MM intercompany account determination

Hallo Everybody,
when purchasing (ME21N) I would like to use a different G/L account for intercompany and third party purchases without creating a separate plant or using split valuation
For stock postings my FI substitution based on trading partner kicks in during goods receipt but when I purchase goods using a CO object this does not work because commitments with the wrong accounts are used. OK, during goods receipt everything works well from then on but the wrong account is displayed on the PO.
I tried to solve this problem using a CO substitution with the same logic. When debugging I can see that the right G/L account is chosen but it is not put on the purchase order. When saving the wrong account is of course chosen. I can change the account manually in the purchase order, then the CO object will be posted with the newly entered G/L account.
Do you know of any other automated way to solve this problem?
Best Regards

Find it hard to understand on why you are trying the re-invent the wheel. Split Valuation is the solution for your requirement, if that cannot be used, then creating a new solution will be creating the split valuation logic without naming it as such. Not sure what is the value of doing a such costly, error prone process when you have tested and proved solution on hand.

Similar Messages

  • Account determination error during intercompany billing invoice

    Hi experts,
    I am getting 'Account Determination Error' shows in red during 'intercompany' billing.
    I tried to release to accounting but didn't help.
    Pls advise
    Br,
    Umesh

    Hi Sushant,
    The error during the invoice creation. This document is for intercompany billing.
    I checked in Account Determination Analysis --> Revenue Accounts
    When I click on the Item no., it shows as 'No G/L account found in KOFI' & messege 121.
    In VKOA, there are few tables but I am not sure how & what to compare between these two.
    Br,
    Umesh

  • Intercompany Goods Moment Account Determination Question

    Hi,
    I'm wondering how to meet a business requirement relating to intercompany FI postings.
    We use the NB stock transport order to transfer materials between plants in different company codes. For this order type, SAP uses movement type 643 for the shipment and movement type 101 for the goods receipt.
    The requirements are:
    1) we would like to use the same FI account as offset for shipment as the receipt
    2) the account should not be the vendor Purchase Price Variance (PPV) account; otherwise it would be too difficult to analyze this account.
    The account determination for the 643 is determined in GBB VAX; and the account determination for the 101 is in PRD (no modifier). However this is the same account determination as Purchase Price Variance (PPV).
    Aside from creating a new movement type for the goods receipt, is there any way to achieve the required FI Postings?
    Thanks -- points to be awarded for a good solution.
    Dan

    Hello MA,
    The intercompany PO we create is at a $0.00 price.  We also uncheck the IR box on the PO, as we do not expect a vendor invoice from the receipt.
    The WRX T/E key controls the GR/IR account; we do not want to change this account because we still want receipts against external vendor POs to post there.  Also, since the IR box is unchecked, SAP will not make a posting to the WRX account (GR/IR).
    We want the difference between standard and PO price (which always equals standard price because the PO price is $0.00) to post to the same account as the PGI posting.  However we do not want this posting to go to our vendor PPV account, which is configured in PRD.
    Hope this clarifies for you.
    Thanks,
    Dan

  • Intercompany Goods Movement Account Determination

    Hi,
    I'm wondering how to meet a business requirement relating to intercompany FI postings.
    We use the NB stock transport order to transfer materials between plants in different company codes. For this order type, SAP uses movement type 643 for the shipment and movement type 101 for the goods receipt.
    The requirements are:
    1) we would like to use the same FI account as offset for shipment as the receipt
    2) the account should not be the vendor Purchase Price Variance (PPV) account; otherwise it would be too difficult to analyze this account.
    The account determination for the 643 is determined in GBB VAX; and the account determination for the 101 is in PRD (no modifier). However this is the same account determination as Purchase Price Variance (PPV).
    Aside from creating a new movement type for the goods receipt, is there any way to achieve the required FI Postings?
    Thanks -- points to be awarded for a good solution.
    Dan

    Dear Dan
    Yes this is achievable.  But instead of changing the standard feature, you better copy the standard 643 and create a new movement type.
    For that go to OMJJ, select Movement Type, input 643 and execute.  You can see some tabs to your left screen where you double click on [Account Grouping]  so that a screen will open where you can modify the Account Grouping under the tab Account Modification.  Change it to required Account Group and save.
    Now try your process from begining and check the FI impact.  All these changes have to be tested thoroughly in development, get the concurrence from FI people and then transport to production.
    thanks
    G. Lakshmipathi

  • ACCOUNT DETERMINATION "INTERCOMPANY SALES &3RD PARTY SALES" -kishore,AK ,

    HI ,
       Rajesh , Kishore , AK ,
          well 2day  i had   client interview ,  he was very much stressing on " ACCOUNT DETERMINATION  " process  in intercompany sales , both in ordering comapny  and delvering plant .
           At the same time  account determination  for 3rd party sales . well got some docs had  brief capsule study , still stuck up . 
       can u pl throw  come clarity .
    Regards,
    jerry

    Dear Jerry
    Inter-Company Scenario in SAP is quite different than its literal meaning.
    Inter-Company means, customer gives order to company code A (PlantA), but Plant A is not having stock, so it passes on to Plant B(CoCd B).So in Sales order of A you enter Plant B.
    So now goods are delivered by Plant B to Customer and commercial invoice for customer is from CoCd A.
    Cocd B just gives inter company invoice.
    Now Comming to account determination , it totally depends on pricing procedure as account keys are there. There is not much difference from standard scenario, but you can have seperate G/L Accounts
    If you are talking about <b>sales between different company codes</b>, then this can be handled having different sales document and thus different pricing procedure, you can ask customer , what is there requirement. and can say that it is like normal sales cycle only
    <b>Third-Party Processing</b>
    1) two standard process provided by SAP in the frames of the third-party processing:
    a) pure third-party process: X creates the sales order, automatically purchase requision and later a purchase order will be created at the vendor. Then the vendor sends the goods directly to your customer and send the invoice to X. The company X creates the invoice to the customer Y.
    b) individual purchase order: the same process, but the vendor sends the goods not to the customer directly, but first to X, and then the company X delivers the goods to the customer Y. The invoice is coming from Z to X (transaction MIRO), and then X creates invoice to Y.
    you can refer the accounting document to get Idea of account determination
    Regards
    Jitesh

  • Cost of Goods Sold account determination by customer type (inter-company)

    We have a business need to separate the the cost of goods sold be customer type.  Specifically separating the inter-company cost of goods sold from the 3rd party cost of goods sold. 
    The standard COGS account determination in GBB/VAX only allows for differentiating between material valuation class. 
    Has anyone attempted this before and what method worked?

    For those who may need an answer to this, our solution was the following: 
    1)       Created new types for SO, SO Item, Sched. Line, Delivery, Delivery Item, Billing type  
    2)       Created new Pricing procedure
    3)       Created new movement type Y61/Y62 modeled after 601/602
    4)       Mapped Y61/Y62 to account modifier ZAX.
    5)       Mapped GBB/ZAX to the new account.
    Benefits, they now have better view of the orders going inter-company.  It is flexible enough to adjusting prices for intercompany separate from standard orders, even though for now it is a straight copy of cost.  They are able to remove the sales/use tax, from the calculations. They are able to plan with these orders separated out.  Plus, this will standardize their process for inter-company. 
    Hope this helps someone. 
    Cheers!
    Rick

  • GL account determination for  vendor invoice in cross company sale sales

    Hi
    we are planning to implement cross company sales scenario.
    High level design-
    1) Sales Order is in co code X and the delivery is from group company  lets say  co code Y
    2) The delivery from co code Y generates two invoices- one in Sales area of co code X for the final customer and 2nd in sales area of co code Y for the inter company
    3) The intercompany invoice has EDI output type (Sap standard delivered object is RD04).  The output generates a IDOC which has ability to post automatic vendor invoice in co code X crediting the inter company vendor Y.
    4) The automatic vendor invoice GL account determination is via customisation OBCB and OBCE
    I have some questions around this , particularly if in the vendor invoice we have to account for material and returnable packaging
    In my current project there would FG packed in returnable packaging in co code Y
    For Export there would be a dedicated co code(X).
    Co code X gets orders from customers; and creates sales orders in its sales area with delivery plant of co code Y.
    Along with FG  returnable packaging is also charged as deposit  by - co code X to customer and Co code Y to Co code X.
    so in the vendor invoice how to generate the following entry
    Inter company vendor              150 Cr
    Cost of Goods sold         100 Dr
    Returnable Packages deposit    50 Dr.
    Similarly when the end  customer returns the packaging generate the following entry via the cross company return order and intercompany invoice
    intercompany vendor 50 Dr
    Returnable packages 50 Cr
    if you have worked on this kind of scenario and share how to customise  to post for FG and Returnable packaging separately in the automatic vendor invoice it would be great.
    Edited by: pravin_shah1403 on Nov 25, 2011 3:00 PM

    Hi Pravin.
    Did you figure this out?
    I'm seeing that via OBCB we can hit only one G/L account.
    We also need to hit multiple accounts.
    We've figured out how to hit this via user-exit, however I'm hoping that I've missed something in configuration and that a resolution via configuration is possible?
    Any ideas?

  • Account Determination in CASH SALES.

    Hi All,
    A)  I have configured cash sales scenario, but I am not able to post the cash received to FI.  Are their any different settings for cash sales account determination compared to regular sale sceanrio.
    B) Do we need different pricing procedure for intercompany sales? If yes what is the difference between standard and intercompany sales if we can accomodate the intercomany sales in standard.
    Regards,
    Danny.
    Kindly guide.
    Regards,
    Danny.

    Hi,
    please find answers below,
    A) I have configured cash sales scenario, but I am not able to post the cash received to FI. Are their any different settings for cash sales account determination compared to regular sale sceanrio.
    Ans:In cash sales accounty determinations will be posted to cash clearing account  and the account key is EVV,but g/l account sholud be assigned to this key in VKOA.
    B) Do we need different pricing procedure for intercompany sales? If yes what is the difference between standard and intercompany sales if we can accomodate the intercomany sales in standard.
    Ans:Do not required,because in our std. pricing procedure we have two condition types PI01 and PI02 and these conditions are used in intercompany and these condition types are statistical,so no posting in accounting.
    If you need further assistance get back to me...
    Regards,
    Chandra

  • Account  determination-urgent

    hi
    how the account will post in GL account    during intercompany billing transaction, third party order, and STO.  very urgent. 
    please give me the answer
    regards
    murali

    Hi,
    Apart from the above information,i would like to add one more point i.e.condition types KOFI/KOFK are controlled with the reqirement type given in the Account determination procedure.
    I hope this info will add up to your query.
    kiran,

  • Account determination for COGS account by customer

    Dear gurus
    I’d like to get advice about account determination for COGS account.
    I have requirement to determine COGS account based on “Customer”.
    If the customer is outside the group, we want to charge to
    “Sales: Third-party” and “COGS: Third-party” accounts.
    And if the customer is in the group, we want to charge to
    “Sales: Intercompan” and “COGS: Intercompany” account.
    However, since COGS account is determined from Valuation class in
    Material master (OBYC), it cannot be determined from “Customer”.
    (Because same material can be sold to third-party and intercompany too)
    Do you know any solution for it?
    Yoshi

    Hi
    The only other way I could think of is to do an enhancement at the time of delivery to read the customer and substitute the GL Account for COGS based on Customer recon Account.
    The sales can easily be seggregated based on Customer Account Assignment Group in the customer Sales Area. Assuming the material account assignment group is 01 and customer account assignment group are as under:
    External Customer 01
    Group Customer    03
    Now in VKOA you can seggregate the revenue account determination for Group and external customer based on different customer account assignment group.
    The only issue is for COGS GL for which you might want to look at Enhancement or Split Valuation that I talked about earlier.
    Thanks & Regards
    Sanil Bhandari

  • Account determination error - in creation of invoice

    Hello experts,
    i have an error in creation of invoice, after( pgi post goods issue)
    will you please help me out to solve this error.
    thanks & Regards,
    yogesh raina

    hello sir,
    After going throuth this path it shows no gl account in account determination chart
    as below
    Condition type     Message     Description
      ZPR0                                  123     Access KOFI not carried out (initialized field)
    Access     Message     Description
    10     123     Access KOFI not carried out (initialized field)
    20     121     No G/L account found in Account determination type KOFI
    30     123     Access KOFI not carried out (initialized field)
    40     121     No G/L account found in Account determination type KOFI
    50     121     No G/L account found in Account determination type KOFI
    60     123     Access KOFI not carried out (initialized field)

  • Account determination error in VF02

    Hai Guru,s
    In VF02 when i am going ton release the flag to accounting i am getting following error  "Posting keys for accounting determination for transaction EXD does not exist"
    I checked VKOA EXD a/c key availabele .This is Exise duty account key.....In pricing procedure also EXD assigned to respectine condition type.............
    where i did wrong.........which setting i missed........
    Thank u in advance
    Regards
    Anjan

    Dear Anjan,
    For Tax Conditions you have to maintain Account Determination in OB40
    Go to T-Code OB40
    Select the Transaction - EXD - & Double click on it...
    Mention required GL Account here...
    Your problem would definitely get solved.
    Hope this helps...
    Give Points if useful...
    Thanks,
    Jignesh Mehta
    Edited by: Jignesh Mehta on Sep 26, 2008 10:42 AM

  • Account determination error in Subcontract PO-MIGO.?

    Hi all
    While doing GR, i mgetting error i "Account determination for entry LDCA BSV 0001 ___ 5010 not possible".
    The above PO is subcontract PO .
    Thanks
    sap-m

    Hi,
    For subcontracting..maintain these keys..so that you will not get any problem..
    BSX, BSV, WRX, PRD, FRL
    Regards,
    Prasath

  • Account determination error in FI-MM

    Hi Gurus
    I trying to raise PO requisition in ME21N. Here I am facing couple of issues
    1) If I select the K in account assignment category I can't assign the raw material GL account in account assignment tab  as it falls under balance sheet item.
    2) I have saved the PO with out K in the account assignment category and proceeded to MIGO when the saving the document in MIGO the system showing the rejection as "account determination is missing for Valuation class and for COCD"
    and postings are not reflected.
    I want make sure that all the settings related to account determination are good in OBYC.
    Please advise here
    Kishore

    Hi,
    As you mentioned the below is the error message.
    "account determination is missing for Valuation class and for COCD"
    What is COCD ???
    Is it Chart of Account or else????
    Ravi Polampalli

  • Account determination error in FI doc during SD billing doc posting.

    hi,
    when I create one billing doc ref to s/o,
    I check account determination in condition type:
    G/L account no.: 110000
    Provision acc.   : 120000
    in FI doc,
    should debit 110000 and credit 120000
    but current status is credit 110000 and debit 120000
    Please help.
    Thanks.

    Hi,
    One of the following could be the reasons for the Account determination error.
    Please check.
    1.Incorrect account assignment group entered in the customer and material master
    Resolution:Maintain correct account assignment group in customer and material master,Eg.External Domestic,Z1 - External Foreign,Internal Foreign,etc,.
    2.GL account not extended to the respective company code.
    Resolution:Extend the required GL account to the company code.
    Regards,
    Sophia Xavier

Maybe you are looking for

  • Trouble with saveAS

    I am having a problem with a javascript function. <br /><br />I can save as a Tiff with no problem - <br />but now I would like to have another option that allows my users to save data as a PDF file. <br /><br />I can't seem to get it to work for a P

  • How to get SAAJ impl. working on 9.0.4 (Lehmann?)

    Hi, I'm currently working on an assignment which needs to leverage functionality as described by the SAAJ spec. Since I had/have trouble getting the SAAJ (10.0.3) impl from Oracle working on either 9.0.3/9.0.4 OC4J, I'm currently developing against t

  • PHP Namespaces in Dreamweaver?

    HI I was wondering if Dreamweaver supports PHP namespaces?  I've tested the following code in Dreamweaver CS4 it tells me I have an error in my code (even though it executes flawlessly on the server). person.php <?php namespace pandemicode; class Per

  • "Missing or offline titles, effects or generators" mystery

    Suddenly, I have that little yellow warning triangle on my event name and when I go to export, I get this "missing or offline titles, effects or generators."  Nothing in the time line or in the bin has a yellow triangle beside it.  Only yellow triang

  • Are datatypes plattform independent?

    Hi all, maybe this one is a silly question (if so sorry for that..), but as we are migrating a MaxDB 7.6 database from a Win32 to a Win64 server machine we came up with concerns if the datatypes - esp. INTEGER - were plattform independent; meaning: i