HTPC Mini-ITX motherboard - Which CPU/APU to choose?

Hi there!
I will soon start to build a HTPC setup, which will be used for 1080p (H264) playback through the onboard HDMI port, as well as audio playback through onboard toslink S/PDIF.
What to choose, Amd Fusion or Intel Atom /w the ION 2 GPU? I expect that the GPU part will be able to handle most of the H264 decoding, and that the platform will be stable and fully functional.
I already own a Asus E35M1-I mini-ITX motherboard which i currently use for my headless file server, but it seems to be somewhat unstable, and the network interface is missing some throughput (550Mbit/s). This causes uncertainty about if it is smart to choose the Amd Fusion setup.
Any input/tips?
(This is not strictly related to Arch Linux, but the system will run Arch Linux, so i guess it should be okay to ask here in this forum)

signor_rossi wrote:Anandtech has a lot of articles describing the Fusion platform and comparing it with the Atom/Ion combo.
http://www.anandtech.com/show/4134/the- … or-miniitx
As for your problems with your Asus board, is your BIOS up-to-date?
Sadly there are no BIOS updates other than the version shiped with the motherboard. I think I will just have to wait and see if Asus releases a new version. I will take a deeper look into the article tonight, thanks for the link!
zenlord wrote:
I don't think you can choose a wrong solution these days. All the recent chipsets are perfectly capable of decoding 1080p. I myself am an intel-gpu-fan, because of the good and open source drivers. If your pc will be positioned in your living room, you should definitely investigate the noise levels of the onboard fans, PSU fans and case fans (not to mention the noise of the hard disk(s)).
That's why I have chosen to make my file server (which is in the basement) play/decode all the content and stream it over the network to a PS3, but there are many passively cooled DLNA-clients out there...
Regarding noise, i will probably use a cheap SSD/my old 4GB CF-card as local storage, and the motherboard will be one of the fanless versions. External laptop-style PSU. The noise level will not be a problem.
Regarding a pure DLNA client: I want to be able to do other things on the HTPC in the future. And for now, it will in addition to XBMC run MPD for music and LIRC for IR remote control support. If i just wanted it for video playback, i could have easily gone for a DNLA set top box with a lot less hassle
.:B:. wrote:
I'm considering an E350 setup myself, especially since the Intel offerings do not support 24 Hz, and that's a showstopper for me. That would mean either I'd need to get an Atom/Ion combo (which is too underpowered for my taste when it comes to the CPU) or get a Sandy Bridge with an nVidia card, which means higher power usage. From what I gather, Zacate should be a bit smoother than the Atom setups, and a bit more power-efficient as well.
Clvn, if network performance is your concern (and I doubt 550 Mbps is a bottleneck for what you're doing, but then again, I don't know what else your setup is doing while it's streaming HD stuff), there's only one solution: get an Intel gigabit card. Or you can go for a full Intel platform as well though, if that 24 Hz problem is not an issue for you.
I did not know anything about the 24Hz frequency limitation, I have not paid any attention to it. I think i will have to read a little bit about it. Thanks for the input about that!
SInce the E350 platform performs better, it's sad that it seems a bit unstable (at least that is my experience so far..). Hopefully this will be better with driver updates.
About the network speed: That motherboard will continue to be used as a file server for a while longer (with the onboard NIC), untill it will be used as a dedicated firewall with a dual gbit NIC (at least that is the plan). The 550Mbit/s throughput is not a problem, but it seems a bit strange that it does not perform better. I've changed the TP and the port at the switch, but still got the same available bandwidth. That too will probably be fixed with either a BIOS update or a driver update.
graysky wrote:I have an Atom-based (older 330) solution that works great for HD stuff.  VDPAU rocks.  Dunno about AMD's stuff.
Even 1080p mkv (H264)?
flamelab wrote:Choose the all-time-classic reliable Nvidia solution, since VDPAU will surely work. I'm not sure for the AMD solution and I wouldn't choose it for Linux usage. For Windows, it would be very much OK.
Thanks for the input.
signor_rossi wrote:Good point, flamelab. As for info on the Linux driver support, phoronix.com is a good place to get info:
http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=a … ixed&num=1
And zenlord made me remember to ask you what you will use the HTPC for, since in some cases a networked media player like a WD TV Live! might suffice, too.
I will do some reading at phoronix about the AMD Fusion driver support. And regarding devices like WD TV, i would like to have a fully functional pc. MPD and LIRC will be used on regular basis.
After all the feedback in the thread, i think the Intel/VDPAU option will be a lot more safe and stable. I will just have to read a bit about what the missing 24Hz support from Nvidia's side.
If i choose Intel Atom/ION, i think this Asus card will do the trick: http://www.asus.com/Motherboards/Intel_ … /AT5IONTI/
Thanks for all the input so far, guys! I really appriciate it

Similar Messages

  • PCIe-8183 users, what Micro ATX or Mini ITX motherboard/PC works to get full [0,255] PCI bus enumeration???

    Do you get a full range of PCI buses [0,255]? I cannot find a Micro or Mini system that will work. My limit is [0,3e] (dec 0-62 buses) using NI's bus enumeration utility: MXIeBusDetect_64bit.exe from the site: Determining the Number and Range of PCI/PCI Express Root Bus Devices 
    Thanks in advance!

    hello sir,
    i want to your help
    i was installed fresh windows 7 via cd rom and then after installed all software.
    and now after 1 day customer complained me that cd rom not read any cd and i m also check when i insurt cd so its not read and when i am double click on cd rom icon its eject so what i do for that please reply on my email address.
    [text removed for privacy]
    VIMAL

  • DIY/DYO MediaCenter PC (mini-itx mobo)

    Hi,
    I wasn't really sure which subforum should I post this to, but anyway...
    The other day (well, actually night) I kind off got obsessed with the idea of buying a mini-itx motherboard and do some really custom low-end PC. The main use would be to have mp3s and movies stored so I could play them with a remote. Of course I'll  have other uses for it, but that would be mainly it.
    So, next monday I'll be getting an Intel D945 GCLF motherboard. After that I'll start with a 1G DDR2 667MHz memory. I've got a 350W PSU lying there already, so I'll use that one. Also there's an extra CD drive at home, so I can start by trying a LiveCD.
    What I'm getting at with this is that I'm going to install Arch on it, because I think that, even if other distributions would be more suitable, I can't help it: I wan't a KISS distro like Arch on it, so I can tweak it as I want.
    I'm hoping I can make it boot fast (so it actually feels like an appliance, not a PC that requires a keyboard to make it boot if something goes wrong).
    My idea is to make a case from scratch with spare parts from other leftover ATX cases from work. I'll try to make a cube-case from that.
    Regarding software, I'll try xbmc and elisa (they both look great, but I don't know if the hardware will take it).
    I'll upload pics from the project as I get it going, if you archers are interested.

    Well, I've got a little more serious with the project.
    I got the mobo:
    (the Intel manual only serves structural purposes)
    Yesterday I received a 320G Samsung SATAII 16MB 7200RPM drive, and a OCZ DDR2 80MHz 1G RAM. I took the necessary cables from empty cases and a PSU I had laying there. Everything hooked:
    I forgot to connect the P4 connector, so when I turned it on, it didn't worked =b
    After fixing that, I got into the BIOS:
    that's a really professional look =b
    I didn't installed anything yet since I'm missing a cable, but I'm going to wait until I build the case... too much hastle to install it like that.
    I thought about it, and the case is going to be made of acrylic, with some metal parts taken from old cases (to make it tougher). I'm using Google Sketchup to design the case. My idea is to take this general design and adapt it to this bigger PSU, and the regular DVD and HD drives it will be using.
    The last component I will buy (not for the moment) will be a wireless PCI card.
    Will post some pictures of the design when it's more mature.

  • Motherboard or CPU is dead......which one?

    I have today tried to turn my computer on............its dead. I've changed ALL the components expect the CPU. How can i tell which is the fault the motherboard or CPU. I have two computers at home but the other one doesn't use the same CPU. Nothing works fans, lights drives......nothing, can the motherboard still power up without a working CPU?
    Motherboard =MSI K8N Neo Platinum Nforce3
    CPU             =AMD Athlon 64 3200
    Hope you can help, i need to send one of them back under warranty, but which one.

    Quote from: K6dude on 10-January-06, 01:10:48
    I was just wondering if you checked the fuse in either the PC power lead or the extension/4 socket adapter?
    If you used the original power lead then the new PSU would fail too...same with the adapter.
    I have seen 4 way multi adapter fuses go often if the total load exceeds the rating of the adapter, and with PCs needing more and more power, this is getting far more common recently.
    Just a thought.
    K6dude
    You wouldn't believe how many ways i tried still no joy, its now go back...........i await the doctors verdic

  • MSI H61I-E35-B3 Mini ITX and Intel Xeon LGA1155 Cpu ?

    Hi,
    I've bought MSI H61I-E35-B3 Mini ITX board, it supports LGA1155 processors, core i3 / i5 / i7. My question is - have anyone tested this board with Intel Xeon processor ? For example Intel Xeon E3-1235 3.20GHz LGA1155. I've read in some other Mini ITX LGA 1155 boards descryptions, that they suport this cpu's. Maybe this one can also support it.

    It's not in the supported list;  http://eu.msi.com/product/mb/H61I-E35--B3-.html#/?div=CPUSupport
    Recommend to confirm with MSI Tech Support; http://support.msi.com

  • Can the MSI H81I Mini ITX LGA1150 overclock out off the box pentuim g3258 ?

    Hi everyone Im building a mini itx gaming computer and I want to know if the MSI H81I can overclock the g3258 easily and out off thé box ( I dont have any other cpu to make a BIOS update )
    Thanx
    Nalfein

    Obviously voice inflection doesn't come across well in typing.  If we're here only to sing MSI's praises, it's not a forum.
    "Fix the attitude" is little harsh considering MSI seems to be the only one following Intel's wishes.  Perhaps you missed the light hearted "Peer pressure:  Come on MSI...everybody's doin' it!  Lol" and the part where I said I like the board? ASUS, Gig and others as well as other MSI boards can run the little Haswell multiplier up, this H81i, bummer...nope.
    No, overclocking it is not endorsed by Intel, MSI or anyone else for that matter and no company can endorse cranking a 3.2 chip to 4.7.  However, the web is full of H81/g3258 overclocks.  Like, for instance, Tom'sHardwareguide.com.  We all read the specs (or should) but as is well publicized, you don't need the expensive Z boards to work low end magic.
    I've used MSI components since the Athlon 750 CPU was new and still have an old MSI GeForce 4 Ti 4200 in a drawer out of nostalgia. I would simply like to play with the multiplier and tinker up to 4.0 or something modest, just to see.    Heck, even ECS is doing it.  I wanted to stay with MSI products since I'm happy with them.  As a board, it's fine.  The news about updating the BIOS and rolling up the multiplier just isn't true.  (Yet)
    Edit-Ok...I missed this: "Rules- Attack, abuse or otherwise 'bash' MSI or its products. We are only interested in providing help to users having problems with their hardware and seeking assistance."
    Now I understand.  In a way the links in the next post help.  They all still endorse MSI products by specifying which boards are g3258 multiplier friendly. 

  • Web/Email experience on your HTPC Mini

    I can understand why people have enjoyed the Mac Mini as a pure HTPC, once it is setup in the entertainment room. Here's a question for those of you who currently have your Mac Mini connected to your HDTV and use it dual purpose: HTPC and basic computer tasks such as email, web, etc. Are there many of you out there, or are these HTPC's relegated to just that, HTPC's?
    How would you rate your experience using your HTPC Mini also as a computer? What accommodations have you had to make to improve that experience?
    Some unthikables for me are running USB wires across the coffee table or having a separate mouse or trackball next to me on the couch. I can envision a bluetooth keyboard and integrated trackpad, but have yet to find the right one. (Logitech diNovo Edge looks most promising?).
    How about the size of onscreen fonts? Do your eyes hurt from squinting at small fonts 10+ feet away? Even if my 40" LCD was capable of 1080p (which it's not), I would probably have to run the Mini's desktop at 720p, just to make the OS's text legible. Assuming your HDTV doesn't cover your entire wall, do you find yourself constantly straining or using "Apple''" to make fonts bigger in your browser?
    Thanks for sharing your experiences.
    PowerBook G4   Mac OS X (10.4.9)   Sony KDL-40S2010 HDTV

    From, 1 to 10 I would rate my experience with the macmini as HTPC with an 8. Here is why:
    1) No noise at all comparing with a standard PC.
    2) Low cost if you compare with a custom made PC as HTPC.
    3) All software works: internet, email, youtube, music player, DVD player, MIDI player.
    4) Good communication with the wireless keyboard and mouse (Bluetooth)
    5) FrontRow and the moni-remote make a good couple.
    6) Can do Unix, Linux, VNC from my other machines.
    7) Everybody at home understands it. Cam start working with it with zero training.
    8) Unbelievable small footprint for such computing power.
    9) Burning CDs is a breeze.
    Now, responding to your inquiries:
    USB: Try to install the macmini as close as possible to the display to save on cabl and reduce noise and cable losses. I bought a mount bracket for the wall (behind the 26" TV flat panel), which comes with four USB in the front. Right now I am using one USB port only for the MIDI keyboard.
    Location: I installed the 26" LCD display on the wall in the kitchen dining room. So, I have the table to put the keyboard and mouse.
    Font: even with the 26" screen fonts are kind of small when you try to watch an inmternet page or the menus from 8' away. Then it comes handy the Ctrl+Scroll where you can zoom-in and out. Also, what I did is set the resolution to 1024x768 instead of the maximum resolution (1380x1024). That enhance the menu fonts to something more legible. And yes, the eyes hurt for the first two weeks. Then, you get used to it.
    What do I dislike of the macmini as HTPC:
    i) The mini-remote is too directional; it is optic not RF.
    ii) The DVD player software does not show subtitles for all the movies.
    iii) Macmini is slow to play divX or mpg movies via network. I even tried with VLC, but you can see the delay. Not fast enough.
    iv) DVD recorder only works reliably from Parallels Windows. Could not record yet a workable data DVD from the pure Mac OSX.
    I think, so far, the Macmini has been a remarkable experience.
    Good luck.

  • Which CPU should I buy to support hardware virtualisation

    I would like to buy a cpu/motherboard bundle , but I want it to definately support "hardware virtualisation" . Am having great difficulty in find clear and easy to read info as to which CPU does or does not support hardware virtualisation.
    are there any guidelines ??
    George

    For any AMD or Intel processors made in the last year (other than some of the very lowest end chips), VT/AMDV should be present. You may be able to verify for a specific processor from one of these pages.
    http://www.intel.com/products/processor_number/
    http://products.amd.com/en-us/default.aspx
    Note that some systems disable VT/AMDV in the BIOS, so if you build a system with a processor that you think should support VT/AMDV and Xen says it doesn't, you may be able to enable it in your BIOS.
    For other x86-compatible processor vendors, sorry I can't help.

  • Solaris 10 b69  and EPIA Mini-ITX Boards

    I am trying to install the Solaris 10 on a EPIA PD
    see http://www.viaembedded.com/product/epia_PD_spec.jsp?motherboardId=241 for details
    But then when it starts loading the kernel (no matter which install option I choose) as it passes controll to the kernel which may just get to
    print out the first line I can be sure as thats when the mahine resets (clearing the screen!!) and starts to load the bios again!!!!
    I would actually like to get the new board from vie the EPIA PS board that has been talked about using the new CN400 chipt set looks much faster!! see here
    http://www.viaembedded.com/product/epia_sp_spec.jsp?motherboardId=241
    But untill then I have the PD versions. Has ANYONE got this to start up and install, I have founf ethernet drivers and a CLE266 screen acc for the X11 (xfree, but I think will work on X.org too) but just can't get it to install!!!!
    If you have WHICH via board are you using and which Solaris build? I think this could be an amazing set of kit for Solaris to run on..... i
    Russel

    Hi,
    I have a Via CM266 Motherboard with a Via C3 1GHz CPU, Ezra not Nemih. I added a cheapo ATI video card since nothing but the newest Linux can grok the S3 Ultrachrome builtin video. B^(.
    For the first week I could get Beta 7 to boot about 30% of the time, now it just hangs after loading in the mmu32 module; I haven't tried the -kv boot option yet.
    When it DID load it ran GREAT! I had to get the third party driver for the builtin ethernet tho; Google for Solaris x86 ether drivers and use the rh driver on the guys web site; I hope Sun picks his drivers or equiv. for general release! Anyways, third party ether driver worked great.
    I hope you get it running on your EPIA board, Solaris 10 IS slick for these mATX boards once it does get running!
    -Rob

  • V210 bad fan - Identify which CPU physically is the one involved

    I have a V210 server.
    One of the fans for the CPU's has failed. I want to replace it (have the replacement part) but I don't know physically which CPU is the one that is effected. I have a admin guide, but it doesn't show the internals of the machine, just normal replaceable parts.
    The error:
    CPU_FAN @ MB.P0.F0.RS has FAILED
    Indicates it is the Motherboard CPU 0 fan, but there are 2 CPU's in the box. Which one is CPU 0 and CPU 1?
    How do I tell? Cant seem to find a diagram of the box internals to differentiate between the various CPU's
    Output from showenvironment:
    Fans (Speeds Revolution Per Minute):
    Sensor Status Speed Warn Low
    F0.RS OK 8544 -- 1000
    F1.RS OK 8333 -- 1000
    F2.RS OK 8437 -- 1000
    F3.RS OK 8544 -- 1000
    MB.P0.F0.RS FAILED -- 2000 2000
    MB.P0.F1.RS OK 17763 2000 2000
    MB.P1.F0.RS OK 16875 2000 2000
    MB.P1.F1.RS OK 17307 2000 2000
    Edited by: 804736 on Mar 5, 2011 10:19 AM

    Found a PDF which is for replacing the cpu fans... Document ID 817-4048-13.pdf
    URL which most likely will change
    [http://download.oracle.com/docs/cd/E19088-01/v125.srvr/817-4048-13/817-4048-13.pdf]

  • Get NI RMC 8355 motherboard and CPU serial number programmatically

    Hi all,
    I need to read the motherboard or CPU serial numbers of the NI RMC 8355 programmatically.
    I have tried to use "wmic baseboard get serialnumber" comand in cmd, but it returns "0123456789", which apparently is not a valid serial number.
    Does anyone have any idea how I can read that information?
    Is there any toolkit or LabVIEW VI which will do that job.
    Thanks in advance.

    Gevorg,
    This is a Windows property that you can access the same way you would with a desktop PC, using the 'wmic baseboard get serialnumber' command.
    http://www.windows-commandline.com/get-serial-number-for-ram-motherboard-hard-disk/
    Regards,
    Kristen

  • Arch Linux on Mini-ITX

    Hey There,
    Because that I've got serious problems with my HP laptop (not related with Arch Linux) and I have to get my laptop laid at the tech. service the 4th time, I'm planning to have my mini-itx system based on Arch Linux.. I've always tought about VIA Epia mainboards but my friends keep saying that:
    - the graphics card is not that powerful so that i can't watch some quality movies like HD..?
    - that the architecture is i586 based so that i'd have to compile every package that i need
    - because that via's drivers are not open source, i could have many problems
    and etc..... they suggest buying an intel mini-itx mainboard as well.. So I want to ask you guys if these rumors are true or not... What would you recommend ? By the way:
    - i'm not a gamer... i just play maybe openarena as a 3d game..
    - instead of a harddisk, i think of using something like a sd/cf card with a few gb's of storage
    - i'd like to connect the machine to a projector and a monitor.. so having 2 output connectors would be better..
    - i think of building a multimedia box with it so having some modules (ports) for irda etc would be good..
    thanks..

    If I were you I'd just go for a small mATX, probably one of those cube cases. The epia boards will be useless for basically any 3d games and the CPU isn't powerful enough to decode HD movies like 1080p. If your must I definitely say get a board that supports a core2 intel cpu, but really a mATX is just an all around better buy. You get better hardware for the money, it is still really small, power consumption shouldn't too high albeit a bit higher then an mini-itx, it will be as powerful as a full tower desktop PC and give you a better upgrade path. Oh you can also make it really quiet depending on the case.
    I am not sure if the VIA CPUs are 586 or 686 though.
    Last edited by Zepp (2008-04-20 05:23:20)

  • Move Windows 8.1 Pro Hard Drive, Graphics Card and Programs to New Motherboard and CPU

    Want to move everything, hard drive, installed programs, video card, network adapter, ram drive, DVD, from one computer to another, nothing will change except motherboard and CPU.  Old motherboard and CPU will be installed in a new computer case which
    will revert back to a Windows 7 Pro computer with a fresh install and no programs to be used as a dedicated CAD work station. Motherboard and CPU swap will be the only change, even the RAM will be the same.  What activation problems will I encounter,
    I do not want to re-install anything, if possible.

    Hi,
    I would like to confirm what kind of licensing you used on Windows 8.1, the OEM or the retailed.
    For the OEM one, the Windows 8.1 transferred to another new Motherboard will not be activated.
    For the retailed one, you should find that the system will boot with the new motherboard, install some drivers then boot successfully.
    You will need to use telephone activation for the updated system, but should not need to re-install. When warned that you need to activate, select the "Contact Microsoft Customer Support" option and follow the instructions. With a tone dial phone
    you can do this without speaking to anyone. See http://www.eightforums.com/tutorials/24636-activate-windows-8-phone.html
    Kate Li
    TechNet Community Support

  • I need to align the margins of my forms with those of my website, I have looked at all the options and unfortunately I am unable to do it with access to the Adobe.form.min.CSS file which I can't access as a consumer, how else can I fix my problem

    I need to align the margins of my forms with those of my website, I have looked at all the options and unfortunately I am unable to do it with access to the Adobe.form.min.CSS file which I can't access as a consumer, how else can I fix my problem

    I need to align the margins of my forms with those of my website, I have looked at all the options and unfortunately I am unable to do it with access to the Adobe.form.min.CSS file which I can't access as a consumer, how else can I fix my problem

  • Can I install and boot mac os x 10.6.8 on a new mac mini model A1347 which shipped with osx 10.8.3?  I need to run a custom application using Mac OS X 10.6.8.

    Can I install and boot mac os x 10.6.8 on a new mac mini model A1347 which shipped with osx 10.8.3?
    I need to run an application customized using Mac OS X 10.6.8 on this new mini.

    Hi, not normally, but you can run a Virtual Machine, using 10.6 Server  within...
    Parallels...
    http://www.parallels.com/
    VmWare Fusion...
    http://www.vmware.com/mac
    VirtualBox...
    http://www.virtualbox.org/wiki/Downloads

Maybe you are looking for