Mixed environment migration (OCS\Lync 2010 to Lync 2013) retaining BES Integration

Hi All,
I have an existing OCS 2007R2 and Lync 2010 environment which contains BES Collaboration for Enterprise IM on Blackberry devices. I want to migrate this environment to Lync 2013 whilst retaining the BES integration. Understanding that tri-existence is not supported
I've been going through the process of decommissioning all of my legacy OCS servers, which I have now completed, in readiness for starting the Lync 2013 deployment and prepping AD. 
Here's my issue - The BES collaboration service was integrating with an old OCS CWA server. I removed the CWA server and migrated the Collaboration service to a new server so that I could configure it to directly communicate directly with the Lync 2010 pool,
however I still needed to install OCS components on the new server in order to achieve that integration. Now I've run the final step of Merging the OCS 2007R2 Topology with the Lync 2010 topology in preparation for deleting the BackCompatSite, the old OCS
servers have gone, but the new Collaboration server has now appeared as a trusted application server within the BackCompatSite. I've done an LDIFDE export of the RTC Service container and have had a look through the contents. I can see that the new BES Collaboration
server is there and that it has an msRTCSIP-TrustedServerVersion value of 4, whereas all the Lync 2010 values are 5, which I'm guessing is what the Lync Topology is using to establish that the BackCompatSite needs to be populated with that Trusted Server entry.
So my question is this - What do I need to do in order to successfully remove the BackCompatSite entry and migrate my environment to Lync 2013 whilst retaining integration with BES and keeping the Enterprise IM service service running on Blackberry devices? 
Here's some options that I've thought about - Using ADSIEdit to remove the Trusted Server Application for the new BES Collaboration server so I can merge the Topology and delete the BackCompatSite, although will this break the Enterprise IM service? Temporarily
changing the value of the msRTCSIP-TrustedServerVersion for the Collaboration server from 4 to 5, merging the Topology, deleting the BackCompatSite and then changing the msRTCSIP-TrustedServerVersion back to 4 afterwards? Over a weekend\out of hours, removing
the BES Collaboration server and service altogether, going through the Topology merge\BackCompatSite deletion and then reinstalling the Collaboration service?
Has anyone else gone through this process, or got any advice\experience to pass on before I start working through my list of options?

I've asked this question several times:
Does the 2007 R2 CWA server count as tri-coexistence?
I've asked that both in MCM rotations and directly of people on the PG and the answer is always something along the lines of "nope, it's a trusted app server and not a pool".  When I've run into this issue in other deployments, we simply left the backcompatsite
in the deployment into production.
I've never found the above as a publically approved statement just something I've asked previously and been told is OK to do.  This is one of those situations that will work but was most likely not tested.
Thanks,
Richard
Richard Brynteson, Lync MVP | http://masteringlync.com | http://lyncvalidator.com

Similar Messages

  • Lync 2010 to Lync 2013 migration - Dialin conferencing

    While migrating from Lync 2010 to Lync 2013, i have stopped all services on the Lync 2010 servers to make sure all is okay and everything is working fine with Lync 2013.
    Nevertheless, when someone on Lync 2013 schedule a meeting, and someone dial one of the PSTN Dialin conference number and enter the conference ID, this scenario is not working.
    If i start the Lync 2010 front end services, then the previous scenario works.
    So i did something else. I have scheduled a meeting and i change the meeting options to get a new conference ID. this makes the conference work over dial in pst number while Lync 2010 services are down.
    This means:
    - When someone (Lync 2013 user) schedule a meeting, the default conference ID that is generated, requires the existence of Lync 2010 services for a PSTN Dial in user to connect
    -When someone (Lync 2013 user) schedule a meeting and change the meeting options to get a new conference ID, then the PSTN Dial in user can connect even if all Lync 2010 services are down.
    Any clue?
    ammarhasayen

    i have found it. moving the conference directories from Lync 2010 to Lync 2013 solves the whole thing.
    ammarhasayen

  • Unknown Presence in Lync 2010 and Lync 2013 co-existence

    I have lync 2010 and lync 2013 in my environment. Everything was working fine except when I moved the DNS of the Lync 2013 pool to the load balancer. When I did that, users on lync2013 could see the presence of users on Lync2010 pool but not vice versa. 
    I have point the Lyncdiscoverinternal.domain.com to the lync2013 pool DNS. I have opened migration ports on the load balancer but still not working. It works perfectly fine if I point the DNS of the pool to one server directly without going
    through the Load balancer VIP.
    Am I missing anything here?
    Thanks!
    Alert from TechNet Posting

    Hi Kojo Obeng Antwi,
    Please check out the following information.
    Deploying DNS load balancing on Front End pools requires you to perform a couple of extra steps with FQDNs and DNS
    records.
    A pool that uses DNS load balancing must have two FQDNs: the regular pool FQDN that is used by DNS load balancing (such as pool01.contoso.com), and resolves to the physical
    IPs of the servers in the pool, and another FQDN for the pool’s Web services (such as web01.contoso.com), which resolves to virtual IP address of the pool.
    In Topology Builder, if you want to deploy DNS load balancing for a pool, to create this extra FQDN for the pool’s Web services
    you must select the Override internal Web Services pool FQDN check box and type the FQDN, in the Specify the Web Services URLs for this Pool page.
    To support the FQDN used by DNS load balancing, you must provision DNS to resolve the pool FQDN (such as pool01.contoso.com) to the IP addresses of all the servers in the pool
    (for example, 192.168.1.1, 192.168.1.2, and so on). You should include only the IP addresses of servers that are currently deployed.
    Best regards,
    Eric

  • Lync 2010 with Exchange 2013 UM

    Hi,
    I am currently in the early stages of a large migration from Exchange 2010 to Exchange 2013. We have moved some test user mailboxes over to Exchange 2013 however have stumbled at the UM integration.
    We have 2 x CAS and 3 x Mailbox servers with Lync 2010.
    When a user diverts his/her calls to VM, the calls just cuts off and we get "Unable to establish a connection. No connection could be made because the target machine actively refused it 1.1.1.2:5061.
    We get this message for all 3 Mailbox servers that it attempts to route the call too. Mailboxes servers listen on 5063 for TLS in Exchange 2013 and these cannot be changed. So what is going wrong with my setup?
    Only the CAS are members of the DialPlan (we have tried putting the mailboxes servers in the dial plan with no avail).
    Shouldn't the CAS servers redirect Lync to the Mailbox servers on 5063 instead of 5061? Why is Lync trying to connect on 5061 (I know why, but how do I stop it!)
    Many Thanks,
    Eddie

    In my case it were Active Directory attributes of object
    CN=MCA1,CN=Servers,CN=Exchange AdmGr...DC=local,DC=com
    The attributes
    msExchUM* weren't configured at all, despite being set by GUI and PShell. I had to set them manually through ADSIedit.msc and UM began to work after restarting Lync Server.
    I need to investigate further why they aren't set.

  • Co-Existence Lync 2010 and Lync 2013

    Hi,
    How do we check that CMS is moved from lync 2010 to Lync 2013 in Co-Existance environment lync standard edition.
    I know that users are moved form Lync 2010 to Lync 2013 but i don't if CMS is moved? And in the existing co-existence we have two edge servers Lync 2010 and Lync 2013. How can i check if traffic is  routing through Lync 2010 or lync 2013. 
    Because we want to Decommission the Lync 2010 STD Edition before doing this i want to make sure every thing go smooth.
    Please help me on this.
    Thanks
    Whenever you see a helpful reply, click on Vote As Helpful & click on Mark As Answer if a post answers your question.

    To find out if the CMS is moved:
    Get-CsConfigurationStoreLocation, if it's a standard server it will tell you the pool name.  If it's an Enterprise server, it will tell you the SQL server name associated with the pool. 
    http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/gg412814.aspx
    Otherwise it's at the top of the topology builder (the top top part that says Lync Server in the left pane, under the Central Management Server spot in the right pane. 
    For a full decommission article, here's a decent one with screenshots.  As Ben said, if you can advise about the other places we could be more specific.
    http://www.oiboran.com/?p=1073
    Please remember, if you see a post that helped you please click "Vote As Helpful" and if it answered your question please click "Mark As Answer".
    SWC Unified Communications

  • Lync 2010 and Lync 2013 blinking icon in taskbar not working properly

         Hi,
         We're experiencing a strange behaviour. Lync IM notifications are supposed to work this way below:
         1) Notification bubble on the right-bottom corner
         2) After a few seconds, a blinking icon in the task bar
         3) After a few seconds, a coloured icon remains in the task bar
         Some of our users, both Lync 2010 and Lync 2013, go 1) and 2) but then icon won't remain in the task bar, so they don't realize they have a conversation waiting (Windows XP and Windows 7).
         If they open the icon, the conversation is there and coloured, and they can answer.
         In my computer, it has also happened but most of the time it works fine (testing it, maybe it works 15 times and fails 1). Nevertheless, a lot of people is suffering from this strange behaviour.
         We have looked into the causes but haven't found anything.
         Any clue?
         Thanks!

    How long have you seen the problem?
    What version of your Lync client? Try to update your Lync client to the latest version.
    Try to repair office 2013.
    Uninstall and reinstall Lync 2010.
    Please install Lync 2013 or Lync 2010 on a fresh installation of Window to check if you can still see this problem.
    Lisa Zheng
    TechNet Community Support

  • Lync 2010 and Outlook 2013 - not talking!

    I have problemns with Lync 2010 with Outlook 2013 under Windows 8.
    Conversation History is not being saved.
    All the patches are installed.
    When I click on "show more in Outlook" it complains the accounts are not the same. I have two exchange accounts configured within the one Outlook profile. I never had this issue under Outlook 2010.
    ERROR:
    The email address used in your default Outlook profile is different from the sign-in address used in Lync 2010.
    Change your default Outlook profile to match the sign-in address you are using in Lync, and then sign out and sign back in to Lync.
    My default account is the same as my Lync sign-in name.
    I have tried everything.

    Mate,
    There is no issue on conversation history save option, when I use Outlook 2010. 
    The issue only to Outlook 2013 with Lync 2010?  Two observations;
    => Save IM in outlook ( greyed out ) - Lync 2010 client 
    => When I check Lync config information - MAPI is not installed  - Lync 2010 client 
    Could you advice. 

  • After Migrating from Sharpoint 2010 to Sharepoint 2013 list filter options changed

    Hi All,
    After migrating from SP 2010 to SP2013 i found list View filter option is changed and filter is not working Pls help its really urgent.... you can check field 1 and field 2 in following screen shot.
    Prasad kambar

    Hi  ,
    According to your description, my understanding is that your list filter cannot work after Migrating from SharePoint 2010 to SharePoint 2013.
    For your issue, please check your log files for any issues. Also you can refer to the blogs for troubleshooting SharePoint 2013 migration:
     Firstly try running Test-SPContentDatabase on your source database for any issues -
    Test-SPContentDatabase - http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ff607941.aspx
    Troubleshoot site collection upgrade issues in SharePoint 2013 http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/jj219648.aspx
    Verify database upgrades in SharePoint 2013 -http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc424972.aspx
    And please have a look at your custom solution on your site.
    Best Regards,
    Eric
    Eric Tao
    TechNet Community Support

  • Planning a migration from Exchange 2010 to Exchange 2013

    Hello,
    I am planning a migration from Exchange 2010 to Exchange 2013 and I was wondering if there was a good guide on the UM migration. I haven't found one that isn't confusing as heck.

    Hello,
    Is there any update?
    If
    you have any feedback on our support, please click here
    Cara Chen
    TechNet Community Support

  • CMS Migration - Lync 2010 to Lync 2013 & Pool Pairing

    Hi all,
    Question regarding CMS installation when migrating away from Lync 2010.
    Here's a brief overview of topology
    - Lync 2010 Pool in Data Centre 1
    - Lync 2013 Pool #1 in Data Centre 1
    - Lync 2013 Pool #2 in Data Centre 2
    - Lync 2013 Pools are paired 
    Consider the following
     - CMS located on SQL Backend server for Lync 2010 Pool
     - CMS database installed on SQL Back end for Lync 2013 Pool #1.  CMS is moved to this location
    Now for correct pool pairing and failover capabilities I would assume that
     - CMS database needs to also be installed on SQL back end for Lync 2013 Pool #2
    Once this is done then Lync 2013 Pool #2 Front Ends should replicate back into the CMS stored on the back end SQL database for pool #2?  Nothing else would need to be done?  As soon as it's installed its now a backup?
    If I'm reading into this correctly the following from TechNet is basically telling me to do this?
    When you establish a pool pairing that includes the pool hosting the Central
    Management store, a backup Central Management store database is set up in the
    backup pool, and Central Management store services are installed in both pools.
    At any point in time, one of the two Central Management store databases is the
    active master, and the other is a standby. The content is replicated by the
    Backup Service from the active master to the standby.
    Thanks,
    paul.

    Correct, when you enable pool pairing on Pool A - if it's a CMS server - it will prompt you to create the CMS database on Pool B. If you move CMS into a pool that is already pool paired, my experience is that CMS doesn't get created on Pool B because the
    creation only happens during the pool pairing setup. Thanks -Richard
    Richard Brynteson, Lync MVP | http://masteringlync.com | http://lyncvalidator.com

  • Lync 2010 to Lync 2013 Trusted application Migration

    We have Mitel Live Business Gateway as trusted application server on the Lync 2010 server for Remote call control. I am in the process of migrating to Lync 2013 and can't find
    a way to migrate the Trusted Application. This is how we setup the Trusted application on Lync 2010.
    http://www.justin-morris.net/configuring-lync-server-2010-for-remote-call-control-with-mitel-3300/
    Malli Boppe MCITP Enterprise Messaging Exchange 2010

    Hi,
    You cannot move it to Lync Server 2013. You need to create new trusted application server and select Lync Server 2013 front end pool as the next hop.
    Configure Trusted Application Servers
    http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/jj204735.aspx
    Kent Huang
    TechNet Community Support

  • User migration from Lync 2010 to Lync 2013

    We have Lync 2013 pool co-existence with Lync 2010 pool. Need to move users based on their AD Group membership. In a particular AD group, only few of the users are enabled for LYNC 2010, not all users. How to get the list of only Lync enabled users in AD
    group and move them on to Lync 2013 by PowerShell script?
    Thanks in advance for your help
    Tek-Nerd

    When I ran the below command
    Get-ADGroupMember Mygroup | where {$_.msRTCSIP-UserEnabled -eq "true"}
    on my Lync 2013 server, got the below error message...
    At line:1 char:46
    + Get-ADGroupMember MyGroup | where {$_.msRTCSIP-UserEnabled -eq "true"}
    +                                             
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~
    Unexpected token '-UserEnabled' in expression or statement.
    At line:1 char:59
    + Get-ADGroupMember MyGroup | where {$_.msRTCSIP-UserEnabled -eq "true"}
    +                                                          
    ~~~
    Unexpected token '-eq' in expression or statement.
        + CategoryInfo          : ParserError: (:) [], ParentContainsErrorRecordExcep
        + FullyQualifiedErrorId : UnexpectedToken
    Tek-Nerd

  • Lync 2010 upgrade to 2013, 2 domains

    Hello,
    I have following scenario:
    We are having two domains, old domain ( domain1.local ) is running Exchange 2010 + Lync 2010 with single FE & Edge and new domain ( domain2.ads ), where we are currently deploying Exchange 2013 + Lync 2013. Two-way trust exists between domains.
    Useraccount & computers are joined to new domain. Users have linked mailboxes to old domain, and they are using lync with old domains credentials. E-mail address that is used is in form [email protected], and the same domain is being used on new exchange
    & lync aswell.
    Currently I have installed Front End, Edge & ARR as reverse proxy, and configured networks for them.
    I also created a topology, However, I have not published topology yet, as I am not entirely sure what possibly could happen if I would do that.
    There are some DNS-records missing on internal DNS, as i cannot figure, how I could add the SRV records without breaking the old enviroment, as users are using new domains DNS.
    So Question goes,
    If I publish the topology, is it possible that the old lync enviroment could malfuction, and if yes, is it possible to revert the changes ? I tried to download old topology, but it cannot be found ( probably due missing dns-entries ).
    Second question is that is it possible to migrate user contactlists etc to new enviroment, as the useraccount is going to change?
    Thanks In advance

    Hi,
    If the two domains in the same forest, only one Lync Server environment should be deployed. You can deploy the Lync Server 2013 as another Lync Pool which hosted in the Domain 2.
    You can refer to the link below:
    https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/jj205144%28v=ocs.15%29.aspx?f=255&MSPPError=-2147217396
    Best Regards,
    Eason Huang
    Please remember to mark the replies as answers if they help, and unmark the answers if they provide no help. If you have feedback for TechNet Support, contact [email protected]
    Eason Huang
    TechNet Community Support

  • Moving CMS from Lync 2010 to Lync 2013 - WIndows Firewall??

    We currently have the Windows Firewall disabled on all 3 of our Lync 2013 FE servers. We just don't use it and it gets in the way of some other applications. I remember when I was installing Lync on these servers, I had to enable the Windows Firewall or
    setup would fail. Now that Lync has been running for a while, I have the Firewall disabled again.
    Now, I am moving the CMS from Lync 2010 to 2013 and I am wondering if I should again enable the Firewall? I am concerned that the commands I need to run to prepare the 2013 FE server and the Move-CsManagement-Server command itself will fail if Windows Firewall
    is disabled.
    Does anyone know?

    Hi,
    As I know, if you want to disable Windows firewall for getting in the way of some other applications you can
    just turn off all three (Domain, Private, Public) profiles or disable the Windows firewall service.
    If you just turn off all three (Domain, Private, Public) profiles, it means that during the install, Lync Server will add all the firewall rules to the Windows Firewall, so if after you turn on all three profiles all you need to do is turn the Windows Firewall
    back on from the inside the Control Panel.
    If you disable the Windows firewall service it means that the Windows Firewall snap-in won't even load. So during the install Lync Server won't be able to create the firewall rules. So after Lync installation you can enable the Windows Firewall service is
    to run Step 2 from Lync Server Deployment Wizard.
    More details:
    http://blogs.technet.com/b/dodeitte/archive/2012/05/25/how-to-update-windows-firewall-rules-for-lync-server-2010-after-installation.aspx
    So if you just turn off three (Domain, Private, Public) profiles, you should be OK to move CMS from 2010 to 2013.
    Best Regards,
    Eason Huang
    Eason Huang
    TechNet Community Support

  • Migrating from SP 2010 to SP 2013

    I m new to sharepoint and our new project requirement is to migrate the contents from SP 2010 to SP 2013. we r not going to use any tools , so if we go manually what would be the approach to migrate the custom data to the next version. there is lot of custom
    data like features, event recievers, webparts that we have to take care of . do we have to code them again or what . 
    in depth reply or even some forums link will do . thanks

    Check out
    http://www.falconitservices.com/support/KB/Lists/Posts/Post.aspx?ID=124
    All customizations will have to be tested again  though, you can't expect them to work correctly. I would start by creating a list of customizations that have to be upgraded and still need to be supported
    Kind regards,
    Margriet Bruggeman
    Lois & Clark IT Services
    web site: http://www.loisandclark.eu
    blog: http://www.sharepointdragons.com

Maybe you are looking for