Which 1TB (or bigger) SATA drive is the coolest/quietest/least power-hungry

I have a Power Mac G4 Dual 1.25 GHz MDD (it's this model here) which (as it's unmodified) runs very hot & noisy much of the time.
What doesn't help is that I have 3 hard drives installed. 2 of these (including the boot drive) are IDE (80 GB & 120 GB), and are attached to the cables at the front of the machine (am I right in thinking that this is the ATA-66 bus?). The third is a SATA drive (250 GB) connected to one of the sets of cables at the back of the machine (the ATA-100 bus?) via an IDE -> SATA adapter (not a PCI card).
This adapter took me many weeks of research to track down (& order online from the USA) as there didn't appear to be (at the time - a few years ago) anyone here in the UK that made or sold these adapters. (The opposite adapter - IDE drive to SATA cable - was freely available ironically, even in my local electronics shop). The physical size of the adapter means that I can't sit one of the other drives in the empty drive bay at the back of the machine.
A few months ago, as I was almost out of hard drive space, I decided to get a new (SATA) drive to replace the existing 3 drives. As well as giving me lots of capacity, one drive is going to use less power than 3, give off much less heat than 3, and hopefully reduce the fan noise.
Incidentally, I've found many good articles on reducing heat/power consumption/noise in MDD Macs - see here, here, here, here & here.
At the time, 1TB was the largest size available. After much research, along with some forum postings - see here & here - I decided to go for the Samsung Spinpoint F1 drive, which is currently quite cheap - see here.
However, I recently discovered that Seagate now makes a 1.5 TB drive, which would obviously be preferable - see here & here although it is much more expensive - see here.
However, there are many reports of problems with the Seagate drive - see here, here & here.
What I'm wondering is if there are any drives that are bigger than 1TB apart from the Seagate?
If not, would people recommend that I chance going for the Seagate, and hope that I don't have the problems, or that I'll be able to flash the firmware at some future point to sort the problem if it occurs (I have Virtual PC 7.0.2 installed, running Windows 2000 Service Pack 4 - would this enable internal hard drives to have their firmware updated?) or should I just play safe and go for the Samsung, even though it's "only" 1TB?
The largest capacity money can buy is my primary concern, followed by low power usage, low heat output & low noise.
Many thanks.

Thanks for the info.
I don't really see the point in the expense of a PCI card when the IDE -> SATA adaptor works fine, and if I bought a PCI card, I'd then feel obliged to go through the hassle of selling the adaptor on eBay to try to recoup part of the cost of the PCI card.
I should have mentioned before that I want to format my new drive as a single partition, in Mac OS Extended (Journaled) format, and to boot from it. I only want the new drive in the Mac - I don't want any other drives in there. Apart from increased capacity & performance, and reduced power consumption, heat & noise - the main point of getting the new drive is so that there is only one drive in my Mac. Having more than one is a complete pain for me.
At the moment, despite having "Put the hard disk(s) to sleep when possible" unchecked in the Energy Saver pane of System Preferences, all 3 drives spin down very soon after they stop being accessed, which means an infuriating delay (& spinning beach ball) when they spin up again. One or more of them spinning up even interrupts music playing sometimes, and when I go to shut down the computer, if they are spun down but mounted on the desktop, they spin up again before they spin down as part of the shutdown procedure! Also, with more than one drive, I can't tell which drive a file/folder is on just by looking at it, if it's on the desktop.
As far as Other World Computing goes, they may ship to the UK, but by the time the international shipping charges are added, I very much doubt if the total cost of a new drive would work out cheaper than ordering from a UK supplier & getting free shipping.
Another potential problem I've discovered with the Seagate drive is actually a quote from the Other World Computing website that's reproduced in comment number 66 (on page 3) of the MacRumors Forums thread that I gave the link to in my initial post. Basically it says that if you format the Seagate drive as a single partition on a Mac, the performance isn't acceptable. It's apparently fine though if it's partitioned in 2 equal size volumes, or if you format it as an NTFS or FAT32 drive. Neither of these work-arounds are any use to me though.
Everything so far suggests that I should just go for the Samsung 1 TB drive, but I'm hesitant to do so until it's confirmed to me that there aren't any other drives out there that are bigger than 1 TB apart from the Seagate, and also, knowing my luck, the day after I buy the Samsung, Western Digital or Hitachi or someone will bring out a flawless 1.5 TB drive for not a lot more money, and I'll be kicking myself for ending up with only 2 thirds of the capacity than I could have had...

Similar Messages

  • Is there any LabVIEW driver for the Agilent 53147A counter/power meter?

    I am trying to find a LabVIEW driver for the Agilent 53147A counter/power meter, but I cannot find it. Is there any?

    NI does not have a driver and a quick check with Agilent shows that they don't have a driver either.
    You can go to http://www.ni.com/devzone/idnet/ and request a driver. You will also find links on how to create your own driver. Your other option is to use the Instrument I/O Assistant.
    p.s. In the future, you should use the Instrument control board for posting questions. this board is for NI counter/timer products.

  • Sata Drive and the KT6V Motherboard

    Hi all, Wondering if anyone could help me. I just got a new PC and am setting it up as a server. Now I have a 40G hhd running the O.S. which is windows 98se ( I know its old and has problems but it should work fine) I also have a 120g WD SATA drive that i want to use as a storage drive. ( I have a set up on my other pc this way) but windows does not see the Sata drive and when i try the raid setup I see the Drive but i cant do anything with it. My mother board is a KT6V and all drivers and programs are loaded. I can use the Raid Tool and see the drive it says its working but again I cant do anything with it. Just wondering if this is the way this MotherBoard runs or if there is a setting im missing. Thanks for your time.

    Hello,
    Win98se,
    How did you format the 120GB sata drive?
    With the KT6 boards, if you have only one sata drive and enter the Sata ROM, you cannot choose any options, That is normal.
    Must be using FAT32 for win98se.

  • Adding 2 extra SATA drives pn the cheap

    I am looking at an inexpensive way to add 2 extra 500GB drives to a new quad 3.0 Mac Pro. 4 drives are in the machine now.
    How about using the eSATA extender cable from Newer Technology to add 2 ports
    http://www.newertech.com/products/esata_cable.php
    and then adding an enclosure from OWC
    http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Other%20World%20Computing/MESATATBEK/
    I could then pick up 2 inexpensive 500GB drives such as a WD or Maxtor
    Has anyone done this? It looks like the cheapest way to add a TB. I will not raid them or boot from them - just store data.
    Mac Pro 3.0, G5 2.7, 2 intel iMacs, 1 MacBook, 1 Powerbook, 18 G4 Macs, 3 iPods   Mac OS X (10.4.9)   I teach Digital Photography clases - on Macs

    Yes, a couple of us have. And there are reports of some on
    http://www.xlr8yourmac.com
    They have to be on at boot time or restart time. You can't power down and unmount while running. For two drives, go with FW800 cases.
    The case, I bought one, and two small cool running drives got too warm and started giving my system the fits. They will run 10-15ºC higher. Spend $199 and get the FirmTek case. While at it, instead of the $25 kit, get a real SATA PCIe from Sonnet for $70. You will have a much much better solution.
    I bought one WD 500GB and one MaxLine Pro (cheaper). The WD outpaces, outclasses, and runs 10ºC cooler. Not a big deal for backup drives (maybe use WD for internal boot drive, and move one to backups).
    Disassembling Mac Pro is either hand sweating crazy and why do it; or you love to do such things, and have small fingers that can get in so you don't need to pull it apart. Another vote for Sonnet or FirmTek controller. Which are hot swap and can be unmounted and powered on/off as needed.
    Penny-wise, yes, but maybe pound-foolish in the end. But I had to try and see how it goes. I was going to go with two drives in optical bays.
    With summer and warmer temperatures, I am keeping my eye on drive temps, which is how I know the external case was hotter than internal drive temps by a full 15ºC.

  • MSI PRO-E takes forever to autodiscover the SATA drives in RAID mode

    If I change the bios from IDE to RAID, it takes at least a minute to find each SATA drive during the post.   Any ideas?  The bios is at 8.2 so I'm wondering if a flash to 8.5 would help.
    Thanks,
    lavesa

    I flashed the bios to 8.5 and I still have the same problem.  These are older SATA drives so I wonder if it's a compatability issue.  Maxtor 6Y120MO drives.  They were fine on my old Gigabyte MB with SATA Raid.  They are at least 6 years old though.
    If I leave the RAID type to IDE, the bios picks up one of the drives quickly.  These drives actually have the normal IDE power connectors on the drives.
    Any help is appreciated!

  • Can I get a new and bigger hard drive on my macbook?

    Right now I have an 80GB Hard Drive, It keeps getting filled up too easily and I need a bigger hard drive. When I chatted with a person (online) at the apple store they said it couldn't be replaced after it has been formatted or something, unless something was wrong with it. I'm not worried about losing information because everything is backed up to an external hard drive. Why isn't this possible? In January I got this new 80GB Hard drive along with a new battery. I'm wanting to upgrade it to around 120/150GB or something like that, whatever is in the hundreds. Any help would be appreciated. My macbook's specs are posted below. Again, thanks for the help in advance!
    Hardware Overview:
    Model Name: MacBook
    Model Identifier: MacBook1,1
    Processor Name: Intel Core Duo
    Processor Speed: 2 GHz
    Number Of Processors: 1
    Total Number Of Cores: 2
    L2 Cache: 2 MB
    Memory: 512 MB
    Bus Speed: 667 MHz
    Boot ROM Version: MB11.0061.B03
    SMC Version (system): 1.4f12
    Serial Number (system):
    Sudden Motion Sensor:
    State: Enabled
    Hard Drive Specs:
    FUJITSU MHY2080BH:
    Capacity: 74.53 GB
    Model: FUJITSU MHY2080BH
    Revision: 0081000D
    Serial Number:
    Native Command Queuing: Yes
    Queue Depth: 32
    Removable Media: No
    Detachable Drive: No
    BSD Name: disk0
    Mac OS 9 Drivers: No
    Partition Map Type: GPT (GUID Partition Table)
    S.M.A.R.T. status: Verified
    Volumes:
    Macintosh HD:
    Capacity: 74.21 GB
    Available: 33.9 GB
    Writable: Yes
    File System: Journaled HFS+
    BSD Name: disk0s2
    Mount Point: /

    basstone97:
    Your MacBook will support a 2.5" SATA drive. The largest drive currently available is 500 GB. Other sizes are 320 GB, 250 GB etc. The Apple tech was likely referring that Apple will not do a free replacement of your drive unless is was defective or failed. However, you can purchase the drive and install it yourself. It is relatively easy on the MacBook, or you can purchase the drive and have Apple or an Authorized Apple Dealer install it for you. The risk of DIY installation is that if you screw up Apple will not be responsible for any damages. If you are interested, please post back for a list of available HDDs and step by step directions and tips for installation.
    cornelius

  • Mac Pro Compatibility With Older SATA Drives And DVI Connectors

    I soon plan to replace my 5 year old G5 with a new Mac Pro and need two questions answered so that I will know what options i have for the transfer of older data and apps. The Apple web site for the Mac Pro includes the following paragraph which gives me reason for concern:
    Your Mac Pro includes four drive bays, allowing you to configure it with
    up to 8 terabytes of storage using 7200-rpm Serial ATA 3Gb/s drives, up
    to 2 terabytes of storage using high-performance solid-state drives, or
    any combination of each type of drive. Configure each drive bay
    separately.
    Does the phrase "using 7200-rpm Serial ATA 3Gb/s drives" mean that the Mac Pro will ONLY work with 3Gb/s drives or that it performs best with 3Gb/s drives?
    I currently have two internal SATA 250/300 GB Maxtors (Maxtor 7Y250M0 and Maxtor 6B300S0... both are 7200 RPM but I don't know the data transfer speed). Ideally I would get a Mac Pro with a single 1 TB drive, move one or both of these older SATA drives to the new computer, one temporarily and the other permanently in order to transfer data and Apps to the new machine. If this is not possible then the new machine will need to wait until after I get a new larger FW external drive to use as a data transfer medium (I had planned to do that anyhow). I need to do some advance planning for this so I need to know what to expect in advance. I noticed this possible wording ambiguity on Apple's description of the Mac Pro long ago, but now I need to find out the answer for sure. Apple, you need to be more specific with your words.
    Can anybody answer this question for me?
    My second question regards display connectors. Does the standard (no bucks added) display card include a standard DVI connector or only the newer Mini-DVI connectors. I think I see a standard DVI connector in the low res picture of the back of the Mac Pro but am unsure. My 5 year old Apple display bit the dust a year ago and I had to replace it with an HP 2009m display (mumble grumble) which does use a standard DVI connector. A new Apple display is too rich for my blood so I plan to continue using the HP display for now and need to find out if I will need a display adapter to go with it.
    Many thanks to anyone who can answer these questions authoritatively.
    For anyone who asks why I still run 10.3.9 on my G5, I can only answer response speed. New OS versions always act like a lead anchor on a machine with their added overhead and Tiger really does feel like a ball and chain tied to me... it just does not reaspond as fast as I do. I look forward to the speed of a new machine.
    Phil Rogers
    --

    Does the phrase "using 7200-rpm Serial ATA 3Gb/s drives" mean that the Mac Pro will ONLY work with 3Gb/s drives or that it performs best with 3Gb/s drives?
    Any commercial sATA drive will do just fine. 7200 RPM is not a requirement.
    WD "Green" drives have caused user complaints about "long delay until ready" when installed inside a Mac Pro, but are fine for backups.
    You are making the leap from PowerPC to Intel Mac. Eventually, you should re-initialize your old drives to GUID partition table for best responsiveness.
    Migrating your System will not be possible. Use the pre-installed System or Install a new System on a GUID-partitioned drive with the release DVD in the box.
    Migrating your Applications is a Bad Idea. You should plan on re-installing all your third-party Applications from their release discs.

  • Possible to put two or more 3.5 SATA drives in optical bay of early 2008 mac pro?

    Hello! A question about expansion really. Here is my iexpansion plan. Wondering if you can see any possible problems?
    drive bay 1 - SSD - raid with drive 2
    drive bay 2 - SSD - raid with drive 1
    These will make the boot drive.
    Then...
    drive bay 3 - 3.5" sata - raid with drive 4
    drive bay 4 - 3.5" sata - raid with drive 3
    Two extra internal eSATA ports being extended out with wires to an empty PCI slot, leading to two external 3.5" drives in eSATA interfaced, self-powered enclosures.
    Optical Bay - Removing the two currently installed optical drives and replacing with two 3.5" SATA drives. In order to do this I'll need to get some form of ATAPI to SATA adapter as my early 2008 macpro uses the older interface.
    So my question is:
    Can you see any reason why this would not work and if you can point me towards an adapter that might work for holding/converting the interface of those two 3.5" drives in the optical bay? Will there be enough space for the adapter? I'll probably rig my own bracket for holding the drives there but any suggestions welcome!
    Will power become an issue? I'm also running a flashed PC graphics card which uses both of the additional power  ports (rather than just one). But other than that nothing extra.
    Many thanks for your time!

    Hi Hatter,
    Thanks for your reply. I'm not so worried about the SSDs as I am about the ability to put 2x3.5" SATA drives into the optical bay and have them fit (I do not want to pay a lot of money for any fancy pieces of metal such as the one you linked) when they necessary PATA-SATA adapter and power supply adapter if attached to them. Have you ever seen someone do this and what adatper did they use? I'm looking at this sort of thing:
    http://www.cooldrives.com/satoidecofor.html
    I can not put the SSDs in the Optical bay because the slower PATA interface would cut the speed so much it would not be worth it.
    Any tips on known reports of 2x 3.5" drives fitting in there would be great, and what adapter was used.
    Thanks!

  • Urgent - No 64bit Promise SATA driver (not RAID)

    I'd already installed XP64 on an old PATA drive without problems, so today I decided to use the new VIA SATA drive to dual-boot it off my SATA drive, along with my main XP32 installation. Unfortunately, although it found the VIA driver at F6 and got to the GUI install it locked solid at Devices. Worse than that it's totally screwed all the boot files so I now can't get to anything on either the SATA or PATA drives, and blue screen on any attempt to boot either drive. That's 4 OS installs gone.
    I moved the SATA over to the Promise controller thinking I'd seen 64bit Promise drivers for weeks, but it seems these are only RAID drivers and are called "Promise FastTrak 378 (tm) Controller". Needless to say they don't find a single SATA drive. What I need would be the driver called "Promise SATA378 (tm) Controller" but I can't find it. Have Promise really released a RAID driver but no single SATA driver for the same controller???
    If I don't find it I guess I'm looking at 4 days spent formatting and reinstalling.

    Hi Jocko
    OK, I'll try explain (and remember!)
    First I installed XP32 on the lone SATA drive. No problem as it was the only drive.
    Then I added an old PATA drive, which BIOS and Windows Setup always sees as Disk 0 and the SATA as Disk 1.
    I then installed XP32 onto the PATA drive. No problem, I think it was because Windows saw it as Disk 0 as it put the MBR in the right place.
    I then put Server64 and XP64 on the PATA drive to test them (leaving by day-to-day install safe on the SATA drive. Again, no problems, it updated the MBR correctly to let me multiboot between the 3 OSes on the PATA drive.
    I then tried to add an install of XP64 to the SATA drive, but because I left the PATA drive connected, Windows setup updated the MBR of the PATA drive instead. On subsequent reboot it failed because it was pointing to the wrong drive (I think). So I had half an install on the SATA drive, and a boot.ini on the PATA which pointed to a non-existent half installation. Even with BIOS listing the SATA drive as the boot device, each time the PC restarted it tried to carry on the installation and of course failed.
    That's when I had to refer to my book on Recovery Console...
    So it seems that if multiple drives are installed, it will update the MBR on the lowest ID drive, which is not necessarily the drive the installation is actually going on to! I think!  

  • Using SATA drives...no luck!

    I bought a couple of 500 gb SATA drives over the weekend thinking that I could use them with FCE. I think I'm assuming they work like firewire, and I'm thinking they don't.
    * Can you daisy-chain SATA?
    * Is there some kind of outboard E-SATA to Firewire converter? I'm using a Mac Mini until Apple comes out with something better. I also have an adapter for my MacBook pro, but can't get it to work.
    So in the meantime I'm using the drives as USB 2.0 and just going off and doing other things around the house during captures, which take forever, as do rendering.
    Tnx.
    /john

    Well, I would have put them in an enclosure that supports FireWire, esp. since the Mini has no eSata interface but does have FW400. Take a look at the OWC enclosures - they have a pretty good reputation. The Mercury Elite enclosure is a 2-drive FW800/400/USB2 unit; there is also a 1-drive Quad interface version.
    Putting the drives in the G4 will work but you will need a SATA controller card. BTW, I'd think a 2x1GHZ G4 would be a pretty nice machine. How much RAM do you have? And what is the existing graphics card?

  • Preparing SATA drive

    G'day guys
    Just wondering if anyone can help, I have just purchased a 200 Gb Seagate SATA HDD and want to have it as my primary drive. It will be partitioned using Acronis partition manager and I am going to copy the contents from my current 80 Gb ATA HDD including the OS onto the 200 Gb SATA, is this ok. I still want to keep my 2 existing 80 Gb ATA drives for home videos and other assorted files and photos, backups etc. Is it fine for me to have the 2x 80 Gb HDD still in the IDE 1 slot on my mobo, with the SATA drive in the SATA port? Windows should configure this correctly won't it, it won't keep searching the ATA's for the primary partition? Do the ATA's need to be set to slave or cable select with regards to the jumpers. I will also change the existing primary part on the 80 Gb ATA to a logical partition. Is this correct?
    All correspondence greatly appreciated, thankyou.
    Cheers

    No, it's because after you clone your drive you are going to have two identical drives that differ only in size.
    SATA only and PATA only determine which drive is going to place higher in the bios internal IDE list. PATA only puts the SATA drive higher, and vice versa. You want your boot drive higher in the list.
    The Keep Enabled settings keep the other type of drive enabled for use.
    PS: Any time you change a setting that rearranges drives in the IDE list, on the very next boot you need to go back into the bios to set the boot drive again.

  • RS480M2 sees IDE drive but not SATA drive

    I had never had any problems with my computer until now. I installed a Samsung 250GB IDE drive internally besides my usual Samsung 80GB SATA drive but the BIOS does not see the SATA (which is connected to IDE Controller), it only recognizes the new IDE (connected to Channel 0 Master). I also have a LiteOn CD connected to Channel 1 and it is OK. The SATA drive was working normally before as the only drive and I also know the new IDE drive works because I used it on an external enclosure as a backup. Any ideas?

    You may need to try cable select instead.

  • MSI Z77A G43 A2 Error with Bluray SATA Drive

    Hey guys!
    My old Asus P67 motherboard died last week so I bought this board as a replacement. I plugged everything correctly and it seemed to work at first. PC booted fine into windows and I was able to play all my usual games and do my usual stuff.
    After an hour or so I restarted the PC after installing the new chipset driver and LAN + Audio driver. I then got the A2 problem. I get this error code before the BIOS Picture. I googled around and it seems to be a problem with the SSD/HDD connectors or something. I then went about trying to find out which drive was causing it and it was my Bluray SATA Drive. The PC will start fine if I do not connect it, but once I do I cannot get passed the A2 error. I tried running the MSI Live Update 5 software to update my BIOS but it says I have the "latest" version.
    Any thing you guys recommend? The Bluray SATA Drive worked fine on my old motherboard.
    Thanks.
    MPC

    Quote from: flobelix on 05-May-14, 01:13:30
    The SSDs and three other drives? So you are trying to populate all ports? If so try removing one of the other drives and retry.
    Yes. I got too many drives laying around xD. Edit: 1 x SSD Crucial C300 64 GB for OS. 1 X SSD Kingston 240 GB for games. 2 x WD 1 TB Drives for storage. 1 x WD Raptor Drive for other programs.
    About your request, I did this earlier on today when I was trying to find out what was causing the problem. It did not help the issue when I unplugged one of the other SATA Drives. Still would not start while the bluray player was connected.

  • Satelite L40-17U: Sata driver WinXP

    This problem isn't that hard to fix but I'm searching for the driver but I can't seem to find it. And don't tell me to go to the drivers download page for my L40-17U because I was there and you just don't get the driver I'm looking for there.
    Every driver else I do get there. So help me through this problem please. I formatted my laptop which had vista home basic on because I want to install XP Pro.
    Now the trick is my laptop says "hard drive not found" I know how to solve the problem. Here is the method(you need a Windows XP CD, Sata driver for your laptop for XP, the program nlite and a clean CD):
    Take a Windows XP CD and use the program nlite to slipstream the sata driver + XP files from the origional XP CD to the clean CD.
    The process is not that difficult but you need all the software and drivers for your laptop for Windows XP. The driver I'm struggling to get is the sata driver. Can anyone help me find out where to get the sata dirver for my L40-17U please?
    Here are the specifications for my Laptop neede to get the sata driver for xp:
    model no: PSL48E-02P031ZA
    cpu: Dual-Core T2330 1.6 GHz
    If U need any more information please let me know and I'll provide it.
    Message was edited by: chvw1987

    >And don't tell me to go to the drivers download page for my L40-17U because I was there and you just don't get the driver I'm looking for there.
    I dont believe that you know what you are talking about.
    Ive visited the Toshiba European driver page and yes I checked the L40 PSL48E download area and YES I found the necessary SATA driver!
    The Intel Storage Manager contains the needed SATA driver!
    As you suggested you can create a new Win XP CD and could include the SATA driver to this page using the nLite.
    Its not complicated and runs smoothly
    Would recommend checking this

  • Can't get SATA drive to boot - MSI K8NGM2-FID

    Mobo is MSI K8NGM2-FID.  I've had two IDE drives w/ XP and added a SATA II (WD7500AAKS) recently as a storage drive.  Now I'd like to make the SATA the boot drive, but after cloning it from the IDE boot drive it hasn't yet got far in the start up process (cloning with WD Tools, then again with Acronis).  I can't tell whether the problem is BIOS or Windows (XP) or ?  MSI Update says the BIOS is current and I set the SATA drive as the first HD in the boot order in Advanced BIOS features.
    On start up, the computer runs through the BIOS sequence onscreen and then stops somewhere between the end of that and the Windows blue screen coming up, leaving a blank screen except a flashing cursor on the left. When I disconnect the two IDE drives as a test, the same thing happens. Then, with them still disconnected, I try booting from the XP CD and it gets to the point of checking the computer's current configuration and then the screen goes blank indefinitely. I would think it would either show the XP setup menu or give a message that's something is missing.
    Does this sound like BIOS or Windows or ?  Is there anything else in BIOS that needs changing?  I've been told that IDE drive jumpers have no effect on SATA drives.  Is that true?  Thanks.
    MSI K8NGM2-FID
    Athlon 64 3000
    2GB RAM
    XP/SP2 current

    Quote from: genegold on 29-January-08, 01:31:18
    Good timing.  I'd like to add partitions to my new (cloned) SATA boot drive (C:), but wanted to back up first.  A problem and a question come up.  First, when I remount the old IDE drive as a second drive D:, even wiped clean, problems ensue.  Comodo wants to look for my firewall installation on D: and Acronis won't allow me to clone back, i.e., clone from the new drive to the old.
    It's not really clear what you had before or what you have now in terms of HDDs: you had two IDE drives, C: & D: and one SATA as E:??; now you have a SATA boot drive.  Do you still have the 40GB IDE drive?  Did the clone over to the SATA automatically extend the old 160GB C: partition to 750GB?  Sorry but I've no idea how Acronis works.  "Wiped clean" is kinda vague - it could mean using the HDD mfr's utility to write zeroes to the entire surface... or just creating a new Extended partition containing a formatted(?) logical volume.  If that old IDE drive has a Primary partition it could still be marked as bootable, which you can check with BootitNG... and it's not a good idea to have a Primary partition on a 2nd drive.
    Quote
    Second, I assume that files are spread over the boot drive, not just grouped in the first 150GB, even if defragged.  In reducing the partition size - now 698GB - how does BootitNG know to make sure everything ends up in the first partition?  I read about this somewhere but don't see any mention in BootITNG.
    Again, I don't know how you got to the situation of a 698GB partition on the SATA boot drive - it would have been better to clone to the same sized C: partition as the old 160GB drive and then use a tool like BootitNG to extend it to whatever size you want... then add new partitions.
    No partition management software can guarantee a partition shrink will work - they can only shrink out unallocated space.  In that respect Windows XP Defrag is unreliable at both leaving unallocated space at the end of a partition AND at accurately reporting what is used and what is not.  In such a situation, without a better, more accurate, defragger I generally run defrag several times, with reboots in between until it "looks" like it's safe to shrink and do the shrink in steps, with checks and defrags again, in between.  Yes, it's a PITA.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Flash photo gallery, popup image

    Hi! I'm new to flash. I have created a small flash thumbnail gallery. What I would like to add now is that when you click on one of the images, a bigger version of the selected image appears as a popup. At least it looks that way. How is this done? D

  • Working with scans of old photo collection

    I'm trying to use iPhoto 8.0.2 to organize my grandmother's photos, with the end goal of sharing with family on Flickr. So, an old photo collection which has been scanned. First, dating. I'd like to be able to order photos chronologically. I could ch

  • Am I doing this wrong?  Pixs

    Hello to the mac family, I'm back with another question. I bought my wife an I-pod Nano along with my new I-mac. I am not sure what generation it is but is about 3 weeks old. I am very new to X (9,2 user) so please be kind. I put some sings in I-tune

  • Statistical Indicator check in MM pricing.

    I have not put a statistical indicator in MM pricing still.The condition shows as statistical.Can you help me to find how this statistical indicator is autogenerated.

  • What gives Apple, I can't open a CVS file!?

    So I download a CVS file from my online banking and go to open it with my new version of numbers, and the formating is out and the cell format for currency have not been preserved. It was a simple matter to correct, a couple of highlighted columns an