Which format to capture home movies into?

I have 100+ hours of home movies on tape starting from 1983. I want to capture them into a computer digital format. But which one? Which format will stay supported the longest time from now? In other words, what format will computers 30 years from now will hopefully still have built in support for it? I sure don't want to have to do this again. What would you recommend and why?
1) AVI (but doesn't it even have problems now requiring the right codecs?)
2) MPEG -2
3) MPEG-4 H.264
4) Some other one?
Thanks!

It will depend on what you wish to do with the material. If you wish to edit it, then DV-AVI Type II would be the ultimate format. Once edited, you can then Export to whatever delivery medium you wish. DVD would be a good one, as you should be able to play DVD's for decades.
Nothing that you can do will be totally future-proof. Everything has a life expectancy, and it is logical that every format available today will not work in 15 years, unless you retain legacy equipment and software.
Since your material is not HD, by any definition, the only advantage to going H.264 and then to Blu-ray (with proper scaling, etc.) would be to have it available should DVD-Video suddenly die. While I do not think that this is likely, it IS possible. CD's are still going fairly strong, but the higher-def formats, SACD, etc., are pretty much dead, even if they offered better audio response. Right now, the market is going towards horribly compressed audio (MP3, etc.) for portability - the heck with quality, so even CD sales are sagging.
If you do undertake the process, I'd recommend purchasing a D-A interface, like the Canopus 300, and also a large external, or two.
Hunt

Similar Messages

  • Can I download DVD home movies into imovies?

    Can I download DVD home movies into imovie to edit and create enhanced DVDs?

    Yes.
    You need to convert the VOB files in the TS-Folder of the DVD back to DV which iMovie is designed to handle. For that you need mpegStreamclip:
    http://www.squared5.com/svideo/mpeg-streamclip-mac.html
    which is free, but you must also have the  Apple mpeg2 plugin :
    http://www.apple.com/quicktime/mpeg2/
    (unless you are running Lion in which case see below))
    which is a mere $20.
    Another possibility is to use DVDxDV:
    http://www.dvdxdv.com/NewFolderLookSite/Products/DVDxDV.overview.htm
    which costs $25.
    For the benefit of others who may read this thread:
    Obviously the foregoing only applies to DVDs you have made yourself, or other home-made DVDs that have been given to you. It will NOT work on copy-protected commercial DVDs, which in any case would be illegal.
    If you are running Lion:
    From the MPEG Streamclip homepage
    The installer of the MPEG-2 Playback Component may refuse to install the component in Lion. Apple states the component is unnecessary in Lion, however MPEG Streamclip still needs it.
    To install the component in Lion, please download MPEG Streamclip 1.9.3b7 beta above; inside the disk image you will find the Utility MPEG2 Component Lion: use it to install the MPEG-2 Playback Component in Lion. The original installer's disk image (QuickTimeMPEG2.dmg) is required.
    The current versions of MPEG Streamclip cannot take advantage of the built-in MPEG-2 functionality of Lion. For MPEG-2 files you still need to install the QuickTime MPEG-2 Playback Component, which is not preinstalled in Lion. You don't have to install QuickTime 7.

  • Imprting home movies into IT7

    I have been able to import (if that is the right word) my edited home movies into iTunes 7. I think this will be a neat way to organize these.
    These are movies initially edited and then saved out of iMovie as CD-ROM quality QuickTime movies, and stored in a folder called "Completed Movies" inside my "Movies" folder. I have been able to use iTunes to categorize them by year, genre, etc. I think this will work rather well to organize my movies, and may motivate me to clean up all the loose video I have on my hard drive.
    Questions? Have I really imported these movies into iTunes7? Or as I suspect, is iTunes just acting as a organizer of all this data, be it music, movies, podcast, etc? Depending on how iTunes work, how do I then upgrade to another Mac and keep all the organization intact? THANKS!
    iMAC G5   Mac OS X (10.4.7)  

    I think only mp4 variants work.  Definitely not mpeg2 or Flash.  If you have mp4s you could try changing the extension to .m4v
    iPod 101: Which Files Work With iPod and iTunes - http://support.apple.com/kb/TA38530

  • How do I import a home movie into I movies from a video camera when it says format not valid

    How do you import a home movie straight from your video camera to i movies when it advises format not recognised.

    iMovie
    http://www.apple.com/support/imovie
    http://www.apple.com/support/ilife

  • Best file format for 8mm home movie conversion

    Hi there,
    I'm about to get some old 'standard' 8mm home movies from the 60s & 70s converted to DVD as a Christmas gift for my mum.
    The transfer company will also supply the footage as files to view/edit on my mac at a later date. I'm a complete iMovie novice so my question is, which file format should I choose?
    They're offering AVI, MPEG 4, WMV, .MOV or Pro Res files.
    Many thanks in advance for your help...
    Jon Howard
    PS I'm running iMovie '08 (7.1.4) & OS X 10.6.8 on an intel 13" macbook in the UK (PAL area).

    Pro Res in potentially the best, but you would need Final Cut Pro, not iMovie, to edit it.
    It is difficult to advise you without knowing the technology they are using. Are they capturing in High Definition progressive or Standard Definition interlaced?
    I found a US company that would scan the 8MM at 1080P. They provided the files in Motion JPEG format. This proved to work great in iMovie.
    If they are doing Standard Definition, I would say go for DV if they can. MOV is generally good, but MOV is a container, not a codec, so it depends on what is inside it.
    Here is a post where I discussed the results.
    Here is a link to the company that did it. http://www.mymovietransfer.com/
    Here is a sample of the results. Watch in full screen if you can.

  • Bringing in DVD home movies into QT question

    My mini-DV tape camcorder is on the blink, so today I purchased a Panasonic mini DVD camcorder that doesn't have firewire [it has USB 2] and since my old Mac only has USB 1.1 and firewire I have a question.
    My question: I've read that QT pro can bring dvd home movies in. How does one or what does one do to bring in a DVD home movie to QT pro? My purpose for doing this in the future is to share clips from the home movies via email to family and friends [I know they will be small and compressed but family and friends still really enjoy seeing them in an email].
    Further information: my old Mac also has a [firewire connected] Lacie DVD burner that can read and burn to most any DVD format [dvd-r, dvd+r, and even can accept mini DVD's and read them]. The Panasonic mini DVD camcorder I bought today is the model number VDR-D230.

    I made and finalized my first mini dvd movie on the camera today to test it in the Lacie external drive connected to the Cube.
    Concerning the comparison between Handbrake and Streamclip. Does either allow one to record only parts of the dvd home movie on the fly and exclude other parts. From using Handbrake, I think the last time I used it, that Handbrake basically converted an entire dvd to QT (or mpeg which is readable by QT). I may be wrong about Handbrake because I can only remember using it twice. Is Streamclip better at this, meaning can Streamclip allow me to record only parts of the dvd home movie on the fly to a format that QT can recognize, or does it work in the same fashion as Handbrake when it comes to this area. Also, I should mention that the Panasonic dvd camcorder does come with software called ImageMixer 3 - but after reading about ImageMixer 3 in the manual it requires a 1ghz G4 mac, and I'm only at 450 currently (I could upgrade my cube's processor to a dual g4 (costs almost as much as buying a mini mac or better yet even a single g4 (1.8 ghz speed for $249). I probably won't go the route of ImageMixer 3 since I just bought a $400 camcorder but it was an idea that crossed my mind (until I read about it's requirements) - I am wondering if ImageMixer 3 is good software though.
    I did notice you said one can buy a plug in for QT that allows it to see dvd movies. I wonder how that works. I know with my prior mini dv tape camcorder qt would allow me to play the tape (while connected via firewire) and make a movie on the fly and could choose (as it played) when I'd click record and stop (while in qt). Does the plug in for QT for around $20 that allows it to bring in a dvd home movie allow QT to work in a similiar way? If so, for $20 it's a no brainer and I'll dish out the $20 right now.
    By the way, I'm not looking at doing in major serious video work here or looking for high quality video. My reason for doing this is to get a low quality small short clip into an email that can be viewed, amuse the parents and friends, and is small enough to email (like qt sharing did with my prior mini dv tape camcorder that went on the blink).
    As a follow up to finalizing my first mini dvd on this camcorder. I made a mistake by following the young salesman's recommendation to use the mini dvd-r dual layer disks. When I inserted it into my Lacie which I thought could read anything [and it can read and burn cd, dvd-r, dvd+r] I quickly learned it could not read a dual layer mini dvd disk. Thankfully, I have 2 dvd players connected on top of my tv [one is a dvd burner) and did a copy of the mini dual [I tested and both of them could read the mini dual - the must have been manufactured after the Lacie was]. I know this is not the best solution, since I think the mini dual was converted into an analog signal and then recorded to another dvd [but it was a workable solution to get the dvd to be recognized and pulled into my Mac]. I'll buy some mini dvd's tomorrow for the camcorder that aren't dual layer and test in the Lacie (they should work - I hope). I know it's definitely not advisable [or would work] to try to insert any mini dvd into straight into my Cube [always use the Lacie drive with mini's since it's tray loading, eh].
    p.s. I was just informed by Handbrake of this update [dunno if the update changes anyones thinking on Handbrake], but here's the link
    http://handbrake.m0k.org/

  • Can I import AVI QuickTime home movies into iTunes

    I have some home movies I would like to place into my iTunes. I take the icon of the movie, and I place it over the iTunes and a plus sign appears, however when I release the mouse, the movie does not imports into iTunes.
    I have also tried to go to the iTunes menu, choosing file, add to library and choosing the file. But it does not work ether. I still do not see that the video has been imported into my iTunes.
    Can any one tell me what am I doing wrong?
    I thought it would be easy to import my videos to iTunes.
    The music videos I have downloaded from the iTunes store have downloaded well. Are they a different format?
    Hope you can help.

    I don't think iTunes will take AVI files directly. You will have to convert it.
    Frequently asked questions about viewing and syncing video with iTunes and iPod
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1708
    GUIDES TO: Converting Video for iPod - Mac & Window
    http://forums.ilounge.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=123067
    The Complete Guide to Converting Video to iPod Format (Mac)
    http://www.ilounge.com/index.php/articles/comments/the-complete-guide-to-convert ing-video-to-ipod-format-mac/
    See other tutorial articles over at iLounge...
    http://www.ilounge.com/index.php/articles/tutorials/
    Cheers,
    Patrick

  • How can I get my own home movies into the Video app in iOS 5

    How can I get my own home movies to be visible in the Video app in iOS 5.
    where do I place them and what format does iPhone want it to be in?
    thanks

    Thanks for this info Johnathan, it answers part of my question about format.
    I also want the videos I'm transfering to be visible in the "Video" app on my iPhone (I dont have an iPad, Yet. )
    Right now, in order to see my videos I have to share iPhoto albums/etc.. from within iTunes. this mixes them up within the "Photo" app. Don't get me wrong, that is great, at least I can see them there in an album I made for "Home Movies". but I would like to know if there is a way to make them visible to the "Video" app which has catagories like "Podcast" & "Music Videos".
    I'd lke to add a "Home Movies" catagory there and
    Has anyone out there done this?
    Ance again, thanks for the info

  • Old home movies into iMovie

    My father-in-law had some old home movies put onto a DVD and I wanted to put them with music with iMovie how can up convert the old movies on the DVD into a format I can use in iMovie. I copied the disc onto my computer using disc utilty and came up with a .cdr file
    thanks

    You can extract video from a DVD, but you will lose some quality.
    http://www.dvdxdv.com/NewFolderLookSite/Products/DVDxDV.products.htm
    Have a look at this thread for a bit more information:
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=4562113&#4562113
    A simpler method would be to just put the DVD in a DVD player, connect your miniDV camcorder to the player and just record the DVD to DV tape that way. There would be some loss of quality, but if the original movies were VHS or even the old reel-to-reel tapes, the loss would probably not be detectable. I have done this on occasion, and it worked fine. Having old VHS footage on a DVD improved it quite a bit, so recording from DVD to DV camcorder still produced a movie that was better than the original.

  • Scanning DVDs (of home movies) into iMovie?

    I am working on making a movie for a family event.
    I have two questions:
    1. I have a lot of home movies that we had transferred from video to DVD. Is there some way to scan the DVD and then just import the segments I want into iMovie? As these are not commercial, there is no protection -- would like to put in comptuer, scan video, and select clips to put in iMovie
    2. I have some older movies with clips that I would like to use in iMovie 6 -- should I stick to iMovie6 or use iMovie 7? I know how to use iMove6, but am happy to learn the new one. Just want something easy to use. End product will be projected on large screen at family gathering.
    Would any sort of video grabber help?
    thanks for your help!
    Paul

    1. I have a lot of home movies that we had transferred from video to DVD. Is there some way to scan the DVD and then just import the segments I want into iMovie? As these are not commercial, there is no protection -- would like to put in comptuer, scan video, and select clips to put in iMovie
    Most direct approach would be to simply copy the non-zero VOB title sets from the DVD to a local hard drive and then convert them to DV (useable with either iMovie HD or iMovie '08). I would personally use MPEG Streamclip (free but requires the $20 QT MPEG-2 Playback component) here so I can flag the content as either 4:3 or 16:9 for proper handling by iMovie '08, but many applications can actually perform the conversion -- including iSquint (free), FFmpegX (donation-ware), Visual Hub (pay-ware), MPEG2 Works (pay-ware but also requires the $20 component), etc.
    2. I have some older movies with clips that I would like to use in iMovie 6 -- should I stick to iMovie6 or use iMovie 7? I know how to use iMove6, but am happy to learn the new one. Just want something easy to use. End product will be projected on large screen at family gathering.
    If the editing you wish to perform is more or less traditional, then iMovie HD offers more "traditional" options. iMovie '08 is probably better suited for "lite" edits requiring simple titles/transitions coming from non-DV source files and destined for immediate online posting. Since many of their functions overlap, in many cases either can be used. As you become more proficient in their use, you will like lend to lean towards one over the other depending on you specific project requirements, so it is probably best to keep both handy.

  • Importing home movies into itunes

    i know that you can import home movies from imovie into itunes and then import it onto your ipod, but im not sure on how you do that.

    Go to the "FIle" menu, select "Export", and select the iPod icon. Only works in iMovie 6.0 (iLife '06).

  • Imprting home movies into iTunes7

    I have been able to import (if that is the right word) into iTunes 7. I think this will be a neat way to organize and store these.
    These are movies initially edited and then saved out of iMovie as CD-ROM quality QuickTime movies, and stored in a folder called "Completed Movies" inside my "Movies" folder. I have been able to use iTunes to categorize them by year, genre, etc. I think this will work rather well to organize my movies, and may motivate me to clean up all the loose video I have on my hard drive.
    Question? Have I really imported these movies into iTunes7? Or as I suspect, is iTunes just acting as a organizer of all this data, be it music, movies, podcast, etc? Depending on how iTunes work, how do Ithen upgrade to another Mac and keep all the organization intact? THANKS!

    I think only mp4 variants work.  Definitely not mpeg2 or Flash.  If you have mp4s you could try changing the extension to .m4v
    iPod 101: Which Files Work With iPod and iTunes - http://support.apple.com/kb/TA38530

  • Compress dvd home movie into one vob?

    I have created a home movie in imovie and then transferred it back to my camcorder and burned it onto a dvd. There are 5 vob files containing the entire movie. Is there any software to "join" all of the parts to upload to the internet?

    ladybug-1969 wrote:
    I have created a home movie in imovie and then transferred it back to my camcorder and burned it onto a dvd. There are 5 vob files containing the entire movie.
    sure, a vob for the menu, a vob for the autostart (even when empty), a vob for the first 20min of project..
    vobs are part of the videoDVD standard, a delivery file .. no 'format' for further processing.
    plus, any re-and-back-and-forth-conversion doesn't add any quality to your video, these formats are all lossy.
    upload your iMovie (in case you use iM08/09, this is just a click away, Share).
    or, export from within iM (vers. 6,5,4,...) in needed resolution... upload that.
    but converting backwards from DVD?? is .. sorry .. nonsense.
    esp. when it is a iMovie project AND the video exist on tape!
    import tape - upload.
    ahh, and welcome ladybug 1969 to the  boards ..

  • How do I put dvd home movie into photoshop to edit

    I have converted old Family movies to DVD and am trying to download into Photoshop to edit and burn copys can this be done?  Try to get done before christmas for family gifts and I don't know how to do it please help.

    If you mean Premiere Elements and and not Photoshop Elements, probably. If so, you want to ask in their forum:
    http://forums.adobe.com/community/premiere_elements

  • Apple TV vs. PS3 for photos & home movies

    I'm sure some of you have both of these units and have a comparison as to which unit displays photos & home movies better (sharpness, color, etc.) I recently bought the Apple TV and I'm not that impressed with the photo quality and 960x540 home movie recoding quality. The PS3 outputs at 1080p, and should be superior to the Apple TV in quality. I know you can use the Medialink software on the PS3 to interface with my Mac's iphoto & itunes.
    Looking for some real world comparisons from owner's of both systems.
    Thanks guys

    I own both, use a Mac for my computer, and have owned my PS3 longer than the Apple TV.
    Honestly, the PS3 sees more use than my ATV. However, for simple viewing of iTunes media on my HDTV, the ATV works well whereas I know I'd have issues with the PS3.
    I use a transcoding media app on OSX that allows me to browse through my videos on my PS3 as if my iMac were a media server. The system works quite well, honestly. I'd say that it is EASIER in a way to view non-Apple-formated videos this way, but if it is a standard that iTunes or ATV can play in HD, then the ATV works better and outputs it at the HD res without transcoding loss like I'd see through the PS3-media server linkage.
    For example: I have all of Farscape and Babylon 5 bought through the ITMS and thus watch it on my HDTV via the ATV. Also, my other videos that iTunes plays play though the ATV perfectly well without some of the network hitching I get when trying to view them transcoded via the PS3 media server (I'm convinced this is a case of my iMac needing more RAM to let my 2 cores do their work..... if only I had the new 27" iMac.... drool . . . . 4 cores available do to the encoding.....) for the HD versions (for example, the HD version of the popular "where the **** is matt" youtube video).
    As an iTunes interface to an HDTV, the ATV does its job and does it well (with some caveats). Outside of that, the PS3 excels. Also, HD movies through the ITMS are nothing compared to their blueray counterparts. Then again, the PSN video store pales in comparison to the ITMS. Star Trek is available in HD through the PSN video store, but the audio is only in 2ch stereo. Sad. I have the movie on blu-ray (which has the audio in 5.1 Dolby TrueHD), so I'm not sure what the HD version is on the ITMS.
    I see the 2 systems (ATV and PS3) as complementing each other. My PS3 is my blu-ray player, non-iTunes video player, and game system. My ATV is my iTunes interface for my Home Theater system. However, as I live in an apartment, I more generally just use my apple remote and control the audio on my iMac directly. Still, the ATV is quite useful for nights when I just want to rent a video (the PSN video store is lacking,and the new netflix service for the PS3 requires a Netflix authorization disc to use in the PS3.... most likely due to contractual agreement..... (thankyou M$ for binding Sony's hands like that, you know you're the ones who did that with your money paid to Netflix). The ITMS through the ATV is therefore easier for me to use and more expansive on video selection (though I still have yet to see Gods and Generals appear on the ITMS video store.... grrr), so for HD rental, the ATV is the choice I make.
    As far as photos.... since my Photos are in the standard place on my mac, the ATV is more readily there to display them all than is my PS3, which would require me to have up and running the media server app on my Mac (which I don't always have running).
    So, like I said, the 2 systems complement each other. Still, for the specific use you're talking about, I think the ATV does just fine. However, if you're looking for a comprehensive system, I might suggest the PS3 first, as you get the PSN, blu-ray player, and game system all in one. If you can, though, BOTH is even better (and affordable since the PS3 Slim now came out.... though I have been hearing gripes about some problems with people's PS3 Slims.... but that's in Sony's Disc. forums, and it is like the ones here: kind of an emergency room).

Maybe you are looking for