MacBook verse MacBook Pro - Which one to buy?

So after reading the specs on both the MacBook and Pro the only differences are:
1. Bigger Screen
2. More Video Ram
3. Backlight Keyboard
I will use the Machine to develp websites on, do MS Office, and Surf the Web, run Parallels Desktop for some Windows suff and perhaps a game every so often.
So my question is - is the MBP really worh ~1000K increase in price?
Thoughts?
MacPro 3Ghz   Mac OS X (10.4.8)  

I own both. A first gen MBP 1.83 with 1.5gig of RAM and a brand new C2D Blackbook with 2gigs of RAM and a 200gig HD.
They are 2 completely different beasts. I was using my MBP as my main machine since I got it in March, or whenever they first shipped. It's a beautiful notebook, I still smile everytime I open it. But for traveling and running around all day, it just didn't cut it unless you are very careful with it. Which I couldn't always be. It got a few dents in it, and I felt bad about that. To grab the unit by the corner and move to another lab, the machine just felt to heavy for that. It was to big and cumbersome and to nice for the use I was giving it.
So I bought the Macbook. The subjective 'feel' of the machine isn't that of the MBP, but the keyboard is nice (I still love the backlight of the powerbooks though) and the machine is nice and fast and pretty and does everything I want it to during my daily travels. Others will tell you that the .4lbs and 1.25 inches or whatever it is don't make that much of a difference. I disagree. The Macbook feels like a much more compact machine. Maybe its the color.
Any both machines run windows, the MBP in Boot Camp, the Macbook in Parallels and both do a stand up job. My MBP is now my stay at home or coffee house machine, used when I have to read and go through several hundred pages of text or financial reports. Or the occasional game or Photoediting. The Macbook is with me on my everyday travels, doing the leg work, the backpack duty.
Just my thoughts, others will vary, but I hope it does help in some way.

Similar Messages

  • Considering buying MacBook or MacBook Pro--which one?

    Hello,
    I am thinking of buying a new computer. I'm university-affiliated, and can get the 13" MacBook for $900, and the 13" MacBook Pro for $1100. It looks like the specs are similar on both as far as HD size, RAM, etc. The main differences seem to be the processors (2.13GHz on the white one vs. 2.26GHz on the aluminum), and the FireWire ports (400 v. 800). Anybody have any thoughts on whether the Pro is worth $200 more? Do either of these machines have some potential known issues? (For example, I have an iBook G3 that has the black screen issue, which seems to be well-known.) I don't do a lot of heavy-duty graphics or anything like that, but I like to have a decent computer.
    A follow up question is this: The apple care protection plan is an extra $183 for either computer. It's my impression that this is the same as the computer's 1-year warranty, just extended to 3 years. If one buys on AMEX, the warranty is doubled by the card to 2 years. So is a third year worth $183? Aren't any problems likely to occur by the end of the 2nd year? (If I'm understanding this incorrectly, feel free to correct me.)
    Thanks a lot in advance!
    Anna

    The Pro is absolutely worth the money.
    I don't know if this has changed with the current revision of white MacBooks, but my machine (a late-2007) is quite susceptible to scuffs, scratches & chips. I don't have a case on it--which probably would have helped!--but this computer isn't as robust as my iBook G4 or my friend's older PowerBook. I've also noticed that my MacBook runs hotter than his MacBook Pro, but that may be due to different hardware components in each machine (his Pro is newer than my computer).
    As for the warranty, it's up to you. I've never purchased Apple Care and all of my Apple products have lasted 5 or more years without issues (aside from a hard drive crash on my iBook within its first year). Do keep in mind that phone support is free with the extended warranty--this would come in handy if you live far from an Apple store.
    And if you want to be safe, get Apple Care for that 3rd year--$183 will more than cover even 1 repair by Apple.
    ~Lyssa

  • Hi, I want to buy a Macbook Pro, which one is the best for...

    Hi, I'm currently studying graphic design... Besides using Adobe collection like Ai, Ps, Dw, Fl, etc., I'm beginning to use After effects, Final Cut, Cinema 4D, basically stuff for audio&video, 3D modelling.. So I'm looking for a Macbook Pro to buy, that allows me to use all those heavy (file size, visual effects) programms.. which do you recommend for me?

    High res-anti-glare 15" or 17" with the top end video card, scores 45 points on Cinebench, which is very impressive for a laptop, about half as fast as the fasest current Windows towers.
    That most certainly will do the job.
    The 17" hight res/anti-glare as the ability to display 1920 x 1080 (1080i HD) on it's 1920 x 1200 pixel screen in actual resolution.
    I've got the Early 2011 MPB and I can run a 3D animated screen saver as my desktop all the time, it's a real workstation type machine in a laptop, very very impressive machine.

  • I'm debating between a Macbook Air or a Macbook Pro which one would you suggest?

    I'm debating between a Macbook Air (MC965LL/A) or a Macbook Pro (MD313LL/A) which one would you suggest?
    I will be using this for college and taking it to class with me.  My biggest fear is that I may be too hard on the Air and damage it, but I like that it is lighter and looks cooler.  But which one do you believe is more logical and provides the best computer quality overall?

    This is an objective comparison,
    Meanwhile, we start from the price of their basic models, considering of course that could get discounts as a student in the Education Store. Required about 100 € more to buy an Air with the same screen size of this Pro and already, in some cases, may be enough to make your own choice.
    Assuming a score to score, we could say: Pro 1 - 0 Air
    Until recently, the beloved laptop for school purposes was the white MacBook.Orphaned "bianchino", now out of the list for some time now Apple, the Mac that is most on the economic front is approaching the Air 11 "(900 € on the edu store). Air 13 "display offers a native that could be called HiRes, identical resolution to that of Pro 15" base:
    Air 11 "(16:9) 1366 x 768 = 1,049,088 pixels
    Pro 13 "(16:10 format) 1280 x 800 = 1,024,000 pixels
    Air 13 "(16:10 format) 1440 x 900 = 1,296,000 pixels
    The comparison on the screens is not to be taken seriously. After all, is what we will see during every second of computer work.
    And so the challenge back in a tie: Pro 1 - Air 1
    For size and weight comparison is merciless. The Pro is a portable slim, well built and, after all, not too heavy. However, this aspect of the Air is unsurpassed. He created a new category of laptops is so small wonder. The weight is also almost halved with 1.3 kg against 2Kg. For those who are always on the go is a godsend for the university and also the difference in the shoulder is remarkable.
    We update our score: Pro 1 - Air 2
    The battery is offered in both cases with a duration of 7 hours. 2-Air Pro 3. Another aspect that is rather in favor of a tie on the graphics: Both models use the Intel HD Graphics 3000 with 384MB of DDR3 SDRAM condivisa.Pro 3 - Air 4.
    In academia, it may not feel quite the need for a Firewire port, but the fact remains that the Air does not have it.
    I guess that's the case to score another point: Pro 4 - 5 Air
    I scored a little more than necessary to have a complete line of Air, but for the purposes of this comparison we are interested in the value obtained from the Pro 13 'Air base and 13 "base. Both processors are dual core and, as you can see, the little guy gets along very well though with a slower clock. There is also a crucial aspect to consider: these data refer to the computing power but do not take into account the incredible speed-bump-up by SSD. Translated into monetary terms means that if the Pro 13 "is marginally faster when the CPU is under stress (such as video encoding) Air 13" is significantly more responsive in every area. By now you will present the advantages of SSD, as we talk about it constantly, and be assured that we are talking about really obvious differences in the everyday. The advantages obtained clearly outweigh the disadvantage resulting from a delay of a few seconds more in exporting an iMovie or a few seconds to compress a full-bodied zip file (which then increased the write speed scale in part). To assign a score in this area I find then a little 'in difficulty. From the viewpoint of the CPU Pro 13 "is slightly faster but we are sure you can assign an advantage when then every single operation, to start since, requires up to 8 times (the value is clearly approximate) of the time ' Air 11 "? I have no doubt to say that overall performance on the front of the Pro 13 "basis, as configured, is beaten hands down Air 13" base.
    I say then: Pro 4 - Air 6 (but wait ... is not over)
    Do you know where the above discussion decade? The MacBook Pro is much more expandable: add just € 77 and takes a 60GB OCZ Agility SATA3 that mounts in an instant. At that point, the bill draws on the opposite reactivity with SSD and the difference of the processor, though not so obvious, back to bite. It is also possible to realize different combinations. We have spoken of a disk of only 60GB in effect, but in the Pro can also be used as an adapter to enter the optibay the HDD of 320GB in place of the original SuperDrive. In this way we obtain the speed of the solid disc for the operating system and applications and the increased capacity of a traditional hard drive for archiving. Also, the RAM, which base is 4GB on both, on the Pro can be easily increased to 8GB. To want to do things right we should say that the added cost rises well and lose the initial assumption for which we have assigned a point to Pro for the greater economy.Furthermore, the comparison is based, only the basic models, however, the counter remains a valuable expandability, both now and in the future: if after some time you should decide to improve the performance of your Mac, is with the Aircan only change SSD (mSATA but those are expensive), while the Pro will have more flexibility.
    u point for the Pro: Pro 5 - 6 Air
    With the 2011 version of the MacBook Air has resumed the backlit keyboard, but still (and will) not have an Ethernet port, Superdrive and the infrared receiver. The absence of the reader / writer is a point against him, this is indisputable
    equal footing Pro 6 - Air 6. As Apple moves fast towards a future where this will no longer be necessary (see installation and operating system software via the web) can still be useful today. It must be said that with less than 30 € you take an external drive efficiently (review) but this still requires to carry around another "element". On a personal level each of us will be evaluated differently this absence, there are those who do not tolerate it and who has already got used to (in extreme cases supported by the Remote Disk feature) but it is still a lack of perspective in a single complete computer , at least at present.
    For this reason we say: Pro 7 - 6 Air
    pull the money (or better scores ) won the pro of a single point.
    i hope it can help you ti choose
    Francesco

  • Two graphics card on macbook pro which one do I use?

    I have two graphics cards on my macbook pro. ADM random 6490m (256mb vram) and Intel HD graphics 3000 (512mb vram). My question is which one should I use? I don't do any hardcore gaming or photoshop. I guess that I am just looking for the best display and least buffering if that even has anything to do with the graphics card. I just want to get the most out of my macbook. I appreciate any advice. Thank you.

    Your MBP more or less chooses which graphics card to use automatically.  In System Preferences>Energy Saver, check Automatic graphics switching.  When it's checked on, it will use the higher power and higher quality dedicated AMD 6490 when you're plugged into the wall, and uses the Intel 3000HD when on battery.
    I have downloaded gfxCardStatus to give me more control over which graphics card to use.  There are times I might want the AMD while on battery, even though it runs hotter and uses more battery life. 
    Either card will do well with HD movies, though I notice a lot more artifacts with the Intel 3000 when the movie has a lot of action or explosions or sounds.  If you want to do hardcore gaming, you need the AMD of course.  Photoshop is more dependent on the central processor rather than the graphics card, so I'm not sure you'd have much issue using either one.

  • VMWare running on a MacBook Pro.Which one ?, VMWare running on a MacBook Pro.Which one ?

    Good morning people !
    I currently have a MacBook Pro 15" Duo core 2008 model running the latest OSX.
    I need to have Windows on my machine because of the accounts software, currently I am using VM Ware Fusion 3.
    My machine has really slowed down now and I think it is time for a new MacBook Pro.
    I know that the new processors are available on the 13" in i5 and i7, and the 15" has a quad core i7.
    I do not at present use iMovie although I may get into it later on. I have CS Suite 5 for Dreamweaver and Photoshop.
    My question is, as I am running a virtual machine most of the time and I need it on most of the time too, would you recommend an i5 processor or the i7 quad core for doing the sort of work I do (no gaming at all)
    I can either buy a new i5 13" or a better spec Early 2011 model i7.
    Views please....

    Thanks Sig
    I have now ordered an 15" MacBook Pro quad core i7.
    Will upgrade the RAM ASAP.

  • Tiger upgrade on MacBook Pro, which one?

    I have a 15" MacBook Pro (2.2 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo) running Tiger (OS10.4.11) that I just got off of eBay. It has 2 GB 667 MHz DDR2 SDRAM.  Would like to upgrade the OS to the latest version it can run.  What OS can run on this machine & how do I proceed?

    Mac OS X 10.8.2. Phone the online Apple Store, order a Mac OS X 10.6 DVD, run Software Update, and then get 10.8 from the Mac App Store.
    (71163)

  • Macbook Pro, Which one?

    ok, this is going to be my third time asking this question, but I finally made my mind up.
    I am choosing between the 13" models because All im going to be doing is surfing the web, taking notes, youtube, and email. but I will be using iMovie every now n then for youtube videos. Im thinking that the Base 13" model will be fine, but I want your opinions, I want to save money!

    Based on what you said you're going to do I will suggest you just buy a 13" Macbook Air. I had a 13" MBP myself and I ended up selling it to a friend because I didn't really feel like it was the right computer for me.  My use of it is near verbatim what you said yours would be, minus iMovie. I've never been happier with a laptop, and I'm only using a high-end 11" MBA.
    The one advantage I can see is that the MBP would allow you a certain level of expandability but again, based on your description of what you want to do with it, I don't think you need to go Pro.

  • Macbook/Macbook Pro Which One?

    Hello, I didnt know which topic to put this under so sorry for that. I am a high school student looking to get a new mac laptop. The decision is now MB or MBP. I dabble in video (nothing serious) and do digital photography with photoshop. I plan to install Vista via Parallels or Bootcamp in the future for whatever reason. I realize the graphics card in the MB is integrated and that is the main point of my indecision. Also how much RAM do you recommend for my uses? Thanks al lot

    Get as much RAM as you can afford. Also, I owned a MB and upgraded to a MBP because of the weaker graphics circuit. My fan ran a lot on the MB. The MBP is real quiet. IMHO...I think a MBP is a much better value--especially if you get the educational discount. You will have a larger screen/resolution, processor and hard drive, along with better sound quality, backlit keyboard and FireWire 800.
    -Bmer
    Mac Owners Support Group
    Join Us @ MacOSG.com
    iTunes: MacOSG Podcast
     An Apple User Group 

  • TS1544 I am the administrator of my MacBook Pro, which I share with my kids. One of them forgot his password, so as the admin I changed it for his account, but  when I try to see his account, it says I need to provide the keychain password. How can i get

    I am the administrator of my MacBook Pro, which I share with my kids. One of them forgot his password, so as the admin I changed it for his account, but  when I try to see his account, it says I need to provide the keychain password. How can i get it? I have no idea how to sort this out...

    First, make sure caps lock is not on.
    You must back up all data before continuing, unless you've already done so. If you need to back up but can't log in, ask for instructions.
    If the user account is associated with an Apple ID, and you know the Apple ID password, then maybe the Apple ID can be used to reset your user account password.
    Otherwise*, boot into Recovery mode. When the OS X Utilities screen appears, select
    Utilities ▹ Terminal
    from the menu bar. In the Terminal window, type this:
    res
    Press the tab key. The partial command you typed will automatically be completed to this:
    resetpassword
    Press return. A Reset Password window opens.
    Select your boot volume ("Macintosh HD," unless you gave it a different name) if not already selected.
    Select your username from the menu labeled Select the user account if not already selected.
    Follow the prompts to reset the password. It's safest to choose a password that includes only the characters a-z, A-Z, and 0-9.
    Select
     ▹ Restart
    from the menu bar.
    You should now be able to log in with the new password, but your Keychain will be reset (empty.) If you've forgotten the Keychain password (which is ordinarily the same as your login password), there's no way to recover it.
    *Note: If you've activated FileVault, this procedure doesn't apply. Follow instead the instructions on this page:
    If you forget the password and FileVault is on

  • Hello, I have a Macbook pro which runs under 10.5.8. I want to use a PC interface. been told I need to purchase paralellDestop 6, Windows & Microsoft 2008licence?

    Hello, I have a Macbook pro which runs under 10.5.8. I want to use a PC interface. I've been told I need to purchase paralell Destop 6, Windows licence and Microsoft Office 2008 for PC. Is that correct ?

    If you have a MacBook Pro with 10.5, that's usually a machine that's getting long in the tooth and thus running Windows as a virtual machine (one OS inside another) will likely be slow.
    Also spending all that money for Windows (VirtualBox is free) and Office seems like almost a waste of effort if the machine is going to die suddenly.
    MacBook Pro's last about 4-5 years.
    To do what you want your going to have to upgrade OS X to 10.6, then either buy VMFusion or Parallels which they are now catering to 10.7 and 10.8 users, so it's slow on 10.6, or use the free VirtualBox which will run well on 10.6. Then buy a copy of Windows 7 as earlier Windows versions are not being sold, then Office 11 or whatever.
    You can also install OfficeMac into 10.6, if they still sell a copy.
    You see your outdated really, and anything that can work is soon to be ignored etc.
    What I would consider doing instead, since your not a OS upgrade type of person (we are on 10.8 now which won't run on your machine or be extremely slow) is to buy yourself a decent Windows 7 laptop and install Office into that. Some have the demo already inside and all you have to do is activate it.
    This way you get your Windows experience and Office experience, don't have to fiddle with complicated virtual machine software, or Apple's problematic Bootcamp etc as Apple really is leaving 10.5 and 10.6 users behind, and by next summer will be leaving 10.7 users behind too.
    Windows 7 laptop will be the cheapest and least stressful option for you, you can continue to use the Mac until it drops dead of course.
    I say this because your on 10.5, your like most computer users, just a computer user and not a geek.
    You obviously have some reason you need Office, likely for a job or school and since 99% use Windows and Office, then that's what you should be using.
    If your only needing Office or Office like program for something temporary, then I suggest you install the free LibreOffice into OS X, however I don't know if it will run in 10.5, you might have to upgrade to 10.6 via the 10.6.3 white retail disk, however Apple doesn't sell it anymore, but perhaps Amazon or elsewhere does.
    Sorry, you have been out of the upgrade loop for quite some time, so a new machine is in order as that one is about to die soon, so I wouldn't be spending too much on it really.
    If you have a fat wallet you can buy a new Mac with 10.8, and have Windows 7 installed in BootCamp (direct boot) and also into VMFusion or Parallels (copies the Bootcamp Windows so you can use both) and Office for you. It will come all set up, enter your password and use the machine.
    I think OtherWorld Computing will sell you a pre-configured Mac all set up like that for you, Apple won't do it though.
    You can also pay a local PC/Mac specialist to do the same.
    Don't forget setting up a backup system for both Windows and OS X, add anti-malware software in Windows, you'll need that.
    IMO a new Windows 7 laptop would be the cheaper, less stressful option, Learning Bootcamp and virtual machine software can be a pain if your not computer savvy, al;so Apple has a nasty habit of upgrading the operating system constantly, now on a annual basis. You don't upgrade and all your third party software, then your denied security updates in short order. Windows 7 laptop will last a decade on the same version, only needing simple updates, not upgrades.
    If you want your Windows machine to last even longer, like a decade, then get a desktop tower instead of a laptop.
    Mac's are for those who can handle a lot of change, as Apple is about always inflicting change.  It's costly change too.
    Good Luck
    Windows in BootCamp or Virtual Machine?
    Things to consider before upgrading OS X

  • What are the different ways to back up your photos from iphoto using a MacBook Pro which does not have a disk drive?

    What are the different ways to back up your photos from iphoto using a MacBook Pro which does not have a disk drive?

    Note - that no internet backup service has been proven to be safe and effective for backing up the iPhoto library - unless you personally have backup uyp an iPhoto library and restored it sucussfuly form one it should not be recommended - a large number of people have lost their photos trying it
    LN

  • I want to install OS X Mavericks on my MacBook Pro which is not with guid partition table

    i want to install OS X Mavericks on my MacBook Pro which had both mountain lion & windows 8.1, its not in GUID partition table format, so i couldnt install mavericks, so is there any way to change into GUID partition table format & install Mavericks  without losing Windows from my hard disk ?

    Open the App Store and upgrade iPhoto to the Mavericks version.
    iWork and iLife for Mac come free with every new Mac purchase. Existing users running Mavericks can update their apps for free from the Mac App Store℠. iWork and iLife for iOS are available for free from the App Store℠ for any new device running iOS 7, and are also available as free updates for existing users. GarageBand for Mac and iOS are free for all OS X Mavericks and iOS 7 users. Additional GarageBand instruments and sounds are available for a one-time in-app purchase of $4.99 for each platform.
    The iWork apps are free with a new iOS device since 1 SEP 2013. They are free with a new Mac since 1 OCT 2013. They are also free with the upgrade to OS X Mavericks 10.9 if you had the previous version installed when you upgraded.

  • Transferred backed-up data from external hard disk to new hard drive on my MacBook Pro which seemed to be successful. I now find that some (or maybe all) old emails have been resent. Can anyone tell me what has happened?

    Transferred backed-up data from external hard disk to new hard drive on my MacBook Pro which seemed to be successful. I now find that some (or maybe all) old emails have been resent. Can anyone tell me what has happened?

    Greetings,
    I've never seen this issue, and I handle many iPads, of all versions. WiFi issues are generally local to the WiFi router - they are not all of the same quality, range, immunity to interference, etc. You have distance, building construction, and the biggie - interference.
    At home, I use Apple routers, and have no issues with any of my WiFi enabled devices, computers, mobile devices, etc - even the lowly PeeCees. I have locations where I have Juniper Networks, as well as Aruba, and a few Netgears - all of them work as they should.
    The cheaper routers, Linksys, D-Link, Seimens home units, and many other no name devices have caused issues of various kinds, and even connectivity.
    I have no idea what Starbucks uses, but I always have a good connection, and I go there nearly every morning and get some work done, as well as play.
    You could try changing channels, 2.4 to 5 Gigs, changing locations of the router. I have had to do all of these at one time or another over the many years that I have been a Network Engineer.
    Good Luck - Cheers,
    M.

  • HT201343 I just verified that i have an early 2011 Macbook Pro and the airplay icon does not appear.  i also have a 2013 Macbook Pro which shows the airplay icon.  do i need to enable airplay on my early 2011 or is there an update that is needed?  Confuse

    I just verified that i have an early 2011 Macbook Pro and the airplay icon does not appear.  i also have a 2013 Macbook Pro which shows the airplay icon.  do i need to enable airplay on my early 2011 or is there an update that is needed?  Confused.

    To check your model go to About This Mac (by clicking on the Apple icon, top left) and then select more info. If you wish to use mirroring you will need one from 2011 or later running OSX 10.8 or later. The alternative would be to use 3rd party software like Airparrot.
    About AirPlay Mirroring in OS X

Maybe you are looking for