Best quality iDVD or iDVD Pro or Toast?

I dragged a FCE .mov, which was 1 hr 45 minutes in length, into iDVD and produced a single layered Disk that played good until the last three minutes of the program where I had six layers of video. At that point I got about 30 seconds of wormy looking transitions. I then rendered a new iDVD with a double layered disk and it played perfectly, indicating that added space and more thorough rendering can produce a clean DVD. My question is does iDVD pro or Toast offer a better algorithm that would have made the single layered disk play smoothly?
Thank you in advance,
Art

Hi Alex,
no conversion needed:
iM works with dv, a dvd has finally mpeg2 - any "inbetween conversion" means loss of quality!
in case, you have many stills in your project, many recommend here NOT to use the export button in iM, but simply drag'n drop the project (that file with a star) onto an open iDVD project, so rendering is done by iDVD......

Similar Messages

  • Encoding: Best Performance vs. Best Quality

    So I have a project that if I select Best Performance it shows that the DVD will be 3.4GB, and if I select Best Quality it shows the DVD will be 2.0GB.
    So my question is: isn't that contrary to logic? Why wouldn't Best Quality be the largest size? Is Best Quality going to give me the best possible video quality?

    Since you have posted to the iDVD 6 forum, I asssume that is what you have.
    iDVD 6 has two encoding modes: 'Best Performance' and 'Best Quality'. iDVD '08 adds: 'Professional Quality'.
    People misunderstand the names and I wish Apple had used different names for all three modes.
    The below applies to a single layer disc (double the times for a double layer disc):
    'Best Performance' uses a fixed video encoding bit-rate that produces a DVD with a data playback bit-rate just about as high as a set-top DVD player can handle. This limits content to 60 minutes or less.
    'Best Quality' uses a fixed video encoding bit-rate that is BASED ON THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF CONTENT BEING COMPRESSED and is best suited for content between 60 and 120 minutes. Note that all the content is encoded at the same bit-rate so that it can fit on a single layer disc. (Apple calls this single-pass variable bit-rate encoding because 120 minutes of content gets compressed more than 60 minutes of content.)
    The new 'Professional Quality' uses a variable video encoding bit-rate that is BASED ON THE INFORMATION IN THE CONTENT BEING COMPRESSED. It uses a two-pass process to first evaluate the content and then encode it based on the motion/detail of individual clips. It is best suited for content between 60 and 120 minutes. Note that not all the content is encoded at the same bit-rate BUT the maximum data bit-rate on playback can not exceed the playback capability of a set-top DVD player. (This is two-pass, variable bit-rate encoding.) This means the BEST encoded quality should be about what is obtained with 'Best Performance' for content under 60 minutes.
    If your content is under 60 minutes, use 'Best Performance'. If your content is between 60 minutes and 120 minutes, use 'Professional Quality' if your processor is fast enough and you don't mind waiting about twice the time required for 'Best Quality'.
    About the only thing Apple can do to further improve the quality of DVD encoded video is to offer compressed audio instead of just the present uncompressed PCM audio because the audio 'eats up' part of the playback bit-rate a set-top DVD player can handle. Compressed audio would make more of the maximum playback bit-rate available for video.
    In your case, with iDVD 6, use 'Best Performance' for content under 60 minutes and 'Best Quality' for content over 60 minutes. Remember that your menu content counts against the total time limit.
    F Shippey

  • Compression quality: iDVD vs DVD Studio Pro vs others?

    I am merrily editing along in FCE, and looking to eventually compress and burn onto DVD. Since I can use all the quality I can get, and don't have spare money (so what else is new?), I am wondering about the differences in compressing software. Is there a visible difference in the final product using DVD Studio Pro vs iDVD? Is there something else out there that is better than iDVD but doesn't cost as much as DVDSP? Any opinions or experience welcomed!
    Thank you!

    If your project is under an hour, iDVD will give you very satisfactory results (use the Best Performance settings).
    You can create an up to 2 hour movie with iDVD but personally (with Best Quality), I think the quality begins to slide off a bit over an hour
    DVD Studio Pro, with Compressor, gives you many more compression options. Compressor has lots more compression pre-sets and you can go in and tweak bit rates, single or double passes, etc. You can do that inside DVD Studio Pro as well. Overall, Studio Pro just gives you a lot more options and control.
    Roxio Toast is a relatively cheap (around 80 bucks Cdn) piece of software that will compress your FC movies. You are way limited in terms of things like menus and chapters but compression wise it does a fairly nice job ... again, you don't have the versatility of iDVD. With Popcorn, it will allow you to cram a big movie onto a single layer DVD but the quality begins to hurt
    Personally, no matter what you use, two hours is the reasonable quality limit for a single layer DVD

  • IDVD 5 project, 26 chapters, burns Best Performance not Best Quality

    My iDVD project WILL burn with 26 chapter headings at "Best Performance", but the same project will NOT burn at "Best Quality". The same file will burn at "Best Quality" without the chapter headings. I have retried multiple times. Each time Best Performance will burn, Best Quality will not.
    As a rule I use Best Quality. The last project finished a couple of months ago. (So, probably earlier than 10.4.7) Best Quality usually works for me, just not on this project.
    Note, I have filed a bug report but thought I should also share this with discussions.
    (All the usual remedies, with resetting cache plist repairing permissions performed between each attempt, and attempts to burn from a new user. The video file has no transitions)
    iDVD 5.0.1 (626), Quicktime Pro 7.1.3, 10.4.7
    Mac G5 Quicksilver 867 MHz, 2MB L3 cache, memory 1.5 gig.
    Entire video length is 00:45:58.
    My user set chapter markers are at [00:01:19.2637] [00:03:18.1194] [00:04:06.2638] [00:05:45.2235] [00:07:07.2781] [00:08:16.0988] [00:09:53.0879] [00:12:22.2126] [00:13:04.0552] [00:15:30.2190]
    [00:16:15.2725] [00:17:13.0799] [00:18:26.2418] [00:20:02.1206] [00:22:48.1704]
    [00:27:03.1369] [00:27:59.0637] [00:29:56.1588] [00:31:27.1161] [00:34:26.1298]
    [00:34:59.0097] [00:38:54.1302] [00:41:12.1516] [00:42:02.2966] [00:43:34.1742]
    [00:45:09.1127]
    So the first chapter marker is over one minute into the video and the last is 49 seconds before the end of the video.
    It took me a couple of weeks of futile attempts at Best Quality to figure this out. I am exhausted and don't have the energy to start deleting chapter markers one at a time to see if and when it will burn at Best Quality.
    Any thoughts?

    Hello Robert,
    I'm not really able to provide a solution - maybe some of the more knowledgeable users on this board will chime in - but can only offer a guess.
    There hav been several reports of compatibility issues between Tiger/QT 7 and iMovie/iDVD 5, so maybe that's your "bug".
    Recommended is:
    • OS X 10.3.9/QT 6.5.2/iLife 5
    • OS X 10.4.x/QT 7.1.x/iLife 6
    I would also try to create a new iDVD project for your movie after deleting iDVD prefs and repairing permissions. Then try to create a disk image (if you didn't try that already)
    hope this helps
    mish

  • Quality of DVD Studio Pro using Compressor vs iDVD

    Sorry to repeat the question below, which I have also posted under DVD SP...I thought that perhaps someone watching Compressor would also have input.
    I have been trying to obtain a DVD output with DVD Studio Pro where moderate speed pans don't jerk. Oddly, I get better results using iDVD. The image in iDVD isn't as sharp, but the quality of movement (pans, tilts) is smoother. My program length is only 20 minutes and I have used compressor to encode outside of DVD SP. The compressor setting was for DVD, 60 mins, best quality. Why is it that a consumer software such as iDVD yields better results in this aspect? What am I doing wrong in DVD SP that results in less than professional results. All input appreciated. Thanks in advance

    Pamela
    hy is it that a consumer software such as iDVD yields better results in this aspect? What am I doing wrong in DVD SP that results in less than professional results.
    You are messing around with Compressor settings . . . I guess!
    Hope that helps !
      Alberto

  • Quality of DVD Studio Pro vs iDVD

    I have been trying to obtain a DVD output with DVD Studio Pro where moderate speed pans don't jerk. Oddly, I get better results using iDVD. The image in iDVD isn't as sharp, but the quality of movement (pans, tilts) is smoother. My program length is only 20 minutes and I have used compressor to encode outside of DVD SP. The compressor setting was for DVD, 60 mins, best quality. Why is it that a consumer software such as iDVD yields better results in this aspect? What am I doing wrong in DVD SP that results in less than professional results. All input appreciated. Thanks in advance

    Hal MacLean wrote:
    Wow - wikipedia link is a superb article, but a tad geeky...
    That is why I refused to understand it, I am not a geek and no one will convince me otherwise... even if every new application and computer released by Apple is like catnip for me

  • Best performance vs. Best quality in iDVD Prefs!?

    What is the difference? i have selected "best quality" and see no difference in picture, but one can fit more onto a dvd with best quality vs. performance. what is the difference!? thanks!

    A quick, simple explanation is given in David Pogue's little iLife '04 manual. I will pare it down a little:
    "Given that a blank DVD contains a limited amount of space, how much picture-quality data can it afford to devote to each frame of video?
    The Best Perfomance option in iDVD 4 ....allots a fixed, predetermined amount of data to each frame of video--enough to make it look great--no matter how many minutes of video is included. A lot of the DVD might wind up being empty if the project contains less than an hour of video. But, the burning process will go quickly and the video will look really great.
    The Best Quality option uses every micron of space on the blank DVD, analyzes the amount of video included and divides it into the amount of space available on the DVD. The amount of information used to describe an indiviual frame of video will vary from project to project, and it will take a lot longer to burn the DVD because of so much analysis. But it will give two hours of great-looking video per disc."

  • I import in HD and Export in HD 1280x720 and Use the IDVD burner How do I get the best quality? It seems to be a generation down on quality.

    Need help with getting best quality for DVD's.

    The best quality you can get is to first understand that the biggest frame you can play back using a DVD player is 720x480. So no matter how big the image is going into iDVD it is throwing away some information to get it all to fit 720x480. Your best option then is go to Share Menu > Media Browser... Then choose the Large size.
    Open iDVD and find your video project by clicking on the Media button in the iDVD lower right hand corner. Then above that there's the media browser window with the Movies button on the right hand side. Click Movies button and browse for your project under the iMovie star icon.
    Drag that project into a clip and burn the project to a DVD-R.

  • IMovie to iDVD: Error: Need to change to Best quality

    I think this must be a bug in iLife 06, create a project in iMovie 6, it will be less then 2 hours long but longer then one hour. Share out to iDVD and you get an error that the files are too large and you should change to Best Quality. Change is made to Best quality but the error still returns, there is no way to get rid of this error with the current iDVD project. Solution: Export the iMovie project (I always use Full Quality) and then drag into the iDVD theme of your choice and it will burn. This happens on my Macs at home and all of the Macs I manage at the university with iLife 06. Has anyone else seen this problem?

    But you didn't say you made the change in both places. This needed to be done by someone a couple of days ago.
    You can also try this, but you'll have to reset Prefs:
    This frequently helps solve some problems. Quit iDVD. Search for the file named com.apple.iDVD.plist and trash it. (A new one will be created next launch of iDVD.) Or look in: User/Library/Preferences. This may solve project loading errors too. Restart and use Disk Utility to Repair Permissions.

  • Best quality for SD movie into iDVD

    I just finished creating a movie in iMovie '09. It was originally recorded with a Sony 8mm camera and passed through a Sony DV camera into my MacBook.
    I've added the titles, transitions, chapter marks, etc. The movie is about 50 minutes long.
    What is the best way to get it into iDVD and retain the best quality possible?
    Should I "share to iDVD" or export as a QuickTime movie and then drag that into iDVD? Which settings would be the best for that choice?

    You can actually convert them AFTER you've moved them in. When you captured them from the camera, they were saved into DV format. You can use mpegstreamclip (free download) to convert the DV clips into AIC or M-JPEG. If you do it correctly, the next time you start iMovie it will import the AIC-based clips in as well. Then, when iMovie reads them into your project and eventually renders the final movie, it will handle rendering better with AIC or M-JPEG clips as the source material.
    I understand needing to work with what you have; it is a pain to go and replace each clip, clip by clip, with new clips. However, I have very little experience with DV. I've been using mpeg clips from a HDD camcorder for over a year and have only just started using DV as I am now also shooting with a higher-end DV camera for church projects.
    I wish I could give you advice on how to export your project so iDVD can make the best DVD from it, but all of my work to date has been exported into movie files and played onto a HD TV through a laptop using QT or presentation software.

  • Best quality slideshow in iDVD

    Hi,
    I made a slideshow in iPhoto, imported it into iMovie, added music and exported the slideshow to "Media Browser." The slideshow is about 4 minutes long. When I play the slideshow in iPhoto or iMovie the pictures and text are crystal clear but after I import them into iDVD and burn them to disc, the text is very hard to read and some of the photos seems to vibrate. Also the overall quality of the photos is not very good. The sounds is fantastic so I am happy with that. When I exported from iMovie I used the largest possible setting (I tried it once with the 2nd largest and it was much worse). In iDVD I tried Best Performance once and also Professional (the latter was better). I am using Verbatim DVD-R discs. I have plenty of free memory on my computer. I made a similar project once before, using the same camera to shoot the photos, and it turned out great. The only difference that I can think of between the projects is that I didn't use a theme in the first project.
    I'm wondering how I can improve the quality of the photos in the finished dvd.
    Thanks for any ideas!

    DVDs are just standard definition devices - for NTSC, think 640x480 square pixels.
    For best quality in NTSC use 720x540 pixels for 4:3 video and 854x480 for widescreen. Using more pixels does NOT produce a better DVD!

  • Best quality to export to iDVD

    I have a two part question.
    I know someone has definitely answered this question but I just can't find the right answer. My doco is 2h 13mins. I have broken it up into two parts to get the best quality. I have put chapters in and I know that I must use Quicktime Movie instead of Conversion to register the chapters. So how do I get the best quality to do this. Do I go into preferences in FCE or iDVD or Quicktime? I have never been good at this end of it all.
    The second question is: I have broken the film into to parts the first is 67 mins long, the second is 66 mins long. If I want to scrap the chapters and use the Quicktime Conversion instead, what is the best quality setting I can use for each part. I plan on playing this in our local cinema which we can rent out so I want it to be the best I can get it.
    If there is more info you need to help with the decision let me know.
    Cheers.

    Hi
    It said the duration was too long, which it isn't.
    Duration is not just movie - it is Movie + MENU and they can be hugh if to elaborated
    eg if You use a QT.mov clip on about 60 minutes in background or as button etc.
    then set it to show 10 sec. - THE full QT.move will count when adding together DURATION.
    Audio also counts when in Menu.
    iDVD 08, 09 & 11 has three levels of qualities. (vers 7.0.1, 7,0.4 & 7.1.1)
    iDVD 6 has the two last ones
    • Professional Quality *(movies + menus up to 120 min.)* - BEST
    • Best Performances *(movies + menus less than 60 min.)* - High quality on final DVD
    • High Quality (in iDVD08 or 09) / Best Quality (in iDVD6) *(movies + menus up to 120 min.)* - slightly lower quality than above
    About double on DL DVDs.
    Yours Bengt W

  • IMovie '08 option to make the best quality video on a DVD using iDVD '08

    Which iMovie '08 option will make the best quality video on a DVD using iDVD '08?
    1. Share-Media Browser-Large-Publish
    2. Share-Export Using Quicktime
    3. Or can you use an unpublished iMove in iDVD?
    (Of course I'll have to first get iDVD to open without crashing...)

    Which iMovie '08 option will make the best quality video on a DVD using iDVD '08?
    1. Share-Media Browser-Large-Publish
    2. Share-Export Using Quicktime
    3. Or can you use an unpublished iMove in iDVD?
    As always, this depends on a number of factors which you failed to cover in your original question.
    1) If you source files are SD, other than an increased loss of time in converting you gain nothing in scaling the files up in iMovie '08 only to scale them back down in iDVD. On the other hand, if your source files are HD, then you will likely see a marginal increase in quality which may or may not be worth the price of increased processing time. In this latter case, you are allowing the MPEG-2 compressor to get the most it can out of your file at the P- and B-frame level.
    2) Export using QT allows you to customize your output with regard to both compression format and settings. For instance, you can use a codec with extremely high data rate (e.g., VGA dimensions with DV at 28.5-57.0 Mpbs, AIC at 18.0-22.0 Mbps, or even unlimited H.264/AAC at 16.0-20.0 Mbps). High video data rates generally translate to less lost quality during the re-compression process. Thus, if the intermediate file produced by iMovie '08 and passed on to iDVD retains more of its original quality, the MPEG-2 compressor can get more quality out of the final conversion as stated above.
    3) Since no physical file actually exists until the project (simply a set of instructions detailing how the final file will be created) is published, there is nothing to be physically sent to iDVD. basically you must create a physical file from the project in order to do anything at all whether sending it to a gallery, iTunes, YouTube, iDVD, etc.

  • Final Cut Express movie or iDVD - need best quality

    I have tried various settings, rendering, and burning, and I am not satisfied with the quality of the iDVD burning of the FCE movie. I used an HD camcorder - looks awesome straight from camera to HD tv via hdmi plug. Movie loaded into computer via FCE and still looks good on browser and canvas. When I use File, Export, Quicktime Movie or Quicktime Conversion, to save the movie, the quality does not seem as good. Then in iDVD it doesn't get any better. What are the best settings on FCE and iDVD to make the best quality movie.

    Zak- from all that I've read, QT Movie is better than QT Conversion for quality - Correct?
    The FCE program supports the HD quality. When moving to iDVD, it seems Best Performance is the best quality. Are there any specific settings I need to do in iDVD, as there aren't many to choose from. I have a 3 1/2 hour movie set up in FCE with transitions, double video, editing, etc. I have split the movie so I can produce on 2 separate dvd's for best quality and I am using the 7.7 double layer dvd's to burn on. I have also put in photos, iphoto, that look perfect on the canvas of FCE in the movie, but when on idvd , even before i burn the dvd, the pictures lose quality have are a bit fuzzy.

  • IDVD project to toast

    Is their anyway to burn a complete iDVD project in Toast?

    Less errors? That's great, because while I was using iDVD, I got a lot of errors... so I bought Toast 10 lately.
    What do you think makes more sense: To let iDVD to do encoding (and one can have a nice menu..not like the ones in Toast), or distrust iDVD all together, and to do the encoding and burning in Toast alone to avoid the iDVD's potential errors? - this is 1st question,
    The 2nd: since I'm still inexperience with using Toast to burn DVDs, so I do not have a "feel" yet for the burning quality settings... and looking for the best burning settings for 2hrs of Standard Definition DV home movie (in full quality Quick Time DV file).
    I noticed that the material burned using "Automatic" settings is looking less desirably than while using manual with higher "MAXIMUM" and higher "AVERAGE" values, like 8 or 9, but then I also learned that setting those too high may cause the reading errors in people's DVD players.
    Thus the question for you - experienced Toast's burners:
    - at what maximum value should one set the"MAXIMUM" and the"AVERAGE" values for 1-hr and/or (if different) 2-hrs of the Standard Definition material, so it will fit on just one regular single layer DVD, and will look possibly the best, with an error-free playback on people's DVD players?
    (I will set the audio at compressed 320 kbps in order to gain some extra room for the video's quality... but at what settings?)
    Please help, if your burning and then playing back experiences are positive, or PLEASE - let me know about some pitfalls that I might be not aware of. Thank you.

Maybe you are looking for