directly to the person who posted the message. To post a reply, either reply
    to this email or visit the message page:
    http://forums.adobe.com/message/6016307#6016307 To unsubscribe from this
    thread, please visit the message page at
    http://forums.adobe.com/message/6016307#6016307. In the Actions box on the
    right, click the Stop Email Notifications link.  Start a new discussion in
    InDesign at Adobe Community
    <http://forums.adobe.com/choose-container!input.jspa?contentType=1&container
    Type=14&container=3359>  For more information about maintaining your forum
    email notifications please go to
    http://forums.adobe.com/thread/416458?tstart=0.

  • Is there a way to Search (List search) for more then one field text from a column for Bulk uploading?

    I've been trying to find more information on this and I apologies if this has already been answered. I just don't know the correct way to ask this. We have a SharePoint List at the company that we have people input information into different columns. The
    problem is most of those information are very repetitive. Is there a way for me to search more then one field text in the column and just input that same information in?
    ex:
    Column 1
    Column 2
    Date:
    883851
    MidWest
    User input 
    8831518
    MidWest
    User input
    On the search field in the SharePoint List, I would need to search for 883851, 8831518 etc,  would view those requested numbers, then I would click edit and change dates to those rows. Does that make sense? I'm sorry I'm fairly new at sharepoint.

    I think what you're asking is about having repetitive options in a list, show up easily for new items being created.
    This can be done by setting the columns that contain repetitive information to Choice fields.  In the configuration of the Choice field, check the box for "Allow custom values".  Now as users are entering data into the list, the dropdown of options
    for a given field grows and users can quickly see and select previously entered and thus repetitive values for the given fields.
    I trust that answers your question...
    Thanks
    C
    |
    RSS |
    http://crayveon.com/blog |
    SharePoint Scripts | Twitter |
    Google+ | LinkedIn |
    Facebook | Quix Utilities for SharePoint

  • Displaying text in two columns in SAP Script

    Moved to correct forum.  Please use a meaningful subject in future - I've edited it for you this time.
    Hello Everybody,
    I have a text to be displayed in Scripts. I want to split the text into 2 columns.
    Like in news paper.
    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa   aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa   aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa   aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa   aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa   aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa   aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    Like this.
    Can someone tell me how to do that?
    Thanks,
    Edited by: Matt on Mar 11, 2009 4:31 PM

    As far as I believe....
    Always text flows out of the main window if it is completely filled.
    So, create an instance of the main window.
    Go to Page windows->Select the main window->Edit->Create
    You will get one more main window and that will be of type with the name Main01
    Go to Screen painter and adjust the window in the way that you required.
    Just start printing the text by writing the code in main00.
    Automatically main01 will have the same code assgined(you can check if you want) and the data gets displayed once the main 00 window is filled.
    Hope it helps....

  • How to Display  Formatted Text  IN ALV Column?

    HI experts ,
    I am displaying  ALV with Multiple Column's , One of the Column is TEXT(Fomatted text).
    When ALV is Displayed  TEXT Column Comes as Continues TEXT . and is Not Formatted .
    Now when i want to edit this text i am Calling another View  which contains text edit . This Text edit will display correct Formatted Text . but when i save it and Come back to ALV again i do see continues text .
    Is there  any way where in i can display  the Formatted text in ALV Column ?
    Any body have any clue with this ...
    Thanks in Advance
    Patil
    Edited by: Badarinarayan Patil on Feb 22, 2008 3:45 PM

    Hi Juergen,
    I found Your blog and found it  really interesting... though I was not able to use it: I (like Jun Li is asking, I guess) need to use a dynamic text, containing formatting informations (according the xhtml syntax).
    I tried to pass it to the form by an ABAP-dictionary based interface and by means of the context (in a webdynpro page), but both tries failed.
    Some suggestion will be greatly appreciated.
    Thankyou
    Simone

  • Set the css style of text in a column according to the value of another col

    I'd like to set the css style of text in a column according to the value of another column. Each field may end up with a different style of text as a result, for instance.
    Any ideas? I looked thru the forums but couldn't find anything.
    Thanks,
    Linda

    Does the class=”t7Header” make it into the rendered HTML?
    ---The text "class="tHeader" does not show but the other text is rendered using the style t7Header as defined in the stylesheet! Exactly what I wanted.
    You might want to use a div or a span instead of a p.
    ---Yes -
    What's very cool is we can create a display column that is dynamically filled with the html and style wrappers based on a lookup to see what style should be applied according to the actual data value. This is critical as our tables are all dynamic so I can't depend on using the additional APEX methods to control the display of a column (as the # of columns in the view vary from instance to instance) and I did not want the display specs to muddy up my SQL queries.
    I wonder why this is not well documented. It is so easy!
    Thanks again for your help.
    Linda

  • Parallel currency and Parallel ledger activation

    Dear all,
    In one of our client places, they have done the parallel currency and parallel ledger activation in the middle that is after 1 month of go live. Because of this they are not able to clear the already posted documents. When they  try to clear, all the documents are going to dump. Please suggest what has to be done.
    Thanks & Regards,

    Paralle ledger activation in the middle of the year is very dangerous for the previously posted open items.
    At the time of clearing system try to post the entries in the parallel ledgers. But parallel ledger not available in the previous postings.
    It will result adverse results in most of the transactions.Please check and take necessary action

  • Since upgrading to Lion USB devices no longer connect to my virtual machine in parallels despite my parallels settings.

    Since upgrading to Lion USB devices no longer connect to my virtual machine in parallels despite my parallels settings. As a result all usb devices show as networked drives from the mac. Therefore cannor access encrypted part of drive. Any ideas???

    I actually have the same problem, since I upgraded to Mavericks my MacBook Pro can't seem to find the Bose sounddock 10. Has anyone found a solution to this.
    It still works with the iPhone 5
    Thank you

  • I have never used PS, and I am trying to edit a brochure created by someone else.  I need to move text from one column to another

    I have never used PhotoShop and do not have time at the present. Please help me to move a section of text from one column to another in a brochure.

    Here are 3 options for future reference:
    1. With the setup you've described, apply a Match Move behavior to  the text and make the rectangle the source. Change the Transform parameter to Mimic source.  This way you can still adjust the text postion as needed, but the rectangle will drive the animation.
    2. Use a group to do the animation.  Put both your rectangle and text in the same group and animate the group's postion.
    3. Use the Link behavior.
    Each of these has it's advantages depending on what you need.

Maybe you are looking for

  • The Speaker phone option on my iPhone 4s is no longer working! Help!!

    The Speaker phone option on my iPhone 4s is no longer working.  Whenever I press the speakerphone button I can no longer hear anything and can not get back to the call.  I then must end the call in order to hear anything again.  Its not the actual fa

  • X-Fi Xtreme Music +

    Hi,I can't get my microphone to work on my X-Fi soundcard. It used?to work on my onboard soundcard, so it's definitely not broken.Now, i searched the forums here, and saw there are many problems with the mic and the X-Fi cards. I read something about

  • GNOME (Wayland) doesn't work correctly after resume

    I installed Wayland, GNOME and GDM on my laptop. When I resume and unlock laptop after supend GNOME log me out. EDIT: I'll add some logs: lut 09 23:55:57 adam-laptop gnome-session[353]: OK lut 09 23:55:57 adam-laptop gnome-session[353]: Received sign

  • How to the wireless mouse with IPad 2

    I bought the bluetooth wireless mouse for IPad, but unfortunately my IPad can't paired. Please assist

  • Advice on upgrading processor for HP A6010n (P5LP-LE Leonite MOtherboard)

    Hi i did some searching around and yes i did find some results but most of those were posted back in 2006 so i am sure there are many new products and information since then. I am currently attempting my first real pc rebuild and i am using my old Hp