Color Shifts when rendering to H.264 Blu-ray

Since upgrading to After Effects CS5 I am seeing the following:
Whenever I render out a video file using the "H.264 Blu-ray" Output Module option, the resulting m4v video has a different color appearance than the After Effects composition from which it was rendered. The rendered file appears to have a yellow cast to it, especially evident in red highlights. This appearance is seen within After Effects (after importing the file and dropping it in a composition) as well as in VLC media player. In addition, a blu-ray disc created using the m4v file also has the yellow appearance when viewed on an HDTV. In other words, the color shift is consistant in various players as well as within After Effects itself.
Here is the bug report I submitted:
******BUG******
Concise problem statement:
Steps to reproduce bug:
1. Create a project with HDTV (Rec. 709) color space, 8 bit.
2. Import a 1920x1080 video file (any kind).
3. Render out to H.264 Blu-ray (using project color space).
4. Import the resulting m4v file and compare it to the original video.
Results: The color has been shifted; has a yellow cast to it.
Expected results: the color should appear the same for the rendered file as the original.

Chris,
Thanks for your input.
"I can assure you this isn't a widespread problem as I've rendered a fair amount of h.264 directly out of AE and haven't noticed it. Nor have I heard anything from our testing department."
Try this simple test:
Make a 1920x1080 comp in AE with your choice of footage, using any AE settings/color management etc. you want to.
Render to format "H.264 Blu-ray" (or plain "H.264") with any settings you care to choose, with the goal being best color fidelity possible.
After rendering, import the output file into After Effects.
Drop it in the original comp.
A / B the two and compare the color.
Do they match?
If so, then you have achieved what I cannot, and what no one so far has demonstrated to me that they can do, and at that point I would greatly appreciate your sharing with me the secret of your success.
If not, then join the club, because I can assure you that I am not the only one.

Similar Messages

H.264 Blu-Ray rendered .m4v files won't playback in any media player except Adobe software

Hello guys and thank you in advance for your help. I am going to pull my hair out!
I had to reinstall Windows 7 and am experiencing an issue that is driving me crazy. All of my 720p H.264 Blu-Ray.m4v files rendered with After Effects will not play in any player I try in Windows. I've tried Windows Media Player, VLC, and Media Player Classic. I've tried with a clean install and no other codecs except those included with Windows 7. I've tried installing additional h.264 codecs. I've tried installing ffdshow and other codecs as well and no matter what I do, the files will not play at all.
The only way I can preview the file it to load it in AE or Encore or something similiar. Unfortunately, this is not the best solution for me. I'd love to be able to preview the files quickly and efficiently through Windows Explorer / Media Player without opening Adobe software. I don't think that's too much to ask.
Another issue is that before I reinstalled Windows that these files played back just fine in Windows Media Player! I don't know why it was working and now it's not on a clean install. All of the hardware is the same. On the original working install, I don't recall installing any additional codec packs or anything. It just worked...
Regular .mp4 H.264 files (not Blu-Ray) play just fine in all players. Something the Blu-Ray spec is doing to the file causes it to not work. And changing the extension to mp4 does nothing.
Please tell me what I am doing wrong! Is it something with the Mainconcept codec? Is it something with my drivers? What am I missing?!?

Thanks for the suggesstion Mylenium, but that didn't help either.
I installed PowerDVD which came with the Blu-Ray drive, and also a trial of ArcSoft's Blu-Ray player, and neither would play the files.
Any other suggestions? This is killing me. I don't understand why they would play before and not now. The files arne't corrupt. Even new rendered outputs in the same preset won't play. They'll load into Encore just fine though and even are listed as "Don't Transcode", so I know the files themselves are okay.
Could it have anything to do with drivers? I was testing an Nvidia video card with my last build and now I'm just using a Sandy Bridge chip with Intel's on-board video. But I do remember even when I took the Nvidia card out and just ran on-board video the last time, the files still played fine...

Premiere Pro CC H.264 Blu-ray rendering problem

Hi!
I have a problem when try to render AVCHD files (.m2ts) to H.264 Blu-ray. This is the issue that follows me from Premiere Pro CS6 and old machine. When I create a sequence from AVCHD (.m2ts) files and try to export it with H.264 Blu-ray settings (only two changes I made in default settings are multiplexing to TS and change audio to Dolby digital) i got few seconds shorter video file than the original timeline and automatically audio and video are out of sync. I notice that when I try to play rendered video with Windows media player (Media player classic and VLC player also play it the same way) after a while audio is starting to be out of sync. When I import rendered file again into Premiere Pro CC and put it in timeline I can see that my rendered video is shorter than original timeline (I have 4h 30min project and rendered video is 4sec shorter; everything is there but 4sec shorter - probably faster, it is hard to notice how faster because of long timeline, but obviously 4sec faster)
Also, when I take that same project to my friend and render it again everything is ok. He is running a little bit better machine but also he is running Premiere Pro CS6 and I'm running Premiere Pro CC. That was the issue also when he was running Premiere Pro CS 5.5 and run Premiere Pro CS6 a year ago. All settings stays the same when I render and when my friend render the same sequence. I have audio out of sync and he haven't
One more question: Premiere Pro and AME not using Mercury Payback Engine GPU Acceleration at all. In AME I chose renderer: Mercury Payback Engine GPU Acceleration but when I look at NVIDIA inspector I can see that GPU usage is 0% when rendering is in progress. Any idea?
THX!

Thank you Jim,
but I'm confused. Same project, absolutely same settings but with different hardware got different results?
About 2 years ago I had AMD Athlon 3200+, ATI Radeon X800XL, 8GB DDR2 RAM, Win 7, Premiere Pro CS6 (AVCHD input, rendering to .m2t, all settings to default, just multiplexing set to TS because I need audio and video multiplexed to be able to play directly from external HDD to LED TV via USB) - result: audio is out of sync.
My friend had Intel i7, nVidia GTX 550, 16GB DDR3 RAM, Win 7, Premiere Pro CS5.5 (same project, AVCHD input, rendering to .m2t, all settings to default, just multiplexing set to TS) - result: everything OK.
Few days ago same thing, but with new hardware - my hardware: Intel i5, nVidia GTX 760, 16GB DDR3 RAM, Win 8.1, Premiere Pro CC (AVCHD input, rendering to .m2t, all settings to default, just multiplexing set to TS) - result: audio out of sync (as a matter of fact video is shorter - I didn't realize that few years ago, but just now).
My friend with his same hardware as above, few years old (AVCHD input, rendering to .m2t, all settings to default, just multiplexing set to TS) - result: everything OK.
Why is video (rendered) shorter than the original timeline? Is it possible because of multiplexing to TS? If it is the reason, why Adobe left us to choose do we want to use multiplexig or not, when it causes such drastic problem? Why Adobe left us so much option to play with? They don't want to certificate every peace of hardware (graphic card, although many graphic cards are compatible and can be used "at our own risk") because, as they said, it can cause problems, and they left us so much option to change before rendering, and some of them causing problems and aren't compatible with each other If I check some box then I got bad result, and if I not check it, then everything is OK? Don't understand why they left us that option when it's not OK to use it, because it produce bad result?
Not to mention that rendering (AVCHD to H.264 or MPG2 Blu-ray) is significantly faster with i7 than with i5, because, as I can see, GPU Acceleration is not used at all for rendering (maybe just for few effects, that I didn't used yet).
THX!

Color shift when using save for web

Hello,
I am converting my psd files to jpegs using "save for web". I am noticing that the colors are shifting from the original after saving for web. The color shift does not happen if I just convert the psd files to jpegs by using "save as". The psds have a profile of RGB1998. I am using CS3 and my monitor is color calibrated.
Do I need to convert the psd documents to sRGB first before I go to "save for web"?
The preview doesn't look any different if I check ICC profile in the save for web window. I have been told that you are not supposed to embed the ICC profile in the document when saving for web because most monitors are untagged.
Anyway I am wondering if I have to accept a color shift when saving for web or is there something I can do to get the saved for web jpegs to more closely match the original psd?
Thanks a lot for your help.

I think the reason why this question is asked often is because the FAQ entry is pretty lame and incomplete, especially for Mac users that by default have a color managed browser and by default have a screwed up rendering mechanism for untagged images.
Depending on your version of Photoshop, you can convert to sRGB before or during the Save for Web operation.
cesspool13 wrote:
...I have been told that you are not supposed to embed the ICC profile in the document when saving for web because most monitors are untagged.
You convert to sRGB for the systems that do not fully support color management.
and...
You include the sRGB ICC profile for the systems that do support color management.
Doing both covers your bum in most situations. You may choose to omit the ICC profile if you are working on common interface graphics that do not require strict color management. The ICC profile adds a few kilobytes to the file size that are not necessary on lesser graphic elements on a web page.

Color shift when printing

We have a Xerox workcenter 7655 at work and since I upgraded to Snow Leopard I get bad color shifts when printing. It's mostly too much magenta. I converted a cmyk file to a high quality pdf and the color was accurate when printing from a Windows machine but the light blue was badly shifted to lavender from my Mac. I tried different cmyk profiles when creating the pdf and printed the native file out of InDesign with the same results.
The print I get from the Windows machine has the same colors as what I see on my Mac's monitor. I do mostly web design now and have been out of the print end for some time. Until I moved to Snow Leopard, I didn't have this problem.
Can I get some ideas on how I can address this?
thanks

You answered your own question: CS5. There have been a slew of reports of workflows spun upside down when upgrading to CS5. It may require updating your system software and/or Adobe applications, along with any printer driver updates that may be lurking out there somewhere. The twist to your situation is ( and is very common ) that everything was working before and now it does not. Or there is a certain print disorder of some sort. Very troubling. I wish I had a smoking gun answer for you, but I don't. It sounds like you have a very viable workflow in place that worked before and damn well should perform for you now. I'd stick with what works and dump what doesn't ( if you can ).

Color shift when uploading

I have been trolling other sites to learn what might cause this.
I recently got a Huey device to callibrate my monitor. (I send out digital images of artwork and they need to be acurate color.)
After taking some images and loading them onto iPhoto, they seem to look very much like what I saw on the camera lcd screen. I can make subtle color and tone adjustments while capturing on the Panasonic Lumix camera. Usually, they are so close to what I want, all I do is crop in iPhoto.
But I am experiencing color shifts when I upload to make webpages so I can burn discs, or today when I uploaded to a local photo printer. They seem to move a bit towards more orange/pink tones, but when I drag them to the desk top, and open in Preview, they look identical to the iPhoto stored images.
I have read some ideas about RGB and there being bugs in iPhoto that alter your files even as you are loading them from the camera!
Does anyone know how I could fix this?
I can write scripts if it takes it. Thanks

Nanci
The pics look correct in iPhoto and Preview, right?
But not on the Web or at your local printer?
iPhoto and Preview are both Color Managed - that is (along with Safari) they read and respect the color profile of the pic.
Do the apps your Printer is using, or that you are using to view online, respect the color profile?
Regards
TD

How to fix color shift when converting ProPhoto rgb to srgb IE61966-2.1

How do I fix the color shift when converting my photos in photoshop to srgb for the web. I work in lightroom color space prophoto rgb and after editing in photoshop I convert it over but I get a shift in the colors. Thanks

are you working in 16-bit (ProPhotoRGB, you probably should be)
exactly how are you doing the Conversion
MAKE SURE YOU ARE NOT CONVERTING ANY ADJUSTMENT LAYERS (flatten or merge them before convert)
AND MAKE SURE YOU ARE VIEWING THE PROBLEM AREA AT 100% ACTUAL PIXELS when you do the convert

AME Shuts Down when exporting H.264 Blu Ray

I have a current project that was shot in HDV and I am trying to export an H.264 Blu Ray file. This is a 4 Disk set and the other 3 files exported with no problems but for some reason I cannot get this last one (which happens to be Disk #3). I will start AME running as I am getting ready to leave my office. When I come back in the morning there is nothing open on my desktop, just the normal screen. Anyoen have any ideas??? Below are my export setting and computer info
Format: H.264 Blu Ray
Preset: Custom
Pixel Aspect Ratio: Widescreen 16:9
Profile: High
Level: 4.1
Bitrate Encoding: VBR 2 pass
Target Bitrate: 20 Mbps
Maximum Bitrate: 25 Mbps
Audio: PCM
Multiplexing: None
Computer
Windows XP Pro 64
Intel Core 2 Quad 2.5GHz
4 GB RAM
300 GB System Drive
1.5 TB Video Dive with 700 GB of free space.
Thanks
Phil

This is from the regular LOG.
5/9/2009 12:37:29 PM : Queue Started
- Source File: C:\DOCUME~1\ADMINI~1\LOCALS~1\Temp\Kapadia Wedding_24.prproj
- Output File: V:\DVD's\Kapadia\From Premiere\Disk_3_HD.m4v
- Preset Used: Custom
- Video: NTSC, 1440x1080, 29.97 [fps], Upper
- Audio: PCM Audio, 48 kHz, Stereo
- Bitrate: VBR, 2 Pass, Target 20.00, Max 25.00 [Mbps]
That is it... It does not show that there was a problem or that it was completed.
I then went into the Errors Log and there was nothing about this particular project.
Do you think that maybe the PC is shutting down and restarting? Not sure how I would know that...
Dont get me started on the Pr not supported by XP 64 thing. Quite frustrating to me....
Phil

H.264 Blu-ray Rendering is Blocky at Start

Hi,
I'm rendering some 1920x1080 23.98 video out to H.264 Blu-ray M4V files in After Effects. Once we start authoring the Blu-ray disc in Scenarist we notice the very start of the video, for the first 12 frames or so, is very blocky. It then cleans up and looks great throughout the rest of the video. We are using a bitrate of 25 average and 30 max.
A temporary solution is to render out to uncompressed 10-bit 4:2:2 quicktime and then compress with our CinemaCraft(which doesn't support ANY type of compressed files). But this is a few extra steps and the quicktimes are so big it's kind of a pain and rendering straight out of After Effects would be ideal.
Does anyone have any experience with why it may end up blocky at the start? I've tried this on both Mac and PC versions on After Effects CS3. I don't have CS4 yet, so maybe that solves the problem.
Sorry if this has been covered before, I searched around and didn't see anything. Thanks for any help!
Rey

Ultimately, you're going to get a lesser quality encode directly from AE - it's just not the ideal tool for compressing anything using a temporal compression algorithm, by nature of how AE works.
It's rare for me to use AE as a compression tool. Standard operating procedure is to render a lossless/uncompressed file from AE and encode with a more appropriate tool. In your case, if you're using a Mac, Compressor is the obvious choice. On the PC, you've already mentioned you have Omni CinemaCraft. Either of these tools will be superior to AE as an encoder.

Color shift when pasting from CMYK document to RGB document

Hello,
We're creating an image for a client that will eventually be printed 4c process, and we have to use some very specific CMYK values. However, since we need to use certain layer effects, we need to work in RGB. I assumed that since the CMYK values we use are within the RGB gamut, there would be no color shift when copying from a CMYK doc and pasting into an RGB doc, but I'm apprently mistaken.
I'm not very familiar with color management, since we don't do any heavy duty color work in house, so this is likely a very rudimentary question: how do I keep colors from shifting when pasting from a CMYK document into an RGB document (which will eventually be converted back to CMYK for print)?
Any help is greatly appreciated. Thanks.

x
x
x
you have two possible issues at work that would explain a change
"out of gamut" color between color modes (the RGB colors don't translate well to CMYK)
you are discarding profile information information when pasting (and not Converting to the destination)...

Adobe prem / media encoder h.264 blu-ray jitters, flickers /w slow-mo

hello
using the Adobe Production Premium CS4 pack... hardware is not an issue, also all the latest updates are installed.. prem 4.2.1 (003), encoder 4.2.0.006
after export and authoring, we are having strange glowing flickers, and bad slo-motion effect playback
the problem seems to be consistent with slo-motion and time remapping, frame holds and especially when an additive dissolve is thrown in.
the edit's are far from saturated with these effects, but a simple frame-hold with motion-rotation and motion-scale occurring with keyframes. the problem also happens with something as simple as a 30% speed/duration added onto a clip..
the footage is captured and on a timeline at - 1440x1080 (1.3333) HD Anamorphic, 25fps (50i)
the export profile after edit is - H.264 Blu-ray - 1440 x 1080i 25 High Quality
i get the feeling the problem may be occurring as the footage is remaining as interlaced footage through-out and not being blended or discarded to progressive.
i have tried making the footage progressive on export thinking it might solve the problem, but it turns out there is no such thing as progressive HD PAL in media encoder and encore
i love adobe's workflow but we have never been fond of main-concept from the start with things like this, even Mpeg2-DVD exports come out softer than you'd expect
any thoughts, light or general directions on what to do to help figure out the problem would be great..

after around 30 small sample exports, builds and different renders... I have discovered the problem and am now on track to fixing it..
it turns out certain adobe effects such as 'lighting effects' do NOT work well with slo-mo or frame held clips.. upon taking this one effect off, the clip looks flatter and less dynamic in context of my edit, but the clip plays normally no matter what the export settings, codec or format..
what's hallarious is that these effects and edits export and author perfectly fine onto DVD through Mpeg2.. i guess they just flatten better etc.. i get the impression when Adobe started crafting their software for HD they just built on top of the normal effects etc they already had and expected them to work.. if only Premiere could get the updates, priority and attention Photoshop does..
again, i love premiere's work flow, i just can't see how they can put the word 'Pro / Professional' near this software...
many thanks all
Steve

H.264 Blu-Ray Codec

Premiere Pro CS4 is not rendering H.264 Blu-ray videos correctly on my computer. I can save H.264 videos fine, it saves as an MP4, but when I try and do the higher quality one, it gives me a couple different files: An m4v, a wav, an xmpses, and an md0 file. I'm assuming these all should have come together after rendering, but they did not. Anyone know what's going on?

YOu have me confused...
Is it BluRay, or Youtube you're looking for?
If you're looking to create an H264, then don't go to the Bluray setting, but go to the generic H.264 button, and flydown to the YouTube settings..Whether widescreen or standard...
It's easy as cake..Personally, i like to keep the HD encodes no more than 3000kbps. I've noticed that the YouTube videos are being streamed at 785kbps anyways...
I believe you're making it harder than need to be..

H.264 Blue Ray audio question

I have seen this question brought up before but not answered fully.
The background:
i need to make a video that is
(Video)
File format: MP4 H.264
Aspect Ratio: 16 x 9 (1920 x 1080)
NTSC HD 60i (interlaced)
Square Pixel
(Audio)
48kHz
24 bit stereo
When exporting i selected H.264 Blue Ray and set the video accordingly (set the resolution to 1920 x 1080 @ 29.97, upper, square pixle) the problem I’m having is setting up the audio to be 24 bit. From my understanding AC3 only supports 16 bit but what about Dolby Digital can i get 24 bit audio if i use it and what setting do i change to get 24 bit audio at 48 kHz?

Do you HAVE sound in your comp? You'd be surprosed by the number of embarassed "no" replies.
Did you use the AE Render Queue? You have to specify that you actually want to inclue an audio track in the th Output Module; it isn't automatic. Most people don't even bother with audio when rendering from AE.
But here's the big thing: don't use AE to render H.264 files in the first place. AE stinks at it. Instead, use Adobe Media Endoder. You Can open an AE project in AME, then make an H.264 of any comp in the project.

Exporting H.264 Blu-ray material in CS3

System:
2009 Mac Pro 3.33GHz Quad core
Snow Leopard 10.6.5
16GB RAM
Radeon HD 5870
Adobe Premiere Pro CS3, 3.2.0
Video material:
DVCProHD, 1080p60i/24p, 23.976fps shot on P2, MXF file format.
Exporting to:
H.264 Blu-ray via Adobe Media Encoder
I can render Blu-ray material, and even burn it in an internal LG 10x Blu-ray burner that I installed. The result was wonderful when played back on a Blu-ray player and HDTV.
What I cannot figure out is why I have to render projects in small little segments, rather than one large one, and then line them all up on a timeline in Encore. I then have to rearrange my chapter points, since Encore places a chapter marker at each clip. It's not the biggest deal in the world, but it's just annoying.
I've tried different settings, and the one that gives me the most success is starting with the preset for H.264 (Blu-ray), HDTV 1080p 23.976 High Quality, and switching the Profile from High to Main, and leaving the rest alone. I'm not sure if I tried HDTV 1080i 29.97... maybe I should. Whether it crashes or not seems to depend on how many effects are in the clip, or how long the segment is, but I can usually get away with up to about 10000 frames of video without a crash. The crash almost always occurs during the second pass of VBR encoding. It closes Premiere and offers the crash report window, which I am not good at decyphering. Anyway, I always submit the crash report with what I was trying to do. Adobe has many of them from me now.
Can anyone shed some light as to why it only allows 6000-10000 frames go through this encoding process? My system will show that it only used about 6 out of 16 GB of RAM after a fresh reboot. It helps if I reboot between each encode session, as well. If I try to encode two short segments without rebooting between, I usually get a crash. Also, I can encode DVDs just fine with the same project. I encoded the 105 minute movie with all the same effects, clips, etc. and the DVD was flawless on the first try. It's just the H.264 Blu-ray setting that jacks it up.
I'm glad I can get the thing done piecemeal, but I was hoping someone could at least explain why it's so difficult. (:

I would agree, and I think it must have to do with RAM. When I get a segment exported successfully, the Activity Monitor shows very close to all 16 GB used in many cases. I surmise that when the program sucks too close to all 16GB up, it crashes.

Premier CS4 will export H.264 Blu Ray, but not a H.264 file.

When I export the file under H.264, Adobe Encoder won't even load the project file. However, it loads and completely exports my 25 minute 1080p HD 24 fps film under the H.264-Blu Ray option which takes about 17 hours on my Dinosaur PC.
So basically, I already have a 25 minute 4 gig film on a Blu-ray disc that I burned at my friends Modern computer, and now I just want a standalone MP4 file as a backup.
Anyone?
Bill Hunt?
Specs,
Windows XP service pack 3
2.8 Ghz
3.25 GB RAM
37G free HD
and 30G free on a 640G EXTERNAL

Despite the Interlaced UFF export setting, the H.264 option doesn't respect that and exports out a poorly deinterlaced progressive video instead.
If you need interlaced H.264, always use the H.264 Blu-ray option.

Color Shifts when rendering to H.264 Blu-ray

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for