Solid state drive= wrong choice for the newmacbookpro 2010?

Hi
i've been exchanging on the logic pro forum about the ssd vs the hdd serial to configure a macbook pro for logic.
I would love to hear your point of view or experience about that .
also since it's the apple forum i hope there should be some advice from technician from apple.
since from logic pro forum i had the point of view of logic pro certified level 1 and 2
here is the links :
http://www.logicprohelp.com/viewtopic.php?t=57664
http://www.logicprohelp.com/viewtopic.php?t=55058&highlight=solid+state
thanks a lot for any comments or experiences.
june

but why is it bad to record internally today
I didn't say it was "bad" as such, I said I'd only do it when necessary (and I do) but I'd generally still record to external drives where possible.
imagine you're having a 500 GB internally you can still back up on a other drive after.
is there any consequence about that kind of configuration?
The thing is, the internal drive is the system drive, so it has all kinds of drive activity going on in addition to audio - swap file reading and writing, loading apps, utilities, logging functions and many more.
i heard about the lifetime too but more from some experience from 2009 but i don't know what
happen with the new model if they upgrade their ssd in anyway?
Time will tell I guess, these technologies are new and unproven over enough time yet.

Similar Messages

  • I have a MacBook Pro, 15-inch, Mid 2009.  I would love to upgrade to a Solid State Drive.  What is the best possible upgrade I can buy.  I need the specs and even brand name.  Thank you to anyone who can help.

    I have a MacBook Pro, 15-inch, Mid 2009.  I would love to upgrade to a Solid State Drive.  What is the best possible upgrade I can buy.  I need the specs and even brand name.  Thank you to anyone who can help.

    A 15" mid-2009 MBP RAM specifications are: 204-pin PC3-8500 (1066 MHz) DDR3 SO-DIMM.
    As has been pointed out, OWC is an excellent source for Mac compatible RAM.  Crucial is another first rate source for Mac RAM.  RAM from either vendor will work just as well as any purchased from Apple with the bonus of being less expensive and having a lifetime guarantee.
    Ciao.

  • How do I copy my operating system to a solid state drive and make it the disk I boot from?

    How do I copy my operating system to a solid state drive and make it the disc I boot from?

    Where is your operating system now? Basically, you clone it from wherever it is now to the SSD:
    Clone Lion/Mountain Lion using Restore Option of Disk Utility
    Boot to the Recovery HD:
    Restart the computer and after the chime press and hold down the COMMAND and R keys until the menu screen appears. Alternatively, restart the computer and after the chime press and hold down the OPTION key until the boot manager screen appears. Select the Recovery HD and click on the downward pointing arrow button.
    Select Disk Utility from the main menu then press the Continue button.
    Select the destination volume from the left side list.
    Click on the Restore tab in the DU main window.
    Select the destination volume from the left side list and drag it to the Destination entry field.
    Select the source volume from the left side list and drag it to the Source entry field.
    Double-check you got it right, then click on the Restore button.
    Destination means the SSD. Source means the drive now holding OS X.

  • My Mac Book Pro has just had a new memory and solid state drive installed. After the installation, the Lightroom tools all became grey. There is no longer any color on the screen other than my picture. Even the color sliders are grey.  Can you please help

    My MacBook Pro just had a new memory and solid state drive installed. Since the installation, the Lightroom tools are now all grey. Even the color sliders are grey. Please help!

    My guess is that your operating system got updated to Mavericks and that you are running an old version of Lightroom:
    Sliders are white, look different | Mac OS X 10.9 Mavericks
    Be aware of a Lightroom bug with color management in mavericks that makes shadows too deep in the Develop module: Jao's photo blog: Serious color management bug in Mac OS 10.9 "Mavericks" and Jao's photo blog: Further quantification of the Mavericks color management problem.

  • Solid State Drive (SSD) Questions for G4 "Sawtooth".

    Below are some questions concerning using a Solid State Drive (SSD) in a G4 "Sawtooth".
    Would a controller card need to be installed for an SSD to work in this machine?
    Would the G4 be able to operate in Classic mode with the SSD?
    Would the G4 be able to boot into OS 9 with the SSD?
    Should the SSD be used only for booting and applications, with user data stored on another drive that does not use SSD technology (such as an ATA or SATA drive)?
    Should only 50% of the drive space be used, in order to ensure optimized performance?
    Would the G4 only be able to use the first 128 MB of drive space of an SSD that has a capacity greater than 128 MB? If so, would either of the below cards enable the G4 to read the entire drive?
    [http://eshop.macsales.com/item/ACARD/AEC6280M>
    [http://eshop.macsales.com/item/ACARD/AEC6880M>
    -John

    Would a controller card need to be installed for an SSD to work in this machine?
    One like this:
    http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Sonnet%20Technology/TSATA/
    Would the G4 be able to operate in Classic mode with the SSD?
    Yes.
    Would the G4 be able to boot into OS 9 with the SSD?
    Depends on the controller card, but with the linked card, it shouldn't be an issue.
    Should the SSD be used only for booting and applications, with user data stored on another drive that does not use SSD technology (such as an ATA or SATA drive)?
    Smaller capacity drives will limit file storage, and keeping OS and applications separate always improves performance, regardless of the drive type.
    http://www.jcsenterprises.com/Japamacs_Page/Blog/00E03B83-1ADA-406E-A940-396D39F 598EA.html
    Should only 50% of the drive space be used, in order to ensure optimized performance?
    SSD's can be filled further, but should maintain 20GB or more for virtual memory.
    Would the G4 only be able to use the first 128 MB of drive space of an SSD that has a capacity greater than 128 MB?
    A controller card removes that limit.
    If so, would either of the below cards enable the G4 to read the entire drive?
    Those controllers will work for and allow use of large capacity ATA drives.

  • Which SSD (Solid State Drive) is good for my 2011 MacBook Pro?

    Okay I am looking for a good ssd for my macbook pro 2011 between the 150$ and 250$ price range. Which company and price would you guys reccomend?

    None, at that price it would be so small as to be practically worthless.
    You need about 500 GB to future proof and grow into, and those run about $1200-$1500
    SSD's really don't offer that much more performance, it still takes the computer 20 seconds to boot and programs still have to set themselves up so. So although the computer and programs launch a bit faster, it's not instant.
    Then to really take advantage of SSD speed, you need to have to have a large amount of files to transfer constantly, to another SSD (or else the slow hard drive slows everything down)
    So if you have 500GB to transfer to another 500GB SSD, then that would take about 30 minutes compared to a hour if you had a hard drive instead.
    And if you transfer a large amount of data often with a SSD, it wears it out prematurely. SSD's don't even have secure erase ability because allowing that would prematurely wear it out.
    So the only thing SSD's are good for are OS boot and program only drives, where little changes, place one's user files on a external 7,200 RPM drive with more space and can handle a large amount of writes and rewrites.
    Unfortuntly in a MacBook Pro you have only one space for a drive, you could use a kit to remove the Superdrive and replace it with the hard drive when you add the SSD. Problem with that is you can't boot from any OS X or Windows install disks that way.
    So there you have it, SSD is crap.
    But if you want to go the SSD + Hard drive with kit route, see Bmer (Dave Merten) who runs Mac Owners Support Group. he will walk you through it all.
    And the fastest SSD's can be found on this chart
    http://www.harddrivebenchmark.net/high_end_drives.html
    https://discussions.apple.com/message/16276201#16276201

  • Inspiron 20 3000 can I add a solid state drive to boot for speed ?

    I'm looking to purchase an inspiron 20 3000. I asked sales if I could get it configured with an SSD drive, and they said no. I'd have to purchase it and then the drive myself. But on Dell's web site I don't see any SSD drives, or hybrids listed as compatible. 
    Anybody know if this is possible ?
    Thanks,
    Ed 

    Hi ekratz,
    The system uses normal 2.5 inch mechanical hard drive with hard drive bracket (hard drive case) as the system can be used for SATA III technology hard drives the system should accept SSD drive but Dell has not tested this system with SSD.

  • OWC 120GB Mercury Extreme Pro 6G SSD Solid State Drive Best SSD for a Mac?

    ive read that OWC is the best for mac. Is this true. what is your recommendations for a SSD for an 08' Macbook

    Yes. Your model has a SATA II bus that only supports up to 3 Gb/s drive interfaces. Thus, there is no point in spending more for a SATA III drive. If you expect you will soon want to move the SSD into a new model that does support the faster interface, then be sure the 6G model is downward compatible with the 3G bus. Most, but not all 6G SSDs are, so it's best to ask first.

  • What is the difference in price of MacBook Pro 13-inch:   2.9GHz750GB and  256GB solid-state drive

    What is the difference in price of MacBook Pro 13-inch:   2.9GHz750GB and  256GB solid-state drive ?

    go to the Store and configure all the models with upgrades but... an SSD will be fast and responsive, no noise or heat and adds $200 probably to the cost
    macbook series forum though, are here (not here)
      MacBook Pro
    https://discussions.apple.com/community/notebooks/macbook_pro
    https://discussions.apple.com/community/mac_os?view=discussions
    http://www.apple.com/support/macbookpro

  • Solid State Drive (SSD) on MacBook Pro unibody (and fast hard drives)

    I've reviewed the 80GB Intel X25-M solid state drive (SSD), along with the Hitachi 320GB Travelstar 7K320, Seagate 320GB Momentus 7200.3, Western Digital 320GB Scorpio Black and Western Digital 500GB Scorpio Blue.
    All of these are great drives for the MBP, but the X25-M really screams for anything with reads, and writes are quite respectable.
    http://macperformanceguide.com/Reviews-SSD.html

    German computer-magazine CT tested SSD drives recently, rating only Intel-SSD's as "faster and more energy-efficient under all circumstances". They are definitely not all the same...

  • Solid state drive

    I have 2 Solid state drives in my computer. For a while they worked fine. Then a couple of weeks ago the main drive stopped working. I got a error message that said  "drive not found". The only way that I could get the main drive (PNY 480 gb) to work, was to reinstall the operating system and disconnect the second drive (SAN DISK 256gb). When I had both drives hooked up, the main drive would not boot-up. Then I would get the error message that said "driver not found". Why did the drives work for a couple of weeks an not they won't work togather. Will 2 SSD's work in my computer?

    Hello @JLAR,
    I have read your post on how the main solid state drive on your desktop computer has stopped working, and I would be happy to assist you in this matter!
    To test the integrity of your solid state drive, I recommend following the steps in this document on Testing for Hardware Failures (Windows 7).
    If the 'hard drive' appears defective, please call our technical support at 800-474-6836. If you live outside the US/Canada Region, please click the link below to get the support number for your region.
    http://www8.hp.com/us/en/contact-hp/ww-phone-assist.html
    I hope this helps!
    Regards
    MechPilot
    I work on behalf of HP
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos, Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!

  • Solid State Drive .vs. 2TB Hard Drive (Finder Sidebar)

    Hello all,
    I just purchased a new 27-inch iMac, which comes with a 256 GB Solid State Drive and a 2 TB SATA Hard Drive.  Before purchasing the iMac, I had read that the Solid State Drive was designed to be used for the System and Applications, while the SATA Hard Drive would be used to store all application data files (Pictures, Movies, Music, etc.).
    However, the Finder Sidebar icons (Documents, Pictures, Movies, Music, etc.) are linked to the associated folders on the Solid State Drive.  So when I click on any of the Sidebar icons, I am directed to the folder contens on the Solid State Drive.
    How do I set up my iMac so that the 2 TB SATA drive is the default storage drive.  I'm guessing that there has to be a way to configure the Sidebar such that when I click on one of the icons (Documents), I'm directed to the Documents folder on the 2 TB Hard Drive and not the Solid State Drive.
    Thanks for any help you can provide.
    Calvin

    Calvin, I am in the exact same boat. Help us someone...

  • Purchase questions: solid state drive and 8GB RAM

    I am finally going to upgrade from my PBG4, and I am salivating over either a 13" or 15" MBPro. Two questions:
    1) A solid state drive is expensive, but the way I abuse laptops, it may be worth it. In addition to being more rugged, what are its other advantages? Is it faster than a 5400 or 7200 rpm hard drive? Does it boot/shut down faster? What else?
    2) I do graphics, so 8GB RAM can help me with Photoshop, etc. If I can get 4GB RAM chips elsewhere cheaper than through Apple, can I upgrade the RAM myself, without voiding the Apple warranty?

    You're probably about as good a candidate as there is for a big (250GB) SSD, but only for the sake of its ruggedness. The current small sizes of SSDs compared to HDs will be a serious disadvantage for anyone who works with a lot of graphics. SSDs are still in their infancy, and there are large variations in speed from one to another and new models coming out almost weekly. Taken overall, any SSD will be as fast or faster (and some are *many, many* times faster) than any conventional notebook hard drive. But some are slower than fast hard drives for certain operations, e.g. sustained large writes. Try to pick one that's fast across the board, because they'll all be highly shock-resistant (and astronomically expensive) compared to any HD. It's going to take a bit of Googling to dig up many reports — I haven't seen any big "roundup"-style tests yet myself, but that doesn't necessarily mean there haven't been any. Here's one test that may or may not be representative:
    http://www.barefeats.com/hard121.html
    With respect to MBPs themselves in your situation, we haven't heard from anyone in these forums since the introduction of the unibody MBPs who has reported how well they've held up to the kind of ultra-rough handling you describe. If there are some uMBPs out there with you, you would know better than we do, and you'd have a better chance than we do to ask how well they survive. Hard drives would certainly be among their most vulnerable parts, but I would also ask pointedly about display hinges, glass display covers, optical drives, and above all, dealing with dust. These machines can't be sealed, and their keyboards and ports can't be cleaned easily or effectively. In a desert setting, I would think keeping a keyboard cover in place, taping over the ports, optical drive slot and speaker grilles when they're not in use, and finding access to a vacuum from time to time would be essential if at all possible. Even so, the fans in these machines run all the time, and they will continually draw dust inside.
    Good luck in your research.

  • Solid State Drives on a Mac

    I am thinking of getting a Solid State drive for the OS only.
    Problems that may a Solid State drive may have with the OS.
    1) Defrag I never thought that Leopard needed to or did Defrag the Drive but a Sales rep for apple at Best buy said he thought that they did once the mac was shut down. This was done he said to make defraging easier were unlike windows you had to tell it to or schedule a time to do it and leave it on.
    From what I read you are not suppose to Defrag Solid state drives.
    If this is true is ether a way to disable it in the OS and if so is their a way to tell it what drives to not defrag?
    2. I also see programs for sale for the Leopard OS that parts of programs that are left over from installs and when you delete something if this is true this is also not good because it will slowly fill up the drive.
    3. If any of the issues above are true I hope the is a work around for it or a update to it to correct this. Hard drives have been the bottle Neck for any OS for a long time and these solid State drives even though new tech seem to be the answer for this.

    Network 23,
    Well, "never" may have been too strong, but I stand by my statement. OS X just doesn't "defragment" in the commonly accepted sense of the word.
    First, it uses "delayed allocation" to reduce the amount- in many cases to zero- of fragmentation that ever occurs.
    Second, it does use "adaptive hot-file clustering," whereby an elite class of the most frequently accessed files are written to the drive's "hot band." The limitation on size is <= 10 MBs (if I am not mistaken), and this does occur dynamically. Since this necessarily eliminate any fragmentation for these files, one could state that dynamic fragmentation is occurring. The amount of data we're talking about here is very small, however, so to classify this as generic "defagmentation" would be a stretch.
    Third, there is one very limited case when a file will actually be rewritten. Several conditions must be met, the most important being that the file in question must have an allocation of over 8 extents. Since this still applies only to files <= 20 MBs, and given the other fragmentation-prevention measures in place, the conditions under which this occurs will be very, very rare. I will grant, however, that in the rare case that these conditions are all met, the file is indeed relocated to an unfagmented allocation when/if it is opened. Yes, this is dynamic defragmentation.
    All this said, "defragmentation" is generally considered to be when a volume is scanned for fragmented file, and those files are all relocated to elimate all fragmentation. This does not occur in OS X.
    Scott

  • Uprading a solid state drive

    Hello All,
    I have a Macbook Pro currently with a 128GB Solid State Drive. I was wondering if it is possible to add to the drives for larger memory or do I just have to completely buy a new Solid State drive which would be the 256 GB I am guessing? If that would be the case is it hard to switch everything over from the drives?

    No, there is no way to increase the capacity of a drive. You will need to buy a new one.
    Replacing it on a MacBook Pro is pretty simple. Take the bottom cover off, and between the HDD and logic board there is a small retaining clip with two PH00 screws in it. Take that off, then carefully lift the HDD up and disconnect the data and power cable. Be careful not to tear that cable, or it will have to be replaced. Then you need to transfer the 4 pins sticking out of the old drive to the new one, those are usually T6 Torx screws, and just put everything back like you found it after that. That retaining bar will only fit on one way, so if the screws don't line up, flip it around.

Maybe you are looking for