IPhoto v7.x (iLife 08) RAW workflow

I'm looking for some opinions on a workflow here.
I have an Olympus E-510 and shoot in RAW. For my amateur needs, iPhoto's editing tools are sufficient and I like iPhoto's library characteristics. I import the Oly RAW files and then edit as needed which of course creates a jpeg. There are some pictures that I really don't care about keeping the RAW file as it considerably increases the size of the iPhoto library. I can of course right click on the particular photo and select show original file which shows the RAW file in the Finder, and of course can then delete the RAW file if so desired.
The problem (which I guess isn't really a problem, just kind of anal on my part) is that the edited (jpeg) picture in iPhoto still "points" to the original RAW file's location. I.e., you can right click on the jpeg and select show original file and it opens the folder in the finder where the original RAW file was. I've tried rebuilding the iPhoto library after deleting the RAW file but it makes no difference.
I could of course use another editing program first to edit the RAW image and save a high quality original size jpeg to import to iPhoto, but I kind of would like to keep everything to one application.
If there's no solution to this I simply need to make the decision to either keep the RAW files or ignore the jpeg thinking there is still an original RAW.
Just wondering if anyone else has considered this or has any opinion/suggestion.
Thanks,

Terry:
Deleting the RAW file as you've described is tantamount to committing the cardinal sin of iPhoto, messing with the contents of the library via the Finder. There's really no way to do what you want other than exporting those edited photos you want to keep to the desktop at full size and quality, import into iPhoto and delete the first copy of them.
Another possible workflow would be to upload the RAW files to a folder on the Desktop from the camera. Using a 3rd party editor create a folder of jpg files from the RAW, burn the RAW files to disk or another drive to store as digital negatives and import the folder of the jpgs.
Since iPhoto uses nondestructive editing you're always only one generation away from the originals jpg file. You won't get any significant image quality loss due to multiple edits.
Unless you use a 3rd party editor, like Photoshop, to edit the RAW files there's little advantage to using RAW in iPhoto. With an application like PS RAW files can be handled/edited far better than any other format but you need such an editor. Also, all edits are then saved to another format leaving the RAW untouched.
Since you're only using iPhoto for your editing needs just shoot jpg as that will eliminate several steps in your workflow and save lots of disk space.
Happy Holidays
TIP: For insurance against the iPhoto database corruption that many users have experienced I recommend making a backup copy of the Library6.iPhoto database file and keep it current. If problems crop up where iPhoto suddenly can't see any photos or thinks there are no photos in the library, replacing the working Library6.iPhoto file with the backup will often get the library back. By keeping it current I mean backup after each import and/or any serious editing or work on books, slideshows, calendars, cards, etc. That insures that if a problem pops up and you do need to replace the database file, you'll retain all those efforts. It doesn't take long to make the backup and it's good insurance.
I've created an Automator workflow application (requires Tiger), iPhoto dB File Backup, that will copy the selected Library6.iPhoto file from your iPhoto Library folder to the Pictures folder, replacing any previous version of it. It's compatible with iPhoto 08 libraries and Leopard. iPhoto does not have to be closed to run the application, just idle. You can download it at Toad's Cellar. Be sure to read the Read Me pdf file.

Similar Messages

  • RAW workflow question

    I have begun using the RAW format on my Canon dRebel and I am having some difficulties in figuring out what my workflow should be. I found the post below in this discussion group, but I am not sure I completely understand the process around converting RAW files in an external program.
    This is what I have tried to do:
    1. in Photoshop Elements 3 I click Open and navigate to the folder containing the RAW files (if I control-click the RAW file in iPhoto and select Edit in External Editor it opens a JPG version of the file in PSE3 bypassing the Camera RAW application)
    2. I make the necessary adjustments and convert the file to JPG at which point I "replace" the JPG in the iPhoto Library
    This does not seem to be working as I am either unable to read the file after or iPhoto will not reflect the new version.
    Any help would be appreciated.
    Michel
    PS: Bonus question: I copied all my old jpg files to the picture directory before launching iPhoto for the first time and importing them into the library. Do I now have duplicates of all files that were on the harddrive before doing the import? Can I delete these to free up space?
    Jan,
    I should have been more clear. Importing from the camera or a reader is the same. If the camera is not supported, it won't work from either as its the RAW file format that determines compatibility. If the RAW files imported into iPhoto the format is supported and you will now have an iPhoto generated JPEG for each RAW file imported.
    If you double click on a thumbnail, it will open in edit mode (or an external editor if configured to do so) in its JPEG form.
    To edit the RAW file you need to drag the thumbnail into your favorite RAW editor and save that converted file in your choice of format outside of the iPhoto library.
    If you double click an image and then want your RAW file back to drop into a RAW editor, you need to select the thumbnail, right/control click, and select "Revert to Original".
    Also, I believe the E1's RAW format is supported since the 10.4.3 update.
    Hope this helped!
    Sam

    Hi Michel,
    I don't do RAW but I can point you to an Apple article. Is RAW supported for your camera? Meaning does iPhoto import the RAW files and put them in an Originals folder in the iPhoto Library folder in the Finder?
    Supported RAW cameras
    iPhoto 5 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ): Working with RAW images
    Working with RAW in iPhoto 5
    For the bonus question. You can delete the jpg files you have in the Pictures folder as they were copied into iPhoto's database (the iPhoto Library folder in the Finder) when they were imported into iPhoto.
    Lori

  • RAW workflow questions - image degradation over several edits with 08?

    I currently use Aperture to manage (and edit) my digital photo library. After reading about iphoto 08, the only major thing I can see preventing me from using it would be the RAW editing.
    An example would be a photo taken in RAW format and edited in iPhoto. It is saved as a JPEG. Any future editing ontop of that jpeg and the image begins degrading as levels of compression are added ontop of it (I think).
    In Aperture, the raw file is maintained and any editing to the RAW file becomes non-destructive as the RAW format is retained in "real time" (so to speak).
    I know iPhoto also retains the original RAW file, but not the edited RAW file.
    My question is this: with the great extra features of iPhoto (such as easier integration with .Mac) I am seriously considering a switch, but am concerned about image degradation. For all the semi-pro users, what is your RAW workflow in regards to iPhoto? Do you edit the file once, then when editing is required in the future just re-edit the JPEG or go back to the original RAW?
    For any former Aperture users who switched to iPhoto, was it worth it?
    Thanks!!

    Terence,
    Once again, thank you for a most helpful answer. I was wondering about the same issue. I guess this means that when you edit RAW files in iPhoto, it uses a similar approach than Aperture and Lightroom now. With far less options of course, but if you just doing basic editing of white balance and shadow/highlight, iPhoto is an appealing alternative.
    If I understand correctly the Raw conversion is done at the system level, so iPhoto and APerture even use the same conversion engine, right?
    Thank you
    Bo

  • Photos not visible in iPhoto v8.1 (iLife 09)

    I've copied my iPhoto library to a new computer and even though all pictures are in the library, about half of them are not visible in iPhoto v8.1 (iLife 09).
    • Only 74 events of 219 are visible.
    • Picture count on new computer is 2752 and 7709 on old computer in iPhoto
    • iPhoto on older machine is v7.1.5 (iLife 08)
    • New albums have been created on new machine that must have disappeared during previous iPhoto updates.
    • Photo library size is 3 GB larger on new machine
    • Running 10.5.8 on older machine and 10.6.1 on new machine
    I've played with "Hide Photos" and no change.
    Any one has any ideas how to correct this?
    Thanx in advance.

    Just an update on this...re-copied and I'm having the same issue. Here are some additional testing I did.
    • Updated iPhoto to v8 (iLife 09) on the original machine (G5 PM) and no issues.
    • Copied updated Library to new machine (iMac 3.06) and still same issue. Its running iPhoto 8.1
    • Updated iPhoto to 8.1 on G5 and I'm encountering the same issue as the iMac. Only see 74 events out of some 220 events and 2752 pictures out of 7100 pictures.
    Conclusion - iPhoto 8.1 (iLife 09) messes up something in my photo library.
    TD - thanx for your quick feedback.
    BTW - just got notification that a new iPhoto update, 8.1.1, is available! Going to try it and update the results here.

  • What method does iPhoto 6 use to convert Raw photos for Books?

    I shoot Raw. I like to have the odd soft cover iBook for Holiday memories.
    Obviously iPhoto does not upload the RAW files to the printers, so what is its conversion process? Would I get better results if I converted them first before creating a Book File? I have followed the list of disappointments people have with these smaller books. Old Toad was most helpful with the Pref Setting 300 tip, but I wonder if in the process of conversion from Raw iPhoto uses a lower quality route?
    Any one out there who knows the best practice for Raw Shooters. By the way I am based in London and so the alternative printing websites do seem to take a bit too long with postage.

    Adobe Camera Raw is the way to go – it will do all you want and more.
    You can pick up the basics very quickly but it pays in the long run to discover its incredible versatility by visiting the Camera Raw forum.
    And read the book too!

  • DNG in Smart Object RAW workflow?

    I'm totally immersed in the Smart Object RAW workflow. I've been on the fence about using DNG as SO layers, but it suddenly dawned on me that, since you're building in raw layers, rather than having access to your original RAW files easily, that DNG becomes essential to ensure an archival process.
    That is, if I have separate RAW files I can always, at some point, convert them to DNG. Once they're in the file as a SO, I'm hosed. (Yes, I can extract them, but I lose all my work in the TIFF.)
    Is anyone out there slamming to DNG before working with a Smart Object RAW workflow? (Is anyone working in a SO workflow even? Sometimes I feel like the only one... heh)

    Been requested since B2 or so. Still a wait.
    Don
    Don Ricklin, MacBook 1.83Ghz Duo 2 Core, Pentax *ist D
    http://donricklin.blogspot.com/

  • Camera Raw Workflow options

    HI
    when i open jpag (or tiff) in camera raw Workflow options,
    i have option to size image.
    may question it's: if i choose the large size, what hapen to
    may image - interpolation like in Ps?
    thank

    I don't know which algorithm Camera Raw uses ... but the result of the upsampling is virtually the same as Bicubic Smoother in Photoshop. Except for one thing: Camera Raw's upsampling will add tiny ringing artifacts to the result; Photoshop's won't. The artifacts are bright, horizontal or vertical, 1-pixel-wide lines along sharp, high-contrast edges. So for perfect results I recommend to convert the raw image to its native size in Camera Raw, then do the upsizing in Photoshop using the resampling method Bicubic Smoother. Before upsizing, apply some gentle source or capture sharpening.
    However those ringing artifacts are really
    i very
    small; it takes a very close look at high magnification to notice. In most cases they'll go unnoticed. So you may decide not to care. However they tend to get emphasized by subsequent sharpening.
    -- Olaf

  • How do I get iPhoto but NOT iLife?

    How do I get iPhoto but NOT iLife?

    If you want iPhoto for Mac, click on this link: https://itunes.apple.com/ca/app/iphoto/id408981381?mt=12
    If you want iPhoto for iOS, click on this link: https://itunes.apple.com/ca/app/iphoto/id497786065?mt=8
    The Mac iPhoto is $15
    The iOS iPhoto is $5
    Hope This Helps!
    Mini Apple Genuis

  • Uninstalling iPhoto Update from iLife

    Does anyone know how to uninstall the iPhoto update from iLife (and even for iMovie too)? I really don't like the new iPhoto as simple things are now more difficult or aren't available anymore. The changes seem more superficial as I haven't found any new tools or processes that help. Don't even get me started on the iMovie problems. Please tell me there is a way to go back.

    iPhoto 7 did not make things harder to do, in fact it is virtually identical to the previous version!
    I generally agree - But a few things are different and there is a requirement that a user LEARN how to use the new features and those that have changed - for doing that you get a greatly expanded capability so IMHO it is a great trade off - but for a user who is unable or unwilling to learn a few new things it can be difficult - as can ANY new version of ANY new software
    LN

  • Cant open iphoto after getting ilife

    Like others I downloaded ilife and get a message "in order to open iphoto you need to update for latest version". I removed everything, tried again but no good. What should I do please. I was happy with previous version of iphoto. Looking at all the problems reported here, i think I will revert to that. How do I do that please, if i decide to do so

    Like others I downloaded ilife and get a message "in order to open iphoto you need to update for latest version".
    No - no one here has downloaded iPhoto '11 or iLife '11 - it is not an available legal download - updates are available to download
    I removed everything, tried again but no good.
    Exactly what did you remove?
    What should I do please. I was happy with previous version of iphoto.
    What version of iLife was that?
    Looking at all the problems reported here, i think I will revert to that.
    Note that the reason all for those problems are here is -- BECAUSE - this the place to report and solve problems - making a judgement here is like going to the hospital emergency room and deciding that everyone in town is sick - few people have had problems and with the 9.1.1 update almost every thing appears to have been cleared up
    How do I do that please, if i decide to do so
    To revert is simple - load your backup of the previous version and install the previous version from the the disks
    LN

  • Cannot install iPhoto 4 from iLife 04

    Help, I cannot install iPhoto from iLife 04 cd, i always get a message that one of these programs are opened itune, idvd, iphoto...
    Iphoto is not installed in my computer.
    What should I do?
    Regards
    negiL

    I had this same problem. There is probaby a iTunes help file or something like that running in the background. I think you can look in system profiler and find what is running and shut it down. Once you do this you should be able to load iPhoto for the iLife disk. I am not at my mac right now. I will check this evening when I get home and see where I found the file running and post a more detailed response.
    Rick

  • IPhoto does not support Olympus Raw

    Understand that IPhoto does not support Olympus Raw, and since IPhoto will disappear from support next year, will the new Photo support this version of Raw?

    It isn't just iPhoto - if RAW is supported, it will also be in Aperture and ( I believe, but am not sure) in Image Capture.
    babowa,
    I think, only Aperture and iPhoto are supported.
    See the requirements in the Raw Compatibility updates:
    Digital Camera RAW Compatibility 6.01
    System Requirements OS X 10.10 w/ iPhoto 9.6 or Aperture 3.6

  • I have iphoto 7.1.5.  How can I update iphoto without buying ilife, which i don't need?

    i have iphoto 7.1.5.  How can I update iphoto without buying ilife, which i don't need?

    I'm not sure where you are seeing the "negative reviews" but I like it and many, many people posting here do even though this is a forum for people with problems
    No one knows when the next upgrade will be bu tit will require a purchase
    I'm sure that there will be a few more updated for iPhoto '11 but probably not many - it has had a lot and is approaching the end of its life cycle I would think
    And be sure to have a good backup prior to upgrading (as always) - I suggest in addition to your normal backup routine that you make one more copy of the iPhoto library on your main hard drive if you have space - remember that you need a minimum of 10 GB of free space jus tto run your Mac
    And prior to launching iPhoto '11 the first time be sure to run software update and be sure it is up to the latest version
    LN

  • I had to re-install OS X recently and lost iPhoto and other ilife apps. Do I have to buy them now?, I had to re-install OS X recently and lost iPhoto and other ilife apps. Do I have to buy them now?

    I had to re-install OS X recently and lost iPhoto and other ilife apps. Do I have to buy them now?, I had to re-install OS X recently and lost iPhoto and other ilife apps. Do I have to buy them now?

    Welcome to Apple Support Communities
    This is normal. OS X doesn't come with iLife apps, so you have to reinstall them after reinstalling Mac OS X.
    If your Mac came without DVDs or you purchased it after July 2011, you have to install the iLife applications from the Mac App Store. Open the Mac App Store, log in with your Apple ID, go to Purchases and download GarageBand, iMovie and iPhoto free of charge.
    If your Mac came with DVDs and you didn't purchase the iLife apps in the Mac App Store, insert the Applications DVD and install the iLife apps. Then, open  > Software Update, and install the latest iLife applications version

  • IPhoto Raw Workflow

    I have been experimenting with shooting in raw and am now trying to figure out how best to work with the files. I've always found iPhoto 11 to be sufficient for organizing my photo library (~50K images), while occasionally using Photoshop Elements to adjust or clean up specific images and create panoramas.
    As I understand it, the raw file appears in iPhoto as both a raw file and a tiff that is used for display (in addition to the separate jpg created by the camera). When editing the raw file, it seems that the changes are saved in a tif that is *much* larger than the original (10mb ->100 mb). When I have tried to use Photoshop Elements to edit the raw files, there are more options for working with the file in ACR, but this process seems to create a second raw file on export (_2 appended to the filename) without incorporating the changes, thus requiring the resulting tif (or jpg) file to be re-imported into iPhoto (the resulting tif files do seem to be much smaller, however).
    Working directly in iPhoto is much easier, but those large file sizes add up and my hard drive space is running low. Reimporting photos into iPhoto is cumbersome, but would seem to save space. Especially if I can then delete the duplicated raw file, which doesn't seem to have any purpose (as I understand it, I can always go back to the original if I want to try processing it differently). Is there another, better option for working with raw files than either of these imperfect solutions? I could rationalize the price of upgrading to Aperture *if* it would actually solve these problems, but I'm not sure I need if if it doesn't offer some demonstrable advantage.
    Thanks for any advice.

    As I understand it, the raw file appears in iPhoto as both a raw file and a tiff that is used for display (in addition to the separate jpg created by the camera).
    No it doesn't.
    If you import a Raw it's copied in and a jpeg preview made of it. There is no tiff involved. If you shoot Raw+Jpeg pairs then you get duplicates. Shooting Raw+Jpeg doesn’t make a whole lot of sense in this case.
    When editing the raw file, it seems that the changes are saved in a tif that is *much* larger than the original
    It's only saved as a tiff if you have chosen that option in the iPhoto -> Preferences -> Advanced. Otherwise it's saved as a Jpeg. A tiff - as it's uncompressed - will always be a lot larger. That's in the nature of tiffs.
    When working with Raws and an external editor again there are no tiffs involved unless you choose there to be:
    iPhoto does not handle this gracefully and it's a bit of a kludge.
    First off set your preferred app as an external editor in iPhoto:
    Note that iPhoto sends a copy+ of the file to Photoshop, so when you save be sure to use the Save command, not Save As... If you use Save As then you're creating a new file and iPhoto has no way of knowing about this new file. iPhoto is preserving your original anyway.
    Next: In the iPhoto Preferences -> Advanced, elect to use Raw with your External editor:
    Now when you go to edit the Raw it will be sent to your external editor.
    Now for the kludge:
    You cannot save a Raw. The work you do must be output to a new file, in a new format (jepg, tiff, whatever). However, as the External Editor is making this new file iPhoto has no knowledge of its existence. Therefore you must save it to the desktop and then import it back to iPhoto as a new file.
    This means that you will have your Original Raw and the processed version in iPhoto but they will not be recognised as version and original. iPhoto will see them as two separate shots.
    So, again, there are no tiffs anywhere in either workflow unless you choose to make them.

Maybe you are looking for