SAP XI - Webpshere - complementing each other?

Hello everyone,
we are in a planning process to roll out SAP throughout several locations in Europe. The project will involve upgrading the central location's 4.6C R/3 system to SAP Netweaver. The EDI business scenario in place is built upon SAL ALE/EDI technology and IBM Websphere as an EDI Subystem. Would you please be so kind to enlighten me by answering these 2 questions:
1)     Is XI essential/optional to an Netweaver environment? Quoting a whitepaper,  it “provides a technical infrastructure for XML-based message exchange in order to connect SAP components with each other, as well as with non-SAP components.” what does this mean in a concrete business scenario? What does “SAP components” relate to specifically? R/3 components (MM, SD, FI) or Netweaver components?
2)     What are the pros/cons of integrating XI with Websphere juxtaposed to replacing Websphere with XI entirely? Is XI fully EDI compliant, or if 3rd party tools are to be used to make XI EDI compliant, how do these compare to Websphere in terms of costs and complexity?
Kind regards,
Sven Buttler

1) By SAP Component, they mean pretty much anything with the name SAP attached to it. Either components like BW or Modules like FI (really this is integrating with the underlying Net weaver platform anyway). There are different methods for integrating with SAP systems depending on which versions are been run but they are all supported out of the box. Non SAP systems may require an adapter.
Basically XI is designed to centralize all the integration between SAP Systems, SAP and non SAP Systems (e.g Websphere in your case) and non sap to non sap systems (if necessary). Older methods of integrating will still be supported although XI would be the recommend method.
2) XI requires an additional adapter (at an additional cost) in order to integrate EDI.  There are also specific Websphere adapters from IBM for integrating it with XI. I cant really comment too much on the pro's and con's of either approach, sorry. Maybe try asking on the Exchange Infrastructure forum.

Similar Messages

  • BODS / SAP : what set-ups are required for communicating with each other ?

    Hi.
    There is a new SAP system
    And there is a new BODS installation.
    Both on independent server machines but on the same lan network.
    On the test system of BODS. We tried to see how the communication happens with SAP.
    While we try some test jobs by trying to pull a simple table on SAP R/3
    In Dataflow, we used simple SAPR/3 ABAP flow. And put it into target database thro query transformation.
    In the datastore,
    We used the Generate and Execute option,
    with a path on the local directory of BODS server for creating the ABAP program and the dat file.
    However,
    We are always getting error on batch job schedule.
    Although the user is having rights on the R/3 table
    And can login into SAP R/3 system and check the table.
    Still we get an error saying Databstore unabel to connect to R/3 system. Check for user login etc.
    For anyone whose login we use. We get the error.
    However, if i directly generate the code on the ABAP flow (without running the job),
    make the program available on R/3 system.
    and then run the job as execute preloaded
    this works fine without any error.
    and we are able to see the data in the target table.
    Now both the systems are new.
    And am not aware of the initial set-ups which are required for communication between SAP / BODS.
    Are WE missing something on the SAP side setups - for generate and execute option to be used?
    Is there anything specific to be done for ease of the communication between SAP server and BODS server in this regard.
    Can anyone share some inputs on this.
    Actually for any user with full admin rights too, on the sap side, if we use the user login for R/3 connectivity for this particular "generate and execute" option,  it errors out after nearly 10 minutes. Then the error says, login info not correct.
    So basically, the communication channel by itself between SAP R/3 and BODS seems to be locked somewhere.
    If anyone with SAP admin expertise - can help or advise on this.
    Many thanks
    Indu
    Edited by: Indumathy Narayanan on Sep 13, 2011 9:20 PM

    Getting data out of R/3 requires two distinct setup tasks, and they don't have much to do with each other.
    The first basic task is to get the little ABAP extraction programs loaded and run in R/3.  You can pre-load them and then call them, or generate, upload, and execute them all on-the-fly, at BODS runtime.  During development, use "Generate and Execute" for your ABAP.
    Once that's done, you have four different choices to get the data back: "Direct download", "Shared directory", FTP, and "Customer Transfer". Normally, you'll use either FTP or "Shared directory".  Refer to the documentation (the BODS SAP Supplement) for a description of all this.
    In all cases (or at least, quite certainly, using the FTP and Shared Directory methods), the ABAP extraction programs are directed to plop their output as flat files in the "Working directory on SAP server."  For testing, you can look in that folder to see if any flat files are appearing when you submit an ABAP data flow.  If not, then either 1) your ABAP program isn't getting in there (a Basis admin should be able to tell you), or 2) it's not running (ditto), or 3) it's running but unable to generate the output file (ditto), because a) SAP isn't permitted to write to that folder, or b) the folder doesn't exist (it needs to be defined from the perspective of the SAP server).
    If you do see files appear in the "Working directory on SAP server" when you run a BODS job w/ an ABAP dataflow, then the problem is that BODS can't fetch them.  If you're using the "Shared directory" method, which is suitable for and often used in all-Windows environments, then the account under which the Job Server in question is running must have access to the "Working directory on SAP server," but this time from the perspective of the Job Server.  So if, for instance, SAP was directed to put the flat files on a local folder, say, "E:\USR\SAP\BODS", then you might want to share this folder out as, for instance,
    sapdev1\bods (for an SAP host called "sapdev1"), and then enter "
    sapdev1\bods" in the "Application path to shared directory" field, in your SAP datastore configuration.  If your Job Server service is logging-in as "Local System," though, it won't be able to get there -- it needs to log-in as an AD domain account w/ rights to that share.  Get it?  Try logging in to your BODS job server computer with the AD "service account" setup for use by the Job Server service, and try to open a file on the "Application path to shared directory". If you can't, then BODS won't be able to get data from ECC, either.  FTP works similarly -- if you're using that and having trouble, please re-post.
    Best wishes,
    Jeff Prenevost
    Data Services Practice Manager
    itelligence

  • Keeping messages to different receivers independent of each other

    Hi
       We have a scenario in XI where a message from R3 in EOIO QOS hits XI and then the message has 3 receivers depending upon the content of the payload. Each receiver is a different application that is waiting to receive messages from R3. There is no BPM involved in this scenario.
    What we find is all these three messages are put in the same queue on the receiving side as I see in RWB . So - if one of the receiving systems had an issue ( either in mapping or application error while XI tries to communicate with that end system ) , the other two messages are in queue - and in HOLDING status.
    Our objective is to make these messages to different receiver systems independent of each other with this QOS - EOIO . Am i missing something here ? Is the queue name at the receiving end - not supposed to contain the receiving system name also as a part of it - so that the three queue names are unique and independent of each other ?

    Hi Karthik
    Default behavior of Adapter engine is EOIO. You will see the messages in queue in RWB. When you remove the configuration for "Maintain order at runtime" from interface determination then PI will process the messages independently. But in RWB as its having EOIO you will see the messages under a queue. But expected is PI should process as EO.
    http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw70/helpdata/EN/42/ea20e737f33ee9e10000000a1553f7/content.htm
    Thanks
    Gaurav

  • Logo and text required in the same window adjacent to each other

    Hi experts,
    Kindly provide a solution to get logo and some text adjacent to each other inside a single window using SAP SCRIPTS.

    pass th logo in to paint and add the text u want in to it.......
    and make it as a image file ...
    and use that image in ur script................
    Regards
    Anbu B

  • NetWeaver XI components are not talking to each other

    I am an XI  consultant, i dont have proper Basis support at my client, since they are fond of only ABAP stack.
    They installed netweaver xi from the market place.
    I am unable to import any SWCV (even SAP BASIS) from SLD to IR and IR menu is blank.
    Unable to find list of adapters in Integration Directory.
    RWB -component monitoring is blank .
    SLD- creation of products,SWCV,Technical Sys,Buss Sys is possible.
    In conclusion i can say that they all are not co-operative and not talking to each other
    And also i want to know wheather xi 7.0 is compatable to databases Oracle 8.0.3 and Oracle 8.0.4

    Hi Venkata,
    Does the XI post Installation steps done by the team or not? It seems that there is some steps missing while doing the XI installation. Talk to to the BASIS team and tryu to find out the solution.
    >>> Unable to find list of adapters in Integration Directory.
    Check thisblog for it:
    /people/venugopalarao.immadisetty/blog/2007/03/15/adapter-engine-cannot-be-found-in-integration-directory
    >>> And also i want to know wheather xi 7.0 is compatable to databases Oracle 8.0.3 and Oracle 8.0.4
    In my view, yes. XI is compatible with all the versions of Oracle Database above version 8 but never tried it.
    Reward points if helpful. *
    Regards,
    Subhasha Ranjan

  • How to show masterdata in colums next to each other?

    Hey guys!
    I'm working on a query where we're using a characteristic and several key figures. This characteristic is a masterdata object which shows various user roles belonging to a project.
    What I would like to see in my report is the project name plus the user roles (multiple roles per project!) in the colums, followed by the key figures. Each 'rolecolumn' then shows the name of the user.
    BUT!
    I would like to see the roles (masterdata) next to each other, each in a separate column followed by the key figures.
    Standard SAP shows a role in a colum, then all key figures, then another role, then all key figures again etc.
    Any advice on how to solve this?
    Regards,
    Joost
    Edited by: Joost on Jun 2, 2008 12:09 PM
    Edited by: Joost on Jun 2, 2008 12:10 PM

    Hey Balaji,
    Thanks for your reply. Unfortunately, your solution of drilling down to other reports is not allowed at the customer. Should you have any other solutions, let me know.
    Regards,
    Joost

  • HT204053 I have multiple family members using one apple id account and all of each others information is going onto each others phones/how do i stop this?

    I have multiple family members using one apple id and all of our data is going onto each others phones/how do i stop this?

    Each person needs to have their own separate Apple ID along with their own separate computer user account and iTunes Library.

  • How do I Help Apple Care Stop Warring with Each Other and Fix the Problem with My iPhone that They Acknowledge Creating?

    How Do I Help Apple US & Apple Europe Stop Warring With Each Other And Fix The Problem They Created?
    PROBLEM
    Apple will not replace, as promised, the iPhone 5 (A1429 GSM model) that they gave me in London, UK, with an iPhone 5 (A1429 CDMA model).
    BACKGROUND
    My iPhone 5 (A1429 CDMA model) was purchased this year in September on an existing Verizon Wireless (VZW) line using an upgrade. The purchase took place in California and the product was picked up using Apple Personal Pickup through the Cerritos Apple Retail Store. I will refer to this phone at my "original" phone.
    The original phone was taken into the Apple Store Regent Street in London, England, UK on November 15, 2012. The reason for this visit was that my original phone's camera would not focus.
    The Apple Store Regent Street verified there was a hardware problem but was unable to replace the part.
    The Apple Store Regent Street had me call the US AppleCare. At first they denied support, but then a supervisor, name can be provided upon request, approved the replacement of my original phone with an iPhone 5 (A1429 GSM model) as a temporary solution until I got back in the US. And approved that the GSM model would be replaced with a CDMA model when I came back to the US. I will refer to the GSM model as the "replacement". They gave me the case number --------.
    The Apple Store Regent Street gave me the replacement and took the original. The first replacement did not work for reasons I do not understand. They switched out the replacement several times until they got one that worked on the T-Mobile nano SIM card that I had purchased in England, UK. Please refer to the repair IDs below to track the progression of phones given to me at the Apple Store Regent Street:
    Repair ID ----------- (Nov 15)
    Repair ID ----------- (Nov 16)
    Repair ID ----------- (Nov 16)
    The following case number was either created in the UK or France between November 15 to November 24. Case number -----------
    On November 19, 2012, I went to France and purchased an Orange nano SIM card. The phone would not activate like the first two repair IDs above.
    On November 24, 2012, I went to the Apple Store Les Quatre Temps. The Genius told me that my CDMA phone should not have been replaced with a GSM model in the UK and that this was clearly Apple's fault. They had me call the AppleCare UK.
    My issue was escalated to a tier 2 UK AppleCare agent. His contact information can be provided upon request. He gave me the case number -----------.
    The UK tier 2 agent became upset when he heard that I was calling from France and that the France Apple Store or France AppleCare were not helping me. He told me that my CDMA phone should not have been replaced with a GSM model in the UK and that this was clearly Apple's fault.
    The UK tier 2 agent said he was working with engineers to resolve my problem and would call me back the next day on November 25, 2012.
    While at the Apple Store Les Quatre Temps, a Genius switched the phone given to from repair ID ----------- with a new one that worked with the French nano SIM card.
    Also, while at the Apple Store Les Quatre Temps, I initiated a call with AppleCare US to get assistance because it seems that AppleCare UK was more upset that France was not addressing the issue rather than helping me. I have email correspondance with the AppleCare US representative.
    A Genius at the Apple Store Les Quatre Temps switched the replacement with a new GSM model that worked on the French SIM card but would not work if restored, received a software update, or had the SIM card changed. This is the same temporary solution I received from the Apple Store Regent Street in the UK.
    By this point, I had spent between 12-14 hours in Apple Store or on the phone with an AppleCare representative.
    Upon arriving in the US, I went to my local Apple Store Brea Mall to have the replacement switched with a CDMA model. They could not support me. He told me that my CDMA phone should not have been replaced with a GSM model in the UK and that this was clearly Apple's fault. My instructions were to call AppleCare US again.
    My call with AppleCare US was escalated to a Senior Advisor, name can be provided upon request, and they gave me the case number -----------. After being on the phone with him for over an hour, his instructions were to call the Apple Store Regent Street and tell them to review my latest notes. They were to process a refund for a full retail priced iPhone 5 64BG black onto my credit card so that I could use that money to buy a new iPhone 5 64GB black at the Apple Store Brea Mall to reoslve the problem.
    The Apple Store Regent Street did not process my refund. He, name can be provided upon request, told me that the AppleCare US did not do a good job reviewing my case, that they were incapable of getting to the bottom of it like they were, and instructed me to call AppleCare US and tell them to review this case number and this repair id. I asked if he read the notes from the AppleCare US Senior Advisor and he would not confirm nor deny. When I offered to give him the case number he accepted but it seemed like would do no good. Our call was disconnected. When I tried calling back the stores automated system was turned on and I could not get back through.
    Now I have the full retail price of an iPhone 5 64GB black CDMA on my credit card and Apple will not process the refund as they said they would.
    I've, at this point, spent between 14-16 hours at Apple Stores or on the phone with AppleCare representatives, and still do not have the problem resolved.
    SOLUTION
    AppleCare US and AppleCare Europe need to resolve their internal family issues without further impacting their customers.
    Apple is to process a refund to my credit card for the cost of a full retail priced iPhone 5 64GB black.
    DESIRED OUTCOMES
    I have an iPhone 5 (A1429 CDMA model) that works in the US on VZW as it did before I received the replacement phone in the UK.
    Apple covers the cost of the solution because I did not create the problem.
    Apple resolves their internal issue without costing me more time, energy, or money.
    This becomes a case study for AppleCare so that future customers are not impacted like I have been by their support system.
    Does anyone have recommendations for me?
    Thank you!
    <Edited by Host>

    Thanks, but I've been on the phone with AppleCare US (where I am and live) and AppleCare UK. They continue bouncing me back and forth without helping resolve the problem.
    Perhaps someones knows how to further escalate the issue at Apple?

  • HT3529 My wife and I both have an iphone.   We initially created it under her apple id.   We will receive each others text messages from certain people not all.   Any ideas why and what we can do to stop it

    My wife and I both have an iphone.  We initially set them up under one apple id account.  When we text sometimes we will receive each others text messages from others.   Example I will text a friend...she will not see my text but the reply comes to both of us.  It seems to be random which ones.  Any ideas how to correct this

    Yup, get your own AppleID.
    The messages that are being sent to both phones are technically not text, they are Apple's iMessage. They use the data part, not the texting part. So if you have an iPad or a Mac computer, you can send/receive the iMessages there too.
    KOT

  • How can my bf and I share are itunes on our computer together but with separate apple ID's so we DO NOT receive each others iMessages all the time?

    My boyfriend and I both share an itunes together on my mac book pro, is there away to have seperate apple ID's but both are connected to the shared itunes and have access to all of our purchases? I am asking this becaue since my boyfriend and I both have iphones, we keep revieving each others messages and conversations, and not only is it annoying, but it is an invashion of privacy both ways, on his side and mine. What do we do?
    Can you even change your apple ID on your iphone without losing your contacts, apps, music etc..? Can you even have two apple ID's on one shared itunes? Some help me out here, I am so confused.

    All apps and purchases are linked to your apple ID, so you can't share them across 2 devices that are using different apple id's, it won't work. the purchases that are on your mac at the moment will only work with the apple id they were brought with.
    the only thing thats possible to share is purchased music. you have to first covert it to mp3 within itunes, then your bf can import it into his own itunes library and sync with his phone.

  • HT4865 So who believes Apple should be a bit more cautionary about the sharing of iMessages and other content when several members of a family share the same iCloud account and unknowing can audit each other's iMessages, Contacts, and god only knows what

    I think Apple should be a bit more cautionary about iCloud and privacy.  My family shares the same iCloud account as we all enjoy the music we collectively purchase on iTunes; we paid Apple for this feature with some kind of grouped account.  We didn't know, however that this joins our devices so that iMessages, contacts, pictures and just about everything else is shared too.  The unprivate default seems to be to share everything between all devices vs. to allow access by exception or by choice (or by password?).  Sure, when my kids get all my texts I can go figure out why and fix it but that is in my mind the antithesis of privacy and could be quite embarrassing for any family.  I guess it is good for stalking the kids or parents though if they don't know about the partyline approach to privacy.  Maybe a tech solution would be to have the iPhone show somehow the extent of its audience to its user.

    No argument from me about the vagaries of using and sharing Apple IDs.  This can lead to unintended consequences, especially in a family situation.
    If you're sharing the same ID for FaceTime, you might want to go to Settings>FaceTime, tap the ID, sign out, then sign in with separate IDs there too.  Otherwise, you'll end up getting each other's FaceTime calls.
    Also, if you need to migrate everyone's devices to separate iCloud accounts to keep your synced data separated, you can do this by saving any photo stream photos you wish to keep to your camera roll (unless already there) by opening your my photo stream album, tapping Select, tapping the photos, tap the share icon (box with upward facing arrow), then tapping Save to Camera Roll.  If you are syncing notes with iCloud, you'll need to open each of your notes and email them to yourself so you can later copy and paste the text into new notes created in your new account.  Then go to Settings>iCloud, tap Delete Account (which only deletes it from this device, not from iCloud), choose Keep on My iDevice and provide the password to turn off Find My iPhone.  Then sign back in with a different Apple ID to create your new account and choose Merge to upload your data.  Once everyone's devices are on separate accounts, you can go to icloud.com and delete each other's data from your accounts.

  • I have one Itunes account for myself and children.  Can we facetime each other on different devices?

    I have one Itunes account for myself and my children.  Can we facetime each other on different devices?

    Yes, you can.
    See here: https://www.apple.com/ios/facetime/

  • HT204053 Our family uses one Apple ID for all of our iPhones.  We installed the update and now we are all getting each others photos and texts.  How do we stop this?

    Our family uses one Apple ID for all of our iPhone 5's.  We installed the update and now we are all receiving each other's pictures and texts.  How do we stop this? 

    Have a look here...
    http://macmost.com/setting-up-multiple-ios-devices-for-messages-and-facetime.htm l

  • Can my family use 'find my iphone' for each other if we each have separate apple ids? recently had to create separate ones b/c we were getting each others texts/facetimes and i read this happens when you share an apple id.

    Can my family still use the 'find my iphone' app from our iphones / ipod touch to locate each others phone if we have separate apple ids?  We were sharing a single apple id but recently we started getting each others texts/facetimes .. I read that this happens when you share an apple id.  Will we just have to sign in with the others' apple id to locate their phone ?

    Use Find My Friends app instead.   Much easier to manage, and you won't need each other's id/pw's to do it.   They only need to accept your invitations and vice versa.

  • My MacBook Air (2011) and my iMac (2008) can no longer see each other.

    Hi
    My WiFi is via a TimeCapsule which seems to work perfectly well with the Apple TV, Hot plugs for the TV and my iPhone/iPad but my two computers (above with Mavericks operating system) can't see each other any more.  It's been about a week now.  I have restarted both of them but to no avail.  My MacBook Air has alternate backups to a local USB connected hard drive and Time Capsule and both are working fine.  I've tried looking in System Preferences to see if something's turned off but can't find what I'm looking for.  I tried changing the settings in Airport Utility but that made things worse so I've reverted to the original "Bridge Off" mode.  What has happened or have I inadvertently turned off?
    Many thanks
    Sue Clark

    Ralph Johns (UK) wrote:
    Hi,
    I can see that Accounts/Screen Names can get messed up on the various flags set by an App to and therefore On the AIM servers.
    What I can not see in this case is why it seems to be limited to just one Buddy on each computer.
    As the Block list (And therefore presumably Allow Lists) are not actually shown in the .p0list I ma hoping that deleting it and restarting ichat at one end at least will reset that iChat form the Defaults haled in the app when you do this.
    (you could delete that Account Screen Name from iChat ? Preferences > Accounts to achieve the same things in a more destructive way as it would tend to rewrite all the .plists which may included Jabber ones that are OK
    We both did delete our screen names in iChat, and also deleted ALL the prefs manually.
    Also, we've tried using entirely different computers to log-in to those same accounts, with the same results - somehow we're blocked from each other.
    I think we're both giving up at this stage. We have additional accounts we can use to see each other. But it would be really nice to get to the bottom of it, because if it happens once it can happen again. Who knows? Maybe there are other people in my buddy list that this is happening with right now, but we don't know it. This person just happens to be someone I chat with a lot, and we noticed we weren't seeing each other.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Passing Dynamic Values to a Stored Procedure

    I have a stored procedure to create a Table. How to I pass a value to the procedure to name the Table. This SP works except the name of the table is @newcomm not the value I am trying to pass in. What is the proper syntax to make this happen. CREATE

  • MS Office documents locking itself when user is trying to save it on a network drive.

    As the subject states I am having a issue with a user that when he is trying to save a document it is stating that the file is in use by another user.... for every single document he tries to save to. I made a test account and assigned it to the same

  • Return Delivery - Purchase Order Caracteristics

    Hi, I am trying to use a purchase order to return delivery using the mvt type 161. This is a new business process for us, so we need some help about the order creation, the goods issue and the related configuration. In this moment, the most important

  • Strange border issue

    When printing full images on A4 or 10x15 paper, when I select borderless prints I get a border on 3 sides of the paper, then on the longest side no border at all, i.e. image all the way to the edge. I have to select to print with borders such that I

  • Cannot smb to Windows 2000 Server share (works in 10.4)

    After installing a fresh copy of Leopard on my macbook pro I cannot connect to a previously working share on a Windows 2000 Server using smb. I am using Go > Connect to Server to connect. I am prompted for a username and password but the connection f