Cinema Display "badly" recognized

Hi,
I'm using a Cinema Display (20 '') on a G5 since 2 years, and today I've encountered a problem I've never had before: when I press the F14/F15 keys, the luminosity of the display doesn't change. When I open the "Monitor" pref pane, I dont have the luminosity "ruler" anymore... and when I put the Mac in "sleep" mode, the led of the display is fix, it doesn't pulsate as before...
I know that can seem ridiculous as a problem, but this used to work so it can't stop like that...
I've tried with two OSes (Tiger and Panther) the result is the same. I've also tried to remove the power cords of the Mac and the display for some minutes, and reinitialized the G5 PRAM, but none of those changed anything...
Any idea someone ?
Thanks in advance.

Ok, thanks for the information. I'll keep a closer eye at it, then... It's sad your AppleCare ended before you figured it out
Don't you know if that's a peripheral that damaged the display's hub or if it just "died" by itself ?

Similar Messages

  • Built-in camera in Cinema Display not recognized after SL Install

    Is anyone else having this problem? After installing the Snow Leopard upgrade, my system no longer recognizes the Cinema Display build in camera, not in iChat and not in Photo Booth. Help!

    What I've done is create a new admin user account in System Preferences Accounts pane
    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?path=Mac/10.5/en/8235.html
    after upgrading to Snow Leopard. The new account is using default settings (for Snow Leopard), so it is a good basis for comparison tests. Your issue would be a good use for it.
    After creating that new admin user account, log out and log in to the new account. Try the thing that does not work, in the new account. If it works in the new account, the problem is not technically Snow Leopard, but some conflict with something in your existing pre- Snow Leopard user account. It might be some user preference file that you have to trash or some background process that is conflicting, but you can focus troubleshooting on your normal user account as the cause.
    If it still does not work in the new account, then the problem is likely to be a bug in the overall system, or a hardware issue.

  • HT1338 cinema Display 30" no longer recognized by my mac pro? What can I do? It worked fine until now.

    Cinema display 30" no longer recognized by my mac pro. Until now it worked without problems, then after a crash it fails to recognize the display.
    Now it runs in a far lower resolution. What can I do?
    I tried to get da driver for it, but could not find any.

    Try the other DVI port on the graphics card.  On early Mac Pros, only one port is the dual-link DVI needed for full resolution on the 30" display.  Make sure the display's USB cable is plugged into the computer.

  • Macbook aluminium unibody (not pro) not recognizing my cinema display

    hi guys, i have an issue as you can read on this topic, i just purchased a macbook aluminium, and tried to connect my cinema display with the mini displayport to dvi, and does not work at all. when i connect the adapter it seems the machine suddently recognize that theres an external monitor hooked, but the display doesnot show any image. i went to preferences and noticed that the display was not there. my display is an adc connector with the adc dvi adapter. any help

    it´s the large one, the one you connect to the adc port and goes to the wall for power, and has a usb cable extension, and a dvi in, the i connect the the mini displayport adapter to the dvi of the adapter and just happen like when you press f7 (in older mac) to choose if you want to mirror the display or not, thats makes me think that maybe something is wrong (the adapter you said), the only thing is that i dont have another dvi monitor to make a test

  • Some bad news about the dust issue occuring with new cinema displays

    Hi. Just wanted to share what I went through today. I received a new cinema display for Christmas (early gift exchange with my gf) and was very shocked when I hooked it up to my MacBook Pro and noticed a long piece of dust under the glass (resembled a short piece of string). Once I confirmed it was under the glass, I packed up the display and brought it to the Apple Store in midtown. The Apple reps at the store were friendly and understanding and gave me no problems with an in store exchange request (the original display was purchased online). Upon receiving my second display, I hooked it up in the store to make sure there were no issues. Guess what...DOA. The Apple reps were shocked and slightly embarrassed and went to the back to get me another display. Once display #3 was brought out, we unpacked it and hooked it up to make sure everything looks alright. As soon as we turned on, 1 dead pixel and multiple pieces of dust behind the glass (5-6 dust particles). Once again, the reps say the dust issue is not acceptable and they go into the back to get display #4. Repeat routine and guess what...even MORE dust this time. Close to 9-10 particles throughout the monitor. Unbelievable! I ended up clearing out their stock so we had to leave the store empty handed (gift card equal to the amount of the display for future purchase).
    So what to do now? The manager and staff were very friendly and helpful and told me I could call in next week to see if they replenished their stock yet. Once replenished, the manager will check the monitor I am going to purchase prior to me stopping by the store so I don't waste another trip. I have a feeling this issue will be ongoing until it is addressed by Apple but we shall see. I really want this monitor for my new MacBook Pro so hopefully this will get sorted soon.
    Anyone else have this problem? Anyone purchase a good display?

    I'm glad there are others out there who are also seeing this stuff. My local apple store manager was more concerned about her stores sales rather than making the swap and getting me a new one. They held one after I was on the phone with them for 45 minutes, and this process required me to call back the next day again to make sure it was put on hold because even though they were closed, she couldnt place it on hold. Then, this monitor had dust behind it, and they were out of stock and were very unhelpful. I contacted apple and they have since been shipping me a new monitor. The first one came two days ago, cluster of 4 stuck green pixels noticeable on a black background, backlight issues, and there was some dust.
    I've said it before and will again, Apple you make great great stuff, but the displays are going down in quality. I've had iphones, new MBP's, and now cinema displays with dust under the glass. I dont know if they feel that most people don't catch this, and this is worth the price of doing busisness, however, its a shame to waste my time in hopes of getting one eventually that is perfect.
    Everyone who I talk to at aplcare is very nice and helpful. It just seems a huge waste of money for them to keep shipping monitors out with this issue when they are ultimately spending more to let me win the lottery so to speak in getting a display that doesnt have issues.
    Hopefully apple will see these posts and escalate them. Because I am bout to drop another 6,000 on a 2nd macbook pro and the new imacs when they release, and I pray that I dont have these issues. I would love to know who the vendor is, because they have been very sloppy lately.
    Maybe I could get a job at apple working quality assurance? That would be a dream job, playing with all thier new product and doing something useful, and getting paid.......

  • Problem w/ two 27" LED Cinema Displays on ATI 5770 MacPro

    Attempting to connect a second display to a mid 2010 Mac Pro. There are two mini-ports + a DVI on the 5770 card. Currently I have a single 27" LED connected using one of the mini ports. The computer isn't recognizing the second monitor in the other mini port. I used to have an older 24" LCD Cinema display running successfully, using the DVI port on card with a powered adapter. That configuration isn't doable with a newer 27" given the output from it (not the older style video cabling, but rather the mini display port. Would appreciate any suggestions on how to get the two 27" monitors running together.

    Hey turbostar, finally a chance to get back to you, sorry about the delay.
    I had already tried both ports with no success on the second monitor, but when I moved the primary monitor to the second port and it worked... it it got me to thinking maybe the power outlet was bad if not the monitor itself. Indeed that was the issue. The second monitor was plugged into a power strip in which one of the six outlets on it was not working. Replaced the surge power strip with a new one and all is good.
    Thank you for your time and help.

  • Cinema Display 30" problem

    Hi
    I have a 30 inch Cinema Display from 2006-ish. I have not used it for a while and when i powered it up again a few days ago it was kind of broken.
    There is no image from my Mac, only these vertical lines (check the photos). The lines change a bit if I move a window around and using a different Mac does not help.
    https://www.flickr.com/photos/69744417@N06/15415125321/
    https://www.flickr.com/photos/69744417@N06/15231698748/
    The screen itself appears to be intact. Does anyone know of anything I can try to get it fixed? Or replace a part or two?

    If you're not yet sorted - I had similar prob with my then 1 year-old iMac - AppleCare swore blind it wasn't a hardware problem and told me to wipe my hard drive and re-install EVERYTHING...!
    Fortunately, I didn't believe them, and hunted thru various forums...and identified that, as I thought, it WAS a hardware prob - and the next AppleCare guy acknowledged it and sorted the repair, finally!
    The heat sensor was from a bad batch (that it turned out Apple knew about and could have identified immediately by the serial number, so could have saved me days of frustration and wasted time) and it was erroneously turning the Mac off as what it perceived was a safety thing. Hope that helps...

  • Mid 2009 13" MacBook pro mini-dp to Cinema Display screen jumps from blue to desktop

    I'm using a kanex brand iAdapt mini-dp to dvi adapter to connect my macbook pro to my 23" cinema display from early 2007, but it seems like the macbook is having trouble recognizing that the display is connected. The screen will go blue for a second, then show the desktop, then go back to blue. it repeats like this for as long as the adapter is plugged in.
    I've gotten the screen to connect properly twice, but as soon as I unplug my laptop and try to plug it back in another day, I run into the same issue as before. I've seen other discussions about screen flickering, but this isn't really a flicker. Not sure if anyone else has experienced this, though it seems likely that this has happened before.
    Any solutions? Thanks!

    Hi thedankness,
    Thanks for visiting Apple Support Communities.
    You may find the steps in this article helpful with troubleshooting your display connection:
    Apple computers: Troubleshooting issues with video on internal or external displays
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1573
    Regards,
    Jeremy

  • How to connect a mac pro A1186 to 27" cinema display

    Hello! Trying to connect a newer display to older mac pro.
    Have a mac pro A1186, want to connect it to a 27" Cinema display. Any way to do this? I've read that there needs to be a female-mini-to-male-dvi converter, and that those don't exist?
    Any suggestions or help?
    Thank you!

    Hello,
    A new graphics card wouldn't be a bad idea; but if you don't want to go this route, I know from experience that the Altona DVI to Mini DisplayPort Converter works all right. It is discontinued now, but I'm sure a few of them can still be had through eBay or another similar source. I bought and used one to connect a 2006 Mac Mini to a 27" Cinema Display a while back. Hope this helps.
    http://www.atlona.com/Atlona-DVI-to-Mini-DisplayPort-Converter-p-17859.html

  • Cinema Display to be used with DVI to ADC Adapter

    Hello everyone,
    I have a 22-inch Apple Cinema Display (clear enclosure) connected to my Mac mini (Mid 2011) through Apple DVI to ADC Adapter.
    So far, this configuration has allowed me to get beautiful OS X desktop displayed on my old Cinema Display, though it wasn't perfect.
    Pressing the display's power button does not turn off the display nor put my Mac to sleep. Instead, holding the button just makes the power LED brighter than usual.
    Two USB ports on the back of the display doesn't seem to work. It does charge my iPod, but any device connected to those ports (including iPod) won't be recognized on my Mac.
    Can anybody see what's going on here and help me troubleshoot the issue?
    Thanks.

    Pressing the display's power button does not turn off the display nor put my Mac to sleep. Instead, holding the button just makes the power LED brighter than usual.
    That's normal with the DVI to ADC adapter.  ADC (Apple Display Connector) has pins for power control but there are no such pins in DVI so the display's power button has no way to control the computer.  I don't know why the power light brightens when pushed, but mine does it too.
    Two USB ports on the back of the display doesn't seem to work. It does charge my iPod, but any device connected to those ports (including iPod) won't be recognized on my Mac.
    Is the adapter's USB cable plugged into the computer?  The displays ports are USB 1.1.  Some devices, such as iPhones, require USB 2.0.
    Failure of the USB circuitry is common with those displays.  My 22" ADC display started having USB problems years ago.  It started with intermittent USB port problems, then it started interfering with computer sleep.  Since I now use the display with a DVI to ADC adapter I don't connect the adapter's USB cable (and don't use the display's USB ports), so don't have any computer sleep problems.

  • IMac with 24" Cinema Display

    Yesterday I went to the Apple Store and asked about buying a new 27" iMac and connecting it to my 24" Cinema Display. I was told that I could do that with an adapter and was sold a Mini DisplayPort to DVI Adapter.
    When I got home I realized that wasn't the correct adapter. I called the store and was told that it wasn't possible to connect the iMac to that particular monitor. (As an aside, I was really ****** because that was the whole reason for making this purchase!)
    Then I realized that the video plug fit in the iMac video port. I plugged it in and it seems to be working just fine. I just don't have the power and USB plugs from the monitor cable plugged in.
    So, am I okay doing this? Am I hurting anything? Was the genius at the Apple store wrong when I was told I couldn't connect the iMac and the Cinema display? The reason for my concern, several years ago I plugged an external display into an older iMac and it caused video problems requiring the replacement of the monitor.
    I can't seem to easily find anything in the forums, so any response/reassurance would be much appreciated!!

    OK, you confused me talking about the m-DP to DVI adapter. The Apple Store should refund your money for that bad recommendation. I think whomever sold it to you made the same mistake that I did. They thought that you had the model Cinema Display prior to the one that your have.
    So you have the 24" Cinema Display that was available from 2008 until just this past summer. It has one cable that ends in three connectors; mag-safe, USB and m-DP. Well the mag-safe connector was to power a MacBook so that one is fine not plugged in. The USB connector is for connecting the USB ports on the back of the display to your Mac, so there should be no issues plugging that in because it will give you an extra self-power hub if you need more USB ports at some point. And of course the m-DP is allowing the Mac to drive the display.
    I think that you should still be OK. Your iMac has a better GPU than the minimum requirement for your display.

  • Hello everyone, hoping for some help with my new Apple Cinema Display 20"

    Hi everyone, I bought an Apple Cinema Display 20 inch LCD monitor, just about 3 weeks ago. I have two issues I am hoping to get some help with.
    1) I am using the screen on a PC with Windows XP, and I was very disappointed at the lack of PC support. I have no on screen display (OSD), so I can't see what percentage I have my brightness set to, and I can't alter the colour or contrast of the display, etc. Luckily it defaulted to very good settings, but I would really like to be able to use the (fan made?) program called "WinACD". If I would be best asking somewhere else, please direct me there. If not, my problem is that I installed it added the "Controls" tab, but it just says, Virtual Control Panel "None Present". I have tried googling for an answer, and I have seen many suggestions, but none of them worked. I installed the WinACD driver without my USB lead plugged in, and someone said that was important. So I have tried uninstalling, rebooting, then reinstalling it again with the USB plugged in, and a device plugged in to my monitor to be sure. It didn't seem to help. I have actually done this process a few times, just to be sure. So I would really like to get that working if possible.
    2) I am disappointed at the uniformity of the colour on the display. I have seen other people mention this (again, after a google search), and that someone seemed to think it is just an issue we have to deal with, with this generation of LCD monitors. Before I bought this screen, I had an NEC (20wgx2), and it had a very similar issue. Most of the time, you cannot see any problem at all, but if you display an entire screen with a dark (none prime) colour, like a dark blue green colour, you can see areas where it is slightly darker than others. It was more defined on the NEC screen, and that is why I returned it. I now bought this Apple Cinema Display, because it was the only good alternative to the NEC. (It has an 8bit S-IPS / AS-IPS panel, which was important to me). But the problem exists in this screen too. It isn't as bad thankfully, but it still exists... I have actually tried a third monitor just to be sure, and the problem existed very slightly in that one, so I think I am probably quite sensitive in that I can detect it.
    It is most noticable to me, because I do everything on this PC. I work, I watch films, and I play games. 99% of the time, I cannot see this problem. But in some games (especially one)... the problem is quite noticeable. When you pan the view around, my eyes are drawn to the slight areas on my screen which are darker, and it ruins my enjoyment. To confirm it wasn't just the game, like I said, I can use a program to make the entire screen display one solid colour, and if you pick the right type of colour (anything that isn't a bright primary colour), I can see the problem - albeit fairly faintly.
    I am pretty positive that it is not my graphics card or any other component of my PC, by the way, because everything is brand new and working perfectly, and the graphics card specifically, I have upgraded and yet the problem remains - even on the new card. Also, the areas that are darker, are different on this screen than on the other screens I have used.
    So basically, I would like to register my disappointment at the lack of perfect uniformity on a screen which cost me £400 (over double what most 20 inch LCD screens cost), and I would like to know if anybody could possibly suggest a way to fix it?
    It is upsetting, becuase although this problem exists on other screens too, this is, as far as I know, the most expensive 20" LCD monitor available today, and uses the best technology available too.
    p.s. If anyone would like to use the program that lets you set your entire PC screen a specific colour, it is called "Dead Pixel Buddy", and it is a free piece of software, made by somebody to check for dead pixels. But I found it useful for other things too, including looking at how uniform the colour of the screen is. That's not to say I was specifically looking for this problem by the way... the problem cought my eye.
    Thanks in advance!
    Message was edited by: telelove

    I've been talking about this on another forum too, and I made some pictures in photoshop to describe the problem. Here is what I posted on the other forum:
    Yes, "brightness uniformity" definitely seems to be the best description of my issue.
    Basically it just seems like there are very faint lines down the screen, that are slightly darker than the other areas on the screen. They aren't defined lines, and they aren't in a pattern. It's just slight areas that are darker, and the areas seem like narrow bands/lines. Usually you can't see it, but in some cases, it is quite noticeable. It is mainly when I'm playing a game. The slightly darker areas are not visible, and then when the image moves (because I am turning in a car, or turning a plane, or turning in a shooter etc.) the image moves, but these slightly darker areas stay still, and that makes them really stand out.
    As for how it looks, I tried to make an example in photoshop:
    Original Image:
    http://img340.imageshack.us/img340/3045/td1ja9.jpg
    Then imagine turning the car around a bend, and then it looks like this:
    http://img266.imageshack.us/img266/959/td2hq7.jpg
    It's those lines in the clouds. If you can tab between the two images, you can see the difference easily. Imagine seeing those lines appear, every single time you move in a game. (I haven't tested this in movies yet, but I am assuming it's the same).
    It isn't very clear on a static image. But when the image moves, the darker areas stay in the same place and it draws your eyes towards them. It isn't terrible, but it is annoying, especially consider how much this screen cost.
    Message was edited by: telelove

  • Can't Use Cinema Display 30-inch With G5 (AGP)

    After making a trip to the Apple store to make sure we got what we needed, and because we needed a monitor ASAP, we brought home a 30-inch cinema display. The people at the store assured us that even though they didn't carry it, we could easily find a graphics card that would support this monitor on a G5 that has only AGP and PCI. Turns out they were wrong. After spending most of the day, between the hour drive each way to the store and lots of searching on the Internet, we finally came to the conclusion that we need to return the monitor. There are currently no available AGP or PCI cards that support the 30-inch monitor on a G5. The few that do support it are either discontinued or out of stock indefinitely, even from their manufacturers. Even Ebay only has one or two that are certain to work (as there are apparently multiple versions of the Radeon 9600 Pro). Whatever video card you get, you must be sure it specifically supports Mac, since the Mac's video card requirements are apparently not standard.
    So this serves as a warning, if you have a G5 you may or may not be able to use a 30-inch monitor. It is far from a sure thing, and definitely not something you can go out and buy and then just bring home and plug in. This was also my first (attempted) purchase at an Apple store (since we buy mostly mail order), and it was very disappointing. We got bad information, a product we can't use, and now two wasted 120-mile round trips. Actually the best advice we got from the Apple store was to buy another brand of monitor. We should have listened.

    Thanks. I saw your post just in the nick of time. I read it while I was on the phone with the Apple store discussing their restocking fee. I'll have the card tomorrow and hopefully my problem will be solved. And I was also able to cancel my order for the other monitor as it had not shipped yet.
    But I still think my warning is valid. This particular card is discontinued and OWC only has a few left. And as far as I can tell, no one else has anything compatible. So in the near future, driving a 30-inch monitor with a G5 without PCI-Express will not be a sure thing, and will certainly not be a one-stop shopping experience.
    Interesting side note, the Apple store was going to waive their restocking fee because they could not find a compatible card for me. When I told them I just found one, they said OK and didn't even ask what I found or where I found it.
    1.25 GHz G4 DP    

  • Apple 23" HD Cinema Display no longer working with new Macbook Pro

    I bought a 23" used HD Cinema display the other day along with the ADC-DVI and DVI-Mini Display adapters. I had it hooked up and it was working perfectly for 3 days. Today my wife tried to connect her Macbook accidentally via the USB that is part of the ADC-DVI adapter which didn't work (why is that USB there anyway?). Then when she went to connect the external display back to my Macbook Pro it did not wake up after being connected. I have tried resetting the PRAM on the MBP and have disconnected and re-connected all connections but nothing will get the display working with the MBP anymore. When I connect and disconnect the mini-display plug into the MBP the MBP flashes the blue screen as it appears to be reacting, but that's it. I can't detect any display when I go into the display system preferences. Does anyone know how I can get the Apple Cinema display working again? Thanks for any help.

    Ryan Nagy wrote:
    Upon reflection, I think my issue is different. Probably should not have posted it here. As it turns out sometimes my display works, sometimes it does not. I think the power adapter has gone bad. A common occurrence here in Mexico where the power can fluctuate quite a bit. - Ryan
    There are couple of long threads in the display section about problems with the power supplies on the 23" HD DVI. See this one for instance: https://discussions.apple.com/message/17981683#17981683
    Mine one day just wouldn't turn on -- connected to an old G4 MDD and the Mini -- a bit of fiddling it would occasionally start up, sometimes not. Similar to what you described, the Macs would see it in System Profiler, but it just wouldn't turn on.
    Based on that thread, I figured the problem was mostly likely the power supply. A local authorized repair place didn't have a spare for me to try, but the tech sniffed it and mentioned it the burnt electronics smell. LOL, I sniffed it and sniffed the power supply for my 20" DVI Cinema display -- indeed a weird smell.
    Based on that thread, I decided to bite the bullet and buy a beefier 150" power supply for the 30" Cinema display, which Apple says in compatible with the 23". See: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2803
    I hooked it up, crossed my fingers, and it fired up right away. It's been working fine for about 3 months now. Cheaper than buying a new monitor.

  • Dell 2005FPW vs. Apple 20'' Cinema Display

    I know this is sacrilege, but it is my patriotic duty and right to save $300 on my consumer electronics (after education discount for Apple, and tax, ACD comes out to $756, and Dell comes out to $453; both are out the door prices).
    Is there a difference in quality between the 20'' Apple Cinema Display and the Dell 2005FWP, or is the difference mainly superfical? What are the advantages disadvantages to either? Do these differences warrant $300I know there was a previous post, but if anyone cares to chime in, please do.
    I am running a Powerbook 12'' G4 1.5 GHz, and am consider getting a new Mac Mini in the near future, but just generally speaking...

    I've read of a lot of people saying that the 2405 is blindingly bright. To my eyes, that's true, but only if you turn up the brightness to max and change the color temperature setting to 9200K. At brightness around 50/100 and the standard 6500K color, everything's fine for me. Constrast is not adjustable using DVI (which is how it's suppose to be).
    But to the question, the Dell 2405 uses a Samsung PVA panel, whereas all the Apple displays use LG-Philips S-IPS panels. Reviews, personal opinions, and your own eyes can tell you one is better over the other. In my experience, I don't consider the LG-Philips 20" and 23" panels (the same panels found in displays by Apple, Dell, HP, Viewsonic) to be anything spectacular. Colors are somewhat bland, black levels aren't as good, and the LCD or coating over the LCD has a grainy appearance that kind of gives off an annoying glittery look. The Samsung panel at 24" looks better to me. But with the 30" LG-Philips panel (shared by the Dell and Apple displays), it's amazing. The grainyness isn't noticable, viewing angles are good across the entire screen (though not with blacks which turn purple at an angle), and color/contrast are good.
    Bottom line is that S-IPS panels like in the Apple 23" do have better viewing angles (in which colors don't shift as bad at an angle, and detail isn't lost as badly), but blacks don't look as deep and turn purple at an angle. It's also less bright, but perhaps also has not as good contrast. Color is probably subjective - some will say the 2405 is over-saturated, others will say it's vibrant. I'd try the Apple if the Dell doesn't satisfy you. Both are regarded as the best of the best.

Maybe you are looking for

  • HOw to start the project for first view in webdynpro application

    Hi,I am having  a problem regarding scenario for customer feedback for portal end user i.e..wen user login to a application for feedback there it check the Id of the user wether it had given the feedback or not by comparing the Id with the database I

  • Desktop Software does not detack BB 6 System Software and Language

    Hi, I wanted to install other languages back to my phone (currently only English).  However,  my Desktop Software 6.1.0.36 installed in Vista does not detect and display BB 6.0.0 system software, and so is language option.  BI can see other installed

  • Enterprise Systems Vs Distributed Systems

    What is the difference between Enterprise system and Distriubted system and Role of J2EE in these two systems?

  • Passing Parameters within a DPS App

    I have a DPS App with 2 slots. One slot contains embedded code which is suppose to show a list of assets. One slot contains code that launches an external site in a frame within the DPS app.  As per this article New Consumer Marketing APIs | Adobe De

  • My ipod just stopped working.

    hi. I got my ipod shuffle 2nd Generation a while ago and it had so far worked fine, until I connected it today and windows gave the "USB device cannot be recognized" error message. I updated Itunes (which was a hard thing to do in itself) but I still