Is Raid 50 Really safe?

I am interested in striping my to raid 5 arrays together to make 1 raid 50 (2.7 TB) array. My tech department was told by a top apple technician named keith (He supposedly designed much of the xserve raids design) that the raid 50 was not safe and that in the event of a drive failure all data would be lost. Is this true or is this top guy misinformed.
Thanks, Dylan

Ummm...
I'l sorta suspicious of a "top technician" who doesn't know much about RAID 50. Then again, RAID 50 indicates software RAID 0 on top of RAID 5, and the hardware guys don't strictly have to know about the OS that runs atop them, and what it can do.
RAID 50 is pretty safe. If you lose a drive on one of the sides (or, heck, a drive on both sides), you're fine. If you lose 2 drives on one side at the same time, you'll lose all the data on the array.
RAID 50 does have twice the risk of downtime, however. If a RAID controller goes offline, the whole array will become unavailable. As there are 2 controllers, there's twice the risk. Replace the controller, and you're back up and running without incident.
So it will double the chance of unexpected downtime, which is a relatively low percentage play anyway. But it doesn't really make data loss any more probable.

Similar Messages

  • Is it really safe to send such information? Please Help!

    Hi everyone,
    So, I'm "working" with an iPhone developer, who has already some apps selling on the App Store! I asked him, if he could get me a better icon of his Application for me. Then he answered me kindly, that he would be able to send me a personal preview release of the next release of the correspondent app.
    However, he asked me for an info: he wants me to send the iPhone ID (which is found, by clicking on the label 'serial number').
    So, is it really safe to send such information?
    Any help would be greatly appreciated!
    Francisco

    "Safe" is a relative term. However, short of waiting for the app to be released on the iTunes App Store, that's the only way to get a version of it. The three possible ways for distributing apps are 1) the App Store, 2) direct distribution within an Enterprise organization for internally-developed apps, and 3) limited sharing by a developer with a release tied to a device serial number.
    However, note that #3 may not always be possible, as reported for one developer in this linked article.
    To be honest, there's not too much a developer could do with your serial number, other than release the app to you, or perhaps report your iPhone as stolen (pretty unlikely, I think).

  • Is it really safe/secure to do online banking in private browsing using Wi-Fi?

    Is it really safe/secure to do online banking in private browsing using Wi-Fi with the https: and Firefox security blue or green on the left at the top?
    Is it safe/secure to check my banking/credit account online over the hotel wi-fi connection?
    Is it more secure if my laptop was connected with wire rather than using the wireless connection?

    Take a look at this:
    Firefox Helps You Stay Safe - Worried about online security? We’ve got your back
    * http://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/security/
    Its your decision to get on with it or not. I am just providing you some info. Check and tell if its working.

  • Is mac really safe from viruses

    Is mac really safe from viruses....

    There are no know viruses that can infect your Mac OS system at the present. You can still receive and sent Windows files that are infected to Windows users. (This can be either good or bad )
    Still any OS, including Mac, is open to Trojans which are malicious code that is disguised as something desirable. The latest being MacDefender, which Snow Leopard looks for and helps remove. http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4651

  • Is your JTable really SAFE ????????

    when I grab the right most column end of the table and drag it to the left
    something wierd happens...
    I get all these exceptions and the table becomes useless
    is there a way to block the user from making the size of the last column smaller by draging that column end to the left (Is it a bug in java????????)
    thx
    Exception occurred during event dispatching:
    java.lang.ArrayIndexOutOfBoundsException: 4 >= 4 /* my table has 4 columns*/
         at java.util.Vector.elementAt(Vector.java:417)
         at javax.swing.table.DefaultTableColumnModel.getColumn(DefaultTableColumnModel.java:276)
         at javax.swing.JTable.accommodateDelta(JTable.java:2187)
         at javax.swing.JTable.columnMarginChanged(JTable.java:2906)
         at javax.swing.table.DefaultTableColumnModel.fireColumnMarginChanged(DefaultTableColumnModel.java:581)
         at javax.swing.table.DefaultTableColumnModel.propertyChange(DefaultTableColumnModel.java:620)
         at javax.swing.event.SwingPropertyChangeSupport.firePropertyChange(SwingPropertyChangeSupport.java:153)
         at javax.swing.table.TableColumn.firePropertyChange(TableColumn.java:242)
         at javax.swing.table.TableColumn.firePropertyChange(TableColumn.java:248)
         at javax.swing.table.TableColumn.setWidth(TableColumn.java:475)
         at javax.swing.plaf.basic.BasicTableHeaderUI$MouseInputHandler.mouseDragged(BasicTableHeaderUI.java:133)
         at java.awt.AWTEventMulticaster.mouseDragged(AWTEventMulticaster.java:260)
         at java.awt.Component.processMouseMotionEvent(Component.java:3761)
         at javax.swing.JComponent.processMouseMotionEvent(JComponent.java:2377)
         at java.awt.Component.processEvent(Component.java:3550)
         at java.awt.Container.processEvent(Container.java:1167)
         at java.awt.Component.dispatchEventImpl(Component.java:2595)
         at java.awt.Container.dispatchEventImpl(Container.java:1216)
         at java.awt.Component.dispatchEvent(Component.java:2499)
         at java.awt.LightweightDispatcher.retargetMouseEvent(Container.java:2458)
         at java.awt.LightweightDispatcher.processMouseEvent(Container.java:2212)
         at java.awt.LightweightDispatcher.dispatchEvent(Container.java:2132)
         at java.awt.Container.dispatchEventImpl(Container.java:1203)
         at java.awt.Window.dispatchEventImpl(Window.java:918)
         at java.awt.Component.dispatchEvent(Component.java:2499)
         at java.awt.EventQueue.dispatchEvent(EventQueue.java:336)
         at java.awt.EventDispatchThread.pumpOneEventForHierarchy(EventDispatchThread.java:134)
         at java.awt.EventDispatchThread.pumpEventsForHierarchy(EventDispatchThread.java:101)
         at java.awt.EventDispatchThread.pumpEvents(EventDispatchThread.java:96)
         at java.awt.EventDispatchThread.run(EventDispatchThread.java:88)

    Ive taken some of the functions out but these are the relevant functions
    I think it happens on any table
    just drag the right most column seperator (the after the last column) to the left as if your trying to
    make the last column smaller by dragging its right end to the left
    and then watch what happens
    public class DraftsPanel extends JPanel
    private JScrollPane draftsScrollPanel = new JScrollPane();
    private DraftsTable draftsTable = new DraftsTable();
    public DraftsPanel()
    try
    jbInit();
    catch(Exception ex)
    ex.printStackTrace();
    void jbInit() throws Exception
    draftsScrollPanel.setBounds(new Rectangle(4, 4, 225, 171));
    draftsScrollPanel.setBorder(null);
    draftsScrollPanel.setFont(new java.awt.Font("SansSerif", 0, 10));
    draftsScrollPanel.setAutoscrolls(true);
    draftsScrollPanel.getViewport().setBackground(Color.white);
    this.setLayout(null);
    draftsTable.setFont(new java.awt.Font("SansSerif", 0, 10));
    this.setVisible(false);
    this.add(draftsScrollPanel, null);
    draftsScrollPanel.getViewport().add(draftsTable, null);
    draftsTable.setAutoResizeMode(JTable.AUTO_RESIZE_NEXT_COLUMN);
    draftsTable.setGridColor(new Color(177, 190, 255));
    draftsTable.setShowVerticalLines(false);
    this.add(draftsScrollPanel, null);
    public DraftsTable getDraftsTable()
    return draftsTable;
    public class DraftsTable extends JTable
    private DraftsTableModel draftsTableModel;
    public DraftsTable()
    try
    jbInit();
    catch(Exception ex)
    ex.printStackTrace();
    void jbInit() throws Exception
    draftsTableModel = new DraftsTableModel();
    setModel(draftsTableModel);
    this.setEnabled(true);
    getTableHeader().setFont(new java.awt.Font("SansSerif", 0, 10));
    public class DraftsTableModel extends AbstractTableModel implements TableModelListener
    private final String[] columnNames={"To","Subject","Composed"};
    private DraftsMessageVector draftsMessageVector = new DraftsMessageVector();
    private Object[][] data={};
    public static final int TO_COLUMN = 0;
    public static final int SUBJECT_COLUMN = 1;
    public static final int COMPOSED_COLUMN = 2;
    public DraftsTableModel()
    updateData();
    public int getColumnCount()
    return columnNames.length;
    public int getRowCount()
    return data.length;
    public String getColumnName(int col)
    return columnNames[col];
    public Object getValueAt(int row,int col)
    return data[row][col];
    public void setValueAt(String value,int row,int col)
    public void updateData()
    int dataLength = data.length;
    int messageVectorLength = draftsMessageVector.length();
    data = new Object[messageVectorLength][columnNames.length];
    try
    for(int i=0 ; i < messageVectorLength ; ++i)
    data[i][TO_COLUMN] = draftsMessageVector.getMessage(i).getDestination();
    data[i][SUBJECT_COLUMN] = draftsMessageVector.getMessage(i).getSubject();
    data[i][COMPOSED_COLUMN] = draftsMessageVector.getMessage(i).getDate();
    catch (Exception e)
    System.err.println(e.getMessage());
    finally
    try
    draftsMessageVector.saveToFile();
    fireTableRowsInserted(messageVectorLength-1,messageVectorLength-1);
    catch(Exception e)
    System.err.println(e.getMessage());
    public void tableChanged(TableModelEvent e)
    }

  • Is it safe to use the MBP in closed clamshell mode?

    I've connected my MBP to my LCD TV and started to use it as my desktop.
    I'm deactivating the main display of the MBP by putting it into sleep mode and moving my mouse, so it wakes the computer up and shows image only in the TV, keeping the main display turned off.
    I'm constantly monitoring the temperatures of the MBP with iStat Menus. It seems that the temperature is always the same, no matter if the main display lid is open or closed.
    So, based on these 2 articles:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3131
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1778
    Is it really safe to use the MBP with the display lid closed?
    If I decide to run a heavy load application (like a game) and the MBP starts to get warm, would it damage the display, because it is too close to the body of the MBP?

    Yes it's perfectly safe and designed to be used that way, 90% of the time this one's used in a similar configuration. The only time the fans come on 100% is when I watch Flash-based items from YouTube or similar. I've never run it for any extended length of time with the fans at maximum I must admit but as long as the air flow is good there shouldn't be any problem.

  • RAID Volume Directory

    I recently had a near melt down of an 8-disk RAID 5/0 volume. A G5 Mac running OS X Server 10.4.11 is the host.
    These are Seagate drives that were struck with Seagate's firmware bug.
    4 drives fell out of the volume, but after flashing all 8 drives in the RAID, 2 of the 4 failed drives came back. I have replaced the 2 drives that failed with new and the volume has rebuilt itself. Whew!
    I am maintaining 2 backups with Retrospect 8 and another nightly sync with Carbon Copy Cloner.
    Both Retrospect and Carbon Copy Cloner are reporting corruption with the same few files. These are unimportant files and deleting them is all I want to do. But I am unable to delete them.
    One file is an old copy of iPhoto. When I try to empty the Trash I receive a "files are in use" message.
    The other files are contained within a few deeply nested folders. When I click on those folders in the Finder they just disappear, however they do return by the next day. This folder disappearing is limited to these few folders. The rest of the RAID really seems to be healthy,
    I suspect directory corruption due to bad blocks/sectors on the media.
    I want to use Disk Utility to verify & repair the volume. I also want to use the HighPoint RAID tools to scan & map out the bad blocks on the media.
    And here is where I am not sure on how best to proceed. Which should I do first?

    I'd try deleting the files in Terminal. It doesn't care if the Finder thinks the file is busy. That might allow you to delete iPhoto anyway...
    After that, I'd probably try Disk Utility first, followed by the RAID Tools.

  • HT201272 Hi, My name is Angelina. I don't know how to download my old purchases that i bought from iTunes store. I lost all my music when i tried to update my iPhone. I feel really lost, and i really need my music back. Is there somebody who wants to help

    Hi,
    I really need some help, with my loved and lost musoc. I really need to get it back. I lost all my music after i trid to update my Iphone. Can anybody help me with this? Im really desperate and i really need som help with this. It would really safe my day!

    The article from which you came provides step-by-step instructions on re-downloading purchases. Where in those instructions are you encountering difficulty?

  • Is my flash drive safe?

    I have a flash drive that is not supposed to allow password protection or encryption. Somehow I did not know that. When I set up the drive, I right clicked on it and Mavericks allowed me to encrypt it with a password. When I insert the drive into the USB on my iMac, it always asks for my password. I talked with the manufacturer of the flash drive who was baffled how Mavericks overrode its software to allow for the use of a password. I'm baffled myself. Does anyone know how this might have happened? Is this flash drive really safe?
    I plugged the drive in to a Windows computer just to see what would happen, and it did not recognize the drive at all. Is this because it was formatted for an Apple computer?
    Should I erase this drive and move on to a safe one, or should it be all right?

    There isn't a storage device in the world that can prevent a user from password protecting the data on it. In your case, you used FileVault, but you could also use various apps to password protect a compressed archive, such as a .zip file that requires a password to open it after being created.
    I talked with the manufacturer of the flash drive who was baffled how Mavericks overrode its software to allow for the use of a password.
    Whatever software they included with the drive was wiped out as soon as you reformatted it for use with a Mac. Not sure why that would confuse them. There would be nothing to stop a Windows users who didn't reformat the drive to encrypt the data fully, or selectively either. Sounds like the manufacturer doesn't understand the basics or writing data to a drive, as hard as that would seem to believe.
    As Barney said, Windows didn't recognize the drive because it's now formatted as Mac OS Extended, which Windows cannot read without installing third party software.
    There's nothing wrong with the drive the way you have it. There's no need to erase it.
    Don't be overly concerned about the BBC article notcloudy was referring to. It takes deep knowledge of, and the ability to write data to the embedded EEPROM of the flash drive to do what he noted. It can't happen by simply plugging it into a computer.

  • CoolBook: Is it effective? Is it safe?

    My MBP (2.33 GHz, Core2Duo) gets extremely hot. Following Apple discussions, it maybe normal. Normal but hot, especially the left part. I have heard about CoolBook, and am getting tempted to use it. However, a small question mark has entered my head. Namely, if the solution is so simple, and so very cheap, why was not it simply adopted by Apple? I guess Apple engineers were looking for the best working conditions, and thus, even if CoolBook is apparently effective, is it really safe to use it in the long run?
    Rμν - ½gμνR = 8πGTμν

    Is your computer not working? If it's just hot, I wouldn't use this. Notice that Apple refers to these are notebooks, not LAPtops. Don't touch bare skin with them.
    They're made of aluminum to help disperse the heat, so they are going to get very warm. But messing with internals with software is something I wouldn't recommend if you don't know what you are doing.

  • Raid Battery issues....

    I keep getting a warning for my Raid battery...saying write cache temp. disabled due ti insufficient battery charge.....Restarting does nothinng...Leaving system on for 72hours does nothing......

    Does this RAID enclosure have a Battery itself that needs replacing, or is it the Mac's Battery? Is there a UPS involved?
    a hardware RAID controller may carry a dedicated battery-powered write-back cache of its own, thereby allowing for efficient operation that is also relatively safe. Fortunately, it is possible to avoid such problems with a software controller by constructing a RAID with safer components; for instance, each drive could have its own battery or capacitor on its own write-back cache, and the drive could implement atomicity in various ways, and the entire RAID or computing system could be powered by a UPS, etc.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAID
    Mac Pro Raid Card - Battery issues...
    http://www.mac-forums.com/forums/other-hardware-peripherals/157895-mac-pro-raid- card-battery-issues.html
    The RAID card reconditions its battery from time-to-time. During the interval when the battery is discharged, it may report that the RAID cache is disabled (and you are enduring longer writes because of that). It should charge up and start using the write cache again within a few hours.
    https://discussions.apple.com/thread/2684029?start=0&tstart=0

  • Is System.arraycopy thread safe?

    I found many IO Servers use this method to perform underlying data copy, but it is really safe to use it in such environment?
    please help!

    what do you mean by, 'would it help'? Help thread safety? No. The method returns quicker because it is native, but it does not impact thread safety (unless you consider a quicker return to some how increase thread safety).

  • Max safe CPU Voltage?

    I am in the middle of OC'ing my system.  So far I am doing pretty good.  I can get up to 252 clock generator x 9.5X CPU multiplier at 4X HT multiplier.  (I currently got my memory at 133 3-6-6-11: I'll tweak this a little bit later.)
    To get this I have my CPU Voltage at 1.7V.  Running Prime95 with option #2, I can keep my CPU temp below 55C.
    My question is, is this voltage too high?  I understand that voltage will raise the temperature, and that it will decrease the life expectancy some, but is there some other problem?  Is this really safe?  Or should I reduce the voltage?https://forum-en.msi.com/images/msi/smilies/confused2.gif

    Increasing Vcore increases the gate voltage on the transistors inside which lowers the on resistance allowing the transistors to drive their signal lines harder and thus faster. Increasing Vcore also means the signal lines need to swing farther (voltage wise) than they did before. As you continue to increase Vcore the on resistance of the transistors improves less and less as other limiting factors in the transistor take over, however the signal lines still need to swing more and more as vcore goes up. It's like being able to speed a runner in a race up, but when you do the race also gets longer. At some point the runner is going as fast as he can but the race keeps getting longer so it actually takes him longer to finish.
    You want to find that sweet spot where he finishes the race the quickest.
    The other problem with increasing Vcore is increasing the temperature of the die because of all the heat generated. The hotter it gets, the more the asphalt melts and the slower the runner will go. You don't want it to get to hot or things slow down.
    Increased Vcore also brings a pair of failure mechanisms with it, one is just that the heat can't be removed quickly enough and when the silicon gets hot enough the currents from thermally generated carriers cause a runaway condition and the chip just melts down. This happens fast.
    The slow failure mechanism is electromigration, where the currents are so high in the metal interconnect wires on the die that the metal starts to flow. Eventually the wires break. This happens slowly.
    Always use the lowest Vcore you can that will give you the performance you want. In other words, err on the low side.

  • SATA or PATA hdd ??

    Hi,
    I´m planning a hdd upgrade and are a bit unsure what to choose between sata and pata disks.
    Up until now I´ve preffered pata disks of several reasons but more and more of high performance hdd are running sata, so my question;
    Will I loose any OC capability when running sata disks ?
    Will I be able to run the sata disk at same FSB as my PATA ( at least 240-250fsb) without datacorruption, assuming I lock AGP/PCI to 66/33 ????
    Is there any other issues involved when talking OC with sata disks on MSI 865pe boards ( No raid) .
    Thanks for comments and input.

    But, Maesus, like Danny said that he only can go to around 230?
    And if I'm not wrong, many users using SATA (1 or 2 which from ICH5) also reported can go only around 230. But this problem goes when they tried to use SATA 3 or 4 (which from 3rd party).
    But my board is only standard "P", so my board only have SATA 1 and 2 (from ICH5).
    Is it really safe to OC more than FSB 230 with SATA HDD? (as maybe my local store will not accept RMA for HDD only because it's limiting my OC   )
    Thanx.
    nb: I think I really need new HDD, as mine is so slow on loading. My system is very fast when working only with RAM (app have loaded) + CPU, and become faster after overclocked... but when loading big application at first... fiuhh, I don't feel the speed at all...  

  • GetParameter()==NULL and memory

    Hi everybody !
    I'm creating a web site where users will be able to plot data from a database.
    So, I've an HTML code which call a PHP one which himself get data from database and create an JAVA applet on the following model :
    echo "<APPLET\n";
    echo "<PARAM NAME=\"valeur\" VALUE=\"".$string."\">\n";
    echo "</APPLET>\n";where $string is like "time1%data1@time2%data2@...."
    Then I get this string value in the JAVA applet with :
    String[] res = getParameter("valeur").split("@");But for too huge data size the getParameter return a NULL value as PHP hadn't create the associated param value.
    Does someone have an idea to explain such behaviour ?
    Thanks !

    nodules wrote:
    ..in that case I'll have to execute the query in the applet, and so, on the client side which is not really safe, isn't it ?In my suggestion I think the answer is 'yes'.
    .. Since I'll have to export password, etc on the client side ...Which is why ejp (who knows far more about remote access to DBs) added..
    ..or have it perform an HTTP request of its own ..Which I think means to have the applet connect to (for example) a servlet that does the query. The servlet would not expose the password or location of the database, and might do other checks (like that the user is actually allowed to delete every record). ;)

Maybe you are looking for

  • Error Message, possibly related to recent upgrade

    Keep getting this error message =>This file was created using a previous version of Edge Animate. This file will be automatically upgraded and saved with the suffix 'upgraded'. - After clicking "ok" This error message appears => An error occurred whi

  • Ipod touch recorded video choppy when watch on my PC

    When I try to watch recorded videos on my PC they are extremly choppy. I have tried to watch in Quick time but the color is off and no sound. When I try to watch in picasa it is too choppy/jerky to watch with no sound. How can I watch my recorded vid

  • Getting following msgs in alert log repeatedly

    I am getting the following msgs in the alert log repeatedly.Please help me in understanding as to why this is happening as none of the commands have been executed by the user. Oracle 10g Rel. 10.2.0.4.0 AIX 5.6 Content from alert log: Tue Dec 13 11:1

  • Photoshop video frames to layer is not working on windows PC

    Hi, I am using photoshop CC and it says video (It does not support video on this version of windows. I am using windows 8 32bit, 8gb ram, i7 equlent AMD 64 bit processor, 1gb graphics card. Please help me to fix this issue. Thank you

  • Help with replacing an Adobe XI with an older version on Windows8

    I have Windows 8, Adobe Export PDF (which is an essential for me), and Adobe Reader XI. An online course that I am taking requires that I uninstall Adobe XI, and replace it with an older version (10.1.4?) in order to access class online textbooks. I