Question for the Adobe Illustrator team or anyone who might know

Is Adobe Illustrator meant only to use Bezier curves? I know that they are very useful for a number of curves, but are they used to approximate circles? Granted, all screens require rasterized objects to the nearest pixels in order to display them, but when drawing a circle, information is lost because it is converted into 4 Bezier curves (cubic or quadratic, I'm not sure). However, when I export a circle from Adobe Illustrator CS5 to SVG it preserves the circle or ellipse's information with its proper tag.
So, my question is, does the Adobe Illustrator Artboard file format have some internal representation of ellipses and circles such that it it not broken down into Bezier curves?

function(){return A.apply(null,[this].concat($A(arguments)))}
when I export a circle from Adobe Illustrator CS5 to SVG it preserves the circle or ellipse's information with its proper tag.
So what? That means nothing. You're just talking about terms within a progamming language. One could program Illustrator to export a freakin' square as SVG's circle tag if one wanted to.
As explained in your previous thread about the same worry-wart subject:
There being a "circle element" in SVG programming, in itself, means nothing. I can write you a Javascript called "Illustrator's Circle Element" that will work in Illustrator, that will prompt you for center coordinates and a radius, that will appear in one of Illustrator's menus, and that will cause Illustrator to render that which for any practical purpose is a circle. The presence of such a command in no way signifies to you what kind of curve-rendering math is employed by that "element" to actually plot the curve!
By the same token, SVG's providing something called a "circle element" in its API and asking you to specify it in terms of center and radius in no way tells you what kind of curve-rendering math is actually being employed to render the curve, nor does it ensure that its rendered result will be any more precisely mathematically circular than rendered by a cubic Bezier curve. If you don't know for a fact that SVG's rendering math does not employ Bezier curves, then your concern is moot.
It's moot anyway, because it's ridiculous. Again: the "inaccuracy" is so tiny as to be completely pointless for any practical SVG purpose.
Again: You are reading entirely too much into a mere popularly-cited curiosity about the cubic Bezier equation. You are being silly; you just don't realize it.
Illustrator's (i.e; PostScript's) using Bezier math to plot curves does not make Illustrator (or any of the similar programs) in any way "sub standard" or "less accurate" or "less desirable" or more "dumbed down" than any other. In fact, here are some other related curiosities for you to loose sleep over:
The math primarily used for plotting curves in most CAD programs is quite arguably "more crude" than Bezier curves.
Illustrator uses cubic Beziers. TrueType uses quadratic Beziers. But there are Bezier equations of higher order than cubic.
(If I remember right) Bezier himself discovered the formulae bearing his name in pursuit of more supple curves for the automotive industry.
If you're still worried about this, you really need to go take a couple of math courses, so you can understand that this really is silly.
JET

Similar Messages

  • Hi - I am looking for the Adobe Illustrator 2014 1.2 (or .0.2) bugfix update for Mac - and it is not visible in the Adobe Creative Cloud Packager (Mac version). The only update visible is Illustrator CC 2014.1  - which is what introduced the bugs.

    Hi - I am looking for the Adobe Illustrator 2014 1.2 (or .0.2) bugfix update for Mac - and it is not visible in the Adobe Creative Cloud Packager (Mac version). The only update visible is Illustrator CC 2014.1  - which is what introduced the bugs.
    The only thing that I can think of that might be causing the issues that I have a Mac Mini on Mavericks.
    Dave

    Hi
    I have discovered that my question above is a non-question. A user triggered by looking at the below article about Illustrator 2014 cc 17.0.2
    http://helpx.adobe.com/illustrator/release-note/illustrator-17-0-2-release-notes.html 
    He had recently upgraded from wht we now know is 18.0 to 18.1 which is the latest version. He read the above artic
    le and supposed that it was a bug fix release for his version - because the v17 ov18 number is not often displayed. It is usually just 2014 CC.
    I have asked him to post a bug report about Adobe Illustrator CC 2014.1
    Dave

  • I have a question for the Adobe customer service dept., not for the "community" as a whole!

    I have a question for the Adobe Customer Serice Dept., not the "community" as a whole. And I expect an answer! I want to know why I am expected to sign up for another service package when I just paid $25+ yesterday to be able to convert files back and forth from a PDF to a Word file and then back to a PDF. What kind of rip-off is this?

    Hi,
    I am very sorry that you had unpleasant experiences with our customer service.
    If you would like to export your PDF files to MS Word files then ExportPDF tool will do the job.
    If you would like to convert MS Word files to PDF then ConvertPDF tool will the the job.
    If you would like to export your PDF files to Word file then convert the Word files back to PDF then PDF Pack service is required which includes ExportPDF/Convert to PDF/Combine Files tools.
    Please let me know if you have any questions/issues.
    Thank you.
    Hisami

  • I just bought and installed the Adobe Illustrator. I would like to know how long can I use the product before an extension is needed?

    I just bought and installed the Adobe Illustrator. I would like to know how long can I use the product before an extension is needed?  And on how many computers can I install this product? Thanks.

    What version exactly did you buy? If you bought CS6, then the license is perpetual and doesn't need any extension. If you bought CC, then you need to renew your plan every year. You can install each Adobe software on 2 machines with a single license for non-concurrent use.
    Mylenium

  • Perhaps a question for the IDCS programmers team

    I hope not being naïve in the titling of this post but this situation probably does not seem derived from a bad use of ID.
    In CS5.5 switching between layout and master pages may be very problematic if you modify the pasteboard options/vertical margin in the «Guides &Pasteboard Menu».
    Changing the default value (in vertical margin) makes ID altering the view, showing nothing or just parts of the page in the layout menu and master pages. Examples below show the situation.
    It seems that in View/Fit spread in window this strange behaviour had been controlled. But it is not satisfactory as most part of the time different views are required to control pages.
    (I made this proof in CS4 and there is not problem at all).

    It means it looks to me like this is a bug and the only way it will get fixed (if at all) is if somebody (and that should be you since you know how to make it happen) files a bug report with details about how to reproduce it. The way to do that is to file a report using the link in my previous post.
    You most likely will not hear from the engineers, but that doesn't mean they didn't see the report or ar ignoring it, and it most likely will not get fixed for CS5 or 5.5, and maybe not for CS6, but it will get on the list of things to do and based on the difficulty and cost of correcting the behavior, and how serious it is in terms of number of users affected or impact on usability of the application, it will be assigned a priority.

  • Hi there, I made the monthly payment for the Adobe apps, i managed to download Illustrator and Photoshop but can't seem to download Indesign. It says that "file seems to be corrupted... try later". How do I solve this problem?

    Hi there, I made the monthly payment for the Adobe apps, i managed to download Illustrator and Photoshop but can't seem to download Indesign. It says that "file seems to be corrupted... try later". How do I solve this problem?

    Hi shuster9,
    It seems the downloaded setup for InDesign has got corrupt.
    Could you please clear the TEMP from your computer and then retry.
    Thanks,
    Manish Sharma

  • I'm looking for the adobe suite 5.5 and it says it will only work on leopard or snow leopard... but i'm running on lion... anyone know what to do here?

    i'm looking for the adobe suite 5.5 and it says it will only work on leopard or snow leopard... but i'm running on lion... anyone know what to do here?

    Hi.
    I'm guessing that you'r not buying a new edition of the Adobe Suite 5.5.
    Apparently Adobe haven't been awake to make sure the 5.5 is 100% compatiable with Lion. However, I do believe it's only a few minor troubles you will experince and Adobe constantly update their software to adjust to Lion.
    You should go to Adobe.com and see the list of known issues.
    Best regards.

  • I am the administrator for an Adobe CC team which I set up yesterday.  I invited a co-worker to join

    I am the administrator for an Adobe CC team which I set up yesterday.  I invited a co-worker to join the team, but she is experiencing difficulty getting appropriately verified.  Consequently, she cannot access the CC apps.

    Hi SBIBBS,
    Your co-worker needs to log in to Creative Cloud to download and install applications see [http://helpx.adobe.com/creative-cloud/help/install-apps.html] for a solution
    You can also refer this [ http://helpx.adobe.com/creative-cloud/creative-cloud-teams.html ] for other creative cloud team issues.
    Let me know if it helps.
    Regards
    Eshant

  • To the Adobe MUSE team....Have you considered adding an "Upload File" field for the contact forms?

    To the Adobe MUSE team....Have you considered adding an "Upload File" field for the contact forms?

    But seriously...
    Is there any development being done for this?  I have a careers section on our website that I have been asked to "make easier for applicants" (right now, there is a link that just opens an email).  I'm going to make a full version of an application, but I would really like a way to upload resumes and CV's. 
    I'm going to have to look into some kind of service if this isnt something on the Muse radar.  A reply of some kind would be fantastic! 

  • I trying to cancel the adobe illustrator CC monthly plan. I followed the direction of the web site but there's no cancel icon in the plan management page.

    I trying to cancel the adobe illustrator CC monthly plan. I followed the direction of the web site but there's no cancel icon in the plan management page. I am paying more than 30 USD for several months for what I not using.what should i do?Creative Cloud Download & Install

    Moving this discussion to the Adobe Creative Cloud forum.
    Ssy10101 if you are unable to cancel your membership then please contact our support team directly at Contact Customer Care.

  • How to chek the adobe illustrator document version.

    hi all,
    Can anyone guide me how to check the version of the adobe illustrator document.(currently active document).
    I tried using app.version which gives the version of adobe illustrator application i.e 12.0.0 for CS2.
    But i want the version of the illustrator document.I tried app.activeDocument.version which gives me the undefined value.
    Any suggestion on this ?????
    Also please help me on the script for finding out the font type used in the document. e.g. times new roman,arial new etc.
    thanks in advance,
    Sanat

    owh dear
    var v_fl = "/d/_temp/3ds_eles_msh.ai"
    function getFileVersion(v_flToOpen){
        var v_fileObj = new File(v_flToOpen);
        var vrs = null;
        v_fileObj.open("r");
        try{
            while(v_fileObj.tell() < v_fileObj.length) {
                var line = v_fileObj.readln();
                //alert(line.reflect.methods);
                var idxOf = line.indexOf("Creator: Adobe Illustrator(R)");
                if(idxOf > 0) { vrs = line.substring(idxOf+30, line.length);}
        catch(ex) { alert("There is some sort of strange error ... damn, and all was going so well");}
        finally { v_fileObj.close(); return vrs; }
    var v_fileVersion = getFileVersion(v_fl);
    if(v_fileVersion != null) {
         alert("Version of the file is:" + v_fileVersion);
    } else {
         alert("Now seriously did you really selected an .ai file? If so, something strange happened!");
    cheers;

  • I have a new email address and my old email keeps coming up on icloud when trying to update apps and i don't know the password or security questions for the old email. I can sign in with my apple id which is tied to another email but not itunes how to fix

    I have an apple id and it has my current email attached to it. however when i go to update apps it's asking for the password for an old email. I no longer have the old email and can't use it. when I go to icloud on my ipad it asks for the password for old email. it doesn't allow me to change the old email to current. when i go to reset it i can't remember the password or security questions for the old email so it doesn't let me go any further. How do I fix this? Do i need to call apple support?

    I have the same problem - it is maddening. I rely on this iPad for work so this is not just an annoyance! The above solutions of changing the appleid on the device or on the website do not work.
    The old email address no longer exists - I haven't used it in a year probably and I no longer have the account.  I logged into the appleid website and there is no trace of the old email address so there is nothing that can be deleted or changed there.  On the iPad there is no trace of the old email address so nothing can be deleted there either. I have updated the iPad software and the same problem comes right back.  Every 2 seconds I am asked to log in using the old non-existent email.  The device is currently useless.
    The only recent change to anything was the addition of an Apple TV device, which was set up using the correct login and password.
    Does anyone have any ideas? The iPad has been backed up to the iCloud so presumably it now won't recognize the current iCloud account? So restoring may notbe an option?

  • Ive just signed up for the adobe photoshop pack, i use a mac, when i click download, nothing is happening..  Am I doing something wrong?? When I try and open the software I already had from trial it says its expired,  or i need to use a serial number... H

    Ive just signed up for the adobe photoshop pack, i use a mac, when i click download, nothing is happening..  Am I doing something wrong?? When I try and open the software I already had from trial it says its expired,  or i need to use a serial number... HELP Anyone else experienced this?

    If there is an option to "license this software", and it takes you to a sign-in page with username and password (not a serial number) - then just go ahead and sign in.
    If it insists on a serial number you need to uninstall the trial. Then try to download again.

  • Configuring the Destination URL for the Adobe Document Services

    hi all,
    I am going through the documentation for "Configuring the Destination URL for the Adobe Document Services " at :
    http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw2004s/helpdata/en/02/560f41ca73d349e10000000a1550b0/frameset.htm
    I am not able to understand 7th step
    <b>7.      Define the user name and password. To find out how to create the user name and password for the Adobe document services, see Creating a User for Basic Authentication in the document Adobe Document Services – Configuration Guide. You can find this guide in the SAP Service Marketplace under Quick Link /InstguidesNW04.</b>
    In our scenario
    <i>We are running NW04s SP11 on 2 machines
    1) <u>32-bit machine with ADS and credentials properly configured on Web AS for Java installation</u>
    <b>com.adobe  AdobeDocumentServices  null (710.20061024154505.342190)
    com.adobe  AdobeDocumentServicesEjbClientLibrary  null (705.20060407121920.289077)
    sap.com  SAP-JEE  7.00 SP11 (1000.7.00.11.0.20070201154700) 
    sap.com  SAP-JEECOR  7.00 SP11 (1000.7.00.11.0.20070201154700)
    com.adobe  DocumentServicesBinaries2  null (710.20060629085312.115621) 
    com.adobe  DocumentServicesConfiguration  null (710.20061024154505.342190) 
    com.adobe  DocumentServicesDestProtoService  null (710.20060821084105.325745) 
    com.adobe  DocumentServicesLibrary  null (710.20060629090137.115621) 
    com.adobe  DocumentServicesLicenseDatabase  null (705.20051005114147.242570) 
    com.adobe  DocumentServicesLicenseManager  null (710.20060929113452.336248) 
    com.adobe  DocumentServicesLicenseService  null (710.20060929113452.336248) 
    com.adobe  DocumentServicesLicenseSupportService  null (710.20060929113641.336248)
    </b>
    2) <u>64-bit machine with portal installation on Web AS for Java, with ESS and MSS</u>
    <b>sap.com/SAP-JEECOR  7.00 SP11 (1000.7.00.11.0.20070201154700)  20070308153304 
    sap.com/SAP-JEE  7.00 SP11 (1000.7.00.11.0.20070201154700)  20070308153213 
    sap.com  SAP_ESS  600 SP7 (1000.600.0.7.12.20070314050106)
    sap.com  SAP_MSS  600 SP7 (1000.600.0.7.4.20070321052655)
    sap.com  tc/wd/webdynpro  null (7.0009.20060804145649.0000) </b>
    </i>
    Why do we have to create a new user for the server which is consuming the web service? We already have an user "ADSUser" defined for the Web AS server which has ADS services deployed.
    I have opened this thread to solve the previous unanswered question I posted on SDN Empty area in place of Interactive form. .
    One more thing the adobe print forms of ESS [Total Compensation Statement and Salary Statement] are rendering properly, only the ones with Interactive ability or not.
    thanks,
    Sanketh

    Hello Sanketh,
    1. To access the NW04s configuration guide,
        - Go to https://service.sap.com/adobe
        - On the left frame (tree), under Adobe > Media Library > Documentation
        - On the right had pane you will find the link to the NW04s Configuration guide
    2. The link that you have mentioned below details the steps required to be carried out on the client machine that consumes the Adobe Document Services. In our case that is the j2ee engine on which your Web Dynpro application is running. It could be the same physical machine with two different j2ee instances hosting Web Dynpro and ADS or it could be two different physical machine or a single machine having a single instance of j2ee engine hosting both the Web Dynpro and the ADS.
    You do not have to create a separate username and a password on the consuming machine but you need to configure the Web Service client proxy to point to the ADS (maybe hosted on a different machine) with the username and the password created on the ADS server. As you have mentioned, you have already created such an user on the ADS (ADSUser). This user authentication on the client machine (consuming server - Web Dynpro) would be required at the runtime by the j2ee engine to authenticate itself with the ADS.
    Best Regards,
    Krish

  • How do I Prepare for the Adobe Certified Associate (ACA) exam.

    how do I Prepare for the Adobe Certified Associate (ACA) exam

    I have NO idea where you should ask that question, but THIS forum is about help with installing Cloud programs
    If you will start at the Forums Index https://forums.adobe.com/welcome
    You MAY be able to select a forum for the specific Adobe question you have
    Click the "down arrow" symbol on the right (where it says All communities) to open the drop down list and scroll

Maybe you are looking for

  • Itunes apps dont work in mac !

    i hv OS X 10.8.2 mac, when i dwnload apps from itunes app store on my mac.. they dont work, why??? n if they are only for iphones n ipads then why that facility is given in mac?

  • How can i use iPhone 4s in bangladesh?

    I buy a iPhone 4s in UK with a sim.now I use the phone in Bangladesh.i insert Bangladeshi sim in phone a dialog come screen"activation required".i connect WiFi and try to activate but not active the phone.i have no original sim.why I active and use B

  • I want to listen to BBC4 shows on my

    I have a Zen 20gb (not video) I have tried downloading BBC radio 4 programmes today, which they play through REAL player. I would like to transfer them to my Zen, but they are .ram files, and my creative media source player can't play them. I have re

  • Comment detecter avec LabView une impulsion sur le port série et traiter l'information?

    Je dois automatiser un banc de test avec LabView 7.0. Pour cela il faut que je récupère une impulsion (1 bit, pas de trame) provenant de la carte à tester. Je dois la récupérer via le port série du PC. Je ne sais comment faire, aidez-moi svp.

  • Converting Unicode in File

    I am using an event script (AftExportToDat) to create a file to clear data in the target system. When I open the .dat file (in Notepad) it contains characters like 吀䔀䴀倀㬀㈀ ㄀㄀㬀倀 㘀㬀夀吀䐀㬀䠀䔀开䄀唀匀吀刀䄀䰀䤀䄀㬀㰀䔀渀琀椀琀礀 . I believe it is due to the fact that FDM v11.