Why does ppi matter for web images?

Hello
When placing an image in my (web/pixel) project the resolution is dependent from the set ppi.
When I create a new document for web, then logically only the pixels matter. Nonetheless there's a ppi field, why? And depending what value it has, placed pictures (file > place or drag&drop from Windows' explorer) get resized instead of the wanted 1:1 resolution.
1 pixel should remain 1 pixel when working with in pixels.
Try it out:
Create a new document with Full HD resolution (1920x1080 pixels), set ppi to 10.
Import a Full HD picture (Blu-Ray screenshot whatever) and it's mini-sized.
My screen resolution is 59 ppi (I use my 39" TV as monitor) and this is set in the Photoshop preferences (in case I do some print stuff that I get a 1:1 view if wanted). If there was any logic behind the pixel-ppi-placing thing, then this set standard monitor ppi should bring me a 100% sized picture... but it doesn't. Only when the ppi is set to the fantasy value of 72 I get a 100% sized placing.
This can be disturbing and is very annoying when starting a new project by opening an image that does not come with 72 ppi by default (my Canon camera makes 180 ppi JPEG photos)  and placing new pictures in this project. They get opened in wrong sizes, in my case largely upscaled, with no way to correct it but guess-scaling it down.
Bug?
Pls pls fix it.
Ppi has nothing lost in pixels-only projects.
The only way that works is to open all single images in Photoshop as tabs, and then drag&drop from within Ps. -.-
Regards
Mopsi
Example screenshot: http://www.m-i-u.de/images-i83580bxvogj.jpg
The yellow framed layer is a image from my camera, opened in Photoshop CS6 extended. 3264x2448 pixels (180 ppi).
The green framed layer is a screenshot from a movie, drag&drop from the explorer. 1920x1080 (normally) unwanted upscaled here.
The red framed layer is a screensot as well, but drag&dropped from a tab within Photoshop. It remains in its original resolution of 1920x1080.

I'm wrong and your right. I just did some testing and Photoshop does indeed interpolate the lower resolution 600x400 72DPI image is  up size to match the higher resolution document document size during the place process. I just assumed Photoshop would preserve image quality and not interpolate the image.    As you have shown it does interpolate the image which greatly lowers the image quality of re-sized low resolution image.
This shows you should not use Photoshop to merge images into a composite if they have greatly different resolutions.  I don't have a problem there for I never use "save for web" to save images to be displayed on displays from the web or my machine.  I use Fit Image and save as, or a Image Processor script that uses Fit Image to re-size and uses save as.  The leave all my images files resolution setting unchanged.   For some reason Save for Web changes all jpeg files it saves resolution  setting to 72 DPI even if they are 8MP images for high resolution displays..
During testing I also tried using Photoshop's script Load Files into Stack instead of using Place.  That script works the way I assumed Photoshop Place would work.  Images layer are not interpolated they remain the correct number of pixels and the image quality is not is not changed.. The image layer are normal layers but can be converted to smart object layers however the object would be normal layer not an image file.
When you use Place you get
It also possible to undo Photoshop's Place scaling with a simple calculation.  Divide the image layer's original dpi by the document's dpi here there are three layer that did not start at 300dpi. two started out as 74dpi image file the other a 500dpi image file.  72/300=.24 = 24% the other 500/300=1.66666 = 166.66%
all you need do is change the associated layer's image transform width and height scale from 100% to the calculated percents
The only time I set document to 72DPI resolution is in Photoshop Scripts so I can calculate a font size  for a charter sting so it will fit the canvas size.  Photoshop Text Tools seem to be tied to 72DPI resolution.  Once I add the text layer I restore the document DPI resolution back to its original setting.
So when it comes to Photoshop all files use in a project should have identical DPI resolution for best result when making composites.    My image files are either RAW files which have no DPI for they are not RGB image files. Or RGB Image files that have a high DPI resolution. I process images for print. Image files DPI resolution is meaningless when if comes to Display Screens.  All that matters is the number of pixels a display can display and the number of pixels in the image. Even images I re-size for display screens DPI are high for I do not use "Save for Web". I see no good reason to strip metadata and change resolution to 72DPI.  I tend not to interpolate image except the ones I save to be displayed on a display.  I change Print size by changing the DPI setting without resample.  My Epson 4800 inkjet printer has no problem printing high resolution pixel I see no reason resample my camera 16MP image down in size just to print at 300dpi.  If I want to a single 6"x4" print I see nothing wrong printing it at 816DPI.  My eyes can not resolve down there the printer can.  However when Printing on Roll Paper many 6"x4"  the composite document I create via a script has a 300DPI resolution and the image layers are resized to be 6" x 4".

Similar Messages

  • Photoshop slice tool and Save for Web image quality. Will it affect prints?

    I want to slice a large photo into multiple smaller (4x6) printable photos to arrange in a 12x12 inch scrapbook binder pocket (made of of 4x6 pockets). I need to order separate 4x6s online so tiling in the print options is not what I need.
    The slow way I know to do this involves cropping and saving each section (maybe even recording this action to do batch processing). However, another way is to use the slice tool to quickly divide up the sections then "Save for Web...". I can adjust some parameters, but I'm afraid there are other automatic adjustments that I don't want. For example, all images are converted to 96 dpi instead of the original 300 dpi. The number of pixels remains the same so I don't think there will be problems printing the picture.
    My question is: does the Save for Web function reduce image quality in any way when printing (it is obviously intended to be used to optimize images for websites)? Are there settings in "Save for Web" that would optimize for high quality prints? Is there a better way to tile an image?
    I have not yet compared any prints.
    W7
    CS6

    If you understand that something will do something you do not want like convert to 96 DPI as long as it does not resample you can always convert back to 300 DPI. If you want 6 4x6 to form a 12x12 you must start with an square 1:1 aspect ratio image. That you resample to 12"x 12" at 300 dpi if you want 6 4x6 300 dpi images.
    If the original images vary in size and aspect ratio you need to crop them square or add two borders to make them square.   The rest is easy to do with an action.
    The square crop or border can be automated with a little scripting.  If crop  a center crop would be the route to go. My crafting actions package contains  more the a dozen scripts to be used within action. One is a plug-in script that would make center cropping a snap two steps menu File>Automat>AspectsRatioSelection followed menu Image>Crop.  Add a menu Image>Size set side to 12" and resolution 300 DPI and you have your  starting 12"x12" 300 dpi image.
    Flatten the image make your first 4"x6" selection copy past to add it as a layer. Select the background select the next 4x6 area copy and paste repeat that process till you have added the 6 4"X6" layers. Then delete the background, Select all, target all layers and use layer>Align layers to selection>Top edge then repeat align to left edge. the Image>Trim you have your 6 4x6 in a stack.   You can the use Adobe Photoshop Script Export Layer to file.   All automated in an action however the last step Export layers to files is interactive for its not a plug-in script. So if you batch it you keen to hang around to interact with the last step for each image.
    You could also write you own export script that would not need human intervention to use instead of Adobe interactive script.
    Crafting Actions Package UPDATED Aug 10, 2014 Added Conditional Action steps to Action Palette Tips.
    Contains
    Action Actions Palette Tips.txt
    Action Creation Guidelines.txt
    Action Dealing with Image Size.txt
    Action Enhanced via Scripted Photoshop Functions.txt
    CraftedActions.atn Sample Action set includes an example Watermarking action
    Sample Actions.txt Photoshop CraftedActions set saved as a text file.
    More then a dozen Scripts for use in actions
    Example
    Download

  • Why does the "fix" for firefox copying and pasting not work?

    I did the fix a few times and restarted firefox, with no success. Also, I installed the latest version of firefox and it is slower now. I have to use firefox for school, otherwise I would just find another way.

    In what way is Firefox slow?
    Is this all the time or only with loading web pages?
    What kind of fix do you mean with: ''Why does the "fix" for firefox copying and pasting not work'' ?

  • When updating itunes, it keeps saying invalid drive E, why does it look for drive e?

    When updating itunes, it keeps saying invalid drive E, why does it look for drive e?

    Try the following user tip:
    "Invalid drive X:\" install errors

  • Why does it take for a month to get internet services?

    I'd like to know why does it take for a month to get internet services? I ordered my service on Jan 18,2012 and I got the installation kit on Jan 21,2012. But I can't  use the internet and I have to wait until Feb 9,2012 for my service ready date. I think it takes a long time. I need the internet to do my project, but I can't. I'm very disappointed right now. I think I can use the internet after I place my order. (2 or 3 days it's ok, but I have to wait for a month that's terrible) Why can't they just turn on the services? I'd like to know who can i talk with? 

    Have you tried hooking the modem up, and does it get sync and does the Internet light come on? Even though you technicaly shouldn't do this, the line might already be up and running but they haven't told you yet. I don't know why it takes a month to hook up DSL. In my area, it takes two weeks typically from order to live, whether it's new service or a speed upgrade/downgrade (these are usually one week. They can be done on the spot, though!). No one has ever explained why it takes that long, but I presume it has someting to do with the billing cycle and perhaps line conditioning if they still do that (away from removing bridged taps and load coils), giving a technician time to pick up the service request and perform the task before someone goes, builds the profile for the line and then connects a few cables to an empty slot in a DSLAM and does some other background tasks to bring the connection online.
    ========
    The first to bring me 1Gbps Fiber for $30/m wins!

  • Trying to load my Photoshop CS3 onto new Mac Book Air. Why does it ask for InDesign CS4 part way through?

    Loading my Photoshop CS3 onto new Mac Book Air. Why does it ask for InDesign CS4 part way through?  I have a CS5.5 disc. Will suffice?

    that doesn't make sense.  you will only be prompted for earlier adobe versions when installing a latter upgrade version.
    double check your versions.
    also, you might want to clean your computer before retrying to install, Use the CC Cleaner Tool to solve installation problems | CC, CS3-CS6

  • HT1349 Why does iPhone ask for apple password after rebooting?

    Why does iPhone ask for apple password after rebooting? It just started to do that recently. I've had iPhone5 for several months now and it just started to do that.
    Before I could reboot without having to type apple ID password to start using my phone.

    Could be part of Apple's new security procedures that were implemented this past week.

  • Why does the wheel for the apps close and how to keep it open?

    why does the wheel for the apps on the tool bar close and how to keep it open? i've checked thru all the information on your site..

    Exactly which driver did you downlaod and from where? By "GET STRAT", do you mean one of the Getting Started VIs? Error 5 means "NI-488:  Command requires GPIB Controller to be System Controller." Are you using GPIB to control the instrument? If so, what type of board are you using and which version of VISA and NI-488? If the error only occurs on a read, try issuing the query from MAX and see if the error occurs there. In a couple of the Xantrex drivers I looked at, there seemed to be some fixed delays after a write and before a read. You might try increasing those values to see if that makes any difference.

  • I just got my shipment and My Ipad mini is just shut down without reasons during upgrading. I'm doing restore it. Does it matter for the future use?

    I just got my shipment and My Ipad mini is just shut down without any reason during upgrading. I'm doing restore it. Does it matter for the future use?
    ACtually I really really don't want to use it anymore. I'm so disappointed.

    PolishAngel756 wrote:
    Some friends have told me that their phone can last up to 2 days without charging??
    If they are getting 2 days without charging, it's unlikely they use their device very much.
    A full day is pretty good....and if I'm careful, I can easily get a full day of usage.
    For me, normal is charging the iPhone mid afternoon at work, but I use it a lot.
    My typical usage is 35 mins of listening to podcasts, checking email, checking my RSS feed, and checking a few apps while I ride my bike when I first get up.  Then listening to several podcasts at work.
    I typically stream music while working out during my lunch hour and use the Men's Health Fitness app to track my progress.
    By about 2pm I'm ready to charge the device as it's getting low (somewhere between 20% and 50%).
    I leave bluetooth, Wi-FI, and location services turned on all the time.
    Personally, I just do not see the point in going into settings to turn on the feature when I need it... just too much hassle.  All of my listening to podcasts and music is via Bluetooth.
    I know I'm not the heaviest user, but I just do not see how anyone can realistically make it two days on a single charge, it makes me think they simply do not use the features of the device and would be just as well served with a basic or feature phone.

  • Why does the installer for Dreamweaver stop at Adobe Linguistics CS6 at 21% complete

    Why does the installer for Dreamweaver stop at Adobe Linguistics CS6 at 21% complete

    We cannot know. You are not providind any usefule details. System specs, other (Adobe) software on teh system, possibly install logs
    Mylenium

  • If I have money on my account why does it ask for a payment method in order to buy the song?

    If I already have money on my account from an itunes card, why does it ask for a payment method when I try to buy a song?

    Most likely because your credit card is expired.
    Either repklace the credit card with a valid card or remove the credit card completely.

  • Why does Apple charge for Apps that are FREE? That's my concern.

    Why does Apple charge for Apps that are FREE? That's my concern.

    Free means Free....
    As both Johnathan and Demo have indicated, if it says Free there is no charge associated with it. If you upgrade to a "Pro" version, or if you do in-app purchases, then it is no longer free....but when you initially install the app, you do not pay anything if it says "Free".
    And "Yeah? I'll show you" does not help us to understand what you are talking about. If you want help, then provide specifics and we will help you to figure out your misunderstanding.
    Cheers,
    GB

  • Why does the quality of my images change after I click on Save For Web?

    After I click on "Save For Web" the quality of my images changes, how can I stop this?
    I use photoshop CC on a macbook.
    Thanks in advance!
    Bo

    Good day!
    Could you please post screenshots to illustrate the issue?
    Regards,
    Pfaffenbichler

  • Why does Keynote Beta for PC suddenly stop, making all work in presentation unreadable?

    Keynote Beta seemed to be working fine on my PC and could be seen on my iPad 2 for a while, but suddenly, the screen with all the pages created went away and an error message popped up saying the presentation could not be opened (said this on the iPad, too).  Very frustrating, as many hours of work went away.
    Thought the problem might be too large files for the photos, so did the whole process again the following day with smaller photo files.  Same infuriating results at some point.  No explanation, can find no documentation, at sea.  Want to use the PC to assemble presentations as the photos are accessible there.  What to do?  Why does this happen?  Is there a maximum size for the presentation?   Hope this is going to the right forum or if not, that it will be redirected.  Also, how do I find this post an any answers.  I confess, I'm a complete newbie here.
    Thanks for any help, TC

    Just an update, a workaround to this problem was to download the Keynote file to my Mac and save that copy of the document on my Mac, not in iCloud Drive. I have been able to work with the document just fine since then, with Keynote on my Mac. This just means doing without the syncing benefits of iCloud Drive. Seems this problem was more with iCloud Drive itself than with Keynote.
    iCloud Drive did have the most recent, up-to-the-minute copy of my work online when I visited it via the web. I was able to work with the file with the Keynote beta program in the web browser, but that program is missing some of the features of the desktop version.
    The original problem of the file becoming unreadable has been solved by this workaround. But it is still a bug. I reported it through Apple feedback and hope they will fix this.

  • Save for Web Image Is Offset

    I have AI CS4 on Windows Vista and have created an artboard that is 220 px wide and 88 px high. I then added a rectangle of the same dimensions as a background to cover the entire artboard. When I export it to Save for Web and Devices, the resulting image show a white boarder on the left. If I shift my background 1 px to the left on the artboard so that it shows white space on the right and overlaps on the left, it looks fine on the Save for Web export. Is there some set up that I'm missing to get a WYSIWYG conversion?
    Thanks,
    Curt

    If you are trying to save as a jpeg, gif or png then you are rasterizing the vector graphic, which is likely the case of the 'white' space.
    To get around this, try creating bleed of 2 pixels all the way around the artboard and then use the crop tool to crop the image to 220x88.
    An alternative to this would be to open the file saved for the web in Photoshop or Fireworks and fill in the white/blank space.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Purchased movie disconnects from itunes every 15 minutes

    I purchased the movie Frozen and every 15 minutes or so it disconnects from itunes which is super frustrating after I spent $25 buying it. How do I fix this?

  • Avoid forms personalization/trigger during record update

    Hi all, I am trying to use forms personalization restrict users not to duplicate invoice numbers for a given supplier in Oracle Payables(Oracle Apps R 12.1.3). Here are my details, Trigger Event: WHEN-VALIDATE-RECORD Trigger Object: INV_SUM_FOLDER Co

  • QM for Pipe line Material

    Hi Experts Scenario: We have water as Pipe line material. We have activated 89 inspection type & user is creating manual Inspection lot for the same. Since this is a Pipe line material, there will not be any PO, GR so no inspection lot at GR. We do t

  • T400 beeps **ANNOYINGLY** every time you open the laptop lid

    Has anyone else experienced a beep when you flip open your laptop? I notice that if you mute, then it doesn't happen. If you use audio or have any volume on, it makes a loud annoying beep. Has anybody been able to turn it off? Here is how I tried sol

  • Limit the maximum size of attachment in ME22N or ME52N

    Dear All SAP Experts, How do I limit the maximum size of attachment in ME22N or ME52N (System > Services for object > Create attachment)? (for example, attachment size cannot be above 10 MB). Some Experts told me that they don't think there is a stan