Who is blocking video Airplay for websites, is it Apple or the website?

I have to think the reason I can't share video from most websites to my TV is not due to technological limitations, but due to either Apple or the website owners themselves deliberately withholding from us this functionality. The reason I think this is because I've found a way to trick Airplay and/or the website to share the first ~15 seconds or so of the video to my TV. If you have an iPad and an AppleTV, here's how to Airplay share at least a portion of video from a website that's seemingly non-compatible for video Airplay sharing:
1. On your iPad, go to any website with a video you'd like to watch on your TV (I tried it out on cnn.com).
2. Tap to play the video on you iPad2.
3. Tap to share the video to your AppleTV via AirPlay. Except for a few select sites like Vimeo and I think You Tube, you will see that you can only share the audio to your TV, not the video. I'm having you do these first three steps just to prove the video is not compatible with Airplay sharing.
4. Now go to vimeo.com and play a video. I'm not sure this works with every video, so try out this one (don't worry, it's rated G): http://vimeo.com/14853945 When I played it I had HD selected so HD was highlighted in blue. Tap to share to your AppleTV (you should in this case be able to share both the audio and the video).
5. Now go back to that same website you were at before, tap the same movie to play it, and then tap to share to your AppleTV over AirPlay. This time around, you'll notice that you can in fact share both the audio and the video to your TV. However, after around 15 seconds or so it kicks you off so you are no longer able to share that video to your TV.
I think that's interesting. Does anyone know why that would be? My guess is that it's because once you can share anything you want from the web to your TV, you might no longer need to receive any cable broadcast, and, as an example, if you watch CNN on your TV straight from the Web, CNN doesn't get any money from that, whereas if you watch over cable or satellite, they already have an arrangement whereby the cable/satellite providers pay royalties back to the various TV networks for the right to distribute their content to our televisions.
However, I think it's already possible to share anything from the web to your TV, even on an iPad, right? I believe that that digital AV adapter allows you to fully mirror whatever is on your iPad to your TV already, doesn't it? If that's the case, why bother blocking the functionality via Airplay when we already have the option via an HDMI hookup?
This is all very interesting to me. My stepdad thinks in ten years the broadcasting landscape will have totally changed the way we watch TV. Rather than pay Comcast or DirecTV to distribute your content, you will access your content through a tablet or other device which you would then have mirrored on your TV.
I think my stepdad's wrong. I give it two years. Two years from now I think many of us will no longer pay Comcast or DirecTV for our content, and aside from sports and news, there will no longer be a schedule for when a program is on TV. Everything will be on demand. It's pretty much that way now anyway for anyone who has a DVR.

Thanks for all of the commentary. I posted this before I received my iPad2. I now have an iPad2 and while I've successfully mirrored it to my TV, I find it useless for mirroring anything other than video (because webpages, etc. look like crap on the TV) and the mirroring only works about half the time, if that.
At least half of the time when I plug the digital AV adaptor into the back of my iPad2, I get nothing on the TV. I think this is because it's a really long HDMI cable (cuz who wants to have to sit right next to your TV?) and I run it through an HMDI hub because my TV only has one HDMI input and I need 3-4 HDMI inputs (one for my DVR, one for my AppleTV, one for my HD camera, one for my DVD player and one for my iPad if I want to mirror it, which I won't if it continues to be so inconsistent).

Similar Messages

  • I am trying to use firefox as the web lauch for citrix ica but when I go to login into remote site - I get the message waiting to find website but it nver finds the website. Has anyone else had this problem?

    I am trying to use firefox as the web lauch for citrix ica client but when I go to login into remote site - I get the message waiting to find website but it nver finds the website. Has anyone else had this problem?
    When I installed firefox, it asked if I wanted to use safari settings and I said yes but I think this might be causing the problem. Safari is no longer compatible with citrix ica client. When I reinstalled firefox it automatically installs the safari info. Does anyone know how to re-install firfox without installing safari info?

    Did anyone ever suggest you reset your PRAM?
    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=2238
    Also might want to try resetting the SMC, although I
    doubt there's an issue there.
    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=304123
    I'm getting tired of people who supposedly know what
    they're doing simply guessing that resinstalling the
    OS might solve the issue. It's like trying to dissect
    a frog with a sledge hammer, and wondering why you
    didn't learn anything about anatomy in the process.
    These sorts of things, although bizarre, should be
    (and probably are) fixable without major surgery.
    Thanks for the suggestion... but I think my first question would be why these parameters would need re-setting? This is a new machine... It has never been shut down hard. It is used at most 10 hours per week... mostly using Office 2004 for MAC. I need to figure this out as I will soon need it as a Cs2/CS3 - Aperture workhorse.
    I too agree that it is best not to use a sledge when a scalpel is needed... but as a novice to the MAC world I may have been misled by Apple support. I seems to have fixed the symptoms ( some) but appears NOT to have addressed the cause... which is what I am after.
    Would TechTool Pro detect a bad HD or RAM?
    Thanks....

  • Who do i get lion for free, when i bought it the 17/6

    Who do i get lion for free, when i bought it the 17/6?

    If you are in the US go here:
    http://www.apple.com/macosx/uptodate/
    It could be in your country's Apple website like this (Canada - ca):
    http://www.apple.com/ca/macosx/uptodate/
    If its not there then try the regional apple website like:
    http://www.apple.com/asia/macosx/uptodate/
    Country chooser page:
    http://www.apple.com/choose-your-country/

  • I'm new to Mac and I have a Mac Mini. Could you please tell me how I could paste an URL to a video downloader like "Coolmuster Video Downloader for Mac"? I can copy the url but I could not paste it on the downloader. I appreciate your help to my problem.

    I'm new to Mac and I have a Mac Mini. Could you please tell me how I could paste an URL to a video downloader like "Coolmuster Video Downloader for Mac"? I can copy the url but I could not paste it on the downloader. I appreciate your help to my problem.

    Is this happing because the external is formatted to PC and not mac?
    Yes that is correct.
    Will I need to get a mac external hard drive if I wish to continue to save my documents like this?
    If you no longer use a PC you could format this drive for the Mac. However be aware that formatting a drive will erase all the data on it. So you would need someplace to copy the data off this drive to while you did the re-format and then you could copy the data back.
    You could get another drive, format it for the Mac and copy the data to it. Then re-format the original drive and use it as a backup drive. Always good to have backups.
    Post back with the drive type and size of the current drive, if you are doing backups now and how and if you still need to access this drive from a PC.
    regards

  • Why can't I set up POP/IMAP emails for my Muse website in Business Catalyst? I don't have the option 'use this service for email as well as hosting the website' under Advanced options

    Why can't I set up POP/IMAP emails for my Muse website in Business Catalyst? I don't have the option 'use this service for email as well as hosting the website' under Advanced options.
    Is this due to my Hosting Plan? Appreciate any answers.

    Your site is a CCM site which is on a WebBasics plan (This plan does not provide hosted emails on Business Catalyst).
    If you want to create email addresses on this site, you would need to setup your email server elsewhere and configure the MX records on your site to point to that external mail server.
    If you want to use Business Catalyst's hosted email services you would need to use a WebBasics+ or higher siteplan. To upgrade your CCM free site, Access your site's admin area  -> Site Management -> Upgrade Now -> choose the desired site plan and billing frequency -> Add personal and credit card details -> Submit.
    Please refer this article about setting up email accounts on your BC site: http://docs.businesscatalyst.com/user-manual#!/site-settings/email-users
    For setting up records to point to external mail server, check out http://docs.businesscatalyst.com/user-manual#!/site-settings/email-users/creating-inboxes- for-your-users
    Regards,
    Surjeet

  • I have upgraded my iPhone 4S to ios 6... I am surprised to see that the wi-go option is grayed out.. I did reset all the setting but no luck... Is there any fix coming for this or will apple exchange the device??? I want wi-fi option back

    I have upgraded my iPhone 4S to ios 6... I am surprised to see that the wi-go option is grayed out.. I did reset all the setting but no luck... Is there any fix coming for this or will apple exchange the device??? I want wi-fi option back

    Seems like a wide spread problem. See this post: https://discussions.apple.com/thread/4310121?tstart=0

  • I Had 4 more Months Left for My One to One but the Website is all of the Sudden...

    Hello-
    I purchased the One to One after the first year was over because I received an email asking if I wanted to purchasee another year. all was good, I was using it mostly for my MBP and I would go to the website for the Apple Store near me, sign in and reserve a time for a One to One appointment.  I recently saw that the local apple Store had changed their website around, and I did not attend a One to One for about 4 months. I purchased an iPhone 5 and went to the Apple Store to purchae Applecare for the new iphone.  I was curious so I asked the sales guy to check how much I had left for the One to One.  he said about 4 months. when I came home I tried to sign in on the website I used before and it keeps saying 'this apple ID does not have any One to One sessions left.  I looked at my receipt and I should have about 4 months left.  I have no idea who to contact. I called the store and the person who answered the phone told me they cannot take care of this at the store level.  he did not know who to send me to.  Does anybody have any idea who I can call to get help with trying to get the 4 months back?  when I did get the iPhone 5 recently, I did have trouble getting to sign into iCloud, but I went to the website and signed in twice there and that did something that allowed me to sign in to icloud on my iPhone.  I do not know if that had anything to do with it, but it is the same Apple ID and password.
    thanks for any help you can give me.

    May be your carrier but try a reset:
    Hold the Sleep/Wake and Home buttons until the screen goes dark and the Apple logo appears

  • I just bought the new 2014 Mac Mini 2.6 8Gig for $699 at the Apple Store Online. I want to use it for light editing in iMovie making video's for YouTube, I couldn't afford the higher priced models. Is this going to work for me? I hope so..

    Will this do basic video editing for YouTube Video's in iMovie, I hope so.  It's all I could afford.
    Just under $800 with tax and Applecare.
    It's stock 2.6 8gigs 1 terabyte hard drive.
    I have two monitors DVI that I plan to hook to it.
    I know it's weak but will it get me going without too much hardship.
    I want to grow into the more high priced computers and Final Cut Pro later on.
    I know I will need a bigger computer then.
    Thanks

    There are many people using the basic (i5) 2012 MacMini and even older ones to edit complex films in FCP X so you should have no problems.
    I have been using FCP 7 and FCP X since they came out on my 2008 iMac Core 2 Duo and am thinking of getting the same model as you rather than pay the astronomic price for a new 27" iMac.
    The performance won't be quite as fast but it will be at least 4 times faster at rendering than my old iMac.

  • I'm on a website and can't access the website because it states that my security settings are too high, how do i lower them on firefox?

    The website i am on also shows what to do in explorer by lowering the privacy settings bar, but i'm not sure what to do on firefox's browser.

    That is usually a problem with cookies, so make sure that you allow cookies.
    You can see the permissions for the domain in the current tab in Tools > Page Info > Permissions
    See also:
    * [[Cookies]]
    * [[Enabling and disabling cookies]]

  • I want to upload files to my website. I can open the website with ftp, but I do not see any possibility to upload my website html pages..?

    I have a website and I have all the rights to it. Now I want to upload my html pages, but I cannot see how I do this with firefox.

    Hi,
    You can add enhanced functionality using the [https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/fireftp/ FirefFTP] add-on. The installed add-ons are listed in Firefox ('''Tools '''('''Alt''' + '''T''') > '''Add-ons'''. Please also go through the reviews, ratings, FAQ and help. There could also be similar add-ons.
    [http://fireftp.mozdev.org/help.html FireFTP support]

  • When I search for a website, then click on it, the website will not load as the following has been added to the address - &vm=r

    I have been experiencing this issue for several days. I look up a website or subject. When I find something that looks good and click on it, it tells me that site can not be found. If I look at the address that is listed above, on the end has been added &vm=r. If I delete this and hit send the site then opens.

    Ii want to thank you for your help in resolving this issue I was having.
    By doing as you suggested by using the safe mode process, it did work, I also noticed that it also shortened the very long address as well.

  • Need a video card for Dual G5 w/ Apple 23" LCD

    The ATI Radeon 9600 Pro AGP video card has died in my Dual G5 1.8GHz. I ordered the machine CTO with that card in October 2004 because I was doing some amateur video and graphics work.
    Having changed career paths completely my big-bad Mac has been relegated to bookkeeper and web-surfer status so I no longer need any more video horsepower than is necessary to drive the Apple 23" LCD.
    Please suggest a fair to good card I can get as a replacement, preferable at or near $100.
    Thanks for the help!!

    Here is a selection of video cards which will all fit your particular model G5:
    [http://eshop.macsales.com/MyOWC/Upgrades.cfm?model=206&type=Video&TI=2503&shoup grds=Show+Upgrades]
    These are available from OWC in the Chicago area; very reputable dealer, and good prices.

  • Need custom button for Thunderbird for FF toolbar; Don't know the website.

    I have had a Thunderbird Custom Button for my FF toolbar and have lost it. This happened once before had someone gave me a website where all of the old custom buttons qwe listwed and I was able to drag & drop the button from there. Unfortunately I do nor had that website and hope that someone will be able to provide it for me. Thanks.

    Take a look at [http://www.google.com/search?q=Thunderbird+Custom+Button+for+my+FF+toolbar&sourceid=mozilla-search&start=0&start=0&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8num=100 this search]

  • Video tutorial for removing entire display assembly with the apple logo on white Macbook?

    Hi, my Macbook has a bad display screen and I've been using it hooked to an external monitor for a while. I would like to swap out the display from another parts Macbook. I searched Google and all the videos I saw shows the display assembly already removed and the LCD panel within the assembly being replaced. I need to change the whole assembly though as there is a crack in the plastic near the apple logo. Anyone know of any video tutorials to do this like on Youtube or somewhere else? Thanks

    iFixit have good step by step guides with clear photographs, if you follow this link you can select your model of MacBook:
    http://www.ifixit.com/Device/MacBook

  • When I use iMovie 11 to capture HD video from my Handycam, there is a loss of quality that is very noticable when vewing on apple tv3.  What is the best way to get full HD video quality for home movies on apple tv?

    I currently capture HD 1080i video from my Handycam using iMovie 11, then convert the .mov files to .mp4 using Aunsoft Video Converter.  Then view the videos on apple tv.  The quality is definitely lacking.  Not sure if the loss of qulaity is from using iMovie 11 or the Aunsoft software.  Any ideas on how to capture HD qulaity video and view on Apple TV?

    I currently capture HD 1080i video from my Handycam using iMovie 11, then convert the .mov files to .mp4 using Aunsoft Video Converter.  Then view the videos on apple tv.  The quality is definitely lacking.  Not sure if the loss of qulaity is from using iMovie 11 or the Aunsoft software.  Any ideas on how to capture HD qulaity video and view on Apple TV?

Maybe you are looking for

  • I have just purchased a new iMac and for some reason the 3D menu is greyed out and i cant access the settings. What is the reason for this?

    Adobe Photoshop Version: 2014.0.0 20140508.r.58 2014/05/08:23:59:59  x64 Operating System: Mac OS 10.9.4 System architecture: Intel CPU Family:6, Model:60, Stepping:3 with MMX, SSE Integer, SSE FP, SSE2, SSE3, SSE4.1, SSE4.2, HyperThreading Physical

  • Problem with 3G

    I would like to make sure my 3G and roaming is off. My blackberry curve currently has 3G in the right top corner of the screen, but after, what I thought was turning all roaming off, there is also a red triangle next to the 02 sign in the middle of t

  • Receiver soap error

    Hi, i have abap proxy 2 soap (sync). and i imported wsdl into IR, which created by target web server(tomcat). here is target soap adapter info. target url : http://58.232.198.104:8080/axis/ApprovalService.jws?wsdl action : Approval actually, you can

  • I installed Prokit 7 upgrade and now I can't see any of my type 1 fonts when in Indesign or Photoshop

    I installed Prokit 7 upgrade today and now I can't see any of my type 1 fonts when in Indesign or Photoshop. Not sure if the upgrade did it, but it seemed to coincide with the problem. I am a graphic artist spend all day everyday using these programs

  • Cartesian Coordinates

    Ok, let me start by saying that I am really really new to Java programming. For my first coding project (outside of the tutorials) I want to create a 2D Cartesian map. I am at a loss though of where to go next. The class I built to hold the user give